It's just more focalized on writing experience. I've bought a Boox because I primary use it to read off manuals but I still consider remarkable for the future as a paper replacement
I think its a more niche product for sure. I bought it because I'm a stem student with many notebooks of notes and scratch work. The reason I chose it over everything else is because of the battery life so I accept the devices limitations as I understand that they are in place to maximize its specialty.
I’ve been shopping for a tablet like this for sometime and I see the value in the ones that offer more services for the price point. The thing I really like about the remarkable 2 is the pen to paper feel experience and believe it or not the fact that there are no other apps. It is meant to simply replace a notepad and I kind of like that because it’s mindful when there are other apps involved it’s very tempting to take your focus away from what you’re doing. Part of me feels like that’s worth the money but then another part of me feels like I’m not getting as much for my dollar. This is why I haven’t gotten anything yet.
But think of it this way, are you really gonna be using social media and apps like that on this screen to be distracted like that? I think the screen and how it behaves is a big deterrent for getting distracted like that and you can download other apps that you can use to take full advantage of that, the part where they leave that out and say it's for focus just feels like a cover up for their short coming
I think that’s everyone’s dilemma. I played with a remarkable recently at Best Buy and really enjoyed it. 2 weeks later I bought the remarkable, I’m like 3 days in and love it, and even though they’ve added a lot of features that weren’t available at the time of review, pretty old videos now. Despite the additional features I still have a hard time justifying the price. $500 out the door is what I paid for an iPad Pro that I love and worth every penny. But with the remarkable, I’m both missing features and money… Sad to say, I’ll be returning the remarkable
I can't believe the one thing that literally everybody is asking for is writing feel on the onyx glass surface in comparison to remarkable surface. It's like you're deliberately not mentioning this on both note air reviews
Also why are speeding the footage of you writing on both devices. This is the part where we check latency. Peter you should check other reviews about eink and learn what matters in these devices.
You know, I thought it was weird that they started the video by insisting on their impartiality. I wonder if reviewers want to have access to future Onyx devices because Onyx puts out so many-thus, more content. If so, rM is at a disadvantage with these folks, as rM does not rotate through models all of the time. Or, maybe it’s something el$e.
As an "overall" device the Onyx Boox Note Air makes way more sense. But there's something about the reMarkable that makes it more appealing to me as a specialized device meant for a specific purpose without distractions.
It truly makes a huge difference when you think man I should change to my email and check it but you can't. Keeps you focused. The drawing ability on remarkable is amazing I have to have tilt
I started to think about this too. I am in the market right now and the moment it was mentioned the Onyx Air running Android (basically) I was like, wait! I thought the point was to get away from notifications and these apps! I feel like this would (having Android) keep me from buying an eInk device. The point was to get away from android and distractions not buy more devices with distractions. This video has made me feel that Remarkable is the better option..
Having seen (and read) many reviews of the reMarkable2, I bought one. Like anyone who's ever tried it, I was blown away by the writing experience, but I quickly began to have doubts. While the hardware is beautiful, the software felt very lacking, and, as I dug around online, I soon realised that the company has not kept up with the competition in that area. Furthermore they did not seem very willing to engage with customers or open up any kind of roadmap on future developments. I decided, therefore, to try out the Box Note Air and make a decision thereafter on how to proceed. Long story short, he Note Air has been everything I'd hoped for and then some. I had grave concerns that comparing it directly with the reMarkable 2 would leave me disappointed (to the point where I might actually consider keeping both devices). The stylus that comes with the Air is far from the best so I tested with both reMarkable and Lamy pens and have been delighted with the results. The Air doesn't provide tilt functionality for the stylus but that doesn't matter to me. The writing experience on the RM2 is only marginally better, and certainly not noticeable on a day-to-day basis. Given everything else that the Boox software brings to the table the decision was a trivial one. I know it's been a long time since this video was posted, but I discovered it - and its legion of comments - just last week while deciding whether to try the Note Air. Thanks to My Deep Guide I did just that, and will be forever grateful. I hope that the reMarkable team listens closely and addresses the concerns of the money-paying community because they provide an incredible device withe immensely underpowered software. In the meantime I'll keep scribbling away on my Box Note Air with a big smile on my face.
Thank you for your detailed comments. I just got my Remarkable 2 this week and so far it's ok. However, I just ordered the boox note air and can't wait to compare the two.
I recently lost my beloved Onyx Poke 3 reader and want to replace it with something I can also use for journalling. This was a very helpful comment. Thank you!
Hi, morning! I'm really unsure between the RM2 and the note airc 3 C. My idea is to replace my college notebooks. I need to read and write it in PDF and attach some photos that I take of the whiteboard. I don't know if the NA3C has the same feeling of writing on paper that the RM2 has. What would you advise me?
@@marcelomonteirocarvalho5137 The newer Note Airs - the 2 and the 3 - have a great writing feel, at least as good as the RM2 in my experience. With the Airs you also get a lot of functionality and extensibility with apps.
The thing Remarkable is focusing on the most is the writing feel. They are very explicit about it. Why don't you compare that in your impartial comparison?
Absolutely! That's like comparing a Tour de France race bike with some cheap Mountainbike and then saying "O k , - this is better because it offers the possibility to do some offroad.... " Don't get me wrong, I do love my Onyx Note, but we still did not have any information about WRITING EXPERIENCE NOW!
Yeah! I wonder why they are voluntarily not reviewing and comparing the writing feel or experience. Since they are the only ones in posession of a Note Air... maybe Onyx gave them that explicit restriction? I mean come on, they even fast forwarded all writing examples in their last "review". Anyway, what a waste of an opportunity! I do want to know if that shock in the mountain bike is comfortable enough to be worth it or if I should keep my road bike for commuting. This not so impartial review makes me kind of angry
The writing feel is not a great difference, but the rest of the device ... yes. And that is not an excuse for that price ... If you only care about writing or you use a paper or a h10l LCD Writing Tablet ...
@@Maisonier it is for some of us unfortunately my friend. I feel miserable writing on a glassy Galaxy Note surface, but also having a pile of paper notebooks ain't fun either
Can you say something about the following points: 1. Battery usage (life time, loading time, usage time) 2. weight and grip 3. writing surface 4. using the onyx without backlight (reading quality) 5. are there differend highlighter colors with onyx (as - virtually - with remarkable)? Thanks!
Guys, you're missing the point. You're comparing a feature intensive device with a device built just for a single purpose: to perfectly replicate the feeling of writing on paper. You didn't compare this aspect at all. Onyx has a glass screen whole the remarkable works with a flexible display, which should mean that right out the gate, the writing experience with the two should be vastly different. Also, writing latency. What are the exact numbers for the boox note air vs 21 ms in rM 2? Granted, rM2 could use better software, but as far as the hardware goes, how do these two compare? What's the build quality like? How durable are they? Which one can take accidental falls better than the other? Also, VERY IMPORTANT: how do the battery lifes compare?
rM uses also glass and has a 27ms latency. The hardware is cheaper on the rM2. Compare the specs and the size and you will see how they lie. Or do you really believe they can't fit something like a uSD card or similar with more than 8GB somewhere to mention only one point.
I don’t want to watch videos, listen to music or read emails my notebook. That’s what my iPad is for. I want to know what the writing experience is like.
@@greenboarder89 It's s a very different experience and purpose. The intent of the Rm2 is to provide you with a possibility to take notes and work with your thoughs. That is why they do not put any distractions but focus on things like battery longevity (last 1 week when used), writing experience, thin product. The fondamental purpose of an ipad and Rm are different. With the ipad you write on glass it is not as nice but the initial purpose of an ipad is not to enable you to be with your thoughts or take notes. Rm is not for you if you want a device to do many different things.
Straight feature comparison? Sure. Note Air wins. But the rM2 isn't trying to be an all-encompassing tablet like the Note Air. So it's a little of an unfair comparison due to different use cases. I will say - this seems like an obvious biased video since you sell the Note Air but not the rM on your store. You're stoking this fire of giving a comparison on a surface level and not doing what people really want: comparing the note taking features and feel.
That’s right. Part of it might be that Goodereader doesn’t like that they cannot sell the reMarkable yet. That sped-up writing at the end was surprisingly shady.
I don’t think this is biased at all, wish this video was out when I bought the remarkable2. Just gonna copy my comment to other ppl: I just received my remarkable2 yesterday and am so frustrated with it already I had put in the return request. No matter how good it feels to write on it, it’s just impossible for me to utilize it because how bad it is to read! The table of content is so bad it drives me nuts! If you want to take notes on PDF slides it’ll be impossible to navigate if it’s a big document with more pages. Also PDFed books obviously becomes very small so it ends up straining my eyes anyways.. zoom is a joke. Impossible to use. I can tolerate the small fonts while reading, but I cannot tolerate having no way of navigating to the page I want to read. There’s no point of paying that much money for a note pad that’s harder to find things than on paper. Lol I found myself watching more reviews this morning and left a few messages under these videos, I don’t usually do this, I guess I am REALLY frustrated with remarkable2. I waited 5 month for it since the Pre-order, imagine my disappointment!!!
Hi, couple questions: - What's the erasing function like on the Onyx over the reMarkable? - How does the response speed of the screens during writing and drawing compare? - How does the writing feeling of both devices compare?
About for first question: I've already watched other reviews: As always, the standard pen does not feature an eraser on the back, on both devices. If you preordered the rM2 with the discount, where you got the $100 pencil for free, THAT does have an eraser on the back. The expensive pencil with an eraser from boox costs "only" $60 in comparison. If you question was about the performance of erasing... I guess it's the same, but maybe you should look through other reviews yourself to confirm if it suits your expectation. About the feel: Just found a comment from him Goodereader vor 1 Stunde they are both running glass so they are fairly identical. the days of comparing glass vs non-glass seem to be behind us. Almost no one uses non-glass screens anymore. if you want the real answer, look for the comment from "Luiz Silva"
Sadly the feel is a taste and you have to try them out. So even if one wins in a review maybe you wont like it at all. Due to environmental reason's and some others I cancelled my rM2. I know allready I would send it back even if it feels superb. You also can not compare them because the glass surface is different and also the nibs are different. You need to cross test it at least. For example, I'am thinking of getting the rM2 pro pen for my Air.
In the PDF, the RM2 looks like it has deeper blacks and whiter whites. Is that just due to the settings on the Boox Note Air? Or an artifact of the camera? To be honest, the RM2 looks so much clearer and better than the Note Air.
I have an onyx nova 2 and the contrast does not make a deeper Black. It only helps to visualize a better image. I have this same feel that remarkable 2 has a deeper black and best white screen . I feel the light on my onyx is useful but not essential.
I was really hoping that around 11:00 you would have shown the note taking in real time. My biggest question was about the response of the tablet with the writing. :(
How does the air feel?????? This seems to be a major question that many users have (as well as myself). All the bells and whistles aren't worth much to me if it doesn't feel good to write on.
