I have collected different brands and styles of knives over the years. In the last few years I have collected brands such as Bark River, Benchmade, Smith and Wesson, CRKT, Case, Buck, etc.. Your videos are a breath of fresh air. Finally someone speaks on the appropriateness of the shape and design and not just the looks.
As much as everyone complains about the Kabar being a rat tang, when being used as what it's designed for the cross guard way over compensates for it's deficiencies.
The tang on it is actually about a half again larger than the portion you see on the bottom. It's notched down at the pommel where it slides into it and gets locked in with a pin. I've seen them being made and not many people know that. Yes, it isn't a full slab tang, but I wouldn't call it a rat tail either. Cheers.
Yeah honestly, the classic Kabar USMC knife is great for a Self Defense type of situation obviously. It's been trendy for years now to bash it for the small tang and what not, I mean yes a full tang blade is better for beating on logs, but for Defense and ending someone's life in War when it's down to that. It's a solid great choice. Especially the Kabar Extreme D2 one. I'm thinking about getting that at some point.
Very much agree with this. Even outside of self-defence, I get a little leery of knives that don't have a guard or great handle/grip retention. Having gone through and taught survival courses, these small preventative measures can go a long way to compensate for your carelessness when your fatigued, have sweaty hands or bloody hands from processing game, etc.....
A long time ago I was in a 3 gun club that held a knife match once a year. Mostly simple skill tests and cutting tasks, sometimes mixed into standard 3 gun stages. A member using a typical folder suffered a severe hand cut when his hand rode up as he stabbed a cardboard IPSC target: exactly the scenario you are talking about. He had a firm grip but impact, even on light cardboard, is powerful. Thanks for spreading the word on this.
Imagine a powerful grip, hard stab, while your band is bleeding or wet on top of that. I've see fights lost, and a life lost, due to a cut recieved while fighting to the hand, which made his hand slip up the knife causing a deep wound allowing for a death blow. Hopefully I will never be in a place to see that again, or an environment that life js lived in that way, but just in case, finger holes, hand guards, and handles must be tested and retested , drawing test and practiced over and over until you are secure in your own safety.
I would never carry a folder because I've developed numerous techniques for comfortably concealing fixed blades since I was teenager, but if I did it would have to be strictly OTF precisely for that reason. Injuries from knives failing to deploy fully under stress and closing on the users hand are very common and I've read about numerous incidents like that from street fights, and even stuff like people trying to slash other people's tires. Swing out designs are just objectively bad and I don't use them. The reason they're so common is because most states have archaic laws against "gravity knives", which effectively ban OTF knives even if they're not automatic. This stupid issue has singlehandedly ruined the folding knife industry.
I have it i wouldn't use it for Bushcraft or anything more then when shtf it will save you but if I was you I'd keep that edge perfect till the time comes you wanna be able to put the guy down as fast as you cann stay safe
Great advice, also if you have time, do a video on why a straight edge barber's razor would be the worst blade to bring to a fight. I run into guys that watch old mob movies and think you can fight with an actual shaving razor, I mean sure, someone could but as a barber myself I hold one often and as knife enthusiast I can't even explain how many ways it could go wrong. Cringeworthy wrong.
Well actually back in the day in Scotland we had the razor gangs. They are 100% a good weapon that causes so much damage great for slashing a mans face and for making your enemy bleed out. Some were slashed from ear to the groin. Very nasty. You guys have guns but we have knife fights
@@heathenshaunt681There is no problem fighting with a straight razor. If you train. I train with various slip joints. While not the ultimate, definitely doable.
I am a knife maker. I always have a guard on my fixed blades. The only knives I make. Plus I do not put a tang hole on the handle end … for lil cutsie hanging items than can get caught in machinery & drag your hand in with it. My handle shaped fit the hand as well - not flat slabs like on production knives. Great article btw.
@@CadillacDriverMaybe this guy cleans the inside of his mower blade bay with his knives like a real smart guy. Maybe even with the mower still running.
Why would little cutsie items be hanging from the end of a knife that you are putting next to moving machinery? If you are sharpening/grinding it then I would think that anything hanging off the end would be removed before you do that? 🤔
I was cleaning a squirrel with a pocket knife when I was younger and my bloody hand slid down the handle and sliced my finger open. I will always have hand/finger guards on my knives. Very good information sir.
The answer to your question is: NONE!! I'm glad someone finally did a video on this, because I've been telling people this for years to get a knife that u can get a secure grip on without your hand sliding down the handle on to the blade. Thank you sir for sharing a very sensable video.
When I was active duty in the Army with the 101st Airborne (3/187th Infantry), the personal blade I first carried was a Gerber Mark 1, which was basically the same design as the Smith & Wesson HRT/Cold Steel Counter Tac you show. It was a great fighting knife, but a pretty terrible utility knife. Turns out, I needed a utility knife far more than I needed a fighting knife for general use, so it got replaced reasonably quickly by a Gerber Gator. The Gator was a far more practical utility knife, without losing TOO much capability as a fighting blade. Fast forward multiple years to nowadays, and I pretty much exclusively carry knives that are primarily folding utility blades, typically a Muela Navaja GL-10R, or a Boker Magnum Rescue. I do this with the understanding that there are inherent limitations in their application as a self-defense knife, and essentially must be always used in a reverse grip for such applications, but am willing to deal with that limitation in that particular niche application for the gained broad practicality of utility in my 99.999% case usage of my blades. So, I guess it might be said that I don't even carry a knife "for self defense" per se, but I'm unwilling to dedicate the additional weight and bulk of carrying a dedicated fixed fighting blade for a 0.001% application, or 'pay' for the limitations inherent in true fighting blades when used in the utility role. But my knives are always a second or third fallback for me in terms of self-defense in any case, so I don't think I'm really missing out much in terms of practical limitations to usage with my blade choices. But that's just my view, ymmv.
Hand protection and retention almost fot together. Be it a guard or a karambit ring. You need a way to keep the knife in hand, and keep the hand off the blade. Bare minimum requirements for defensive blade. And most other blades for that matter.
I like the looks of a lot of the “Japanese” style knives, or at least they have Japanese names ( : , but many have no hand protection of any kind, even though they are obviously made for defense. A few CRKT’s come to mind. Love the look, but they stay in the drawer. We get cut sometimes when we’re just fiddling with or sharpening knives. Imagine using a forward thrust with the force necessary to save your life. On a different note, I am a leathercrafter and I hate to make sheaths for knives with guards! So many more options if there is no guard in the way haha. If I get a new knife for myself with a guard, it stays in the kydex ( :
I recently purchased a Cold Steel OSS. Now living in England there is no way I can carry the thing, so it's my bedside blade. I also bought it because it is a sleek beautiful looking thing to my eyes.
as to your question, what knife that I got worries me, is the cold steel espada xl, a really big folding knife. It has a lot looking for it, but it seems to me that one little mistake deploying this knife and you can easily cut your fingers off.
