Because other regions like Catalunia, the Jura or even Bavaria could follow all over Europe. We would have a patchwork like before WW1, which didn’t end well for anyone! Besides, the E. T. A. are marxist communists, which didn’t end well either. A social capitalism might not be perfect, but it gave us peace, food and freedom our ancestors could only dream about. Good enough for me.
I´m daughter of a political exiled because of Basque independentism. Terrorists wanted money so they threatened my family, this is what they called "impuesto revolucionario" (revolutionary tax). My family had to sell their home and leave Basque Country in secret just because if you don´t pay you will die because of a bomb in your car or a gun shot in the street. It is suposed that ETA have been disolved today but this is because they had gained the streets. Disidents were/are bullied in many ways, many has left the country and many other just hide their true feelings and remain silent and scared. Independentist teach their propaganda in schools so after 35 years of that they had legions of blind loyal followers. 1997, after Miguel Angel Blanco murder, was a moment of hope. When many of this non independentist feel strong and free to point independentist as accomplices of a criminal movement. But this moment past, nothing can be done when young generations were teached in hate and lies. Independentist has manipulated Basque history and corrupted their culture. They are a shame. They are worst than fascists.
Bienvenida, hermana. Yo también soy vasco, y mi padre igualmente fue amenazado de muerte por ETA. Mi madre estaba llorando cuando me contó cómo fue el día en el que secuestraron a Miguel Angel, nunca la vi tan conmovida… Y tienes razón. No hay nada que haya hecho tanto daño a Euskadi como el independentismo… por eso, soy vasco, y estoy orgulloso de ser parte de España. Viva Euskadi! Gora Espainia!
Why not ? Do you enjoy having your ‘ nation ‘ notoriously renowned as a revolting gaol of peoples ? Remember. N O T H I N G, I repeat, NOTHING, lasts forever. And not shall ‘ Spain ‘ ( a mere Castilian empire ).
The Basks from Spain, are descendents of the Huns, when Attila invaded Europe, he reach the north of spain, some of his hordes remained in that area, this ppl are basically hungarians descendents and this guys have no mother land, they came from mongolia, if you look at their migdaled eyes, you will recognize them easly.
Basques have nothing to do with huns. And also; Attila was turkic, not mongol. At that time there wasn't such a thing ''Mongol''. Huns were turkic federation of different turkic tribes.
When Humberto Undueta said that during Franco dictatorship Basque culture were baned is FALSE. My grandparent whas "txistulari" (player of a typical basque instrument) during franquism. He recorded discs, traveled through all Spain playing traditional basque music and dances in typical basque dress as a member of "Coros y Danzas" (chorus and dance) a national organization to preserve and promote folklore from all Spain. This is how he meet my grandmother!!!!! Of course is true that Franco was represive, he was a dictator! But after him, in democracy, "euskera" (basque language) was recognice as co-oficial language in Spain along other idioms like "Galego" (galician) or "catalan" (catalonian) and is teached in schools, in fact they are highly autonomous (spanish autonomic system is the more open and permisive from EU. Scotland has said they are jealous of that!!!!)
Jon Muniain Most of the vasques are not independentist. In Madrid is almost impossible to see a independentist vasque. The vasquds in Madrid usually have scaped from ETA and for that as they were minaced they are not independentist.
Jon Muniain You could, but the vasques in Madrid tend to be spanish patriots, the feel very spaniards, it is very rare see a independentist vasque in Madrid. There is freedoom, you could, but it is very unusual on the Madrid Vasque community.
People must be allowed to decide how they want to be ruled, so why is Spain afraid of giving them what they want? It is their own dream.
The Spanish Constitution does not allow for it. You would have to change the Constitution to allow for it which is no easy task
@Sayan Dutta I am but I want to do so legally
@Sayan Dutta used to but the desire for independence has died down from what I heard
@Sayan Dutta it lost support from the population as violent actions were being much less supported as now the population had more autonomy
Because other regions like Catalunia, the Jura or even Bavaria could follow all over Europe.
We would have a patchwork like before WW1, which didn’t end well for anyone!
Besides, the E. T. A. are marxist communists, which didn’t end well either.
A social capitalism might not be perfect, but it gave us peace, food and freedom our ancestors could only dream about.
Good enough for me.
The song the marchers sing at 1:45 is "Eusko Gudariak", or "Basque Warriors", which was the anthem of the Basque Country during the Spanish Civil War.
Continuing `Solidarity from Ireland!` Tiocfaidh ár lá!
its a empty dream
I´m daughter of a political exiled because of Basque independentism. Terrorists wanted money so they threatened my family, this is what they called "impuesto revolucionario" (revolutionary tax). My family had to sell their home and leave Basque Country in secret just because if you don´t pay you will die because of a bomb in your car or a gun shot in the street.
It is suposed that ETA have been disolved today but this is because they had gained the streets. Disidents were/are bullied in many ways, many has left the country and many other just hide their true feelings and remain silent and scared. Independentist teach their propaganda in schools so after 35 years of that they had legions of blind loyal followers.
