ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 ก.ย. 2024
- This video shows the DNA results of a Kalash woman from Pakistan. The Kalash or Kalasha people are an ancient Indo-European speaking indigenous group with unique culture and traditions, living restrictively in the Hindu-Kush mountain range of present-day northern Pakistan. Due to their mysterious origin and fairer European complexion, the genetic history of this ethnic group has been investigated previously using different markers.
Data Source: Human Genome Diversity Project
Visit MyHeritage DNA: www.myheritage...
#Kalash
Handsome people. I like their use of saffron yellow in their clothing.
As Turik I am glad for them keeped they blood
Keeping you identity is important
Agree
Unlike the turks who today are all mixed 50 different people
Love you bro❤
Great work.
Based on the results, the Kalash people are not Greek.
1:35 Interesting that "The Kalash population contains abundant South Asian paternal ancestry such as L and H, but the mitochondrial lineage is exclusively of West Eurasian origin". Sample had R0a. It still doesn't explain who they are.
The sample is a female
They contains haplogroup R1a too
Because the west eurasion women were traded into these tribes. Patrilocality was almost universally practiced until modern tjmes. Women were traded to other tribes and that’s how you get maternal west eurasion with paternal south asian.
It's pretty common knowledge that Kalash are mostly L & H paternally, but overwhelmingly steppe maternally.
It means that Zagros and AASI men of Indus Valley Civilization married steppe women and selected for lighter traits.
@@jmab721 Probably not "married" in those days. Could be forced or through battles.
I must say that I deeply respect Kalash people for them saving their original unique traditions and beautiful faith and not became Muslim like every surrounding them people(I’m not anti-Muslim but a lot of ancient cultural and religious practices in Asia was abandoned because of Islamic expansion) Among my Mongolian people although most adopted Buddhism, Paganism is still practiced, Mongols just like Kalash 1:23 also praise the spirits of nature, the Sky gods(99 Burkhans of Tengeri) and worship their ancestors, forefathers. We don’t believe in that Allmighty God concept which is found among Abrahamic religions.
In Turkiye, textbooks say in Tengri belief Tengri is also allmighty like Yahweh or other abrahamic gods. Is it true or bullshit?
The problem is: 'Who created?' not 'Who did it?'... Nowadays it's 'A la mode' to beat Muslim descendent of the Abrahamic religions after the fuss in Iraq, Libya, Old Yugoslavia, Lebanon, Afghanistan, etc. of religiously biased god dammed attacks.
To '@barguttobed',
It is so easy for you; 'You will not be a candidate of the 'Heaven' of the Abrahamic believes, that's all. As a commenter, I believe you will incarnate as a rat in your future life, the same as you are now, because of your nonsense approach to the people of practicing Muslim Faith for 1 400 years!
@@athonos13WTF? You sure?
@@shehan117bro WTF are you sure ..
They've always suffered attacks from Muslims, even in resent years there's been forced conversions.
Other than the "music" and the odd use of the word 'infer,' this was a very interesting video.
Could you do an ethnicity estimate on Nakht Ankh or any other bronze age Egyptian sample like Ancient_Egyptian:JK2134:Schuenemann2017
Ancient_Egyptian:JK2888:Schuenemann
Ancient_Egyptian:JK2911:Schuenemann
They have a high percentage of ANE
25% !
I would suspect more related to tarim mummies than yamnaya
Who also had ANE but less percentage by the time they invaded western Europe and came back in afanasievo culture to altai
But kalash do have high percentage of mtdna u4
Any thoughts
Hi dude,can you make a video on Baloch DNA,cheers mate
Baloch are 10-20% steppe mlba, negligible AASI and super high Zagros. Probably the highest Zagros in any population ever.
12% Scandinavian, 65% South Asian, 23 % West Asian.
Are they indian tribal
@@tejamajhi2271 no
@@kasyakyoubfgamindikisborat dna test realved
They are originally from indian
@@tejamajhi2271which one, when, by whom and over how many people and with selection from which different locations. Where is the certification of answers to all above question. If you cannot present here on this Page, that means you azsertion is FABRICATION.
@@tejamajhi2271 They live in Pakistan. They're Pakistanis.
My ancient Sarmatian/Slavic migration path starts from there to Siberia, then the Steppes by the Caspian Sea, and then into Poland
@mr.savage2586 we Slavs are 50% Sarmatian and we are not Turkic. We were on horse 3000 years before the Turks were on horse DNA and Archeology shows this fact.
@mr.savage2586 the 1st Slavic state was Palosie founded in 1200 b.c. along the Dneiper River basin, so the Sarmatians could sanction a peace treaty with the Slavs and create an Alliance to defend them from Scythia, and Dacia was a part of that defensive alignment. I wrote THE FIRST HORSE PEOPLE the history of my ancient tribe the Sarmatian knights, and the Amazon women and the Slavs
@mr.savage2586 Eventually, Armenia became an ally to the Sarmatians as well. Many times, the Sarmatians freed Armenia from the Romans
@@mr.savage2586 weirdo
@@geraldbrefka1145 Isn't Kiev the first Slavic city?
