Why do people even like Wuthering Heights?! (reading Emily Brontë for the first time)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 ต.ค. 2024
- In preparation for Emily (2022) I read Emily Brontë's Wuthering Heights for the first time. The movie is released on October 14 and stars Emma Mackey (“Sex Education”, “Death on the Nile”) - VERY exciting. Are you going to see it?
#EmilyMovie
Charts about Wuthering Heights I show:
www.theguardia...
Other interesting articles:
www.theguardia....
theconversatio...
JOIN THE GUMPTION CLUB: / thegumptionclub
Being in the club means you get: a free weekly podcast, access to a secret facebook group, a free poetry collection and play written by me, access to livestreams AND you get to access to all my videos before anyone else sees them!
ORDER my poetry collection, BARGAIN BIN ROM-COM! linktr.ee/barg...
// COME AND HANG WITH ME IN BETWEEN UPLOADS //
IF NEWSLETTERS ARE YOUR THING, sign up to get a little letter in your inbox from me once in a while! As a thank you for signing up, you’ll get a FREE downloadable list of my best books of all time: leenanorms.sub...
INSTAGRAM: / leenanorms
TWITTER: / leenanorms
All music used is licensed through Epidemic Sound - I've been using them for years and hand-on-heart it's really fab. You get unlimited use of their music per month for a pretty bargain fee. Here's my referral link (if you sign up through it I get a free month): www.epidemicso...
If you're a company that makes plastic-free products, pays their tax and doesn't exploit people, I'd love to hear from you if you'd like to sponsor the channel: leenanorms@gmail.com
I'm sorry, but quoting Wuthering Heights at your wedding is basically cursing your marriage, holy heck 😂
I know a couple who use the ring from Lord of the Rings as their wedding ring and had the always quote from Harry Potter monogrammed onto all of their wedding dishes and Cutlery
wedding quotes are always the wildest choices
Do you think it was read at Harry and Meghan's wedding?🤭
It's the worst and most toxic enmeshment and somehow it's an airy fairy Pinterest quote now. 🤷🏻♀️
Hahaha those poor people.
I think you need a series with reading classic novels and reviewing them! Very curious to hear you talk about Rebecca :)
Now that's a good book
Seccond this!
I loved Rebecca so much!
Sooo good! Would love to see this
Yes please!
Interesting that you picked up on the fact that all of heathcliffe and Cathy’s love is reported; I quite like that because we feel so shut out from their relationship- it heightens their obsession and insulatority I think. I actually feel shut out from all the characters- feels like we’re peeking in the windows of the houses
But since it is a ghost story In a way, it makes since that she wrote it that way. Keeps it very intriguing and haunting
My dad named me Catherine after this book. Still to this day have no idea why he thought that was aspirational for his daughter.
🤣😂 your poor Dad has probably never lived his choice down. I am sure he meant only the best for you.
I’d like to think it was because of Kate Bush’s enticing depiction of her haha😅
@@moominmay I'll take that 😂
girl same here my mom did this to me
Your Dad was a true romantic, so forgive him. Don’t forget Cathy was quite a feisty woman, perhaps he wanted you to be. I hope this cheers you up. It is a nice name after all.
I absolutely love this book because everyone is so rotten- there's no discrimination between male and female, everyone is just bitter and cruel. And I feel that's so rare in classics, where there's usually a saintly redeeming female lead, that it's actually quite refreshing. I recommend the 2011 film version! Although it had some problems, like most adaptations, the cinematography is absolutely gorgeous and captures really well the wild and isolated feeling of the book!
Joli, this is why I love Austen's Emma. By conventions of the time, Jane Fairfax should be the point of view character saintly orphan that she is, and Emma the antagonist. This book shows the story from the mean girl's side... And she doesn't know she's a mean girl!
@@carlatate7678 second this 100%!
The book follows no class conventions of the time, I loved that so much the first time I've read it! It was so refreshing and new, I couldn't believe it was written almost 200 years ago
Exactly! It's fascinating, especially for a Victorian novel. There's no decency and no moralizing, no matter how awful and insane things get. It invites us to hate and love the characters the way they hate and love themselves.
I agree that's what is amazing about the book, it didn't have moralising undertones.
Wuthering Heights is one of my favorite books because Brontë is so intentional with how she describes characters and their actions. She lets the reader read between the lines to figure out plot points. Her portrayal of Heathcliff is particularly interesting because she creates one of the most cruel characters of all time, but Brontë allows the reader to feel sorry for him and also understand why he is the way he is- you can sympathize with him but also absolutely condemn his actions as wrong. The complexity of every character is what gets me.
Yes! That’s what I love about him as a character! You see the abuse he suffers and can understand his antipathy while condemning its consequences.
I read this book when I was a bit too young, and English is also not my first language. I couldn't keep up at all haha. I'm not necessarily saying this is the fault of the book, but my experience of it. Interesting to see that you love letting the readers read between the lines, but my experience of it was "wait hang on, these characters apparently love each other??? since when?". Maybe I need to give it another chance!