1997, after Miguel Angel Blanco murder, was a moment of hope. When many of this non independentist feel strong and free to point independentist as accomplices of a criminal movement. But this moment past, nothing can be done when young generations were teached in hate and lies.
Independentist has manipulated Basque history and corrupted their culture. They are a shame. They are worst than fascists.
Bienvenida, hermana.
Yo también soy vasco, y mi padre igualmente fue amenazado de muerte por ETA.
Mi madre estaba llorando cuando me contó cómo fue el día en el que secuestraron a Miguel Angel, nunca la vi tan conmovida…
Y tienes razón. No hay nada que haya hecho tanto daño a Euskadi como el independentismo… por eso, soy vasco, y estoy orgulloso de ser parte de España.
Viva Euskadi! Gora Espainia!
ETA was sold two times. It's occultism. Mimetism military. A tactic strategy.
Franco: exists
Basque country: uh oh, I'm in danger
Quite interesting to see some people speaking from the other side. Estamos hartos de escuchar a las """""víctimas""""" hablar de SU única verdad.
Saoirse. Tiochfaidh ár lá.
@our rights first what even is britishness anymore? britain is not even scotish english or welsh anymore...
Gorra ETA. Beti Erreala.
ETA a ido de gorra, cierto. Con Real Suciedad.
The last indigenous Europeans.
You forgot the finnic peoples.
Literally LOL!
And Sardinians.
@@NotOrdinaryInGames The: Basque language and Finnish language have entrounched roots.
@@errikartazuri5651 Cannot be proven one way or another, sorry :(
Gora Euskadi!!!!
Nice flag.
Cheers mate!
Union Jack's copy.
Euskal Herria
Spain will not compromise their integrity or borders by granting the basque people a separete nation.
It did not happen in 500 years or in the future.
Why not ? Do you enjoy having your ‘ nation ‘ notoriously renowned as a revolting gaol of peoples ? Remember. N O T H I N G, I repeat, NOTHING, lasts forever. And not shall ‘ Spain ‘ ( a mere Castilian empire ).
well, some said the same about the "sahara province" or "guinea" ... not in a hurry, spain is broke by itself
The Basque, Catalunyan and Galician regions should join forces to demand independence from Madrid.
independence only leads to disappointment. thats what usually happens.
Donosti is not Spain
Rush B banana
Gora ETA
Where was the USA?…
Far left paramilitary
Jon Muniain freedom fighters
Based
@@oracle8192 cringe
@@Nangong123 seethe
Based paramilitary
The Basks from Spain, are descendents of the Huns, when Attila invaded Europe, he reach the north of spain, some of his hordes remained in that area, this ppl are basically hungarians descendents and this guys have no mother land, they came from mongolia, if you look at their migdaled eyes, you will recognize them easly.
No.
Some families with long lineages look Asian. I am basque
Is that a joke?
Basques have nothing to do with huns. And also; Attila was turkic, not mongol. At that time there wasn't such a thing ''Mongol''. Huns were turkic federation of different turkic tribes.
😂 what a load of bollox
Where do they want their country? Is it Andorra?
b r u h
Bietan jarrai
Euskal Presoak ETXERA
GORA EUSKAL HERRIA... eta NAFARROA... eta ARAGÓN.... eta CATALUNYA.... I..... (...) URTE BERRI ON 2024🎆🥃🎱🌊👉
🤮
When Humberto Undueta said that during Franco dictatorship Basque culture were baned is FALSE. My grandparent whas "txistulari" (player of a typical basque instrument) during franquism. He recorded discs, traveled through all Spain playing traditional basque music and dances in typical basque dress as a member of "Coros y Danzas" (chorus and dance) a national organization to preserve and promote folklore from all Spain. This is how he meet my grandmother!!!!!
Of course is true that Franco was represive, he was a dictator! But after him, in democracy, "euskera" (basque language) was recognice as co-oficial language in Spain along other idioms like "Galego" (galician) or "catalan" (catalonian) and is teached in schools, in fact they are highly autonomous (spanish autonomic system is the more open and permisive from EU. Scotland has said they are jealous of that!!!!)
what if I am basque (family), but born in Madrid
Jon Muniain Most of the vasques are not independentist. In Madrid is almost impossible to see a independentist vasque. The vasquds in Madrid usually have scaped from ETA and for that as they were minaced they are not independentist.
but im wondering if i could be a independentist if I was born in madrid, but have only basque blood
Jon Muniain You could, but the vasques in Madrid tend to be spanish patriots, the feel very spaniards, it is very rare see a independentist vasque in Madrid. There is freedoom, you could, but it is very unusual on the Madrid Vasque community.
You could still play for athletic club
Madrid is full of maketanos de puta y de equaafricanos. Hahaha.
Bars El
Spain will not compromise their integrity or borders by granting the basque people a separete nation.
It did not happen in 500 years or in the future.
There is no integrity in what Spain does to hold onto the prosperity generated by the Catalans and Basques
Gora ETA