@@LeaLeaA7 idk if you know the history of why Shuhua isn't comfortable singing but here's why. Some knetz complained about her Thick Korean Accent. She's Taiwanese btw.
Minnie first part and last part suits her so well, she seems to be getting better at the oh my god part, her voice is really beautiful and dreamy and she is actually really stable Soyeon, she is a stable queen, she singed the falsettos even tho they are really hard to sing while dancing, her rap part was amazing like always, and her oh my god always give me goosebumps I love the color of Yuqi voice so much, she is really stable too, more in her second part, I think that her and Miyeon part suits them so well, it really shows her singing I really love it Miyeon, what a stable queen, she did that second part without taking a single breath, is incredible, I feel like we don't aprecciate Miyeon enough as a main vocalist, she really deserves a lot more because her singing is so beautiful geezzz Shuhua is getting so much better! I really like that she's trying to sing live, she seems more confident and I'm so so happy for her! Soojin, I know she isn't the most stable in her part, but honestly she owns the "oh my god" part, also we have to consider that she's only a vocalist and also a main dancer, that means she has to focus on her dancing and her stage presence Idle are queens so let's give the members love and support for doing their best at this amazing comeback. Neverland fighting!
This is Just my opinion but, none of them are stable. Before any of you said "can you do what they do?" No, i can't, i have learned how to sing and perform 1 time, singing livestage and singing at room are way diffrent. So do the girls have skill and potential? Yes. But is this perfomance good? Kinda, their live vocals will improve when their stamina improve. But i believe in this group potential. Stan giddle and talent✊
yall saying soyeon is so stable esp at the rap part, but if yall watched unpretty rapstar, youll know rapping live for soyeon is like speaking for her, and in produce she showed off her vocals. so expected that soyeon could be so stable, she even tries to sing the falsetto part, queen soyeon. yuqi and miyeon lines are so so good though
@@iwillhityouwithblackpinksl9879 still doesn't sound good. The rest of her performance is good. I hope other members can try to improve themselves. Only she and Miyeon or sometimes Yuqi can sing live.
Lyma is still the only MR remove I trust. She always tells us when it's pre recorded etc. She does a good job. She doesn't make fake MR removed videos. She always keeps it real. Thank you Lyma ❤ Edit: why I write this? 1. it is the truth 2. I once got hated on a "MR removed" video by another youtube channel. It was pre recorded video and he didn't say it. So when I said it I got hate and called fake fan :)
@@mateokovacicchelsea It means that they've recorded the vocals beforehand. Because they can't always dance and sing :) it's normal in kpop to use this
MinhVu pre recorded means they recorded it before the performance. Usually they do this at full volume in their first performance for their comeback. But the next few stages they lower the pre recorded vocal
actually there are all improving .. if you watch their previous song mr removed like uh oh and lion .. they are all really stable .. this song actually is a bit hard to sing because of the chord and the technique
@@aryssa-qh1jo honestly all of them are off key and can't hit notes correctly. Only Miyeon did good, Soyeon is only stable on her rap part. No hate, just stating facts. This is like lowering the standard.
Red are you an anti of Soyeon or something? Cause I’ve seen you talking shit about Soyeon not being stable and I was like?????? You need to get your ears check and get a therapist
@@exit-orion3559 Yall should stop making fan wars between Gidle and Blackpink. Miyeon is and always will be a small portion of blackpink, the girls were friends in the past. Both groups support each other, so why hate?
Oh my god 😍😍😍 all of them are so talented and stable!!! Soyeon even try to sing those high notes😎 Shuhua improved so much!!!!!! I am proud of her!Shuhua fighting!!!!! Taiwan's pride😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
The fact, that Soyeon Raps live even though her Raps aren't easy to Rap because they're so fast and also the coreogeaphies aren't that easy … that's what I call live performance /stage presence! Go girl!💓
Yuqi, Miyeon you're doing great as usual despite how many line you got in this song! Shuhua, thank you for your hard work for singing that long line! Soyeon, Minnie, Soojin, as usual you're slaying. Still pissed off of why the chorus can't be splitted with the other member when there's 6 part of it and they can do it like Lion.
Wow Yuqi and Miyeon's part really needs strong lungs. Imagine dancing hard then singing without pausing 😳😱🤯 I also want to applaud all of them! Wow! We stan stable queens!
Soyeon was a dancer first before she decided to be a rapper, she did ballet and hiphop when she was younger, having those skills early helped her build a strong control with her breathing and endurance, that's why she sound so good during live. Plus her tone is high, she do well most with mid to high range of notes than falsetto.
