This one surprised me. I expected more of the same, and, whereas it's the same system, some nice thematic additions are to be found! I really enjoyed this one. If you enjoy it too, please 'Like' and Comment below. And thanks for visiting! 👍😊
Great overview, Solo! So well explained, and this looks like a great challenge! It looks like they’ve spent a lot of time working on the AI, so that games will play out quite differently. Wonderful work!
@@ZillaBlitz Yes Zilla correct. Now I wish they had 'difficulty' steps like they did in the other bookgames. Here we get 12 day 1 without step changes and then 12 day 2. Admittedly the 2 days of battle are very different to be fair.
Thanks for the excellent and enthusiastic review. You give a good sense of the play so - as the comments show - people can decide if it suits them. I’ll have to watch your Waterloo review. A minor note: the names shown on the Day 2 map reflect divisions rather than brigades, e.g., Hood’s division.
Thanks for another excellent video. I suspect given how much fun I've had with the other titles in this series I'd buy this anyway, but your video tipped the balance for me 😊
Gettysburg is a very tough battle for the Confederates to win, although they should be able to score a tactical victory on the first day...which they did. They outnumbered the Union at that point. Their morale was extremely high, and they had utmost confidence in themselves after several past victories. The Union, on the other hand, fought harder than usual, being on their home ground, and they chose very good defensive positions which is often the key to winning Civil War battles. After Day 1 their growing superiority in numbers, plus their positions on the high ground eventually began wearing out the Confederate army. It is not really surprising that the game deals only with the first 2 days, because after the 2nd day had ended Lee should have disengaged. His famous attack on the Union center on the 3rd day was a disaster, and should never have been made in the first place....but Lee's "blood was up" and he was in no mood to just give up the fight and leave Pennsylvania. It was not the first time Lee had been reckless, but this time it did not work out!
Another brillant, indepth review Paul, tremendously well done! I was on the fence about this book because I wasn't sure if it's that different from Waterloo to justify the purchase. Your explanation and presentation is excellent in showing the differences and now I'm convinced it's more than worth it. I'll order it right away. By the way: I can't wait for your take on On to Moscow Solitaire. I got it yesterday but wasn't in the mood to play it yet (the rules seemed a bit messy to me).
Another good presentation Solo. Whilst not being drawn into ACW at all this may well be just that game book for the non enthusiast. As always good posture on presenting the flow of what the game is and really good focus on the three days as separate games, definitely an interesting bonus.
Hi Heth, thank you for the kind words. These books are well presented in general but next I'm returning to something much more to your taste - back to the Age of Reason!
Just letting you know I've bought all four in the series based on your videos! Any ideas on what might be next? Battle of Cannae? Agincourt? Cydonia? Okay that last one isn't real, but I would be interested in a fictional sci-fi battle on Mars, but that's just me haha. Love your content and look forward to seeing more!
Thanks very much for taking valuable time watching the videos, I really appreciate it. Grape vine suggests Coral Sea is in the pipeline and may be next! 👍
Hello! I have a question: in the scenario for Day 2, how should I interpret the result 4 on the Random Events Table ("Meade in command: Ignore 1 Union hit this turn")? Does this mean that I should ignore a "hit" inflicted by the Union on the Confederates, or conversely, should I ignore a "hit" inflicted on the Union by the Confederates? (Note: I am French, and perhaps my English is deficient!)
Bought Bismarck. wow!!!😀😀👍👍 not big on Napoleonics but I figured I'd give the Waterloo one a shot. 😀😀👍👍. enjoy so much I went out and bought about 50 English 50 French and 60 Prussian 28 mm figures. Yes I've finally gone deep into the Napoleonic era I guess I need to get my Avalon Hill War and Peace out next...lol. braveheart and Gettysburg. just don't feel interested in them. for the ACW; what no day 3 fight?
Yeah Charles, Bismarck is my favourite! And Napoleonic figures? Amazing! Just shows how our interest can be triggered at any time. Thats the sign of an agile mind and a healthy hobby 😊
I know, really weird. I bought mine from Amazon UK but I've checked since and its dissapeared! One rumour is it may have been challenged because of Copyright on the title. But Worthington are silent!