Great video. A guard is a must in for certain situations. Back in the 80’s everyone carried Buck 110’s on their belts in school. Someone sliced my brothers tire in high school and there was blood everywhere. We figured his hand must have slipped down the blade when whoever did it stabbed the 36” off-road tire sidewall. The next day a guy who my brother had fought a month prior had a bandaged up hand in school. Coincidence? My brother didn’t think so and gave him another tail whooping on top of that messed up hand. 😉
I never thought of this but it sure makes sense. Thank you. I subscribed to learn more. The knife I just bought that now I’d never consider for self-defense is the Mira Garberg. I did not buy it for self-defense. But it’s the last knife I bought.
Very good information... I just got into knife making. And I'm finding some problems... I've made a couple very nice looking blades with exotic wooden scales and handles. But when I polish them so they look great... they're almost too slick to use . Especially if you're hands are wet ... it's hard to beat rubberized handles.
Hobbyist knife maker here as well. Polished handles look really nice, but I don't like how they feel. I prefer a "grippier" finish. I've even taken a few purchased knives with polished handles, sanded them down and textured them. I haven't used any rubber material, but "Terotuf" material feels phenomenal. (It's not the fanciest looking though)
@@LastBastian I'll have to try it... I've done one skinnier handle with nice wood and then wrapped it with paracoard and it worked good but colors didn't match. I want to find the balance between beauty and function. I know it's possible. And have used some like that.
@@donscottvansandt4139 For comfort it's hard to beat. Has a cloth like look and feel, and actually gets slightly more grippy when wet. It's also non toxic to sand, unlike G10 or Micarta, etc...
Missing a pinky finger reduces your overall hand grip strength by 75%. Found this out the hard way. Guards are a must on blades in which any sort of thrusting could be utilized.
I have two Stings and you are right, forward grip is not easy, I had to exercise a lot to learn using it like that. Yet, those prpoved extremely useful when I needed to crawl up a tree and used Sting as a step - it holds my 220lbs with no issue, does not bend or give even slightly. I have got SW too, it is great overall and, probably is suitable for fighting, but I would never dare to use it as a ladder step.
Facts!!! Great insight and advice. No guard on either fixed blade or folding knives is a non-starter. The Schrade SCHA9 provided the only lesson ever needed. Thanks 187/10 🙏
scythe grip with a thumb cap grip. i prefer point down, edge in grip. this makes the handguard question irrelevant, and makes lock strength in a folder less important.
These are high value advices! The truth must be told and shown, thanks! Great video as always ❤👍🏻👍🏻✌🏻 P.S. try skateboard tape on the handles when having no guard..aw hell on any knife that's meant to be used for real.
Use to work at a fish plant in my youth when the fresh cod would arrive we would gut them and another would take heads off and debone, I was really good and fast to cut cod tongues at 50 cents a pound and standing in fish cuts all day 😂 A buddy from a short distance pitched me a cod tongue too fast before I was ready so when I tried to catch it in the blink of an eye and forgot about the very sharp knife in my right hand, well in went in my left dead centre, the only thing that saved my knife from going through was my gloves were soaked and slippery from fish slime causing my right hand to react in more kindness and slide down the blade 😂 one needs a guard so you can take it back out if need be or make sure there’s a hole in handle to tie a rope to and pull hard , I’m living proof 😢If one wants to protect his goods in the house and shed just put Vaseline on the door knobs , one lady put it on the bedroom door knob so the kids couldn’t get in 😂
Great advice. A guard is one of the first things I look for on a combat knife. The blade is important, of course, but do not ignore the importance of the guard, grip handle, and sheath that you deploy the knife from. In my truck I keep a TOPS Operator 7 and a TOPS Sky Marshall Tanto. Both fixed blades that vary in size and ability to conceal. Both are chunky monkeys that deliver impact. It's also good to keep pepper spray and a strong flashlight so you can blind your adversary.
As a Cold Steel fan, I make sure that I buy a knife with some sort of guard for protection. Whether it is a fixed blade, food prep, machete, or even a folder, knowing that your hand won't slip brings peace of mind when doing a task. Thank you for this informative video! This needed to be said!
I have a Buck Pathfinder, 5" fixed blade. I had a boot repair man make me a leather horizontal sheath. He got it right. The blade will not fall out. It is not big and bulky. I live on a ranch, so it also serves as a work tool. Decent steel and keeps an edge OK.
Agreed. I have that very same Smith you showed, as well as a Gerber MK II. Both are combat (tactical) blades, the Smith is very good, the MKII is one of the BEST I’ve ever seen!
You don't want to be in a knife fight. One man goes to the hospital. The other man goes to a morgue. Carry a pistol and be proficient using it. I carry a large Cold Steel Ti-Lite.
A cold steel wasp is one of the knives I would say not to buy. I bought one and gave it away. The kabar ek44 is a much better knife after you replace the sheath.
Few people understand the nasty business that's involved in defending yourself with a knife. They're unfamiliar with just how much blood is involved and how slippery that blood can make a knife handle. Oftentimes police find stabbing assailants getting stitches at the same hospital their victim is in because their hand slid down the guardless blade. As for tactical folders that are what I definitely carry daily, flippers are great because they make a guard along the bottom of the blade that I think in most cases would stop your fingers from sliding down the blade. Great advice!🇺🇸
Great video and all points you make are valid. For me, my early 80s vintage Gerber Guardian comes to mind. I never had a bad experience with it, but it was pointed out to me that if hands were wet, they’d slide forward on that aluminum handle. I traded a knock-off of a Mark I for it straight up so it’s not like I’d be out any money to let it sit on the shelf, though. Maybe next up was my Colt Steel Tri Lire folder. It does at least have a thumb stud that sort of might function as a guard. I bought it because it was slim and I wanted something that was easier to carry. Don’t carry it anymore, however. Not a fan of filet of finger.
have you heard of the series of books, 100 Deadly Skills, by retired Navy Seal Clint Emerson? I believe they would make for a great video/videos, and to see your opinion on them.
That Smith and Wesson HRT is what I carry in my boot...I'm happy that you approve. How do you feel about the KaBar made "Spartan Harsey Fighter"...? The Buck Tops Nighthawk 650 and the 655..?
I see Microtech ultratech and Benchmade Infidels promoted as fighting knives but I have the same feeling about the grip. I own both because they where "grail" knives for me but I'd be hesitant about fighting with them.
Finally, somebody said it these knives are dangerous and I might have a couple laying around. I prefer I hand guard a double hand guard you are absolutely correct and thank you for saying it.
Good advice! Any knife I would consider for a defensive situation would have a good guard on it. Most EDC knives would not be ideal for self defense. Fixed blades are superior in this regard. One can make do with anything, but using the right tool for the right job comes to mind...🤔
Crkt has a design by James Williams who is very well respected. That design is called the hz6 I think. I don't like it because its a tanto with no guard. The grip is very aggressive but in my experience when you have a blade with a very aggressive handle like that you leave yourself open to training scars. I challenge someone to stab into something with some type of resistance. That super sharp edged g10 is going to bite you and you'll develop an aversion to it. Design should not dictate use. Use should dictate design. What good is a fighting knife that I can only use gloved and in reverse grip? It's good to see someone else who actually trains share the same opinion.