Wuthering Heights is a novel about the problems created by child abuse. People don't get that enough.
See this is literally the only reason why I enjoyed the novel. I really believe it's the mark of a great writer to make you love and hate a character. But it's a bigger achievement to do this with more than half your characters. I hated the characters so much (even Nelly) it almost took the enjoyment out of the novel for me. But when I finished it and reflected on it, I could not stop thinking about all the characters and how complex they were. Emily Bronte's writing is amazing.
@@sigridsimmen I mean if you love being told stuff straight up you won’t like WH and you probably wouldn’t like a lot of my favourite books, but I do recommend you to reread it otherwise because while it’s quite challenging to keep up with as a non-native English speaker (the bloody accent is the bane of my existence truly), it’s an incredible piece of writing
I dont totally get why so many people hate wuthering heights, it's so interesting and unique. It's about the cycle of abuse and PTSD and bpd and womanhood and growing up and obsession and soulmates
It's just tastes. I don't like it and there's nothing wrong about it, and you do and there's nothing wrong about it too :) It's kind of interesting to see how people think so many different things about the same book
I think, if approached through that lens, it's compelling, but I think that a lot of people who aren't familiar with the Brontës kind of assume she's like an Austen and are expecting a romance or something. Maybe that's just my experience coming from a white, lower middle-class, conservative background, but it was way darker than baby Ginger had expected it to be, haha. But if we want to examine the dark stuff (which I love *now* but didn't when I was 18, haha), then I think it's great.
I lovee it toooooo xxx
Think it just comes down to expectations, a lot of readers that hated Wuthering Heights expected a brooding romance but what they got was a novel of horrible people doing horrible things. My cousin is a massive Austen fan and she started reading Wuthering Heights so she asked me what I thought as she knew I read it and I told her I loved it (it's my fav classic) but I said if she's expecting romance out of this novel she's gonna be really disappointed.
@@sabzc3898 I completely agree. For most classics, having a tad bit of background info on the book is helpful to set expectations, both for the structure of the novel and for the time period/region in which it was written. I would have hated Anna Karenina if I didn't know what I was getting into.
This book sat with me years after, the cruelty that people inflicted on their apparent nearest and dearest. I remember hating everyone but couldn't put it down. I can safely say though, that Cathy and Heathcliff deserved each other.
Thanks for confirming that it's not just me who finds it difficult to read this book. I thought it's because English is my second language, but I know that some classics I didn't struggle with at all.
I'm still on page 50 and have been for over 4 weeks 😂 just not enjoying it at all, struggling to follow all the characters and the what's happening. But at the same time I feel like I have to read it to feel EdUcAtEd.
Which classics did you nit struggle with?
There is an Audible version (included with subscription) that is INCREDIBLE. Read by Joanne Froggatt. It had me absolutely glued to the story and I was able to understand it completely. I had also tried and struggled with the book itself (and I am a native English speaker with many years of post grad education lol). I am listening to all of the free Audible classics on my morning walks and while doing chores etc and it's changed my experience with them. Just also finished Persuasion read by Florence Pugh-amazing as well! Anyways, just wanted to share in case it helps.
@@shaynaloveswiss1 I also really struggled with Wuthering Heights but Jane Austen for example was so much easier for me to read, as well as Little Women or Jules Verne, especially Around the World in 80 Days. I think that's partially because the characters didn't all hate just each other.
That's funny, because this is one of my favorite books. I've read Wuthering Heights so many times, my copy is falling apart.
@@shaynaloveswiss1 for example one of the 'younger' classics - 'the remains of the day' . Or even similar stuff to WH - Persuasion, Pride and Prejudice etc. But this one I just CAN'T pay any attention. I keep re-reading the same sentence and it's not sinking it. I have not got a clue what she's on about 😂🙈 I'm page 55 now... 8 days later 🙂😭
I read this book a few years ago and I distinctly remember how delightfully terrible people the characters were, like I couldn't look away
I fell very deeply in love with this book as a teenager, but I'm pretty sure I never thought it was romantic. It's filled with horrible characters doing horrible things, it's cold, creepy, violent, repulsive... but in a deliciously good way. I distinctly remember being around 17, sitting in my bed and reading the whole book in one day.
me too. And it is still my favourite novel.
Exactly. It's my favoruite book, but it annoys me to no end that it's gotten a rep as a romance. It's as romantic as the cycle of abuse.
Yes yes and yes!
"I'm an optimistic book buyer and a pessimistic reader." I felt that
6:05 I read somewhere that Emily was actually quite mad that some women at the time thought Heathcliff was hot while she had pourposly made him a terrible human being and not to be desired
And sadly many are still like that, like those women that wrote letters to serial killers.
I thought it was published after she died?
