It’s interesting how similar both Saturn seiyuu’s voices are. They found someone who really has the same quality to her voice as Minaguchi Yuko. Absolutely lovely.
90s = Attacks are more powerful but cannot be used regularly, only as desperation moves, other than Silence Wall. Eternal = Definitely better intro and actually has a transformation sequence. Attacks can be used normally but not as powerful as 90s version. I love both. I grew up with the 90s version but have to say I like Eternal a little more because Saturn has more screen time.
@@depressed_firefly I loved season 3 of Crystal! Saturn is my favorite scout. Yes, you're right. Her strongest power move is to simply swing her glaive down with the intention of ending the world, thus making it possible for rebirth to happen.
@@jofez27 I always was surprised also with how quickly other outers shift their opinion on her - in one moment she's basically one of the enemies bcuz she ended the world (like please, did she have any other choice than to use her glaive last time in Millennium? why blame her?) to literally Pluto not wanting to lock Pharaoh 90 bcuz it would've mean to lock Saturn too. Even tho minutes ago she thought Saturn is guilty and shouldn't be awaken ever. What? And then Neptune and Uranus be like "nah, nvm, we're gonna raise her as our own child, forget what we told about killing her to stop Saturn awakening"
@@depressed_firefly Lol! Totally agree! My guess is that no one wanted to hear Saturn out as to why she exists and had so mich power so they sealed her up with the talismans. But when the talismans resonated and set her free for her to fulfill her duty, she was all like "F**k this, I ain't going to explain myself right now! Payback bitches!" Lol! Now that she was released again, she was all cool, holding no grudges anymore and finally explained her role and all the scouts were like, "Ooohhhh! Yo, this girl is dope AF! Let's raise her now that we know more about her" 🤣
I honestly think that every single one of Saturn's attacks should follow up with total audio silence. She is the only scout who can counter Sailor Moon's super sonic crying from episode 1 (I wonder if that attack is called Silent Sanctuary 😂)
To be fair, they basically made Silent Glaive Suprise do what Death Reborn Revolution is supposed to do in the 90’s one. The fact she makes a giant field of energy around her followed by her slamming her glaive down in silence is exactly what she does in the manga. So it’s odd they decided to have her say Glaive Suprise instead when it’s clearly the other attack. And even tho they now made SGS just a slash of energy in Eternal it’s more disappointing they didn’t give her a cinematic sequence for it 🙄😓
Death Reborn Revolution is the attack used against Pharaoh 90 in the manga, but it's not Saturn unleashing ruin. Likewise, in the 90's anime, Silence Glaive Surprise was used to repel Nehelenia's attack; Saturn unleashed the power of ruin afterwards. Saturn's world destroying power has no name: all she does is lower the Silence Glaive.
I still wonder why that happens. Maybe her powers got nerfed in her ressurection so she could fight more balanced lol. That is, she can freely battle without sacrificing her own life
I think in the classic version, she never use Death Reborn Revolution which basically a reset the world attack. In the manga/eternal, Silent Glaive Surprise is a normal attack. For some reason in the classic, it acts as a instant kill move in exchange for her life.
The 90s anime changed a lot from the source material. Crystal is a lot more true to to it. They had to give Saturn some cool powerful moment in the 90s, because they completely took out her big moment in season 3. Silence Glaive Surprise is VERY underwhelming compared to DRR.
@@martin.allaman death reborn revolution doesnt end her life, its just an attack she used against paraoh 90 to remove him from the earth. They mention in the manga her killing attack doesnt have a name she just needs to swing her glaive with the intention of destroying everything.
Silence Wall is a skill used for emergency its natural that it should be done faster so Eternal did that well Silence Glaive Surprise should mute surrounding sound and cause darkness in the area like in the 90s because its supposed to be a SILENT (no sound) SURPRISE (unforeseen).. 90s did it better for this skill however SGS isnt supposed to kill Saturn on the first place its her normal attacking skill and not Death Reborn Revolution so Eternal won this function of that skill
@@nooteese cause its her normal attack, she doesnt die by performint it. The 90s silence glaive surprise should have been death reborn revolution that we saw in crystal season 3, and that attack was boss.
Actually Death Reborn Revolution wasn’t the world ending attack either. It’s just another one of her moves, one that generates a negative aura to disempower her opponent. She speaks no attack name to end the world, she merely drops the blade.
