Caro Luca, che ricordi, e che emozioni... Dopo 13 anni mi è ricomparso questo video, non so come, che ha contribuito, a suo tempo, a farmi appassionare all'organo per poi arrivare dove sono ora. Un abbraccio, Elia Calzolari
Scarlatti was king of the harpsichord, better maybe than even Bach. Kind of like Liszt and the piano. Handel was better at organ than Scarlatti, however. But I bet JS Bach was a better organist than both. All three are great composers.
Santosificationable I have to disagree. Bach’s technicality in many of his keyboard music outside of the organ is far more sophisticated and difficult. If you can play Bach, you can play Scarlatti but if you can Scarlatti that doesn’t mean you can play Bach.
@@Oceananswer I wish it was that black and white, Scarlatti has a unique texture compared to both, Bach was better counterpuntally, but Scarlatti came from a different school of music namely in the neopolitan tradition his improvisational skills were developed from an early age maybe he could've written beautiful harmonies and sophisticated themes but bach would won in the fugal style
Scarlatti better harpsichordist than Bach?? Have you ever listened to Bach's harpsichord concertos, or the book for Anna Magdalene, or the Goldberg Variations, or the famous solo of Brandenburg concert 5? Surely their style was completely different -Scarlatti had nothing of Bach's counterpoint, Bach had nothing of Scarlatti mannerisms - but to place the Sicilian above the German means to understand nothing about music.
Improvisation ? Incredible...extraordinary...Seriously, the world looses a fantastic musician...Musician like you must be see by every ears ! (Sorry for my english, je suis français!)
Domonico Scarlatti should of been the winner in of the harpsichord. although we are not sue exactly how the preformances went that day but over all handel wrote better organ music and scarlatti harpsichord and both of their choir music was equal.
Esse "Handel vs Scarlatti " veio de um filme em que mostra Handel e Scarlatti tendo um duelo de cravo. Mas, quem fez a música foi Handel: Passacaglia in G-Minor. No entanto, a música do vídeo está bastante alterada, um arranjo, mas lembra a música original.
Scarlatti é o maior mestre das teclas (cravo e pianoforte de Cristofori) para sempre! Humilde e cortês elogiou Handel para não perder o amigo! Quanto a Bach, talvez na plateia, copiando alguma coisa dos mestres! Scarlatti is the greatest master of keys (harpsichord and Cristofori fortepiano) forever! Humble and courteous, he praised Handel for not losing his friend! As for Bach, perhaps in the audience, copying something from the masters!
this is amazing, we can rarely hear someone play the organ so well. there are no organ players around. I have advice for you, if you're reading this, play some modern pieces or rock music pieces on the organ that way you'll get a lot of viewers and subscribers because they'll be impressed by an old instrument playing modern music.
La verdad esque ha sido bonito, pero para los que no conozcan esta batalla, el simplemente esta recreando los acordes que se utilizaron en la batalla, e improvisando sobre esos acordes. Pero esta muy bien, le felicito.
@Handel81 Sei bravissimo, sia come esecuzione che come gusto artistico. Un amico comune mi ha segnalato questo tuo video e lo ringrazio per averlo fatto. Una curiosità: hai riprodotto il clavicembalo per i registri nativi dell'organo o hai un accoppiamento MIDI? Come ti chiami? Ciao e grazie! Filippo
Good morning Luke !!! I AM YOUR BIG FAN. I wanted to ask you about the purchase of the Alborn 3 organ, and I wanted to ask you what you think about this model today, or is there even better something and which version to choose German and others? Thank you for your earlier reply.
not sure what is Scarlatti's and what Handel's, generally I prefer Handel as composer of orchestral music, but there is not comparison to Scarlatti for all the rest: Scarlatti historically outperformed Handel on the "cembalo" and on keyboard completely.
@Handel81 Sei bravissimo, sia come esecuzione che come gusto artistico. Un amico comune mi ha segnalato questo tuo video e lo ringrazio per averlo fatto. Una curiosità: hai riprodotto il clavicembalo attraverso i registri nativi dello strumento o hai un accoppiamento MIDI? Come ti chiami? Ciao e grazie! Filippo
Handel: nice harpsichord improvisation, maestro!
Scarlatti: thanks, nice organ playing, you won!
JS Bach: hmm... hold my beer!
haha
Caro Luca, che ricordi, e che emozioni... Dopo 13 anni mi è ricomparso questo video, non so come, che ha contribuito, a suo tempo, a farmi appassionare all'organo per poi arrivare dove sono ora.