I like Soojin but it's obvious she cannot do the high notes live. Even their encore, she always looks nervous when it comes to the high note parts. If that's the case, then they could have given it to Minnie or Miyeon who are stable. Soyeon's awesome for trying.
No hate tho, I love my girls. But you can clearly see that Soyeon is stable because she has the most lines and shuhua is the last because she got the least lines...
Everybody is saying that shuhua sounds out of breath but they forget that she is the last person to sing in the song so with all that dancing she’s obviously gonna sound tired
Miyeon is so stable slong with Yuqi, and she has been stable through most their songs...Soojin, as much as I like her stage presence needs to train her vocals more.
I watches their mr removed for their blue outfit. they sound out of breath there. But sound a little bit better in here. I guess they are really tired. Even today's interview, usually they very energetic but they looked like they wanted to fall asleep especially soyeon.
![[CLEAN MR Removed] SORIBADA 2019 TWICE (트와이스) Fancy](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/nb9kBAhCcaQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![[4K] 카게레루 (츠루, KAGERERU) - 恋する忍者 (KAGERERU) @ 241105 아로아로홀 직캠 By SSoLEE](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QkBZA8P9YvQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![[UNCUT] The Loyal Pin ปิ่นภักดิ์ EP.15 (1/4)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/TLBjiHvkKtE/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Full] 4 ต่อ 4 Celebrity EP.922 | 10 พ.ย. 67 | one31](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/zmV5HRIxIBI/mqdefault.jpg)
![[CHANGE CAM] (여자)아이들 - Oh my god ((G)I-DLE - Oh my god) l 주간아이돌(Weekly Idol)](/img/n.gif)
0:53 can't feek how hers "oh my god" sounds good live
Exactly😍
Ikr
Ik sis.
You are talking about Jeon Soyeon, dont tell me you expected any different than spectacular 😎🙏🏻✨
I don’t understand how they can still stay stable when they do the oh my god move
I love how Shuhua is trying to sing her whole line. It's long and she even say
that it's hard so I'm proud of her
neverblidzy loveKPOP it’s also near the end which is harder since she danced the whole time before her part
@@LeaLeaA7 She didn't mean that. Shuhua isn't korean, so singing in korean is so hard for her since She didn't learn it
@@LeaLeaA7 idk if you know the history of why Shuhua isn't comfortable singing but here's why. Some knetz complained about her Thick Korean Accent. She's Taiwanese btw.
@@Flying-Chicken no international fans? sorry but i don't understand?
Himawari Uzumaki I think the person was correcting you that the international fans were complaining instead of the knetz
Nobody:
Not a single soul:
Soyeon **Slurp**
😂😂
U nice keep going I found this comment right on time 🤣
😂😂😂
I died 😭😭😭 I wasn’t expecting that
Yo_dood _im_here same here🤣🤣
Miyeon so stable, CUBE must give her more lines
Agreee!!!!!!
but soyeon do that
Agree!!!!!!
and Yuqi 😔❣️
It's not cube tho, Soyeon is the one who writes lyrics for the whole group
2:38 their necks cracking lmaoaoaooa
🤣🤣🤣
XD
i loled so hard when i replayed it.
*A S M R*
thats the video fake a lot of things
Minnie first part and last part suits her so well, she seems to be getting better at the oh my god part, her voice is really beautiful and dreamy and she is actually really stable
Soyeon, she is a stable queen, she singed the falsettos even tho they are really hard to sing while dancing, her rap part was amazing like always, and her oh my god always give me goosebumps
I love the color of Yuqi voice so much, she is really stable too, more in her second part, I think that her and Miyeon part suits them so well, it really shows her singing I really love it
Miyeon, what a stable queen, she did that second part without taking a single breath, is incredible, I feel like we don't aprecciate Miyeon enough as a main vocalist, she really deserves a lot more because her singing is so beautiful geezzz
Shuhua is getting so much better! I really like that she's trying to sing live, she seems more confident and I'm so so happy for her!
Soojin, I know she isn't the most stable in her part, but honestly she owns the "oh my god" part, also we have to consider that she's only a vocalist and also a main dancer, that means she has to focus on her dancing and her stage presence
Idle are queens so let's give the members love and support for doing their best at this amazing comeback. Neverland fighting!
you know that anyone can reach a falsetto, it's not that special.