Maybe it’s sounds strange but I found Kalash looking most similar to Gypsies 😂 Unlike the stereotypes it’s actually not rare for gypsies to have light skin and eyes and they also have some similarities in facial features
It´s a legend about the Campaign of Alexander the Great,after his death the Diadochs have inherited parts of his Army I think in the zone it was Seleucos maybe the admixed greek-persian settled down in the Valley.There are no gypsies whith blue eyes sfaik.
@@ver_idemthat theory came out as totally bullshit. The kalash were there way before Alexander.
To me they look like Kurdish people.
@@ver_idem If then why their paternal groups are mostly native Indian? so greeks bring their wives to sell them to Indians?
@@lamariposa5919 no H and L among Kurds
Day 6 of asking for Ainu results
Yeah 🙂👍
Japanese. same with other countries like The Philippines theres Ilocano, Tagalog, Cebuano, pangasinense all filipinos same race different tribe. they all look the same.
Rh negatives Aryans
@@DeanMorrissey-fu1yfStop brainwashing yourself by watching that idiot Robert's video. He doesn't even hide it that he's a nazi. Ainus don't have anything to do with IE.
How Scandinavian..how is that a possible?
Indo-Europeans of the Sintashta culture were steppe peoples and they mixed with Iranian farmers, the mixture gave rise to the Indo-Iranian peoples. The Indo-Iranian peoples migrated to India and mixed with the Dravidians, the mixture gave rise to the Modern Indians.
Another proof that our ancestors travelled...a lot! I loved the dance and the joy on their faces.
"Our" people here meaning ancestors of Indo Aryans.
@@jmab721 You do know Europeans also descend from two other lineages besides Steppe pastoralist ancestors right? There are no Europeans who are solely descendants of Steppe pastoralists. In fact, you'll find more people with mostly Steppe pastoralist ancestry in various parts of Central Asia.
@@user-jt3dw6vv4x What has that got to do anything with my comment? I think you misunderstood my reply.
And about the steppe ancestry thing, no, central asians do not have higher steppe than northern euros.
@@jmab721 That you're not 100% of Steppe origin. That's my point. In fact, these people have more Steppe ancestry than you.
@@user-jt3dw6vv4x Which people? You're still not conveying your point properly.
They might be descendents of nomadic peoples such as the Kushans,Sakas and Huns.
Can you do a voiceover so I can just look at the beautiful people and scenery 💜
Can you please do some of the Canaanite samples ?
Just look at your Mayans and South Amarican tribes, I'd say those people were Canaanites, same customs, same ways of living and the same Gods!!! Hey just saying...
@@sarahwaters10sw they are different ethnicities
@@fillfinish7302 nope the Canaanites were not white if that's what your thinking and they all were not killed and some they ran somewhere else!!!! And those people have claimed to be from the Land of Canaan they have found tablets saying that's where they came from, No hate Here I'm a North Amarican Native, I am a Wyandot to be exact from Canada. So it's not because I'm racist against these people because I'm also Native, but people must do thier own research on things!!!!!! Just like I did!!!!! Look up those tablets they found, THE OLD ROCKS WILL SPEAK..... And from my research I'm thinking the rest of us Natives are from the tribe of GAD out of Isreal..... Hey just saying!!!!!! And God did say Canaan would be wiped out and destroyed and that we would suffer.... Well those people were destroyed just look at what they were doing!!!!!
Proud to be tArkalani sayyed
My maternal side uncle's daughter-cousin's Mtdna haplogroup ROa.
where are you from?
This only proves "man traveled all over this planet" in search of better living conditions.
Can someone explain why Scandinavian is present in most of the tests?
alguém pode explicar porque escandinavo está presente na maioria dos testes ?
Yes, it`s bollocks as usual, the bones must be ancient not a modern human kalash,
Citting:"Haplogroup R0 derives from the macro-haplogroup R. It is an ancestral clade to the R0a subclade and haplogroup HV, and is therefore antecedent to the haplogroups H and V.
R0's greater subclade variety in the Arabian Peninsula suggests that the clade originated in and spread from there.
R0a is believed to have evolved in Ice Age oases in South Arabia around 22,000 years ago. The subclade would then have spread from there with the onset of the Late Glacial period circa 15,000 ybp.[4]
The subclade HV whith his subclades are in modern times often present in Scandinavia as H1 and H5a,who knows the same snip is inherited tru the generations.
