Yes, Turkey is the winner but Turkey paid the price for it. It didn't happen overnight country has done more to the Syrian people than Turkey. Saving the lives of 4 ml Syrians from certain death by the regime and has been taken care of them for the last 14 years costing the Turkish taxpayers over 40 bn $ yet you don't hear that in the Western media.
Turkiye did not win. It did not loose yet, but there is more than enough reason to fear that international bringers of democracy and human rights (USA, EU, Israel) will come after Turkiye after Iran now so they may reshape Anatolia in theşr image. (For the good of Kurdish poeple and democracy and rainbows, of course. 🎉 (Did anyone thing this is about geopolitical and military interests rather than ethnicity and culture clash??. 😮))
The biggest winners here are likely the Syrian people, as they have regained control of parts of their country. Choosing Turkey as an ally makes sense because Turkey has been very clear about its goals in the region. Turkey wants to stop Kurdish groups from creating a stronghold near its border, seeing it as a threat to its security. This partnership could bring some stability, but it also raises questions about what it means for Kurdish people and the region as a whole.
It was once said that England was so focused defeating the Spainsh power of the sixteenth century that she forgot to notice the rise of France.We are congradulating ourselves on the demise of Russian power even if only temporary and the retreat of Iran from from Syria that we have not noticed the sudden rise of Turkish power.
Israel got Mt. Hermon summit and the Al-Wehda Dam. Two of the most strategic areas in southern syria. Surely make it a fortress. I think Israel is the biggest winner especially the brilliance takeover of Mount hermon. Israel can now monitor Syria, lebanon and the Israeli occupied Golan heights.
That's a occupation and you're saying that's a win but later on you white Western people will start saying Israel has the right to protect itself hypocrisy people
Yes Turkey is the winner. Turkey wins a neighbour full chaos with a 1000 km of border and with hundreds of diversities and conflicts. Turkey wins millions of immigrants. Would anyone come and take this win? I hope all Syrians will be the winner. I hope one day Syrians will be talking of electrical cars, environmental issues, holiday plans, healthy diets, art, music and fun.
I want to know what the effects of this massive withdrawal of drug supply is going to be on the whole region. We've only seen the bags that have been found. There are 10's of millions of people who depend on the drug to be i.e. taxi drivers, security guards, night workers, nurses & doctors.. They work in the region under harsh conditions and (yes I was there) this drug enables them to do their jobs.. and its not the rich, it's a lot of the people who provide the basic services .. will be hit .. unless there is any kind of support (which I can't imagine happening) .. repercussions of that mass withdrawal will be significant.
Which makes it obvious, really, Putin is not going to let that billion dollar export industry that was in Syria go to waste. Russia has the manufacturing and export capacity. It would be better if that wasn't the case, but I feel for the millions working in the middle east who are (pretty much) reliant on this drug to be able to work the hours and labour expected of them there.
Unfortunately, there are no winners in wars. There was a sentence in the movie The Pianist: "No cause in which people die is justified." I hope a free Syria again
Once a person has become radicalized, it's impossible to turn back. He's just putting up a show. Why can't the Middle East, Eastern communists let us Americans live in peace?
DW why are you lying ? Turkey has NOT been a long supporter of HTS , they actively supported other opposition groups such as Syrian National Army , but Turkey is not the main power behind HTS. Hakan Fidan have openly said that Turkey DID NOT SUPPORT HTS , they just did not interfere when HTS was taking Aleppo and other regions. HE said TURKIYE IS NOT RESPONSIBLE . What is your problem ? WHY ARE YOU LYING? If you are a news outlet, YOU MUST take official statements into account when giving news.
everything you see on SYRIA, you will see also in IRAN,,, see how HAPPY SYRIAN PEOPLE ARE after that DICTATOR DEFEAT>.. that will be the IMAGE of IRAN if IRANIAN REGIME DICTATOR will defeat... iranian people will be free from extremist dictator
same Turks that foam at the mouth defending Turkey, will lie that there is no such thing as KURDISTAN but will in the same breath tell you that China's Ethnically diverse Xinjiang province should belong to "Ughur Turks" as they like to call it. biji KURDISTAN
Watch the forex reserves situation in Turkiye & Egypt. USA fiscal strategies is a big factor. Russian strategic needs and financial capacity is next. 😢
Turkiye Syria needs cash & food. This state is weak for next few years, it could collapse during TRUMP II. Assad could return with Wagner & Russian National Guards. Don't discount that especially if the Russian Special Operations ends. 😢
What a game a. This world is a game. Strategic game. One day you are terrorist and enemy's next day you aint. Everybody wants to take what they can from syria.
