स्टॉक में मार्जिन को खत्म करने से ये प्रॉब्लम हो रहा है दोबारा से स्टॉक ट्रेडिंग में मार्जिन को पहले जैसे कर देने से बहोत लोग ऑप्शन ट्रेडिंग नही करेंगे क्योकि स्टॉक ट्रेडिंग में कम प्रॉफिट होता है तो हानि भी कम होता हैं
And Lot size fir se adha kardo Bank Nifty ka lot size 7 krdo Nifty ka 10 kardo fir dekho kitna brokerage and tax aayega Logo ko 100 rupye kamane me bhi *.... Fatt jayegi aur fir bhi agar galti se profit ho bhi gaya to Usme bhi 50 aap rakh lena (govt tax)
If you make money, they hate it, that's why they tax it. Crypto 30% tax, option trading 30% tax, education 28% GST. How will India become a superpower with such a non-sense finance management, and illiterate FM.
Zerodha founder says...99% of his customers fail to beat even FD retaurns in day trading....then how come governemnt thinks everyone is making money in trading???
If govt ban future and options, I will leave the country for sure because it is my source of bread and butter. I just don't get why don't govt just ignore people who loose money in trading? It is their fault and stupidity, why should we face it? We are already paying huge taxes. I hate such ministers and chairman's who always target us. I will never vote again if such thing will happen....
I'm a hardcore BJP follower but if this tax is implemented then I will never vote for BJP in my life again and I know atleast 100 of them who are having the same thought.
@@abhishekraj4635It is the Congress which kept long term capital gain tax at zero, BJP introduced it after coming to power. You might be recent born, but stock market historically has shown most growth during Congress time, including 2008 second biggest bear market phase.
Zerodha founder says...99% of his customers fail to beat even FD retaurns in day trading....then how come governemnt thinks everyone is making money in trading???
agar F&O speculative income hai toh SEBI ko puri tarah se abolish kar dena chahiye kyun ki sebi regulator hai agar regulator ke hote hue market ka kisi segment satta hai toh regulator rakhne ka kya matlab
This decision will be biggest blunder by so called finance minister. Q=why US has so many millionaires? Are they doing Govt job and becoming millionaires? A= No. Q=Then what's the reason? A=Because they have multiple source of income and Sharemarket is one of them . And here is our foolish FM who wants to change the peoples standard of living by implementing more taxes. Abe bewkoof agar itna change chahti he to traffic rules todne walon ke upar jyada tax laga ke paisa kama na.
US people are millionaires by money value as dollar has more value than all other nations currency. They don't have multiple streams of income, and all do not trade in markets. cost of living in USA is very high and even taxes are high.
@@rohietthakur6466 Indian traders are already paying lots of different kind of taxes and now they are planning to add 30% TDS on earnings so what a citizen can do in this situation you tell me no government doing this kind of shit in any other country.
They calculated it before, if they had implemented in Match-April they knew it would affect them. So they did it right after the election so that till next 5 years people will forget or calm down.
As FM said Earlier, Mein Piyaaz Nehi Khati, mujhe kuch Farak nehi parta, Now, She gonna Say,Mein Trading Nehi Karti, Mujhe Kuch Farak Nehi Padta.... #Nirmala(FM), School Teacher
Government सिर्फ अपना स्टाफ को अच्छा सैलरी देने के लिए जनता से TAX, TAX, TAX लेता,... लॉस हो तो जनता भोगे.. Profit तो 30%गवर्नमेंट का.. क्या.. कानून इस देश का
स्टॉक में मार्जिन को खत्म करने से ये प्रॉब्लम हो रहा है दोबारा से स्टॉक ट्रेडिंग में मार्जिन को पहले जैसे कर देने से बहोत लोग ऑप्शन ट्रेडिंग नही करेंगे क्योकि स्टॉक ट्रेडिंग में कम प्रॉफिट होता है तो हानि भी कम होता है
Instead of stupid banning and unlimited taxes. Govt should make income proof say 12 lakh or 15lakh per annum compulsory to do options trading. That way poor and lower middle class don't lose money and people who indulge in F&O also wont face high taxes
Arey sirf ek step implement karwa do SEBI se bas agar Sach mein dum hai toh : F&O mein trade karne wale ka intraday mein 10% ka loss hote hi kill switch activate automatic ho jana chahiye for next 24 hours. But I know govt. Will never do this 😅😅😅 bcoz govt ki income half ho jayegi...
I don't think option trading will be ban , because it is highest source of tax for the government .With everyday expiry , the tax which government receives is high
Jaise road pe Four Wheeler chalaneke liye Driving License lagta hai, thik usi tarah agar Government yeh kar de ki FNO mein wahi log trade kar sakte hai jo SEBI se qualified certificate mila ho, SEBI ne woh certificate oosko aachchhe se test karneke baad diya ho, iss tarah ka hoga toh jo serious log honge wahi log Option mein trade karenge, aise waise log Option Trading mein nahi participate kar payenge. Aur oos Certificate ko hasil karneke liye Rs1.00 lakh spend karna hoga, test trading ke liye. Agar woh Rs1.00 lakh ko nahi bacha pata hai test trading mein toh oosko certificate nahi milega, isse automatic faltu traders ka participation khatam ho jayega.