Just found a comment from him Goodereader vor 1 Stunde they are both running glass so they are fairly identical. the days of comparing glass vs non-glass seem to be behind us. Almost no one uses non-glass screens anymore. if you want the real answer, look for the comment from "Luiz Silva"
Feels good to write on, screen is "grippy" and the new pen has a hard nib. New pen maybe too hard for my liking, swapped it out for a tab s3 pen with hard nib, like that combo better. Air pen feels great on my max3 tho 👍
Disappointed with the review. In reality the one deciding factor that could possibly sway a decision to purchase the RM2 over the Air was overlooked. The whole writing element was fast forwarded and confined to a few seconds at the end of the video. Please provide a proper demonstration of both of the tablets writing capabilities side by side so that those who wish to purchase the highest quality writing and sketching tool can make an informed decision. I appreciate the upload but this did not tell us anything that we did not already know. Can the Air search written notes? Is the RM2 writing experience superior or not? (With clear video evidence)
I don’t think the majority of people are buying tablets to do primarily writing. Just do it on paper, I’m more interested in the features of the actual device
@@revl6151 Uhm - but THIS is exactly the most important point of the remarkable: It does NOT want to be a tablet - it wants to be a digital version of paper - real ePaper. If you ignore the main purpose of a product... why bothering at all? Why being interested in remarkable? And why suggest people exactly the opposite of what they want and why they are being interested in the remarkable? Being interested in remarkable means being interested in finding a digital alternativ to paper. How can someone be so ignorant to tell the people exactly not taking the one function a product is about without any reason?
I just received my remarkable2 yesterday and am so frustrated with it already I had put in the return request. No matter how good it feels to write on it, it’s just impossible for me to utilize it because how bad it is to read! The table of content is so bad it drives me nuts! If you want to take notes on PDF slides it’ll be impossible to navigate if it’s a big document with more pages. Also PDFed books obviously becomes very small so it ends up straining my eyes anyways.. zoom is a joke. Impossible to use. I can tolerate the small fonts while reading, but I cannot tolerate having no way of navigating to the page I want to read. There’s no point of paying that much money for a note pad that’s harder to find things than on paper. Lol I found myself watching more reviews this morning and left a few messages under these videos, I don’t usually do this, I guess I am REALLY frustrated with remarkable2. I waited 5 month for it since the Pre-order, imagine my disappointment!!!
I have a ReMarkable 1 and absolutely love it. I'm a nursing student so I take lots and lots of notes and I love how I can just carry one light device instead of a giant notebook. Even though the speed is a little slow when flipping pages/opening documents, the writing speed from pen to device is perfect. It never lags for me. Honestly I like the ReMarkable more because it doesn't have all the other features to distract me.
whaaaaaaaaaaa whaaaaaaaaaa whaaaa.. traioning to hurt ppl much??? you wont even know what im saying but instead of elevating your feelings. you should mauybe learn
@@SashiroKun He isn't really selling both. He may have both listed, but he doesn't have any Remarkable 2s. If you order a Remarkable 2, it is not available until February 2021 and it is way more expensive then going to the Remarkable website. My guess, if someone did buy from him, he would buy from the Remarkable store and ship it, when he got it, for a nice markup. Looking at his site, it would be $300 more than what I paid for mine, to order form him. Now I am guessing about how he gets his, but it would be $300, more than what I paid for mine, including shipping.
I guess he was using it on the highest latency mode. As he said, you can switch to X Mode, which gives you the lowest latency on any device. - I just take a bold guess and expect that to be the same for the writing
@@ximaxwellix Screen latency and writing delay is not the same. If the delay through software is long when processing the pen location data, it really is just a matter of a further delay to make it visible. The delay in pen tracking is devastating since it can make your handwriting complete rubbish. The screen latency is an annoyance with you feedback loop into your brain. Both needs to be short... Just try different note apps on an iPad and you will see what I mean, for the same - very fast screen - the feel of writing can go from "sucks" to "okey" between programs, and of all of the IOS apps, only a few comes near the responsiveness needed. I have tried them all... I *hope* the rM will be good enough. The eInk devices I have had a number of years, have not been good enough. Neither have the iPad Pro 2017 or 2020 (I have them both and use them a LOT, but not for notetaking, still doing that on paper).
Does anyone that has RM2 or Onyx, how does it work when writing? When I write on paper, I tend to rest the palm on the paper itself. Would this interfere in the e-ink devices?? It's something I've always wondered. In the video, it seems Peter writes without touching with the palm, of course. Only with the pen. Would appreciate your insights. Thanks.
I get that the reviewer values functionality in e-ink devices, but that really doesn't do justice for a large fraction of people interested in such devices. A lot of them value the writing experience/feel over functionality. As a reviewer you should consider that.
For everyone asking. I've used both for about 4 months. (I was indecisive & got both). The remarkable 2 hands down is a better writing experience. It's almost indescribable. It doesn't feel like you are writing on paper. It feels, in a word, better. Sure the boox can do a great deal more but that's specifically what the rm2 focuses on NOT doing. As a writer, I was stuck in the mud between writing on paper & typing on a computer. Sure, writing was nice but it wasn't portable & transcribing it was a chore. I'd spend hours speaking through dragon to have it type it up for me. Typing wasn't a good creative medium for me either. The rm2 let me go for hours just writing & when I was finished the transcription rate was about 98% (I have terrible handwriting) accurate. The boox had significantly for trouble recognizing my handwriting. For the bang & the buck go ipad pro. For a true writing e-ink experience, rm2. P. S. The battery life on boox was trash in comparison.
As a college student, I actually prefer the simplicity of the remarkable 2. Recently purchased mine, and it's great. I know myself all too well and I know that if my tablet had access to internet and apps like Facebook I will easily get distracted instead of using the device as I intended at purchase; to take notes during class without needing to deal with an abundance of paper.
This is my thinking ad well. As tempted as I am to get the Boox, I know that my main thing that I want is note taking and doodling. Any other features are going to distract me. Thank you for giving your input. I think you may have just solidified my decision. ♥️
I purchased a SuperNote (instead of a Remarkable) based off the comparison video you posted and I was actually disappointed with it. I have a friend with a Remarkable and I found it much better. I am going with the Remarkable 2 this time. I have a Samsung tablet to do all the multimedia stuff and I just want a no-distraction tool/device for annotating and study purposes. I appreciate the review though, it gives viewers a reasonable idea of the capabilities of these two EInk devices.
If you want it for anotating, the onyx air is better device because it works with books and pdfs better. Remarkable is really just for notes and drawing.
@Lauren Maxwell I didn't like the cloud service, not only was it ridiculously slow but VERY unreliable. I am also concerned about the location of the cloud servers (CCP China). I found the SuperNote to have slow responsiveness and the stylus was not as close to a pen/pencil-paper writing experience as the Remarkable. The SuperNote also had OS bugs that were not horrible but annoying (e.g., the odd freeze, interference from the OS overlay while writing in documents). Lastly I found that not all of the advertised features worked as it was advertised (not on the video by this channel but as advertised in other locations). I pre-ordered a Remarkable 2, so here's 🤞🤞that it lives up to its reputation.
I have a Remarkable 2 and I use it for doing work, not interested in the distraction of internet. For play and other features I use an iPad. I want to see documents in PDF and I want to work freehand and like the organization of Remarkable. I got it because working with a pen on the glass of my iPad I did not care for, I like the feel of the Remarkable, very paper and pencil like tactile experience.
I pre-ordered RM2 (batch 7) and I'm trying to understand if it fits my needs or I should switch to onyx note air. this review however looks to me a bit unfair (and therefore useless) as it does not expressly take into account the peculiar aspect of the RM2 (hand writing) whilst it considers bell and whistles that nothing has to share with note taking. to the same extent, it would be unfair (if not correctly carried on) a comparison between note air and iPad pro...
my advice : if you can, then you should wait (until november) for your rm2. it’s the best note taker in the market. it’s going to be totally worth it so hang in there :)
On the iPad Pro I have tried every note taking app there is, and most fail due delays in software between samples of pen location making the writing look totally off compared to paper. Just shut your eyes and write in the app and on paper and compare them, that part has nothing to do with screen latency. Then screen latency is added ontop and makes the visual feedback loop a bit annoying. If both these types of delays are dealt with combined with precision of pen location, then you will have a great writing experience. Additionally distance between image and surface creates a parallax error, contrast and light source/reflection, hardness of surface and sound and feel between pen and surface... Writing on iPad glass is not ideal in any way, but the Apple pencil in itself is near perfect. Paperlike screen protector helps somewhat. I will keep using my iPad Pro 2017 and 2020, a lot! They are more important to me than all my other desktop or laptop computers... AND I wait eagerly to recieve my rM2 which should arrive within the next few weeks...
Unbiased review from someone who doesn't actually take notes or draw, you mean. Remarkable is has almost inperseptable latency. Which is not only better than the Onyx, but a key feature. And the lack of internet is a feature also.
I'm glad I'm not the only one who sees this. The Note Air is very tempting because it's jam-packed with lots of neat features, especially split-screen. My problem is that *ANY* device I *CAN* watch youtube or browse the web on will become a device used *only* for those purposes. I sorely need a distraction-free device. Sad, but true.
@@RamLaska I have a rm1 and I really want to love it, but there are so many features that onyx has and remarkable hasn't. And I don't talk about a browser or apps or stuff like that, but simple shapes like a line, a triangle, etc. or pinch and zoom or insert a picture to your notes. Remarkable has a huge lack on software and I'm not the only one who thinks about it that way, there is a whole community on reddit that is working on hacks and workarounds to make it a better device. I don't need a browser, I'd also be ok with that very simple "ebook reader", but remarkable has to work on their software and add the few really simple but necessary features. It's a shame that this wonderful piece of hardware fails because it hasn't a solid software. But instead of listening to the costumers and adding this few elementery features they just do nothing and keep saying that it's the philosophy of their device.
@@heiligerklabautermann Remarkable really needs to publish a roadmap. They're far too secretive and Apple-like. Being Apple-like works for apple, but they don't have the clout or the cash for quite that much haughtiness.
@@RamLaska that's right, I think without a roadmap they will loose a lot of costumers/potential costumers. If I knew they are working this or that feature, I'd wait for it. But instead they don't say anything about it and leave the costumers in a situation where they are just standing in the rain. I personally have ordered a note air, not because I love the company or what they stand for, but remarkables lack of the few elementary features kills my workflow in so many ways and I think note air will fit better to my usage. It's a shame because as I said, I really love the hardware especially the writing experience of remarkable, but there are so many moments in which I just hate it for being so limited.
@@heiligerklabautermann I'm thinking about the Note Air, too. One new wrinkle I've just found out about is that Onyx isn't posting their source code faithfully/regularly. So, they're benefitting from others' work, but not sharing their modifications. Remarkable is quite faithful to post their code and even make the device open enough to allow hacks and things like that for new functionality. Of course, I'd rather the functionality just *be there*, rather than rely on hacks. We'll see where this goes. I'm looking forward to seeing an in-depth review of the Note Air from My Deep Guide, and a comparison with the rM2.
