So I just went through the keyboard 🎹 and Katrina’s Key jumped higher on that last part. No wonder the song got even more intense towards the end. “Good example of a great cover” C. Aguilera would be proud of her.
4 ปีที่แล้ว +5
Katrina tells on vlog that they make it higher a half note thats why it is more higher than christinas version. If you watch her the making of reflection, they're both great 🥰 but i love the tickness of the voice of christina Aguilera so good 🥰, idol ko din si katrina kasi sobrang galing.
Christinas voice is captivating..most people go for a song that captivates them..its not because the highest note..christina might be able to do that as well..
4 ปีที่แล้ว +3
@@romar30567 on the first parts of comparing, Christina Aguilera gives me goosebumps, this is for real, i watch it the whole video. Im not against any of them, cause I love them both CA and KV
This is the best way of comparing two versions; like point-by-boint, and then you realize how powerful each one is in their own rights. I would like to believe that both of these girls are the winners but hey, the real winners are actually us, the fans! We were treated by magnificent talents from the opposite parts of the world and we were truly entertained. I'm just grateful we are able to enjoy two different versions among others who gave life to our all time favorite Mulan ❤💋❤
This is indeed an awesome compilation from you. I have always loved Cristina Aguilera ever since her song Genie in a Bottle I just adore her husky voice and her tone.. OMG. But since I discovered Katrina V, I have been listening to her music She is a very talented artist and I love her so much. Mabuhay , Philippines!! God bless..
Christina = perfect tone and power Katrina = perfect technique and range Both are perfect in their own ways so no need to bring down the other just to lift up the other one 🙂
+ I was listening extremely close. Christina sang doing more RIFFS & RUNS. Katrina used more vibrato. This is something people criticize Christina for. If only she would sing the song "straight" and used less Melisma (packing different notes into one word or syllable). But when your voice is agile, hey... Why not?
Lea salonga: emotions, soul and a real disney type... Christina:sometimes there is the soul and emotions.. Katrina: clear and you can't hear broken (something gurgling water)...Katrina win
I like Katrina but Christina's unmatched. What i really like about Christina is not only her voice but her authenticity. She doesn't care what other people say, she is who she is. And actually her low to mid range is eargasm for me, her tone is untouchable. I think the reason why Katrina is underrated doesn't have the same spotlight like others is because we have too many biriteras here in PH. And you must have something different to offer for you to have that spotlight. A great example is KZ Tandingan she's not a biritera but have a unique style that's why she excel from other biriteras.
True! Xtina's tone is untouchable its one in a Billion! Technique-wise, Katrina is better but perfect technique is boring without amazing tone.. Lets all admit, Katrina dont have unique tone, its a typical pinay biretera tone but her technique is perfect. Xtina's tone is pure emotion! She is the epitome of Aggressive singing, Though its not everybody's cup of tea, but she got Millions of diehard fans all over the world because of her tone and singing style..
@@Sejuani89 yes, anybody can have an amazing technique thru trainings but to have an amazing tone that cuts through the heart and soul you must be born with it. And Chritina is a total performer, a gebre killer.
Christina is such an icon and is out to prove it. This updated version is just as epic as the 1998 version. But then Katrina held her own with her flawless rendition. That high note in the end definitely gave Christina a run for her money. Both ladies are divine.
The girl with the short hair nailed it. I know Christina is amazing but she sounds angry every time she sings. I wanna hear her like when she was young where everything is natural. Listen to the other girl, she sings naturally. Less effort but full of emotions
Didn't like Christina's old version of "Reflection" at all - her belts sounded like a cow screaming while giving birth. Her newer version sounded better but, I agree, she sounds angry when she sings even if the message of the song doesn't call for it. Katrina's version, though a cover of Christina's, is more classy and refined, and indeed more natural and full of emotions. And when she belts, it's not painful to the ears.
@@angelogamalong4092 Yung voice tone ang pinaguusapan dto. Mas manipis ang voice ni Kat kesa kay Christina...ang sabi ng reactor...mukhang mas mataas pakinggan yung kanta ni Kat dahil daw sa mas manipis ang voice nya. Pero this is not the case... kaya sya mas mataas pakinggan ay dahil mas mataas talaga ang key na kinanta nya. Accdg nga mismo kay Katrina... she will sing it a half key higher than Christina's. Yan ang pinaguusapan dto. Yung voice tone ni Kat. Hindi yung binabanggit mo. Kinorekt ko lng naman yung reactor dahil mali ang paniniwala nya.
