Hello Narasimha Rao Sir, I want to request you to do a prediction and analysis on future of Bangladesh and it's relations with India.....like many Indians, I am really worried about the way things turned out for Bangladeshi Hindus on Durga pujo ,2021 .
Bangladesh will become Zero Hindu Nation in coming the next decade, and from its they become 2nd syria and after 2045 they returned to their root dharma and intrigated with India. Pvr Narsima predicts about Akhnd Bharat starts from 2042 and its continues.
1.Please make Video on Hinduism future in India &in particular the states like WB, Kerala and assam. 2.Will Pakistan break-up if yes how will it impact islam in India will there be decline in their population. 3.Will China break up and would it become a friend of India. 4.How long India would be Hindu Majority Country and How long BJP will remain in power I wish they stay for 50 years.
4:00 For a few seconds I was wondering why the other 3 participants are just staring still on the camera, until I realised its a photo and not a video about their faces 😁
U r asking the credibility and the existence of the thing which these people are using as a tool...simple answer... eternal is hinduism...they can surely tell what time... Dharmic people will suffer more or less when they will be prosperous...and such things...
Dr Manish Pandit explained why that cannot be the time period for the Arundathi/Vasustha movement. He explains basically that the verses indicate that the phenomenon is supposed to be a temporary movement, which happens every year. Not a long epoch phenomenon. He uses the scripture as proof, which calls the phenomeon a nimita. As in, it is not a long epoch movement.
Obviously a parallel universe where Prabhupadas translation is widely accepted! The talk was centered on biases without appropriate validation like date for Kali Yuga, for instance.
Hare Krishna. Srila Prabhupada's translation is the pure truth for us. I looked up another researcher and it is quoted by that one too. When I looked at the video closely though, I saw that there was another translation of that same verse in the next slide. It showed a very similar translation although Dr Pandit went to the slide after that. I hope he puts out the shlokas of many other Puranas like Brahma Vaivarta Purana which point to the war starting after Kaliyuga. Hare Krishna. All obeisance to Srila Prabhupada.
Pt. Sanjay Rath/Visti Larsen has further rectified on Lord Krishna’s chart from Dr. BV Raman in “Notable Horoscope” and it’s around 3000+ BCE not 5000+ BCE
@@SD-1192 here is Nilesh Oaks response to this post when i shared it with him Their claims are falling apart: 1. Because of the wrong premises they are built upon 2. Due to internal contradictions 3. Disconnect with Mahabharata evidence. There is no need for me to do anything. Watch the fun as it unfolds.
Hare Krishna. Finally I found proof that ignorance is bliss. I had no idea that followers of Mr Oak knew so little. I ask myself whether it is possible that a culture which gave us the Gita which we recite here in Europa, can know so little science in today's age. A simple Google search would have told you that Redshift, Cybersky and Jhora all account for Precession of the Equinoxes. That is the same software used by Dr Pandit and Jhora is made by Narasimha Rao. All dates except 3136/3137bc account for Axial precession and that is because the author of that dating effort used Surya Siddhanta which takes trepidation into account. In fact, if I have understood it correctly, it is ny using Precession of the Equinoxes that Mr Oak's theory fails. All obeisance to Srila Prabhupada.
@@suhasinidasi3126 Redshift, Cybersky you got me ..so now i am going to have to check again these three items that Oak pointed out to me ...please stand by ...'their claims are falling apart:. 1. Because of the wrong premises they are built upon 2. Due to internal contradictions 3. Disconnect with Mahabharata evidence.'
@@rdrr5973 Einstein :: Science. Dr.BV Raman::Astrology Dr. BV Raman has arrived at Lord Krishna’s chart with 3000 BCE and not 5000 BCE. To all Vedic Astrologers, no human, no force on earth is greater than Dr. BV Raman in Astrology, unless you contradict. Then you may as well contradict greatest Einstein in Science.
@@agnipath4184 he has written an amazing software for astrology. He has written quite a few wonderful books and gives for free on his website. He has simplified and spread lot many important Vedic methods to make everyone's life a lot more beautiful. Yes he is an excellent role model and a Super Hero. Its difficult for me to even imagine doing what he has done already.
@@pawmin88 Yes I know ,Hindu scholars always try to demean other hindu scholars. That's very painful for all Hindus.Their egos are too big.Instead of debunking western pseudo Sanatan dharm specialist , they try to destroy their own scholars.
@@agnipath4184 I m sure there was no ill will here towards anyone, I m yet to complete the video. But you should not be disappointed, just bcoz someone saw this, doesn't make them not listen to their critics. Yes scholars tend to have an attachment with their own hardwork and thoughts, but that doesn't change the fact that the intelligent listeners(the ones who can have a broader impact) are always thirsty to know the other side
@@agnipath4184 I disagree with your rant on Hindu scholars, it's a phenomenon accross the world, not just Hindus. People hate their neighbor's more than strangers
What difference does it make if it did happen. I personally believe it did. What is important is that the 'Mahabharat' explains the meaning of karma and the 'Ramayana' is the perfect example of the path of Karma Yoga. Learning from them can provide healing in this modern world.
Sirs…. When will this get its place in Indian History? World don’t look at it with Bhakti but empirically …. We need it be justified… we have west to confirm it…. Please initiate the process 🙏
@@pvr108 Namaste sir 🙏 I would like to ask do you provide consultation readings as well. I had no way of contacting you thus reaching out this way. Thank U in advance sir 🙏
@@pvr108 dear sir . Some people are frequently reading my mind. Please make a video including a best possible solution for this also .. I will be grateful if you do so .. its so frustrating that people are blackmailing me like this .. many people might not believe to what I am writing but it's absolutely fact ... PLEASE HELP ME 🙏.. GURUDEV .. YOUR RESPONSE MIGHT HELP TO THOSE PEOPLE ALSO WHO ARE FEELING THE SAME WAY DEALING WITH EXTREME PAIN .. JAI GURUDEV ...
Bharata Varsha is 7 continents of America to Asia. Babylon was a major center of Bharata Varsha. Ashurbanipal is Asura Bani Apli, he was an Asura. Arjuna crosses the White Mountains probably at the North Pole to reach Kimpurusha varsha. Bharata Varsha is one of the varshas in Jambudvipa. Jambudvipa is the middle circle among the dvipas. You can watch the videos that state there is more land beyond the poles and the videos regarding Operation Highjump.
@Narasimha Rao Garu. Could you please ,with an open mind, read and comment on the astrological (old vedic 7×7 matrix chart based on Sarvathobhadra Chakra), lineage based, and literary evaluation (e.g. alternate interpretations of word "varshani" in vedic, RM and MB sanskrit) for dating of Ramayana, MahaBharatam in "The science of time and timeline of World history" by Sunil Sheoran? He did draw many interesting hypothesis about differnt aspects such as length of yugas (i.e. not some millions but rather only decades), other contemporary civilizations, and demystification. Fyi, as per him, MB war ended in 827 BCE. If possible, please invite him to your next workshop as well. We would like to watch this discussion as well. ధన్యవాదము 🙏
You should also consider geological evidence in form of Dwarka being submerged. Astrological evidence is strong but geological evidence can be stronger.
pranam guruji, I started learning vedic astrology from your book. can you please take a session on your youtube channel on how to learn astrology from your book and lectures please.
@@thewalkthrougher6556 1 Divine year equals to 360 Human years. 1200 Divine years equal to 432000 human years and also the span of Kaliyuga. Krishna passed on 3102 BC, and now it's 2021. So approximately 427000 years left.
@@shibasishkar7564 I'm telling, it has astronomical elaboration in Surya Sidhanta for yugas in sense of planets, not yuga transitions on earth. It has been interpreted as yugas transitions on earth that is not true!
@@shibasishkar7564 Your calculation is correct. In kaliyuga human life span is max 100 years whereas in satyayuga it was 1lakh years, Lord Rama lived for 10000 years and in Dwapara yuga 1000 years life span and Lord Krishna lived for 125years. So there is a method to calculate Yugas and I heard somewhere 2025 or 2026 Kaliyuga will end and Dharmic people will enter to Dwapara yuga. And it's a cycle we need to follow like clockwise and anti clockwise.