What I like about the reMarkable 2 is that very fact that it doesn't have all of the bells and whistles that the Onyx offers. I have used both devices and I can tell you that the Onyx feels like a device from the past. It literally feels like an old B&W Macintosh and it completely takes away the whole "futuristic" feel of the device. The rM2 on the other hand truly feels like a brand new type of device. True, the Onyx may have more features, but the battery life falls very short compared to the reMarkable 2. The reMarkable 2 has a better feel when writing compared to the Onyx. One thing that I noticed with the Onyx is that you really get tired of using it. I mean, it literally makes you want to put down the device and write on a real piece of paper. By contrast, you don't get tired of using the reMarkable. The entire experience of writing on a tablet becomes very enjoyable with the reMarkable. In my opinion, the reMarkable is the right choice. (it also looks and feels way more professional)
To those wondering about the whole return policy and how long it will take to get your money back, it took me exactly 30 days from the day the item was received at their facilities. I live in Australasia. Very credible company. And if the item wasn't so niche I would have kept it. The technology is phenomenal! And I would rank the brand up there with Apple in terms of service presentation and being environmentally conscious.
I think this was a bit too hard on the Remarkable... the one thing it has been created for is the feeling of writing on paper with a pencil. This is something Remarkable does best, period. Getting close to this (not even matching) with the Onyx requires buying a different pen with softer nibs and third party screen protectors. For everything else, OBNAir is just an other league, a different product. I have tried the Remarkable from a colleague that is totally in love with it, but I have chosen the Onyx because I need my notes to be sent by email quickly and for the possibility to review documents selecting the text to add notes is a game changer. Backlight makes it better than paper, the possibility to check emails is crucial, apps or browsing are just a plus, but very welcome.
Excellent comparison of 2 direct competitors. Note Air is an excellent allrounder but Elnk devices, at least for me should be firstly defined through the write feel, then features (otherwise a Tab S6-S7\Ipad are the clear winner with the exception of the screen) Q: how does the write feel compare with Remarkable 2, which until now was mentioned to be best in business?
I had the same mindset, but since the lack of features on the rM1 requires me to always carry a tablet with me, it would be better FOR ME to choose the Boox Air, because it will shrink my needed devices to one. I can trade in some writing feel. But I was going back and forth with that decision for 2 weeks now. But once I came to the point what the rM2 improves over the rM1, it didn't really feel right to upgrade something for 450€, I didn't have a problem with in the first place. [Edit:] So as of now... IMO: Buying the rM2 feels more like buying the newest iPhone, Galaxy, Pixel, etc. - do you have a problem with your current phone, that the new one will fix? No. So why would I pay so much money for something I don't need. Yea and that was basically the point where I decided yesterday, I'm gonna cancel. As a student, I can use the money in a better way in these times. BTW! Please consider, that the rM2 is nothing else than a technical upgrade and I even believe that we already got a rM1 vs. rM2 comparision, saying that the canvas display of the rM2 is slightly less paper-like than the rM1. Would need someone to confirm tho. And if that is the case, you need to consider if you need a technical upgrade of the rM1.
@@ximaxwellix personally, I could say I am drooling for Remarkable since V1. Nevertheless the points mentioned by you are exactly the reason why I waited. With RM2, I wanted to see a bit more functionality; but, the writing feel is for me the most important aspect for buying a elnk device that costs as much as a tablet. Now if the Onyx Note Air, has the same feel as for example Ipad/Samsung, because is glass only, then only Remarkable remains. IF Onyx mimics a write on paper feel in an acceptable way then as @Goodreads mentioned, Onyx Note Air is just in another league
Just found a comment from him Goodereader vor 1 Stunde they are both running glass so they are fairly identical. the days of comparing glass vs non-glass seem to be behind us. Almost no one uses non-glass screens anymore. if you want the real answer, look for the comment from "Luiz Silva"
“Pretty unbiased when it comes to these devices” “But when the onyx books air came out it absolutely destroyed the remarkable” “There’s absolutely nothing about the remarkable that is better than the onyx” Also includes a sponsor from Onyx Note in description, but not remarkable. ...
I love the fact that the Onyx is based on Android and lets you treat it like a tablet. But... The Remarkable has a noticeably brighter screen when no glow light is active on the Onyx. I really don't like the extra layer and the dimming that the front lighting on any e-ink device provides. Let the screen act like paper and turn on your reading light.
Why would I use the Eink device as a monitor or watching videos or listening to music? I think it should be as simple as a piece of paper. Your cheap iPad will do other things much better.
Completely agree. Although it's nice to have kindle on it. And probably even listen to audiobooks or music while using (although for audio I would probably use my phone instead).
3 things I think was missing. How you do manage files on each? Is it easy to manage folders. Is there an easy backup of the files incase you break or loose the device. What is the latency like when drawing. Does the device keep up with the pen?
I use both , feelings when you write on reMakable is a lot more better for that reason alone reMakable win for me i just need to on paper carry a lot document I can do anything else boox do on ipad
Thanks for the review :D Any comments or the "paper feeling" when writing on them? Which one has more friction and precision? Which one is best when writing small letters? Or, an unfair question, which one is closest to pen/pencil on paper (unfair because that would havily depend on the paper and pen/pencil, so it may the worth to specify to which combination is the closest).
That would interest me too. Multimedia features I can have enough on m phone or other devices. I want this thing for basic note taking and se the feeling of writing on it is more important to me. Would love a comparison for this aspect.
they are both running glass so they are fairly identical. the days of comparing glass vs non-glass seem to be behind us. Almost no one uses non-glass screens anymore.
@@goodereader Screen on Remarkable has a special coating. So You really shouldn't write that it's just a glass because You suggest that is has a very smooth, glassy surface like iPad. All the other Remarkable reviews claim the writing feel is good or even great, much better than all the other "glass" devices.
The thing is I have a laptop/tablet so If I wanna do anything internet related I can just use that, that is the same for many. So to me the remarkable is the right choice because I don't need another tablet like device. In fact I like that it's only for note taking. This may be reaching but because it is far more simple it may last me more years, hopefully through undergrad and med school.
Hi, congratulations for your channel. I have a question; You can write over the epubs directly with pen as in PDF. Is it possible write in EPUBS with pen directly as in PDF to take notes, or underline...etc? thanks.
Note air placement of power button and USB port is really odd. Does it interfere with using folio case? Also does power button gets accidentally triggered when using with a bluetooth keyboard? What about the writing experience? Is glass surface slippery? I do agree specwise, Note air is ahead, but question the usability. Most likely end up with Note Air because of crappy reader software on RM2.
It's great to see a direct comparison! Both of these have similar designs, but appeal to different target audiences. reMarkable is more popular* and provides a focused experience, while BOOX is less popular but provides a more open experience that appeals more to someone like me who wants to read more kinds of content, including DRM-protected e-books, which includes content from major publishers, across many e-book platforms, even those without dedicated e-readers. *This, at least for me, affects things like the availablity of third-party accessories and note templates.
Definitely would not claim that ReMarkable is more popular. It is praised by a very tiny minority who want nothing more than a very expensive digital notepad for their own specific reasons. Onyx Boox devices are way more popular in general and cater to multiple audiences. You can probably compare this to Android vs iOS with the latter being used by a small minority compared to Android on the global scale. Just like you, I am more attracted to the new Onyx Boox devices for my studies.
This is an apples to oranges comparison though. These two tablets have completely different uses. I have a remarkable 2, and the one thing I love the most is that there are no notifications, no apps, no email, no messages. No clutter, and i can focus on work. Also, the screen and feel of writing on it is far superior to anything else that exists today.
@@louisleedham3422 Well, not really. I mean, the response time, the feel of using the device and the build quality, is enough to justify the price imo. Because of the same reasons, I think the reMarkable 1 was much more overpriced. Some might disagree, but it's difficult to set a price on quality. It's a bit like saying the macbook is an overpriced laptop. It definitely has an insane price, but it's the best device of it's niche, and that makes up for a whole lot of money.
A couple of points I hope that can be addressed. Any “dead pixel “. Are the dpi the same? What is the onyx policy on stuck pixels? One of the advantages of reMarkable is if you have a problem with the screen they will replace it. I’m not sure of the onyx replacement policy. Maybe some viewers can pipe in about that part. If we are comparing the onyx as a multimedia device, shouldn’t it be compared to an iPad for features and price? If comparing to reMarkable we should hear a lot more about writing experience and lag. Speeding up video of the writing then stating onyx is more accurate without explanation needs to be rectified. Maybe another video is to explain how you concluded why onyx is more accurate. I’ve been with you guys since the way the beginning even before you had your own eink devices. Maybe this was an overreaction to the beginning of the year when your channel highly rated the remarkable 2 even before any review units were available to test. Keep posting interesting videos but do be careful making general comments without qualification. I know you guys put a lot of work into your reviews but this one felt a little too rushed.
I have been using my Boox Max 2 for a while now; I've used it every day. I was thinking I needed an upgrade and, was looking deeply at reMarkable2. Now, I am rethinking the whole thing. Maybe keep what I have for a while longer. How is the Max 3?
Here's an idea that Goodereader can do for us. How about fast shipping/lending the Note Air over to My Deep Guide for an in-depth review comparison. I know it's in the best interest of Goodereader to sell these devices so its all good, but please allow us a more detailed review on the things that are important to potential buyers instead of these "feel" good reviews. What may be "great" on one device does not negate the other if it's lacking in features.
I looked at both of these devices. They both look great. In the end I went with the Remarkable 2. I have an IPad Pro. I wanted something with no distractions, simple design and looked nice. I can use my IPad for the complex stuff.
i have my rM2 and love it but was going to buy a new laptop to replace my Macbook Air thats quite old now, but now i'm considering gettting the Onyx Book Note Air instead with bluetooth keyboard whats anyone think?
I wanted to ask, for an aspect on both of them, how does file transferring work? As I would like to be able to download pdfs and make notes and then put them somewhere on Dropbox/Google Drive. Is this possible for these devices? I hear Remarkable charges for this service
"We are going to be as fair and impartial" you started by saying...before you went on to talk for 13min and never discussing the writing experience which is a huge thing for users and before I decide to buy one or the other... Thank you for the tilted advice. :)
I personally think people don't get it remarkable has released the first model that has apps and shit but the second one is not about that! For me the second one is meant to be like a book can you zoom on a real book? No ! Sure there are hacks for those that want them but the concept is what most people want! 1 tablet that is like a book that doesn't make your eyes feel like shit and keeps you from printing God knows how many pages! It's exactly what I've been waiting for I can't wait to order as soon as I've saved the money! I don't think it's for everyone!
Which is the best option amongst all Botox/Onyx products? Is there any expected release by any writing pad manufacturer? How does the Onyx compare to the Supernote A 5x and the IPad Pro?
Little pissed at the review. I almost made a decision based on it. Your comparison implies that the Onyx has similar functionality as the Remarkable. In fact it never mentions the key point of the Remarkable or that the Onyx lacks it. The Onyx is just writing on glass. I have a surface, and other devices with active stylus pens to write on, that blow the Onyx out of the water. Those devices are simply writing on glass, we would I need an Onyx, if I was ok writing on glass? The Remarkable is trying to give a feeling of writing on paper. I have different tools for different needs. Either you are a dishonest person or a lousy reviewer; you will have to decide which one you are.