Good to hear from you again, thanks! I've put quite a bit of my game into the video in various parts but have too much on to do a playthrough. They're a fairly simple concept but cleverly done. You'd probably enjoy it 👍
This one I did not enjoy. I was really disappointed. I felt there were issues in the rules, all 12 battles for the 2 days are the exact same unlike in Waterloo where they change the bots actions. My final major issue is that day 1 strategy for victory is basically always the same- attack in same order, never go after the reserves.... For anyone debating which book to get, I would say get waterloo and pass on this one
Fair comment my friend. I've only played once each battle so far so I suppose can't really make that judgement. With one play each battle my first impression has been positive. Always appreciate your view, thank you 😊
I've watched every video you have made, I may not purchase all of the games but I very much enjoy your humours explanations and I have to say I have never noticed your hands, too interested in the game and enjoying your explanations! Personally speaking I don't think comments like that are helpful to anyone.
This one surprised me. I expected more of the same, and, whereas it's the same system, some nice thematic additions are to be found! I really enjoyed this one. If you enjoy it too, please 'Like' and Comment below. And thanks for visiting! 👍😊
I might purchase this game. Superb video, love watching your videos!
Thanks Brun! I just reckon these books are so accessible for a quick filler game every so often.
Thanks for the overview, mate. I think I'll grab this one. Cheers from Canada.
Thanks very much, hope all is well in great Canada! I had some fun with this edition 👍
Great overview, Solo! So well explained, and this looks like a great challenge! It looks like they’ve spent a lot of time working on the AI, so that games will play out quite differently. Wonderful work!
Thanks for checking in Zilla, appreciated. Yes I like these publications mainly because they're just so accessible! And tough to beat 😊
@@soloboardgaming I did have one question. Is the book basically 2 sets of 12 identical battles? So each page for the 2 battles is repeated 12 times?
@@ZillaBlitz Yes Zilla correct. Now I wish they had 'difficulty' steps like they did in the other bookgames. Here we get 12 day 1 without step changes and then 12 day 2. Admittedly the 2 days of battle are very different to be fair.
@@soloboardgaming Thanks for clarifying, SOLO! Yes, I can see how some variability in the 2 would be nice. :)
Thanks for the excellent and enthusiastic review. You give a good sense of the play so - as the comments show - people can decide if it suits them. I’ll have to watch your Waterloo review. A minor note: the names shown on the Day 2 map reflect divisions rather than brigades, e.g., Hood’s division.
Hi thanks for watching and for your comment. And I appreciate your info that we're dealing with divisions and not brigades, it all helps 😊👍
Thanks for another excellent video. I suspect given how much fun I've had with the other titles in this series I'd buy this anyway, but your video tipped the balance for me 😊
Thanks again Andrew. Enjoy!
Gettysburg is a very tough battle for the Confederates to win, although they should be able to score a tactical victory on the first day...which they did. They outnumbered the Union at that point. Their morale was extremely high, and they had utmost confidence in themselves after several past victories. The Union, on the other hand, fought harder than usual, being on their home ground, and they chose very good defensive positions which is often the key to winning Civil War battles. After Day 1 their growing superiority in numbers, plus their positions on the high ground eventually began wearing out the Confederate army. It is not really surprising that the game deals only with the first 2 days, because after the 2nd day had ended Lee should have disengaged. His famous attack on the Union center on the 3rd day was a disaster, and should never have been made in the first place....but Lee's "blood was up" and he was in no mood to just give up the fight and leave Pennsylvania. It was not the first time Lee had been reckless, but this time it did not work out!
Another great review. Well done, Sir!
I enjoyed doing it actually so I'm glad you liked it, thanks!
Another brillant, indepth review Paul, tremendously well done! I was on the fence about this book because I wasn't sure if it's that different from Waterloo to justify the purchase. Your explanation and presentation is excellent in showing the differences and now I'm convinced it's more than worth it. I'll order it right away. By the way: I can't wait for your take on On to Moscow Solitaire. I got it yesterday but wasn't in the mood to play it yet (the rules seemed a bit messy to me).