Mujhe ye samajh nahi aata ki F&O me jab 90% retailer loss me hai, to fir tax ki chinta kyu karte hai. Chinta ko big trader, operator kare, jo lakho caroro kama rahe hai.
Big trader to 30% tax de hi rahe hai अब आपको मै समझता हु जैसे मैने F&O ट्रेड लिया और मुझे 1 हजार प्रोफिट हो गया तो सरकार अपना ३०० रुपए टैक्स ले लेगी और मुझे ७०० देगी अब 90% लोग F&O ट्रेड हारते ही है लेकिन वो कभी न कभी १००० २००० १०००० जीत थे भी तो है अब मन लो मै सुबह ट्रेड लिया और १० हजार का लॉस हो गया फिर मैने दूसरा ट्रेड लिया उसमें 1००० का प्रोफिट हो गया तो ३०० टैक्स गया ७०० जमा होगा कुछ समझा अब
@@maksudhasan2622 operator kabhi open position nahi rakhte, wo strangle, straddle, spread banate hai. Tab ja kar over all profit me aate hai. Ab 30% tax to dena hoga, lekin jo opposite direction ka loss hua, us se profit ko compensate nahi kar payenge, matlab operating ka overall tax double ho jayega, agar abhi compensate kar k 100 caror profit par 30% tax dena padta tha to ab, wo tax unhe ab 200 caror profit par dena padega, matlab tax double, kyuki ab unka hedging ka loss compensate nhi hoga. Ab aya kuchh samajh.
@@maksudhasan2622 chinta mat karo, ye nahi hone wala, werna market se liquidity gayab ho jayega. Aur is rule se jyada nuksan unka hai, jo jyada profit karte hai, is liye big money aise rule ko nahi aane denge.
@@ajayverma6346bro jitna hedge tm bta rhe hoo.. agar utna strangle straddle banayenge na toh kuch paisaa nhi kamma payenge.. q ki ye sb neutral and sideways ke liye toh thik h.. but jb market trending hoo jaata hai toh straddle or strangle me huge losses hoo jaate h... It was like earning 10 RS per day aur lost 100 in single day, smze chahe koi bhi ho jb tk wo market me move nhi pakad payega TB it's very hard to get money, haa 10 din bhalle hi profit dikh jaayega ye kr ke but phir jb kbhi market trending hoga then wo iss mindset se huge loss le lenge.. they most want trending market..
Budget presentation on July 22 2024. The other option government must explore is to set up proper curriculum where the Option trading and its strategies are taught in a simple and clear manner. On top of it, Government must allow the passed out students to re-attend the course for refreshing their knowledge once every year for next 5 years since passing out. Education will lead to more confidence building and more confidence will result in more participation. increasing taxes will only result in innovative scams and gang trading and mafia trading. Its a loss loss proposition for all.
Thanks main jab stock market me aya tha us se pehle he aapki videos follow karta tha 2017 se ek baar aap se call par baat karne ka chance bhe Mila tha aap se aur kuch aur fallow youtubers se guideness mili isi liye Aaj Tak kabhi loss nahi hua agar hua bhe hai toh apni marzi se Kiya h Investing from 4 years longterm but mostly pany stocks but thank you for guideness love you Want to meet once Comment is liye kiya ki aap ne video me kaha koi longterm se stock market start nahi karta but I started with longterm but just because people like you
Taxing that much would be increased the number of gambling which is not regulated by sebi or Government. They should think once again if they taxing fno. Satta waise hi lagate hai chote chote log. Ye naye traders ko rok denge. BJP Government should think again.
Agar janta ka itna hi usko fikar hota toh berojgari se juj rahe berojgar pe dhyan deta ,, garibo par dhyan deta ,, na ki woh g20 par garibo ko chhupata 🤬
The one perfect solution, Govt should allow the trader to settle their profits with their last 5 years losses. If someone has very bad losses in his past, he should be given a chance to pay less taxes till 5 years as he can settle his profits with his last 5 years.
Dear Sir, Seeking your advice on this... Motilal Oswal founder Mr. Ramdev Agarwal says in Investing, Buy Right, Sit Tight , Here what he exactly means, whether it's company shares ,Active Mutual Fund or Passive Funds...? In your view what are the Buy Right, Sit Tight kind of mutual funds for the next decade...?
I love my India and proud to be an Indian but unfortunately I have to admit we have worst education system, taxation system and corruption. This Government is not letting anyone grow and do something great.
Zerodha founder says...99% of his customers fail to beat even FD retaurns in day trading....then how come governemnt thinks everyone is making money in trading???
brother please tell me can I set off my Options trading losses with capital gains from investing in stocks? I turned my 16L into 30Ls I am a house keeper with no other sources of income.
Some argue to increase lot size but so that it is out of reach of average person. But i think this sitution is like if a there is well and most people fell in it trying to jump over it to get some reward. As a solution increase the depth or width so that not any average person try to jump over it. Insteed I will prefer to decrease lot size so that if any one falls in the well the hurt is manageble.