Un abbraccio,
Elia Calzolari
Grazie di vero cuore. Ti abbraccio 🙂
"I have lived with my music as I have my friends, princes and all"
"I have had to make certain accommodations as we do.....as we have ALWAYS needed, to do..."
I believe my pet Pulcinella was friends with you in the 18th century.
Handel81 sei un genio! Complimenti vivissimi per questa splendida esibizione. La tua fantasia e la tua genialità non hanno limiti! Bravissimo!
YOU win this battle between Händel & Scarlatti! Bravissimo!
Just found this today. I know it's been a while, but this is a great rendition of this piece. Only other version than the movie I could find!
Straordinario complimenti bravissimo.
Non ho parole!!!! Mi sono commosso... Complimenti davvero!
Scarlatti was king of the harpsichord, better maybe than even Bach. Kind of like Liszt and the piano. Handel was better at organ than Scarlatti, however. But I bet JS Bach was a better organist than both. All three are great composers.
Santosificationable I have to disagree. Bach’s technicality in many of his keyboard music outside of the organ is far more sophisticated and difficult. If you can play Bach, you can play Scarlatti but if you can Scarlatti that doesn’t mean you can play Bach.
@@Oceananswer I wish it was that black and white, Scarlatti has a unique texture compared to both, Bach was better counterpuntally, but Scarlatti came from a different school of music namely in the neopolitan tradition his improvisational skills were developed from an early age maybe he could've written beautiful harmonies and sophisticated themes but bach would won in the fugal style
There are the generation of 1685
Your nuts, Scarlatti was noti n the same class as either Bach nor Handel.
Scarlatti better harpsichordist than Bach?? Have you ever listened to Bach's harpsichord concertos, or the book for Anna Magdalene, or the Goldberg Variations, or the famous solo of Brandenburg concert 5? Surely their style was completely different -Scarlatti had nothing of Bach's counterpoint, Bach had nothing of Scarlatti mannerisms - but to place the Sicilian above the German means to understand nothing about music.
Complimenti, una maestria che definirei degna di quei grandi compositori
옛날부터 주기적으로 와서 듣고가는데 항상 좋네용ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ최고
Passacaglia is a great masterpiece of genius!
Improvisation ? Incredible...extraordinary...Seriously, the world looses a fantastic musician...Musician like you must be see by every ears ! (Sorry for my english, je suis français!)
Ton anglais est très bon!
passcaglia handel NOM DE LA PIECE
I like choice of music, I love old music. So very well played an honor to the composer
So beautiful for the audience,BRAVO !!!
Una versione della passacaglia davvero splenda.complimenti.
Très joli ! A Tutti !
Domonico Scarlatti should of been the winner in of the harpsichord. although we are not sue exactly how the preformances went that day but over all handel wrote better organ music and scarlatti harpsichord and both of their choir music was equal.
Increible !! magica esta musica y excelente interpretación !!
una "rilettura e sintesi" davvero interessante ed entusiasmante: GRAZIE !!!!
🎉🎉🎉🎉magnífico, sublime
Bravissimo! L'accostamento è davvero squisito. Complimenti!
This is absolutely beautiful! Bravo!
Bravo, bravíssimo. Venha tocar no Rio de Janeiro, será magnifico ouvir você ao vivo, grande abraço.
Cara, eu não entendi esse título?
Quem compôs essa peça, Haendel ou Scarlatti?
Esse "Handel vs Scarlatti " veio de um filme em que mostra Handel e Scarlatti tendo um duelo de cravo. Mas, quem fez a música foi Handel: Passacaglia in G-Minor. No entanto, a música do vídeo está bastante alterada, um arranjo, mas lembra a música original.
Wonderful!
A master piece!
5 STARS*****
I FOUND THE PIECE AFTER ONE YEAR !!!!! passcaglia handel
Complimenti Luca sei bravissimo!
Maravilloso!!!
Scarlatti é o maior mestre das teclas (cravo e pianoforte de Cristofori) para sempre! Humilde e cortês elogiou Handel para não perder o amigo! Quanto a Bach, talvez na plateia, copiando alguma coisa dos mestres! Scarlatti is the greatest master of keys (harpsichord and Cristofori fortepiano) forever! Humble and courteous, he praised Handel for not losing his friend! As for Bach, perhaps in the audience, copying something from the masters!
non trovo le parole... bravo :) Buona festa di Ognissanti!
this is amazing, we can rarely hear someone play the organ so well. there are no organ players around. I have advice for you, if you're reading this, play some modern pieces or rock music pieces on the organ that way you'll get a lot of viewers and subscribers because they'll be impressed by an old instrument playing modern music.
StopFear really make sense!
amazing... needless to say !!!