I give the lows to Xtina and the highs to Katrina. Yeah different tones: one is heavy, the other one is light and airy but both powerful.Though Katrina can mimic Xtina's voice, she chose to make the song her own.😍
Nobody can sing like Ms Christina Aguilera.. is he voice, her tone and her unique style.. other singers can do high notes than she but when Christina sing is incredible ❤
It actually sounded like they were singing together and they both sound absolutely wonderful! We know both ladies can sing with riffs and runs, Katrina just chose not to use as many and it sounded marvelous. Comparing these ladies is like comparing Luciano Pavarotti to Dimash Kudaibergen and that's crazy! 🥰😍🥰😍
They're both my favorite, i love them both. I love Christina Aguilera since i was a child and katrina when i was a lady ahaha, char! Basta mahal ko silang dalawa, no to comparison. 🥰😍
Christina has more access to many vocal range and parts,her voice is versatile,singing higher doesn't mean better,even I can sing higher than Christina but I am a shit near her vocal prowess and agility,so Christina Aguilera wins for me for her tone timbre and originality,and Katrina good job...
* Katrina has more access to many vocal range and parts, her voice is versatile. Why? She can even sound like Mariah, Whitney, Celine and of course Christina. Im sure you have watched her impersonation videos. Talk about who's got the edge when it comes to Vocal Range and Versatility. *Hitting high notes here is not just about being high like a simple scream. Its an art and a display of vocal ability and control. We call it belting. And both of them has their own way and style of belting. It is just that Katrina's RANGE is wider. *Both of them have their own tone, timbre and originality. In the end it all boils down to one's preference. Even Lea Salonga's version is on a different league and legendary. And speaking of preference, the 1998 Christina version is I think much better. The 2020 version is over the top its as if she is shouting.
Let's not forget we are comparing one original (that cost possibly at least a million dollars to produce) recorded in a hollywood music studio with the best equipment mickey has to offer, staffed with world renowned sound engineers, against a cover that only cost a teeny tiny fraction of that. Both talents are top class but for a cover piece to even match the emotional impact of an original, that is nothing short of epic greatness. Huge props to everyone involved in making Katrina's version
A good singer is who can make a song that is soulful and pleasant to the listener's ears, not only because of the high note/key in singing, i love them both.
It's not Katrina's voice much higher just because she has a thinner voice than CA, but the key at the latter part of the song on Katrina's adds +2 higher.
True, ni-share nya sa vlog nya yun ng the making of reflection, kung ano hiningi ng tunog yun ang ibibigay ng singer. They're both great, but the thickness of the voice of christina Aguilera is so amazing 🥰, katrina also is really great.
no at that range it was Christina's voice that got thinner and it was katrina's voice that got richer. so if they do a duet together, they can merge the richness of Christina's voice on the low ranges with katrina's voice on the high ranges and i can just imagine the impact of that kind of collab
Pero pansin na pansin kay lods kung knino sya na papangiti ng todo at na iimpress sa dalawang singer..palagi nyalang bukang bibig kay Christina sobrang ganda ng Tone ❤ kailangan nya lang maging patas sa dalawa para mahatak nya parehas ung mga humahanga kay Christina at Katrina at iwas narin sa maraming negatibong kumento ☺ KeepItup Lods.. Godbless 😊
You can't compare both of them. Each has own style and both of them are great in their own ways. Simply, Christina is Christina and Katrina is Katrina.
I prefer Katrina’s version to be honest. The two higher key changes made it more dramatic and majestic. Christina’s vocals are impressive, but Katrina’s was more heartfelt and gave me goosebumps, and I’ll admit that her singing got me a little emotional. Kudos to Katrina. Just proves that you don’t have to be a famous diva to have the best rendition of a song.
Correct , you don’t have to be famous, but she studied Christina’s version. She added some differences in there but she used Christina’s blueprint. She had that to go off of. In the future I hope Katrina has the same effect on other artists as well. She is talented.