1.Why isn't SEBI/GOVT considering both equity and options together to calculate profit & loss. 2.Many are doing covered calls & hedgeing for trading both delivery and options/futures together. 3.Now that physical settlement is made mandatory for options in the money stocks on expiry, will also act as hedging for option loss with consolidated profit considering trading as a whole.
It is the govt who motivates people to leave the country and settle in another, Thats why millionaries are leaving Bhaarat because of these worst Finance minister and govt.... On an Average Middle class is giving 50-60% taxes of his income.... In form of Income tax, GST, TOLL TAX, Road Tax ,URBAN TAX, ...... #Middle class is Grain in the Hand Using Chakki....
Govt should ask brokers for compulsory 6 months paper trading with fix amounts not unlimited amount (let’s say 5 lakh )of all new participants. And activate fno real trading if they’re profitable after 6 months
Don't banned option trading our house hold based on it we will die if you option trading .. option trading is a business not a speculation... Now why Indian government act like dictator
Hi Prasad, Few mistakes which u need to correct in your video: 1. Speculative losses can be set off with other speculative income and set off is allowed for 4yrs 2.U mentioned speculative income is taxed @30%which is wrong there is no specific section for speculative income taxation Requesting you to plz highlight the points in your video to give viewers a frame of entire picture rather than a hindsight .
This same pattern of dissuasion is used by the government to tax alcohol, cigarettes, second vehicle and plastic carry bags. It's not inhibiting the traders or ones burdened by such penal charges, but the loss in disposable income for the household. The government puts up a straight face as if these kinds of taxes are prohibitive in nature, But it's just a ploy to rake in more money to the govt coffers. Totally unacceptable.
In order to save small investors government should ban option trading and distribute profits earned by 11% profitable traders to loss makers. Government should ban Upsc, Neet, IIM and IIT exams as very less % of students pass, should only pass to less privilidge SC, ST and minorities. Should ban every business where more than 50 % are loss makers and distribute the profits of those who profitable to loss makers..
Very Good Decision by Sebi... Minimum Lot size should be above Rs.25 Lakhs in FnO. It is not a game for retailers. Retail traders should instead focus on swing trading and delivery. GST should be reduced here. STT should be abolished in delivery and swing trade. STCG should be waived for profits up to Rs. 2.5 Lakhs in a FY. LTCG should be applied if securities are held beyond 5 years. This will motivate retail traders to focus on cash segment and delivery trades instead of dreaming to become Ambani overnight through FnO
कितने लोगो ने पैसे कमाये है.. ऑप्शन मे 10 साल से मार्केट मे हुं option से झीरो था मैं....कुच नहीं पडा ऑप्शन.....अगर किसिको भिक मंगणी है....कटोरा लेके तो करो ऑप्शन
Very logical approach. You are right. Thousands of people will be disappointed and heart broken. Many people will lose steady income. Pathetic approach and mindset the proposers showed. 😡😡😡
Misleading post. Options are the oldest form of hedging tool. Banning options would be regressive. Ofcourse taxes can be raised on such intraday speculation income but those who hold options for hedging will be barred from speculative income.
govt should stop NSE:BSE from creating smaller lot sizes, instead of increasing taxes. Make the lot size 100 or 150 or 200. Many folks will not be able to afford option buying
Govt of India 🇮🇳 ne abhi bhot ku6 karne ka planning 📝 kr rkkha hai.. 🆎 Rupiya ₹ aayega kidhaar se?? Taxes bada diye hai.. Magar Goods & Services mehengi ho rhi hai.. Profit half ho ja rha hai.. Har mayene se..
I am big supporter of BJP but i am not in favour increasing taxes on profits be it LTGC, STGC or F&O , Bcoz to earn money from market it takes lot of experience and time , then govt comes and tax you when you make money. This is not reasonable
Simple solution to reduce 89% to 70% is just put restriction on trading on 1st 3 to 5 years from date of opening Demat account. This is simple and clear solution. But mind says big players wont allow this to do. Its disadv to them.
Actually issue is privatisation of government sectors. So government can't make money. So to earn revenue only option for them is taxes. And there main goal is to collect tax from wherever possible. We should remember political parties are always concerned about themselves than country
99% of the retailers are losing money in F&O... Some more strict measures should be taken by the government to regulate the retailers from losing money and should do some measures to improve investments in good stocks and mutual funds...