Wonderful revealing by Shri Narasimha Ji regarding Jagannath Hora software that even when Surya Siddhanta (SS) is used the eclipse is not predictable as it can vary and the underlying logic is drig method of computation and not really the SS for many other calculations. And none can be as close as real observation and recordings that is more important than just formulas that are approximations and use of the pushya based Ayanamsa (I am convinced with this use) but still I believe the far planets could have undergone changes similar to moon hit by comets etc. And it is highly unpredictable to the frank unless it is counted day by day similar to how we have our current agreement on the Kali period mentioned that has support from many quarters including the inscriptions pointing to the same by Smt. Dr. Jayashree Saranatan Ji. The date is irrelevant as there is no year wise count that is mandated in our sankalpa based on the MB war rather it is just based on the Kali starting that count is kept. This is more important.
Hare Krishna. In fact, if I have understood it correctly from this video, Surya Siddhanta uses Drik Siddhantha to compute eclipses but is not accurate for various other reasons. Drik Siddhanta computes eclipses to within a few hours as does Cybersky.
Dear Narasimha ji, i am watching your channels for a long time and as per your earlier prediction good time of PM Modiji & HM Amitshahji will start after sept or Oct,21. but till now we are not finding any symptoms and we are worried on India and Hindus. Please do some reading to console whole Indian Hindus using your great skills and what we have to do to protect our dharma in this worlds against various evil elements
I believe when PVRji mentioned "good period", he was talking about Modi and Shah being able to implement some tough decisions in this period for the good of the nation, and not a time where there is a lot of calmness (which is impossible in today's geopolitical scenario). If you take it that way, we already have Air India sell off, OFB conversion into PSUs etc., which were stuck for decades. May be more are on the way..
He takes wrong lagn of Modi as libra lagn. Modi's lagn is scorpio. 9th lord in 1st house moon - poetry, emotions. 12th lord in 10th house - implementing world bank and IMF's conditions in the name of reforms as is. Scorpio lagn - this secrecy, planted.
@@mrpradeep313 yes same with bad bank which gonna improve situations of Non performing assets of banks, with 100Cr vaccination mark, glad we have a great leadership at right time.
Based on Veerabrahmendra's life and his sayings, Kaliyugam is running in 5000 years... I am still skeptical about the 3000 BCE....Veerabrahmam is not a simple person....we have to verify
Yes, The ANTARDASHA of Satyug is going to start. Veerabrahmendra Swami is also famous in Maharashtra, Because of Dattatreya/Nath Sampraday. Yesterday I ask question to shri pandit on twitter and he admitted that currently we are in Pralay sandhi. If you are on twitter see this. I also shared reference of Shripad Shrivallbha of Pithapur/pithikapur
Sir Jayashree madam says there is a celestial body hitting both the earth and the moon disturbing the trajectory of the moon and shaking it out of equilibrium. She substantiates the same by showing temperature maps on the celestial body during those times. We recently even seen photos from NASA where Jupiter was hit by some meteor. Is it not possible that such astronomical phenomenon should have happened to shift the Thithi of the moon and if it happens then the dating matches with the calculations of Dr Jayashree madam 🙏
Hare Krishna. I recently happened to read the original paper by Seifert where a comet hit may be given at the 3200bc time frame. But then I realised that his paper relies on Axial precession model which is rejected by madam. The other problem is that this 3200bc date would fit any theory in the 3200bc range, but if it fits 3137bc, then it fits 3138,3138 and 3140 bc as well. There are numerous comet hits even at a later stage, those would fit other theories. Thus it is not specific to any researcher. It would fit any theory.
@@suhasinidasi3126 Hare Krishna 🎉 Thanks for taking time to comment Madam 🙏 Jayashree madam says the celestial object hit both the Earth and Moon making a shift in the Thithi in itself and the Moon took time to get back to its equilibrium considering moon a small object in the solar system do you consider it as impossible provided we have the temperature maps of the moon at that particular point of time there is a strong fluctuations in the temperature in some particular regions of it ?
@@indianfromsouth7756 Hare Krishna. Thanks for the comment. I think that this idea you suggest is a possibility. But then what would be the force required to shift the earth's orbit so much even if momentarily? I remember a conference in the United States where they discussed this possibility from 10000bc. That sort of comet strike would be surely classified as an extinction level event? Where is the crater on earth which points to such an event? If such an event has taken place during the Mahabharat, how did humans survive it and why is there no evidence for the same? All obeisances to SrilaPrabhupada.
@@suhasinidasi3126 Hare Krishna 🙏 Yes Mam this did cross my mind as well will have to check the recording of impacts of this celestial happening. Dr. Pandit ji I think has corroborated the dates wonderfully. I do understand from his speach in Sangam Talks that he has oceanographic evidence of Dwaraka Submergence corroborated for his Dates. I am going through panditji's book again to understand him better. Many thanks madam for your time and insights 🙏 Jai Shree Rama ! Jai Shree Krishna !!
@@indianfromsouth7756 Hare Krishna. Thank you. I was a follower of Mr Oak for many years and then realised that his theory was all wrong after witnessing a few Moonrises in Ireland. That is when the penny dropped that he was completely wrong. I then saw Dr Pandit explain the 14th war night in a few workshops and realised that he had gotten it spot on. When I commented on a video and pointed this out, Mr Oak felt that I had "no scientific acumen". Then I knew that Mr Oak's Moonphases were fake. Dr Pandit on the other hand, appears to have solved the puzzle that is the Mahabharata. His explanations have improved over time. Previously there was more verbosity but now there is a great insight with far fewer words which carry a tremendous impact. Coming to cometary impacts, I think that these are at best hypothetical unless they carry evidence of craters like the Burckle crater. I hope these two Dr Pandit and Mr Rao make a separate film on it.All obeisance to Srila Prabhupada.
Very patchy research..pvr ji, I hv been hearing many such researchers on TH-cam I wonder if it will be a good idea for u to individually pursue this…based on yr knowledge and insights I believe Mahabharatha will reveal itself only to the blessed. I would request you to research this if u r not in it already
Amazing insightful video. Sir one humble request to you is that please make a video on detailed prediction of events for the MVA government's fall or loss of power. We the people in Maharashtra are at the epitome of suffering now and its getting unbearable to the point that daily activities in life are getting miserable from dealing with dirty cops to bureaucrats it is just terrible. When will get relief from another government formation? When will the thugs and goons party be wiped of from Maharashtra?
Sir, according to Shri Yukteshwar guru of Yogananda, we're currently in Ascending Dwapar Yuga. He has given Yuga cycle of approx 12000 years of Descending cycle from satya to kali yuga and approx 12000 years Ascending cycle going from kali yuga to satya yuga. According to to him kaluyuga ended around 1900 and technology age which is dwapar started. What is your take on that?
I have read Sri Yukteshwar Giri's Holy Science but in my honest opinion, I do not think he was true. First of all, he does not give any evidence to back his theory. Secondly, according to his theoy, Mahabharata would have occurred some 2,500 years ago but a recent study has found that Saraswati River disappeared 4,200 years ago which means Mahabharata would have occurred atleast 4,200 years ago (probably even more) since Saraswati was a perinnial river during the times of Mahabharata.
@Pati Bangla No no! You should not say that. He was an enlightened being and we should respect him. Swami Vivekananda also carried the book 'Imitation Of Christ' along with Gita so was he also making cocktail of Krishna and Christ? Enlightened beings take birth all over the world and Christ was one of them. If you actually look into his pure teachings, it seems very Vedantic. Yes, it is true that what the missionaries are doing is very unjust and there are also many adulterations in Bible.
@Pati Bangla whether cocktail or not it depends upon whom you believe. The fact is Jesus Christ is a combination of two words having historical two different communities and language roots and there is no real evidence to point at a historic person, in reality, if you follow x-Christian Esther Dhanraj Ji you will know more about it Coming to the way these great personality like Paramhansa Yogananda and Ramakrishna Vivekananda - they are of different league who moved the people who were blinded by the western theology. So it is fair to assume that it was a correct step to attract them without offending them and provide an exposure to the alternative Indic views from an insider's point of view. You have to remember they never let down the Hindu Dharma or cause, even though they accepted the beliefs of RoP (assume that to be a sales pitch, no harm, as selling something worthwhile is important by someway or other, it is like adding suger to a sour syrup to make a adamant child to consume).
