It's not social media unfortunately The primary source of revenue for artists has changed, and streaming is now the first (by a great margin) so artists have to shorten songs in order to maximize streams and to be able to earn more. It was first more noticeable in hip hop back in 2018/2019 as up and coming rappers were turning to platforms such as Soundcloud to spread their music
No one has mentioned it yet, but Dreamcatcher's Rose Blue is also 4 minutes. I always find these songs to be the most enjoyable, they are so complete. They usually stand the test of time
@@vixxexo6855 “most of them were bad” is crazy. i agree that there are songs that definitely lull at some point and just go on for too long, but a lot of these are well produced and thought out throughout. Even if it’s not your style you can see the quality if you actually listen to the full songs
Exo: "What If..." (4:19), Miracles in December (4:34), What is love (4:22), Universe (4:24), Baby (4:00), Beautiful (4:03), Cloud 9 (4:01), 24/7 (4:03), Moonlight (4:26), For Life (3:58), Wait (4:08), The Star (4:07), My turn to cry (4:07) EXO-CBX: Cry (4:20), In this World (4:27) SNSD: Forever (4:29), Star Star Star (4:29), Lost in Love (4:00), Lost in St. (4:00), Light up in the sky (4:01), Flyers (4:03), Dear Mom (4:05), Let's talk about Love (4:11), One Year Later (4:01), Mistake (4:07), Back hug (4:09) Tiffany: Heartbreak Hotel (4:24) Aespa: Forever (4:58), Savage (3:58), Shinee: Tell me what to do (4:06), Romeo & Juliet (4:44), Romantic (4:55), Y Si fuera ella (5:15), Four Seasons (4:06), In my room (4:25), A-yo (4:24), Quasimodo (4:08), Obsession (4:08), Your Name (4:06), Life (4:38), Selene 6.23 (4:10), Sleepless Night (4:41), Better of (4:00), Trigger (4:01), Farewell my Love (4:00), An Ode To you (4:17), An Encore (4:04), Chocolate (4:12), Don't stop (4:05), Wish upon a star (4:14), Beautiful Live (4:25), If you love her (4:16), Our Page (3:59), please don't go (4:10), The Name i loved (4:36), The Reason (4:17), Close the door (4:01), Colourful (4:07) Red Velvet: One of these nights (4:21), Cool world (4:05), Eyes Locked Hands Locked (4:11), Candy (4:22), Rose scent breeze (4:52), First time (4:02), Sunny asfter oon (4:00), Last love (4:54), You Better Know (4:10), Taeyeon: Time Lapse (4:14), Find me (4:07), Better Babe (4:11), Do you love me? (4:08), My Tragedy (4:29), Drawing our moments (4:33), U R (4:34), Thos Christmas (4:27), Christmas without you (4:19), Vanilla (4:01), Signal (4:10) Super Junior: Don't Do (4:11), No Other (4:16), This is Love (4:07), Lo Siento (4:01), House Party (4:01),Keep in Touch (4:31), Believe (4:54), You're my endless love (4:32), Disco drive (4:07), She's Gone (4:38), Mirror (4:01), Midnight Fantasy (4:00), A man in Live (4:35), Heartquake (4:07), Dead at Heart (4:09), Coagulation (4:20), In my Dreams (5:02), Good person (4:04), Storm (4:16), Memories (4:11), Someday (4:13), Midnight blues (4:21), Mid-Season (4:01), Islands (4:27), ...ing (4:16), Simply Beautiful (4:03), You got it (4:23), Dorothy (4:24), One more Chance (4:15), BLUE (4:03), More Days With you (4:15), My wish (4:06) F(x): Beautfiul Goodbye (4:06), Beautiful Stranger (4:06), Rude Love (4:18) NCT: Resonance (5:14), Beautiful (4:21), - NCT 127: Angel (4:09), Limitless (4:07), No Longer (4:57), Long slow distance (4:25), Pandora's Box (4:09), Love me now (4:08), White Night (4:03), Gold Dust (4:08), Love is a Beauty (4:48), - NCT U: Timeless (4:10), From home (4:24) - WayV: Up from Here (4:01), Broken Love (4:04), Back to You (4:12), - NCT Dream: Teddy Bear (4:02), Moon (4:13), Breathing (4:13) BTS: Danger (4:05) , Fake Love (4:02), iKON: Dumb&Dumber (4:01), SUPERM: Jopping (4:11) BigBang: Haru Haru (4:16), If You (4:24), Junsu/Xia: Tarantallegra (4:14) Infinite: The Eye (4:00),
Some other songs that are 4 minutes (or at least 3:55 cuz its basically the same thing) are The Ring (4:01), Days (4:20), Utopia (4:00), and Desire (3:55) (all by Ateez), Savage by Aespa (3:59), What is Love by Exo (4:22), and Blue Hour by Txt (4:25; the performance version cuz it's 10 times better)
Some more from my playlist: Red Velvet - Little Little (4:00) EXO - 24/7 (4:03) BoA - Addiction (4:05) GOT the Beat - Alter Ego (4:07) NewJeans - Hype Boy (250 Remix) (4:11) Brown Eyed Girls - 끈 (4:12) Brown Eyed Girls - Second (4:18) EXO - What If... (4:19) BoA - 気持ちはつたわる (4:23) BoA - happiness (4:33)
love the video! kinda sad that most of these songs are 3rd gen or prior :') the era of reasonably elongated music is behind us SAVE US SM ARTISTS also for a first video this is really good! algorithm hit this REALLY well so good for you man :D
I LOVE Windy Day, The Fifth Season, and Secret Garden so much! I've been getting into Oh My Girl recently and those 3 songs along with Dun Dun Dance and Summer Comes are my favourites. I didn’t even realize they were over 4 minutes, they’re just so good. There’s a lot of other really awesome songs in this video too!
