Love the video! I started listening to GC when I was about 9. Around the time “The Young and the Hopeless” came out. When I got older, I started listening to heavier bands and just stopped paying attention until “Youth Authority” came out. Now at age 31, I owe them a lot that began my love for music.
The first CD I ever owned was The Young and The Hopeless. I don't listen to them as much as I used to (on repeat), but I still listen to CoLD from time to time. Definitely a major influence on my early music interest!
I started listening to good Charlotte in 03. My older friend busted out a cd player on the bus at 6 in the morning and it blew my 11 year old mind. The good Charlotte to MDC pipeline does exist.
It's so funny that Good Charlotte, while not technically punk in the traditional sense, ended up introducing me to a lot of punk I ended up liking..even stuff that was well before their time. Same kinda happened with Nu-metal bands because funnily enough, some of them cited old 80's new wave groups as part of their influence. I've also had my screen name as Evapunk since like the 2000's because of the band Orgy (who has a song called Eva) and because I ended up liking a lot of punk rock music. All music is wonderful because how it makes you feel...that should really be all that matters...
That first band i loved was New found glory. But Good Charlotte was a very close second, especially since they're local to me! MD people stand for each other.
that was enjoyable as always dude!! i can't stand Good Charlotte so you did well to keep my attention. i think i was listening to a lot of Glassjaw at that time...there were SO many bands coming out at that time that all sounded and looked the same. I used to buy dozens of crappy albums trying to find something to relate to! I'll always remember being excited over finding Taking Back Sunday's first album...just couldn't stop listening to it!!
Thanks for checking it out even though you don’t like the band! For real, so many bands. I didn’t know about them back then, though. I think I was like 10 when I heard them and had no idea how to find new music, so I’d just grab random CDs at FYE and listen to the previews haha
I never really thought about Good Charlotte that much but getting a new respect for them knowing where they came from through this video thank you very much
Good, thorough vid man! I was one of those (2 punk 4 Good Charlotte) gatekeepers back in the day. Now I feel bad about it honestly. They’re good musicians who worked their butts off with the same influences that plenty of other bands I listened to had. That “reject the mainstream” narrative of early 2000’s was like a shared form of hysteria. I think we all just tried too hard to be cool back then. I slept on quite a few good artists because of a misguided elitist attitude. Example: just got into plain white T’s in 2024. Also the person who said you have “millennial hair” is super mean. Little comments that cause people to have complexes about their appearance are truly nasty/ not cool.
That's super interesting to get that perspective! I think the irony is that I, as a Good Charlotte fan, also looked down on people who liked different music since I thought I was cooler than them. I've also matured out of that, but it's funny how every group finds some reason to look down on others.
@@soundofhistory_ I think it’s because we were all surrounded by intense gatekeeping, people who made music their whole personalities, and at least among my peers people would gossip about you and shun you in the music scene if you came off like a poser or crossed the wrong person in the little alternative hierarchy. I’m gay and there was a lot of homophobia in the punk/ hardcore/ and metal scenes in my town. I would sometimes over-compensate due to a perceived shortcoming not feeling tough/ masculine. Anything feminine I did made me an emo f slur. There were approved and disapproved of bands. In general the local music scene where I live was toxic as heck. All that said, I’m glad I took part in it and learned how quickly trying to fit in can compromise your self respect.
I don’t know if they’re underrated but I do know that I still get little things stuck in my head every few weeks despite it hearing it in years, that should count for something
I saw Good Charlotte open up for I think Showoff or some other pop punk band in the late 90s. They looked like a buncha preppy/jock dudes playing music that if you squint hard enough could be pop-punk-adjacent. I then saw them at Warped, when The Young & Hopeless or whatever dropped. In just a few short years, it was a total transformation. Sorry, but fuck this band.
Well YES and no, no because its 2024 and they…dont have any new music (without Petty Hendrix remix) BUT… BUT, yes… because they are awesome boys(mens), who sing about current(actial) topic… and they pulled me out verrrrrrrrrry sad period on my life(well not me only). And…AND…they are awesome in 2024 and so on 2000… ohhh. So yeah, we all LOVE GC and cant wait for TOUR. (And of course Im from Latvia❤). And yeah, Im listening(and my fav.group all the time) GC from 2000 years… much and strong love… Waiting u in L A T V I A❤️
I really loved their first album. The second was pop-fun and LAZY guitars (Ughhhh 😮). Rest I just couldn’t stand. I tried. But nothing hit like their first
I like how it’s just implied that Benji’s relationship with Hillary caused her major trauma while speaking about how their families are close and they’re lifelong friends…what?