You have easily brushed away the AV observation as a regular occurrence. Some questions in this regard. a. why was it called a bad omen, if it was a yearly occurrence? b. AV observation is on astronomical timescale (thousands of years). Hence the definition of Nimitta has to be aligned to the astronomical timescale. it is unreasonable to expect that to happen for a few hours or days. Events like these cant be expected to be like eclipses, since movement of stars (relative to earth) is very slow. c. if it was a yearly occurrence as Panditji says, Arundhati will still lose her "paativratya", regardless of whether it happens for 1 hour or 1 day or 1000 years. So, the claim that it was just a bad omen which never occurred falls flat. Unfortunately, instead of doing shastrartha, there have been 2 gangs created and each side is trying to add clout. A sanatani who is after truth is lost in this hegemony. The reality is somewhere in between. Both theories (5561 and 3067) have certain aspects unanswered, while Oak admits it(in his book), Panditji says his theory answers all. Truth said, 3067 fails AV observation. A last naive question : Why do we accept that start of Kaliyuga was 3102 BC? Is this a postulate or a theorem with proof?
Follow Smt. Dr. Jayashree Saranathan and this humbug of AV observation in her blogs and many videos and you will understand why it is not true. But be open to hear strong critical answers that clearly counters this theory.
There were a lot of (almost reluctant) references to what I have called the Oak conjecture which stands boldly in opposition to your theory. You do need to demolish it thoroughly for any other view to become more acceptable. Your criticism of the AV observation was not forceful enough, and was not very clear. If you destroy this plank, the Oak conjecture fails. Could you please explain once again with greater rigour that this is an annual phenomenon and nothing special hinges on this? You could further explain how many warriors died, and is their death reflected in population estimates? The Oak conjecture deduces a date for the flooding of Dwarka, and the evidence for that particular date. Are you able to do the same for your date? Thank you.
When did Mahabharata war happen? I know the answer ....in my life the day of my marriage was the day i was defeated and even since then I m living life in asylum war has become a routine part of my daily livelihood some day bramhaashtra some day pashupatashtra some day sudarshan and some day narayanashta ....the quarrels at home is so intense and dense that every god gets disappeared just at an onset .....the original answer to this question is I don't know but in my life ....the day of my marriage ... mahabharat started on my life ....the only thing left is ruins of life
I totally agree with Narsimha Sir, the Kaliyug started after Shri Krishna left for Vaikuntha, the story of Kali meeting Parikshit and his death from takshaka is completely ignored in this conversation, in jyotish even if dasha of a planet if not started its effects can definitely felt before the dasha has started.
How does the Parikshit - Kali narrative affect the commencement date of Kali Yuga? Parikshit became king just prior to the Pandavas leaving for their final journey after the passing of Bhagavan Krishna. By that time Kali was in fully virulent, which was why Parikshit confronted and captured Kali Purush, the personification of Kali Yuga. So it in fact buttresses Sri Pandit's case that Kali Yuga began before the war, because it would be natural for the effects to gain full strength after a few decades.
@@thrinethran2885 but he has to counter that with sastric evidence, when you already have clear sastric evidence in terms of when kali starts both in MB and SBM.
How can it be possible that even after the Ashtami date of Shukla Paksha, 3/4th of a month will be left? Whereas in our Indian calendar, the first side of a month is Krishna Paksha and the last and second side is Shukla Paksha. Either you have misunderstood the meaning of the verse or our current Panchang is wrong.
Hi.. next time when you make PPT slides can you please try and use colors that can be seen even by ppl with a visual disability. For example yellow text in blu background is Not visible to me .. on the contrary black text in white or yellow or cream background is perfect .. thank you
Hello Sir, please make video on Tamilnadu Hindu fates and Hindu temples fate due to DMK want to melt all temple golds and silver to cash and spend. Is there any way to protect temple assests and pariharam to stop this happenings.
Sir, An Astrologer must be unbiased But you use word "Unfortunately" while predictions on opposition But not the same word while predictions on BJP. Why?
It should be verifiable whether Mackay discovered the clay tablet and how it was dated, eg by radio carbon dating which gives an approximate time period. The picture is unmistakably that of the Yamalarjuna bhanjana episode, is all one can say. But the tablet is not germane to the discussion which focuses on the astronomical or astrological identification of the specific period before 3000 bce in which the Mahabharata war occurred.
@@thrinethran2885 It was made germane by the host. Nevertheless, as for astrony based predictions, the star chart repeats after approx. 26,000 years so that alone cannot be sufficient.
Sadhguru says we are at the end of dwapar yuga th-cam.com/video/1WNQDqXZOWg/w-d-xo.html To accommodate all of Kalyuga and Dwapar yuga the farthest date looks valid. 🙏
Narsimha ji, can you please revisit mamata banerjee's chart? She has been on a campaign spree in various states and is looking to form alliances to form a central government. We saw how people of bengal were enticed, and i am concerned for the future of this country if such people ride on power.
What I think the situation going on around world the way everybody expanding military, it does gonna end and dharmic and sustainable practice gonna rise within 10 to 15 yrs, ------------PVR Narsimharao Sir said in one of videos
cant tolerate any discussion without Nilesh oak. only astronomical data is not important, what about hydrology, geology, paleobotany, climatology, and many other branches of sciences?. Nilesh provided parallel evidences along with astronomy, in a one-on-one, Manish pandit didnt last long,last time I saw they faced.
Nilesh Oak, 5561 + 2021 = 7582 years ago. Probably he gave a date for Ramayan. Why, because 2500 years ago Vishnu's 9th avtar Gautam Budh came. Then going back further Vishnu's 8th avtar Krishn came roughly 5000 years ago. Again, going back further, 7th avtar Ram must have come 7500 years ago. And, let me add, now is this the time of Vishnu's 10th - Kalki avtar?, Narsimha Rao
Budhha was not incarnation of Vishnu . Budhha was normal mortal being like you and me who was heavily influenced by Uttar Mimansha . Incarnation does not have to find truth they are the truth .
This is an astrology platform. Go to BPHS chapter 2. Sage parashar has given an analogy of all the avtars compared with the planets. Matsya = Ketu Tortoise = Saturn Boar = Rahu Narsimha = Mars Vaaman = Jupiter Parshuram = Venus Ram = Sun Krishn = Moon Gautam Budh = Mercury So, the 9th avtar was Gautam Budh born 2500 years ago, 8th avtar Krishn born 5000 years ago, 7th avtar Ram born 7500 years ago? And, therefore, now Kalki time?
@@pranshupushpam All your assessments are wrong . Ram came way back at least 15000 years back and Krishna at least 7500 years back . And Budhha was not incarnation. I don't derive my conclusion based on what is written by whom . I don't believe in dogma . It's my personal assesment that Budhha was not enlighten since birth and attained some good knowledge through mimansha text which later became foundation of Buddhism. Infact if you read in detail of Budhha , he was quite doubtful about Brahma and seems to not understand larger concept of eternal Braham as Ishwar . He was very convoluted in terms of his assertion that Ishwar is eternal existing and main driving force . Unlike Budhha all other incarnation were self aware and solidified the foundation of eternal Brahma without any ambiguity . That is why I don't consider Budhha as Incarnation rather just as a noble genius soul .
To add more, if there is a cycle of 24000 years then give a time span of 2400 years between two avtars and so you get the approximate date of the 9th avtar Budh and the 8th avtar Krishn, that also fairly matches the popular belief of their respective birth years. Are we into the ```sandhi kaal``` of yug parivartan and soon will also get to see Kalki avtar?
Very nice discussion SIR according to guru parampara sara of sri sampradaya nammalwar is supposed to have taken birth five thousand years ago approx and in one of his verses he says he missed krishna by a week oru varam tappinene in tamil so the date of war seems to be correct.Secondly though kali yuga manifested earlier as long as lotus feet of lord krishna was touching the earth it could not be effective this explanation is also in srimad bhagawatam dhanyosmi
Debunking 5561 BCE without any reason given just assuming it to be false, this is not the way to analyze things, how much work has been put on this date can you imagine, just read Nileash Oak's work and then try to debunk it!