I as well do prefer guards. But also I understand that some people avoid them, especially in dmall knives, because of the risk of snagging the guard through clothes and fabric. The hole in the sting one is designed for Your thumb, so the blade sits well, without the risk of cutting Youself, but that greatly diminishes it's clinch knife abilities. In my opinion, kraton guards and handles are in between, giving You both of the advantages. I've recently posted a short video about that with Marauder's bowie.
I don't have a single knife only and specifically for self-defense. On the other hand, I have an APO-1S type survival knife ("Survival Lilly" design, made of austenitic steel), I am very satisfied with it, this knife is good for almost everything that can happen in bushcraft and in the hobby of "survival in extreme conditions". And when it comes to self-defense, I deeply believe that it would be an excellent tool there as well, although I have not yet had a case where I had to use it for this. But I'm sure it's big enough and robust enough to have enough deterrent power, because it just looks scary enough. The weight is 432 gramm, the length of the blade is 14.5 cm, full tang, the total length is 27.5 cm, the blade thickness is 4.7 mm. It has finger-guard, of course, although on the bottom only, not on the top. Very, very robust, a real monster! I don't think it needs to be better than that. Those who are not deterred by this will not be deterred by all kinds of daggers and double-edged knives. On the same time however, as it was told above, I can use this for any other purpose as well, not only for self-defense.
Long ago I "used" a military Puukko and a Buck 110 . As with any tool you have to know what you are doing. Today for legal reasons I Edc a Spyderco UKPK slip joint. I train with an old one. I don't feel "under knifed".
@@411Outdoors parents moved to asia for work, and i spent most my youth jumping between Thailand and Philippines, so got a chance to train in both silat and kali, so the pikal style knives fit me perfectly because of that and shivworks makes the most ergonomic ones i own
I just subbed because of the martial arts practicality content. I would prefer a blunt force weapon like a slap jack or even a kukri or cleaver design but if you were in very confined spaces like on the floor being mauled or etc, the gentleman of this channel is the one evidently giving you far better options and advice
at my age, 53yo after military, just the kobun and the hide out from Cold Steel but I'm not a defensive guy anymore, so I prefer a good camping knife 😂...if you put in your mind the need of self defense you are opening the chances of a situation where you have to defend yourself against someone...really, a knife fight is extremely dangerous, is erratic and fast and brutal...perhaps, running away as fast as you can is the choice...nice video and thanks.
I'd strongly disagree here. If you don't think about self defense (or self protection, the term I prefer), then you're irresponsible. Not thinking about and preparing for bad things does not prevent bad things from happening. Conversely, thinking about and preparing for bad things does not make them happen.
I really like my SOG Seal Pup in terms of fit, feel and usability. Single sided blade so carry should be easier to deal with, but I’m about to test out the Benchmade Adamas fixed, standard and mini folders this week so stoked to Try them out. Very helpful video
Suggestion survival equipment I use and swear on Smith's diamond coat sharpener with great case and lid convertible to extension handle. Fast sharpening. Work's giving razor edge.
Is it limitisation or specialisation? It would be interesting to ask the maker's reasoning/thoughts. I am glad you recommend the HRT. Inexpensive knives scare me.
Glad you mentioned legality of double edge. But I train with my puka style knife against my palm and pinky. I’ve stabbed stuff with heavy resistance. Obviously there is still a risk, but as with firearms and multiple participants one has to practice properly so you do not flag or reduce flagging your team mates. Nice good points.
Swiss army knife. Cousin got it for me. Buuut, it's basically impossible to use that normal grip or the blade would fold down, or no your hand would slide forward. I'd say just skip any foldable knives, it might have a good mechanism and lock but you never know what's gonna happen in an emergency. Karambits are kinda limited to reverse grip as well but, they're meant to be used with a certain martial art so those can still be used. Plus they're awesome for opening packages and picking fruits. So it's not really a problem about limitation but rather being forced to use something one way that it's not exactly specialized for.
Thanks for the video. I believe that many knives are made for comfort of carry more than self-defense. Most knives are never going to be used in self-defense, so optimizing the knife for self-defense becomes less of a factor in design of many knives. I think that's particularly true for the CRKT Sting. While the double-edged, dagger design makes this knife look like some kind of self-defense knife, I suspect that this knife has been used in very few fights. This knife seems to be a lightweight utility knife that can be carried easily without snagging on things. Putting a guard on this knife to optimize the fighting qualities of the knife would add quite a bit of bulk and a little bit of weight. A knife that currently doesn't have any protruding parts to dig into the skin would suddenly have protruding parts. I don't think most people using this knife would like the look or feel of this knife with the changes that you would recommend to optimize this knife for fighting. I agree with you that someone who wants to carry a knife for self-defense needs to consider whether there is positive protection to keep the hand from slipping forward and being cut on the blade. That factor is important even for some utilitarian uses. On the other hand, many knives can do everything that they ever need to do without that design feature. Companies design knives without that protection because they know that most users aren't planning to use their knives in self-defense. You mentioned that many places ban double-edged knives. While knives with a guard may not be specifically banned, an ambitious prosecutor might try to claim that carrying a knife with that guard to allow heavy thrusting into a person is evidence of intent to get into a knife fight. On the other hand, stabbing someone with a pocket knife that had secure grip but not guard couldn't be spun the same way. Much also depends on fighting style. One of the most famous fighting knives of all time is the Ghurka kukri. These knives have no protection to keep the hand from sliding forward, but the whole fighting style for these knives is based on slashing and chopping. One could thrust a little bit, and the odd angle of the blade might redirect the force and prevent one's hand from sliding onto the blade. However, the fighting style is not based on thrusting.
I agree with you.i carry an srk.theres just as many crappy knives as there are good ones,and most people I know buy cheap ones.all it took was a USMC kbars tip to break on me and I stopped buying knives that just aren't up to the job.i just buy cold steel I use fixed blades,they are so much more reliable and dont break or bend.
Good point that I've thought about myself. My EDC is the "Phrike" from Spartan Blades. It has good jimping on the back & a recessed cut for the index finger but, once the handle gets bloody, I don't think those features are enough to keep my fingers from sliding down the blade. I figure that after the second or third stab, I'll switch to a slashing attack. This will probably work against a single opponent but, against a mob a better designed blade is in order.
I carry a $10 folder on my belt daily. Its used everyday for cutting plastic wrapping and other things, usually sharpenedwith a flap disc on my grinder. Good for what I use it for,but for defense, its best left unopened and held in my hand so I don't brek my knuckles when punching.
I’ve pretty much moved away from modern knives, because they are at best multi purpose tools. Meaning, combat is an additional feature of the knife design instead of the focus. The most dangerous knife I carried was a dirk that had only a hole drilled through it for retention. That’s something I can make myself honestly. I think the TOPS Ranger dagger was a decent modern compromise, and definitely one of the best balanced knives for the money. But I’ve moved over to Bowie knives instead. Most bowie knives don’t look menacing, they come in various useful sizes, and the actual fighting designs from historical examples are very effective.