bts idol ft nicki minaj 4:20 dionysus 4:09 interlude: shadow 4:19 ON 4:06 disease 3:59 cypher 4 4:54 ma city 4:16 moving on 4:52 whalien 52 4:03 war of hormone 4:25 hip hop phile 4:12 cypher pt3 4:27 embarrased 4:01 cypher pt.2 4:48 attack on bangtan 4:06 come back home 4:04 and more... (i was bored)
It breaks my heart to keep seeing 2 minutes and 30 second min songs Like it’s genuinely disappointing Thank god for the songs that are over 4 mins I think the bare minimum for a song length should be is 3 mins and 30 seconds and finding a song that is between 5-8 mins is just beyond rare these days
@@K-Limu oh sorry! didn't understand that. coz where ever I go, I see fans always bragging about those Idols and boasting about them.. even if videos being not about them, it's kind of irritating. So, I thought you're one of them too.
I have some songs of 4 minutes (or atleast 3:40) in my playlist: Promise by Twice (4:20) Pieces of Love by Twice (4:02) Ex by Stray Kids (M/V) (4:00) Bouquet by Misamo (4:25) 24 to 25 by Stray Kids (M/V) (4:40) Winter Falls by Stray Kids (M/V) (4:23) Gone Away by I.N, Seungmin, Han (M/V) (4:23) Mirror by Itzy (4:19) Not Shy by Itzy (M/V) (4:03) Ice Cream by Twice (3:53) 21:29 by Twice (3:48) Be As One by Twice (3:52) Midzy by Itzy (3:49)
Love Lucy! Stove is also over 6 minutes and they have a fair amount over 4 minutes like Snooze, Flowering, You and Me, Rolling Rolling, Youre Right etc
Love that the three most prevalent genres here are Christian Horse Girl music, dramatic 2nd gen songs and SM B-sides😂
+ yukika songs
Christian horse girl music 💀
exactly 😭
How I miss 2nd gen dramatic ass 😪
Gfriend, the queens of Christianity and the horses 😌😌🐴🤠🤠💅💅👑👑👑🤞☦️🤞
In sm artist and Christian horse girl music we trust
notice how it’s all good music
The fact that 90% of these are SM songs lol. In SM we trust for good quality music
Social media screwed up our attention spans so much that now we're stuck with 2:40-2:50 min long songs😭😭
It's not social media unfortunately
The primary source of revenue for artists has changed, and streaming is now the first (by a great margin) so artists have to shorten songs in order to maximize streams and to be able to earn more. It was first more noticeable in hip hop back in 2018/2019 as up and coming rappers were turning to platforms such as Soundcloud to spread their music
@@liyahsun8843 Didn't know that lols thanks for the info :0
@@liyahsun8843don't forget songs being used in tiktoks which tend to be shorter songs
@@liyahsun8843thats social media
@@liyahsun8843it boost in popularity too
only aespa can save us with their 3+ minutes songs
And Everglow
aespa💀
lets not forget Red Velvet
introducing ONF
omg yukika & red velvet mentioned, we cheered
🫡
No one has mentioned it yet, but Dreamcatcher's Rose Blue is also 4 minutes. I always find these songs to be the most enjoyable, they are so complete. They usually stand the test of time
This would make an immaculate spotify/youtube playlist, ngl. I miss long, dramatic k-pop songs.
i made a playlist about it
open.spotify.com/playlist/3r7O6ycAdcWCxvn3OmdqzP?si=zi_kg-_LRNy82cHdmqEWIQ&pi=a-wBh99BYsSsWb
It’s because so many companies stopped putting bridges in their songs! SM is the only company still giving us S tier bridges.
afterschool shh being 4 minutes and 55 seconds of pure excellence
!!!!