Hare Krishna. This was an awesome workshop. The eyeopener for me was the part where Bhisma Nirvana was perfectly shown in the waxing phase of the Moon and on the 8th part of the Moonphase on the 4th day after Winter Solstice in Dr Pandit's theory and Dr Oak's theory was seen to be failing on all possible fronts (it looked to be the waning phase Moon on the third part of the waning phase which was obviously wrong). You also pointed out that 3 more theories fail on some set of criteria? I think it would be useful to name the researchers as most people do not know about a theory. I certainly didn't know about the fake Moonphases or Srila Balram's Naksatra mistake in Mr Oak's theory until they were pointed out to us by our Guru. The explanations given in your video definitely seem very credible. As a former Christian, it is well known that the legends of Christianity are based on the solstitial movements of the Sun so thanks for pointing out an even earlier tradition from the East. The Aldebaran star at Bhisma Nirvan is magical. More of this please. I did not know that any researcher used Surya siddhant until you pointed it out. That is obviously wrong. The correct settings must be used to get the right result.
Guruji, Nilesh oak has done very scientific work with hundreds of evidences from Mahabharata, oceanography, geology and so many others to arrive very elaborate dating of this. Suggest give him chance to present thro your channel 🙏🙏
No, his research is nonsensical, though he has excellent communication skills and marketing savvy. Influential people who wanted to _believe_ that Mahabharata actually happened promoted him without paying attention to details (i.e. fell for his smooth talk)! _Bottomline:_ Mahabharata war did happen, but 2000 years after the date he gives.
@@pvr108 Guruji, then, it's good to call Nilesh Oak for shashtrath and discuss and derive to a point with evidence and findings and correct him for the betterment of the humanity. It is the duty of seniors and gurukuls to teach correct knowledge. Why don't you write letter and send him a whitepaper on your views and infact on his book analysis and so he could connect the dots correctly and we have right information. 🙏🏼
@@dwiranwic while your request is totally correct, not sure PVR sir will have time and energy to correct all such people. People like you and me who are after facts, have to do something to correct those who are wrong.
Hello Sir, can you please tell the fate of Sameer Wankhede. Is he honest and if so, will he be saved ? please please do a youtube video on him. thank you.
@@pvr108 I watched the entire live streaming event however it abruptly ended and unsure if it has continued beyond 49 minutes or will it be a part 2 live event for next week?
This is my favourite theory of all proposed, and I accept it above Nilesh Oak's theory. But it is largely dependent upon the accuracy of the start of Kali Yuga. Who is to say that this is the accurate period for its beginning?
No, his research is nonsensical, though he has excellent communication skills and marketing savvy. Influential people who wanted to _believe_ that Mahabharata actually happened promoted him without paying attention to details (i.e. fell for his smooth talk)! _Bottomline:_ Mahabharata war did happen, but 2000 years after the date he gives.
@@pvr108 From a learned person like you, Mr.Rao, I was expecting an argument with some substance, and not one relying on the style or personality of the other.
@@chhupparustom Yeah I'm so surprised with his answers, Narasimha should try to prove it wrong through some sense not like just say he is unscientific, I doubt he ever have read the book or listened to him just heard some rumors, thats not how a person with some reason talks! A talk should be held between all these learned people to reach the truth together respectively.
Dear Brothers, Guruji Dr. Manish Pandit had a debate with Nilesh Oak, which is available on TH-cam and also have several videos on dating of Mahabharata, Balarama’s Piligrimage. This video is just a Tip of Iceberg.
Srimad Bhagwat puran clearly mentioned that Kaliyug started on the day ,when Lord Sri Krisna departed from Earth. Hence, rest talks between these Anchors are WASTAGE OF TIME.
All the frauds have joined together so that you can challenge Jayasree Saranathan ji real vedic astrological timings I never thought Narshimha ji that you will fall down at this level, now I realize why you were promoted by Rajiv Malhotra
Mrs Saranathan means well, but made the terrible mistake of relying on Surya Siddhanta formulas tuned for one era to another era. We clearly explained in the video. She at least get the date in the right ballpark (around 3k BCE).
@@pvr108 ji Why not debate this with Jayasree ji herself instead of passing judgement on her? She is always ready for discussion and debate Please be transparent, did you not call out Jayasree ji with that cryptic tweet the other day? Were you pressured by someone to put out that tweet? Also stay away from Rajiv Malhotra don't let his influence effect you in your thoughts
Hello Narasimha Rao Sir, I want to request you to do a prediction and analysis on future of Bangladesh and it's relations with India.....like many Indians, I am really worried about the way things turned out for Bangladeshi Hindus on Durga pujo ,2021 .
Bangladesh will become Zero Hindu Nation in coming the next decade, and from its they become 2nd syria and after 2045 they returned to their root dharma and intrigated with India. Pvr Narsima predicts about Akhnd Bharat starts from 2042 and its continues.
Pranam Guruji... Absolutely enthralling as always... Om shri guruvae nama
Great discussion. Narasimha Rao's advise to not rely on Surya Siddhanta along with his reasons makes all the difference in the dating of Mahabharatha.
1.Please make Video on Hinduism future in India &in particular the states like WB, Kerala and assam.
2.Will Pakistan break-up if yes how will it impact islam in India will there be decline in their population.
3.Will China break up and would it become a friend of India.
4.How long India would be Hindu Majority Country and How long BJP will remain in power I wish they stay for 50 years.
They will
4:00 For a few seconds I was wondering why the other 3 participants are just staring still on the camera, until I realised its a photo and not a video about their faces 😁
What's the future of Hinduism? Please make a video on this even while discussing the future of other proselytising religions.
U r asking the credibility and the existence of the thing which these people are using as a tool...simple answer... eternal is hinduism...they can surely tell what time... Dharmic people will suffer more or less when they will be prosperous...and such things...
wow, Guruji Narasimha Rao?! just randomly click on this recommended video and am very happy to see Jyotish Guru Narasimha.
For me to
@@visalg Om Guruvae Namah
Maybe you guys should make a video on when dwarka went under the ocean, the timing of that also will support the year theories
Very very important
Without Nilesh Oak this discussion is incomplete!
Nilesh Oak is a very headstrong, stubborn and adamant person.
@@taxoholicmusings have u debated him?
@@satyamm009 yes he's like my way or highway type.
@@taxoholicmusings but he has proof and intense research on his side
The fact is Dr. Manish Pande could not stand in front of him in a direct head on. And that's why sounded odd about the 5K BCE.
5500 BCE is established by Dr. Nilesh oak taking Astrolgical events of Mahabharata . After taking into consideration of Vasustha Arundathi movement .
Dr Manish Pandit explained why that cannot be the time period for the Arundathi/Vasustha movement. He explains basically that the verses indicate that the phenomenon is supposed to be a temporary movement, which happens every year. Not a long epoch phenomenon. He uses the scripture as proof, which calls the phenomeon a nimita. As in, it is not a long epoch movement.
Obviously a parallel universe where Prabhupadas translation is widely accepted!
The talk was centered on biases without appropriate validation like date for Kali Yuga, for instance.
Hare Krishna. Srila Prabhupada's translation is the pure truth for us. I looked up another researcher and it is quoted by that one too. When I looked at the video closely though, I saw that there was another translation of that same verse in the next slide. It showed a very similar translation although Dr Pandit went to the slide after that. I hope he puts out the shlokas of many other Puranas like Brahma Vaivarta Purana which point to the war starting after Kaliyuga. Hare Krishna. All obeisance to Srila Prabhupada.
A genuine doubt, why the issue with Srila Prabhupada's translation, can you point to me any article?
sorry guys .....your whole business about 3100's BCE does not account the precession of equinox ....i 'm more convinced with Oak's 5561 BCE time frame
Pt. Sanjay Rath/Visti Larsen has further rectified on Lord Krishna’s chart from Dr. BV Raman in “Notable Horoscope” and it’s around 3000+ BCE not 5000+ BCE
@@SD-1192 here is Nilesh Oaks response to this post when i shared it with him
Their claims are falling apart:
1. Because of the wrong premises they are built upon
2. Due to internal contradictions
3. Disconnect with Mahabharata evidence.
There is no need for me to do anything. Watch the fun as it unfolds.