Definitely didn’t imply that. It was Joel, not Benji. Current friends does not equal lifelong friends. Current friends doesn’t always equal no past issues. I think you might need to rewatch that part
@@soundofhistory_ yea my bad on Joel/Benji mixup there. What I don't understand is considering all the surrounding info provided regarding the relationship, given the mother was the one to make it public (indicating she was happy to announce it one year later), Hillary saying he treated her better than any boyfriend she had prior, they remain friends nearly two decades later...where are the indications that would necessitate bringing up ideas of trauma that needed working through? Or indications that her being treated well was just PR talk instead of the truth (beyond normal/healhty relationship challenges where everyone throws up a facade publicly)? It's just very odd to say that everyone including immediate family was happy with the relationship, but throw in implications that there was trauma that needed working through. Where the trauma comes in to play is what's stumping me.
@@KPtheViewer The PR talk came up because she said it wasn't physical when she was a Disney actress and later, as an adult, said it definitely was. The idea that there might be trauma to work through comes from the fact that he was a 25 year-old full adult and she was a highschooler.
@@evapunk522 Why would I care about a corporate band who's implicit purpose of existing was to make a record label money and bank on a trend? Awful people. Hollow shallow and meaningless.
They were very much "over rated" one good album and forgettable would be what I rate them as, I still listen to a lot of music of that genre and era but not GC....
Love the video! I started listening to GC when I was about 9. Around the time “The Young and the Hopeless” came out. When I got older, I started listening to heavier bands and just stopped paying attention until “Youth Authority” came out.
Now at age 31, I owe them a lot that began my love for music.
The first CD I ever owned was The Young and The Hopeless. I don't listen to them as much as I used to (on repeat), but I still listen to CoLD from time to time. Definitely a major influence on my early music interest!
Sounds a lot like my story, honestly
I started listening to good Charlotte in 03. My older friend busted out a cd player on the bus at 6 in the morning and it blew my 11 year old mind. The good Charlotte to MDC pipeline does exist.
"Music for 11 year old children" is def the best description I've ever heard for Good Charlotte
@xp8969 lol yeah I kinda feel that way too
It's so funny that Good Charlotte, while not technically punk in the traditional sense, ended up introducing me to a lot of punk I ended up liking..even stuff that was well before their time. Same kinda happened with Nu-metal bands because funnily enough, some of them cited old 80's new wave groups as part of their influence. I've also had my screen name as Evapunk since like the 2000's because of the band Orgy (who has a song called Eva) and because I ended up liking a lot of punk rock music. All music is wonderful because how it makes you feel...that should really be all that matters...
Good Charlotte was on my birthday cake every year from age 11-14.
That first band i loved was New found glory. But Good Charlotte was a very close second, especially since they're local to me! MD people stand for each other.
I think their sister is named Sarah.
that was enjoyable as always dude!! i can't stand Good Charlotte so you did well to keep my attention. i think i was listening to a lot of Glassjaw at that time...there were SO many bands coming out at that time that all sounded and looked the same. I used to buy dozens of crappy albums trying to find something to relate to! I'll always remember being excited over finding Taking Back Sunday's first album...just couldn't stop listening to it!!
Thanks for checking it out even though you don’t like the band!
For real, so many bands. I didn’t know about them back then, though. I think I was like 10 when I heard them and had no idea how to find new music, so I’d just grab random CDs at FYE and listen to the previews haha
Glassjaw was my go to back then 🤘 I still listen to them all the time.
first time seeing a video on this your channel. you reminded me of charlie day haha.... goood video bro keep up the good work
There’s worse people to be compared to, I’ll take it haha
cheers for this dude, btw I wish I still had hair like you !! :)
Thank you!
I never really thought about Good Charlotte that much but getting a new respect for them knowing where they came from through this video thank you very much
I love the first GC album. It's always been their best work, I think.
Never once heard anyone use the words “nu-metal” and “Nine Inch Nails” in the same sentence
Good Charlotte is a Good pop punk band ever
i also first heard of them, when their song "the click" was used as the theme song on the tv show "undergrads"
Good, thorough vid man! I was one of those (2 punk 4 Good Charlotte) gatekeepers back in the day. Now I feel bad about it honestly. They’re good musicians who worked their butts off with the same influences that plenty of other bands I listened to had. That “reject the mainstream” narrative of early 2000’s was like a shared form of hysteria. I think we all just tried too hard to be cool back then. I slept on quite a few good artists because of a misguided elitist attitude. Example: just got into plain white T’s in 2024. Also the person who said you have “millennial hair” is super mean. Little comments that cause people to have complexes about their appearance are truly nasty/ not cool.