Hi how good is Onyx Boox for business meetings and conferencing, like via Zoom? ReMarkable looks pretty good for that, so wondering if Onyx has superiority there too. Thanks
What about the writing experience??? The feel, which one is closer to paper? the latency when jotting notes? I have a tablet that can do everything the Onyx can but better, but obviously writing on glass isn't what most people prefer if they're looking at these reviews.
Great Video thanks. Note Remarkable 2 has seen a lot of updates since this video was made. e.g. PDF pinch & Zoom plus integrations with one Drive & GDrive plus Screensharing to PC using the companion app. Also would love to get feedback on the feel of the writing on the Air. I read elsewhere you need a screenprotector to get a good resistance feel like remarkable 2 has
Well the Onyx wins hands down. Spec and software flexibility is unmatched. Probably why people are expecting the remarkable to cost less. If it was around $300 it would fly. But one thing you are wrong about is the pen. If they both use Wacom, than technically the Onyx can do tilt. I have an older model and regular art apps on android like infinity painter or artflow and more that supports tilt work on Onyx too. Except Infinity painter lags waaaay to much on older boox devices. Not sure about the new ones. I wouldn’t be surprised if tilt is implemented in the Onyx notes app down the line.
THIS is very interesting!!! I'm still waiting for my Air and was looking for an app (I even looked at the Github code from Wacom) to get input diagnostics and see if the pen/digitizer has tilt. Now you confirm that it has and the Onyx software just does not use it. very very interesting indeed! thanks a lot :D For the lag: The apps have to be optimized by their own developer. So as long as they don't include the e ink libraries, the lag should not really get better... :-/
Never had a chance to try out the writing experience on the remarkable but I wanted the extra features as I use it for ebooks as well and the note air definitely delivered
This “review” is ridiculous. Actually you have done this before: with the Dasung external monitor and the Onyx Max. And actually the external monitor feature of the Onyx was utter rubbish.
Is the black also blackier (I.e., is the contrast better)? If so, is the contrast still better with the lights on? I feel like the contrast improved a lot on my kindle when the lights are on, even in the lowest seeing.
@@hunterhenryk In the no light scenario the rM2 should be better because there is no additional layer for the light that steals a minimum when switched off. But if you take all scenarios into account, the Air should be better and even adjustable.
Just found a comment from him Goodereader vor 1 Stunde they are both running glass so they are fairly identical. the days of comparing glass vs non-glass seem to be behind us. Almost no one uses non-glass screens anymore. if you want the real answer, look for the comment from "Luiz Silva"
Quick questions guys, I live in Australia so shipping sucks for most things, wondering if I have to buy the pen tips for Remamarkable 2 from their website, or the Goodereader store or do the Wacom tips will work on the pen? Mostly curious if I should order some ahead of time or if I have a quick solution, thanks o/
Unfortunately no, only Onyx Boox makes open Android powered e-ink readers. A lot of other brands do use android as the operating system but that's as far as it goes. You can purchase more affordable Amazon Kindle or Kobo reader. Try the looking into the Kobo, they're neat. Cheers! = )
4 ปีที่แล้ว +6
I've just cancelled my rM2 pre-order (Batch 2) and I have just ordered the Note Air. My key reason is that I cannot trust Remarkable as a company. They only have 2 products, the environment / ecosystem is completely closed and they are clearly having issues. I've seen that too with Pebble (remember the e-paper 1st of a kind smart watch?). Fitbit bought Pebble and bye bye support, connectivity, functionality. Same goes here with Remarkable. They were VERY innovative, created something completely new a few years ago, but failed to bring it to the masses and were happy to be a "niche" product. Guess what - the competition (Chinese) have caught up technology wise, their scale is MUCH bigger than just a tiny Norwegian company and their longevity in the market is much more secure. The problems Remarkable have gone through just to ship rM2 units already speaks very loudly to the issues to company is facing, if you can't see than I'd invite you to look at the signs. The other thing is that they've cashed a bunch of pre-orders in MARCH and sloooooowly start shipping units in October(!!!! CASHFLOW PROBLEMS?? HELLOOO !!!). Boox Note Air just needed to be equal to rM2 for me to cancel the pre-order, with this review I'm even happier to have done it.
Peter, in the Onyx Note Air review you said that it does not have the pinch-and-zoom functionality and in this video, it seems it does. Is it an update or something?
Great review always punchy quick & to the point. However, the writing feel would be good to know on both. Does the Air have lots of pre-set templates? Also do you have the overview screen on all your saved docs on the Air as you do on the Remarkable? I must say even though I like Remarkable it is looking less remarkable on this factual review. Thanks
@@Qster83 Hey! Thanks for the clarification. Does this mean that you have had the chance to try a Note Air first hand? In that case, is the original screen somewhat grippy or completely glossy? That is all I would like to know for me to decide to buy it or live without it... since I already canceled my rM2 due to a lack of features.
@@oscarsaenzcastro yea mine got here Friday, so I've been playing with it all weekend!😀 I found the screen to be rather grippy, esp when using the new pen. Its probably even more grippy if you use a softer rubber nib.
Thank you, Peter, for your unbiased review based on facts and features. I need a device that I can work with when reading and writing. Disregarding the no-distraction mentality, the rM just doesn't offer me that nearly enough, which is why I cancelled my pre-order and bought the Note Air, which is currently stuck at HKG ;-) but I'm in batch 2, so still well in time. What many of us are still curious about is how the two devices differ in feeling. Anyone who decides for a rM wants that special, snappy, sharp "almost like paper" feeling specifically in writing. You mentioned the new Boox pencil is more precise with its finer tip. I think you mentioned in the first Note Air review that it also gives a little? How do the nibs compare in experience? Is any screen more paperlike thus has more friction? Is the Note Air more glass-smooth? How does it compare to the Max Lumi? Which feeling do you actually prefer apart from the feature comparison? That would be helpful to still undecided users. Thank you!
Dont have a rm/rm2 but the air Feels good to write on, screen is "grippy" and the new pen has a hard nib. New pen maybe too hard for my liking, swapped it out for a tab s3 pen with hard nib, like that combo better. Air pen feels great on my max3 tho 👍
@@blobidibou9503 "unbiased" as his review is based on features and facts and not feelings or feel. I would have preferred a review with a focus on the feel of the two devices, but that was not Peter's intention. So yes, "unbiased".
The review is not comprehensive. It specifically chooses some features to compare while clearly avoiding some. The use of hyperbolic language eg “absolutely destroy” is an indication of emotional biais and unprofessional in a benchmark. The intent is very clear: show that Onyx>Rm to push consumer to buy Onyx. Whomever did this video should be embarrassed to mislead naive/uninformed viewers for their personal interests.
The Remarkable is remarkable for the amount of stuff it doesn't have
It's just more focalized on writing experience. I've bought a Boox because I primary use it to read off manuals but I still consider remarkable for the future as a paper replacement
I think its a more niche product for sure. I bought it because I'm a stem student with many notebooks of notes and scratch work. The reason I chose it over everything else is because of the battery life so I accept the devices limitations as I understand that they are in place to maximize its specialty.
@@willo1345 same, stem student. Thinking of getting remarkable2. Hows it working out so far? Got surface but battery life is shit and it heats up.
@@comedian2479 I love it so far. I no longer try to use up every inch of paper, lol. Just swipe and keep going.
@@willo1345 nice, did u get the marker2 pen with erasable end?
I’ve been shopping for a tablet like this for sometime and I see the value in the ones that offer more services for the price point.
The thing I really like about the remarkable 2 is the pen to paper feel experience and believe it or not the fact that there are no other apps. It is meant to simply replace a notepad and I kind of like that because it’s mindful when there are other apps involved it’s very tempting to take your focus away from what you’re doing. Part of me feels like that’s worth the money but then another part of me feels like I’m not getting as much for my dollar. This is why I haven’t gotten anything yet.
But think of it this way, are you really gonna be using social media and apps like that on this screen to be distracted like that? I think the screen and how it behaves is a big deterrent for getting distracted like that and you can download other apps that you can use to take full advantage of that, the part where they leave that out and say it's for focus just feels like a cover up for their short coming
I think that’s everyone’s dilemma. I played with a remarkable recently at Best Buy and really enjoyed it.
2 weeks later I bought the remarkable, I’m like 3 days in and love it, and even though they’ve added a lot of features that weren’t available at the time of review, pretty old videos now.
Despite the additional features I still have a hard time justifying the price.
$500 out the door is what I paid for an iPad Pro that I love and worth every penny.
But with the remarkable, I’m both missing features and money…
Sad to say, I’ll be returning the remarkable
im in the same boat as you! let me know when a destination is reached
I can't believe the one thing that literally everybody is asking for is writing feel on the onyx glass surface in comparison to remarkable surface. It's like you're deliberately not mentioning this on both note air reviews
Also why are speeding the footage of you writing on both devices. This is the part where we check latency. Peter you should check other reviews about eink and learn what matters in these devices.
Absolutely!! May these guys made an agreement with "my deep guide" to leave this aspect to him?
Also, I would like to hear how it sound when writings. Glass knocking sound is unacceptable!
You know, I thought it was weird that they started the video by insisting on their impartiality. I wonder if reviewers want to have access to future Onyx devices because Onyx puts out so many-thus, more content. If so, rM is at a disadvantage with these folks, as rM does not rotate through models all of the time. Or, maybe it’s something el$e.
@@CLC616 when I reached out to them on Facebook, they said the same thing.
In Among Us language... highly sus.
As an "overall" device the Onyx Boox Note Air makes way more sense. But there's something about the reMarkable that makes it more appealing to me as a specialized device meant for a specific purpose without distractions.
It truly makes a huge difference when you think man I should change to my email and check it but you can't. Keeps you focused. The drawing ability on remarkable is amazing I have to have tilt
It's the Apple effect. Branding + design.
I started to think about this too. I am in the market right now and the moment it was mentioned the Onyx Air running Android (basically) I was like, wait! I thought the point was to get away from notifications and these apps! I feel like this would (having Android) keep me from buying an eInk device. The point was to get away from android and distractions not buy more devices with distractions. This video has made me feel that Remarkable is the better option..
This sounds like such copium. The price makes no sense, given everything missing.
3:07 "Unfortunately"? That's the whole point of this tablet!
I felt that way too. The Remarkable has a very clear purpose, and it's not to be a media consuming tablet.
Having seen (and read) many reviews of the reMarkable2, I bought one. Like anyone who's ever tried it, I was blown away by the writing experience, but I quickly began to have doubts.
While the hardware is beautiful, the software felt very lacking, and, as I dug around online, I soon realised that the company has not kept up with the competition in that area. Furthermore they did not seem very willing to engage with customers or open up any kind of roadmap on future developments. I decided, therefore, to try out the Box Note Air and make a decision thereafter on how to proceed.