Here is a little history when the Ottoman Turkish Empire collapsed the Turks, and Saudi abandon most what we now call Syria. This how a small minority of Alowites took over the country. So I hate to say it only Damascus does ok most the country is very poor. So you are not going to see Turkiye or other countries want to rush in and take more land. Israel is only that trying create a buffer zone however pushing that deep in Syria means a lot of forces that they have pull from Lebanon.
@@Djamonja All countries meddle in the affairs of other countries around it. Traditionally, before we were an industrial society it wasn't too bad. But to maintain an industrial lifestyle you need resources like good land, industrial fertilizers which means access to Pot Ash mines, coal, and iron mines to make steel. And believe or not reliable "rain" or a massive freshwater river. Most countries don't have any of it, which make a hot bed for rebellion and insurrection.
@@Djamonja World War I and World War II where brutal wars they where as much about getting resource for your Empire because "coal" in one part of Europe, the Iron in another, and oil was in North Africa. This before America created "Globalization" and forced the world powers to play nice and trade with one another. But if you lived in a French colony before World War I, and the French did not have access to coal or oil you could not trade with the British because they where rivals.. American created "Bretton Wood Accords" as World War II was ending, it forced the major countries of the world to be nice trade with one another. America would use it's navy the only one to survive the war to act as Imperial navy for you, to go out and get iron, fertilizers, and coal so that you could industrialize. In exchange America asked that you side with it against Stalin and the old Soviet Union. But the Soviet Union collapsed thirty years ago the agreement is null and void American people want to pull back from world and so "Globalization" is disintegrating and countries like Syria, Russia, and China are falling apart. You don't realize how much you world needs American Globalization.
@@Djamonja A lot countries are not self-sufficient, their cotton to make clothes comes from places like "America" or "Kazakhstan". Their coal and Iron to make steel comes from far way places like Australia. Their "pot ash" to make industrialized fertilizer comes from Russia or Morocco. "Bauxite ore" to make aluminum to make cars bodies come from place like Mongolia. And we not even talking about "microchips" they are in everything now days from your microwave oven to your water heater. Those technologies only come from the western countries of America and Europe. Turkiye and the Middle East cannot produce any "microchips" the have no fabrication faculties currently.
It appears that the Turkish population may not fully grasp the consequences. President Erdoğan and his party, the AKP, could lead Turkey toward a disastrous future if the country continues to pursue land grabs in Kurdish territories. The resulting sanctions could be so severe that Turkey might plunge into extreme poverty, similar to what has happened in Iraq and Syria.
the SDF is 60% pkk and 40%arab tribes. Arabs have never been confortable in this US forced arrangement and most are abandoning SDF for Damascus. the US has little excuse to be in Syria now. Preserving a couple of ISIS reminents for 10 years and use it as leverage won't help.
Refrain from casting blame upon one another and acknowledge that each of you would likely act in a similar manner to these nations. It is disgraceful to seek the spotlight in such a manner."
Please leave the Syrians to run their country alone.. Their country was completely destroyed by Bashar al-Assad and when they were dying no one helped them
@@abdiganiaden do you history research Syria is a wastse land.. Syria not many natural resources such as oil, mineral and gold.. so would Russia waste thier time thier..🤣😂😂
@@Keyboard_Thoughts go to history class.. Syria rebel don't like isreal, along with turkey.. isreal don't like turkey along with the Syria rebel.. so what that leave you with.. they will automatically go to war with each other... 🤣😂😂 You people where trick again..