STILL CHRISTINA AGUILERA'S GOT A UNIQUE VOICE... BUT KATRINA VELARDE VERSION IS REALLY MORE THAN ENOUGH...ITS LIKE UR RIDING A ROLLERCOASTER...THIS IS ONE OF D HARDEST SONG BUT SHE NAILED IT... ASIDE FROM KATRINA...PLS LISTEN TO LANI MISALUCHA..DESSA.. THEY R GREAT SINGERS FROM PHILIPPINES ALSO
So I just went through the keyboard 🎹 and Katrina’s Key jumped higher on that last part. No wonder the song got even more intense towards the end. “Good example of a great cover” C. Aguilera would be proud of her.
Katrina tells on vlog that they make it higher a half note thats why it is more higher than christinas version. If you watch her the making of reflection, they're both great 🥰 but i love the tickness of the voice of christina Aguilera so good 🥰, idol ko din si katrina kasi sobrang galing.
@ right.its a half note high
@@mikeparilla7790 its a 1 note high😊 She modulated the accompaniment twice at the end part.
Christinas voice is captivating..most people go for a song that captivates them..its not because the highest note..christina might be able to do that as well..
@@romar30567 on the first parts of comparing, Christina Aguilera gives me goosebumps, this is for real, i watch it the whole video. Im not against any of them, cause I love them both CA and KV
Christina is a male version which is so powerful and Katrina is the female version which is soft and sweet!
This is the best way of comparing two versions; like point-by-boint, and then you realize how powerful each one is in their own rights. I would like to believe that both of these girls are the winners but hey, the real winners are actually us, the fans! We were treated by magnificent talents from the opposite parts of the world and we were truly entertained. I'm just grateful we are able to enjoy two different versions among others who gave life to our all time favorite Mulan ❤💋❤
Big yes to that. Thank you ❤️
But dude, you know these kinds of videos garner these responses with all respect
This is how i hear it, "Aguillera's voice is a bit manly, full and raspy, Velarde is womanly, clear and high pitch." Both are wonderful singers. 👍👍
This is indeed an awesome compilation from you. I have always loved Cristina Aguilera ever since her song Genie in a Bottle I just adore her husky voice and her tone.. OMG. But since I discovered Katrina V, I have been listening to her music She is a very talented artist and I love her so much. Mabuhay , Philippines!! God bless..
Philippine artists are becoming popular worldwide.More power
He smiles more on Katrina’s part .. gotcha
HAHAHHA yeah Ive noticed tooo
Christina = perfect tone and power
Katrina = perfect technique and range
Both are perfect in their own ways so no need to bring down the other just to lift up the other one 🙂
+ I was listening extremely close. Christina sang doing more RIFFS & RUNS. Katrina used more vibrato. This is something people criticize Christina for. If only she would sing the song "straight" and used less Melisma (packing different notes into one word or syllable). But when your voice is agile, hey... Why not?
why not? because She is Christina freaking Aguilera. She goes beyond technicalities and made herself different from other singers.
definitely true!
Best Review ever and very fair comparison! this is how they should compare christina and katrina. THANK YOU 🙏!
Better than voice expert wanne be MGN Ovela
@@joppp6918 Ovela not a fan of him either.
Christina Aguilera is the best, only Xtina, only Reflection!!!
@@fao6783 lea salonga is the best becoz she's the original sang that song..no one can beat the original singer
Both two ladies are my fave singer....❤️❤️❤️🎤🎵
OMG!My Dear Katrina Nailed it..... uuuuggghhhh...
Katrina deserve a stage in the international arena along with the worlds iconic diva...
Lea salonga: emotions, soul and a real disney type...
Christina:sometimes there is the soul and emotions..
Katrina: clear and you can't hear broken (something gurgling water)...Katrina win
Sometimes soul for Christina? She is one of the greatest singers of all time. She is soulful dude
Christina is praised by soul singers themselves yet you claim she "sometimes" have emotion? lmao yeah sure why not
@@azriel3644 dont mind stupid people who dont know truth let him be
isa yan sa mga peenoise
Amen to that! Katrina nailed it!