I luckily live in a fairly tame area within a 10 min drive of my house. So I've been lucky for 45+ years with judicious use of awareness and avoiding any sketchy situations. I'm admittedly not a martial artist or self defense guru. Personally not going to attempt to fight anyone with a knife unless I had training for it... and even then it would be a last resort. I've basically been told by a number of people who are knowledgeable on the subject that there are no "winners" in a knife fight. This is what I've heard from friends with backgrounds in military and medical fields. Someone hyped up on adrenaline and drugs isn't going to care you have a knife unless you have the training to hit them with what amounts to a kill shot...which is still damn difficult from what I've heard. That said... I've felt the majority of most knives that "claim" to be self defense weapons are just trying to sell more product. Many of them have no traction on the handle, no finger guard, or both. Glad to see vids like this at least warning people away from bad products.
I am under 130 and need advice on which pocket knife to buy on ebay for self defense. I don't have a wonderful background so it has to be five inches or less. I need this for wild animals such as panthers, gators, bears, wild dogs, boars, and stuff like that. I know if one comes at my two Chihuahua's and I we're completely screwed to hell. I have a few neighbors that don't like me and try to sick their dog on my Chihuahua's and need advice. I can't have mace, guns, or tazers.
Hi there! If you’re going to use a pocket knife for self-defense, you’re going to need something with a solid lock. The cold steel SR1 Lite series is really good. If you’ve gotta have something really small to check out the Coldsteel Kiradashi.
Good hand protection and cheap as hell to make sure that if you have to get rid of it fast you don't want to say goodbye to a $50 Knife. In my opinion the best self defence knife is one that has no shine to it, small enough to easily conceal and easy to get rid of in a hurry.
I like some CRKT products very much, and own three, two tomahawks (one smaller with a hammer pall and one based on an ancient design) and their "Ritual" folding knife. I tuned in to see if you didn't like the Ritual. It's similar to the Cold Steel Scimitar, but slimmer. Might not appeal to everybody.
I don't know. I carry a Spyderco folding blade that is half serrated. It has a thumb stop. I've cut down saplings with full serrated blades in the past. Using a hammerfist on blades is so incorrect. I have a long push dagger with no gaurds that would fully work.
I may be wrong but I don't think that those knives are meant to be held in the reverse or traditional grip (sabre grip). But rather a rapier or pinch grip. Similar to how you would hold a credit card. Given the shape of the handle and the bias towards the thrust. (EDIT) You can also see a depression where the thumb would go on the CRKT Sting just below the ricasso.
Those are the kind of knives I would use in a no-spin throw to disable or distract an attacker while bringing main knife into play. Like in a gunfight, using your pistol until you get to your rifle. Like the video, now a subscriber.
I understand your point however having worked in a prison I've seen inmates make shanks that had no handguard and no real Edge only a point but we're still quite deadly just ask the guy they stabbed with it😅
Over the years I have carried knives, the most important factor for me when choosing a self defense knife is the sheath. I bough a cool knife once, the knife was great but the sheath was garbage, the only way your gonna carry it is if it sticks out like a sore thumb. I finally settled with a 2 inch blade with a finger ring (not a karambit), it disappears on my clothing and deploys out the sheath cleanly, and for two years I have never looked for another knife.
I agree, i don't buy a survival/Utility knife unless it has at least a guard on the front part. On the back it doest matter to me, if it has a full cross guard fine, if it only has the guard in front like the SRK, that's fine too. That S&W and Cold Steel Counter Tac was a perfect example of a good cross guard for your hand, plus that Counter Tac blade shape leaves a gnarly Big puncture. Bigger than most of that size. There's videos on it. Good topic. 🙏🗡💥
I got a " ktc3 " from kansept nice 154cm hawk bill for self defense sharp wicked point but that handle even for medium size hands just ant enough to even get 3 fingers on it to secure it in hand safely.
I've been carrying around a Buck 119 on my belt for the past year. It has a decent hand guard on it, and I keep it razor sharp. All I need is a better sheath and some grip tape. But even then I feel confident I can use it to protect myself if it came down to it. I hope I never have to, though. Until then, I've used it from everything to cutting wires, rope, meal prep, etc. It's a handy knife. 👌
Honestly, a knife is the wrong tool for self defense to begin with...doesnt immidiately stop the attacker (therefore they are still a threat to you) and if they happen to be unarmed and die from your "self defense" stabbing, you now have a malice murder charge on your hands
I have some microtech OTF’s I never carry as they are extremely impractical as a defense weapon. A knife firstly should be %1000 reliable and silent and not hurt the user. That said I like playing around with my UTX-85 drop point
Jim Bowie himself may never have used a knife with a guard . He may have only have used a knife with the exception of the sandbar fight for common purpose .
I have collected different brands and styles of knives over the years. In the last few years I have collected brands such as Bark River, Benchmade, Smith and Wesson, CRKT, Case, Buck, etc.. Your videos are a breath of fresh air. Finally someone speaks on the appropriateness of the shape and design and not just the looks.
As much as everyone complains about the Kabar being a rat tang, when being used as what it's designed for the cross guard way over compensates for it's deficiencies.
I agree , the KaBar is an excellent fighter, not a very good prybar, like you may want in a good combat knife
Yeah but you could grab something like the cold steel leatherneck which has the same design, but also has a big beefy tang
The tang on it is actually about a half again larger than the portion you see on the bottom. It's notched down at the pommel where it slides into it and gets locked in with a pin. I've seen them being made and not many people know that. Yes, it isn't a full slab tang, but I wouldn't call it a rat tail either. Cheers.
That's because they're too ignorant to know the difference between a long-proven hidden tang and a flimsy rat tail.
Yeah honestly, the classic Kabar USMC knife is great for a Self Defense type of situation obviously. It's been trendy for years now to bash it for the small tang and what not, I mean yes a full tang blade is better for beating on logs, but for Defense and ending someone's life in War when it's down to that. It's a solid great choice. Especially the Kabar Extreme D2 one. I'm thinking about getting that at some point.
Very much agree with this. Even outside of self-defence, I get a little leery of knives that don't have a guard or great handle/grip retention. Having gone through and taught survival courses, these small preventative measures can go a long way to compensate for your carelessness when your fatigued, have sweaty hands or bloody hands from processing game, etc.....
A long time ago I was in a 3 gun club that held a knife match once a year. Mostly simple skill tests and cutting tasks, sometimes mixed into standard 3 gun stages. A member using a typical folder suffered a severe hand cut when his hand rode up as he stabbed a cardboard IPSC target: exactly the scenario you are talking about. He had a firm grip but impact, even on light cardboard, is powerful. Thanks for spreading the word on this.
Imagine a powerful grip, hard stab, while your band is bleeding or wet on top of that. I've see fights lost, and a life lost, due to a cut recieved while fighting to the hand, which made his hand slip up the knife causing a deep wound allowing for a death blow. Hopefully I will never be in a place to see that again, or an environment that life js lived in that way, but just in case, finger holes, hand guards, and handles must be tested and retested , drawing test and practiced over and over until you are secure in your own safety.
I would never carry a folder because I've developed numerous techniques for comfortably concealing fixed blades since I was teenager, but if I did it would have to be strictly OTF precisely for that reason. Injuries from knives failing to deploy fully under stress and closing on the users hand are very common and I've read about numerous incidents like that from street fights, and even stuff like people trying to slash other people's tires. Swing out designs are just objectively bad and I don't use them. The reason they're so common is because most states have archaic laws against "gravity knives", which effectively ban OTF knives even if they're not automatic. This stupid issue has singlehandedly ruined the folding knife industry.
