I will take some wild guesses, but the "judges" are either 1. trolling and will just criticize for content purposes (all for it btw), 2. is a composer but has only composed songs that are of a certain genre (or circle of genre) and is not exactly experienced in the music production of other types of songs, 3. Just have extremely biased side in song and is trying to be "harsh in judgement" but is just trying to go through the motions of being "harsh" that they decide to find any and all reasons to "not like" the song. I will lean more on 2 as they has made some good comparisons to the specified songs, but 1 and 3 are still out there. (just my opinion on this, so I will say this can be in the spectrum of 100% right and 100% wrong)
Fair take, rating music will always be controversial, cus everyone's tastes are so diffirent. As you can see, we disagreed a lot in the video itself, lol
@@fathermarkelch.4191 Even at Plush, sometimes all the juries speak negatively, but it seems to me that people there still try to look for pluses more than minuses. Like not listening and trying to figure out if you like it, but rather trying to figure out if it's good music at all. В остальном не знаю, но тоже весело, как и предыдущее. Почаще зовите опоссума. Она создаёт нужный колорит вам.
this was genuinely hilarious to watch, i died when your friends started roasting Operation Ashring (the first CC i had when i got back to AK after a break so. emotional damage XD) but even so it was REALLY funny to hear their opinions hahahahha also i hear there's character themes video coming? can't wait to hear them probably murder Ständchen but i'll enjoy it still :D excited for future vids!
Loved the video, even though I disagree with most of your friends opinions, and agree with most of yours. Maybe we have the same opinions because of playing the game and interacting heavily with the community which I guess isn't the case for your friends. One extremely satisfactory moment for me was when your friends placed cc10 (ashrising) pretty low! It feels like the song is universally loved by the community, but I hate it largely because of the boss mechanic, and for musical reasons too (literally sounds like american high schooll teen drama crap for me) All in all, loved the stuff, reminds me a lot of the arkights troll videos box used to make, who unfortunatey seems to be suffering from a severe bout of mihoyo-itis these days
cc theme is mean a lot to the player, i mean the song could be very rare to hear since its just a event a hard event, im also could say some of it are good and bad but yeah i still enjoy it back when i start in cc10 like i cant even play in that event its so damn hard so the only thing i do its just listen to the bgm. ngl the tier list is su*k but its ok because lot of people who dont play arknight listen to the song.
Колыбельная по тексту и исполнению вполне достойна. В песне и не такое изменение ударений допустимо. Даже не скажешь, что вообще-то проживающая в США монголка исполняет. А вот Реквием и Прощание да, в них акцент силён. Плюс Реквием странноват по тексту вышел, будучи надёрганными частями из одноимённой поэмы Ахматовой.
CC#11 and CC#12 themes are the weakest ones for me, even Wild Scales that's in a genre that I don't like, is a song I wouldn't mind to have on my playlist. Boss themes next?
Ashring just decent? That's offensive >:((( It's one of the best if not the best... But I can understand some people have different taste. Though I'm still offended :')
nah this tier list is just made to trigger me ,the 2 worst ones that imo are F tier go to S and A and the actual good ones dont get to barely go to A tier .ik this tier list is biased af but come on cc3? i thought that was a solid f- tier
You guys keep talking and talking, you're not even wait for the best part of the song and Cinder? Really? So much for a deadline replacement of a song. Please just go back to guess Arknights race or something, You guys are bad at this.
Highjacking pinned comment, to shout out the composer dude, who helped us in making this: instagram.com/mityauker24/?hl=bg
My favorites are 8,9,10,12 they really kicked it up a notch towards the end.
I personally like Pyrite, Deepness and Fake waves the most but I can see why you like these ones!
@@fathermarkelch.4191 i cant stop hearing angry birds with fake waves or it would be there too XD
small correction
CC Pyrites lobby theme was made by Jason Walsh while CC7 and CC12 were made by Life Awaits if im not mistaken
Ooh, thanks! Didn't know that!
I made the same mistake, but by saying Jason Walsh made CC12 when it was Life Awaits. Both are certified bangers.
Ashring done dirty.
Hope one day I will speak English as fluently as you guys :D Thanks for the content ❤
Everyone starts somewhere, so you'll def get there! And thank you, friend!
I will take some wild guesses, but the "judges" are either 1. trolling and will just criticize for content purposes (all for it btw), 2. is a composer but has only composed songs that are of a certain genre (or circle of genre) and is not exactly experienced in the music production of other types of songs, 3. Just have extremely biased side in song and is trying to be "harsh in judgement" but is just trying to go through the motions of being "harsh" that they decide to find any and all reasons to "not like" the song. I will lean more on 2 as they has made some good comparisons to the specified songs, but 1 and 3 are still out there. (just my opinion on this, so I will say this can be in the spectrum of 100% right and 100% wrong)
Fair take, rating music will always be controversial, cus everyone's tastes are so diffirent. As you can see, we disagreed a lot in the video itself, lol
@@fathermarkelch.4191 Even at Plush, sometimes all the juries speak negatively, but it seems to me that people there still try to look for pluses more than minuses. Like not listening and trying to figure out if you like it, but rather trying to figure out if it's good music at all. В остальном не знаю, но тоже весело, как и предыдущее. Почаще зовите опоссума. Она создаёт нужный колорит вам.