Hare Krishna.
Finally I found proof that ignorance is bliss. I had no idea that followers of Mr Oak knew so little. I ask myself whether it is possible that a culture which gave us the Gita which we recite here in Europa, can know so little science in today's age. A simple Google search would have told you that Redshift, Cybersky and Jhora all account for Precession of the Equinoxes. That is the same software used by Dr Pandit and Jhora is made by Narasimha Rao. All dates except 3136/3137bc account for Axial precession and that is because the author of that dating effort used Surya Siddhanta which takes trepidation into account. In fact, if I have understood it correctly, it is ny using Precession of the Equinoxes that Mr Oak's theory fails. All obeisance to Srila Prabhupada.
@@suhasinidasi3126 Redshift, Cybersky you got me ..so now i am going to have to check again these three items that Oak pointed out to me ...please stand by ...'their claims are falling apart:. 1. Because of the wrong premises they are built upon 2. Due to internal contradictions 3. Disconnect with Mahabharata evidence.'
@@rdrr5973 Einstein :: Science. Dr.BV Raman::Astrology
Dr. BV Raman has arrived at Lord Krishna’s chart with 3000 BCE and not 5000 BCE. To all Vedic Astrologers, no human, no force on earth is greater than Dr. BV Raman in Astrology, unless you contradict. Then you may as well contradict greatest Einstein in Science.
Mr. Rao is my New Hero.
Hero? Yes he is good fortune teller.
@@agnipath4184 he has written an amazing software for astrology. He has written quite a few wonderful books and gives for free on his website. He has simplified and spread lot many important Vedic methods to make everyone's life a lot more beautiful. Yes he is an excellent role model and a Super Hero. Its difficult for me to even imagine doing what he has done already.
@@pawmin88 Yes I know ,Hindu scholars always try to demean other hindu scholars. That's very painful for all Hindus.Their egos are too big.Instead of debunking western pseudo Sanatan dharm specialist , they try to destroy their own scholars.
@@agnipath4184 I m sure there was no ill will here towards anyone, I m yet to complete the video. But you should not be disappointed, just bcoz someone saw this, doesn't make them not listen to their critics. Yes scholars tend to have an attachment with their own hardwork and thoughts, but that doesn't change the fact that the intelligent listeners(the ones who can have a broader impact) are always thirsty to know the other side
@@agnipath4184 I disagree with your rant on Hindu scholars, it's a phenomenon accross the world, not just Hindus. People hate their neighbor's more than strangers
The Mahabharata of Maharshi Vedavyas itself says that beginning of the "Kaliyuga" is from 18th day of the great war.
Reference to verse by Shri Madhwacharya at the end is simply wow!
What difference does it make if it did happen. I personally believe it did. What is important is that the 'Mahabharat' explains the meaning of karma and the 'Ramayana' is the perfect example of the path of Karma Yoga. Learning from them can provide healing in this modern world.
Aaram se bhai 🙏🙏
Sirs…. When will this get its place in Indian History?
World don’t look at it with Bhakti but empirically ….
We need it be justified… we have west to confirm it….
Please initiate the process 🙏
Awaiting for ur video
Sir can you please summarize the contents in layman's language cause its too complicated for common people like us to understand 🙏🙏
You are right. We need a concise presentation in layman's language to make it more accessible.
@@pvr108 Namaste sir 🙏
I would like to ask do you provide consultation readings as well.
I had no way of contacting you thus reaching out this way.
Thank U in advance sir 🙏
@@pvr108 dear sir .
Some people are frequently reading my mind. Please make a video including a best possible solution for this also .. I will be grateful if you do so .. its so frustrating that people are blackmailing me like this .. many people might not believe to what I am writing but it's absolutely fact ... PLEASE HELP ME 🙏.. GURUDEV .. YOUR RESPONSE MIGHT HELP TO THOSE PEOPLE ALSO WHO ARE FEELING THE SAME WAY DEALING WITH EXTREME PAIN .. JAI GURUDEV ...
@@pvr108 women power respect in around the world cruel harrasment India China Pakistan arab Africa usa worst worst worst 😓😓😓😓😓😓😓😓😓😓😓😓😓😓😓😓😓😓😓
Namaste. Can you please predict when India will get rid of the reservation policy completely?
Bharata Varsha is 7 continents of America to Asia. Babylon was a major center of Bharata Varsha. Ashurbanipal is Asura Bani Apli, he was an Asura. Arjuna crosses the White Mountains probably at the North Pole to reach Kimpurusha varsha. Bharata Varsha is one of the varshas in Jambudvipa. Jambudvipa is the middle circle among the dvipas. You can watch the videos that state there is more land beyond the poles and the videos regarding Operation Highjump.
I think this group should see video's of Nilesh Oak on Mahabharta and it's dates
@Narasimha Rao Garu. Could you please ,with an open mind, read and comment on the astrological (old vedic 7×7 matrix chart based on Sarvathobhadra Chakra), lineage based, and literary evaluation (e.g. alternate interpretations of word "varshani" in vedic, RM and MB sanskrit) for dating of Ramayana, MahaBharatam in "The science of time and timeline of World history" by Sunil Sheoran? He did draw many interesting hypothesis about differnt aspects such as length of yugas (i.e. not some millions but rather only decades), other contemporary civilizations, and demystification. Fyi, as per him, MB war ended in 827 BCE. If possible, please invite him to your next workshop as well. We would like to watch this discussion as well. ధన్యవాదము 🙏
You should also consider geological evidence in form of Dwarka being submerged. Astrological evidence is strong but geological evidence can be stronger.
pranam guruji, I started learning vedic astrology from your book. can you please take a session on your youtube channel on how to learn astrology from your book and lectures please.
He has already so many teaching videos uploaded
th-cam.com/play/PL8yOO2xYRcZt_P1ah4p2DJEOyEOVFJ3Bg.html
Guruji Pranam.Same request from my side also.
Awesome research 🧐
Is kaliyug about to over? Are we now at the doorstep of Satayga?
427000 years still left to be at "doorstep" of Satyayuga.
@@shibasishkar7564 that is the astronomical yuga for planets not for yugas on earth!
@@thewalkthrougher6556 1 Divine year equals to 360 Human years.
1200 Divine years equal to 432000 human years and also the span of Kaliyuga.
Krishna passed on 3102 BC, and now it's 2021. So approximately 427000 years left.
@@shibasishkar7564 I'm telling, it has astronomical elaboration in Surya Sidhanta for yugas in sense of planets, not yuga transitions on earth. It has been interpreted as yugas transitions on earth that is not true!
@@shibasishkar7564 Your calculation is correct. In kaliyuga human life span is max 100 years whereas in satyayuga it was 1lakh years, Lord Rama lived for 10000 years and in Dwapara yuga 1000 years life span and Lord Krishna lived for 125years. So there is a method to calculate Yugas and I heard somewhere 2025 or 2026 Kaliyuga will end and Dharmic people will enter to Dwapara yuga. And it's a cycle we need to follow like clockwise and anti clockwise.
Settings of Jhora 15:00 especially 19:50 surya Sidhantha vs Drik Sidhantha. Pushya paksha at 19:00
Wonderful revealing by Shri Narasimha Ji regarding Jagannath Hora software that even when Surya Siddhanta (SS) is used the eclipse is not predictable as it can vary and the underlying logic is drig method of computation and not really the SS for many other calculations.
And none can be as close as real observation and recordings that is more important than just formulas that are approximations and use of the pushya based Ayanamsa (I am convinced with this use) but still I believe the far planets could have undergone changes similar to moon hit by comets etc. And it is highly unpredictable to the frank unless it is counted day by day similar to how we have our current agreement on the Kali period mentioned that has support from many quarters including the inscriptions pointing to the same by Smt. Dr. Jayashree Saranatan Ji.
The date is irrelevant as there is no year wise count that is mandated in our sankalpa based on the MB war rather it is just based on the Kali starting that count is kept. This is more important.