That's why I had to change my instrument from a guitar to bass, once I ran out of usable pinky fingers 😞 Sweat is an amazing lubricant.
"EXCELLENT" That S&W HRT Has just been ordered!!!! Thank you Beyond!!!! Your saving lives man, and protecting them!! Much appreciated
My joy and privilege! Thank you!🙂
It does look like a nice knife. Cheers.
I have it i wouldn't use it for Bushcraft or anything more then when shtf it will save you but if I was you I'd keep that edge perfect till the time comes you wanna be able to put the guy down as fast as you cann stay safe
Great advice, also if you have time, do a video on why a straight edge barber's razor would be the worst blade to bring to a fight. I run into guys that watch old mob movies and think you can fight with an actual shaving razor, I mean sure, someone could but as a barber myself I hold one often and as knife enthusiast I can't even explain how many ways it could go wrong. Cringeworthy wrong.
People who think movie weapons are good idea are hilarious just because you can doesn't mean you should 😅
Well actually back in the day in Scotland we had the razor gangs. They are 100% a good weapon that causes so much damage great for slashing a mans face and for making your enemy bleed out. Some were slashed from ear to the groin. Very nasty. You guys have guns but we have knife fights
It's super obnoxious, every one of them refers to a straight razor as a "cut throat razor".
@@heathenshaunt681There is no problem fighting with a straight razor. If you train. I train with various slip joints. While not the ultimate, definitely doable.
I am a knife maker. I always have a guard on my fixed blades. The only knives I make. Plus I do not put a tang hole on the handle end … for lil cutsie hanging items than can get caught in machinery & drag your hand in with it. My handle shaped fit the hand as well - not flat slabs like on production knives. Great article btw.
What on earth would you put a knife near running machinery for?
Weird mentality for a "knife maker".
@@CadillacDriverMaybe this guy cleans the inside of his mower blade bay with his knives like a real smart guy. Maybe even with the mower still running.
Why would little cutsie items be hanging from the end of a knife that you are putting next to moving machinery? If you are sharpening/grinding it then I would think that anything hanging off the end would be removed before you do that? 🤔
@@CadillacDriver Farmer.
@@purpleturtle7477 no occupation or task requires a person to manually use a knife in operating machinery.
I was cleaning a squirrel with a pocket knife when I was younger and my bloody hand slid down the handle and sliced my finger open. I will always have hand/finger guards on my knives. Very good information sir.
The answer to your question is: NONE!! I'm glad someone finally did a video on this, because I've been telling people this for years to get a knife that u can get a secure grip on without your hand sliding down the handle on to the blade. Thank you sir for sharing a very sensable video.
When I was active duty in the Army with the 101st Airborne (3/187th Infantry), the personal blade I first carried was a Gerber Mark 1, which was basically the same design as the Smith & Wesson HRT/Cold Steel Counter Tac you show. It was a great fighting knife, but a pretty terrible utility knife. Turns out, I needed a utility knife far more than I needed a fighting knife for general use, so it got replaced reasonably quickly by a Gerber Gator. The Gator was a far more practical utility knife, without losing TOO much capability as a fighting blade.
Fast forward multiple years to nowadays, and I pretty much exclusively carry knives that are primarily folding utility blades, typically a Muela Navaja GL-10R, or a Boker Magnum Rescue. I do this with the understanding that there are inherent limitations in their application as a self-defense knife, and essentially must be always used in a reverse grip for such applications, but am willing to deal with that limitation in that particular niche application for the gained broad practicality of utility in my 99.999% case usage of my blades.
So, I guess it might be said that I don't even carry a knife "for self defense" per se, but I'm unwilling to dedicate the additional weight and bulk of carrying a dedicated fixed fighting blade for a 0.001% application, or 'pay' for the limitations inherent in true fighting blades when used in the utility role. But my knives are always a second or third fallback for me in terms of self-defense in any case, so I don't think I'm really missing out much in terms of practical limitations to usage with my blade choices.
But that's just my view, ymmv.
It is surprisingly difficult to retrieve a blade from live tissue so pulling is an important part the handles function as well.
Hand protection and retention almost fot together. Be it a guard or a karambit ring. You need a way to keep the knife in hand, and keep the hand off the blade.
Bare minimum requirements for defensive blade. And most other blades for that matter.
I’ve never carried any kind of knife for defense so this was interesting. I’ve carried a folding pocket knife as a tool since I was 10 yrs old.
Cold Steel's Drop Forged boot knife is the better alternative to the CRKT sting if you want full tang
I like the looks of a lot of the “Japanese” style knives, or at least they have Japanese names ( : , but many have no hand protection of any kind, even though they are obviously made for defense. A few CRKT’s come to mind. Love the look, but they stay in the drawer. We get cut sometimes when we’re just fiddling with or sharpening knives. Imagine using a forward thrust with the force necessary to save your life. On a different note, I am a leathercrafter and I hate to make sheaths for knives with guards! So many more options if there is no guard in the way haha. If I get a new knife for myself with a guard, it stays in the kydex ( :
I recently purchased a Cold Steel OSS. Now living in England there is no way I can carry the thing, so it's my bedside blade. I also bought it because it is a sleek beautiful looking thing to my eyes.
as to your question, what knife that I got worries me, is the cold steel espada xl, a really big folding knife.
It has a lot looking for it, but it seems to me that one little mistake deploying this knife and you can easily cut your fingers off.
Great video. A guard is a must in for certain situations. Back in the 80’s everyone carried Buck 110’s on their belts in school. Someone sliced my brothers tire in high school and there was blood everywhere. We figured his hand must have slipped down the blade when whoever did it stabbed the 36” off-road tire sidewall. The next day a guy who my brother had fought a month prior had a bandaged up hand in school. Coincidence? My brother didn’t think so and gave him another tail whooping on top of that messed up hand. 😉
He obviously didn't know how to use a 110. They can puncture tires fabulously 😁
I was thinking about this S&W for a long time now, I think I'm finally convinced, thanks !
Glad I could help!
I never thought of this but it sure makes sense. Thank you. I subscribed to learn more. The knife I just bought that now I’d never consider for self-defense is the Mira Garberg. I did not buy it for self-defense. But it’s the last knife I bought.
Very good information... I just got into knife making. And I'm finding some problems... I've made a couple very nice looking blades with exotic wooden scales and handles. But when I polish them so they look great... they're almost too slick to use . Especially if you're hands are wet ... it's hard to beat rubberized handles.
Hobbyist knife maker here as well. Polished handles look really nice, but I don't like how they feel. I prefer a "grippier" finish.
I've even taken a few purchased knives with polished handles, sanded them down and textured them.
I haven't used any rubber material, but "Terotuf" material feels phenomenal. (It's not the fanciest looking though)
@@LastBastian I'll have to try it... I've done one skinnier handle with nice wood and then wrapped it with paracoard and it worked good but colors didn't match. I want to find the balance between beauty and function. I know it's possible. And have used some like that.