@@sunmiswashingmachine Anyone can reach it, but dancing? Also considering that she's a rapper and not a vocalist is amazing
@@sunmiswashingmachine when standing/sitting still, sure.
@@sunmiswashingmachine why don't you do it yourself while dancing since it's that easy
@@dlmusic6185 they are standing moving their hands and maybe walking a little so it's kind of odd when they lipsync their falsettos.
[Stable Vocal]
My Opinion :
1. Soyeon
2. Miyeon
3. Minnie
4. Yuqi
5. Soojin
6. Shuhua
But...
1. G-idle
1. G-idle
1. G-idle
1. G-idle
1. G-idle
1. G-idle
Ok thanks
YAS
i think just soyeon is stable
They weren't stable tho like yes sometimes they were but only for a few seconds
fre on jah they literally are stable? 😭
This is Just my opinion but, none of them are stable. Before any of you said "can you do what they do?" No, i can't, i have learned how to sing and perform 1 time, singing livestage and singing at room are way diffrent. So do the girls have skill and potential? Yes. But is this perfomance good? Kinda, their live vocals will improve when their stamina improve. But i believe in this group potential. Stan giddle and talent✊
yall saying soyeon is so stable esp at the rap part, but if yall watched unpretty rapstar, youll know rapping live for soyeon is like speaking for her, and in produce she showed off her vocals. so expected that soyeon could be so stable, she even tries to sing the falsetto part, queen soyeon. yuqi and miyeon lines are so so good though
Soyeon so stable, omg
She tries to do the falsetto in live too, what a queen
edit: I'm wrong or she did the tongue sound too?
Wrong
Not even falsetto
@@lyma9466 okk, thank you so much ^^
@@Red-dm7qn A least she try 🙄
@@iwillhityouwithblackpinksl9879 still doesn't sound good. The rest of her performance is good. I hope other members can try to improve themselves. Only she and Miyeon or sometimes Yuqi can sing live.
how many lungs does Miyeon have omg
Ren A i think 68
iTs oVer 9000
*sideways 8*
69( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) jk2
Like 50
I'm so in love with Yuqi's voice, she's doing so well. Also Soyeon's "oh my god" adds 5 years to my lifespan every time I hear it
Lyma is still the only MR remove I trust. She always tells us when it's pre recorded etc. She does a good job. She doesn't make fake MR removed videos. She always keeps it real.
Thank you Lyma ❤
Edit: why I write this?
1. it is the truth
2. I once got hated on a "MR removed" video by another youtube channel. It was pre recorded video and he didn't say it. So when I said it I got hate and called fake fan :)
What happens if its prerecorded?
@@mateokovacicchelsea It means that they've recorded the vocals beforehand. Because they can't always dance and sing :) it's normal in kpop to use this
MinhVu pre recorded means they recorded it before the performance. Usually they do this at full volume in their first performance for their comeback. But the next few stages they lower the pre recorded vocal
'i trust' LMFAOOO
lol sorry i know this is useless-
@@GrizzlyNextDoor bcus theyre tired i guess?
2:19 she laughed or I dream? Minnie u're cute
I think shes just out of breath at that part.
OMG I'm sorry but i'm laughing so hard rn🤣🤣🤣
No she's just struggling to breath
Omg, I just remembered that laugh in snsd's mr taxi too. 😂
I think she laughed
miyeon so stable
She should have more line Cube!!
Yes!
Will she trained in yg .
Soyeon really mouthing "slurp" live 😂😂😂
아 씨 한국댓 찾기 개힘드네 이거 한국영상이라고ㅠㅠㅠ
인정합니다!
영어 댓글 안 보고 싶으면 그냥 꺼져🤗
@@kristen-r2x ?
외국분계정이라 그런가봐용
아이들 jonna 잘 불렁
MY BABY SHUHUA IMPROVED SO MUCH:'(((( I DO LOVE U
I hope the other member will also improve like Miyeon and Soyeon.
actually there are all improving .. if you watch their previous song mr removed like uh oh and lion .. they are all really stable .. this song actually is a bit hard to sing because of the chord and the technique
@@aryssa-qh1jo honestly all of them are off key and can't hit notes correctly. Only Miyeon did good, Soyeon is only stable on her rap part. No hate, just stating facts. This is like lowering the standard.
