I loved the Macy’s December box. The little red bag was adorable, the lip gloss is gorgeous on, and I haven’t tried the Armani product but it is $425 for 30ml so the size we got is worth $70.83!
I liked the smaller Macys bag. It’s different than the larger bags.😂 I carry small purses so a small bag is appreciated. You can put small things in it! The Georgia Armani item was also a replacement. I doubt I spelled that right. So Macys had two subs. That was a high value product. I really liked Macys this time. The spoilers for the next two months look great also!
Both were nice this month! I agree about the foil packet. Really, with soooo many other beauty boxes to choose from those shouldn’t even be a thing anymore. I did, however, like the palette in the Macy’s box, the mascara, and that ABH lip gloss was gorgeous! Ipsy seems to be stepping up their game which is nice to see, but I think Macy’s still edged them out just by a little bit 😊 have a great weekend! Hugs 💖
Macy’s for the win! I get both so I was able to touch, smell, test the products. I absolutely love the small bag from Macy’s! We get too many standard size bags. The small bag is perfect for the basics and fits perfectly in a small handbag or my Corkcicle crossbody drink carrier bag that I carry in the Disney parks, farmers markets, etc. I also enjoy the brands more in the Macy’s bag! However, I was impressed with the Glam Bag! I was going to cancel this one but after getting the December bag, I may keep the subscription!💞
I get both of these boxes. I loved the Macy's box (except for the foil pack...ugh). The makeup bag is a throw away item IMO, but the palette and ABH gloss are great! My Ipsy bag had totally different products...not as good as yours and definitely not large products.
My Ipsy bag was a little different as I chose the full size Elf SFP primer (awesome!) and didn't get the perfume, Pixi lip balm or Fenty mascara, If Macy's had added a perfume sample or two in their old style, it would have pushed them over the edge for me as winners,
I think I'm going to have to give it to Macy's. The curl stuff is a bust for me, so it kind of cancels out the foil pack although I LOVE getting the fragrance also. Hmmm...might call it a draw.
The Gergio Armani was also a different product. 2 oops really. I had a third problem - my red cosmetic bag was missing, but Macy's customer service was very responsive and returned the cost of the whole bag to me as they could not guarantee a replacement.
Last month they sent me a curl spray from him too, but my hair is so stright everyone thinks I strighten it all the time. So, useless to me, but glad I can oass it along. Thankful, I did not get the fragrance, since I can't do those. However, I do like citrus. I picked the Pixie as my full size, but it STINKS! And it dried my lips out so fast, I threw it away after trying it once. 😆
I liked the Macy's better. Only because you received a full size blush pallette from Laura Geller and a very nice size lip gloss from ABH, then the mascara, that looked nicer than Fenty. I like Ipsy's bag better, but that's about it. Ipsy did do better on sample size, but I still have to say Macy's won for me.
I was wondering if you heard anything about Ipsy and the PR boxes. I saw a couple of the Ipsy PR unboxings and they were mentioning something about no longer sending out the PR boxes but there was no real explanation and none of them knew many details. I kind of have mixed feelings about those PR boxes...seems they give them to everyone..I saw one channel where she was complaining about not getting the box anymore and she has just a bit over 3k subs. In my opinion those boxes should only be given to those who have a substantial following like at least 20k and I can't help but wonder if they didn't give away all those PR boxes if maybe the price of the sub wouldn't rise every other year.
Honestly I am not sure. I only received 1 pr box from ipsy and I think it was in February or March of this year. They sent me a free boxycharm box, but I never got anything else after that. I kind of think that ipsy has stopped a lot of marketing because even their instagram is not the same as it was. I could be wrong, but I think ipsy has lost a lot of subscribers in the last year.
No, Macy's won, hands down! All that gorgeous makeup, a serum that will last me 3 days, and it's YSL! 10ml of perfume, and a classy bag to put it in? AND, it's cheaper? Sorry, Sydney, you can keep your kid's bag, 😂, sorry, think you are off this month 😘 ❤ 🌹
I loved the Macy’s December box. The little red bag was adorable, the lip gloss is gorgeous on, and I haven’t tried the Armani product but it is $425 for 30ml so the size we got is worth $70.83!
I liked the smaller Macys bag. It’s different than the larger bags.😂 I carry small purses so a small bag is appreciated. You can put small things in it!
The Georgia Armani item was also a replacement. I doubt I spelled that right. So Macys had two subs. That was a high value product. I really liked Macys this time. The spoilers for the next two months look great also!
I love your green eye shadow with your yellow shirt. Great earrings too.
Macy’s for the win this month! Better brands and adorable little bag.
Hi Sydney. I hope you feel better soon. I got the perfume as well. The gift is a body lotion (retails for $20). Shipping and handling is $4.99.