Long story short, he Note Air has been everything I'd hoped for and then some. I had grave concerns that comparing it directly with the reMarkable 2 would leave me disappointed (to the point where I might actually consider keeping both devices). The stylus that comes with the Air is far from the best so I tested with both reMarkable and Lamy pens and have been delighted with the results. The Air doesn't provide tilt functionality for the stylus but that doesn't matter to me. The writing experience on the RM2 is only marginally better, and certainly not noticeable on a day-to-day basis. Given everything else that the Boox software brings to the table the decision was a trivial one.
I know it's been a long time since this video was posted, but I discovered it - and its legion of comments - just last week while deciding whether to try the Note Air. Thanks to My Deep Guide I did just that, and will be forever grateful. I hope that the reMarkable team listens closely and addresses the concerns of the money-paying community because they provide an incredible device withe immensely underpowered software. In the meantime I'll keep scribbling away on my Box Note Air with a big smile on my face.
Thank you for your detailed comments. I just got my Remarkable 2 this week and so far it's ok. However, I just ordered the boox note air and can't wait to compare the two.
The. $7 mo fee is also a sign of problems and unrealistic projections.
I recently lost my beloved Onyx Poke 3 reader and want to replace it with something I can also use for journalling. This was a very helpful comment. Thank you!
Hi, morning! I'm really unsure between the RM2 and the note airc 3 C. My idea is to replace my college notebooks. I need to read and write it in PDF and attach some photos that I take of the whiteboard. I don't know if the NA3C has the same feeling of writing on paper that the RM2 has. What would you advise me?
@@marcelomonteirocarvalho5137 The newer Note Airs - the 2 and the 3 - have a great writing feel, at least as good as the RM2 in my experience. With the Airs you also get a lot of functionality and extensibility with apps.
The thing Remarkable is focusing on the most is the writing feel. They are very explicit about it. Why don't you compare that in your impartial comparison?
Absolutely! That's like comparing a Tour de France race bike with some cheap Mountainbike and then saying "O k , - this is better because it offers the possibility to do some offroad.... "
Don't get me wrong, I do love my Onyx Note, but we still did not have any information about WRITING EXPERIENCE NOW!
Yeah! I wonder why they are voluntarily not reviewing and comparing the writing feel or experience. Since they are the only ones in posession of a Note Air... maybe Onyx gave them that explicit restriction? I mean come on, they even fast forwarded all writing examples in their last "review". Anyway, what a waste of an opportunity! I do want to know if that shock in the mountain bike is comfortable enough to be worth it or if I should keep my road bike for commuting. This not so impartial review makes me kind of angry
@@oscarsaenz9556 couldn't have said it better .
The writing feel is not a great difference, but the rest of the device ... yes. And that is not an excuse for that price ... If you only care about writing or you use a paper or a h10l LCD Writing Tablet ...
@@Maisonier it is for some of us unfortunately my friend. I feel miserable writing on a glassy Galaxy Note surface, but also having a pile of paper notebooks ain't fun either
Can you say something about the following points:
1. Battery usage (life time, loading time, usage time)
2. weight and grip
3. writing surface
4. using the onyx without backlight (reading quality)
5. are there differend highlighter colors with onyx (as - virtually - with remarkable)?
Thanks!
Wait for my deep guide and everything related to the sw should be already covered by his Lumi and older reviews.
Guys, you're missing the point. You're comparing a feature intensive device with a device built just for a single purpose: to perfectly replicate the feeling of writing on paper. You didn't compare this aspect at all.
Onyx has a glass screen whole the remarkable works with a flexible display, which should mean that right out the gate, the writing experience with the two should be vastly different.
Also, writing latency. What are the exact numbers for the boox note air vs 21 ms in rM 2?
Granted, rM2 could use better software, but as far as the hardware goes, how do these two compare? What's the build quality like? How durable are they? Which one can take accidental falls better than the other?
Also, VERY IMPORTANT: how do the battery lifes compare?
The Remarkable 2 has a glass screen.
rM uses also glass and has a 27ms latency. The hardware is cheaper on the rM2. Compare the specs and the size and you will see how they lie. Or do you really believe they can't fit something like a uSD card or similar with more than 8GB somewhere to mention only one point.
@@lazyman1011 do you really need more than 8 gigs of memory for your writing needs?
@@lazyman1011 ah, wait I'll re check the specs, sorry if I've got them wrong.
@@lazyman1011 if you don't like the remarkable say it
Good review: apart from no comparison in surface feel or latency. Why? 🤔
I don’t want to watch videos, listen to music or read emails my notebook. That’s what my iPad is for.
I want to know what the writing experience is like.
If it was better than Rm they would have shown it for sure and not fast forward the actual most important question.
yes, i totally agree with you
isnt the ipad for writing too? your comment comes off kind of pretentious
@@greenboarder89 eyes are too tired after long time reading by iPad
@@greenboarder89 It's s a very different experience and purpose. The intent of the Rm2 is to provide you with a possibility to take notes and work with your thoughs. That is why they do not put any distractions but focus on things like battery longevity (last 1 week when used), writing experience, thin product. The fondamental purpose of an ipad and Rm are different. With the ipad you write on glass it is not as nice but the initial purpose of an ipad is not to enable you to be with your thoughts or take notes. Rm is not for you if you want a device to do many different things.
Straight feature comparison? Sure. Note Air wins. But the rM2 isn't trying to be an all-encompassing tablet like the Note Air. So it's a little of an unfair comparison due to different use cases.
I will say - this seems like an obvious biased video since you sell the Note Air but not the rM on your store. You're stoking this fire of giving a comparison on a surface level and not doing what people really want: comparing the note taking features and feel.
I remember similar shallowness when the topic were the Dasung external monitor. Complete disregard for the use case.
That’s right. Part of it might be that Goodereader doesn’t like that they cannot sell the reMarkable yet. That sped-up writing at the end was surprisingly shady.
@@CLC616 can't they? It's up on their store....
@@shekhardevm It says, "Available on: 12/1/2020 at 7:11:00." You can probably pre-order it, but they cannot actually give it to you yet.
I don’t think this is biased at all, wish this video was out when I bought the remarkable2.
Just gonna copy my comment to other ppl:
I just received my remarkable2 yesterday and am so frustrated with it already I had put in the return request. No matter how good it feels to write on it, it’s just impossible for me to utilize it because how bad it is to read!
The table of content is so bad it drives me nuts! If you want to take notes on PDF slides it’ll be impossible to navigate if it’s a big document with more pages. Also PDFed books obviously becomes very small so it ends up straining my eyes anyways.. zoom is a joke. Impossible to use. I can tolerate the small fonts while reading, but I cannot tolerate having no way of navigating to the page I want to read.
There’s no point of paying that much money for a note pad that’s harder to find things than on paper.
Lol I found myself watching more reviews this morning and left a few messages under these videos, I don’t usually do this, I guess I am REALLY frustrated with remarkable2. I waited 5 month for it since the Pre-order, imagine my disappointment!!!
Hi, couple questions:
- What's the erasing function like on the Onyx over the reMarkable?
- How does the response speed of the screens during writing and drawing compare?
- How does the writing feeling of both devices compare?
Yessssss same questions. But apparently they're not answering.
About for first question:
I've already watched other reviews:
As always, the standard pen does not feature an eraser on the back, on both devices.
If you preordered the rM2 with the discount, where you got the $100 pencil for free, THAT does have an eraser on the back.
The expensive pencil with an eraser from boox costs "only" $60 in comparison.
If you question was about the performance of erasing... I guess it's the same, but maybe you should look through other reviews yourself to confirm if it suits your expectation.
About the feel:
Just found a comment from him
Goodereader
vor 1 Stunde
they are both running glass so they are fairly identical. the days of comparing glass vs non-glass seem to be behind us. Almost no one uses non-glass screens anymore.
if you want the real answer, look for the comment from "Luiz Silva"
I didn't like the note taking part were everything was just FF and you couldn't see the drawing delay nor reviewer said anything about writing feel.
Sadly the feel is a taste and you have to try them out. So even if one wins in a review maybe you wont like it at all.
Due to environmental reason's and some others I cancelled my rM2. I know allready I would send it back even if it feels superb.
You also can not compare them because the glass surface is different and also the nibs are different. You need to cross test it at least. For example, I'am thinking of getting the rM2 pro pen for my Air.
@@lazyman1011 Environmetnal reasons?
In the PDF, the RM2 looks like it has deeper blacks and whiter whites. Is that just due to the settings on the Boox Note Air? Or an artifact of the camera? To be honest, the RM2 looks so much clearer and better than the Note Air.
Note Air lets you modify the contrast so it could be made better. It is much more versatile in that regard
I have an onyx nova 2 and the contrast does not make a deeper Black. It only helps to visualize a better image. I have this same feel that remarkable 2 has a deeper black and best white screen . I feel the light on my onyx is useful but not essential.
I was really hoping that around 11:00 you would have shown the note taking in real time. My biggest question was about the response of the tablet with the writing. :(
How does the air feel?????? This seems to be a major question that many users have (as well as myself). All the bells and whistles aren't worth much to me if it doesn't feel good to write on.
The device is shelled in aluminum. The bezels are small (not always a good thing).
Just found a comment from him
Goodereader
vor 1 Stunde
they are both running glass so they are fairly identical. the days of comparing glass vs non-glass seem to be behind us. Almost no one uses non-glass screens anymore.
if you want the real answer, look for the comment from "Luiz Silva"
Feels good to write on, screen is "grippy" and the new pen has a hard nib. New pen maybe too hard for my liking, swapped it out for a tab s3 pen with hard nib, like that combo better. Air pen feels great on my max3 tho 👍
@@ximaxwellix The remarkable doesn't have a glass lens
Disappointed with the review. In reality the one deciding factor that could possibly sway a decision to purchase the RM2 over the Air was overlooked. The whole writing element was fast forwarded and confined to a few seconds at the end of the video. Please provide a proper demonstration of both of the tablets writing capabilities side by side so that those who wish to purchase the highest quality writing and sketching tool can make an informed decision. I appreciate the upload but this did not tell us anything that we did not already know. Can the Air search written notes? Is the RM2 writing experience superior or not? (With clear video evidence)
I agree. I have the same impressions.
Goodereader videos are trash
I don’t think the majority of people are buying tablets to do primarily writing.
Just do it on paper, I’m more interested in the features of the actual device
@@revl6151 Uhm - but THIS is exactly the most important point of the remarkable: It does NOT want to be a tablet - it wants to be a digital version of paper - real ePaper. If you ignore the main purpose of a product... why bothering at all? Why being interested in remarkable? And why suggest people exactly the opposite of what they want and why they are being interested in the remarkable? Being interested in remarkable means being interested in finding a digital alternativ to paper. How can someone be so ignorant to tell the people exactly not taking the one function a product is about without any reason?
I just received my remarkable2 yesterday and am so frustrated with it already I had put in the return request. No matter how good it feels to write on it, it’s just impossible for me to utilize it because how bad it is to read!