Red soyeon's chorus is god tier
Red are you an anti of Soyeon or something? Cause I’ve seen you talking shit about Soyeon not being stable and I was like?????? You need to get your ears check and get a therapist
THE GENERATION’S QUEEN OF MR REMOVED: Orig MAIN VOCAL VISUAL CHO MIYEON
0:52 이게 이렇게 바로 음정이 맞는다는게 너무 놀랍다 결론은 큐브를 전소연한테 줘라
점점 라이브 잘해지는듯
QUEEN MIYEON MOST STABLE YES LIKE HER SIS CHU
Anji Crz MAIN VOCALISTTTT
Suiim hihi THE GENERATION’S QUEEN OF MR REMOVED: Orig MAIN VOCAL VISUAL CHO MIYEON
When does miyeon breathe? 😳
Miyeon said that she sings that whole part without breathing ^^
PARK CHAEYOUNG IS THE REVOLUTION i dont think u read this commen right
@@martintxurru Your answer makes no sense. Not really surprised that you like BP.
EXIT-ORION don’t do that lmaoooooo
@@exit-orion3559 Yall should stop making fan wars between Gidle and Blackpink. Miyeon is and always will be a small portion of blackpink, the girls were friends in the past. Both groups support each other, so why hate?
전소연 성량 개쩐다ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 댑악 넘 잘해❤❤ 못하는게 뭐야ㅠㅠㅠ❤❤
민니가 진짜 잘한다...........
the subtitles at 1:31, didn’t know Soyeon changed her stage name
CT Kpop we stan Nigel
We must respect that she is nigel now
lmao
Nigel is very stable
*Nigel best rapper of 4th gen*
LATATA때보다 확실히 실력UP되긴 했네 호흡조절이랑 가성처리만 더 노력하면 라이브 깡패될듯 ㄷㄷ
Miyeon's vocal perfection!
someone’s neck was cracking
2:38 Lmao
it was me
@@prankalll8219 ._.
Miyeon and yugi killing with those stable vocals♡♡♡♡♡We stan talented queens..don't we?
Yupppppp
*Yuqi
Yesss
수진은 음색 되게 힘빼고 살살 불러야할 것 같은데 저렇게 빡세게 추고 잘부른다..
그니까요 2:03 짱
day by day,
antis: *trash talking*
g idle: “yall watching this?” *SLAYING AND GETTING BETTER*
우기 칭찬 댓 없네...개잘하는데....
miyeon tries not to breathe into the microphone when singing.
this is amazing.
MINNIE AND SOYEON 💗
shuhua is improving ^^
이번껀 호흡조절하기 힘들었을텐데 언니들 최고
Soyeon very stable especially the rap part omg
Miyeon don't need air, THE AIR NEEDS HER
Oh my god 😍😍😍 all of them are so talented and stable!!!
Soyeon even try to sing those high notes😎
Shuhua improved so much!!!!!!
I am proud of her!Shuhua fighting!!!!!
Taiwan's pride😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
the way soojin couldn't breath during her part makes me feel so sad
Ikr
Miyeon & Yuqi got the least line but their parts are really hard if they fail to breath on time
2:40 뼈 우두둑 누구냐고ㅠㅠㅠㅋㅋㅋㅋ
이거 우기가 브앱에서 마이크 부딫히는 소리라구 했다네용
Soyeon eats CD's instead of vegetables for breakfast.
SHUHUA IS SO CUTEEEE
the way soyeon raps the whole rap and THE SLURPPP!! we stan a great leader and group
I WAS SEARCHING A MR REMOVED FOR THIS PERFORMANCE AND YOU UPLOAD THIS, WE LOVE YOU LIMA 😭
Me too bcs in live i could hear soyeon do the falsetto so i want to hear at this video
Soojin : babeeeh babeehhhh
me : SH1T AM I GAY?
It was so cute
No one:
not even a single soul:
Miyeon neck on last chorus: **cracking noice**
OH MY GOD ITS SCARY AKJSKWOW
The fact, that Soyeon Raps live even though her Raps aren't easy to Rap because they're so fast and also the coreogeaphies aren't that easy … that's what I call live performance /stage presence! Go girl!💓
Even shu is not stable yet, I think she hits the tune
I believe she will get better and better
Minnie my baby
y’all not gonna talk about minnie’s voice? her “oh my god~” was so great tho
Yuqi, Miyeon you're doing great as usual despite how many line you got in this song!
Shuhua, thank you for your hard work for singing that long line!
Soyeon, Minnie, Soojin, as usual you're slaying.
Still pissed off of why the chorus can't be splitted with the other member when there's 6 part of it and they can do it like Lion.