La verdad esque ha sido bonito, pero para los que no conozcan esta batalla, el simplemente esta recreando los acordes que se utilizaron en la batalla, e improvisando sobre esos acordes. Pero esta muy bien, le felicito.
Eccezionale. Grazie Maestro!
Bravissimo... 6:54 you got time for that too..😂 thanks for sharing..
Veramente bravo, superlativo!!! Ma perché guarda concentrato il leggio quando non c'è nulla? È solo una curiosità non una polemica
Grazie, lo faccio perché sono concentrato.
@@Handel81 La risposta che mi aspettavo, e questo aumenta la mia stima. Ancora complimenti. (Sono un ex organista liturgico). Grazie
Bravo Luca, bravo davvero :)
very very talented man
... che bello!!
@Handel81 Sei bravissimo, sia come esecuzione che come gusto artistico. Un amico comune mi ha segnalato questo tuo video e lo ringrazio per averlo fatto. Una curiosità: hai riprodotto il clavicembalo per i registri nativi dell'organo o hai un accoppiamento MIDI? Come ti chiami?
Ciao e grazie!
Filippo
Che bel "pasticcio" complimenti
Complimenti 🎉
👏👏👏
GENIAL ET SUBLIME
Porca miseria! Quanto sei Bravo, con la B maiuscola!
sei incredibile, tu hai composto alcune parte di questa pezza? (so che é di Handel, ma non é cosí originariamente)
Grandios!
LOVE IT LOVE IT LOVE IT!!!!!!!!!!!!
Bellisimo! Che tipo di organo suoni?
Could I ask you for the sheet music/ score
Good morning Luke !!! I AM YOUR BIG FAN. I wanted to ask you about the purchase of the Alborn 3 organ, and I wanted to ask you what you think about this model today, or is there even better something and which version to choose German and others? Thank you for your earlier reply.
not sure what is Scarlatti's and what Handel's, generally I prefer Handel as composer of orchestral music, but there is not comparison to Scarlatti for all the rest: Scarlatti historically outperformed Handel on the "cembalo" and on keyboard completely.
very beautifull,nice instrument
Brilliant!
bravissimo e brano veramente molto bello ... ma il suono del clavicembalo è elettronico ?
Fabuloso!!!!! es versión libre?
Crazy man lol excellent interpretation
@Handel81 Sei bravissimo, sia come esecuzione che come gusto artistico. Un amico comune mi ha segnalato questo tuo video e lo ringrazio per averlo fatto. Una curiosità: hai riprodotto il clavicembalo attraverso i registri nativi dello strumento o hai un accoppiamento MIDI? Come ti chiami?
Ciao e grazie!
Filippo
I want one of those instruments for MY living room!
Bravissimo!!!
what kind of music intrument is that??? pipe organ, harpsichord, organ, etc omg
BRAVO!!!
Could you tell me, what's this composition name?
Is that a cross between a harpsichord and a pipe organ?
Grande Luca!!!
Bravo!
amazing
Very beautiful
looooove it
bravissimo
incredible
super
@Handel81 Oh ecco! Pensavo vi fosse qualche diavoleria medievale! ahhaha
Bravo !!
Amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! =D
Claviorgan?
Or organcembalo!
Pipesichord
Claviorgan XD
THAT WAS EPIC
just awesome :)
tHANKS.
How did you arrange those keyboards?? You are awesome man
digital mega organ probably
passcaglia handel
❤
Interesante órgano es un Roland?
bellissimo "duetto immaginario"... anche se lo stile è abbastanza "handeliano" anche al cembalo.
@auuandatore Non le leggo perchè non ci sono :)
.....Sarebbero nate composizioni eccezionali!!!!!
Forse questa potrebbe uguagliarle
Baroque RAP battle
sono funzionanti le canne ?? cmq ho anche io il trenino con il nome sull'organo xD
envy..I wish I were him...
Lang leve de barok !
What type of organ is this?
Marry me, pleaseeeee
Scarlatti to #madrid and Haendel to #london jajajajj
Sei bravissimo. Conosci sto brano a memoria ?
@yangmagic0703 Yesss!!
Dove caxxo le legge le note?
The harpsichord part sounds nothing like Scarlatti's style. More like Haendel's.
Maestro que vale un clavecín como el que tiene, quiero uno para aprender a tocar y crear mis melodías.
Hande88 v:
scommetto che lei ha l'orecchio assoluto... o sbaglio?
Ynkka
Ma è Salvini che suona ? 😅
Spleen deParis hahahahhaha 😊😂😂😂
@@Handel81
Eh un po' si dai....
Cmq complimenti. Bacioni....😅😅
amazing