@@donscottvansandt4139 For comfort it's hard to beat. Has a cloth like look and feel, and actually gets slightly more grippy when wet.
It's also non toxic to sand, unlike G10 or Micarta, etc...
@@LastBastian nice! Gotta get me some.
Love your videos, man! No BS, just presenting the facts. I'm so glad I stumbled upon your channel. Cheers!
Thanks my friend!🙂
Missing a pinky finger reduces your overall hand grip strength by 75%. Found this out the hard way. Guards are a must on blades in which any sort of thrusting could be utilized.
You can compensate. My grip strength is above average, despite my moment of stupidity as a kid.
I have two Stings and you are right, forward grip is not easy, I had to exercise a lot to learn using it like that. Yet, those prpoved extremely useful when I needed to crawl up a tree and used Sting as a step - it holds my 220lbs with no issue, does not bend or give even slightly. I have got SW too, it is great overall and, probably is suitable for fighting, but I would never dare to use it as a ladder step.
Facts!!! Great insight and advice. No guard on either fixed blade or folding knives is a non-starter. The Schrade SCHA9 provided the only lesson ever needed. Thanks 187/10 🙏
👍👍🙏
This was a really good point, def reconsidering a lot of my options now
I’ve got another video coming out on this subject this week it’s kind of a part two to this
scythe grip with a thumb cap grip. i prefer point down, edge in grip. this makes the handguard question irrelevant, and makes lock strength in a folder less important.
These are high value advices! The truth must be told and shown, thanks!
Great video as always ❤👍🏻👍🏻✌🏻
P.S. try skateboard tape on the handles when having no guard..aw hell on any knife that's meant to be used for real.
Cold Steel's Spike series has decent hand protection and inexpensive too.
Use to work at a fish plant in my youth when the fresh cod would arrive we would gut them and another would take heads off and debone, I was really good and fast to cut cod tongues at 50 cents a pound and standing in fish cuts all day 😂 A buddy from a short distance pitched me a cod tongue too fast before I was ready so when I tried to catch it in the blink of an eye and forgot about the very sharp knife in my right hand, well in went in my left dead centre, the only thing that saved my knife from going through was my gloves were soaked and slippery from fish slime causing my right hand to react in more kindness and slide down the blade 😂 one needs a guard so you can take it back out if need be or make sure there’s a hole in handle to tie a rope to and pull hard , I’m living proof 😢If one wants to protect his goods in the house and shed just put Vaseline on the door knobs , one lady put it on the bedroom door knob so the kids couldn’t get in 😂
Great idea haha!
Great advice. A guard is one of the first things I look for on a combat knife. The blade is important, of course, but do not ignore the importance of the guard, grip handle, and sheath that you deploy the knife from. In my truck I keep a TOPS Operator 7 and a TOPS Sky Marshall Tanto. Both fixed blades that vary in size and ability to conceal. Both are chunky monkeys that deliver impact. It's also good to keep pepper spray and a strong flashlight so you can blind your adversary.
Smart! Good to see safety addresses safety so explicitly
First honest knife evalutaion I've ever seen. Well done sir!
Thank you!
As a Cold Steel fan, I make sure that I buy a knife with some sort of guard for protection. Whether it is a fixed blade, food prep, machete, or even a folder, knowing that your hand won't slip brings peace of mind when doing a task. Thank you for this informative video! This needed to be said!
I have a Buck Pathfinder, 5" fixed blade. I had a boot repair man make me a leather horizontal sheath. He got it right. The blade will not fall out. It is not big and bulky. I live on a ranch, so it also serves as a work tool. Decent steel and keeps an edge OK.
Agreed. I have that very same Smith you showed, as well as a Gerber MK II.
Both are combat (tactical) blades, the Smith is very good, the MKII is one of the BEST I’ve ever seen!
I have a CRKT Obake that I've carried for years and I had never thought about the danger that you describe. Think I need to retire it.
It’s such a cool knife but it’s limited to ice pick grip with a thumb brace
You don't want to be in a knife fight. One man goes to the hospital. The other man goes to a morgue. Carry a pistol and be proficient using it. I carry a large Cold Steel Ti-Lite.
A cold steel wasp is one of the knives I would say not to buy. I bought one and gave it away. The kabar ek44 is a much better knife after you replace the sheath.
Few people understand the nasty business that's involved in defending yourself with a knife. They're unfamiliar with just how much blood is involved and how slippery that blood can make a knife handle. Oftentimes police find stabbing assailants getting stitches at the same hospital their victim is in because their hand slid down the guardless blade. As for tactical folders that are what I definitely carry daily, flippers are great because they make a guard along the bottom of the blade that I think in most cases would stop your fingers from sliding down the blade. Great advice!🇺🇸
Thanks bro!
i have butcher and kitchen knives for slicing and daggers for well poking things only and a axe or hawk for battoning or splitting wood
Great video and all points you make are valid. For me, my early 80s vintage Gerber Guardian comes to mind. I never had a bad experience with it, but it was pointed out to me that if hands were wet, they’d slide forward on that aluminum handle. I traded a knock-off of a Mark I for it straight up so it’s not like I’d be out any money to let it sit on the shelf, though. Maybe next up was my Colt Steel Tri Lire folder. It does at least have a thumb stud that sort of might function as a guard. I bought it because it was slim and I wanted something that was easier to carry. Don’t carry it anymore, however. Not a fan of filet of finger.
what would u recomend to mount on a tactical vest as a "oh shit" back up?
My CRKT HZ6 also lacks a guard, but the handle on this is so grippy it's almost painful. I would absolutely trust my life on it.
That thing is a Japanese beast for sure. I love the James Williams blades.
have you heard of the series of books, 100 Deadly Skills, by retired Navy Seal Clint Emerson? I believe they would make for a great video/videos, and to see your opinion on them.
That Smith and Wesson HRT is what I carry in my boot...I'm happy that you approve. How do you feel about the KaBar made "Spartan Harsey Fighter"...? The Buck Tops Nighthawk 650 and the 655..?
I see Microtech ultratech and Benchmade Infidels promoted as fighting knives but I have the same feeling about the grip. I own both because they where "grail" knives for me but I'd be hesitant about fighting with them.
Finally, somebody said it these knives are dangerous and I might have a couple laying around. I prefer I hand guard a double hand guard you are absolutely correct and thank you for saying it.
Good advice! Any knife I would consider for a defensive situation would have a good guard on it. Most EDC knives would not be ideal for self defense. Fixed blades are superior in this regard. One can make do with anything, but using the right tool for the right job comes to mind...🤔
Crkt has a design by James Williams who is very well respected. That design is called the hz6 I think. I don't like it because its a tanto with no guard. The grip is very aggressive but in my experience when you have a blade with a very aggressive handle like that you leave yourself open to training scars. I challenge someone to stab into something with some type of resistance. That super sharp edged g10 is going to bite you and you'll develop an aversion to it. Design should not dictate use. Use should dictate design. What good is a fighting knife that I can only use gloved and in reverse grip? It's good to see someone else who actually trains share the same opinion.
Thanks my friend and very well said!