The transition from ses version to RV version of being natural!!! I love music so much
and it ends up being a bop iktr
YVES
Most of them were bad. Songs lasting 4 minutes is too much and you can hear the song is dragged out too much.
@@vixxexo6855 |
@@vixxexo6855 “most of them were bad” is crazy. i agree that there are songs that definitely lull at some point and just go on for too long, but a lot of these are well produced and thought out throughout. Even if it’s not your style you can see the quality if you actually listen to the full songs
@@vixxexo6855average newgen kpop stan
The way this video only had one 4th gen song 💀
10 girl but still we’re doomed
@@desieunmiyeon _ Te Amo also it's 4min 17sec
ONF IZ*ONE and (technically) VIVIZ
@@sense2001nct 127 is third gen
@@143szns oh i might misremembered! Tysm
Exo: "What If..." (4:19), Miracles in December (4:34), What is love (4:22), Universe (4:24), Baby (4:00), Beautiful (4:03), Cloud 9 (4:01), 24/7 (4:03), Moonlight (4:26), For Life (3:58), Wait (4:08), The Star (4:07), My turn to cry (4:07)
EXO-CBX: Cry (4:20), In this World (4:27)
SNSD: Forever (4:29), Star Star Star (4:29), Lost in Love (4:00), Lost in St. (4:00), Light up in the sky (4:01), Flyers (4:03), Dear Mom (4:05), Let's talk about Love (4:11), One Year Later (4:01), Mistake (4:07), Back hug (4:09)
Tiffany: Heartbreak Hotel (4:24)
Aespa: Forever (4:58), Savage (3:58),
Shinee: Tell me what to do (4:06), Romeo & Juliet (4:44), Romantic (4:55), Y Si fuera ella (5:15), Four Seasons (4:06),
In my room (4:25), A-yo (4:24), Quasimodo (4:08), Obsession (4:08), Your Name (4:06), Life (4:38), Selene 6.23 (4:10), Sleepless Night (4:41), Better of (4:00), Trigger (4:01), Farewell my Love (4:00), An Ode To you (4:17), An Encore (4:04), Chocolate (4:12), Don't stop (4:05), Wish upon a star (4:14), Beautiful Live (4:25), If you love her (4:16), Our Page (3:59), please don't go (4:10), The Name i loved (4:36), The Reason (4:17), Close the door (4:01), Colourful (4:07)
Red Velvet: One of these nights (4:21), Cool world (4:05), Eyes Locked Hands Locked (4:11), Candy (4:22), Rose scent breeze (4:52), First time (4:02), Sunny asfter oon (4:00), Last love (4:54), You Better Know (4:10),
Taeyeon: Time Lapse (4:14), Find me (4:07), Better Babe (4:11), Do you love me? (4:08), My Tragedy (4:29), Drawing our moments (4:33), U R (4:34), Thos Christmas (4:27), Christmas without you (4:19), Vanilla (4:01), Signal (4:10)
Super Junior: Don't Do (4:11), No Other (4:16), This is Love (4:07), Lo Siento (4:01), House Party (4:01),Keep in Touch (4:31), Believe (4:54), You're my endless love (4:32), Disco drive (4:07), She's Gone (4:38), Mirror (4:01), Midnight Fantasy (4:00), A man in Live (4:35), Heartquake (4:07), Dead at Heart (4:09), Coagulation (4:20), In my Dreams (5:02), Good person (4:04), Storm (4:16), Memories (4:11), Someday (4:13), Midnight blues (4:21), Mid-Season (4:01), Islands (4:27), ...ing (4:16), Simply Beautiful (4:03), You got it (4:23), Dorothy (4:24), One more Chance (4:15), BLUE (4:03), More Days With you (4:15), My wish (4:06)
F(x): Beautfiul Goodbye (4:06), Beautiful Stranger (4:06), Rude Love (4:18)
NCT: Resonance (5:14), Beautiful (4:21),
- NCT 127: Angel (4:09), Limitless (4:07), No Longer (4:57), Long slow distance (4:25), Pandora's Box (4:09), Love me now (4:08), White Night (4:03), Gold Dust (4:08), Love is a Beauty (4:48),
- NCT U: Timeless (4:10), From home (4:24)
- WayV: Up from Here (4:01), Broken Love (4:04), Back to You (4:12),
- NCT Dream: Teddy Bear (4:02), Moon (4:13), Breathing (4:13)
BTS: Danger (4:05) , Fake Love (4:02),
iKON: Dumb&Dumber (4:01),
SUPERM: Jopping (4:11)
BigBang: Haru Haru (4:16), If You (4:24),
Junsu/Xia: Tarantallegra (4:14)
Infinite: The Eye (4:00),