Hare Krishna. In fact, if I have understood it correctly from this video, Surya Siddhanta uses Drik Siddhantha to compute eclipses but is not accurate for various other reasons. Drik Siddhanta computes eclipses to within a few hours as does Cybersky.
@@suhasinidasi3126 correct, that is what he was saying.
Dear Narasimha ji, i am watching your channels for a long time and as per your earlier prediction good time of PM Modiji & HM Amitshahji will start after sept or Oct,21. but till now we are not finding any symptoms and we are worried on India and Hindus. Please do some reading to console whole Indian Hindus using your great skills and what we have to do to protect our dharma in this worlds against various evil elements
I believe when PVRji mentioned "good period", he was talking about Modi and Shah being able to implement some tough decisions in this period for the good of the nation, and not a time where there is a lot of calmness (which is impossible in today's geopolitical scenario). If you take it that way, we already have Air India sell off, OFB conversion into PSUs etc., which were stuck for decades. May be more are on the way..
He takes wrong lagn of Modi as libra lagn. Modi's lagn is scorpio. 9th lord in 1st house moon - poetry, emotions. 12th lord in 10th house - implementing world bank and IMF's conditions in the name of reforms as is. Scorpio lagn - this secrecy, planted.
@@mrpradeep313 yes same with bad bank which gonna improve situations of Non performing assets of banks, with 100Cr vaccination mark, glad we have a great leadership at right time.
Based on Veerabrahmendra's life and his sayings, Kaliyugam is running in 5000 years... I am still skeptical about the 3000 BCE....Veerabrahmam is not a simple person....we have to verify
Yes, The ANTARDASHA of Satyug is going to start.
Veerabrahmendra Swami is also famous in Maharashtra,
Because of Dattatreya/Nath Sampraday.
Yesterday I ask question to shri pandit on twitter and he admitted that currently we are in Pralay sandhi.
If you are on twitter see this.
I also shared reference of Shripad Shrivallbha of Pithapur/pithikapur
@@realSamarthT really ?? I want to contact you, do u use Instagram or telegram ?
@@HarshSingh-vl2pe twitter
Sir Jayashree madam says there is a celestial body hitting both the earth and the moon disturbing the trajectory of the moon and shaking it out of equilibrium. She substantiates the same by showing temperature maps on the celestial body during those times. We recently even seen photos from NASA where Jupiter was hit by some meteor. Is it not possible that such astronomical phenomenon should have happened to shift the Thithi of the moon and if it happens then the dating matches with the calculations of Dr Jayashree madam 🙏
Hare Krishna. I recently happened to read the original paper by Seifert where a comet hit may be given at the 3200bc time frame. But then I realised that his paper relies on Axial precession model which is rejected by madam. The other problem is that this 3200bc date would fit any theory in the 3200bc range, but if it fits 3137bc, then it fits 3138,3138 and 3140 bc as well. There are numerous comet hits even at a later stage, those would fit other theories. Thus it is not specific to any researcher. It would fit any theory.
@@suhasinidasi3126 Hare Krishna 🎉 Thanks for taking time to comment Madam 🙏 Jayashree madam says the celestial object hit both the Earth and Moon making a shift in the Thithi in itself and the Moon took time to get back to its equilibrium considering moon a small object in the solar system do you consider it as impossible provided we have the temperature maps of the moon at that particular point of time there is a strong fluctuations in the temperature in some particular regions of it ?
@@indianfromsouth7756 Hare Krishna. Thanks for the comment. I think that this idea you suggest is a possibility. But then what would be the force required to shift the earth's orbit so much even if momentarily? I remember a conference in the United States where they discussed this possibility from 10000bc. That sort of comet strike would be surely classified as an extinction level event? Where is the crater on earth which points to such an event? If such an event has taken place during the Mahabharat, how did humans survive it and why is there no evidence for the same?
All obeisances to SrilaPrabhupada.
@@suhasinidasi3126 Hare Krishna 🙏 Yes Mam this did cross my mind as well will have to check the recording of impacts of this celestial happening. Dr. Pandit ji I think has corroborated the dates wonderfully. I do understand from his speach in Sangam Talks that he has oceanographic evidence of Dwaraka Submergence corroborated for his Dates. I am going through panditji's book again to understand him better. Many thanks madam for your time and insights 🙏 Jai Shree Rama ! Jai Shree Krishna !!
@@indianfromsouth7756 Hare Krishna. Thank you. I was a follower of Mr Oak for many years and then realised that his theory was all wrong after witnessing a few Moonrises in Ireland. That is when the penny dropped that he was completely wrong. I then saw Dr Pandit explain the 14th war night in a few workshops and realised that he had gotten it spot on. When I commented on a video and pointed this out, Mr Oak felt that I had "no scientific acumen". Then I knew that Mr Oak's Moonphases were fake.
Dr Pandit on the other hand, appears to have solved the puzzle that is the Mahabharata. His explanations have improved over time. Previously there was more verbosity but now there is a great insight with far fewer words which carry a tremendous impact.
Coming to cometary impacts, I think that these are at best hypothetical unless they carry evidence of craters like the Burckle crater. I hope these two Dr Pandit and Mr Rao make a separate film on it.All obeisance to Srila Prabhupada.
Nilesh Oak should have been invited too
He will win hands down
Very patchy research..pvr ji, I hv been hearing many such researchers on TH-cam I wonder if it will be a good idea for u to individually pursue this…based on yr knowledge and insights I believe Mahabharatha will reveal itself only to the blessed. I would request you to research this if u r not in it already
नमस्कार श्रीमान
I am from India
And I want please make a video on timeline of KALYUGA and a book in odia language BHAVISHYA MALIKA.
Amazing insightful video. Sir one humble request to you is that please make a video on detailed prediction of events for the MVA government's fall or loss of power. We the people in Maharashtra are at the epitome of suffering now and its getting unbearable to the point that daily activities in life are getting miserable from dealing with dirty cops to bureaucrats it is just terrible. When will get relief from another government formation? When will the thugs and goons party be wiped of from Maharashtra?
Sir, according to Shri Yukteshwar guru of Yogananda, we're currently in Ascending Dwapar Yuga. He has given Yuga cycle of approx 12000 years of Descending cycle from satya to kali yuga and approx 12000 years Ascending cycle going from kali yuga to satya yuga.
According to to him kaluyuga ended around 1900 and technology age which is dwapar started.
What is your take on that?
I have read Sri Yukteshwar Giri's Holy Science but in my honest opinion, I do not think he was true. First of all, he does not give any evidence to back his theory. Secondly, according to his theoy, Mahabharata would have occurred some 2,500 years ago but a recent study has found that Saraswati River disappeared 4,200 years ago which means Mahabharata would have occurred atleast 4,200 years ago (probably even more) since Saraswati was a perinnial river during the times of Mahabharata.
@Pati Bangla No no! You should not say that. He was an enlightened being and we should respect him. Swami Vivekananda also carried the book 'Imitation Of Christ' along with Gita so was he also making cocktail of Krishna and Christ? Enlightened beings take birth all over the world and Christ was one of them. If you actually look into his pure teachings, it seems very Vedantic. Yes, it is true that what the missionaries are doing is very unjust and there are also many adulterations in Bible.
@Rahul paramahansa Yogananda. Not Ramakrishna Paramahansa I think.
@Pati Bangla whether cocktail or not it depends upon whom you believe.
The fact is Jesus Christ is a combination of two words having historical two different communities and language roots and there is no real evidence to point at a historic person, in reality, if you follow x-Christian Esther Dhanraj Ji you will know more about it
Coming to the way these great personality like Paramhansa Yogananda and Ramakrishna Vivekananda - they are of different league who moved the people who were blinded by the western theology. So it is fair to assume that it was a correct step to attract them without offending them and provide an exposure to the alternative Indic views from an insider's point of view. You have to remember they never let down the Hindu Dharma or cause, even though they accepted the beliefs of RoP (assume that to be a sales pitch, no harm, as selling something worthwhile is important by someway or other, it is like adding suger to a sour syrup to make a adamant child to consume).