I was swept away when I read and studied Wuthering Heights 50 odd years ago. How did Emily Brontë, living such a restricted life in a remote location, ever conceive of and write this book? Who was Emily? I think she had a wild interior life, mirrored by the bleak moors, and that wildness floods her book. To me, this book is so different from other books of this period because of exploding emotions. The 1939 movie with Lawrence Olivier is a classic film that captures the romanticism, beautifully acted and filmed.
Yes! After reading Wuthering Heights I became obsessed with Emily. I even went to Haworth to see the Brontë home and walk the same street she did.
Also I have never forgiven how mean Elizabeth Gaskell was in her portrayal of Emily in her biography of Charlotte. She never even met Emily and to this day I refuse to ready any other Gaskell work as solidarity in with Emily 🙃
Have you read Anne's books, though? I find them at least as surprising (and like them a great deal more). SO modern and forward thinking, in the way she describes relationships, abuse, substance abuse, self-preservation, and strong women who will not be cowed by men or society.
@@corvuscorone7735 I loved the Tenant of Wildfell Hall. It's a great novel and I agree very surprising and modern. I have to say though maybe it's the wildness or maybe even just the age at which I read it but for me there is just something so intriguing and magnetic about Emily and Wuthering Heights.
I personally think Wurthering Heights should be considered one of the first works of psychological fiction. It's basically about how trauma effects how people make decisions -- badly -- and the self-sabotage it leads to. Emily Bronte was writing psychological fiction before psychology was even a science!
Edited to add my classics recommendations:
The Shooting Party by Anton Chekhov. It's Chekhov's only novel and one of the earliest examples of the mystery genre. But forget all the tropes of the modern mystery genre: this is Russian-style mystery, and it's far more twisted then any mystery novel you'll ever read!
My other recommendation is Fifth Business by Robertson Davies. This book starts off with two 10-year-old frenimies taunting each other as they're walking home from a sledding hill in the middle of winter. One throws a snowball at the other, he ducks the snowball, and it instead hits the head of the young heavily-pregnant wife of the local Baptist minister, bringing about the premature birth of a third boy. The novel then follows the lives of the 2 boys -- one who takes on more guilt then his due, and the other who blocks the event from him mind and takes no responsibility for it at all -- and explores how guilt and shame can alter the course of our lives.
You should definitely do more reading vlogs! I loved to hear your thoughts about this!
one of my most hated books, I rage read most of it. I want the Bronte estate to give me my money back. 🤬
Wuthering Heights is my favorite classic for many reasons. For one, I love Emily's poetic prose. "Be with me always--take any form--drive me mad! Only do not leave me in this abyss where I cannot find you! Oh, God, it is unutterable! I cannot live without my life! I cannot live without my soul!" That is so BEAUTIFUL and tragic. It's also very different yet timeless and relevant for being a classic about the cycles of abuse and trauma. I think the Laurence Olivier movie adaptation from the 1930s (and most adaptations that followed) has really skewed the public's interpretation or image of WH for only telling half the story. Readers who come from the movies expect this brooding, Jane Austen-like romance and don't know what to do when what they get is actually isolated people hurting from lifetimes of mistreatment and hurting others as they feel trapped by their limited options, class expectations, and toxic relationships and for living with the consequences of their immature, abusive behavior. And yet! the book ends on a hopeful note with Hareton and Cathy, Jr. bettering each other and learning to love each other despite their flaws as they both begin to grow past the mistakes of their parents' generation. Wuthering Heights is poetic realism, and I really appreciate Emily (and the Gothic genre at large) for exploring this difficult side of human nature.
You have expressed the depth and complexity of this novel with such articulation. Thank you.
This is one of my favorite books of all times. It’s so nice and refreshing to see a book about love but not the romantized kind, it’s a book about trauma and prejudice, I feel encapsulates better what it felt like to be a woman or person of color in the past .
I read Wuthering Heights in high school and all of my teachers told me not to. And they're were right. it was not good. Not a huge fan.
“…The flippin’ flap…” 😂
In other words, I really enjoy you and your videos, Leena. 😁
This is one of my favorite novels of all time. It’s such a fantastic exploration of where the line is between too much society and not enough society. Heathcliff representing impulse and lawlessness and chaos and Linton representing class rigidity, rules, and order. And Catherine and Cathy in between, mirror images of each other-one ruined by being too free, the other on the verge of being ruined by being too constrained. Ugh, such a stellar, insightful novel, and dramatic AF. I think I read it five times as a teenager lol.
Wuthering Heights: a Narcissist and a Sociopath ruin a whole bunch of people's lives with their bullshit and drama.
Hated it both times I read it (and both times as an adult).