Yes, Turkey is the winner but Turkey paid the price for it. It didn't happen overnight country has done more to the Syrian people than Turkey. Saving the lives of 4 ml Syrians from certain death by the regime and has been taken care of them for the last 14 years costing the Turkish taxpayers over 40 bn $ yet you don't hear that in the Western media.
200 billion Euros...
@@orka6848 While Turkiye was in need of more than 900 billion Euros
Turkey and Israel win. Russia and Iran loss
Are you a loser or winner?
@@ThomasBenson-dt2mt relative to you?
Turkiye did not win. It did not loose yet, but there is more than enough reason to fear that international bringers of democracy and human rights (USA, EU, Israel) will come after Turkiye after Iran now so they may reshape Anatolia in theşr image. (For the good of Kurdish poeple and democracy and rainbows, of course. 🎉 (Did anyone thing this is about geopolitical and military interests rather than ethnicity and culture clash??. 😮))
The biggest winners here are likely the Syrian people, as they have regained control of parts of their country. Choosing Turkey as an ally makes sense because Turkey has been very clear about its goals in the region. Turkey wants to stop Kurdish groups from creating a stronghold near its border, seeing it as a threat to its security. This partnership could bring some stability, but it also raises questions about what it means for Kurdish people and the region as a whole.
Turkey wants them as a proxy
So you don't understand anything @@TibetYılmaztürk
What...you mean the grain and oil producing areas....hahaha
Sultan Erdogan is building the new Ottoman Calafate.
😂
I don't think it will try to encroach its borders towards inside Syria.
It was once said that England was so focused defeating the Spainsh power of the sixteenth century that she forgot to notice the rise of France.We are congradulating ourselves on the demise of Russian power even if only temporary and the retreat of Iran from from Syria that we have not noticed the sudden rise of Turkish power.
Turkey is part of NATO
Little premature to be talking about winners and losers pending a settlement. Without peace, just war by different means.
Praying for the Syrian people 🙏 They deserve unity and peace. They have suffered enough due to dictatorship, sectarianism, and separatism.
Russia humiliated again! Bahahahaha
🌍Dont mes with the Turks Turkiye wil make Siriya Grayt AgenTurk Turkiye Turkic Turan 💫TC R T Erdogan♟Sah Mat ✍😎
Turkey has 25% of Syria- turkey won.
Kurds lost
Syrians won - for now.
Kurds have 35% of Syria 😂
@@vulli8184The question is for how long 😂
@@vulli8184soon it will be 0 %
Don´t poke the Turks.
Israel got Mt. Hermon summit and the Al-Wehda Dam. Two of the most strategic areas in southern syria. Surely make it a fortress. I think Israel is the biggest winner especially the brilliance takeover of Mount hermon. Israel can now monitor Syria, lebanon and the Israeli occupied Golan heights.
That's a occupation and you're saying that's a win but later on you white Western people will start saying Israel has the right to protect itself hypocrisy people
Israel occupied the Highest area in the southern syria Mt Hermon and its just 40km from Damascus. What a move by Israel
It's 5-6km from the Golan Heights buffer zone.
You all talking nonsense, just a week ago you all western media were saying Syria is free in democracy,
Yes Turkey is the winner. Turkey wins a neighbour full chaos with a 1000 km of border and with hundreds of diversities and conflicts. Turkey wins millions of immigrants. Would anyone come and take this win? I hope all Syrians will be the winner. I hope one day Syrians will be talking of electrical cars, environmental issues, holiday plans, healthy diets, art, music and fun.
I want to know what the effects of this massive withdrawal of drug supply is going to be on the whole region. We've only seen the bags that have been found. There are 10's of millions of people who depend on the drug to be i.e. taxi drivers, security guards, night workers, nurses & doctors.. They work in the region under harsh conditions and (yes I was there) this drug enables them to do their jobs.. and its not the rich, it's a lot of the people who provide the basic services .. will be hit .. unless there is any kind of support (which I can't imagine happening) .. repercussions of that mass withdrawal will be significant.
