WE NEED MORE!! 😭💕 The Apothecary Diaries - 1x24 - Jinshi and Maomao

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 ก.ย. 2024

ความคิดเห็น • 79

  • @TheReactPack
    @TheReactPack  26 วันที่ผ่านมา +52

    Bocchi the Rock! is next and all episodes (1-12) are available on our Patreon!

    • @jaredsteele7932
      @jaredsteele7932 26 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      you girls would really love ascendance of a book worm.

    •  26 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      Frieren, Apothecary, Kaiju and Bocchi. It’s hit after hit!!!
      (Also Bocchi shares a director with Frieren apparently)

    • @DesertHomesteader
      @DesertHomesteader 26 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Cool. Bocchi is a pretty good series.

  • @syd.a.m
    @syd.a.m 2 หลายเดือนก่อน +139

    When Meimei said "Big Sis, you should have been honest from the start," she was referring to Fengxian, not the old madam. Remember, the old madam has always been called either the old madam or granny. Meimei was Fengxian's assistant in the past, so she looks up to Fengxian as a big sister. Regarding them keeping Fengxian a secret, you need to look at it from the Verdigris House's point of view. From their perspective, Lakan is a man who seduced and got a courtesan pregnant and then abandoned her for three years. They don't know that it was Fengxian who deliberately conspired to get pregnant, nor do they know the reason Lakan went missing. From their point of view, Lakan was a scoundrel who ruined a high-ranking courtesan, and almost ruined the House itself, and is hanging around to harass them. They can't completely get rid of him because he's too high up, so they tolerate him. The old madam keeping Fengxian hidden is her way of protecting her from the man who "ruined" her. Also, the old madam doesn't set the courtesans' value, the market does. She doesn't own the Verdigris House, she's just the proprietor. It's shitty, of course, but that's the society they live in.
    Meimei said Fengxian "should have been honest from the start" because she realized that Fengxian had deliberately gotten herself pregnant so that Lakan would be able to buy her out. And since Meimei was the only one interacting with Lakan in the Verdigris House, she also realized that Lakan loved Fengxian, contrary to what everyone else thought. No one else (other than Maomao, who also figured it out) knows or realizes that Lakan and Fengxian loved each other. She realizes that had Fengxian been honest from the start about how she felt about Lakan rather than trying to entrap him by getting pregnant, then the whole tragedy could have been averted. Meimei was also crying because she had fallen in love with Lakan (look back on the statements she'd made about Lakan and her interactions with him), and while she was hoping that he would buy her out, she realizes that Lakan loved Fengxian and not her.
    You've probably realized by now that Maomao and her family are pretty neurodivergent. So if you're expecting the typical female romantic lead character type of reactions from her, you'll be disappointed. But that's what makes her so great. Not often you see what's basically a typical male romantic lead character try to pursue an aro-ace female romantic lead character. It makes for a fresh and interesting dynamic.

    • @argetlam05
      @argetlam05 26 วันที่ผ่านมา +3

      This arc is a huge highlight and also a lowlight. Ultimately it’s a great story with complicated interactions but the whole thing relies on miscommunication like a lame high school drama or romance story. I still really like this arc, just wish it didn’t rely on a long drawn out multi-year miscommunication.

    • @kk_sj3635
      @kk_sj3635 26 วันที่ผ่านมา +18

      @@argetlam05the original comment literally just said Maomao’s parents are both neurodivergent, and you come up with “lame highschool drama” 😅

    • @Bayard1503
      @Bayard1503 26 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@argetlam05 I mean the entire arc shows you that while you might think it's a lot of miscommunication actually it's not. Sure, there was the original one with the pregnancy, but after that, it's not about people not talking, it's about logical decisions. Maomao simply doesn't want him as a father, the old lady doesn't need his money so she can afford to keep Feingxian and treat her herself (she's probably her daughter) and on and on...

    • @nolan4339
      @nolan4339 26 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      I took that comment to mean Fengxian refused to meet him and not wanting him to know she was alive, and now is accepting him only after her mind has slipped

    • @Xagzan
      @Xagzan 26 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      The next question then is, during all his visits, why didn't Lakan ever explain why he was gone?