Please don't treat the new film as a biopic by any means, it will absolutely reveal nothing of any semblance to Emily's true character because all we have are conjectures. All we know of her is that she was near obstinately introverted, petrified of being away from home, and kept very little society. She was an enigma even to Charlotte, who she ended up having somewhat kind of a strained relationship with her in the end as their brother became more unwell. Some psychologists have gone on to ponder if Emily may have fallen somewhere on the ASD spectrum which, not going to lie, fills me full of pride as an autistic person and with WH being my favourite ever, ever book. She had no romances, and I was gutted to see her genius being discredited to some type of lived experience in 'Emily'. Wuthering Heights to me is an incredible, unflinching look at generational trauma and almost I may imagine may be seen as a cathartic release from the moral pressures of 19th century society. Unrestrained wildness of emotion. I absolutely loved to hate all the characters. 🤣
this video could've easily be titled "I read Wuthering Heights so you dont have to" coz i feel like i learnt what i needed from it hahah i've been so tempted to pick this up coz I've never read any of the sisters books and I feel bad. but this does not sound like something i'd enjoy lol. I'm interested in the show tho, didnt even know it was coming out!
If you read only one Brontë, read Jane Eyre
Wuthering heights is exceptional, just because she didn't get it doesn't mean you wouldn't love it
honestly if I'd judged based on what people had told me about this book and considering my usual tastes I would've never read it and would have missed out on one of my favorite reading experiences. I can't even describe how it made me feel with a word other than feral, it was so intense and heart-wrenching, some of the quotes still give me chills when I think about them. That being said yeah it's not for everyone
it's now a year later from this video and i ended up reading Wuthering Heights and HOLY HECK THIS VIDEO COULDN'T BE MORE RIGHT. at least now I know for sure it wasn't for me 😅
As a 30-something who recently read Wuthering Heights, I just want to say I also hated every character. It was awful. I will never read it again. Yet I'm glad I have read it, mostly so I can say that I know how miserable the whole book is
I remember reading this years ago and while I forgot most of the plot points by now, I distinctly remember the heavy mood it conveyed and how striking it was. I read it in Hebrew at the time since that was more readily available to me, so good job on the translator's part as well for conveying that intensity so well I can recall it years later - wildly different languages!
I adore Wuthering Heights! The mistake is people assume it's a romance. 😄 It's a story about horrible people fucking things up for each other and everyone around them. It's like beauty and the beast, if both the main characters were the beast and neither got any better than he is in the first act. It delves into the darkest pits of human behaviour and doesn't excuse or shy away from any of it. Gloriously Gothic!
This is my favourite book so I am terrified by this video but also going to watch it anyway! Can't wait for the new Emily film :)
What do you think now that you’ve watched Leena’s review? 😊
I really love the Tenant of Wildfell Hall by Anne Bronte! I would highly recommend it - I feel like it's not nearly as popular as other Bronte books and it's also interesting how different it is from both Emily and Charlotte Bronte.
Please make more of these with other classics! I was a very bad English student in college and skipped a lot of them
Literally came along here to beg you to do more Classic reads videos. The Picture of Dorian Gray by Oscar Wilde... Doooooooooooo it. It's Fabulous.
But also thank you for unshaming me for not having read this book!! I did an English and Philosophy degree - I've read a lot of books before, during and since - but I've read so few of the greats. I feel way less guilty now and that's because of you. Genuinely, thank you xx
I read Wuthering Heights during lockdown (because the world wasn’t dark enough at that point, I guess). Call me a simp, but I hated it. I tried to find something redeeming; a lesson, a commentary, something about gender or class that would help me to understand English culture a bit more, but nothing was illuminating. The only thing I can think of that gets close is that everyone is so selfish and this is slightly reflective of reality- trauma begets trauma begets trauma. Every character in this book fully plays the part of main character. Heathcliff is obviously a sociopath in the clinical sense, but almost everyone else is incredibly narcissistic and self serving. All around a slog of a book. Womp womp.
I loved Wuthering Heights as a child (although I always said "withering") but I also had an abysmal childhood so there was a sense of mentally playing out how I thought my future would be as a coping mechanism and fantasising about how being rich meant food was always available 😂. I honestly thought these people were so nice compared to my family 🤣 Looking back on it it makes me sad for my child self and so proud of where I am now. This book has definitely been integral to my life and I'm so glad you picked it up! Thank you Leena 💚💚
The only classics book I enjoyed reading in school was Bulgakov's 'The Master and Margarita', even though 'Crime and Punishment' and 'War and Peace' are more popular and more beloved where I'm from. Also Griboyedov's 'Woe from Wit'. Definitely worth a shot.
“I already hate everyone in this book. Everyone. No exceptions.”
My exact experience with this book. Don’t get the love at all.
Me too. I couldn't finish it...
For me it helps me feeling less alone because I have dealt with co dependant crazy family members like Heathcliff, and they also became like that in part because of abuse, rejection and crappy childhood. It's a very unique book about the cycle of violence, I don't know any other like it
Same here. I made it only a few chapters before hating everyone involved and deciding they would all benefit from leaving the gloomy moors for the sunny seaside and making some new friends.
I almost threw this book across the room a couple of times while reading it. As you said, I know that not every character has to be likeable, but I hated everyone in this novel. LOL
Same 😒
My #1 classics rec is Middlemarch. A beast of a book, but SO worth it. Also a surprisingly easy read in terms of language, most of the time! It's just the most ridiculously well-observed novel, with this pinpoint accuracy about psychology, about how gossip works, about the small choices that can set a whole life on a different path, about religion and ethics and the different ways they can (or should) function... Ugh its just SO BLOODY GOOD.