Pravin Jadhav, you're absolutely right, chk videos of Nilesh nilkanth oak
You have easily brushed away the AV observation as a regular occurrence. Some questions in this regard.
a. why was it called a bad omen, if it was a yearly occurrence?
b. AV observation is on astronomical timescale (thousands of years). Hence the definition of Nimitta has to be aligned to the astronomical timescale. it is unreasonable to expect that to happen for a few hours or days. Events like these cant be expected to be like eclipses, since movement of stars (relative to earth) is very slow.
c. if it was a yearly occurrence as Panditji says, Arundhati will still lose her "paativratya", regardless of whether it happens for 1 hour or 1 day or 1000 years. So, the claim that it was just a bad omen which never occurred falls flat.
Unfortunately, instead of doing shastrartha, there have been 2 gangs created and each side is trying to add clout. A sanatani who is after truth is lost in this hegemony.
The reality is somewhere in between. Both theories (5561 and 3067) have certain aspects unanswered, while Oak admits it(in his book), Panditji says his theory answers all.
Truth said, 3067 fails AV observation.
A last naive question : Why do we accept that start of Kaliyuga was 3102 BC? Is this a postulate or a theorem with proof?
I think 3102 BC for starting of Kaliyuga is postulate.
Follow Smt. Dr. Jayashree Saranathan and this humbug of AV observation in her blogs and many videos and you will understand why it is not true. But be open to hear strong critical answers that clearly counters this theory.
There were a lot of (almost reluctant) references to what I have called the Oak conjecture which stands boldly in opposition to your theory.
You do need to demolish it thoroughly for any other view to become more acceptable.
Your criticism of the AV observation was not forceful enough, and was not very clear.
If you destroy this plank, the Oak conjecture fails.
Could you please explain once again with greater rigour that this is an annual phenomenon and nothing special hinges on this?
You could further explain how many warriors died, and is their death reflected in population estimates?
The Oak conjecture deduces a date for the flooding of Dwarka, and the evidence for that particular date.
Are you able to do the same for your date?
Thank you.
Am convinced 5561 BCE
It's a very long time sir since you uploaded last video. How r u sir?
He is writing a book, he is active on twitter
When did Mahabharata war happen? I know the answer ....in my life the day of my marriage was the day i was defeated and even since then I m living life in asylum war has become a routine part of my daily livelihood some day bramhaashtra some day pashupatashtra some day sudarshan and some day narayanashta ....the quarrels at home is so intense and dense that every god gets disappeared just at an onset .....the original answer to this question is I don't know but in my life ....the day of my marriage ... mahabharat started on my life ....the only thing left is ruins of life
Sri Nilesh Oak dates it to 7500 years ago though!
As per vakya panchang, the present kali Yuga number is 5122
Happy Deepawali to you and your family. Regards
I totally agree with Narsimha Sir, the Kaliyug started after Shri Krishna left for Vaikuntha, the story of Kali meeting Parikshit and his death from takshaka is completely ignored in this conversation, in jyotish even if dasha of a planet if not started its effects can definitely felt before the dasha has started.
How does the Parikshit - Kali narrative affect the commencement date of Kali Yuga? Parikshit became king just prior to the Pandavas leaving for their final journey after the passing of Bhagavan Krishna. By that time Kali was in fully virulent, which was why Parikshit confronted and captured Kali Purush, the personification of Kali Yuga. So it in fact buttresses Sri Pandit's case that Kali Yuga began before the war, because it would be natural for the effects to gain full strength after a few decades.
@@thrinethran2885 but he has to counter that with sastric evidence, when you already have clear sastric evidence in terms of when kali starts both in MB and SBM.
Sir ur voice is very nice 🙏
Thanks for uploading sir keep uploading like this!!
How can it be possible that even after the Ashtami date of Shukla Paksha, 3/4th of a month will be left? Whereas in our Indian calendar, the first side of a month is Krishna Paksha and the last and second side is Shukla Paksha. Either you have misunderstood the meaning of the verse or our current Panchang is wrong.
Hi.. next time when you make PPT slides can you please try and use colors that can be seen even by ppl with a visual disability. For example yellow text in blu background is Not visible to me .. on the contrary black text in white or yellow or cream background is perfect .. thank you
Sir are you talking about Nilesh Oak ji. Coz he's the one who uses Surya Siddhanta to decode dates of Mahabharata and Ramayana
Sir, when will the part 2 of this video will be uploaded?
Plzz do predictions on crypto currencies,etc…
How many times has Saturn in rohini not manifested in a gigantic ill event?
Hello Sir, please make video on Tamilnadu Hindu fates and Hindu temples fate due to DMK want to melt all temple golds and silver to cash and spend. Is there any way to protect temple assests and pariharam to stop this happenings.
It's the choice of TN people, they have chosen their leader and demonstrated what kind of leadership they want in tamilnadu
Read nilesh oak. Planetary position. And nakshatra. As sun revolves 26000 years cycle.
Wish you read and follow Smt. Jayashree Saranathan Ji to know more with a open mind. She has been criticising this theory for a long time now.
👏🏼
Sir,
An Astrologer must be unbiased
But you use word "Unfortunately" while predictions on opposition
But not the same word while predictions on BJP.
Why?
Opinion of Macay is valuable because he comes from outside!? The man has heavy confirmation bias and resorts to cherry picking fallacy.
It should be verifiable whether Mackay discovered the clay tablet and how it was dated, eg by radio carbon dating which gives an approximate time period. The picture is unmistakably that of the Yamalarjuna bhanjana episode, is all one can say. But the tablet is not germane to the discussion which focuses on the astronomical or astrological identification of the specific period before 3000 bce in which the Mahabharata war occurred.
@@thrinethran2885 It was made germane by the host. Nevertheless, as for astrony based predictions, the star chart repeats after approx. 26,000 years so that alone cannot be sufficient.
WOW
Mahabharata Tatparya Nirnaya gives details of dates
Sadhguru says we are at the end of dwapar yuga
th-cam.com/video/1WNQDqXZOWg/w-d-xo.html
To accommodate all of Kalyuga and Dwapar yuga the farthest date looks valid. 🙏
Narsimha ji, can you please revisit mamata banerjee's chart? She has been on a campaign spree in various states and is looking to form alliances to form a central government. We saw how people of bengal were enticed, and i am concerned for the future of this country if such people ride on power.
@నర్సింహ్మ రావు గారు.. నా విన్నపము మీరు మన్నిస్తారు అని ఆశిస్తున్నాను.🙏
Respect to all,..make such vdo less messy without too much tecqchiquality...otherwise purpose will not be served.
I think that shirt style is as old as Mbharata! :-)
Just wanted to know if time is cyclic will dwapara again begin after kalyuga? And has kalyuga ended or going to end?
What I think the situation going on around world the way everybody expanding military, it does gonna end and dharmic and sustainable practice gonna rise within 10 to 15 yrs,
------------PVR Narsimharao Sir said in one of videos
We are in the end of Dvarpara Yuga(dusk).
After that Treta yug will start.
Kaliyuga has ended already
As per Nilesh oak it is 5561
cant tolerate any discussion without Nilesh oak. only astronomical data is not important, what about hydrology, geology, paleobotany, climatology, and many other branches of sciences?. Nilesh provided parallel evidences along with astronomy, in a one-on-one, Manish pandit didnt last long,last time I saw they faced.
Nilesh Oak, 5561 + 2021 = 7582 years ago. Probably he gave a date for Ramayan. Why, because 2500 years ago Vishnu's 9th avtar Gautam Budh came. Then going back further Vishnu's 8th avtar Krishn came roughly 5000 years ago. Again, going back further, 7th avtar Ram must have come 7500 years ago. And, let me add, now is this the time of Vishnu's 10th - Kalki avtar?, Narsimha Rao
Budhha was not incarnation of Vishnu . Budhha was normal mortal being like you and me who was heavily influenced by Uttar Mimansha . Incarnation does not have to find truth they are the truth .
This is an astrology platform. Go to BPHS chapter 2. Sage parashar has given an analogy of all the avtars compared with the planets.