Make Professional Websites ( Free ), Check out Odoo now -
www.odoo.com/r/6lW
wrong, 305 tds nahin, 30% tax and 1%TDS
Sabhi ka bikalp hai
Government jo karna chahe kar le
स्टॉक में मार्जिन को खत्म करने से ये प्रॉब्लम हो रहा है दोबारा से स्टॉक ट्रेडिंग में मार्जिन को पहले जैसे कर देने से बहोत लोग ऑप्शन ट्रेडिंग नही करेंगे क्योकि स्टॉक ट्रेडिंग में कम प्रॉफिट होता है तो हानि भी कम होता हैं
Me to kehta hu
30℅ se 50℅ kardo
Maja hi aa jayega Govt. Ko
paisa hi paisa hoga
Sab lelo 😅😂
And Lot size fir se adha kardo
Bank Nifty ka lot size 7 krdo
Nifty ka 10 kardo fir dekho kitna brokerage and tax aayega
Logo ko 100 rupye kamane me bhi *.... Fatt jayegi aur fir bhi agar galti se profit ho bhi gaya to
Usme bhi 50 aap rakh lena (govt tax)
If you make money, they hate it, that's why they tax it. Crypto 30% tax, option trading 30% tax, education 28% GST. How will India become a superpower with such a non-sense finance management, and illiterate FM.
India a country were people are poor but government is rich😂
Only tax collection will make 5 trillion economic NAMO
India will become a superpower is the biggest joke of the century
BJP like ..Ab ki baar 100 paar
Isme govt ka koi dosh nahi.... Dosh hai to India ke public ka jo hamesha galat vote dalte hain
Middle finger for government
Happy to see all are against, but no use for us ..|.. for govt
Middle finger for nirmala only
Dck for government 😂
Dubai is tax free😅...forex option trading from dubai 😎
@@jayrajput6629 to this government
The government wants you to stay poor and give more taxes.. nothing more than that they can do😂😂😂
Galat jagah ungli kar di
Banda (Option trader) Nekki kar aur Dariya mein daal ( as per FM -government wish)
Zerodha founder says...99% of his customers fail to beat even FD retaurns in day trading....then how come governemnt thinks everyone is making money in trading???
If govt ban future and options, I will leave the country for sure because it is my source of bread and butter.
I just don't get why don't govt just ignore people who loose money in trading? It is their fault and stupidity, why should we face it? We are already paying huge taxes. I hate such ministers and chairman's who always target us. I will never vote again if such thing will happen....
😢
Bhai mujhe bhi apne team mai le lona mujhe bhi karna hai options
Bread and butter?
How much u made in option can u show verified pnl?
th-cam.com/video/vYHF_4QTFsY/w-d-xo.htmlsi=ODsGPlKejvJ3K6U6
Bann kar hi Dena chahiye
I'm a hardcore BJP follower but if this tax is implemented then I will never vote for BJP in my life again and I know atleast 100 of them who are having the same thought.
Also me be.
Aise hi bjp krta rha to next baar 100 seat v nhi jitegi
Congress wale r tax lgayenge bo log zada freebies dete hain...
May bhi😢
@@abhishekraj4635It is the Congress which kept long term capital gain tax at zero, BJP introduced it after coming to power. You might be recent born, but stock market historically has shown most growth during Congress time, including 2008 second biggest bear market phase.
not gonna vote bjp if this is implemented.
न नौकरी देग,,, न व्यापार करने देग,,,न एग्जाम लगे,,, होगा तों सिफर्फ TAX,,, TAX,,, TAXX,, LA BABU TAX.. TAX.. 🙏🏻
😢😢
Toh aur kamao yar kyun tax ke liye rote ho
Uspe aur tax deja padega@@VinodKumar-xs9uj
I will give you work
Nokari nahi hai terepass na tere pass vyapar hai to tu tax ka tension mat le tu abhi Chhota hai beta 😢
Saala abhi jeene bhi nhi degi govt jab abhi accha profit ho raha option trading mein. Koi hatao FM ko warna jeene pe bhi tax lagayegi ye😡😡
Kon hateya tu kyu nai hatara😂
@WhoAmI-2026 true😭🤣
Wo Fno trading nahi karte hai ..eisiliye unko koi matlb nahi hai ..
@@MadhuKumari-tx8he unke paas toh bhaut paisa pehle se hi h yr
Zerodha founder says...99% of his customers fail to beat even FD retaurns in day trading....then how come governemnt thinks everyone is making money in trading???
Need to immediately remove finance minister she is good for nothing. This government is milking middle class people like anything😢😢😢😢
Fiance minister puppet he modi shah ki uski itni himmat nhi hai k khud decide karke impose kre
You seriously think the finance minister is the actual problem 😂
For them modi and shah is good and all problem is with FM😂😂😂 dono bhai chor hai uska kya..
Remove Modi Government
@@sayanc341 what is gdp? and external debt? Please explain in hindi? Im not that good in English
India tax system is very bad
1947 Se phle gore angrej raj kr rahe th ab kale angrej raj kar rahe h
Aldom
Lol 😅@@s_misra
@@Xi_Jing_pingnikal ping ping
@@vipassanameditation3419 why ? I don't do anything 🤧
agar F&O speculative income hai toh SEBI ko puri tarah se abolish kar dena chahiye kyun ki sebi regulator hai agar regulator ke hote hue market ka kisi segment satta hai toh regulator rakhne ka kya matlab
Yes
Bahut sahi bt bola bhai
Stock intraday is already speculative. Kya bro
Bahut Sahiii
Point to be noted.