Katrina for me, the "must!" got me😍😘
👍👍👍😍
Bravissimo Katrina! Best cover ever!!!
She holds that note better than I did with my money
This is how you do a reaction video and comparison at the same time. Kuddos! 👍👍👍👏👏👏
P.S. Note that Ovela! ☝😂
❤️❤️❤️
ovela is a bitch.... hahaha
Arrangement: katrina
Achievements: CHRISTINA
I like Katrina but Christina's unmatched. What i really like about Christina is not only her voice but her authenticity. She doesn't care what other people say, she is who she is. And actually her low to mid range is eargasm for me, her tone is untouchable. I think the reason why Katrina is underrated doesn't have the same spotlight like others is because we have too many biriteras here in PH. And you must have something different to offer for you to have that spotlight. A great example is KZ Tandingan she's not a biritera but have a unique style that's why she excel from other biriteras.
Nope, i think it was because filipinos choose eyecandies more than talent.. That is a big fact
jhay camp at least still have pinoy who is honest and genuin like you that left
buli ulbo
True! Xtina's tone is untouchable its one in a Billion! Technique-wise, Katrina is better but perfect technique is boring without amazing tone.. Lets all admit, Katrina dont have unique tone, its a typical pinay biretera tone but her technique is perfect. Xtina's tone is pure emotion! She is the epitome of Aggressive singing, Though its not everybody's cup of tea, but she got Millions of diehard fans all over the world because of her tone and singing style..
@@Sejuani89 yes, anybody can have an amazing technique thru trainings but to have an amazing tone that cuts through the heart and soul you must be born with it. And Chritina is a total performer, a gebre killer.
Christina is such an icon and is out to prove it. This updated version is just as epic as the 1998 version. But then Katrina held her own with her flawless rendition. That high note in the end definitely gave Christina a run for her money. Both ladies are divine.
Im addicted to XTINAS's voice....
Katrina vocalbeast!!!!🎼👸🏻🎤❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Im a fan of yours! You are so handsome! More of Katrina pls! fellow RN here :D
Eric Batan stay safe. Thank you of what you do.❤️
The girl with the short hair nailed it. I know Christina is amazing but she sounds angry every time she sings. I wanna hear her like when she was young where everything is natural. Listen to the other girl, she sings naturally. Less effort but full of emotions
Didn't like Christina's old version of "Reflection" at all - her belts sounded like a cow screaming while giving birth. Her newer version sounded better but, I agree, she sounds angry when she sings even if the message of the song doesn't call for it.
Katrina's version, though a cover of Christina's, is more classy and refined, and indeed more natural and full of emotions. And when she belts, it's not painful to the ears.
kunyari pa toh filipino din nmn kung ano ano pa tinatawag eh nasa title na yung pangalan HAHAHA
💕
totally agree..... go girl with the short hair it's Katrina Velarde....❤❤❤
katrina velarde cristal clear so much clean for katrina
Katrinas cover in my opinion is basically a mixture of Christina’s and Lea’s versions ❤️
👑Christina Aguilera is very best! Is THE VOICE!!! QUEEN!👑🔥❤️
kat didnt just sound higher but actually sang it twice as high (key modulation in the song happened twice towards the end of the song)
Katrina sang the song at a higher key that is why it sounds higher not because of the voice. 😁😁😁
Kuya kapag mas mataas po ang key syempre mas mataas din po ang voice other wise magfaflat po yung voice. Hindi tutugma sa key
@@angelogamalong4092 Yung voice tone ang pinaguusapan dto. Mas manipis ang voice ni Kat kesa kay Christina...ang sabi ng reactor...mukhang mas mataas pakinggan yung kanta ni Kat dahil daw sa mas manipis ang voice nya. Pero this is not the case... kaya sya mas mataas pakinggan ay dahil mas mataas talaga ang key na kinanta nya. Accdg nga mismo kay Katrina... she will sing it a half key higher than Christina's. Yan ang pinaguusapan dto. Yung voice tone ni Kat. Hindi yung binabanggit mo. Kinorekt ko lng naman yung reactor dahil mali ang paniniwala nya.
@@kotse9129 check
Ko Tse correct ....