Jeez you sound like a pussy. Get some fuckin man hands for gods sake.
I as well do prefer guards. But also I understand that some people avoid them, especially in dmall knives, because of the risk of snagging the guard through clothes and fabric. The hole in the sting one is designed for Your thumb, so the blade sits well, without the risk of cutting Youself, but that greatly diminishes it's clinch knife abilities. In my opinion, kraton guards and handles are in between, giving You both of the advantages. I've recently posted a short video about that with Marauder's bowie.
I like your vids and the way you deliver the information. Great job all the time. Old Marine 64-70 👍🏻🇺🇸
Thanks my fried!🙂
That's good advice for us and information that can benefit the companies in the future.
SOG pentagon fx Covert is like one of the best out there that i could find. I actually looked closely at the leatherneck before i found the sog.
you make extremely good points. The knife I cannot truly understand is the karambit. It seems like the design limits the use
Ty bro this is excellent information you neva know when life will throw a situation like this at you and you’re not prepared
I don't have a single knife only and specifically for self-defense. On the other hand, I have an APO-1S type survival knife ("Survival Lilly" design, made of austenitic steel), I am very satisfied with it, this knife is good for almost everything that can happen in bushcraft and in the hobby of "survival in extreme conditions". And when it comes to self-defense, I deeply believe that it would be an excellent tool there as well, although I have not yet had a case where I had to use it for this. But I'm sure it's big enough and robust enough to have enough deterrent power, because it just looks scary enough. The weight is 432 gramm, the length of the blade is 14.5 cm, full tang, the total length is 27.5 cm, the blade thickness is 4.7 mm. It has finger-guard, of course, although on the bottom only, not on the top. Very, very robust, a real monster! I don't think it needs to be better than that. Those who are not deterred by this will not be deterred by all kinds of daggers and double-edged knives. On the same time however, as it was told above, I can use this for any other purpose as well, not only for self-defense.
Long ago I "used" a military Puukko and a Buck 110 . As with any tool you have to know what you are doing.
Today for legal reasons I Edc a Spyderco UKPK slip joint. I train with an old one. I don't feel "under knifed".
That is about as honest and logical as it gets folks.
my go to self defence knife is the shivworks disciple, with a clinch pick as a back up
Nice picks!
@@411Outdoors parents moved to asia for work, and i spent most my youth jumping between Thailand and Philippines, so got a chance to train in both silat and kali, so the pikal style knives fit me perfectly because of that and shivworks makes the most ergonomic ones i own
I just subbed because of the martial arts practicality content.
I would prefer a blunt force weapon like a slap jack or even a kukri or cleaver design but if you were in very confined spaces like on the floor being mauled or etc, the gentleman of this channel is the one evidently giving you far better options and advice
at my age, 53yo after military, just the kobun and the hide out from Cold Steel but I'm not a defensive guy anymore, so I prefer a good camping knife 😂...if you put in your mind the need of self defense you are opening the chances of a situation where you have to defend yourself against someone...really, a knife fight is extremely dangerous, is erratic and fast and brutal...perhaps, running away as fast as you can is the choice...nice video and thanks.
Thank you as well! Definitely wanna avoid a knife fight if all possible💯👍👍
I'd strongly disagree here. If you don't think about self defense (or self protection, the term I prefer), then you're irresponsible. Not thinking about and preparing for bad things does not prevent bad things from happening. Conversely, thinking about and preparing for bad things does not make them happen.
I really like my SOG Seal Pup in terms of fit, feel and usability. Single sided blade so carry should be easier to deal with, but I’m about to test out the Benchmade Adamas fixed, standard and mini folders this week so stoked to
Try them out. Very helpful video
Thank you!
Suggestion survival equipment I use and swear on Smith's diamond coat sharpener with great case and lid convertible to extension handle.
Fast sharpening.
Work's giving razor edge.
Is it limitisation or specialisation? It would be interesting to ask the maker's reasoning/thoughts. I am glad you recommend the HRT. Inexpensive knives scare me.
Glad you mentioned legality of double edge. But I train with my puka style knife against my palm and pinky. I’ve stabbed stuff with heavy resistance. Obviously there is still a risk, but as with firearms and multiple participants one has to practice properly so you do not flag or reduce flagging your team mates. Nice good points.
I have two security knives. A cold steel Recon tanto and a condor plan A.
Swiss army knife.
Cousin got it for me. Buuut, it's basically impossible to use that normal grip or the blade would fold down, or no your hand would slide forward.
I'd say just skip any foldable knives, it might have a good mechanism and lock but you never know what's gonna happen in an emergency.
Karambits are kinda limited to reverse grip as well but, they're meant to be used with a certain martial art so those can still be used. Plus they're awesome for opening packages and picking fruits.
So it's not really a problem about limitation but rather being forced to use something one way that it's not exactly specialized for.
Thanks for the video.
I believe that many knives are made for comfort of carry more than self-defense. Most knives are never going to be used in self-defense, so optimizing the knife for self-defense becomes less of a factor in design of many knives.
I think that's particularly true for the CRKT Sting. While the double-edged, dagger design makes this knife look like some kind of self-defense knife, I suspect that this knife has been used in very few fights. This knife seems to be a lightweight utility knife that can be carried easily without snagging on things. Putting a guard on this knife to optimize the fighting qualities of the knife would add quite a bit of bulk and a little bit of weight. A knife that currently doesn't have any protruding parts to dig into the skin would suddenly have protruding parts. I don't think most people using this knife would like the look or feel of this knife with the changes that you would recommend to optimize this knife for fighting.
I agree with you that someone who wants to carry a knife for self-defense needs to consider whether there is positive protection to keep the hand from slipping forward and being cut on the blade. That factor is important even for some utilitarian uses. On the other hand, many knives can do everything that they ever need to do without that design feature. Companies design knives without that protection because they know that most users aren't planning to use their knives in self-defense.
You mentioned that many places ban double-edged knives. While knives with a guard may not be specifically banned, an ambitious prosecutor might try to claim that carrying a knife with that guard to allow heavy thrusting into a person is evidence of intent to get into a knife fight. On the other hand, stabbing someone with a pocket knife that had secure grip but not guard couldn't be spun the same way.
Much also depends on fighting style. One of the most famous fighting knives of all time is the Ghurka kukri. These knives have no protection to keep the hand from sliding forward, but the whole fighting style for these knives is based on slashing and chopping. One could thrust a little bit, and the odd angle of the blade might redirect the force and prevent one's hand from sliding onto the blade. However, the fighting style is not based on thrusting.
I agree with you.i carry an srk.theres just as many crappy knives as there are good ones,and most people I know buy cheap ones.all it took was a USMC kbars tip to break on me and I stopped buying knives that just aren't up to the job.i just buy cold steel I use fixed blades,they are so much more reliable and dont break or bend.
Good point that I've thought about myself. My EDC is the "Phrike" from Spartan Blades. It has good jimping on the back & a recessed cut for the index finger but, once the handle gets bloody, I don't think those features are enough to keep my fingers from sliding down the blade. I figure that after the second or third stab, I'll switch to a slashing attack. This will probably work against a single opponent but, against a mob a better designed blade is in order.