  • @ehellstrom7127
    @ehellstrom7127 2 หลายเดือนก่อน +91

    The Apothecary Diaries is based off of a light novel series written by Natsu Hyuuga. The manga adaptation of the light novel is drawn by Nekokurage. So, the tax evasion will likely not impact any future seasons. By the way, the entire first season was adapted from 2 novels. There are currently 15 novels in print, only 11 with an english translation. If they anime adaptation continues to be this excellent (hardly anything was changed from the novels), we are looking at many more seasons to come!

    • @alexakuto
      @alexakuto 26 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Is it true that Apothecary Diaries LN has a darker version? Or is it the WN?

    • @ehellstrom7127
      @ehellstrom7127 26 วันที่ผ่านมา +3

      @@alexakuto Haven't read the WN. The anime is very close to the LNs though. So if there is a darker version, it would be the WN.

    • @sephorapaulazammit4925
      @sephorapaulazammit4925 23 วันที่ผ่านมา

      ​@alexakuto the darker version could be Gx manga due its a shouldn't style. It's bloody for sure lol the apothecary diaries has a Web novel ,light novel is the Web novel as book then 2 manga version Gangan drawn by neko sensei( the one with tax problrm) snf Gx drawn by Kurata-sensei ( she just had a son and she is back)

  • @percyprune
    @percyprune 26 วันที่ผ่านมา +41

    If you watch the previous episode closely, you'll realise that the old lady told Lakan that Fenxian was 'gone', when he tried to find her. So he assumed she was lost or dead. It never occurred to him that she had been secreted away in the Verdigris House.

    • @Timmycoo
      @Timmycoo 24 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Yeah not watching episodes back-to-back kinda misses important points. I use that as justification for my unhealthy binging.

  • @SangoSama08
    @SangoSama08 26 วันที่ผ่านมา +17

    They showed you that Lakan was told that Fengxian was "gone". He also knew that Maomao was still at the Verdigris House. As far as Fengxian goes, the other courtesans knew Fenxian had cursed him. I mean, she chopped off her finger so it wasn't a secret. There's no telling what Fenxian might have said to them but it was probably a lot of hateful words. It's why the old lady kept him away from her, and why Meimei cried seeing how happy she was when she saw Lakan. They thought she hated him.

  • @Jason8012
    @Jason8012 2 หลายเดือนก่อน +21

    Season 2 has been confirmed to release in 2025 so we won't have to wait too long!

  • @ivansegulja2540
    @ivansegulja2540 2 หลายเดือนก่อน +17

    Thank you for laughing and crying with us this season. May we have many more of those next season too! (Especially giggles)

    • @TheReactPack
      @TheReactPack  2 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

      We’re excited for next season!!! -Morgan

  • @kimexostance
    @kimexostance 26 วันที่ผ่านมา +12

    There is a personal reason the old madam kept Fengxian hidden, but I think it's still a spoiler for anime-only viewers, haha...
    Also re: Maomao's finger, the anime did it very subtly (Also harder to tell due to the art style), but Maomao has stared at her somewhat deformed pinky and reminisced upon it in previous scenes!

  • @Bayard1503
    @Bayard1503 26 วันที่ผ่านมา +6

    What maybe you missed is that Mei Mei is actually completely in love with Lakan, I mean he's smart, funny, kind... and she knows he was innocent of what happened with the mother. Maomao knows this and she would have been fine it Lakan actually bought her. The old lady is probably just protecting her supposed daughter... she was also a great courtesan when she was young.

  • @Le7emeChat
    @Le7emeChat 26 วันที่ผ่านมา +4

    Last episode the Madam told him "she is gone"

  • @luvBB4lyf
    @luvBB4lyf 26 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    Such an amazing story!!!!!!!! And what a beautiful way to end the season too. Lakan and Fengxian’s reunion made me so emotional and so did Mao Mao’s dance sending off her mom 🥹 it’s also tragic that Mao Mao just doesn’t have that parental attachment for either of her bio parents (it’s understandable why) because it would’ve been so cute to see them together as a family even once, but alas… it is bittersweet. I bought all the manga and light novels after this season because I couldn’t wait lmao can’t wait for season 2!