Agree!
I need a warning--does it have a happy ending?
@@schoo9256 Middlemarch? I find the ending really satisfying! It follows several different people, and they each have their own path, so I can't say it's 100% happy. But it's definitely not a tragedy, and compared to Wuthering Heights it's the world's happiest story 💀
@@18becbec thanks for the reply! The ending sounds good to me, in fact the whole book sounds very Jane Austen-y in some ways. Can't wait to give it a go!
@@schoo9256 I'm so glad you're interested! Austen and Eliot are both incredible at observing people, it makes the characters and social politics feel so real. Eliot's life story is also really interesting, she was pretty radical and I think it comes through in her work 😊
i hope this type of video becomes a series, i loved hearing your thoughts and getting to come along the reading journey with you
a bit scared of this video because I love WH & collect editions of the book 🥲😂
me too, I never had a problem with the names, etc. even reading it the first time. WH is awesome. Yes, it is messy and problematic, but love and hate are messy and problematic.
I did not enjoy reading it very much but it's one of those books I love reflecting on after having read it
I read that book as an adult and literally hated it. I hated the characters. Heathcliff is a sociopath.
Kathy B
This is honestly the most depressing book ever. Not my cup of tea. I would, however, love your opinion on Elizabeth Gaskell's 'North and South'. Keep up the quality content!
TW for suicide and eating disorders:
Whether or not Heathcliff is POC (I agree it's plausible), I read him as being so traumatised by poverty and being looked down upon, that even when he essentially becomes part of the upper class, he is still ruined by it and can't accept Cathy The First because of it. He seems to have a real loathing resentment towards her for being born into privilege.
Even if Heathcliff and Cathy 1 aren't biologically related, they are still raised as siblings which is enough to give a modern reader the ick. It reminds me of Frankenstein where Victor is betrothed to his sort of foster sister (or his cousin, depending on which version you read). Watching your review, I am seeing parallels between Frankenstein and Wuthering Heights, which also has a story within a story within a story.
I think you can read one of the morals of WH as being that wild, angry, passionate obsession is not the basis for a great relationship! I wish more romances took that stance, honestly. Mark says something very similar in Peep Show!
I read WH aged 16 and loved it, but I think
[Spoilers Spoilers spoilers]
taking yourself to bed and essentially tantruming yourself to death is more relatable at that age. (That was my favourite part, the intensity of those scenes blew me away).
Speaking of, from a history of women's health perspective, Cathy 1's starvation is pretty fascinating. People will claim that eating disorders are a modern issue, and it's hard to know what to make of Cathy 1's situation.
I highly recommend Frankenstein if you haven't read it. After all, Mary Shelley practically invented two new genres 1. As a teenager 2. For a parlour game 3. Surrounded by trash men. IMO the book is poorly paced but fun and short, and so thematically rich you could view it through many different lenses (feminist, queer, religious etc).
Frankenstein is a great suggestion for Leena's classic reads! David J Bradley has a TH-cam video called The Queer Legacy of Frankenstein, if anyone is interested. It includes discussion of The Rocky Horror Picture Show.
I also think Heatcliff is POC probably of Romani descendence.
Heathcliff possibly being a victim of the Irish Famine is also pretty fascinating when contrasted with rich people starving themselves in the novel.
@@gamewrit0058 agreed, that's a great video.
One of my friends said that she read a book wherein the main characters are discussing the quote on the back of the book and one of them mishears it as “whatever arseholes are made of, his and mine are the same”, so I can’t hear it any other way now.
Also I read this book for school and it was definitely the worst book I was ever assigned.
I studied this book at A Level and at the beginning of every essay (including the exam) we had to declare which of the Catherines we would be referring to as 'Catherine' and which would by 'Cathy' so that the examiners didn't get confused and give us awful marks
Conflicted about watching this when it premieres, because Wuthering Heights absolutely lured me back into reading and most characters’ situations in the novel touched me while reading. I adore WH!!!
I read this novel when I was really young, like 12-13 years old. We had a vague summer reading assignment in-between school years: it was implied that the more we read, the better we'd be graded the next year. But we weren't given an actual list of appropriate books to choose from, so I just devoured a ton of classic literature I was definitely too young to understand.
Well, unlike other masterworks like Jane Eyre or Pride & Prejudice, which I simply consumed on a surface level and/or heavily romanticized, I can tell you in all honesty I blocked Wuthering Heights from my memory. I just remember characters locked in rooms and me hating every minute of it. I put it down and never touched it again and it's been almost 2 decades since then.
But this video has convinced me to finally give it another go.
It would be funny if midway through reading it I'll suddenly remember it all and completely spoil myself. 😂
I love this format and topic!! Please make more read-along classics videos.