Simple por ke el DNA escandinavo es muy antigo, probabilmente kedaron en Svecia u Danimarca personas desde India myt muy anos lontanos, y em Escandinavia no kedaron otro pueblo por su didtancia y por su clima inospitale
@@bibiana761 No, its proto indo European related. Indians have nothing to do with scandia. Insulting.
You could classify it as “common-Indo-European”. Same goes if you see Celtic in seemingly unrelated populations.
Look up the path of the proto Yamnia (Indo-Europeans). From southern Russia west into Ukraine and Central Europe. Next they went north into Scandinavia. Then east into Poland, Belarus and eastern Russia between Ural mountains and Caspian Sea north of the Central Asian Steppe until the Alti mountains. Finally south thru the mountains and eastern Afghanistan into North Pakistan and the Indus Valley. That is very rough path and does not cover the path into the rest of Europe, Central Asia and others.
Caucasian meaning caucus mountains not white or European… but Asian…
They have a habit of hijacking other people's terminologies
people of the caucus mountains are white, just not western (Celtic or Germanic) white.
Can u post about Nuristanis? They have more light features than kalash and they're the most isolated Aryans.
Nuristani maybe modern Andronovo alike people they would get high European
They will have the same results, they are all white Indians
@@Yow531 No such thing as a white indian. Keep dreaming.
@@kasyakyoubfgamindikisboratlol
Yes Nuristani paternal groups are R1a1/R2 Aryan but Kalash are native Indian L and H
Perhaps also partly representatives of the Bactria Mariana Archeological Complex population, in other words mixing Ancient Zagros Neolithic, Steppe/Andronovo indo Europeans as well as proto Indus periphery, ancient, mesoeolithic Baluchistan admixture elements.
The Turks who were waiting to steal their identity but did not have Mongoloid DNA 😂
@@mr.savage2586😂
Ha ha they arenot our ancestor.. Where is greek? They were greek root?😮😮Even we have more greek dna because roman. 😂 Our ancestors are turkman and roman.. 😂
@@meralkeskin8511 lol turkmen 😂
Wtf turkmen themselves are
Mongilian daddi Iranian mummi
Mix u azzzzole
Lol. These turks are everywhere on all IE videos. They literally claim everybody. From Iceland to Bangladesh, everybody is turk according to them.
Kalash videos also see a lot of Greek trolls who try to claim South Asian aryan heritage.
👍💯🤣
Turks tamils
And Filipinos
Omg annoying comments they make
Klav khalash?
They are beautiful people. The girls are gorgeous.
Where is the dodecad k12 b results?
Khazar heritage but i see this group pop up in my dna studies indonaryan connection i’m guessing
In my opinion - Kalash are a native West Asian/Middle Eastern people that originated from Afghanistan and Northwest Pakistan, who over the centures mixed with Indo-European and South Asian peoples.
Kalash couldn't have originated before the arrival of Indo-Europeans since they got their language, culture and significant part of their genes from the Indo-Aryans.
The Kalash ethnogenesis is like any other group.
They are the end product of the peoples that have settled in those lands.
The main ones are
1. the Indo-Iranians who arrived in the Bronze Age
2. the farmers from the Iranian plateau(Dravidians) who arrived in the Neolithic age.
3. the Paleolithic people of south-central Asia, who were similar to the Indian Tribals.
That goes for all the ethnic groups in that region, whether they call themselves Pashtun, Nuristani, Punjab or Baloch.
No middle east
Lol nope. Kalash are IndoAryans, just like rest of the IndoAryans of South Asia. They follow an ancient form of Hinduism and have stayed isolated for a long time.
Their paternal haplogroups are mainly local AASI & Zagros. Their maternal haplogroups are steppe.
@@jmab721 lol their y dna is
Steppe and BMAC (y dna Lm20 )
Which is not assi or zangro
Middle What?
Cool results of Kalash people 👌👍 Nothing unusual in genetics when we take into predict surrounding countries. Northern European is remnant from Yamna gene. Regards
Indo-Iranians are Corded Ware --> Sintashta --> Andronovo --> Central Asia, Iran, Pakistan, India etc
Blonde hair and blue eyes comes from the Corded Ware people, Yamnaya were quite Mediterranean in color
@@SithStudy Blonde hair and blue eyes has nothing to do directly with the culture of Corded Ware and it's borders, but with mutation and adaptation of the people who lived in harsh environment like Northern Siberia, Siberia, Central Asia, Arctic and Scandinavia.
@@SithStudy It's an ignorant (to not say stupid) thing for someone to say that culture is connected with phenotype and dna 🙂
@@dejantodorovski5222 they have nothing to do with the Corded Ware? What did the Corded Ware look like then? Black skin and dark eyes?! You sound salty the Kalash have European dna lol
3:30 Which website did u use for those results?
12% Scandinavian? From ancient Norwegian backpackers, maybe?