  • @reverance_pavane
    @reverance_pavane 26 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    And don't forget that Lakan was hating himself over those last seventeen years, Thinking he had unwittingly caused her death. And because of his disability he felt he had no friends. After all, he couldn't recognise anyone or even read their expressions. He only recognises people from their context/environment (probably the real reason why Maomao thinks he is lazy and sends others to do the investigation). And he already had no family.
    And the Madame hated him because she believes he intentionally ruined Fengxian. But probably not just for the reason you think.

  • @Masterfrogg
    @Masterfrogg 26 วันที่ผ่านมา +4

    I love how the only reasons every viewer hates Lakan (myself too, I'm not pretending otherwise) is because of the tone of the music whenever we got to see him and a few reactions of the people around him DESPITE THE FACT that Maomao's adoptive father, and by extension the entire show, is constantly trying to preach not to jump to conclusions based on circumstantial or incomplete facts.
    Like Lakan is probably not the best person anyway but he's clearly nowhere near the bad guy everyone assumes he is.

  • @ThePorpoisepower
    @ThePorpoisepower 26 วันที่ผ่านมา +4

    Frog! Frog! Frog!

  • @Timmycoo
    @Timmycoo 24 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    Lakan recognizing Maomao's face, realizing she likes the same puzzles she does but he doesn't do and sets her up is kind of a funny dad thing. He's almost a proud dad in a weird way lol. I always liked his char and hated the negative connotations because they were SUPER easily dissuaded if you thought logically. But the romance with Fengxian and he sees her face, so great. Only for us to see a casket.. Hence his leave. Don't think the girls talked about why he took 7 days and 7 nights and left? Did they not understand or see?

  • @karonji_mitsuri04
    @karonji_mitsuri04 20 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา

    So the thing with the old lady is not hard to understand if we put everything together: Fengixian lost her status to zero (the people define the status of the courtersan, if shes getting more attention or less, depends on the people, the granny just ajusts the prices), when people found out fengxian was pregnant and wouldnt be able to get costumers, she lost everything, but after birth, she would still have to work because the courtesans have to pay for they're being in the brothel (clothes, food), but since Fengxian lost her status and in that time the brothel wasnt as luxury as now, they would have her to take any costumer (maomao said that now they are more strict with the mans who can have the courtersans so they wont get ill) and thats when Fengxian got syphillis. Fengxian and the people on the brothel thought Lakan had abandoned her for three years, when he came back, granny said "she's gone" because she thought Lakan would only hurt her more to that point, its not diferent from what happend in previous episodes when that hole brothel was trying to kill the shitty man who caused the death of one of their coutersans and made many other suffer. The brothel is like a big familly in a way (at least some people in them) and when someone do something really bad to one of them, specially in cases like this two that also make them loose money, this person its just fucked, see how even the other people in grannys's brothel doesnt like Lakan, and granny also wanted to shield Maomao from that man who was seeing as evil to them. Also there is a teory that granny is actually Fengcian's mother and thats why she was so protective and let her stay at the brothel even after beeing so sick and even having Luomen to make medicines that helped her with the pain

  • @Okkotsu86275
    @Okkotsu86275 2 หลายเดือนก่อน +11

    What a lovely season finale. The scene with Maomao dancing was so beautifully animated. It was a joy watching this series with you ladies, and I can't wait to do it again for S2.

    • @TheReactPack
      @TheReactPack  2 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

      Such a beautiful scene to end the season on :,) 🤍 - Dani

    • @Okkotsu86275
      @Okkotsu86275 2 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@TheReactPack Most Certainly.

  • @Nuzso121
    @Nuzso121 2 หลายเดือนก่อน +17

    the old woman still took care of her, which normally in that setting they would throw her away. So in that sense as a madam of a brothel she is kind but yeah still weird she didnt led him buy her earlier.

    • @benjabierubino1982
      @benjabierubino1982 26 วันที่ผ่านมา

      It makes sense if you think about the possibility that the Madam might be Fengxian's mother

    • @clowtears1898
      @clowtears1898 26 วันที่ผ่านมา +12

      It's not weird to keep your dying daughter away from the main cause

    • @rafaelrivera9346
      @rafaelrivera9346 26 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@clowtears1898That is my wife’s theory that Momo’s mom is the old lady’s daughter as the only reason she didn’t kicked her out of the house after she got pregnant or gave birth. That makes momo her granddaughter. That would also make sense with why Momo is keep around the house and and her adopted father who probably was the birth doctor of Momo. I bet that old lady force the uncle to raise Momo as like “you need to do that” All of this is what my wife thinks it happen. I think she may be right as it fits so well.