4300 rich Indians gonna migrate this year...thank to taxation
Good for them, f$%^ india
Agar Aisa hua toh, many people will not vote for the BJP in upcoming state elections.. state by state they'll be history.
Bhai Hindutva ko use kar rhi hai na... Aur humein koi dusra option nhi hai. Koi acha party nhi hai
Tax 100% kaar dena chahiye, ajkal itne mehengai me 30% se kya hota hai
😂😂😂😅
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂
😂😂😂
NS is the most hated FM in Indian histrionic
NOT AGAIN ANOTHER FIVE YEARS
Isliye usiko banaya Gobiji ne .. torcher me kami nahi honi chahie.. tisribar chuna.... ab chalo bhugat lete hai
.
Mai bjp voter hu but Sarkar East India company ki tarh behave na kare....nahi to sarkar palat di jaayegi
भुगतो भाई अब 😅😅😅😅
Tumhare hese voters he ek chai Wale ko desh ka dictator bana dete hain....ab vughto sath mein hum v vughtenge....
Kuch nahi hona vala next 5years🙏🙏🙏
Faltu mein de diye BJP ko vote
Vote se pahala sochna chahiya
Bhaiyo Behno maine apni zindagi ke 30 saal chai bechne ke alwa trading bhi ki mujhe bhari loss hua isliye ab 30% tax laga kar sab vassol kruga 😂😂😂😂
Phle loss toh cover toh
Tabhi toh vassol kroge😅
PM
Majority log option se paisa kamate hi nhi hai
@@Mr_chandan67 isliye to TAX lagya jara h
@@JAT_UNKNOWN ha ye baat to sahi h
This decision will be biggest blunder by so called finance minister.
Q=why US has so many millionaires? Are they doing Govt job and becoming millionaires?
A= No.
Q=Then what's the reason?
A=Because they have multiple source of income and Sharemarket is one of them .
And here is our foolish FM who wants to change the peoples standard of living by implementing more taxes.
Abe bewkoof agar itna change chahti he to traffic rules todne walon ke upar jyada tax laga ke paisa kama na.
Ye budhiya pagal ho chuki hey pura ka pura
US people are millionaires by money value as dollar has more value than all other nations currency. They don't have multiple streams of income, and all do not trade in markets. cost of living in USA is very high and even taxes are high.
50 % percent population stock market mai involvement hai😊@@joysonmiller544
महान अर्थशास्त्री निर्मला जी, जिसने option trading से profit नहीं कमाया so उसको लगता है सट्टा है ,traders उसकी live intraday trading देखना चाहते है।
Government should give education to people. This is very important
harkato se to lag raha hai vo khud hi nahi hai
Sab kuch sirf government kare?? Citizens sirf baith ke har baat pe criticism karte hai.
Pehle govt. to educated ban jaaye...😂
@@rohietthakur6466 Indian traders are already paying lots of different kind of taxes and now they are planning to add 30% TDS on earnings so what a citizen can do in this situation you tell me no government doing this kind of shit in any other country.
Govt. Doesn't care about options, they just need taxes thats it
Hagne mutne par bhi laga do tax
Already h bhai, home me sewer ka jata h or Ghar k bahar Paisa deke h public toilet hota h
aur swatch bharat tax bhul gaye kya😂😂😂
😂😂😂
हवा में कर लगना चाहिए 😅
Jitnaa hago gya uska 30% weight ka guu ... government ko
Don't worry bjp... Next time congress ko vote dege...
Iss bar 240 hai Next election mai bjp ko 24 v nahi melega...
They calculated it before, if they had implemented in Match-April they knew it would affect them. So they did it right after the election so that till next 5 years people will forget or calm down.
Pappu stock market hi bech dega
सांस लेने पर भी टैक्स लगा दो।
Next time modi hota to ye bhi ho skta h brother 😂😂
Laga h dada 12% cylinder par oxygen k
Lol 😂
Legega search kar net zero carbon
Modi Ram a 😂😂😂
As FM said Earlier, Mein Piyaaz Nehi Khati, mujhe kuch Farak nehi parta,
Now, She gonna Say,Mein Trading Nehi Karti, Mujhe Kuch Farak Nehi Padta....
#Nirmala(FM), School Teacher
Government सिर्फ अपना स्टाफ को अच्छा सैलरी देने के लिए जनता से TAX, TAX, TAX लेता,... लॉस हो तो जनता भोगे.. Profit तो 30%गवर्नमेंट का.. क्या.. कानून इस देश का
Loss ko tu profit se offset bhi kar sakta hai. Thoda padh bhi liya kar low iq wale
kuch khas salary nhi h staff ki
Andhbhakt ki to lag gai
चुटिया कानून है
@@ManishGupta-rf4gx
प्राइवेट teacher की सैलरी सरकारी चपरासी की आधी भी नहीं बनता है... आप इससे अदाजा लागाओ...
If this happens then market will be destroyed
स्टॉक में मार्जिन को खत्म करने से ये प्रॉब्लम हो रहा है दोबारा से स्टॉक ट्रेडिंग में मार्जिन को पहले जैसे कर देने से बहोत लोग ऑप्शन ट्रेडिंग नही करेंगे क्योकि स्टॉक ट्रेडिंग में कम प्रॉफिट होता है तो हानि भी कम होता है
Sir this govt. Is irritating us....!Sir, this government is irritating us...!