That's super interesting to get that perspective! I think the irony is that I, as a Good Charlotte fan, also looked down on people who liked different music since I thought I was cooler than them. I've also matured out of that, but it's funny how every group finds some reason to look down on others.
@@soundofhistory_ I think it’s because we were all surrounded by intense gatekeeping, people who made music their whole personalities, and at least among my peers people would gossip about you and shun you in the music scene if you came off like a poser or crossed the wrong person in the little alternative hierarchy. I’m gay and there was a lot of homophobia in the punk/ hardcore/ and metal scenes in my town. I would sometimes over-compensate due to a perceived shortcoming not feeling tough/ masculine. Anything feminine I did made me an emo f slur. There were approved and disapproved of bands. In general the local music scene where I live was toxic as heck. All that said, I’m glad I took part in it and learned how quickly trying to fit in can compromise your self respect.
I don’t know if they’re underrated but I do know that I still get little things stuck in my head every few weeks despite it hearing it in years, that should count for something
I saw Good Charlotte open up for I think Showoff or some other pop punk band in the late 90s. They looked like a buncha preppy/jock dudes playing music that if you squint hard enough could be pop-punk-adjacent.
I then saw them at Warped, when The Young & Hopeless or whatever dropped. In just a few short years, it was a total transformation.
Sorry, but fuck this band.
I mean my style also changed a lot from the ages of 17-22 but to each their own
@@soundofhistory_ Sure but your style may not have included terrible music at every turn.
I think that’s very subjective. Don’t know that I’d ever call music someone likes terrible. Life is short, enjoy the music you like while you’re here
I'm still detoxing from haterade, but you're right.
Haha no worries!
you said you don't listen to them anymore, do you ever put an album on? or just not your thing anymore?
I’ll occasionally throw on one of the first two albums, especially since I have those on vinyl, but they aren’t part of my regular rotation at all
Well YES and no, no because its 2024 and they…dont have any new music (without Petty Hendrix remix) BUT… BUT, yes… because they are awesome boys(mens), who sing about current(actial) topic… and they pulled me out verrrrrrrrrry sad period on my life(well not me only). And…AND…they are awesome in 2024 and so on 2000… ohhh. So yeah, we all LOVE GC and cant wait for TOUR. (And of course Im from Latvia❤). And yeah, Im listening(and my fav.group all the time) GC from 2000 years… much and strong love… Waiting u in L A T V I A❤️
I really loved their first album. The second was pop-fun and LAZY guitars (Ughhhh 😮). Rest I just couldn’t stand. I tried. But nothing hit like their first
Who said they're underrated? Sony Music? Or having sold 10 million records?
Did you watch the end of the video?
Oh man, Good Charlotte: they were, and always will be, hilariously bad.
Great video though!
I like how it’s just implied that Benji’s relationship with Hillary caused her major trauma while speaking about how their families are close and they’re lifelong friends…what?
Definitely didn’t imply that. It was Joel, not Benji. Current friends does not equal lifelong friends. Current friends doesn’t always equal no past issues. I think you might need to rewatch that part
@@soundofhistory_ yea my bad on Joel/Benji mixup there. What I don't understand is considering all the surrounding info provided regarding the relationship, given the mother was the one to make it public (indicating she was happy to announce it one year later), Hillary saying he treated her better than any boyfriend she had prior, they remain friends nearly two decades later...where are the indications that would necessitate bringing up ideas of trauma that needed working through? Or indications that her being treated well was just PR talk instead of the truth (beyond normal/healhty relationship challenges where everyone throws up a facade publicly)?
It's just very odd to say that everyone including immediate family was happy with the relationship, but throw in implications that there was trauma that needed working through. Where the trauma comes in to play is what's stumping me.
@@KPtheViewer The PR talk came up because she said it wasn't physical when she was a Disney actress and later, as an adult, said it definitely was. The idea that there might be trauma to work through comes from the fact that he was a 25 year-old full adult and she was a highschooler.
bad charlatan
corporate band
Damn..the band is super old now and y'all still carry the hatred? Like fr..get over bro..
@@evapunk522 Why would I care about a corporate band who's implicit purpose of existing was to make a record label money and bank on a trend? Awful people. Hollow shallow and meaningless.
They were very much "over rated" one good album and forgettable would be what I rate them as, I still listen to a lot of music of that genre and era but not GC....