Matsya = Ketu
Tortoise = Saturn
Boar = Rahu
Narsimha = Mars
Vaaman = Jupiter
Parshuram = Venus
Ram = Sun
Krishn = Moon
Gautam Budh = Mercury
So, the 9th avtar was Gautam Budh born 2500 years ago, 8th avtar Krishn born 5000 years ago, 7th avtar Ram born 7500 years ago? And, therefore, now Kalki time?
@@pranshupushpam All your assessments are wrong . Ram came way back at least 15000 years back and Krishna at least 7500 years back .
And Budhha was not incarnation. I don't derive my conclusion based on what is written by whom . I don't believe in dogma . It's my personal assesment that Budhha was not enlighten since birth and attained some good knowledge through mimansha text which later became foundation of Buddhism. Infact if you read in detail of Budhha , he was quite doubtful about Brahma and seems to not understand larger concept of eternal Braham as Ishwar . He was very convoluted in terms of his assertion that Ishwar is eternal existing and main driving force . Unlike Budhha all other incarnation were self aware and solidified the foundation of eternal Brahma without any ambiguity .
That is why I don't consider Budhha as Incarnation rather just as a noble genius soul .
To add more, if there is a cycle of 24000 years then give a time span of 2400 years between two avtars and so you get the approximate date of the 9th avtar Budh and the 8th avtar Krishn, that also fairly matches the popular belief of their respective birth years. Are we into the ```sandhi kaal``` of yug parivartan and soon will also get to see Kalki avtar?
PLEASE PLEASE ANALYSE HIMANTA BISWA SARMA'S HOROSCOPE THE ASSAM CHIEF MINISTER
Very nice discussion SIR according to guru parampara sara of sri sampradaya nammalwar is supposed to have taken birth five thousand years ago approx and in one of his verses he says he missed krishna by a week oru varam tappinene in tamil so the date of war seems to be correct.Secondly though kali yuga manifested earlier as long as lotus feet of lord krishna was touching the earth it could not be effective this explanation is also in srimad bhagawatam dhanyosmi
Debunking 5561 BCE without any reason given just assuming it to be false, this is not the way to analyze things, how much work has been put on this date can you imagine, just read Nileash Oak's work and then try to debunk it!
There are already many debunkations done by other scholars on Niledh Oak's thesis. U can look at them in the Internet.
@@sudipkumarroy3790 I saw a video just now, it was itself debunked in its comment section!
@@thewalkthrougher6556 Sorry I didn't get what u want to say
🙏🙏
Hare Krishna. This was an awesome workshop. The eyeopener for me was the part where Bhisma Nirvana was perfectly shown in the waxing phase of the Moon and on the 8th part of the Moonphase on the 4th day after Winter Solstice in Dr Pandit's theory and Dr Oak's theory was seen to be failing on all possible fronts (it looked to be the waning phase Moon on the third part of the waning phase which was obviously wrong). You also pointed out that 3 more theories fail on some set of criteria? I think it would be useful to name the researchers as most people do not know about a theory. I certainly didn't know about the fake Moonphases or Srila Balram's Naksatra mistake in Mr Oak's theory until they were pointed out to us by our Guru.
The explanations given in your video definitely seem very credible. As a former Christian, it is well known that the legends of Christianity are based on the solstitial movements of the Sun so thanks for pointing out an even earlier tradition from the East. The Aldebaran star at Bhisma Nirvan is magical. More of this please.
I did not know that any researcher used Surya siddhant until you pointed it out. That is obviously wrong. The correct settings must be used to get the right result.
Are u also an astrology scholar or student?
Guruji, Nilesh oak has done very scientific work with hundreds of evidences from Mahabharata, oceanography, geology and so many others to arrive very elaborate dating of this. Suggest give him chance to present thro your channel 🙏🙏
No, his research is nonsensical, though he has excellent communication skills and marketing savvy. Influential people who wanted to _believe_ that Mahabharata actually happened promoted him without paying attention to details (i.e. fell for his smooth talk)! _Bottomline:_ Mahabharata war did happen, but 2000 years after the date he gives.
@@pvr108 Guruji, then, it's good to call Nilesh Oak for shashtrath and discuss and derive to a point with evidence and findings and correct him for the betterment of the humanity. It is the duty of seniors and gurukuls to teach correct knowledge. Why don't you write letter and send him a whitepaper on your views and infact on his book analysis and so he could connect the dots correctly and we have right information. 🙏🏼
@@dwiranwic while your request is totally correct, not sure PVR sir will have time and energy to correct all such people. People like you and me who are after facts, have to do something to correct those who are wrong.
@@pvr108 your software does not even have precession of equinox ... i trust Oak's work ...sorry
@@dwiranwic knowledge can be shown or given only when you make the approach and not the other way around
I don't know why they discuss indian itihasa in gregorian calander?
Sir please make Jhora chromebook compatible
Hello Sir, can you please tell the fate of Sameer Wankhede. Is he honest and if so, will he be saved ? please please do a youtube video on him. thank you.
Please predict on maharashtra sir ji 🙏🙏
See what happened 🙏😎😁😂
Sir, has the live feed ended?
But you can watch it now.
@@pvr108 I watched the entire live streaming event however it abruptly ended and unsure if it has continued beyond 49 minutes or will it be a part 2 live event for next week?
Narasimha Rao ji, can you look at my horoscope?
Stalwarts of astrology
What age will start after WW3 (2035)?
This is my favourite theory of all proposed, and I accept it above Nilesh Oak's theory. But it is largely dependent upon the accuracy of the start of Kali Yuga. Who is to say that this is the accurate period for its beginning?
Nilesh Oake's has described it in better way and more detailed
Fully agree - Nilesh oak’s book on dating of Maharashtra is superb with hundreds of evidences , very scientific
No, his research is nonsensical, though he has excellent communication skills and marketing savvy. Influential people who wanted to _believe_ that Mahabharata actually happened promoted him without paying attention to details (i.e. fell for his smooth talk)! _Bottomline:_ Mahabharata war did happen, but 2000 years after the date he gives.
@@pvr108 From a learned person like you, Mr.Rao, I was expecting an argument with some substance, and not one relying on the style or personality of the other.
@@chhupparustom Yeah I'm so surprised with his answers, Narasimha should try to prove it wrong through some sense not like just say he is unscientific, I doubt he ever have read the book or listened to him just heard some rumors, thats not how a person with some reason talks!
A talk should be held between all these learned people to reach the truth together respectively.
Dear Brothers, Guruji Dr. Manish Pandit had a debate with Nilesh Oak, which is available on TH-cam and also have several videos on dating of Mahabharata, Balarama’s Piligrimage. This video is just a Tip of Iceberg.
Can you predict when Tibet will get independence from China and when chinnese Communist party will collapse
Please reply last comment..
Common Wisdom has always dictated that Mahabharata was about 5000 years ago. I've heard it from multiple sources. Glad to learn that its correct.
Yes 3000 BCE means 3000+2000 = 5000 years ago which is what common wisdom says
Sir pls videos Hindi me rakh paye to jyada,accha hai taki sab log samjh paye🙏
Srimad Bhagwat puran clearly mentioned that Kaliyug started on the day ,when Lord Sri Krisna departed from Earth.
Hence, rest talks between these Anchors are WASTAGE OF TIME.
All the frauds have joined together so that you can challenge Jayasree Saranathan ji real vedic astrological timings
I never thought Narshimha ji that you will fall down at this level, now I realize why you were promoted by Rajiv Malhotra
Hii can you tellthe contents of jayasree saranathan ji real video and link it
@@dia6888 Ji please visit Jayasree ji twitter account to find the link of the video
Mrs Saranathan means well, but made the terrible mistake of relying on Surya Siddhanta formulas tuned for one era to another era. We clearly explained in the video. She at least get the date in the right ballpark (around 3k BCE).
Don't ever doubt Rajiv Malhotra.
@@pvr108 ji Why not debate this with Jayasree ji herself instead of passing judgement on her?
She is always ready for discussion and debate
Please be transparent, did you not call out Jayasree ji with that cryptic tweet the other day? Were you pressured by someone to put out that tweet? Also stay away from Rajiv Malhotra don't let his influence effect you in your thoughts
🙏🙏
🙏🙏🙏