    • @blaqueup
      @blaqueup 26 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      @@rafaelrivera9346 It's not stated in teh books but apparently there is an extra bit somewhere where the author implies this is the case. Grans is actualy Maomao's grandma and as noted if not probably bother her and her mom wouldn't have been allowed to stay. (Edit due to weird keyboard issue)

  • @JigsRobles-
    @JigsRobles- 26 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    Fengxian probably told the owner to tell Lakan that's she died. cause in the scene where Lakan was asking where Fengxian is. the old hag told him she's gone. and Fengxian probably made them lie cause Meimei was crying out while saying that her big sister should have just to Lakan the truth.

  • @Mark-f7u3x
    @Mark-f7u3x 26 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    Loved watching your reactions to everything going on in this season. Will definitely be coming back for season 2.

  • @matthewk320
    @matthewk320 26 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    And meimei loved lakan this whole time. She was very kind to them.

  • @monzed.3948
    @monzed.3948 26 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    It was fun watching this with you girls, see you in 2025 "big things" are await us 🤭🐸💚💜

  • @sephorapaulazammit4925
    @sephorapaulazammit4925 23 วันที่ผ่านมา

    The apothecary diaries has 2 manga version. GANGAN AND GX. GX IS more shounen style. Also the anime drawing are coming from gangan ( the one with tax problem)
    Natsu sensei is the writer , neko is the manga artist of Gangan manga version and Kurata-sensei is the manga artist of Gx mangas.

  • @willpina
    @willpina 26 วันที่ผ่านมา

    The old madam kept Fengxian hidden because she was sick with syphilis, if word got out their reputation would be damaged. But she didn't want to get rid of her because od Maomao and also because the old madam for some reason has a heavy attachment to her.

  • @reverance_pavane
    @reverance_pavane 26 วันที่ผ่านมา

    This episode always reduces ,me to tears. I do wish people would stop cutting up onions whenever :Lakan discovers Fengxian is actually alive.

  • @Le7emeChat
    @Le7emeChat 26 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    Be careful you're doing to the Madam what was done to Lakan: assuming based on conjecture. And if there is something the show tell us...

  • @AlbionOfAvalon55
    @AlbionOfAvalon55 26 วันที่ผ่านมา

    lol what i see granny preventing fengxia and lakan getting a somewhat happy end... bcoz it cause her to lose business previously and we know she likes money and when lakan unknowingly impregnate fengxia she hold a grudge on lakan for not showing up and buying her out due to him being away for a long time and when he showed up late she started beating him and lies about fengxia being gone (dead) [The Pieces are in the Flashback]

  • @clowtears1898
    @clowtears1898 26 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    Meimei is fallen in love with Lakan. What a sad love story.

    • @gprovidakes
      @gprovidakes 26 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      Meimei was the most lovely big sister, although the others were wonderful. I really hope she gets a happy future as well.

  • @dontassociate
    @dontassociate 26 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Bro got that ankle strength

  • @user-uz7vh9xh2j
    @user-uz7vh9xh2j 26 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Backstory not directly related to the story (author's Twitter information: Old lady is Maomao's grandmother).

  • @Xagzan
    @Xagzan 26 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Ok everyone let's thank Maomao and Frieren for saving anime again

  • @marinauder
    @marinauder 26 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    I like how she tried to "seduce" Jinshi like he usually does haha

  • @MrSmee-vt7cy
    @MrSmee-vt7cy 2 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    14:30 😂😂😂

  • @Erwinjvc
    @Erwinjvc 26 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Laaakaaannnn 😭😭😭

  • @biskuitmelempem9805
    @biskuitmelempem9805 26 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Can't wait to see maomao again in 2025

  • @rafaelrivera9346
    @rafaelrivera9346 26 วันที่ผ่านมา

    This may be consider to be a spoiler by some but I don’t agree. My wife who doesn’t care much about mangas or anime but she is a fan of soaps (specially Spanish, Korean and Turkish soaps) thinks she has figured the story behind Momo and everything that happened with her mother. Both me and Maggie (my wife) haven’t read the Manga or the Novels. May be spoiler if this is what happens to have taken place. Again this is just is my wife’s theory that Momo’s mother is the old lady’s daughter as the only reason she didn’t kicked her out of the house after she got pregnant or gave birth. That makes momo her granddaughter. That would also make sense with why Momo is keep around the house and and her adopted father who probably was the birth doctor of Momo. We think that old lady force the uncle to raise Momo as like “you need to do that” All of this is what my wife thinks it happen. I think she may be right as it fits so well. It’s just theory so it may or may not be true, but it’s is an obvious deduction once I think about it.