@@SethRGray well it can destroy without needing to say anything but it needs drama in fights know and death reborn revolution has as its main function to kill but rescue the soul of the dead and make it revive in a distant future, just like the outer senshi revived in the current present
She didn't do anything in the 90s anime. At least in Crystal/Eternal was actually got to see her kick Pharoah's ass and is instrumental in single handedly fending off and reforming the Amazoness Quartet.
@@mikih636 Sailor Moon started out as a Manga series, not an animated series. The new series is a animated adaption to the manga. That’s why both stories in both series are different I respect your opinion though
I just want to say that I wish Sailor Saturn had a cooler transformation. When I watch the original Sailor Moon, I always hope to see a complete transformation for Sailor Saturn. Maybe it's because the outer senshi have shorter transformations, but it would be awesome if they had given Sailor Saturn a really nice transformation sequence.
I like “normal” sailor Saturns costume much better. It was a little bit different from the others. But the super sailor costumes are all the same except for the colors.
Would it be going too far to want Hotaru Tomoe to use her powers on Mr. Burns to downright DESTROY him in the WORST way possible for EVERYTHING he did?
Am I the only one on Earth that wants Sailor Saturn to use her powers on Mr. Burns to downright DESTROY him in the WORST way possible because of everything he did?
It’s weird because her intro speech in sailor moon eternal after her transformation doesn’t have the same music as in this one. I like it in this one better.
There is no contest. In terms of accuracy, Eternal wins hands down. The only reason why 90s even has a stake in the race is due to nostalgia. The way the 90s anime did Saturn was criminal, but it was also due to the fact that the manga was behind the production of the anime (don’t quote me on this but this is what i heard) so a lot of things from the anime wasn’t accurate, like Saturn’s attacks or Venus’ love and beauty shock. Venus’ attack is literally just rolling heart vibration. They still didn’t have do Saturn so dirty. They made her super lame.
For all the people complaining how the 90s did the Silence Glaive Surprise wrong, have you guys actually rewatched the scene recently? The Death Reborn Revolution doesn’t exist in the 90s anime and while it is implied to be the attack that Saturn uses to end and renew a world (the act of absorbing energy being the main ‘act’ of the attack and the end being Saturn lowering her glaive to bring destruction - though it’s all but interpretation since none of the attacks in the manga are illustrated, explained or the effects even shown). While in the manga the SGS is yet another boring simple wave energy attack that like always misses and with the effects never shown (great work there Naoko), through the dialogue between her and Nehenelia and later Galaxia, the Glaive Surprise is not the same as the Reborn Revolution but grants Saturn the ability to exclusively destroy her and another being of her choice - during Nehenelia’s instance, Usagi was just outside the castle and both Mamoru and Chibi-Usa were next to her in a weaken state so the fact that she choses to use this technique implies the rest of the party would be safe without suffering the effects of the attack. Honestly kudos to the anime staff to actually come up with a sister attack to the Reborn Revolution rather than being uninspired like 90% of the manga is.
.....So I guess I'm the only one who was tremendously underwhelmed by her transformation sequence. it was so uninspired as it was the very thing I was looking forward to since learning about the reboot. The reason why they didn't have transformation sequences in StarS because they lost a ton of money in ratings from cutting them out of SuperS, which they were supposed to be in. They literally did the game sequence version....so disappointing. I've seen fan made sequences that were far better than Crystal....tragic.
Yup. It's so lazy and disappointing. This was the chance to actually fill in the gaps from the old series, and this is what we got: the uninspired video game transformation sequence. Ugh.
I hate the eternal art style, crystal season 1-2 wins. If I wanted to watch the 90s version I would watch the the original. The new one looked like the beautiful manga characters , and then they changed it back. Booo
今風の作画になってもほたるちゃんのかわいさは完璧！！ちびうさも良き
내가 😑 😐 😎 😘
皆口さんと藤井さんお声の声質が近いから違和感があんまないというか。
他の戦士に比べて「変わりました」感がなくていいね
It’s interesting how similar both Saturn seiyuu’s voices are. They found someone who really has the same quality to her voice as Minaguchi Yuko. Absolutely lovely.
The new voice acress is Fujii Yukiyo.