The table of content is so bad it drives me nuts! If you want to take notes on PDF slides it’ll be impossible to navigate if it’s a big document with more pages. Also PDFed books obviously becomes very small so it ends up straining my eyes anyways.. zoom is a joke. Impossible to use. I can tolerate the small fonts while reading, but I cannot tolerate having no way of navigating to the page I want to read.
There’s no point of paying that much money for a note pad that’s harder to find things than on paper.
Lol I found myself watching more reviews this morning and left a few messages under these videos, I don’t usually do this, I guess I am REALLY frustrated with remarkable2. I waited 5 month for it since the Pre-order, imagine my disappointment!!!
I have a ReMarkable 1 and absolutely love it. I'm a nursing student so I take lots and lots of notes and I love how I can just carry one light device instead of a giant notebook. Even though the speed is a little slow when flipping pages/opening documents, the writing speed from pen to device is perfect. It never lags for me. Honestly I like the ReMarkable more because it doesn't have all the other features to distract me.
whaaaaaaaaaaa whaaaaaaaaaa whaaaa.. traioning to hurt ppl much???
you wont even know what im saying
but instead of elevating your feelings. you should mauybe learn
Without the aggressive marketing from reMarkable, I would never have discovered the Onyx Boox. Thank you reMarkable! Loving your work❤!
Oh yeah, I'm definitely buying the Note Air because of the PDF software, but I'm not buying from your store since this "review" is completely biased.
How could this be? He's selling both, so he has absolutely not advantages in prioritizing one.
@@SashiroKun if they make more profit selling one over the other, then they have some incentive to be biased. 😉
@@SashiroKun He isn't really selling both. He may have both listed, but he doesn't have any Remarkable 2s. If you order a Remarkable 2, it is not available until February 2021 and it is way more expensive then going to the Remarkable website. My guess, if someone did buy from him, he would buy from the Remarkable store and ship it, when he got it, for a nice markup. Looking at his site, it would be $300 more than what I paid for mine, to order form him. Now I am guessing about how he gets his, but it would be $300, more than what I paid for mine, including shipping.
Any comment on the latency comparison?? It looks like the Air has slightly higher latency.
I guess he was using it on the highest latency mode.
As he said, you can switch to X Mode, which gives you the lowest latency on any device. - I just take a bold guess and expect that to be the same for the writing
@@ximaxwellix Screen latency and writing delay is not the same. If the delay through software is long when processing the pen location data, it really is just a matter of a further delay to make it visible. The delay in pen tracking is devastating since it can make your handwriting complete rubbish. The screen latency is an annoyance with you feedback loop into your brain. Both needs to be short...
Just try different note apps on an iPad and you will see what I mean, for the same - very fast screen - the feel of writing can go from "sucks" to "okey" between programs, and of all of the IOS apps, only a few comes near the responsiveness needed. I have tried them all...
I *hope* the rM will be good enough. The eInk devices I have had a number of years, have not been good enough. Neither have the iPad Pro 2017 or 2020 (I have them both and use them a LOT, but not for notetaking, still doing that on paper).
What’s that upside down reMarkable logo at 1:42 ??
It's the e-note illuminati
Does anyone that has RM2 or Onyx, how does it work when writing? When I write on paper, I tend to rest the palm on the paper itself. Would this interfere in the e-ink devices?? It's something I've always wondered. In the video, it seems Peter writes without touching with the palm, of course. Only with the pen. Would appreciate your insights. Thanks.
I get that the reviewer values functionality in e-ink devices, but that really doesn't do justice for a large fraction of people interested in such devices. A lot of them value the writing experience/feel over functionality. As a reviewer you should consider that.
For everyone asking. I've used both for about 4 months. (I was indecisive & got both). The remarkable 2 hands down is a better writing experience.
It's almost indescribable. It doesn't feel like you are writing on paper. It feels, in a word, better. Sure the boox can do a great deal more but that's specifically what the rm2 focuses on NOT doing. As a writer, I was stuck in the mud between writing on paper & typing on a computer.
Sure, writing was nice but it wasn't portable & transcribing it was a chore. I'd spend hours speaking through dragon to have it type it up for me. Typing wasn't a good creative medium for me either.
The rm2 let me go for hours just writing & when I was finished the transcription rate was about 98% (I have terrible handwriting) accurate. The boox had significantly for trouble recognizing my handwriting.
For the bang & the buck go ipad pro. For a true writing e-ink experience, rm2.
P. S. The battery life on boox was trash in comparison.
As a college student, I actually prefer the simplicity of the remarkable 2. Recently purchased mine, and it's great. I know myself all too well and I know that if my tablet had access to internet and apps like Facebook I will easily get distracted instead of using the device as I intended at purchase; to take notes during class without needing to deal with an abundance of paper.
@lil jil Yes, with the option to highlight text
Is it easy to load academic papers and read them?
@@hestervankooten3592 Yes, as long as the documents are PDF
This is my thinking ad well. As tempted as I am to get the Boox, I know that my main thing that I want is note taking and doodling. Any other features are going to distract me. Thank you for giving your input. I think you may have just solidified my decision. ♥️
@@rebeccacosme1372 ...so you will pay more.. for a slower and less featured device...?
I purchased a SuperNote (instead of a Remarkable) based off the comparison video you posted and I was actually disappointed with it. I have a friend with a Remarkable and I found it much better.
I am going with the Remarkable 2 this time. I have a Samsung tablet to do all the multimedia stuff and I just want a no-distraction tool/device for annotating and study purposes.
I appreciate the review though, it gives viewers a reasonable idea of the capabilities of these two EInk devices.
If you want it for anotating, the onyx air is better device because it works with books and pdfs better. Remarkable is really just for notes and drawing.
@Lauren Maxwell I didn't like the cloud service, not only was it ridiculously slow but VERY unreliable. I am also concerned about the location of the cloud servers (CCP China).
I found the SuperNote to have slow responsiveness and the stylus was not as close to a pen/pencil-paper writing experience as the Remarkable.
The SuperNote also had OS bugs that were not horrible but annoying (e.g., the odd freeze, interference from the OS overlay while writing in documents).
Lastly I found that not all of the advertised features worked as it was advertised (not on the video by this channel but as advertised in other locations).
I pre-ordered a Remarkable 2, so here's 🤞🤞that it lives up to its reputation.
Really? How come? I bought the remarkable 2 I'm supposed to be getting it soon.
@@coolmagoolsnexus Seriously, CCP. YOU MUST BE A VIP.
Can you also compre the contrast? With and without the light on on the note air.
I have a Remarkable 2 and I use it for doing work, not interested in the distraction of internet. For play and other features I use an iPad. I want to see documents in PDF and I want to work freehand and like the organization of Remarkable. I got it because working with a pen on the glass of my iPad I did not care for, I like the feel of the Remarkable, very paper and pencil like tactile experience.
Can you please make a comprehensive comparison based on pure writing experience?
Their handwriting is on a first grade-level, so the answer is no.
They can't, because no one will buy RM2 from them. RM2 is so much cheaper in the official distribution.
This seems a biased review. Do you sell both devices or just one?
I pre-ordered RM2 (batch 7) and I'm trying to understand if it fits my needs or I should switch to onyx note air. this review however looks to me a bit unfair (and therefore useless) as it does not expressly take into account the peculiar aspect of the RM2 (hand writing) whilst it considers bell and whistles that nothing has to share with note taking. to the same extent, it would be unfair (if not correctly carried on) a comparison between note air and iPad pro...
If you want a device for note taking RM is today the best tool in the world that I know of.
@@blobidibou9503 I really need a device for note taking as I use my iPad pro for everything else...
my advice : if you can, then you should wait (until november) for your rm2.
it’s the best note taker in the market. it’s going to be totally worth it so hang in there :)
blob idibou indeed I’m waiting for the rm2 and won’t cancel my order...
On the iPad Pro I have tried every note taking app there is, and most fail due delays in software between samples of pen location making the writing look totally off compared to paper. Just shut your eyes and write in the app and on paper and compare them, that part has nothing to do with screen latency.
Then screen latency is added ontop and makes the visual feedback loop a bit annoying.
If both these types of delays are dealt with combined with precision of pen location, then you will have a great writing experience.
Additionally distance between image and surface creates a parallax error, contrast and light source/reflection, hardness of surface and sound and feel between pen and surface...
Writing on iPad glass is not ideal in any way, but the Apple pencil in itself is near perfect. Paperlike screen protector helps somewhat.
I will keep using my iPad Pro 2017 and 2020, a lot! They are more important to me than all my other desktop or laptop computers...
AND I wait eagerly to recieve my rM2 which should arrive within the next few weeks...
Unbiased review from someone who doesn't actually take notes or draw, you mean.
Remarkable is has almost inperseptable latency. Which is not only better than the Onyx, but a key feature.
And the lack of internet is a feature also.
I'm glad I'm not the only one who sees this.
The Note Air is very tempting because it's jam-packed with lots of neat features, especially split-screen.
My problem is that *ANY* device I *CAN* watch youtube or browse the web on will become a device used *only* for those purposes. I sorely need a distraction-free device.
Sad, but true.
@@RamLaska I have a rm1 and I really want to love it, but there are so many features that onyx has and remarkable hasn't. And I don't talk about a browser or apps or stuff like that, but simple shapes like a line, a triangle, etc. or pinch and zoom or insert a picture to your notes. Remarkable has a huge lack on software and I'm not the only one who thinks about it that way, there is a whole community on reddit that is working on hacks and workarounds to make it a better device. I don't need a browser, I'd also be ok with that very simple "ebook reader", but remarkable has to work on their software and add the few really simple but necessary features. It's a shame that this wonderful piece of hardware fails because it hasn't a solid software. But instead of listening to the costumers and adding this few elementery features they just do nothing and keep saying that it's the philosophy of their device.
@@heiligerklabautermann
Remarkable really needs to publish a roadmap. They're far too secretive and Apple-like. Being Apple-like works for apple, but they don't have the clout or the cash for quite that much haughtiness.
@@RamLaska that's right, I think without a roadmap they will loose a lot of costumers/potential costumers. If I knew they are working this or that feature, I'd wait for it. But instead they don't say anything about it and leave the costumers in a situation where they are just standing in the rain. I personally have ordered a note air, not because I love the company or what they stand for, but remarkables lack of the few elementary features kills my workflow in so many ways and I think note air will fit better to my usage. It's a shame because as I said, I really love the hardware especially the writing experience of remarkable, but there are so many moments in which I just hate it for being so limited.
@@heiligerklabautermann
I'm thinking about the Note Air, too. One new wrinkle I've just found out about is that Onyx isn't posting their source code faithfully/regularly. So, they're benefitting from others' work, but not sharing their modifications. Remarkable is quite faithful to post their code and even make the device open enough to allow hacks and things like that for new functionality.
Of course, I'd rather the functionality just *be there*, rather than rely on hacks. We'll see where this goes. I'm looking forward to seeing an in-depth review of the Note Air from My Deep Guide, and a comparison with the rM2.