The Kalash are Indo-Iranians, the Indo-Iranians are peoples who originated in Central Asia and are closely related to the Steppe Indo-Europeans, modern Scandinavians have 50% steppe DNA
It doesn't mean they are literally descended from people who lived in norway, but that people who live in norway share a common ancestry with the kalash. it suggest that they are from the same steppe people who later on migrated in different directions, and the kalash intermingled with other very distinct populations along the way.
@@geraldsmithers9270 The Indo-Europeans of the steppes were very different from the WHG and EEF. Norwegians possess all three mixtures plus a residual uralic mixture. For example, steppe EHG was closer to Native Americans and West Siberians, whereas EEF was closer to West Asians.
Don't get confused. It's just my heritage mislabeling ancient groups as per modern groups.
The 12% scandinavian is not actually scandinavian, but simply the 20-30% steppe_mlba of Kalash. Similarly, IVC & BMAC heritage of them is getting mislabelled as South Asian & West Asian.
No Scandinavian came later
They equal Pashtuns in their DNA percentage . Shocking similarities
Nuristani kalashi is Non pashto speaking pashtuns in DNA. Their DNA almost similar pashtuns
theyre are isolated not mixed ancient iranians and me who is native central asian mixed not ancient and not isolated iranian and its interesting how i have almost the same areas as kalash people south and west asia, scandinavia and baltic. Our genotype is still similar despite our phenotype being drastically different
How many are there? Population in homeland and immigrants to other places.
Very small number, less than 5000 iirc and quickly declining due to forced conversions in Pakistan.
Hello please test ancient Elamite and also Bactria-Margiana Oxus Civilization .
They are Neolithic Iranians, the civilization of the Indus Valley is also Iranian
IVC was formed by mix of Zagros & Australoid South Asians.
@@alani3992 not austrolid u azzzzole
Its aasi basal east Eurasian
@@alani3992 AASI is dark skinned but mtdna and ydna is proto east asian, like roundish face and straight hair.
@@alani3992outh Asians are mix of proto-east-asian + west eurasian that's all. west asians are arab and north African.
Vikings came to "THE" Istanbul to trade and moved on to ... the East via the Silk Road, right?
Kalash showed up on my genetic test* i have 0 asian btw
Via ancient north eurasian
CAN YOU PLZ DO YANA RHS I BEG
Actually Decimali once did a video on Yana but later deleted it, it was even the first video the channel. And I still remember that it scored, you have to swear me by words from my memory it’s scored ~33% South Asian and for rest is major Northern European(Baltic, Finnish, Irish), some Inuit/Native American and African ethnicities(must be confusion)
@@barguttobed i once saw g25 list for yana rhs and the closest was khoisan and maori thats why im really confused i hope he does one again
@@barguttobed also where do they even get yana rhs samples from how
@@k1r4z.Lol true there is Māori😂 But no Khoisan actually, other way Bushmen Khoisans are genetically least related group to any Eurasian population(I mean even Bantu Africans are closer) But Māori sample as I said previously is half European and only half native(Maori).
Distance to: Yana_UP
0.13238330 Maori
0.13496373 Nepali_Indo-Aryan_B
0.13707294 Balti
0.13765029 Uzbek
0.14118421 Bahun_o
0.14210593 Nepali_Indo-Aryan_C
0.14212891 Nepali_Indo-Aryan_A
0.14378910 Tatar_Crimean_steppe
0.14394288 Turkmen_Uzbekistan
0.14558057 Burusho
0.14608014 Rajput_Garhwal
0.14678239 Pamiri_Sarikoli
0.14684865 Brahmin_UP_Lucknow
0.14703780 Brahmin_Kumaon
0.14815996 Turkmen
0.14856325 Rajput_Rajasthan
0.14972247 Brahmin_UP_Lucknow_o
0.15006009 Bashkir
0.15161516 Tatar_Lipka
0.15166262 Rajput_Rajasthan_o1
0.15226112 Pamiri_Sarikoli_China
0.15371688 Bahun
0.15447973 Pamiri_Wakhi
0.15560861 Brahmin_Himachal_Pradesh_West
0.15660985 Bhumihar_Bihar
@@barguttobed
THX SO MUCH 🤝🤝🙏🙏
Dear udegram is near to kpk timergra Pakistan
Indo-Europeans migrated to Asia from Southern Russia and Ukraine (the Yamnaya culture) Eastern Europeans also. It coincided with Alexander The Great's invasion of Asia and the Far East.
That is why they are different to neighbouring populations, their language and culture are different too. If you look at the colourful traditional Lithuanian/Ukranian dress etc you can see the similarities.
Obviously over the centuries they became isolated from Europe, many interbred with their neighbouring populations. The European blue eyes and fair skin still arise in their genes today.
Paganism was practiced in European culture long before Christianity.