Yes,almost same ❤
ほたるちゃんがこうやって
普通に活躍してるのを見られるの
すっごく嬉しいよーーー‼️
1番旧に近い声でいいね
声優変えてないと思ってた！声似てるんですねー！
90s = Attacks are more powerful but cannot be used regularly, only as desperation moves, other than Silence Wall.
Eternal = Definitely better intro and actually has a transformation sequence. Attacks can be used normally but not as powerful as 90s version.
I love both. I grew up with the 90s version but have to say I like Eternal a little more because Saturn has more screen time.
In Crystal/Eternal she still has that "desperation move" but not with the name "Silence Glave Surprise" tho
@@depressed_firefly I loved season 3 of Crystal! Saturn is my favorite scout. Yes, you're right. Her strongest power move is to simply swing her glaive down with the intention of ending the world, thus making it possible for rebirth to happen.
@@jofez27 I always was surprised also with how quickly other outers shift their opinion on her - in one moment she's basically one of the enemies bcuz she ended the world (like please, did she have any other choice than to use her glaive last time in Millennium? why blame her?) to literally Pluto not wanting to lock Pharaoh 90 bcuz it would've mean to lock Saturn too. Even tho minutes ago she thought Saturn is guilty and shouldn't be awaken ever. What?
And then Neptune and Uranus be like "nah, nvm, we're gonna raise her as our own child, forget what we told about killing her to stop Saturn awakening"
@@depressed_firefly Lol! Totally agree! My guess is that no one wanted to hear Saturn out as to why she exists and had so mich power so they sealed her up with the talismans. But when the talismans resonated and set her free for her to fulfill her duty, she was all like "F**k this, I ain't going to explain myself right now! Payback bitches!" Lol! Now that she was released again, she was all cool, holding no grudges anymore and finally explained her role and all the scouts were like, "Ooohhhh! Yo, this girl is dope AF! Let's raise her now that we know more about her" 🤣
@@jofez27 and only two youngest of Moon dynasty were like "TOLD YA"
I honestly think that every single one of Saturn's attacks should follow up with total audio silence.
She is the only scout who can counter Sailor Moon's super sonic crying from episode 1
(I wonder if that attack is called Silent Sanctuary 😂)
Eternal wins hands down, but you can't say her lifting the glaive and slashing down in complete silence doesn't give chills.
Eternal became bland when it actually had so much potential. It's ashame that they didn't treat these two movies like an Akira movie.
Agreed!! Eternal was amazing!
To be fair, they basically made Silent Glaive Suprise do what Death Reborn Revolution is supposed to do in the 90’s one.
The fact she makes a giant field of energy around her followed by her slamming her glaive down in silence is exactly what she does in the manga. So it’s odd they decided to have her say Glaive Suprise instead when it’s clearly the other attack.
And even tho they now made SGS just a slash of energy in Eternal it’s more disappointing they didn’t give her a cinematic sequence for it 🙄😓
Death Reborn Revolution is the attack used against Pharaoh 90 in the manga, but it's not Saturn unleashing ruin. Likewise, in the 90's anime, Silence Glaive Surprise was used to repel Nehelenia's attack; Saturn unleashed the power of ruin afterwards. Saturn's world destroying power has no name: all she does is lower the Silence Glaive.
I like the eternal because when she uses Silence glaive Surprise it didn't destroy her body unlike the 90's
I still wonder why that happens. Maybe her powers got nerfed in her ressurection so she could fight more balanced lol. That is, she can freely battle without sacrificing her own life
I think in the classic version, she never use Death Reborn Revolution which basically a reset the world attack. In the manga/eternal, Silent Glaive Surprise is a normal attack. For some reason in the classic, it acts as a instant kill move in exchange for her life.
@@gabsy_ferreira cause the attacks that ends her life is death reborn revolution, but in the 90s they chanced that.
The 90s anime changed a lot from the source material. Crystal is a lot more true to to it. They had to give Saturn some cool powerful moment in the 90s, because they completely took out her big moment in season 3.
Silence Glaive Surprise is VERY underwhelming compared to DRR.
@@martin.allaman death reborn revolution doesnt end her life, its just an attack she used against paraoh 90 to remove him from the earth. They mention in the manga her killing attack doesnt have a name she just needs to swing her glaive with the intention of destroying everything.