Some other songs that are 4 minutes (or at least 3:55 cuz its basically the same thing) are The Ring (4:01), Days (4:20), Utopia (4:00), and Desire (3:55) (all by Ateez), Savage by Aespa (3:59), What is Love by Exo (4:22), and Blue Hour by Txt (4:25; the performance version cuz it's 10 times better)
I can also say girls by aespa! (4:00)
EGOIST MENTIONED YUPPP
In sm music we trust
Some more from my playlist:
Red Velvet - Little Little (4:00)
EXO - 24/7 (4:03)
BoA - Addiction (4:05)
GOT the Beat - Alter Ego (4:07)
NewJeans - Hype Boy (250 Remix) (4:11)
Brown Eyed Girls - 끈 (4:12)
Brown Eyed Girls - Second (4:18)
EXO - What If... (4:19)
BoA - 気持ちはつたわる (4:23)
BoA - happiness (4:33)
I love you for those brown eyed girls songs
Crazy how it’s mostly SM
You had me at ballad excluded
Some of them are jpop (4- 5 minutes duration is normal there, we cheered), but yeah, this is real kpop.
love the video! kinda sad that most of these songs are 3rd gen or prior :') the era of reasonably elongated music is behind us SAVE US SM ARTISTS
also for a first video this is really good! algorithm hit this REALLY well so good for you man :D
4:19 IN RV WE TRUST
gfriend mentioned yay
ofc they gon get my mention cuz thats queens
I hope they come back 😭
most of these songs reminded me of superstar sm gsdhlgkhsdkglhsd
i missed playing it but i can't catch up with their updates anymore
Yes, I'm so sick (by Apink) of 2minute Kpop tracks 😢
I LOVE THAT SONG ❤
@@jamztheworld12 ME TOOOO
the amount of after school..... a true expert i see
I LOVE Windy Day, The Fifth Season, and Secret Garden so much! I've been getting into Oh My Girl recently and those 3 songs along with Dun Dun Dance and Summer Comes are my favourites. I didn’t even realize they were over 4 minutes, they’re just so good. There’s a lot of other really awesome songs in this video too!
The taste in this video's chefs kiss
If anyone’s curious, Spring Day by BTS is 4:33. I don’t consider it a ballad so 👍
bts
idol ft nicki minaj 4:20
dionysus 4:09
interlude: shadow 4:19
ON 4:06
disease 3:59
cypher 4 4:54
ma city 4:16
moving on 4:52
whalien 52 4:03
war of hormone 4:25
hip hop phile 4:12
cypher pt3 4:27
embarrased 4:01
cypher pt.2 4:48
attack on bangtan 4:06
come back home 4:04
and more...
(i was bored)
thank you!! I rarely see bts being mentioned in such videos.
A lot of BoAs song are more than 3 mins, I love mother BoA! 💛💛
Pit-a-pet, Sunny Afternoon, Egoist, SSFWL, Irony… some of the best pop music ever methinks 🤭
Someone send this to KATSEYE
It breaks my heart to keep seeing 2 minutes and 30 second min songs
Like it’s genuinely disappointing
Thank god for the songs that are over 4 mins
I think the bare minimum for a song length should be is 3 mins and 30 seconds and finding a song that is between 5-8 mins is just beyond rare these days
And I hate when they cut ITNW (2nd chorus) & Shampoo (1st chorus + outro) during live performance 😡
pov : you listen illit'S my world twice but these songs are still not finished
my world is 1.48
wasn't that like an intro tho
@@reyopia but still its a song
immaculate taste fr (and onf appreciation, we love to see it!)
YOU ARE WELCOME! FOR THE HELP POOKIE😭😭😭
WE REALLY LOB YEW ❤️
journey to atlantis mentioned WELL YES
EXO SHINEE AND TVXQ MENTIONED
WELL YAS!
In snsd,redvelvet and oh my girl we trust
Egoist is the best song EVAAAA
2 minutes songs watching this video are shaking 😱
BIG THANKS TO SM
👀
@@Royal_Acid 😹😹
@@hrts.4jwkj 💙💙
thankyou for added my fav song 'together' by seventeen
Song others over 4 minutes (BALLAD EXCLUDED)
+ CRAXY - NUGUDOM (4:03)
+ AKMU - DINOSAUR (4:01)
+ iKON - DUMB & DUMBER (4:00)
+ BLACKPINK - BOOMBAYAH(4:00)
Strangely, there is no hybe in this list👁️
nothing is strange. lol. there's more in kpop than hybe, BP and BTS.