Problem is that’s a completely unproven theory. According to DNA examination it’s vastly unlikely - no genetic link to the south-east of Europe could be detected. And the colorfulness os most likely a mere coincidence - it can be seen in a lot of traditional dresses all around the world. Imho geographical isolation is the key - there are even astonishing examples in Europe like the Rheto-Romans for that. Or take the Basques with their unique proto-european language noone knows its roots for sure.
@@luciustitius Its on Wikipedia. Yamnaya is a Russian adjective that means 'related to pits (yama)', as these people used to bury their dead in tumuli (kurgans) containing simple pit chambers.
Genetic studies have suggested that the people of the Yamnaya culture can be modelled as a genetic admixture between a population related to Eastern European Hunter-Gatherers (EHG) and people related to hunter-gatherers from the Caucasus (CHG) in roughly equal proportions, an ancestral component which is often named "Steppe ancestry", with additional admixture from Anatolian, Levantine, or Early European farmers Genetic studies also indicate that populations associated with the Corded Ware, Bell Beaker, Sintashta, and Andronovo cultures derived large parts of their ancestry from the Yamnaya or a closely related population.
Seems you are wrong.
@@careytitan9097 Very interesting aspects - I'm not completely convinced yet, but thank you very much for the response!
@@luciustitius The truth is the truth.
@@luciustitius the proto-indo-iranians were mostly corded were like people genetically but when they diverged from each other they settled in some parts of central asia then Iran and India and mixed with the natives who were related to early hunter gatherers and civilized farmers. there still some groups in the mountainous regions of who are not highly mixed and show good relationship with DNA sequence found in a lot of early Indo-European mummies.
The Kalash also have Iranian DNA, probably they must be descendants of the Scythians, Eastern Iranians ❤
No they are just unmixed people who are descendants of BMAC and PGW cultures of the Subcontinent
They're not Scythian descendents. Their steppe admixtures dates fall LONG BEFORE Scythians even existed.
They're just one of many rigvedic indo aryan people who.
Although, they're certainly cousins of Scythians, just like other Andronovo descended people.
Jats and Rors, on the other hand, might actually have some Scythian or Saka link. But nothing is clear so far, we need more research.
And btw, Scythians and Iranian DNA do not have some direct correlation. Scythians were steppeMLBA people, the Zagros/Iran_N dna you're talking about was later _picked up_ by them
Kailash are said to be the last fully blooded original Indo European people.
no fully blooded but mostly south asian with little mtdna input from Aryans
You're incorrect, they have a significant amount of Indo-European ancestry, and are classified as Indo-European.
@@SehlanMeyKalash are 20-30% Sintashta. Rest of their DNA is mainly Indus Valley & BMAC.
The far darker Jaats & Rors of Haryana, Delhi NCR, West UP, Northern Rajasthan are 30-40% sintashta.
Sikh Jatts of Indian Punjab are 25-32% sintashta.
Plenty other desi groups who are either similar or more steppe than kalash.
Don't fall for the light eyes & light hair phenotypes, that's due to isolation+sexual selection+drifting+bottleneck.
If anything, Kalash are mainly Zagros & AASI paternally, but Steppe maternally. This means that non-aryan local men of ancient India/South Asia married with Aryan women of Andronovo and selected for those lighter traits.
@@SehlanMeyIndoEuropean is a linguist classification, not genetic.
There are Europeans who speak non-IE languages, but have lot of steppe genetically. They won't be classified as IE.
There are Europeans who have lesser steppe than them, but speak an IE language, so they will be classified as IE.
Same goes for Central Asia, South Asia, Iran.
The Aryans were the dominant people while the Dravidians were weaker compared to them. Why would dominant people give their women in marriage to weaker men? Does not make any sense. Impossible.@@jmab721
Pashto results. All hindu kush area ppl are similar, ppl talk about kalasha more just because they are still pagan.
I doubt they are allowed free worship in a muslim majority.
It is protected by law in Pakistan. No one may attempt to convert them
@@land980still half of them are now Muslim lmao
Man?!!? There's 24 millions non Muslims in Pakistan....
I saw the word "Kalash people" and the first thing I thougth of was people who prefer AK style rifles over AR style rifles LMAO
indeed they have kalashnikovs and they shoot at different events like marriage etc,so yeah kalash prefers kalash as main gun
Indo european people with many r1a blood
You are so uneducated 😭😭
make about Kohistani
Would be same. Kohistanis pashtuns nuristanis kalash dardics all get the same results
@@bezbezzebbyson788 No, Pashtuns are lower Steppe than Dardics. Pashtuns aren't South Asians they are Central Asian because they score Turk-Mongol
What is south asian
Indo aryan ? Dravidian ?
For MyHeritage it's both
Exactly what it says. Modern south Asians.
Mix of them
Northen India is a mix of Steppe, BMAC and some Aryan.