Difa Angelina i guess they didn’t split it to keep a tone, pretty sad, would’ve loved yuqi’s deep voice on the chorus
Wow Yuqi and Miyeon's part really needs strong lungs. Imagine dancing hard then singing without pausing 😳😱🤯 I also want to applaud all of them! Wow! We stan stable queens!
Soyeon was a dancer first before she decided to be a rapper, she did ballet and hiphop when she was younger, having those skills early helped her build a strong control with her breathing and endurance, that's why she sound so good during live. Plus her tone is high, she do well most with mid to high range of notes than falsetto.
I like Soojin but it's obvious she cannot do the high notes live. Even their encore, she always looks nervous when it comes to the high note parts. If that's the case, then they could have given it to Minnie or Miyeon who are stable. Soyeon's awesome for trying.
Soyeon's rap is so stable + that slurp
2:17 개치인다 민니야 계좌좀
No one:
Not a single soul:
Not even (G)-Idle:
This video: LyMa cLeaN mR rEmoVeD
Edwin Rivera I LAUGHED SOOOO HARD
miyeon！
Soyeon’s oh my god is powerful
Stability
1 soyeon
2 miyeon
3 minnie
4 yuqi
5 soojin
6 shuhua
Ngl, but isn’t it funny how it also is the list of who has the most lines....
No hate tho, I love my girls. But you can clearly see that Soyeon is stable because she has the most lines and shuhua is the last because she got the least lines...
Julia
soojin do be getting more lines than miyeon and yuqi tho lmao
「 ella 」 yes you're right I think she should take the lines that a main dancer and a lead rapper deserve
Julia yes but what about miyeon and yuqi
They have little to no lines but they're stable
SHUHUA ATE!!!!!!!!!! I am so proud of herrrr
wait, i think i’m in love with yuqi:’)
수진이 원래 부를때 숨소리 많이 내면서 가성 쓰네
This dance was hard and I'm so suprised how they sound so flawless
Not related but...OMFG A CRYBABY
How many lungs does Miyeon have?
_ITS OVER 9000!!_
i'll take my leave.bye
why miyeon sings effortlessly and so so good
Everybody is saying that shuhua sounds out of breath but they forget that she is the last person to sing in the song so with all that dancing she’s obviously gonna sound tired
So I say for the last time! There is a reason why Soyeon has the most lines!!!
They have improved a lot! It’s so good!
Soyeon, Minnie and Soojin.
OMGGGG THE VOCALS PERFECT
without belittle they: Shuhua, Miyeon and Yuqi.
2:05 kinda liked the way soojin sang her part here. Very velvety. It's like touching a fur.
Miyeon deserves more recognition she’s extremely talented and beautiful
Wow..miyeon!!!
Miyeon is so stable slong with Yuqi, and she has been stable through most their songs...Soojin, as much as I like her stage presence needs to train her vocals more.
thet sound so so good this time!
shuhua my babie ur doing good 🥺👋
They improved so much compared to the last mr removed. I'm so proud. :,)
bruh this vid doesnt need to exist i can definitely hear their mics from the original performance
(G)I-DLE is really the rookie queens👸 PLS DO APINK's NEW COMEBACK!!
shuhua you improved a lot, good job^^
I watches their mr removed for their blue outfit. they sound out of breath there. But sound a little bit better in here. I guess they are really tired. Even today's interview, usually they very energetic but they looked like they wanted to fall asleep especially soyeon.
I’m not even a fan of g-idle but this is the best mr removed I’ve ever heard
In this stage they more stable than another stage before
Shuhua stop showing your face and your voice to me
Im crying and im proud of you
Ilove you😿💜💜
When they said “Lyma MR Removed” I felt that 😔✊
Although she sounds a bit out of breath, Yuqi was the clearest in this performance for me.
Is Miyeon even a human? She didn't even breath while singing her whole part ! Like how???
They've improved! 🥺💜💜
0:53 : bless my ears
*soyeon's slurp im dying 💀😭🙉*
I just love them so much.
miyeon really be singing her parts without breathing tho 😳
2:03 is amazingly amazing
Guys. Remember, these MR removed videos can distort the audio. While its mostly accurate, you cant wholly depend on this as a way to rate vocals.
Lyma is the best mr removing channel I doubt they will make fake mr removed vids
Yuqi and Soyeon is so stable!
The stability of Soyeon's "oh my god" and rap killed me.
I hope you understand that it's so hard to sing and dance at the same time. I love my girls more for their hardwork on stage :*
I heard that the mr removed when they stretch they neck and then **neck crack** is it true :^ OH MY FU-
2:38