KATRINA'S VOICE IS CRYSTAL CLEAR, I LOOOOOVE IT! 💖💖👍👍BUT CRISTINA'S VOICE IS GOOD TOO, BUT NOT AS CLEAR AS KATRINA🥰💖
no masmaganda pa rin ang original singer at wlang laban c katrina sa international singer na si christina aguelera
@@jaysonabila5716 opinyon nya yan. Pakialaman mo pa?
Di po sya ang original singer nyan
I give the lows to Xtina and the highs to Katrina. Yeah different tones: one is heavy, the other one is light and airy but both powerful.Though Katrina can mimic Xtina's voice, she chose to make the song her own.😍
I like catrina velarde she nailed it her voice is more clear and clean ....
Katrina .. vocal genius 😍
Christina >>>>
Nobody can sing like Ms Christina Aguilera.. is he voice, her tone and her unique style.. other singers can do high notes than she but when Christina sing is incredible ❤
It actually sounded like they were singing together and they both sound absolutely wonderful! We know both ladies can sing with riffs and runs, Katrina just chose not to use as many and it sounded marvelous. Comparing these ladies is like comparing Luciano Pavarotti to Dimash Kudaibergen and that's crazy! 🥰😍🥰😍
I really got goosebombs in katrina's part
Katrina just takes my breath away.
Katrina velarde for me .
Pinoy ako syempre 😅😅
They both amazing...wonderful..
Great Job 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
They're both my favorite, i love them both. I love Christina Aguilera since i was a child and katrina when i was a lady ahaha, char! Basta mahal ko silang dalawa, no to comparison. 🥰😍
Both are GREAT ❤️
International singers? No ... We have Filipino Singers hehe. Proud!🇵🇭
Christina does it again,beautiful great she is girl with the golden voice don't test her she is a winner love her you go girl !!!!!
So excited!!! 💙✨ I love your vids! Been a subscriber since your first reaction to Dimash!!
Christina has more access to many vocal range and parts,her voice is versatile,singing higher doesn't mean better,even I can sing higher than Christina but I am a shit near her vocal prowess and agility,so Christina Aguilera wins for me for her tone timbre and originality,and Katrina good job...
* Katrina has more access to many vocal range and parts, her voice is versatile. Why? She can even sound like Mariah, Whitney, Celine and of course Christina. Im sure you have watched her impersonation videos. Talk about who's got the edge when it comes to Vocal Range and Versatility.
*Hitting high notes here is not just about being high like a simple scream. Its an art and a display of vocal ability and control. We call it belting. And both of them has their own way and style of belting. It is just that Katrina's RANGE is wider.
*Both of them have their own tone, timbre and originality. In the end it all boils down to one's preference. Even Lea Salonga's version is on a different league and legendary. And speaking of preference, the 1998 Christina version is I think much better. The 2020 version is over the top its as if she is shouting.
Let's not forget we are comparing one original (that cost possibly at least a million dollars to produce) recorded in a hollywood music studio with the best equipment mickey has to offer, staffed with world renowned sound engineers, against a cover that only cost a teeny tiny fraction of that. Both talents are top class but for a cover piece to even match the emotional impact of an original, that is nothing short of epic greatness. Huge props to everyone involved in making Katrina's version
i love christina agielera voice
A good singer is who can make a song that is soulful and pleasant to the listener's ears, not only because of the high note/key in singing, i love them both.
Both has their own quality, both are amazing.
Katrina ❤️😭🎊👏👏
If xtina had added vocal acrobatic and insane high falsetto and gorgeous low voice,than singers all over the world would have a hard time covering..😂
Christina is amaizing, she has one of the best voices in the world, as well as being very versatile in musical genres. The resto is envy!
Katrina can add whistle note 🤣😂 sorry girl don't underestimate Katrina
That was fantastic! And you are a great reactor.
Tone is everything why? That's what will makes you original. The authenticity
I love both of them. But Christina’s version is the best for me ! But kudos to both. 😇😘
For me Kat is the best version of Reflection 😝😝😝
I like Kat version here but Christina Aguilera is so amazingly talented.
Pagod na pagod na idol mo katrina velarde for the win
I love them both as well, both amazing but I love Aguilera's tone so much so I give the node to her.
Cristina is better.
