I've honestly never been so concerned about a political party in my entire life than I am the SNP right now, A new controversy every day seems to be coming out about them and their first minister.
All the "we're different from England" was kicked off by Sturgeon. Get a 6 year old from Glasgow and a 6 year old from Manchester, then get the SNP clowns to quantify the difference between them.
And yet they double down again. Anyone with even a 10th of a loaf in their head would know that puberty blockers are a bad idea. You don't need science or the cass report to come to that conclusion. 🤦🏻 People have been shouting from the roofs on this issue for years!!!
There is something very seedy about the SNP/Greens, and what these people see as priorities for the Scottish people. Better quality schools and facilities are needed, not discussions about children's genders. Schools are to there to give our children the best education possible before they go into the workplace, or have we all forgot this !
“Lived experience” is just a flattering new euphemism for what used to be called anecdotal evidence, and was universally understood to be the lowest quality kind of evidence possible. You cannot reasonably extrapolate, from the personal experiences of a few individuals, filtered through their own subjective interpretation of those experiences, any conclusion that can be applied universally and thus form the basis of public policy. This used to be a thing everybody knew. But that was before pretending not to know things that you know became confused with virtue in some circles.
agree what a shower of numptys they are unbelievable how in hell do they get away with this rambling reading pre written answers Why is the chamber empty are there no msps willing to take part in such a critical process
I'm just so glad my children and grandchildren have left school now. I would be causing havoc now at what's being 'taught'. Shameful. Where are the wise, honourable teachers who refuse to teach things far too advanced for innocent little minds! I despair.
Am I missing something here? That although the four countries of the UK have seperate responsibility for their respective health care, the NHS in each is ostensibly the same. Yet again we have the same old excuse for SNP inactivity or even ploughing a different path. That because this report was commissioned by England it has little or no relevance in Scotland.
Do the SNP and Greens feel that this is the priority of most young people whose votes they are chasing? I would have thought that most young people just want a decent job prospect. One thing for sure is that cheap energy will help industry in Scotland and therefore create the jobs needed for the young.
For this important debate, it’s disgraceful how few politicians are in the house to debate this vital report! And saying it’s an English report is nonsensical. It’s not like Scotland and England are poles apart, scientifically, morally, culturally. There is no solid reason not to implement the conclusions of the Cass Report. ‘Lived experience’ is code for ignoring the science, imo.
Meanwhile, LGBT Youth Scotland is operating in plain sight. If their published brief is ages 13 to 25 (And that’s bad enough), just what are they doing in primary schools?
Get the snp and greens out and save our children from these dangerous so called politicians.
Its really embarrassing how bad Scotland has become under the SNP. At an operating cost of £760 million a year Holyrood is a total waste of money
unbelievable how is this allowed
Just cannot believe they continue, its batshit.
Doctor repeat Doctor Cass produced this report, Patrick Harvie thinks it's wrong,who's the doctor and who's the deviant.
Apparently most in government and institutions!
As pink Floyd said " leave our kids alone"SNP/greens to much interest in our children grandchildren.
Labour no better, women are adult human females and no one is born in the wrong body.
Scottish politics have lost the plot ffs leave our kids alone ,
It’s just another brick in the wall
The waste of money! And lives muddled and - permanently messsed up.
The farce of 'trans'.
Another out of her depth snp minister
Deviant party
Parties.
Shut this circus down Now!!
Just a complete bloody disgrace.
No amount of evidence will ever convince an idiot.
The whole party should be put under a microscope there is something far wrong with these people....
I've honestly never been so concerned about a political party in my entire life than I am the SNP right now, A new controversy every day seems to be coming out about them and their first minister.
This shower should all be jailed. Not obe of them is a credible person. Leave our kids alone
Wait until the harmed children sue the NHS
They will settle before sadly
All the "we're different from England" was kicked off by Sturgeon. Get a 6 year old from Glasgow and a 6 year old from Manchester, then get the SNP clowns to quantify the difference between them.