I only seen the Tom Hardy adaptation of this book, never read it, it seemed weird to me. But, what's even weirder is how much of a homebody she was, and how quiet she was, but she had such a dark imagination, like, where the hell did that come from, lol
Yeah true!!!
Well, sure, but her brother was an alcohol and drug addict, she knew stories about people who'd experienced horrendous physical and emotional abuse (including her own siblings), and she and her family were encouraged to read lots of different material. So it's not like she didn't know anything about the world, she just chose to limit her participation in it.
@@TheBooklover1848 agreed. Just because they lived in quite an isolated place, people think they were very insular and naive. However they had lives as governesses and had friends from whom they’d learn news/gossip as well as being put through some trauma by their alcoholic brother and his scandalous doings. They’d also had personal experience of much grief given their young ages. Add to that an incredible natural wilderness of an environment and pure literary talent - I’m not surprised at all the Brontë sisters had such an incredible and sometimes dark imagination!
Let us count the sources..............she's of Irish descent, mother long dead, brilliant religious father (northern Irish one would guess, not Papist), precocious sisters and an alcoholic brother, steeped in religion but NOT living in a garden, lots of "Christians" around her not at all acting the part, a nearby church yard FILLED with people dead far too soon, sickness and disease all around, superior artistic endowment with a wild imagination.....................where could WH POSSIBLY have come from????
I have a sentimental place in my heart for Wuthering Heights. I was in a play version in high school, which only had three characters: Nelly, Heathcliff, and Cathy. The intimacy of the play made all the aggression and violence and passion of the characters so evident, because everyone in the story (maybe save Nelly??) is truly awful. It's a horrible cycle, but I do think the ending sees a bit of hope that the cycle will be broken by the following generation. Who knows?
I would recommend watching" To Walk Invisible " it is a shorter film but covers so much more.Also loved your video great fun.
OMG, I loved this book as a teenager, but after watching this, I think I need to read it again through my adult brain!
I have to root for someone when I'm reading and I couldn't root for anyone in this story, so I hated it. And the narration (Mr telling us what Nelly told him) was really annoying me.
Nelly always impressed me by how unfazed and badass she was after all her years with the family when Hindley is threatening her and trying to shove a knife in her mouth she's just like "stop it, that's the fish knife, it tastes disgusting" and he's like "alright fair enough" lol
Wuthering Heights is my favorite book, Emily tricks you into emphasizing with the motives for the cruelty and the injuries of the characters. It's a bizarre slight of hand that wouldn't work without the confusion of the names. The names are the symmetry of the story, the resolution in having Catherine Earnshaw the ghost spirit finally returning to home through "Cathy" getting the last name back. Also the resolution of Hareton who is Heathcliff's true offspring as experiencing the same struggles and abuse as Heathcliff but actually softening and healing as does Cathy. Their love story is the perfect resolution.
I read this book in my early 20's and was expecting, for reasons you cover in the video, some sort of Elizabeth-and-Mr. Darcy-esque love story. Obviously, it is not remotely that. I do not remember enjoying it at all, and had no intention of rereading it. But, I think it would be interesting re reading it without that expectation.
Also, highly highly recommend A Tree Grows in Brooklyn by Betty Smith. It was my absolute favorite book as a pre-teen/teenager and should be recognized more as A Great American Novel.
I have to start with the caveat that my experience of the book was positively affected by the fact I read a (fantastic) translation of it, so I didn't have to struggle with old-fashioned English, but it is one of my favourite stories of all time 😅 I completely agree with the "none of the characters are likable" judgement, but to me that's a testimony to its brilliance: it's rare to be captivated by a book without being really invested in any of the characters. I have to say I didn't have trouble with anyone's motivations; they are all very selfish, self-centred and damaged people, and they act in ways that reflect that.
All that said, I loved this video and would love to see more of this kind in the future 💚
The family tree broke my brain for a while there 😅 I paused the video and couldn’t unpause for, I’m not kidding, about 15 minutes
I haven’t watched the video yet, but I can tell you I have TRIED to read this book several times. I just can’t do it!!! Every time I pick it up I give myself a mental pep talk - you can do this - it’s so short - just keep going. Nope I can’t finish it, I want to understand the hype but I think……I hate it.
I remember reading this in secondary school and being told by the teacher that its an epic love story, and thinking ...errm, but like its NOT though! Its a story about abuse.
I absolutely LOVE this book. I first read it when I was 22 or something, and it was the most incredible experience ever. It is definitely not a book with characters that you are meant to fall in love. I love how the book is narrated by a unreliable character, you don't know exactly if everything that Nelly says is true; she was young when the events of the beginning unfold, and she makes clear, again and again, how she despised the adult Catherine's behavior; of course that affects the way she describes the story. I like to theorize that maybe Heathcliff was indeed Cathy and Hindley's brother (maybe that's why Mr. Earnshaw loved him so much, despite any logical reason, and why Mrs. Earnshaw hated him so much, she even dies from sadness), and that's maybe why their mutual feelings (I wouldn't say "love") was doomed to failure and disgrace. There's a lot of nature in the book, so I don't know, just a theory!