@@akihasc7047 yeah it was sarcasm because hybe songs are well known for being short... When did i talk about BP and BTS?
@@K-Limu oh sorry! didn't understand that. coz where ever I go, I see fans always bragging about those Idols and boasting about them.. even if videos being not about them, it's kind of irritating. So, I thought you're one of them too.
@@akihasc7047 yeah i don't mind also saw this type of fans before and even if i'm an army, it's very frustrating.
you know the thing is good when is filled with 2nd gen groups
Soloist Younha title track "Every Horizon" (05:20)
Almost younha song over 4 minutes but song ballad
I need a playlist with all of these songs in it
real music
In SM we trust
COOL WORLD MENTION I KNEW I COULD TRUST YOU
the transitions are heavenly
seriously
Oh my girl are queens
I have some songs of 4 minutes (or atleast 3:40) in my playlist:
Promise by Twice (4:20)
Pieces of Love by Twice (4:02)
Ex by Stray Kids (M/V) (4:00)
Bouquet by Misamo (4:25)
24 to 25 by Stray Kids (M/V) (4:40)
Winter Falls by Stray Kids (M/V) (4:23)
Gone Away by I.N, Seungmin, Han (M/V) (4:23)
Mirror by Itzy (4:19)
Not Shy by Itzy (M/V) (4:03)
Ice Cream by Twice (3:53)
21:29 by Twice (3:48)
Be As One by Twice (3:52)
Midzy by Itzy (3:49)
Dreamcatcher and Fx mentioned! I am quite pleased
NAMYU MENTIONED!!
BEST TH-camR!!
EXACTLEE
Theres also Flare by Lucy which is 6:02 ! Theyre a kband and not a group but it still a great song so i want to bring it up :)
Love Lucy! Stove is also over 6 minutes and they have a fair amount over 4 minutes like Snooze, Flowering, You and Me, Rolling Rolling, Youre Right etc
my favourite 4 minute + song has to be rose blue, idk why but it is underrated af (4:00 is the song length)
oh u ate with the be natural transition
INTRO ATEEE
omg hey oomf, great video!
tysm oomf!
action mentioned DESIEUN WE LOVE U
LOB YEW TOO
We love oh my girl
bro knows all of the hood classics
we live for this
guys listen to RESCENE their first single album is 6 mins already and both of them are more than 2 mins
So many city pop songs! I’m so glad
U ate so hard pls post more
OMG & IU MENTIONED!!!!
VIVIZ, RED VELVET, AND AESPA MENTIONED???
I’m obsessed with El Dorado
It's an immaculate song 😌
PSYCHO4U BY GIRLKIND 🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️ it’s so crazy good and it’s 4 mins 44 seconds, a fun little detail from the 4 in the title
Best video ever
1:09 HEAVY on red sun
Allegro cantabile >>>>>>>>>>
QUEEN MOTHER BOA
YES BESTIE not u being in my must watch videos I LOVE U MOOT
YASSSSSS lob yew too
Ok now i need a only ballad version
a lot of songs by The Kingdom are over 4 minutes too
Right 👍🏻
star by stayc 4:17 is soundtrack sound soft but i don't considered is ballad
if you're easygoing enough then boombayah by blackpink can also be mentioned, it's 4:00 on spotify 😊😊
So?
@@Stefan-xx5fj i don't see boombayah on the list so i'd like to suggest one more song that is four minutes long, that's all
I miss long kpop songs
bts mic drop steve aoki remix not being on here is a crime (5 minutes)
Omg i kinda made this exact playlist not long ago for songs I love 😭😭😭 Bring back 5min songs yupppp
ONF MENTIONED
I would also recommend Dreamcatcher’s “R.o.S.E BLUE” and “Fireflies” from their latest album comeback
I think fireflies is a ballad
ENDED MEEEE
not really!
Thank God aespa (and a few other Gen4 groups) are saving *music* from tiktok abomination
the majority of this video being 2nd gen.............
YASSSED
idk if this will count but the intro to dreamcatchers new mini album intro7: dreamcatcher is i think about 4 minutes
Intro 7 dreamcatcher is I think 3:57
You can count on red velvet every single time 🫡
EVERYBODY
EVERY EVERY BODY
oh taste
GFRIEND = LIKE AND SUB
also almost all of yukika's songs are 4 mins long!