Which makes it obvious, really, Putin is not going to let that billion dollar export industry that was in Syria go to waste. Russia has the manufacturing and export capacity. It would be better if that wasn't the case, but I feel for the millions working in the middle east who are (pretty much) reliant on this drug to be able to work the hours and labour expected of them there.
Unfortunately, there are no winners in wars. There was a sentence in the movie The Pianist: "No cause in which people die is justified."
I hope a free Syria again
❤
It's another failed state....thank you Nato
The joke is Turkie is begging Russia to stay and help them with the mess...no chance
the overthrow of the regime was pretty bloodless.
tekkeyi bekleyen çorbayı içer
Turkey is not a foreign power. Half of the Syrians live in Turkey. No country can have as much say as Turkey.
11:17 guy not for DW. He is not capable
Once a person has become radicalized, it's impossible to turn back. He's just putting up a show. Why can't the Middle East, Eastern communists let us Americans live in peace?
And whoever does not judge by what Allāh has revealed - then it is those who are the defiantly disobedient.
Wow. the mighty bear fell 👌
DW why are you lying ? Turkey has NOT been a long supporter of HTS , they actively supported other opposition groups such as Syrian National Army , but Turkey is not the main power behind HTS. Hakan Fidan have openly said that Turkey DID NOT SUPPORT HTS , they just did not interfere when HTS was taking Aleppo and other regions. HE said TURKIYE IS NOT RESPONSIBLE . What is your problem ? WHY ARE YOU LYING? If you are a news outlet, YOU MUST take official statements into account when giving news.
everything you see on SYRIA, you will see also in IRAN,,, see how HAPPY SYRIAN PEOPLE ARE after that DICTATOR DEFEAT>.. that will be the IMAGE of IRAN if IRANIAN REGIME DICTATOR will defeat... iranian people will be free from extremist dictator
You just want to tell the world that Syria is divisive.
same Turks that foam at the mouth defending Turkey, will lie that there is no such thing as KURDISTAN but will in the same breath tell you that China's Ethnically diverse Xinjiang province should belong to "Ughur Turks" as they like to call it. biji KURDISTAN
East Turkestan is Uyghur.
There is no Kurdistan and never ever will be 🇹🇷
My predictions are that Russia is going to get to keep its base and Syria will stay fragmented
Watch the forex reserves situation in Turkiye & Egypt. USA fiscal strategies is a big factor. Russian strategic needs and financial capacity is next. 😢
The Kurds are screwed.
Not if HTS' leader makes good on his promise.
Already attacking the kurds
Look who screwed in Irak 😂one comes after another
Turkie begs Russia to stay...? Russia reluctant.
Kurds ?
Türkiye wins ❤
One thing we can all agree on is: it can only get worse in Syria
Turkiye Syria needs cash & food. This state is weak for next few years, it could collapse during TRUMP II.
Assad could return with Wagner & Russian National Guards. Don't discount that especially if the Russian Special Operations ends.
😢
What a game a. This world is a game. Strategic game. One day you are terrorist and enemy's next day you aint. Everybody wants to take what they can from syria.
Here is a little history when the Ottoman Turkish Empire collapsed the Turks, and Saudi abandon most what we now call Syria. This how a small minority of Alowites took over the country. So I hate to say it only Damascus does ok most the country is very poor. So you are not going to see Turkiye or other countries want to rush in and take more land. Israel is only that trying create a buffer zone however pushing that deep in Syria means a lot of forces that they have pull from Lebanon.
Nobody is saying the neighbors want to take land in Syria. They want to influence whatever political outcome happens in Syria.
@@Djamonja All countries meddle in the affairs of other countries around it. Traditionally, before we were an industrial society it wasn't too bad. But to maintain an industrial lifestyle you need resources like good land, industrial fertilizers which means access to Pot Ash mines, coal, and iron mines to make steel. And believe or not reliable "rain" or a massive freshwater river. Most countries don't have any of it, which make a hot bed for rebellion and insurrection.