South is dravidian and little mix of Aryan
Dravidian have negroid characteristics,the indo arians more caucasian,yes its quite racist from MyHeritage just bolloks as usual.There are 40 nations in the Indian subcontinent the heck knows why My Heritage is so dumb.
Rh negativesl bloodline
their light eyes/skin are original do europe!
No
Can u upload DNA of Arain cast of Punjabi population of Pakistan
Arian caste is mostly Iranian farmers + Ancestral South Indian from what I have seen, with very little European in them. Iranian farmer is your biggest component at around 50% I think
They're very IVC heavy
@@jmab721 I heard IVC was actually most tribal ancestry, it matches closely to south Indian tribals of today.
@@Deira854 IVC stands for Indus Valley Civilization. It was one of the most advanced ancient civilizations. It was an urban civilization, quite the opposite of tribal.
@@Deira854 One can be IVC heavy depending upon which AASI proxy is being used. The southern Indian tribal thing you're talking about is probably Pulliyar group, the IVC sample being used to call them "IVC heavy" is on the AASI shifted end of IVC samples. Basically an Indus Periphery sample which has high AASI.
There are other IVC samples which range from medium AASI to low AASI. Other populations prefer them and can equally be "IVC heavy."
You must understand that IVC had a huge variation in terms of genetic makeup. Some people were 50% AASI, while others were less than 10% AASI.
Arains probably prefer medium AASI IVC sample.
Vepsian or Komi would be interesting to see I think.
Especially Komi or Udmurts.
kalash folks and hungarian magyars are close brothers
magyar words of hungary
KALÁSZ= bud of grain/wheat
KALÁCS= sweet bread =pánkó/fánk
KÖLES= millet, panic-grass (for pán-ko=kalács)
KOLOZS vár= CLUJ NAPOCA romania today, but a magyar city
KALÁKA= kolhoz, kollective work of village in harvest time of kalász=grain
kell, hozz= what needed will bring in magyar=kolhoz th-cam.com/video/20NnEqueVO8/w-d-xo.html
KULÁK = rich farmer of 1950' hungary who was deported to GULAG killing camps, and all land was grabbed away, now in foreighn hands
Why do you mess up facts?!
Kalash are not descendants of the non existent "indo-European-Aryan etc" ancestors. They are Greeks, that settled down there after following Alexander the Great in his military expeditions.
They still worship their Ancient Greek Gods under different names.
What to do, when obfuscation is a better business than telling the simple truth?
The similarities between the religions is due to a common Prehistoric origin, and not due to some campaign of a short-lived empire. The religion shows great affinity with ancient (Vedic) Hinduism. Genetic research also rejects a Greek origin.
@@r.v.b.4153
Well, the Greeks have another opinion and organized for years now, trips. They go there to help them with their most basic needs, speak Greek with them and have seen that they are worshiping the same Ancient Greek deities under other names.
As for the genetics, well, those who make these tests said as well that the ancient Greeks are not genetically related to the modern ones. This is but a lie.
The Greek anthropologist Aris Poulianos made a study about the bodily proportions of ancient and modern Greeks. This is equivalent to a genetic test of far grater range than those test currently made, because, for every bone in the body there are big amounts of genes at work.
He discovered, scientifically proven, that the modern Greeks are as much Greeks as the ancient ones. They are their descendants.
As for the similarities with the Vedic religion, most probably the Hindus adopted it from the Greeks.
The similarities btw the religion of the Kalash and that of the Greeks has nothing to do with short lived empires. Empires come and go, but Greek culture goes back thousand of years in history and prehistory. As Plutarch inform us in his book "On the face which appears on the orb of the Moon", the Greeks were settled around he Gulf of Mexico 12'000ys ago as an established culture. So, we can assume they are much older than that even.
Your problem is, you didn't read the most important books on this subject but mostly academic hogwash.
@@r.v.b.4153at last whoever talks about an ethnic group should take seriously what these people are saying about themselves !!
They not Greeks or Macedonian
@@joebidet2050
Yes, they are, Joe.
Go grab some history books....the right ones.
Those Vikings were everywhere!
Vikings belong to a completely separate & far away branch of IE. Kalash are IndoAryans, they have nothing to do with Vikings.
Vikings too have higher SteppeMLBA but they weren't Indo-Aryans, they were different populations. This people are Indo-Aryans.
Nothing to do with Vikings or Scandinavians. These are more new and recent populations. It’s more likely from Proto Indo-Europeans.
@@matrixxx3662 It's not PIE. IndoIranians hail from Fatyanovo.
There's nothing Viking about them lmfao
Sort les kalash comme a marseille
Zero% greek or macedonian
stop doing female samples do only males we also want to see their Y-DNA
Sexist?