Silence Wall is a skill used for emergency its natural that it should be done faster so Eternal did that well
Silence Glaive Surprise should mute surrounding sound and cause darkness in the area like in the 90s because its supposed to be a SILENT (no sound) SURPRISE (unforeseen).. 90s did it better for this skill
however SGS isnt supposed to kill Saturn on the first place its her normal attacking skill and not Death Reborn Revolution
so Eternal won this function of that skill
in eternal Silent glaive surprise attack is nothing compared with 90s' version power. easily evaded by mini-boss.
,AzxvB
@@nooteese cause its her normal attack, she doesnt die by performint it. The 90s silence glaive surprise should have been death reborn revolution that we saw in crystal season 3, and that attack was boss.
Actually Death Reborn Revolution wasn’t the world ending attack either. It’s just another one of her moves, one that generates a negative aura to disempower her opponent. She speaks no attack name to end the world, she merely drops the blade.
@@SethRGray well it can destroy without needing to say anything but it needs drama in fights know and death reborn revolution has as its main function to kill but rescue the soul of the dead and make it revive in a distant future, just like the outer senshi revived in the current present
We got to see more of Saturn in action in Crystal. I liked that.
Epic of the writers to do Saturn justice
やっぱサターン大好きです!
eternal with 90s soundtrack = perfection
Saturn is my favourite, i love 90's outfit
Sailor Saturn is ABSOLUTELY AWESOME and STUNNINGLY DROP dead GORGEOUS 💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖
この子好きだったな。
I like the animations better in eternal but i have to say she seems more powerful amd fierce in the 90s intro
She didn't do anything in the 90s anime. At least in Crystal/Eternal was actually got to see her kick Pharoah's ass and is instrumental in single handedly fending off and reforming the Amazoness Quartet.
攻撃技と防御技両方持ってるの強。でもって禁断の技も持ってるのチートすぎる
本意気のサターンはヤバイ♪
可愛ええ
かわいい
やっぱこの声だなぁ
サターンかっこいい(*´∇｀*)
サターンカッコ良い
90's music and overall atmosphere > everything else
可愛い
Hearing Saturn Va made me remember Yu from Creamy Mami glad I watched that series to know that she being a magical girl again
I love Sailor Saturn 💜💜
皆口さんの声久しぶりにきいた
eternal wins
No. 90s wins
They both win? But 90s wins. Without the original 90s there is no eternal...
@@mikih636 No without the manga both of them wouldn’t exist. Eternal could still exist without the 90’s anime
@@taylorserasera but Naoko made the manga in the 90s... so 90s win. Lol
@@mikih636 Sailor Moon started out as a Manga series, not an animated series. The new series is a animated adaption to the manga. That’s why both stories in both series are different
I respect your opinion though
Eternal mejoró mucho a Saturn. Pero el soundtrack de los 90s es impresionante
セーラーサターンかわゆい💜がんばて💗セーラーちびムーン２人ふたりともうつくしいかわゆいがんばてくださいお願いします仁美ちゃんよりメッセージをみてねメッセージをくださいお願いします仁美ちゃんよりクリスタルセーラームーン
I just want to say that I wish Sailor Saturn had a cooler transformation. When I watch the original Sailor Moon, I always hope to see a complete transformation for Sailor Saturn. Maybe it's because the outer senshi have shorter transformations, but it would be awesome if they had given Sailor Saturn a really nice transformation sequence.
90s undisputed
声そのままやw
This is a certified hood classic
Que hermosa es sailor sartun
I don’t know what the hell I just saw, but it seemed cool.
I like “normal” sailor Saturns costume much better. It was a little bit different from the others. But the super sailor costumes are all the same except for the colors.
Would it be going too far to want Hotaru Tomoe to use her powers on Mr. Burns to downright DESTROY him in the WORST way possible for EVERYTHING he did?
I love both, but eternal wins for more fluid animation and more dynamic movement
Am I the only one on Earth that wants Sailor Saturn to use her powers on Mr. Burns to downright DESTROY him in the WORST way possible because of everything he did?
Sailor Saturn 💗💘
While I am a huge 90's fan and find it better than crystal overall. I loved the upgrade that they gave Saturn.
It was always odd how little Saturn was featured but we had a whole filler arc…..