Only Bronte novel that ages relatively well and is genuinely satisfying: Tenant of Wildfell Hall. You're welcome.
I had to read this book over the summer in high school once, and we had to do a project of our own choosing to describe our experience reading it (it was supposed to be more exciting than just an essay). I decided to rewrite the lyrics to "American Pie", putting a summary of different sections in each verse, and then the chorus following it would explain my opinion. My opinion was very negative; I got more annoyed with the book the more pages I read. I can't remember all the lyrics, but the final chorus ended with "I've rhymed everything that goes with 'french fry', now I'll say, I don't like Wuthering Heights." My teacher gave me an A, too!
Literally every character in this book is absolutely awful to each other - I think what I really got out of this book is the idea that people who are hurting, traumatized, etc. will lash out and hurt other people - and I don't think that's a bad idea, but there has to be a more interesting way to introduce the idea that traumatized people can heal & that more people should go to therapy.
Also I totally forgot everyone had the same names!!
I’ve never clicked on something so fast. The rage I still feel 10+ years later thinking about when I had to write a paper on this book in 10th grade English.
Controversial opinion, but I also hate Catcher in the Rye which was also a paper topic in 10th grade.
I've re-read Wuthering Heights a few times and each time I begin I'm optimistic; 'Hmm this is compelling and well written, why did I hate this...' cut to a few 100 pages later and its like oh that's why, because everyone in this book is maddeningly self destructive and horrible.
I still hate this book with a passion. I just don't get how people like it. I could tell Emily Bronte never got out of her house and really got to experience the world because the characters never really develop and it's so overdramatic. It's like a bad fan fic written by a young person who hasn't had much life experience. Also I always thought Heathcliff was darker skinned maybe Romani. Also why the fuck was everyone named Catherine?
Wonder if it was EB's attempt at writing a gothic tale.
I had to give up reading this in English thanks to the one guy early on who is written speaking in a Yorkshire dialect, which I'm not even sure if I've heard spoken out loud, and later got a copy in my first language, then it finally clicked! it's a tragic mess of a book, populated with so many unlikeable characters and that's what I love about it, to the point where if someone says a book has unlikeable characters that's a selling point for me. overall it's very grey imo, exploring some extremely flawed people (for me, the mystery of why Heathcliff is so horrible was central - is it nature or nurture? does it even matter when we see the carnage he leaves behind in his hatred?), and not everyone is into that. I enjoyed it a lot, but even in my first language it was at times a challenging read. also, for some reason my brain decided early on that Heathcliff looked exactly like Taika Waititi as Viago in What We Do In The Shadows.
The first time I read Wuthering Heights I really disliked it. Then we were assigned to read it in school and I don't know what happened but it suddenly became brilliant. It's a grower. I think a lot of it had to do with being able to see the end from the beginning and it's the kind of plot that really works with that. It rereads really well, actually :) I ended up rereading it every year for years (been a couple of years since I last read it so I may need to change that). Loved your review/vlog!
It is melodramatic tosh. I managed to get through it but it wasn't worth it.
I studied wuthering heights for two years at school and for the life of me I cannot remember anything that happened except everyone had the same name and I hated it so much that as soon as I got home after my English exam I literally set my copy on fire and watched it burn 😂😂😂
I read it this summer, it had been on my reading list forever and I really didn’t like it either, so this video was a joy
As you said I hated EVERY character from the beginning, and didn’t care much about what would happen to them. I felt like it was cruel for no real reason, maybe interesting to show the life of some people in this time and era but idk…
and I as well didn’t enjoy that the narration was so much outside of the main character, it made me care even less + I found boring the narrator’s own adventures
oh but there's absolutely nothing like reading wuthering heights when you're an angsty teenage asshole! i definitely read it about 4 times over my adolescence and just adored the atmosphere, the explorations of power dynamics and toxic "soulmates" (i.e. people continually drawn to eachother). the forms and level of cruelty felt really radical to me for a "classic" written by a young woman 170 years ago.
I didn't know they were making the movie!!! So huge thanks for that... and I'm not sure which classics you haven't read, but keeping it on theme for "books with controversial movie choices" might I suggest Breakfast at Tiffany's? It's very short (I believe around 100 pages, maybe even less) and I was surprised by everything they decided to cut for the infamous Hepburn film!
I’ve tried to read wuthering heights twice, my pal absolutely loves it (she bought and papered her room with the prose) but I just can’t get into it 😂 might give it a 3rd try later but after that I’m charity shopping my copy lol
One novel to recommend and that sticked in my mind long after I had read it was "The Thorn Birds" from 1977 by Colleen McCullough. It really good. Romantic book that also has a
frustrating, annoying and stupid man as a love interest. The story is frustrating, but on the same time I was glued to it and couldn't put it down. It's about a young woman in the beginning of 1900 that falls in love with a Catholic Priest. He love her too but loves being a devoted priest too, and he tries to both "ceep the cake and eat it at the same time". ..I recommend it.