1:41 I detect a video editing error…
It's the e-note illuminati
What I like about the reMarkable 2 is that very fact that it doesn't have all of the bells and whistles that the Onyx offers. I have used both devices and I can tell you that the Onyx feels like a device from the past. It literally feels like an old B&W Macintosh and it completely takes away the whole "futuristic" feel of the device. The rM2 on the other hand truly feels like a brand new type of device. True, the Onyx may have more features, but the battery life falls very short compared to the reMarkable 2. The reMarkable 2 has a better feel when writing compared to the Onyx. One thing that I noticed with the Onyx is that you really get tired of using it. I mean, it literally makes you want to put down the device and write on a real piece of paper. By contrast, you don't get tired of using the reMarkable. The entire experience of writing on a tablet becomes very enjoyable with the reMarkable. In my opinion, the reMarkable is the right choice. (it also looks and feels way more professional)
all eInk is laggy as of today, while remarkable being among the laggiest. onxy is less laggy.
You either don't understand the technology and configuration options or are intentionally spreading misinformation.
Disappointing that the reviews on this channel have gotten worse instead of improving.
Unbelievable you didn’t check the main feature of Remarkable- DRAWING!!!!
Exactly
To those wondering about the whole return policy and how long it will take to get your money back, it took me exactly 30 days from the day the item was received at their facilities. I live in Australasia. Very credible company. And if the item wasn't so niche I would have kept it. The technology is phenomenal! And I would rank the brand up there with Apple in terms of service presentation and being environmentally conscious.
But what do they FEEL like to write on???
I think this was a bit too hard on the Remarkable... the one thing it has been created for is the feeling of writing on paper with a pencil. This is something Remarkable does best, period. Getting close to this (not even matching) with the Onyx requires buying a different pen with softer nibs and third party screen protectors.
For everything else, OBNAir is just an other league, a different product.
I have tried the Remarkable from a colleague that is totally in love with it, but I have chosen the Onyx because I need my notes to be sent by email quickly and for the possibility to review documents selecting the text to add notes is a game changer. Backlight makes it better than paper, the possibility to check emails is crucial, apps or browsing are just a plus, but very welcome.
Excellent comparison of 2 direct competitors.
Note Air is an excellent allrounder but Elnk devices, at least for me should be firstly defined through the write feel, then features (otherwise a Tab S6-S7\Ipad are the clear winner with the exception of the screen)
Q: how does the write feel compare with Remarkable 2, which until now was mentioned to be best in business?
Agree with this comment! Same question
I had the same mindset, but since the lack of features on the rM1 requires me to always carry a tablet with me, it would be better FOR ME to choose the Boox Air, because it will shrink my needed devices to one. I can trade in some writing feel. But I was going back and forth with that decision for 2 weeks now. But once I came to the point what the rM2 improves over the rM1, it didn't really feel right to upgrade something for 450€, I didn't have a problem with in the first place. [Edit:] So as of now... IMO: Buying the rM2 feels more like buying the newest iPhone, Galaxy, Pixel, etc. - do you have a problem with your current phone, that the new one will fix? No. So why would I pay so much money for something I don't need. Yea and that was basically the point where I decided yesterday, I'm gonna cancel. As a student, I can use the money in a better way in these times.
BTW! Please consider, that the rM2 is nothing else than a technical upgrade and I even believe that we already got a rM1 vs. rM2 comparision, saying that the canvas display of the rM2 is slightly less paper-like than the rM1. Would need someone to confirm tho. And if that is the case, you need to consider if you need a technical upgrade of the rM1.
@@ximaxwellix personally, I could say I am drooling for Remarkable since V1. Nevertheless the points mentioned by you are exactly the reason why I waited. With RM2, I wanted to see a bit more functionality; but, the writing feel is for me the most important aspect for buying a elnk device that costs as much as a tablet. Now if the Onyx Note Air, has the same feel as for example Ipad/Samsung, because is glass only, then only Remarkable remains. IF Onyx mimics a write on paper feel in an acceptable way then as @Goodreads mentioned, Onyx Note Air is just in another league
Just found a comment from him
Goodereader
vor 1 Stunde
they are both running glass so they are fairly identical. the days of comparing glass vs non-glass seem to be behind us. Almost no one uses non-glass screens anymore.
if you want the real answer, look for the comment from "Luiz Silva"
@@Septimiu13 l&'
Thanks! For everyone cancelling their RM2 order, I'll get mine faster :-)
“Pretty unbiased when it comes to these devices”
“But when the onyx books air came out it absolutely destroyed the remarkable”
“There’s absolutely nothing about the remarkable that is better than the onyx”
Also includes a sponsor from Onyx Note in description, but not remarkable.
...
so how is just buying an iPad Pro... super quick with reading PDF... I guess bad thing was, we cannot annotate the PDF (highlight, write notes on it)
I love the fact that the Onyx is based on Android and lets you treat it like a tablet. But... The Remarkable has a noticeably brighter screen when no glow light is active on the Onyx. I really don't like the extra layer and the dimming that the front lighting on any e-ink device provides. Let the screen act like paper and turn on your reading light.
Why would I use the Eink device as a monitor or watching videos or listening to music? I think it should be as simple as a piece of paper. Your cheap iPad will do other things much better.
iPad pro 12.9 entered chat
‘... cheap you said?’
Completely agree. Although it's nice to have kindle on it. And probably even listen to audiobooks or music while using (although for audio I would probably use my phone instead).
To help your eyes.
@@lazyman1011 Exactly! That’s why people buy e-ink tablets.
@@csc7345 I mean the cheapest iPad will do better than an Eink tablet on the videos or other tasks.
Can you lookup definitions of words on the Boox note air? And/or use google translate in the out-of-the-box .epub / .pdf reader?
3 things I think was missing.
How you do manage files on each? Is it easy to manage folders.
Is there an easy backup of the files incase you break or loose the device.
What is the latency like when drawing. Does the device keep up with the pen?
Great review!! does onyx have a monthly subscription? with onyx can u open a pdf from email sign and send back quick?
no they do not have a monthly fee
I use both , feelings when you write on reMakable is a lot more better for that reason alone reMakable win for me i just need to on paper carry a lot document I can do anything else boox do on ipad
Thanks for the review :D
Any comments or the "paper feeling" when writing on them? Which one has more friction and precision? Which one is best when writing small letters?
Or, an unfair question, which one is closest to pen/pencil on paper (unfair because that would havily depend on the paper and pen/pencil, so it may the worth to specify to which combination is the closest).
That would interest me too.
Multimedia features I can have enough on m phone or other devices.
I want this thing for basic note taking and se the feeling of writing on it is more important to me.
Would love a comparison for this aspect.
they are both running glass so they are fairly identical. the days of comparing glass vs non-glass seem to be behind us. Almost no one uses non-glass screens anymore.
@@goodereader does it mean that's about the same as apple pencil on iPad (that's also glass)?
@@goodereader Has the Lumi a glass screen?
@@goodereader Screen on Remarkable has a special coating. So You really shouldn't write that it's just a glass because You suggest that is has a very smooth, glassy surface like iPad. All the other Remarkable reviews claim the writing feel is good or even great, much better than all the other "glass" devices.
The thing is I have a laptop/tablet so If I wanna do anything internet related I can just use that, that is the same for many. So to me the remarkable is the right choice because I don't need another tablet like device. In fact I like that it's only for note taking. This may be reaching but because it is far more simple it may last me more years, hopefully through undergrad and med school.
How about pdf reading with complicate equations and figures? Which is best?
is the Onyx compatible with android apps?
Hi, congratulations for your channel. I have a question; You can write over the epubs directly with pen as in PDF. Is it possible write in EPUBS with pen directly as in PDF to take notes, or underline...etc? thanks.
Note air placement of power button and USB port is really odd. Does it interfere with using folio case? Also does power button gets accidentally triggered when using with a bluetooth keyboard? What about the writing experience? Is glass surface slippery? I do agree specwise, Note air is ahead, but question the usability. Most likely end up with Note Air because of crappy reader software on RM2.
It's great to see a direct comparison! Both of these have similar designs, but appeal to different target audiences. reMarkable is more popular* and provides a focused experience, while BOOX is less popular but provides a more open experience that appeals more to someone like me who wants to read more kinds of content, including DRM-protected e-books, which includes content from major publishers, across many e-book platforms, even those without dedicated e-readers.
*This, at least for me, affects things like the availablity of third-party accessories and note templates.
Definitely would not claim that ReMarkable is more popular. It is praised by a very tiny minority who want nothing more than a very expensive digital notepad for their own specific reasons. Onyx Boox devices are way more popular in general and cater to multiple audiences. You can probably compare this to Android vs iOS with the latter being used by a small minority compared to Android on the global scale.
Just like you, I am more attracted to the new Onyx Boox devices for my studies.
@@Flamdring
Thanks!
@@Flamdring completely agree with you !
This is an apples to oranges comparison though. These two tablets have completely different uses. I have a remarkable 2, and the one thing I love the most is that there are no notifications, no apps, no email, no messages. No clutter, and i can focus on work. Also, the screen and feel of writing on it is far superior to anything else that exists today.
I agree, do you not feel that should be reflected in the price of the Remarkable 2 though? For me its a hugely overpriced product!
@@louisleedham3422 Well, not really. I mean, the response time, the feel of using the device and the build quality, is enough to justify the price imo. Because of the same reasons, I think the reMarkable 1 was much more overpriced. Some might disagree, but it's difficult to set a price on quality. It's a bit like saying the macbook is an overpriced laptop. It definitely has an insane price, but it's the best device of it's niche, and that makes up for a whole lot of money.
A couple of points I hope that can be addressed. Any “dead pixel “. Are the dpi the same? What is the onyx policy on stuck pixels? One of the advantages of reMarkable is if you have a problem with the screen they will replace it. I’m not sure of the onyx replacement policy. Maybe some viewers can pipe in about that part. If we are comparing the onyx as a multimedia device, shouldn’t it be compared to an iPad for features and price? If comparing to reMarkable we should hear a lot more about writing experience and lag. Speeding up video of the writing then stating onyx is more accurate without explanation needs to be rectified. Maybe another video is to explain how you concluded why onyx is more accurate. I’ve been with you guys since the way the beginning even before you had your own eink devices. Maybe this was an overreaction to the beginning of the year when your channel highly rated the remarkable 2 even before any review units were available to test. Keep posting interesting videos but do be careful making general comments without qualification. I know you guys put a lot of work into your reviews but this one felt a little too rushed.
Have you tried the reMarkable 2 stylus on Note Air? The marker plus is excellent, the eraser works too.
I have been using my Boox Max 2 for a while now; I've used it every day. I was thinking I needed an upgrade and, was looking deeply at reMarkable2. Now, I am rethinking the whole thing. Maybe keep what I have for a while longer. How is the Max 3?
Here's an idea that Goodereader can do for us. How about fast shipping/lending the Note Air over to My Deep Guide for an in-depth review comparison. I know it's in the best interest of Goodereader to sell these devices so its all good, but please allow us a more detailed review on the things that are important to potential buyers instead of these "feel" good reviews. What may be "great" on one device does not negate the other if it's lacking in features.