I liked December Macy"s box.
I liked Macy’s bag. The skincare is extremely expensive and it was nice to be able to try it.
Macy's December box is my favorite !
I'm going with Ipsy this month Sydney! It's a very cute bag and the products in it are good too❣️
Both were nice this month! I agree about the foil packet. Really, with soooo many other beauty boxes to choose from those shouldn’t even be a thing anymore. I did, however, like the palette in the Macy’s box, the mascara, and that ABH lip gloss was gorgeous! Ipsy seems to be stepping up their game which is nice to see, but I think Macy’s still edged them out just by a little bit 😊 have a great weekend! Hugs 💖
Macy's for sure ❤
These were both so good this month!
Hope you continue to feel better. Take care of yourself
The ABH is a mini I got one that size in my IPSY recently but it is a nice size just the same. Full size ABH lip gloss is 0.15 oz / 4.5 ml
Macy’s for the win! I get both so I was able to touch, smell, test the products. I absolutely love the small bag from Macy’s! We get too many standard size bags. The small bag is perfect for the basics and fits perfectly in a small handbag or my Corkcicle crossbody drink carrier bag that I carry in the Disney parks, farmers markets, etc. I also enjoy the brands more in the Macy’s bag! However, I was impressed with the Glam Bag! I was going to cancel this one but after getting the December bag, I may keep the subscription!💞
Liked Macys better..but both were good! ❤
I get both of these boxes. I loved the Macy's box (except for the foil pack...ugh). The makeup bag is a throw away item IMO, but the palette and ABH gloss are great! My Ipsy bag had totally different products...not as good as yours and definitely not large products.
My Ipsy bag was a little different as I chose the full size Elf SFP primer (awesome!) and didn't get the perfume, Pixi lip balm or Fenty mascara, If Macy's had added a perfume sample or two in their old style, it would have pushed them over the edge for me as winners,
I think I'm going to have to give it to Macy's. The curl stuff is a bust for me, so it kind of cancels out the foil pack although I LOVE getting the fragrance also. Hmmm...might call it a draw.
The Gergio Armani was also a different product. 2 oops really. I had a third problem - my red cosmetic bag was missing, but Macy's customer service was very responsive and returned the cost of the whole bag to me as they could not guarantee a replacement.
I think it might be a tie🤷🏻♀️
Last month they sent me a curl spray from him too, but my hair is so stright everyone thinks I strighten it all the time. So, useless to me, but glad I can oass it along. Thankful, I did not get the fragrance, since I can't do those. However, I do like citrus. I picked the Pixie as my full size, but it STINKS! And it dried my lips out so fast, I threw it away after trying it once. 😆
The link says a bad gateway. Could not sign up
I liked the Macy box better
Ipsy, is it free gift with purchase?
Prefer the Macy's box. Better brands.
Is that foil pack their "oops?"
Oh, nvm you say later. Boo, that is a good mascara that you were supposed to get. Least the replacement is "ok."
Macy's❤
I liked the Macy's better. Only because you received a full size blush pallette from Laura Geller and a very nice size lip gloss from ABH, then the mascara, that looked nicer than Fenty. I like Ipsy's bag better, but that's about it. Ipsy did do better on sample size, but I still have to say Macy's won for me.
Agree with you, Ipsy won
Ipsy won!
I hate foil samples.🤩
Macys
I like the ipst make up bag ❤better.But I think macy's won this month
Ispy bag won.
I was wondering if you heard anything about Ipsy and the PR boxes. I saw a couple of the Ipsy PR unboxings and they were mentioning something about no longer sending out the PR boxes but there was no real explanation and none of them knew many details. I kind of have mixed feelings about those PR boxes...seems they give them to everyone..I saw one channel where she was complaining about not getting the box anymore and she has just a bit over 3k subs. In my opinion those boxes should only be given to those who have a substantial following like at least 20k and I can't help but wonder if they didn't give away all those PR boxes if maybe the price of the sub wouldn't rise every other year.
Honestly I am not sure. I only received 1 pr box from ipsy and I think it was in February or March of this year. They sent me a free boxycharm box, but I never got anything else after that. I kind of think that ipsy has stopped a lot of marketing because even their instagram is not the same as it was. I could be wrong, but I think ipsy has lost a lot of subscribers in the last year.
No, Macy's won, hands down!
All that gorgeous makeup, a serum that will last me 3 days, and it's YSL!
10ml of perfume, and a classy bag to put it in?
AND, it's cheaper?
Sorry, Sydney, you can keep your kid's bag, 😂, sorry, think you are off this month 😘 ❤ 🌹
❤
Oh no! These boxes just aren’t it 😅😂
Macys is better. Better brands...
I loved that Macy’s box! Ipsy… meh.