@@Djamonja World War I and World War II where brutal wars they where as much about getting resource for your Empire because "coal" in one part of Europe, the Iron in another, and oil was in North Africa. This before America created "Globalization" and forced the world powers to play nice and trade with one another. But if you lived in a French colony before World War I, and the French did not have access to coal or oil you could not trade with the British because they where rivals.. American created "Bretton Wood Accords" as World War II was ending, it forced the major countries of the world to be nice trade with one another. America would use it's navy the only one to survive the war to act as Imperial navy for you, to go out and get iron, fertilizers, and coal so that you could industrialize. In exchange America asked that you side with it against Stalin and the old Soviet Union. But the Soviet Union collapsed thirty years ago the agreement is null and void American people want to pull back from world and so "Globalization" is disintegrating and countries like Syria, Russia, and China are falling apart. You don't realize how much you world needs American Globalization.
@@Djamonja A lot countries are not self-sufficient, their cotton to make clothes comes from places like "America" or "Kazakhstan". Their coal and Iron to make steel comes from far way places like Australia. Their "pot ash" to make industrialized fertilizer comes from Russia or Morocco. "Bauxite ore" to make aluminum to make cars bodies come from place like Mongolia. And we not even talking about "microchips" they are in everything now days from your microwave oven to your water heater. Those technologies only come from the western countries of America and Europe. Turkiye and the Middle East cannot produce any "microchips" the have no fabrication faculties currently.
@@Madame702 What does that have to do with anything I said?
Bribes and promises for oil
I bet he told u I was pregnant
If he had picked the right one Turkey is Gotti his plot working on a Iran
There must some type of federal government in Syria, because of its factions
Mediocre comments. Cliches.
It appears that the Turkish population may not fully grasp the consequences. President Erdoğan and his party, the AKP, could lead Turkey toward a disastrous future if the country continues to pursue land grabs in Kurdish territories. The resulting sanctions could be so severe that Turkey might plunge into extreme poverty, similar to what has happened in Iraq and Syria.
Turkey think he won
the SDF is 60% pkk and 40%arab tribes. Arabs have never been confortable in this US forced arrangement and most are abandoning SDF for Damascus. the US has little excuse to be in Syria now. Preserving a couple of ISIS reminents for 10 years and use it as leverage won't help.
Turkey will have to Deal with UK
😂
''Turkey has the second largest military in NATO, after the United States.''
@@QuestForGoodHow about economy?
Refrain from casting blame upon one another and acknowledge that each of you would likely act in a similar manner to these nations. It is disgraceful to seek the spotlight in such a manner."
Please leave the Syrians to run their country alone.. Their country was completely destroyed by Bashar al-Assad and when they were dying no one helped them
Why he try to say He got America
Turkey think he got a America weapon
Bhutan wins. Uruguay loses.
😂😂😂 Russian letting the gready NATO and USA fight over syria spill.. Russian lay this trap an they fell right into it...
Putin could not keep his man in power. If USA wanted Assad in power, he would still be there today.
Russia not even on table anymore. Cope Ivan
Of course, every Putin's fart is a genius 5D chess move that puts him 4 parallel universes ahead of Anglo Saxon
@@abdiganiaden do you history research Syria is a wastse land.. Syria not many natural resources such as oil, mineral and gold.. so would Russia waste thier time thier..🤣😂😂
@@Keyboard_Thoughts go to history class.. Syria rebel don't like isreal, along with turkey.. isreal don't like turkey along with the Syria rebel.. so what that leave you with.. they will automatically go to war with each other... 🤣😂😂 You people where trick again..
He mad at Gotti
LoL he is liar
Saudi Arabian honorable king should be careful about Israel and USA.
As a Bangladeshi I deeply support Palestine, KSA and UAE.
Saudis and uae don't support Palestine. They do nothing but provide empty promises.
Keep Israel and the USA out of your mouth.
Bangladesh Pakistan Palestine Türkiye Syria Saudi Arabia, Sudan are all Brothers ❤❤❤
,,mountain of dishonoroability ,,,once had som runnin through ,,eroded 2 wasteland ,,,,