Sala government hi pagl he tex lene pr hi tuli he me to virodh krta hu es 30% tex ka kon kon krta he jo krta ho vo like kre
Indian millionaires are leaving Indian citizenship because of heavy taxes
This govt have no 🧠.
@@sayanc341 gdp per capita 🤡. Ig you need some 🧠
@@sayanc341 see GDP per capita 🤡,🤡
really, think about those who voted for them ?
Par ye sab chiz janta ke liye kar rahe hai na ki janta ki hi gaand maarne ke liye ☠️@@sayanc341
Instead of stupid banning and unlimited taxes. Govt should make income proof say 12 lakh or 15lakh per annum compulsory to do options trading. That way poor and lower middle class don't lose money and people who indulge in F&O also wont face high taxes
Exactly
Congress to Congress, BJP Subhan allah 😡😡😤
what you get after paying high tax in india. moving to dubai soon.
How to move dubai
Boat
Swiming
@@KishanPatel-bv6lgCycle
mee too
Arey sirf ek step implement karwa do SEBI se bas agar Sach mein dum hai toh : F&O mein trade karne wale ka intraday mein 10% ka loss hote hi kill switch activate automatic ho jana chahiye for next 24 hours. But I know govt. Will never do this 😅😅😅 bcoz govt ki income half ho jayegi...
I don't think option trading will be ban , because it is highest source of tax for the government .With everyday expiry , the tax which government receives is high
Hmm
Govt ye chahti hai ki aap log gareeb ban jao aur bibhinna yojna ka muft faida uthao....ye FM world ka best FM hai jo ki gareebon ka masiha hai❤❤
Jaise road pe Four Wheeler chalaneke liye Driving License lagta hai, thik usi tarah agar Government yeh kar de ki FNO mein wahi log trade kar sakte hai jo SEBI se qualified certificate mila ho, SEBI ne woh certificate oosko aachchhe se test karneke baad diya ho, iss tarah ka hoga toh jo serious log honge wahi log Option mein trade karenge, aise waise log Option Trading mein nahi participate kar payenge. Aur oos Certificate ko hasil karneke liye Rs1.00 lakh spend karna hoga, test trading ke liye. Agar woh Rs1.00 lakh ko nahi bacha pata hai test trading mein toh oosko certificate nahi milega, isse automatic faltu traders ka participation khatam ho jayega.
There is no news of ban, then why hv u put such misleading title
basically anything can happen! Just enjoy the Roler coaster!
Just search it on google... every media company is covering it
Just creating a bubble in market so that people short and then market go up
@@namaskarprasadAny link to justify your title?
Without small fish ,whale or shark not survive in market for long time
Ab aake comment kar rahe ho sab , kuch din pahle BJP Modi chilla chilla kar vote dene bhi gaye the....shame on us for choosing such a pathetic govt
Mujhe ye samajh nahi aata ki F&O me jab 90% retailer loss me hai, to fir tax ki chinta kyu karte hai. Chinta ko big trader, operator kare, jo lakho caroro kama rahe hai.
Big trader to 30% tax de hi rahe hai
अब आपको मै समझता हु जैसे मैने F&O ट्रेड लिया और मुझे 1 हजार प्रोफिट हो गया तो सरकार अपना ३०० रुपए टैक्स ले लेगी और मुझे ७०० देगी अब 90% लोग F&O ट्रेड हारते ही है लेकिन वो कभी न कभी १००० २००० १०००० जीत थे भी तो है अब मन लो मै सुबह ट्रेड लिया और १० हजार का लॉस हो गया फिर मैने दूसरा ट्रेड लिया उसमें 1००० का प्रोफिट हो गया तो ३०० टैक्स गया ७०० जमा होगा कुछ समझा अब
@@maksudhasan2622 operator kabhi open position nahi rakhte, wo strangle, straddle, spread banate hai. Tab ja kar over all profit me aate hai. Ab 30% tax to dena hoga, lekin jo opposite direction ka loss hua, us se profit ko compensate nahi kar payenge, matlab operating ka overall tax double ho jayega, agar abhi compensate kar k 100 caror profit par 30% tax dena padta tha to ab, wo tax unhe ab 200 caror profit par dena padega, matlab tax double, kyuki ab unka hedging ka loss compensate nhi hoga. Ab aya kuchh samajh.
@@maksudhasan2622 chinta mat karo, ye nahi hone wala, werna market se liquidity gayab ho jayega. Aur is rule se jyada nuksan unka hai, jo jyada profit karte hai, is liye big money aise rule ko nahi aane denge.
@@ajayverma6346bro jitna hedge tm bta rhe hoo.. agar utna strangle straddle banayenge na toh kuch paisaa nhi kamma payenge.. q ki ye sb neutral and sideways ke liye toh thik h.. but jb market trending hoo jaata hai toh straddle or strangle me huge losses hoo jaate h...