Obviously they have to be different from England. As if Scottish 'trans' kids suffer different issues from the rest of the UK.
The evidence shows they are harming kids so just why are they so intent on continuing to do so?
Anyone who ever supported the GRA or any trans fetishism is (at best) a fool.
And yet they double down again. Anyone with even a 10th of a loaf in their head would know that puberty blockers are a bad idea. You don't need science or the cass report to come to that conclusion. 🤦🏻
People have been shouting from the roofs on this issue for years!!!
Absolutely this
Stakeholders? Lobbyists.
Who is this freak and how does it find itself in any form of power?
How can the SNP read a 400 page report when they can’t even read one page. They are that thick
Scotland has become an embarrassing joke under the SNP. The Green tail wagging the SNP dog
Scottish Government Clown circus in full bull mode.
There is something very seedy about the SNP/Greens, and what these people see as priorities for the Scottish people. Better quality schools and facilities are needed, not discussions about children's genders. Schools are to there to give our children the best education possible before they go into the workplace, or have we all forgot this !
“Lived experience” is just a flattering new euphemism for what used to be called anecdotal evidence, and was universally understood to be the lowest quality kind of evidence possible. You cannot reasonably extrapolate, from the personal experiences of a few individuals, filtered through their own subjective interpretation of those experiences, any conclusion that can be applied universally and thus form the basis of public policy. This used to be a thing everybody knew. But that was before pretending not to know things that you know became confused with virtue in some circles.
Unbelievable
Straight into blaming the English 🙄🙄🙄
This is just theatre. How can ministers, responding to questions, have ready prepared texts to read from?
agree what a shower of numptys they are unbelievable how in hell do they get away with this rambling reading pre written answers Why is the chamber empty are there no msps willing to take part in such a critical process
Totally out of touch with reality, and don't seem to have the will or ability to tackle more pressing problems.
*gender care*? What's that? Another ruse to fund the medical/industrial complex.
Its becoming a joke, they will take the opposite side to anything that comes from central government...no matter the harm done.
It seems that Scot’s have a different physiology to the rest of Britain.
I'm just so glad my children and grandchildren have left school now. I would be causing havoc now at what's being 'taught'. Shameful. Where are the wise, honourable teachers who refuse to teach things far too advanced for innocent little minds! I despair.
Close holyrood now
Am I missing something here?
That although the four countries of the UK have seperate responsibility for their respective health care, the NHS in each is ostensibly the same.
Yet again we have the same old excuse for SNP inactivity or even ploughing a different path. That because this report was commissioned by England it has little or no relevance in Scotland.
Do the SNP and Greens feel that this is the priority of most young people whose votes they are chasing? I would have thought that most young people just want a decent job prospect. One thing for sure is that cheap energy will help industry in Scotland and therefore create the jobs needed for the young.
They call themselves mothers?
There are no trans communities
A 400 page report? Did the Minister read the report?
Baawwzzz. It’s aw Englands fawt. Ooor trans fowk ur different.
Anything about jobs
SNP GREENS ARE NO MORE
This finnished Nicky and they still can't see it will finnish them, it's over kids go home.
"Oi teacher leave those kids alone "
For this important debate, it’s disgraceful how few politicians are in the house to debate this vital report!
And saying it’s an English report is nonsensical. It’s not like Scotland and England are poles apart, scientifically, morally, culturally. There is no solid reason not to implement the conclusions of the Cass Report. ‘Lived experience’ is code for ignoring the science, imo.
Disgraceful. The Cass report findings should be implemented immediately for the sake of our children. This shitshow makes me so angry.
Right speed????? Speed it up!!!!!
Stakeholders is code for private interests and ngo
Meanwhile, LGBT Youth Scotland is operating in plain sight. If their published brief is ages 13 to 25 (And that’s bad enough), just what are they doing in primary schools?
Is there a duller speaker than Jenni Minto?
Meghan, not Megan, sorry.
Lets pander to the unelected Green Slyme, self preservation at all costs