@@mistersomertonmakes sense actually as women only have one Haplogroup
Steppe in india is female mediated
Scandinavian 12%,
@@mistersomertonbecause girls dont have Y CHROMOSOME
Could they be related to the Scythians?
No
no
welll kinda,if we take to consideration that both are iranian folks and speak iranian languages
They are not a Gypsies!
Modern Gypsies around the world are descended from mixed race of Indo-Aryans + some Dravidians who migrated from Rajasthan or anywhere predominantly in North India.
@@aestheticterritory Dravidians were native on whole Indian Subcontinent not just Rajastan. When Indo - Aryans came mostly from North and Northwest, pressed them towards South. That's why nowadays Dravidians are mostly found in Southern Indian states like Karnataka, Kerala, Andhra Pradesh and Tamil Nadu.
@@aestheticterritory So modern Indians are a mix of both (Dravidians and Indo-Aryans) plus they have a significant East Asian component especially found in people from the Eastern parts of country.
@@dejantodorovski5222 That's true. But genetically there are no really pure race in India.
Dravidian people mostly live in South India, and Sri Lanka.
But the remnants of them were also already mixed since thousands of years ago, or absorbed predominantly by Indo Aryan people in northern India.
That's why sometimes we found some (or many) Pakistanis, Northern Indians, Nepalis, Afghans, Kashmiris, Bangladeshis, with some Dravidian features. Although as not much as in South India.
In the contrary we also saw Maldivian peoples (who are located more southern than Indian continent) who are a mixed race, but yet not as dark as some South Indian or Sri Lankan Tamils.
@@aestheticterritory I know that genetics of modern Indians is very complex & unique - they're far enough from every other ethnicity on our planet, that they are of mixed ancestry (Dravidians+ Indo Aryans + Yamna European + East Asia etc). Dravidians can be found in the extreme North - even in Iran Balochistan (Brahui) and an opposite Indo Aryans can reside extremely South of India & Sri Lanka & Maldives. Those who call and count themselves Indo - Aryans almost always have an additional Dravidian ancestry. Those who call and count themselves Dravidians, almost always have also Indo Aryan and European Yamna genes, besides phenotype which in many cases misleads us.
I HATE videos that make me read the whole story.
Kalash are mostly R and U
R and U originated in central asia
Mal'ta boy 24000 lake baikal was R and U
These people migrated into europe making modern day European
Stop with the europeans went there !
Its nonsense
Where did gypsies or romany come from ?
Nw india to Europe
1000 years ago
The same thing but much earlier !
this Pakistani kalash no debate they European
aiaiiai what a nonsenseeeeeeeeeee ahh
these people are original to russia and east europe,that went to these part of the world,,many thousands of years ago,,as worker,first to africa,middle east and then to south asia and even china
aiaiaiaiaiiia ,also they are mixed with south asia and european
can you do yayoi, jomon or hayato samples please
Haplogroup R goes back to the Arabian Peninsula, NOT Europe. Though it is ancestral to H, which is the most popular maternal haplogroup in Europe today.
Nope
Wut
@@joebidet2050 Hello, R starts at R0, which is 100% Arabian.
@@ayeshaashraf9252 YEP. R0 started in Arabia, tens of thousands of years ago.
@@jmab721 I hope y'all understand this is the MATERNAL R we're talking about. Not paternal. They're different. Maternal R started in Arabia.
Now do Nuristani! Nuristanis are even more white than the Kalash.
Is real aryans
They will have the same results, they are all white Indians
@@Yow531 No such thing as white Indians, keep dreaming. Kalash do have lighter features, but id never confuse them with a European.
@@Yow531 Indian are aassi + iran+ European mix
Tiwari Brahmins have more steppe dna than nuristanis but they are not white , neither steppe equates to being aryan , kalash and nuristanis is just indians with less aasi and little bmac , it's common
Aryans.
Ancient Aryans
And you ancient Kurwa
@@barguttobed 🗿
*Modern Aryans
Anceint noblemen? Aryan just meand nobleone or upright.
no. Ancient aryans were europeans. Although these are their descendants living in south aisa
Its kailas of lord shiva
Türk 🇹🇷❤️
Neresi Türk?
Asian turk
Lol, go away
They look more Kurdish then Pakistani, if you go to Turkey in the mountains see so many features
Kalash people are pure indigenous ethnic Aryans. DNA racial studies are not an accurate discipline but nascent and easy to fix and manipulate data. While forensic genetics is extremely accurate thanks to the genius Kary Banks Mullis for this. The Aryan Race is indigenous to the Northwestern Indian subcontinent and touching Central Asia. It is where Rigvedic-Sanskrit and Avestan-Persian (almost identical) languages arose from a common proto-Aryan language. The language of the Kalash, Kashmiri language, Shina language, etc., Dardic languages are directly linked to this proto-Aryan language. Stop making these innocent people as Macedonians, Greeks, Albanians, etc. by fake planted data. Aryan mummies have been found close to this region which pre-date Alexander by several millennia. Also the world famous expert on this discipline and archeologist Viktor Ivanovich Sarianidi discovered an Aryan site not far from this region which again pre-dates Alexander by several millennia. In fact the region where this site was discovered had a large Aryan colony and later on non-Aryans namely the Turks moved into this region. Please see this video on U-Tube: Origin of the Aryan Race - Historical Facts and Evidence
Difference between Aryans and Scythians?