It was like earning 10 RS per day aur lost 100 in single day, smze chahe koi bhi ho jb tk wo market me move nhi pakad payega TB it's very hard to get money, haa 10 din bhalle hi profit dikh jaayega ye kr ke but phir jb kbhi market trending hoga then wo iss mindset se huge loss le lenge.. they most want trending market..
@@ajayverma6346 ye sarkar demonetisation kar chuki h. Nothing is impossible for them
AVOID THIS VIDEO
incorrect information. spreading misinformation and rumors. the entire video is made on rumors.
Indian ministers are nothing but joke😂😂😂 aur inhe super power banna hai vishwaguru.
The only person i hate in BJP is nirmala sitaraman.and BJP makes her finance minister again😢😢
अगर मोडी सरकार ने ऑप्शन्स ट्रेडिंग को बैन किया या टॅक्स बदया तो सभी इंडियन ट्रेडर्स मिल्के मोडी सरकार को सत्ता से बाहर निकाल डॉ.
Aam janta ke paas paisa nhi hona chahiye-- Nirmala modi
Very very Informative 👍
Plz make a video on "trading only one pair"
It is benificial or not
BSE share will tank then
Same will happen with listed brokerage firms..!
Budget presentation on July 22 2024.
The other option government must explore is to set up proper curriculum where the Option trading and its strategies are taught in a simple and clear manner. On top of it, Government must allow the passed out students to re-attend the course for refreshing their knowledge once every year for next 5 years since passing out. Education will lead to more confidence building and more confidence will result in more participation. increasing taxes will only result in innovative scams and gang trading and mafia trading. Its a loss loss proposition for all.
yahi ache din ke sign hain.
Thanks main jab stock market me aya tha us se pehle he aapki videos follow karta tha 2017 se ek baar aap se call par baat karne ka chance bhe Mila tha aap se aur kuch aur fallow youtubers se guideness mili isi liye Aaj Tak kabhi loss nahi hua agar hua bhe hai toh apni marzi se Kiya h
Investing from 4 years longterm but mostly pany stocks but thank you for guideness love you
Want to meet once
Comment is liye kiya ki aap ne video me kaha koi longterm se stock market start nahi karta but I started with longterm but just because people like you
Thank you brother... This means a lot
Thank you for valuable info
'DEVELOPING COUNTRY'
Taxing that much would be increased the number of gambling which is not regulated by sebi or Government. They should think once again if they taxing fno. Satta waise hi lagate hai chote chote log. Ye naye traders ko rok denge. BJP Government should think again.
Agar janta ka itna hi usko fikar hota toh berojgari se juj rahe berojgar pe dhyan deta ,, garibo par dhyan deta ,, na ki woh g20 par garibo ko chhupata 🤬
The one perfect solution, Govt should allow the trader to settle their profits with their last 5 years losses. If someone has very bad losses in his past, he should be given a chance to pay less taxes till 5 years as he can settle his profits with his last 5 years.
Colors Trading chal raha hai desh mai
Big/small, odd/even also.
Our tax system is bad, need to improve it, koun koun ko lgta hai TAX system improve hona hi chahiye
Government ko sirf TAX chahiye....enko retailer ke loss se kuch lena dena nahiii....
Dear Sir, Seeking your advice on this...
Motilal Oswal founder Mr. Ramdev Agarwal says in Investing,
Buy Right, Sit Tight ,
Here what he exactly means, whether it's company shares ,Active Mutual Fund or Passive Funds...?
In your view what are the Buy Right, Sit Tight kind of mutual funds for the next decade...?
Taxes like Europe
Facilities like Africa
barrier entry restriction - age , training, trading experience, family background, net-worth .
I love my India and proud to be an Indian but unfortunately I have to admit we have worst education system, taxation system and corruption.
This Government is not letting anyone grow and do something great.
Zerodha founder says...99% of his customers fail to beat even FD retaurns in day trading....then how come governemnt thinks everyone is making money in trading???
Income from F&O can only be offset in previous F&O loss and not in other business loss.
brother please tell me
can I set off my Options trading losses with capital gains from investing in stocks?
I turned my 16L into 30Ls
I am a house keeper with no other sources of income.
Some argue to increase lot size but so that it is out of reach of average person. But i think this sitution is like if a there is well and most people fell in it trying to jump over it to get some reward. As a solution increase the depth or width so that not any average person try to jump over it.
Insteed I will prefer to decrease lot size so that if any one falls in the well the hurt is manageble.
1.Why isn't SEBI/GOVT considering both equity and options together to calculate profit & loss.
2.Many are doing covered calls & hedgeing for trading both delivery and options/futures together.
3.Now that physical settlement is made mandatory for options in the money stocks on expiry, will also act as hedging for option loss with consolidated profit considering trading as a whole.
I have shifted from FnO to intraday & Swing equity trading after losing 40k last year.
Good decision
It is the govt who motivates people to leave the country and settle in another, Thats why millionaries are leaving Bhaarat because of these worst Finance minister and govt....