I carry a $10 folder on my belt daily. Its used everyday for cutting plastic wrapping and other things, usually sharpenedwith a flap disc on my grinder. Good for what I use it for,but for defense, its best left unopened and held in my hand so I don't brek my knuckles when punching.
man this comment made me cringe so hard as a knife nut
Vids like this are why I’m subscribed!
I’ve pretty much moved away from modern knives, because they are at best multi purpose tools. Meaning, combat is an additional feature of the knife design instead of the focus. The most dangerous knife I carried was a dirk that had only a hole drilled through it for retention. That’s something I can make myself honestly. I think the TOPS Ranger dagger was a decent modern compromise, and definitely one of the best balanced knives for the money. But I’ve moved over to Bowie knives instead. Most bowie knives don’t look menacing, they come in various useful sizes, and the actual fighting designs from historical examples are very effective.
I luckily live in a fairly tame area within a 10 min drive of my house. So I've been lucky for 45+ years with judicious use of awareness and avoiding any sketchy situations.
I'm admittedly not a martial artist or self defense guru. Personally not going to attempt to fight anyone with a knife unless I had training for it... and even then it would be a last resort. I've basically been told by a number of people who are knowledgeable on the subject that there are no "winners" in a knife fight. This is what I've heard from friends with backgrounds in military and medical fields.
Someone hyped up on adrenaline and drugs isn't going to care you have a knife unless you have the training to hit them with what amounts to a kill shot...which is still damn difficult from what I've heard.
That said... I've felt the majority of most knives that "claim" to be self defense weapons are just trying to sell more product. Many of them have no traction on the handle, no finger guard, or both.
Glad to see vids like this at least warning people away from bad products.
I am under 130 and need advice on which pocket knife to buy on ebay for self defense. I don't have a wonderful background so it has to be five inches or less. I need this for wild animals such as panthers, gators, bears, wild dogs, boars, and stuff like that. I know if one comes at my two Chihuahua's and I we're completely screwed to hell. I have a few neighbors that don't like me and try to sick their dog on my Chihuahua's and need advice. I can't have mace, guns, or tazers.
Hi there! If you’re going to use a pocket knife for self-defense, you’re going to need something with a solid lock. The cold steel SR1 Lite series is really good. If you’ve gotta have something really small to check out the Coldsteel Kiradashi.
He's got a point but, what about the Scottish sgian dubh knife? Those were often used as fighting knives and had no cross guard.
I've looked at the Shrill a few times over the years. I always decide against it because it just doesn't jive with carry. Maybe just for fun some day.
Good hand protection and cheap as hell to make sure that if you have to get rid of it fast you don't want to say goodbye to a $50 Knife.
In my opinion the best self defence knife is one that has no shine to it, small enough to easily conceal and easy to get rid of in a hurry.
I like some CRKT products very much, and own three, two tomahawks (one smaller with a hammer pall and one based on an ancient design) and their "Ritual" folding knife. I tuned in to see if you didn't like the Ritual. It's similar to the Cold Steel Scimitar, but slimmer. Might not appeal to everybody.
I don't know. I carry a Spyderco folding blade that is half serrated. It has a thumb stop. I've cut down saplings with full serrated blades in the past. Using a hammerfist on blades is so incorrect. I have a long push dagger with no gaurds that would fully work.
I may be wrong but I don't think that those knives are meant to be held in the reverse or traditional grip (sabre grip). But rather a rapier or pinch grip. Similar to how you would hold a credit card. Given the shape of the handle and the bias towards the thrust. (EDIT) You can also see a depression where the thumb would go on the CRKT Sting just below the ricasso.
Definitely ice pick blades👍
Ngl I was really wanting to get the shrill prior to this video. But if I were to get it it certainly wouldn't be my go to self defense blade.
Real talk!!! Benchmade fact . Not safe brother. Great content.
Those are the kind of knives I would use in a no-spin throw to disable or distract an attacker while bringing main knife into play. Like in a gunfight, using your pistol until you get to your rifle.
Like the video, now a subscriber.
Awesome my friend 🙂
I understand your point however having worked in a prison I've seen inmates make shanks that had no handguard and no real Edge only a point but we're still quite deadly just ask the guy they stabbed with it😅
I'm such a believer in fingerguards that I fabricated fingerguards for all my old hickory knives what a difference they also look cool with them on
Sgian dhu and pukko are two classic self defense knives that lack handguards.
Over the years I have carried knives, the most important factor for me when choosing a self defense knife is the sheath.
I bough a cool knife once, the knife was great but the sheath was garbage, the only way your gonna carry it is if it sticks out like a sore thumb.
I finally settled with a 2 inch blade with a finger ring (not a karambit), it disappears on my clothing and deploys out the sheath cleanly, and for two years I have never looked for another knife.
In this regard - of a self defense knife, what do you think of the SOG Pillar? Because its handle is a bit slippery and it has no guard.
The one I’m looking at seems to have a little bit of a guard. Are there different versions?
@@411Outdoors No, there are not. Only one version - the one which appears on all TH-cam videos.
I’ve been considering the cold steel sr1 lite for edc, but am also wondering how well it would do in self defense? Any thoughts are welcome.
It’s a VERY strong folder tested and approved 👍
New subscriber- thanks for the great advice.
I agree, i don't buy a survival/Utility knife unless it has at least a guard on the front part. On the back it doest matter to me, if it has a full cross guard fine, if it only has the guard in front like the SRK, that's fine too. That S&W and Cold Steel Counter Tac was a perfect example of a good cross guard for your hand, plus that Counter Tac blade shape leaves a gnarly Big puncture. Bigger than most of that size. There's videos on it. Good topic. 🙏🗡💥
I got a " ktc3 " from kansept nice 154cm hawk bill for self defense sharp wicked point but that handle even for medium size hands just ant enough to even get 3 fingers on it to secure it in hand safely.
I've been carrying around a Buck 119 on my belt for the past year. It has a decent hand guard on it, and I keep it razor sharp. All I need is a better sheath and some grip tape.
But even then I feel confident I can use it to protect myself if it came down to it. I hope I never have to, though.
Until then, I've used it from everything to cutting wires, rope, meal prep, etc. It's a handy knife. 👌
Yooo, bro nice video! I will glad to hear your opinion about karambits and self defense with them
💯🙂👍👍
Honestly, a knife is the wrong tool for self defense to begin with...doesnt immidiately stop the attacker (therefore they are still a threat to you) and if they happen to be unarmed and die from your "self defense" stabbing, you now have a malice murder charge on your hands
Knives are tricky. In my training system I focus on Shock zones. Definitely a lot of trouble if unarmed for sure!
I have some microtech OTF’s I never carry as they are extremely impractical as a defense weapon. A knife firstly should be %1000 reliable and silent and not hurt the user. That said I like playing around with my UTX-85 drop point
I would love to know what you think about crkt Clever Girl and crkt Du Hoc? They are 2 of my favorites in my collection. Next to my Ka-bar lol
Jim Bowie himself may never have used a knife with a guard . He may have only have used a knife with the exception of the sandbar fight for common purpose .
If somebody’s good with finding other ways to brace themselves they should be ok👍