ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 พ.ย. 2022
- In today's episode of Bills and Acts we discuss appointment of Supreme Court and High Court Judges in India.
Guests:
1- Pinaki Misra, BJD MP, Lok Sabha
2- Dr. Vageshwari Deshwal, Professor, Faculty of Law, Delhi University
3- Dr. Justice Satish Chandra, Former Judge, Allahabad High Court
Producer: Namrata Singh
Anchor: Kriti Mishra
Guest coordinator: Paras Kandpal, Lokesh Bhardwaj
Follow us on:
-Twitter: / sansad_tv
-Insta: / sansad.tv
-FB: / sansadtelevision
-Koo: www.kooapp.com/profile/Sansad_TV
Subscribe to Sansad TV TH-cam Channel: / sansadtv
Visit Sansad TV website: sansadtv.nic.in/
Such discussions must be held for longer period of time
Very informative discussion specially the 1st speaker..
Thank you very much
Why not NJAC?
Thank you
Judges must hv trial experience , eminent jurists first get some experience ,exam then talk 😂😂😂
🙏🙏🙏
good mam
Eighty-six families of Judiciary run the Sc and High courts
🙏🙏
|🇮🇳
🕉️🔱🪔🙏🙇
Bharat Mata ki Jai 🙏
Prati Mishra ji ku b namaste 🙏
LENARD SIR WHO IS CONSULTING WHOM?....NO, THAT IS THE QUESTION!!! THERE SHOULD BE A PANEL COMPRISED BY THE PARLIAMENT.THE PENAL MEMBERS SHOULD HAVE A finite TIME AND SHOULD HAVE A CHAIR INCLUDING THE CHIEF JUSTICE, A CME FOR ALL, JUST AS WE HAVE FOR THE LAWYERS, DOCTORS,,NURSES...!
Kriti mishra 😍😍
How to be part of that audience sitting there during discussion?
Its an easy task . Sometimes they are DU student and sometimes LLB STUDENTS
My Dream Girl Kriti Mishra i love you 💖
😂😂😂🙏🙏
Teri maa hai wo gadhe 🚩🚩
The recruitment of ADJ by respective State Govts should be replaced by Indian Judicial Service conducted by UPSC.
1. Indian Judicial Service to be introduced.
2. UPSC to conduct the selection provess.
3. Senior DJs of IJS cadre to go through their performance evaluation process conducted again by UPSC.
4. The DJs whose performance reports are satisfactory and whose RAW and IB report are not objectionable to be appointed the Judges of High Courts.
5. The performance of senior High Court Judges to be evaluated SCI.
6. Panel of judges to be forwarded to GOI for onward action
Njac is good but before look lower judiciary..... u. P. Last vacancy 2018
And who is responsible after njac sc....?
Love you 😘 kriti
Bring in NJAC with modification by mutual consultation. Otherwise, let the collegium collect intelligence inputs and recommend the appointment to the president direct . The president or the🎉 peon are elected or selected in an open system but the collegium is non-transparent and nothing is open to public information much less public scrutiny. This is exclusive privilege of the collegium in the name of independence which deprives the independence of the parliament and the executive. I am yet to find a support for the collegium in the constitution. Collegium thus violates the constituion
She is so beautiful
.
Judges....do we want to run the court to make the place valid for fundraising?
According to the above debate if the Collegium select the judges they are eminent jurists but the NJAC involved in the appointments it is not applicable to our country because 🤭🤫🤐🤪😜😝😛
I found a great relationship betwn the Law and Science....as the Science is lucid the Law will be but in cases the Brahmanical approach our Education sustem the Engineering studies have been a sheer vulnerability a pot damage of a candidate...but not demolished....business in sway...how could SC violating inspite of pitfall of the unemployment inspite potential damage to all sect of Economy?
CME IS THE ANSWER TO NEPOTISM?!!! THE APPOINTEE SHOULD HAVE A FINITE TIME ,REAPPOINTMENT IMADE ON HIS/HER CME AND PERFORMACE JUDGED BY THE PANEL!!!!
SO THIS SYSTEM IS UNCONSTITUTIONAL!!!
The CLAT exam for LLM is a very reputed exam.
It is conducted all over the country and there are very few complaints against it.
All candidates appearing in CLAT exam for LLM study a common syllabus, irrespective of which Law College they will join later on.
The syllabus is common for all law universities in the country irrespective of state and language. Besides, the law syllabus is decided by the Bar Council of India for all Law Colleges.
The score of CLAT exam for LLM also is used for appointment of Lawyers by various PSUs.
1. Why then do all states need to conduct separate examinations to recruit Civil Judges? Why can't CLAT exam for LLM be the one and only exam to recruit Civil Judges all over India?
2. This will save a lot of time and money and effort of the Honourable High Courts of the country as also of the poor candidates.
3.Inspite of earlier Supreme Court judgements that interview should not be done since bias is likely to be there, the Chhatisgarh Public Service Commission has advertised posts for Civil Judges and getting qualifying marks in the interview is mandatory.
Besides, the written Mains exam shall have subjective questions. My words may be noted , outstanding candidates will be failed in the Interview and given much lower marks in the subjective questions compared to the ' connected ' candidates '.
Implement the Constitution in the appointment of judges. Why no reservation for SC ,OBC in judiciary?
End Collegium, create Indian Judicial Service.
In Judicial appointments, only objective type questions should be there and no interview should be there.
To become a clerk, one has to appear in a written test, to become a Supreme Court Judge? No!
Haha
They behaved like goons sometimes a fundraiser....whenever we are not naturally selected to put Rice into our mouth....we spread more and more Education .....do the natural law supports that like being personified.
Based on the business vague we have to buy vague things...had ti suffer from poor obliterated business....as our unintended step has been adding few useless steps....the persons trying to rectify the system .....inspite of the candidate himself.
The big picture show ni aata kya ab
See BHARATA FIRST
Aata hain..."Perspective" hai wo ab
@@kohinoor6435 thanku
The entire debate is biased only favouring executive .....
Am challenging to all sc hc judge must solve 35% pcs j paper 😅😅😅😅just 50lakh ₹study jurisprudence in foreign and come be a judge....sc hc. 😅😅😅
I didn’t know about it, if they didn’t study in our country they are not capable to execute judiciary. Am I right
Nobody in our SC or HC appointed as a judge without going through a rigorous selection procedure. They have studied properly and pass the mandated exams that is why they are judges now. They are not selected by a mere consider of foreign return guy. Your points are baseless and miss leading
Who came here from buniyad bacth PW😅
🤣
Itna time baad
Same bhai
Kriti mishra
Corrupt judges of india