Absolutely! Please just send it to Voja! Thanks
Voja's personal (subjective) preference /favorite E-ink device is Boox Note Air over rM2....says it all, assuming his reviews are unbiased.
I looked at both of these devices. They both look great. In the end I went with the Remarkable 2. I have an IPad Pro. I wanted something with no distractions, simple design and looked nice. I can use my IPad for the complex stuff.
Do you feel any difference in the black ink and white contrast between them?
Do either of these have an FM radio?
i have my rM2 and love it but was going to buy a new laptop to replace my Macbook Air thats quite old now, but now i'm considering gettting the Onyx Book Note Air instead with bluetooth keyboard whats anyone think?
I wanted to ask, for an aspect on both of them, how does file transferring work?
As I would like to be able to download pdfs and make notes and then put them somewhere on Dropbox/Google Drive. Is this possible for these devices? I hear Remarkable charges for this service
"We are going to be as fair and impartial" you started by saying...before you went on to talk for 13min and never discussing the writing experience which is a huge thing for users and before I decide to buy one or the other... Thank you for the tilted advice. :)
I personally think people don't get it remarkable has released the first model that has apps and shit but the second one is not about that! For me the second one is meant to be like a book can you zoom on a real book? No ! Sure there are hacks for those that want them but the concept is what most people want! 1 tablet that is like a book that doesn't make your eyes feel like shit and keeps you from printing God knows how many pages! It's exactly what I've been waiting for I can't wait to order as soon as I've saved the money! I don't think it's for everyone!
Which is the best option amongst all Botox/Onyx products? Is there any expected release by any writing pad manufacturer? How does the Onyx compare to the Supernote A 5x and the IPad Pro?
Hello everyone!
Can I use the reMarkable nib on Onyx Note Air pen?
Remarkable tilt is a must for artistic types.
Little pissed at the review. I almost made a decision based on it. Your comparison implies that the Onyx has similar functionality as the Remarkable. In fact it never mentions the key point of the Remarkable or that the Onyx lacks it. The Onyx is just writing on glass. I have a surface, and other devices with active stylus pens to write on, that blow the Onyx out of the water. Those devices are simply writing on glass, we would I need an Onyx, if I was ok writing on glass? The Remarkable is trying to give a feeling of writing on paper. I have different tools for different needs.
Either you are a dishonest person or a lousy reviewer; you will have to decide which one you are.
Which turns on quicker from off?
Hi how good is Onyx Boox for business meetings and conferencing, like via Zoom? ReMarkable looks pretty good for that, so wondering if Onyx has superiority there too. Thanks
For me the killing part on the reMarkable is that it has no flip screen feature.
I need that because i'm lefthanded.
In this video it seems like the boox screen is not as white as the remarkable... Has anyone else noticed?
...and not even a link to the Remarkable2 in the description. Hmm.
Peter. You guys need a "note taking experience comparison" video with these two devices.
Is there a greater gap from the pen tip to the e-ink display due to the added layers of the backlight on the Boox Note Air?
What about the writing experience??? The feel, which one is closer to paper? the latency when jotting notes? I have a tablet that can do everything the Onyx can but better, but obviously writing on glass isn't what most people prefer if they're looking at these reviews.
I heard from the comments, it sounds like people like the RM2 for writinf if they own both. I'm buying an RM2 for that reason.
Great Video thanks. Note Remarkable 2 has seen a lot of updates since this video was made. e.g. PDF pinch & Zoom plus integrations with one Drive & GDrive plus Screensharing to PC using the companion app. Also would love to get feedback on the feel of the writing on the Air. I read elsewhere you need a screenprotector to get a good resistance feel like remarkable 2 has
Onyx Book AIR rocks, it is the better product for sure. As a owner of one for almost a month my workflow has changed and I loving the AIR.
Which would be the best for calligraphy?
Well the Onyx wins hands down. Spec and software flexibility is unmatched. Probably why people are expecting the remarkable to cost less. If it was around $300 it would fly.
But one thing you are wrong about is the pen. If they both use Wacom, than technically the Onyx can do tilt. I have an older model and regular art apps on android like infinity painter or artflow and more that supports tilt work on Onyx too. Except Infinity painter lags waaaay to much on older boox devices. Not sure about the new ones.
I wouldn’t be surprised if tilt is implemented in the Onyx notes app down the line.
THIS is very interesting!!! I'm still waiting for my Air and was looking for an app (I even looked at the Github code from Wacom) to get input diagnostics and see if the pen/digitizer has tilt. Now you confirm that it has and the Onyx software just does not use it. very very interesting indeed! thanks a lot :D
For the lag: The apps have to be optimized by their own developer. So as long as they don't include the e ink libraries, the lag should not really get better... :-/
No tilt on mine so far
Just one thing ? Does the new stylus from Max Air can be used on Max Lumi? How is it the writing experince? Is the nib the same? Thanks!
Can I use remarkable pen to draw on boox
Hi! I was wondering if you can also use the highlighter pen function in the pdfs on the Onyx Boox device? Or is that only possible in your notes app?
good video!!! can i use onyx boox note air 2
to manage tasks with App "asana" or "notion"?
thanks
Never had a chance to try out the writing experience on the remarkable but I wanted the extra features as I use it for ebooks as well and the note air definitely delivered
This “review” is ridiculous. Actually you have done this before: with the Dasung external monitor and the Onyx Max. And actually the external monitor feature of the Onyx was utter rubbish.
Because of that interview I bought Onyx Max 3 for display and regret, so bought Dasung as well after all.
@@omnibus4298 , can you describe the difference as an external monitor?
I don't like the fact that the new Oynx stylus has no eraser. WTF?
The screen on reMarkable2 is whiter, more of a paper-like feeling.
Is the black also blackier (I.e., is the contrast better)?
If so, is the contrast still better with the lights on? I feel like the contrast improved a lot on my kindle when the lights are on, even in the lowest seeing.
@@lacbs I have none of both in my hands, having booked a Note Air tho.
@@lacbs Contrast is a user-adjustable setting on Boox. Also, it has its own lights.
@@hunterhenryk In the no light scenario the rM2 should be better because there is no additional layer for the light that steals a minimum when switched off. But if you take all scenarios into account, the Air should be better and even adjustable.
Just found a comment from him
Goodereader
vor 1 Stunde
they are both running glass so they are fairly identical. the days of comparing glass vs non-glass seem to be behind us. Almost no one uses non-glass screens anymore.
if you want the real answer, look for the comment from "Luiz Silva"
Quick questions guys, I live in Australia so shipping sucks for most things, wondering if I have to buy the pen tips for Remamarkable 2 from their website, or the Goodereader store or do the Wacom tips will work on the pen? Mostly curious if I should order some ahead of time or if I have a quick solution, thanks o/
Is the battery capacity the same for both devices?
is there any budget android e-ink tablets? mostly for manga
Unfortunately no, only Onyx Boox makes open Android powered e-ink readers. A lot of other brands do use android as the operating system but that's as far as it goes. You can purchase more affordable Amazon Kindle or Kobo reader. Try the looking into the Kobo, they're neat.
Cheers!
= )
I've just cancelled my rM2 pre-order (Batch 2) and I have just ordered the Note Air. My key reason is that I cannot trust Remarkable as a company. They only have 2 products, the environment / ecosystem is completely closed and they are clearly having issues. I've seen that too with Pebble (remember the e-paper 1st of a kind smart watch?). Fitbit bought Pebble and bye bye support, connectivity, functionality. Same goes here with Remarkable. They were VERY innovative, created something completely new a few years ago, but failed to bring it to the masses and were happy to be a "niche" product. Guess what - the competition (Chinese) have caught up technology wise, their scale is MUCH bigger than just a tiny Norwegian company and their longevity in the market is much more secure. The problems Remarkable have gone through just to ship rM2 units already speaks very loudly to the issues to company is facing, if you can't see than I'd invite you to look at the signs. The other thing is that they've cashed a bunch of pre-orders in MARCH and sloooooowly start shipping units in October(!!!! CASHFLOW PROBLEMS?? HELLOOO !!!). Boox Note Air just needed to be equal to rM2 for me to cancel the pre-order, with this review I'm even happier to have done it.
Peter, in the Onyx Note Air review you said that it does not have the pinch-and-zoom functionality and in this video, it seems it does. Is it an update or something?
Can you do spreadsheets
Great review always punchy quick & to the point. However, the writing feel would be good to know on both. Does the Air have lots of pre-set templates? Also do you have the overview screen on all your saved docs on the Air as you do on the Remarkable? I must say even though I like Remarkable it is looking less remarkable on this factual review. Thanks
Writing feel is good on air and yes it has templates. All of your notebooks get their own overview page👍
@@Qster83 Hey! Thanks for the clarification. Does this mean that you have had the chance to try a Note Air first hand? In that case, is the original screen somewhat grippy or completely glossy? That is all I would like to know for me to decide to buy it or live without it... since I already canceled my rM2 due to a lack of features.
@@oscarsaenzcastro yea mine got here Friday, so I've been playing with it all weekend!😀 I found the screen to be rather grippy, esp when using the new pen. Its probably even more grippy if you use a softer rubber nib.
@@Qster83 Awesome! Thanks!
Thank you, Peter, for your unbiased review based on facts and features. I need a device that I can work with when reading and writing. Disregarding the no-distraction mentality, the rM just doesn't offer me that nearly enough, which is why I cancelled my pre-order and bought the Note Air, which is currently stuck at HKG ;-) but I'm in batch 2, so still well in time. What many of us are still curious about is how the two devices differ in feeling. Anyone who decides for a rM wants that special, snappy, sharp "almost like paper" feeling specifically in writing. You mentioned the new Boox pencil is more precise with its finer tip. I think you mentioned in the first Note Air review that it also gives a little? How do the nibs compare in experience? Is any screen more paperlike thus has more friction? Is the Note Air more glass-smooth? How does it compare to the Max Lumi? Which feeling do you actually prefer apart from the feature comparison? That would be helpful to still undecided users. Thank you!
Dont have a rm/rm2 but the air Feels good to write on, screen is "grippy" and the new pen has a hard nib. New pen maybe too hard for my liking, swapped it out for a tab s3 pen with hard nib, like that combo better. Air pen feels great on my max3 tho 👍
@@Qster83 Thank you for that! I also prefer the "softer" SPens, so that's a good tip for me ;-)
“unbiased”? did we watch the same video?
@@blobidibou9503 "unbiased" as his review is based on features and facts and not feelings or feel. I would have preferred a review with a focus on the feel of the two devices, but that was not Peter's intention. So yes, "unbiased".
The review is not comprehensive. It specifically chooses some features to compare while clearly avoiding some. The use of hyperbolic language eg “absolutely destroy” is an indication of emotional biais and unprofessional in a benchmark. The intent is very clear: show that Onyx>Rm to push consumer to buy Onyx. Whomever did this video should be embarrassed to mislead naive/uninformed viewers for their personal interests.