  • @ThanoosUdom
    @ThanoosUdom 26 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    About the Madam of the Verdigris House, You see... In the novel, There are faint hints that kinda insinuate that maybe... the Madam of the House might turn out be Fengxian's (Maomao's Mom) Mother... Before she becoming the Madam of the House, She also used to be a courtesan herself. As you saw Fengxian telling Lakan in the last episode, A Courtesan can never be a mother in the pleasure district. Meaning... for their business, The Madam and Fengxian can never let it be known that they were parent and a child. Still... There is a bond between them. Cause why else would the Madam look after Fengxian when she caught a syphilis and no longer take any guest? Not to mention that instead of throwing out Maomao whose birth almost cause the House to went out of business, The Madam kept her around up until she got adopted by Loumen. Why? Well, Maybe it because Maomao is her granddaughter. Again... Because their circumstance in the pleasure district, That connection of their can not be known... Hence their strange relationship.
    Just so you know, This is still just a theory that the fans piecing together from bits and pieces of details here and there through out the novel. There is still no confirmation about the theory being proven yet... But from the look of it, The possibility of it being true is very likely.

  • @Lightkie
    @Lightkie 26 วันที่ผ่านมา

    3:38 Again, you forgot the rumour (now three episodes back) about Lihaku thinking Pairin was getting bought out which turned out to be the old madam wanting to sell *Meimei* off.
    4:00 This scene was changed for the anime by her slowly walking towards the doors to open them instead of some windows but then why would the old madam wait so long to object?
    5:23 FIY, you can contract syphilis just from touching the sores.
    8:45 In the books, she left an actual letter in a hidden compartment. I think I like the anime version better.
    9:05 Maybe that's the rule of cool or I am getting my tropes mixed up but I just think it's lazy writing. If he could just predict what's happening next and didn't do anything about it, it means he would not care whether Jinshi died. It was a matter of seconds, after all (in itself too much of a coincidence but otherwise Maomao would not be the hero who saved the day).
    13:13 Looks like a normal finger to me too.
    13:40 Also changed in the anime from Jinshi climbing down the protrusions with one hand. This is just dumb. No way his legs would be better off than Maomao's after that jump.
    14:50 It was - you guessed it - another change in the anime to hold his face. Not a fan myself.
    18:30 Uh, no. That scene with the knife was just Fengxian cutting Maomao's fingertip off to curse Lakan which also explains why the old madam would not let him near her.
    20:40 You know the manga is based on light novels, right? It only covers a fifth of the published story so far. There is also another manga adaptation that started in the same year by a different mangaka that is further along. It's the same story, I have no clue what the reasoning is behind that.
    One important thing left out of the anime was Lakan finding Maomao walking besides Luomen next to the brothel after getting beaten bloody again by the old madam (he kept coming back) and realising it must be his daughter. It said Luomen didn't object to Lakan getting beaten up which really annoys me. Maomao having an aversion against a guy she didn't know that was creepy looking and bleeding from his head.. fine, she was just a child - but Luomen who knows Lakan wasn't to blame? No.

  • @nakita1351
    @nakita1351 26 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    Can you react to cardcaptor Sakura

  • @osmosisjones4912
    @osmosisjones4912 26 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    Had Kento considered maybe he did try to Make for missing the birth of his son. Had considered why would he make her queen of his world. And get this only countries have positive birth rates . Ate frim countries that treat women like dirt. Only scenario that end with women treated like horribly is if except they aren't queens and a relationship takes 2

  • @Chiraq872
    @Chiraq872 26 วันที่ผ่านมา

    😍Dani🥰Kenny Muney Top. Turn it up gang.🌷

  • @helsi4300
    @helsi4300 2 หลายเดือนก่อน +6

    You guys got the OLD Lady situation so so wrong