A year or two ago I listened to the audiobook, read by the inimitable Patricia Routledge. Even with her *excellent* narration, it was a slog. I found the writing melodramatic and the characters unnatural. It was like Daniel Deronda if every single character were unlikable and hysterical (in the old-fashioned sense of the word). The name thing didn’t get me too much. Then again, for me nothing will ever top the confusing names in Crime & Punishment, so….
Seems like this is an interesting video. I don’t get to see many classics enthusiasts rave about Brontë’s Wuthering Heights. We will definitely look forward to this review, Leena.
I think people are being too literal. Heathcliff was probably ~swarthy, olive skintone not literally black as in of African descent. But who knows as his background is so mysterious. That’s how you write a classic, still debating hundreds of years later !
You should definitely do more reading vlogs! I loved to hear your thoughts about this!
Hell is other people
“Nelly, the ultimate shit stirring servant” 🤣
My personal motto: If you're gonna stir up shit, you should have to lick the spoon.
I first read this when I was 12 and had to read it a few more times in English courses. I thought Heathcliff was an mentally abusive sob at 12 and never changed my mind. It’s a psychological study -not romantic at all.
I just finished reading this book the today! 29 of December of 2022, and I can tell you that I did not love the book and I know really why, I did not like manipulative behavior but for some reason this book did not bored me, I have read more books that have beautiful reading but the plot is boring, so may is for that..
I mean I read it without trying to hard in 7 days, that is a record for me because I have been in a reading slump.
I like the fact that I can enjoy a rendition in song format written by Kate Bush that gives me an entertaining vibe in just a few minutes rather than reading the whole book. My adhd enjoys it too!
could you link it here? it sounds interesting. thanks!
i have MANY thoughts so sorry for the list
1. while i think heathcliff as mixed race is accurate to the books, it’s important to acknowledge how racism of the time may have played into that, especially since he’s portrayed as violent and savage in some ways
2. i read this last year with the combination of the book and the very same audiobook with amy, definitely recommend it, especially since some of the accents are hard to read and comprehend (as an aussie) without amy’s voice and accent contextualising it
3. I LOVE NELLY but also i hate her. she’s really just there for the chaos
4. “hell is other people” very accurately sums this up
i love this book despite how awful everyone is, and i loved your thoughts on it
I think young woke people cannot and will not get any of the Brontes. So go read 50 Shades of Grey? Now thats class for the woke brigade.
To me its composition is one of its strongest aspects - it is narrated by an unreliable narrator, who is told the plot by an equally unreliable narrator - at some point the story reaches us through four-five layers of (equally unreliable) unnarrators. What she could have written had she had a long and productive live!
If you want more Brontë-drama before Emily comes out, Sally Wainwright did a drama called To Walk Invisible which I loved. Lots of stuff on how different the sisters were but how they united due to their situation (aka violent alcoholic messy brother Branwell) - definitely worth a watch if you can catch it!
I remember reading it and thinking it was all over the place. I don’t understand how people find it romantic. Deeply unpleasant overall. Was that the point?
This popped up in my recommended, good video! Coming from a straight A student who read every single novel/poem/hard assignment provided ... I hate this book and it is the only book in my English class in highschool I could not finish and resorted to SparkNotes to complete my work haha. The main reason is that it is absolutely 100% the most depressing thing I have ever attempted to read in my life. It felt like it was influencing my mental health every night I tried to read it. Every page you turn is another depressing angle. I could feel myself being put in a tiny box, with the walls closing in very slowly. If you liked this book, I'm glad, but it is overrated in my opinion. It's a very flat, sad, annoying read :) that's all. Peace and love.
Found this book to be as loathsome as every single character depicted in it. DNF'd it a third in, I couldn't take it anymore :D
i expected to hate wuthering heights when I read it but i actually wound up really enjoying it! Also the movie After ruined that wuthering heights quote from me ngl
Wuthering Heights is my least favorite Classic. I felt very removed from what happened and therefore even the ghastliness of the plot felt rather ridiculous and over the top for me, because I somehow didn't care. So this video gave me a lot to think about but also validated my feelings. I don't want to re-read Wuthering Heights, but I should really have a good think about it and maybe I can take some more from it that way.
Wonder if it was EB's attempt at writing a gothic tale.
I have literally no idea, I had to read it for uni and I really did not like it. Everybody just dies to slowly and I hate the miscommunication. I don't understand how it is supposed to be a love story. :/
It was assigned to me in high school and I simply could not read it. Could not follow, didn’t like anyone, gave up.
I think this books is really good is you want somebody to understand what kind of time where those time, they were awful and people were awful, I think that is why reading this book make me feel sick, there any good or innocent character.
Catherine not to be confused with…. Catherine 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Also I had read Heathcliff is being black growing up and my mother had always read it that he was the illegitimate son of Kathy's Father which is why he was so against the marriage