Thats very kind of you, thank you! I'm pleased I helped a little. And you just reminded me I haven't ordered On to Moscow yet! 😊
Another good presentation Solo. Whilst not being drawn into ACW at all this may well be just that game book for the non enthusiast. As always good posture on presenting the flow of what the game is and really good focus on the three days as separate games, definitely an interesting bonus.
Hi Heth, thank you for the kind words. These books are well presented in general but next I'm returning to something much more to your taste - back to the Age of Reason!
@@soloboardgaming Always looking forward to your showcases. Have to catch up with the Ici... series :)
Just letting you know I've bought all four in the series based on your videos! Any ideas on what might be next? Battle of Cannae? Agincourt? Cydonia? Okay that last one isn't real, but I would be interested in a fictional sci-fi battle on Mars, but that's just me haha. Love your content and look forward to seeing more!
Thanks very much for taking valuable time watching the videos, I really appreciate it. Grape vine suggests Coral Sea is in the pipeline and may be next! 👍
Hello! I have a question: in the scenario for Day 2, how should I interpret the result 4 on the Random Events Table ("Meade in command: Ignore 1 Union hit this turn")? Does this mean that I should ignore a "hit" inflicted by the Union on the Confederates, or conversely, should I ignore a "hit" inflicted on the Union by the Confederates? (Note: I am French, and perhaps my English is deficient!)
I know this battle very well so might be the first of these book games I pick up.
Hi Jon, First again! You'd enjoy it im sure, it's a real tough one and the options have moved up a gear. Loved it! 👍
Bought Bismarck. wow!!!😀😀👍👍
not big on Napoleonics but I figured I'd give the Waterloo one a shot. 😀😀👍👍. enjoy so much I went out and bought about 50 English 50 French and 60 Prussian 28 mm figures. Yes I've finally gone deep into the Napoleonic era I guess I need to get my Avalon Hill War and Peace out next...lol.
braveheart and Gettysburg. just don't feel interested in them. for the ACW; what no day 3 fight?
Yeah Charles, Bismarck is my favourite! And Napoleonic figures? Amazing! Just shows how our interest can be triggered at any time. Thats the sign of an agile mind and a healthy hobby 😊
Braveheart doesn't show up on amazon?
I know, really weird. I bought mine from Amazon UK but I've checked since and its dissapeared! One rumour is it may have been challenged because of Copyright on the title. But Worthington are silent!
Hoping for a playthrough to sell me. Is it even doable and be interesting for this series?
Excited to see the mechanics of it!
Good to hear from you again, thanks! I've put quite a bit of my game into the video in various parts but have too much on to do a playthrough. They're a fairly simple concept but cleverly done. You'd probably enjoy it 👍
@@soloboardgaming I find myself being drawn to simpler, slower but still with some meat on the bones type games and I enjoy solo plays alot! Thanks!
@@jumpmaster82nd. I must admit, I like slow paced games too. I like to take things easy and enjoy my time :)
@@soloboardgaming $29.00 US...not a big gamble to take now days in the world of gaming is it?! Im in...
I think the game is too static even if you can advance a position, much more movement is needed.
This one I did not enjoy. I was really disappointed. I felt there were issues in the rules, all 12 battles for the 2 days are the exact same unlike in Waterloo where they change the bots actions. My final major issue is that day 1 strategy for victory is basically always the same- attack in same order, never go after the reserves.... For anyone debating which book to get, I would say get waterloo and pass on this one
Fair comment my friend. I've only played once each battle so far so I suppose can't really make that judgement. With one play each battle my first impression has been positive. Always appreciate your view, thank you 😊
Interesting video.
The shaking hands are a distraction though.
You should really drop that from the camera view.
Thank you watching and for your feedback, its appreciated. Yes I do get embarrassed by my nervous condition so I'm sorry if you find it distracting.
I've watched every video you have made, I may not purchase all of the games but I very much enjoy your humours explanations and I have to say I have never noticed your hands, too interested in the game and enjoying your explanations! Personally speaking I don't think comments like that are helpful to anyone.
@@Jennie-fo5xj Thank you Jennie, thats kind of you. Life is a box of chocolates 😊
@@soloboardgaming Well, just get rid of the distraction in your video and that will be one less thing to be embarrassed about.
Who is the more valuable human being? My vote goes to the enthusiastic content creator. The other guy suckled from his mother's anus.