@@waqaralikhan6601 Aryan have asi
Scythia have east Asian
Probably some Scandinavian woman slave was sold to the area a long time ago.
yes😂
No, they are of origin from the Andronovo culture of Central Asia, the Proto-Iranians were peoples from the Russian steppes who were related to the current Slavic peoples and the Yamnaya, the part of DNA that you interpret as Scandinavian is actually Andronovo DNA identical to Yamnaya, modern Scandinavians are the humans with the most DNA Yamnaya or ancient peoples of the Russian steppes
@@user-yt3xd2jl6d Proto-Iranians are West Asian people mostly like the Alans - Sarma etc. , it's proto-Indo-Iranians who had features and most of genes from Sintashta mummies. Kalashas don't even speak proto-iranic language their language and gods are similar to that of Rig Vedics.
This comment is by far the dumbest one so far in this already stupid comment section
Burushaski Hunza if possible.
Kalash still worship their Ancient Greek Gods under different names.
Kalash got whiter because of mixing with the Nuristani people who migrated there during the reign of Amir of Afghanistan who force converted them to Islam. Before that the region was called Kafirstan.
The results are not surprising however gives gascinating insight. All these three components of their origin all clearly in favor of white race.
Kalash, Indo Aryan similar to R1a Pashutun, Kurdish as well as proto Indo Greek / Persians.
Descendants or related to Alexander the Great soldiers who conquered Iran and Afghanistan.
Kalasha tribe is an ancient Vedic Indian!
Would you do a Scythian DNA test?
He already did
@@ArturBaidi Are the Scythians one person?
@@Xataievladı No Scythians and Kalash people aren't the same, Kalash have already mixed with the local south asian groups that's why they got more south asian features, Scythians are mostly pure Europeans Indo-Iranians who are descended from Andronovo culture (Proto-Indo-Iranian) and didn't mix with Iranian and Indian local groups.
Scythians have around 50%-55% Proto-Indo-European ancestry, 25%-30% Anatolian Neolithic Farmer ancestry, 15% on Average European hunter gatherer ancestry while the rest is WSHG, ANE ancestry.
@@anzartemersit One sentence. Scythians are Turks.
@@ArturBaididid he do pazyryk Scythians
The Kalash people look very similar to the Amazigh people of North Africa namely Morocco…. It’s obvious they are mixed race so are most afghans …. Due to colonisation by Europeans …
Modern Europeans are the result of three completely different human populations.... There is no pure race...
Amazingh are Europeans 😂😂
Real Berber brown
@@ayeshaashraf9252 The Amazingh are not European, they are North African populations having their origin in the Levant, the closest living human populations genetically are the Arabs, they are brown to white in color
@@ayeshaashraf9252 Amazigh are not Europeans they are mixed race…. Part North African part southern European … some have Arab dna some eastern Asian and a little west African…. That doesn’t make them European 👀….research the Barbary slave trade….
@@ayeshaashraf9252 where in Europe do they come from? Dna doesn’t lie….
They Greek descent origin From Pakistan 🇵🇰
Kakash woman ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Their relegion is animism with Shiva like deity. Ie their relegion is close to ancient ivc dravidan
But Nuristani have indo European gods before islam
Stop they believe in Hinduism? I don’t think that Kalash worship Shiva (btw it’s me Shsrnv)
@@barguttobedthey believe in ancient form of hinduism , they even have a God named Mahadeo similair to hindu god Mahadev, just 1 google search is require
@@barguttobedwhy turk everywhere
@justaguy.2789 Yes they even worship 6 year old girl in the desert, by the command of Allah and rape after 9
@justaguy.2789 Kalash people don't even have r1a or j2 paternal line but native Indian H and L 🤣
I want this woman
Send bobs and vagene saar
Mostly indo, a little european nation. Perhaps releated with gypsy people. l saw blonde and blue eyed gypsies in balkans
Daddy i think south asian here is
Mix of iran and aasi
@@ayeshaashraf9252ohhh hicab Girl. Hoş are you🤣
@@Ersen_abiniz divorce your wife
Make me ur sultan
@@ayeshaashraf9252😂
@@ayeshaashraf9252 kerala apoo you are just another untouchable convert 😂😂😂
Actually they don't have 50% indoeuropean ancestry but only 20/30%