On an Average Middle class is giving 50-60% taxes of his income.... In form of Income tax, GST, TOLL TAX, Road Tax ,URBAN TAX, ......
#Middle class is Grain in the Hand Using Chakki....
Govt should ask brokers for compulsory 6 months paper trading with fix amounts not unlimited amount (let’s say 5 lakh )of all new participants. And activate fno real trading if they’re profitable after 6 months
1) Conduct The Financial Awareness Programmes Through The Best And Knowledgeable Persons
2) Learning The Youth About Future And Options
hindus is in danger ❎️
taxpayers in danger✅️
If this happens by chance.. I would say, I will never vote for BJP ever in my life.... #NoNeedoFSEBI
हम तो वैसे भी नही करते😂
Don't banned option trading our house hold based on it we will die if you option trading .. option trading is a business not a speculation... Now why Indian government act like dictator
Stop daily expiry which has become the biggest nuisance and traders lose huge amount in Options. Only single expiry each week should be there.
Hi Prasad,
Few mistakes which u need to correct in your video:
1. Speculative losses can be set off with other speculative income and set off is allowed for 4yrs
2.U mentioned speculative income is taxed @30%which is wrong there is no specific section for speculative income taxation
Requesting you to plz highlight the points in your video to give viewers a frame of entire picture rather than a hindsight .
This same pattern of dissuasion is used by the government to tax alcohol, cigarettes, second vehicle and plastic carry bags. It's not inhibiting the traders or ones burdened by such penal charges, but the loss in disposable income for the household. The government puts up a straight face as if these kinds of taxes are prohibitive in nature, But it's just a ploy to rake in more money to the govt coffers. Totally unacceptable.
In order to save small investors government should ban option trading and distribute profits earned by 11% profitable traders to loss makers. Government should ban Upsc, Neet, IIM and IIT exams as very less % of students pass, should only pass to less privilidge SC, ST and minorities. Should ban every business where more than 50 % are loss makers and distribute the profits of those who profitable to loss makers..
I'll leave india if this rule come. First family and nice life than country for me.
Very Good Decision by Sebi... Minimum Lot size should be above Rs.25 Lakhs in FnO. It is not a game for retailers. Retail traders should instead focus on swing trading and delivery. GST should be reduced here. STT should be abolished in delivery and swing trade. STCG should be waived for profits up to Rs. 2.5 Lakhs in a FY. LTCG should be applied if securities are held beyond 5 years. This will motivate retail traders to focus on cash segment and delivery trades instead of dreaming to become Ambani overnight through FnO
Why govt is not charging 100℅
Tax
30℅ me kya ukhad loge ?
Lena hi hai to pura profit lo
will commodity market be also affected by this new law???
कितने लोगो ने पैसे कमाये है.. ऑप्शन मे 10 साल से मार्केट मे हुं option से झीरो था मैं....कुच नहीं पडा ऑप्शन.....अगर किसिको भिक मंगणी है....कटोरा लेके तो करो ऑप्शन
Very logical approach. You are right. Thousands of people will be disappointed and heart broken. Many people will lose steady income. Pathetic approach and mindset the proposers showed. 😡😡😡
Misleading post. Options are the oldest form of hedging tool. Banning options would be regressive. Ofcourse taxes can be raised on such intraday speculation income but those who hold options for hedging will be barred from speculative income.
govt should stop NSE:BSE from creating smaller lot sizes, instead of increasing taxes.
Make the lot size 100 or 150 or 200. Many folks will not be able to afford option buying
Govt of India 🇮🇳 ne abhi bhot ku6 karne ka planning 📝 kr rkkha hai.. 🆎 Rupiya ₹ aayega kidhaar se?? Taxes bada diye hai.. Magar Goods & Services mehengi ho rhi hai.. Profit half ho ja rha hai.. Har mayene se..
मेरा क्या है
मै तो फ़कीर हूँ
झोला उठाऊँगा ओर कहीं निकल जाऊंगा। 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😅😅😅😅
I am big supporter of BJP but i am not in favour increasing taxes on profits be it LTGC, STGC or F&O ,
Bcoz to earn money from market it takes lot of experience and time , then govt comes and tax you when you make money. This is not reasonable
Simple solution to reduce 89% to 70% is just put restriction on trading on 1st 3 to 5 years from date of opening Demat account. This is simple and clear solution. But mind says big players wont allow this to do. Its disadv to them.
FINANCE MINISTER ka name change karke TAX MINISTER kar dena chiye.😴😴😴
Actually issue is privatisation of government sectors. So government can't make money. So to earn revenue only option for them is taxes. And there main goal is to collect tax from wherever possible. We should remember political parties are always concerned about themselves than country
Now i understand why every year rich people leave india it is just because or bjp govt. Tax policy
May be yes
COLOR TRADING ही कर लेंगे😂😂😂अगर प्रॉफिट का 30% tax देना पड़ेगा तो🤡🤡🤡
99% of the retailers are losing money in F&O... Some more strict measures should be taken by the government to regulate the retailers from losing money and should do some measures to improve investments in good stocks and mutual funds...
how much tax for equity traders? swing traders