I'm no music man, but i'd like to see a certification or something from the judges. >:c
this was genuinely hilarious to watch, i died when your friends started roasting Operation Ashring (the first CC i had when i got back to AK after a break so. emotional damage XD) but even so it was REALLY funny to hear their opinions hahahahha
also i hear there's character themes video coming? can't wait to hear them probably murder Ständchen but i'll enjoy it still :D excited for future vids!
Yes, we'll finish recirding characters this Friday! They will be on the channel next week probably!
@@fathermarkelch.4191 NICE!! looking forward to it~~
чел вкладывает всю душу в пламя - ну B тир максимум
баба завывает на одной клавише пианина - S тир
Loved the video, even though I disagree with most of your friends opinions, and agree with most of yours. Maybe we have the same opinions because of playing the game and interacting heavily with the community which I guess isn't the case for your friends. One extremely satisfactory moment for me was when your friends placed cc10 (ashrising) pretty low! It feels like the song is universally loved by the community, but I hate it largely because of the boss mechanic, and for musical reasons too (literally sounds like american high schooll teen drama crap for me)
All in all, loved the stuff, reminds me a lot of the arkights troll videos box used to make, who unfortunatey seems to be suffering from a severe bout of mihoyo-itis these days
CC4 and CC6 is the only thing I Have Terrible Taste with, CC8 is Almost
cc theme is mean a lot to the player, i mean the song could be very rare to hear since its just a event a hard event, im also could say some of it are good and bad but yeah i still enjoy it back when i start in cc10 like i cant even play in that event its so damn hard so the only thing i do its just listen to the bgm. ngl the tier list is su*k but its ok because lot of people who dont play arknight listen to the song.
Ngl this tierlist make me want to punch the screen
Меня кукожит кажрый раз, когда слышу песни на ломаном русском из аркнайц. Боюсь даже представить какой стёб будет над реквиемом и колыбельной.
Колыбельная по тексту и исполнению вполне достойна. В песне и не такое изменение ударений допустимо. Даже не скажешь, что вообще-то проживающая в США монголка исполняет.
А вот Реквием и Прощание да, в них акцент силён. Плюс Реквием странноват по тексту вышел, будучи надёрганными частями из одноимённой поэмы Ахматовой.
I'm loving your friends xD let's they rank character music pls
We have already started on it yesterday! Part two will be done on twitch next Friday! The vid will be done after the boss music tierlist!
@@fathermarkelch.4191 really?! omw
CC#11 and CC#12 themes are the weakest ones for me, even Wild Scales that's in a genre that I don't like, is a song I wouldn't mind to have on my playlist.
Boss themes next?
Yup! Boss themes next!
Yup, Boss themes are already recorded (streamed), so the vid is on the way!
@@fathermarkelch.4191 Cool! Can't wait to see it.
Can't compare to an actual composer if we are talking about music but my favourite has to be Pine Soot
I disagree with him on principle
ASHRING IN C TIER????? IM RIOTING
12:10 ну и как мне блть это теперь развидеть или расслышать?)
Ashring just decent? That's offensive >:((( It's one of the best if not the best...
But I can understand some people have different taste. Though I'm still offended :')
Nahhhhh wtf. How could you put the angry bird ass theme of CC#11 in the same tier as Operation Ashring???
Edit: Nvm its actually lower. Bruh
CC11 Fake Waves had a similar rythem to Angry Birds lol
Азиатская маршрутка убила
Я сам выпал, лол
i like every cc themes
Maybe character OST I would like to see the reaction on golden glow and Dorothy theme
Ooh, that's a good way to get lynched, will do those in the near future!
I hate the pine soot theme. Their work on the breakpoint theme is a great improvement though.
ждём новых видосиков
Judges have terrible taste lmao
I knew that we'd make a lot of enemies with this one lemao
@@fathermarkelch.4191 cant believe deepness didn't make S tier. true blasphemy
next with character theme?
Next vid boss themes, then characters!
I love how one of the two S rank songs out of the 12 here is literally a plagiarized track lol
What you're talking about is the initial Perma Map BGM for CC#3 in CN, which was plagarised. The CC#3 Lobby BGM, on the other hand is original.
Lol, I am actually agreeing with them. A lot of the singers are trying too hard.
Based
That actually is the point of CC so the themes fit then.
All the CC themes that had black or latin-american origin were just "k-pop", huh?
or if it's female vocal, is k-pop
nah this tier list is just made to trigger me ,the 2 worst ones that imo are F tier go to S and A and the actual good ones dont get to barely go to A tier .ik this tier list is biased af but come on cc3? i thought that was a solid f- tier
Idk but I can't stand actual songs used as lobby music, so everything other than CC#5 spectrum's theme is mid for me
You guys keep talking and talking, you're not even wait for the best part of the song and Cinder? Really? So much for a deadline replacement of a song.
Please just go back to guess Arknights race or something, You guys are bad at this.
Bad takes all around in this one