土星「勝手に沈黙させんな！」
I think this is the only example where I actually prefer the new version.
💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
It’s weird because her intro speech in sailor moon eternal after her transformation doesn’t have the same music as in this one. I like it in this one better.
Amazing
Saturn…you need to calm down 😨
I am aquarius so this would be my special attack and Neptune
新旧比べるとどのキャラも
足が短く感じる…
Como se llama la música al final del vídeo?
Rustheroine(no.10)
There is no contest. In terms of accuracy, Eternal wins hands down. The only reason why 90s even has a stake in the race is due to nostalgia. The way the 90s anime did Saturn was criminal, but it was also due to the fact that the manga was behind the production of the anime (don’t quote me on this but this is what i heard) so a lot of things from the anime wasn’t accurate, like Saturn’s attacks or Venus’ love and beauty shock. Venus’ attack is literally just rolling heart vibration. They still didn’t have do Saturn so dirty. They made her super lame.
ほたるちゃん
ฉันกรี๊ดเล่นบ้านตอนที่แซทเทิร์นได้ถ้าแปลงร่างแล้ว🤞
Me gusta
For all the people complaining how the 90s did the Silence Glaive Surprise wrong, have you guys actually rewatched the scene recently?
The Death Reborn Revolution doesn’t exist in the 90s anime and while it is implied to be the attack that Saturn uses to end and renew a world (the act of absorbing energy being the main ‘act’ of the attack and the end being Saturn lowering her glaive to bring destruction - though it’s all but interpretation since none of the attacks in the manga are illustrated, explained or the effects even shown).
While in the manga the SGS is yet another boring simple wave energy attack that like always misses and with the effects never shown (great work there Naoko), through the dialogue between her and Nehenelia and later Galaxia, the Glaive Surprise is not the same as the Reborn Revolution but grants Saturn the ability to exclusively destroy her and another being of her choice - during Nehenelia’s instance, Usagi was just outside the castle and both Mamoru and Chibi-Usa were next to her in a weaken state so the fact that she choses to use this technique implies the rest of the party would be safe without suffering the effects of the attack.
Honestly kudos to the anime staff to actually come up with a sister attack to the Reborn Revolution rather than being uninspired like 90% of the manga is.
Hi, quick question, what song did you use at 0:09 ?
Search on TH-cam, Sailor Outer Theme
Doesn't help that everytime she uses Silence Glaive Surprise it fails in some way
Which is more powerful: silence glaive surprise or death reborn revolution???
Death reborn revolution
@@homura-aistra oh ic. Thanks fellow sailor.
0:09
90s song win.
SAILOR Saturn🦁
.....So I guess I'm the only one who was tremendously underwhelmed by her transformation sequence. it was so uninspired as it was the very thing I was looking forward to since learning about the reboot. The reason why they didn't have transformation sequences in StarS because they lost a ton of money in ratings from cutting them out of SuperS, which they were supposed to be in. They literally did the game sequence version....so disappointing. I've seen fan made sequences that were far better than Crystal....tragic.
Yup. It's so lazy and disappointing. This was the chance to actually fill in the gaps from the old series, and this is what we got: the uninspired video game transformation sequence. Ugh.
Eterna sailor moon es aburrida le falta ese encanto que tiene la sailor moon de los 90
But this is a original story
Sailor Jailbait
I dunno, Eternal's Silent Wall should have used the black rutilation effect that it had in the 4D movie attraction.
MFW no Death Reborn Revoluttion
Sailor Soi Fon
พัฒน์นรี
They look prettier in the Crystal series, but the original was still funnier.
.......No they don't.
변신복 변신무기 전부다 웨딩피치가 훨낫다.
일본아재들도 공감하는거야?흐에응...
if this saturn sailor senshi destroys, who or what creates?
Universe creates itself, but in the next arc, the Stars, explain how everyone was born and stuff.
Sailor Moon
Old was better
Why?
+++
I hate the eternal art style, crystal season 1-2 wins. If I wanted to watch the 90s version I would watch the the original. The new one looked like the beautiful manga characters , and then they changed it back. Booo
thumbs down for the low quality filtered vocals from eternal being placed over 90's soundtracks ! keep it pure or don't do a comparison at all.
Or simply just don’t watch the entire video 😅
What a huge downgrade :’( the new one looks so bland