Katrina is the LUNG legend in the universe . .
Katrina is amazing but Christina is legend
They should do a colab to this song omg.
Wow! KATRINA ❤️💕
Katrina nailed it.
biased kase pinoy
Love them both Kat & Xtina 😍😍😍
They both blessed with talent 💞💞💞
How i wish Im blessed with thre amazing talent tooooooo....
I like Katrina hands down.
Katrina 👍👍👍
Katrinas voice much clearer than my future...its pinoy power...i love u katrina velarde....you deserve a grate appreciation around the world...
Christina'a voice is full, round and thick but both great.
Christina’s tone may have more volume but Katrina’s voice is majestic. She has become the song herself.
I LIKE THE KATRINA`S APPEARANCE NOW.....
I just like them both.
ALMOST SAME..I LOVE IT..😍😍😍
Katrina’s version gives me goosebumps, Kristina voice scares me
It's not Katrina's voice much higher just because she has a thinner voice than CA, but the key at the latter part of the song on Katrina's adds +2 higher.
True
True, ni-share nya sa vlog nya yun ng the making of reflection, kung ano hiningi ng tunog yun ang ibibigay ng singer. They're both great, but the thickness of the voice of christina Aguilera is so amazing 🥰, katrina also is really great.
no at that range it was Christina's voice that got thinner and it was katrina's voice that got richer. so if they do a duet together, they can merge the richness of Christina's voice on the low ranges with katrina's voice on the high ranges and i can just imagine the impact of that kind of collab
At the end, CA's hit D5 or D#5 while kat hit E5.
Oh my,,, katrina on a high note with vibrato
Kristina interpretation is on a bit lower note
Katrina nailed it.ILIGAN,PHILIPPINES HERE.
Love Christina Aguilera❤️ now and Forever unbeatable 👏🏻👍🏻🙏🏻♾
Katrina's version is half note higher than christina's version..
They're both amazing singers, no comparison. 💞 I enjoy listening to both of them👏👏👏👏👏
Pero pansin na pansin kay lods kung knino sya na papangiti ng todo at na iimpress sa dalawang singer..palagi nyalang bukang bibig kay Christina sobrang ganda ng Tone ❤ kailangan nya lang maging patas sa dalawa para mahatak nya parehas ung mga humahanga kay Christina at Katrina at iwas narin sa maraming negatibong kumento ☺ KeepItup Lods.. Godbless 😊
You can't compare both of them. Each has own style and both of them are great in their own ways. Simply, Christina is Christina and Katrina is Katrina.
You did great in giving comments to their performances. Kudos! Keep safe.
actually katrinas is higher because of the actual key change.
Katrina version amazing
I prefer Katrina’s version to be honest. The two higher key changes made it more dramatic and majestic. Christina’s vocals are impressive, but Katrina’s was more heartfelt and gave me goosebumps, and I’ll admit that her singing got me a little emotional. Kudos to Katrina. Just proves that you don’t have to be a famous diva to have the best rendition of a song.
Correct , you don’t have to be famous, but she studied Christina’s version. She added some differences in there but she used Christina’s blueprint. She had that to go off of. In the future I hope Katrina has the same effect on other artists as well. She is talented.
im for katrina .. go katrina...wooow...what a power voice...
STILL CHRISTINA AGUILERA'S GOT A UNIQUE VOICE...
BUT KATRINA VELARDE VERSION IS REALLY MORE THAN ENOUGH...ITS LIKE UR RIDING A ROLLERCOASTER...THIS IS ONE OF D HARDEST SONG BUT SHE NAILED IT...
ASIDE FROM KATRINA...PLS LISTEN TO LANI MISALUCHA..DESSA.. THEY R GREAT SINGERS FROM PHILIPPINES ALSO
Katrina, hands down.
Great video. Thanks!
Katrina ❤️❤️❤️❤️🇵🇭
Legend is always a legend😍😍😍 #christina
Best version..katrina..
Both
Amazing fair analysis.
Katrina for me is the best
Katrina is the best
I think Christina have more tehnic...she can created her voice very good..
love this reaction bro.
Katrina Nailed it periodt
I love katrina velarde
Wonderful and professional reaction sir. New sub here.