The difference is that in beamng in every crash you had the evo in totally new conditions as for the clay model it was already damaged from the previous crash, so it was weaker than the beamng one. Also, great video man the evo looked awesome, hope your channel continues to grow:) (im sorry if some parts are hard to understand, english is not my native languaje)
@@-aku2805 i remember a ford bronco mod that would get completely pancaked when it got hit by a truck. It got popular on tiktok and idiots thought it was an IRL crash
While this is a great example of the differences between reality and game physics. There are some main things to take into account which can cause the differences we see in this video. Starting off with the fact in the game the simulation is simulating the car as using both metal, plastic, glass, and rubber. While the clay model is mainly composed of clay, which is a lot more malleable than metal making it a lot more easier to bend and deform. Which I think is acceptable for the scale of which this is at compared to a model comprised of mainly metal. There are other factors to that play a major role in the differences but I don't think people wanna read a entire full on break down in the comment section lol. But this video was really nice and I applaud you for your hard work and your willingness to destroy something you worked so hard on lol.
Well, for starters, the impact speeds of your crashes are very different. Secondly, the material of your clay model deforms 100% uniformly, while BeamNG actually simulates different materials and the car models also have a very complex anatomy. Had your clay model had a massive metal chunk of an engine in the front, the crash damage would have appeared very differently. I'd argue that BeamNG gives the much more realistic crash deformations. BUT: the car you're using is obviously a mod in the game, and as such, can't claim to be recreated super realistically, either. Finally, building on the previous point, it is absolutely possible to set up the mesh simulation in BeamNG in a way so that the wheels on the car can deform, too. But again, real rims aren't made from clay and won't just squish, either. TL/DR: there is absolutely nothing scientifically valid about your testing and comparison method. Other than: it's a red Mitsubishi (we'll generously ignore the different body kit). Still: for spending so many hours on handcrafting the car model (which indeed looks superb, great craftsmanship!) and then destroying it for making this video, you absolutely deserve a like, good Sir! 👍
did you take in factors like metal densities, plastic densities, where and what ALL the parts are located and made of? And the biggest factor is the speed variations? real MPH vs scale MPH (or KPH... meh.)? Just saying there are literally thousands of variables to take into account. other than that, your skill at making that model car from scratch.... AMAZING!
Each vehicle in Beam-NG has different J-beams. A J-beam is basically like a hitbox in very simplified terms. The vehicles made by Beam-NG have the most accurate J-beams also, Beam-NG hasn't added scratch marks and dirtiness to cars yet, but they are planning to add them to a future update. And if we are being real, not all cars are made out of clay. But your videos are great and creative, and I don't really get why people are getting so mad for something that was probably made for fun and not to be taken seriously.
yea this film is pretty shit, and he talking about damage from the side when in beamg 1st. its car from mod, 2 new spawned car vs totally destroyed shit from totally different material, damn this man have no clue what he talking about xD
very acuratte model, taking consideration that ingame the engine held a bit of the chasiss bending and even tho the clay car was perfectly built , it didnt had the engine block to pair some of the iompact
Can't wait for beam to simulate crushing rims and wheels in between fenders. some vehicles have colliders where tires can catch on fenders like T-series and pre runner d-series trucks but not every vehicle has it
Don’t spoil the video with the “ coming up “ part of it at the start pls it makes it uninteresting not hating, but just a suggestion but still your videos are cool
I would say, if you were to do this again, try to match the reverse speed of the Plasticine car with the speed of the one in BeamNG, I bet the damage would be similar then. If we were to take the plasticine version and apply that same reverse speed scaled up to the IRL counterpart or the BeamNG counterpart the reverse speed would have been like 80mph to 100mph in reverse which I don't think there are cars that can do that without any modifications.
beamng drive also simulates the panel materials. such as steel, plastic, etc... your clay model car is weaker in comparison to those materials. that is also why in beamng the wheels didnt break like the model.
No, they don't. Beamng does not 'simulate' different chassis materials. The only difference that these have on deformation is what sound they make when they scrape.
The reason the tures arnt bent us because it didnt hit with enough force. Also this video doesnt even have s good camprison because your using A toy car. Toy cars get damaged easily. ( Running your toy car is a eall or dropping it won't do anything) But of course the force you did was like 100 miles an hour in toy version scale....so like. Edit some cars can fet cut in half. Also its beam....its still in beta after 13 years. Give the game time ong. Thank you.
I don't think it's accurate to compare Clay to the materials actually used to build the different parts of the car. This is fun to watch but it isn't accurate at all. No to talk about the mods of beamng. Modders use models to built diferent types of cars which is will break similarly which wouldn't happen in real life is that specific car.
Your car was not changed out I’m the last test that’s why it snapped plus it’s not even close to being able to be realistically compared since you use clay, against wood and other speeds then in beamng, and since it’s not different materials in the different parts like wheels you can’t say it’s not realistic when the beamNG wheels don’t bend the same way buddy.
I think the difference is in speed, in beamng drive the speed of the crash was very slow in comparison to the real life model
Maybe it looks like that becouse of the scale?
@@naglislaurinaitis7301 idk maybe
@@rafael20074no because beamng drive is a SOFTBODY car game so the car is softer but the model is harder so he hits it harder
The model is lighter then the beamng car idiots
@@icebergs25with softbody they meant that the car can deform, not that it's particularly soft, they can change the stiffness values
Damage models are different for every modded car on BeamNG it's better to use lore friendly or built in cars for tests like this.
love this channel. You should start another channel on fixing these cars after the crash. seeing whats usable and whats not.
Would be a cool take
The difference is that in beamng in every crash you had the evo in totally new conditions as for the clay model it was already damaged from the previous crash, so it was weaker than the beamng one. Also, great video man the evo looked awesome, hope your channel continues to grow:) (im sorry if some parts are hard to understand, english is not my native languaje)
The Damage Physics change depending on the model car your using on beamng
It also depends on the quality of mod
@@Kronflax yeah a lot of these real life cars have very unrealistic crash models
@@-aku2805 i remember a ford bronco mod that would get completely pancaked when it got hit by a truck. It got popular on tiktok and idiots thought it was an IRL crash
Couldn’t do a Subaru
Yeah i once had a mod i rear ended a car i only had a broken light and the cars back was crushed
this is a very high quality video format im surprised you do not have more subs great video!!
man, your video is interesting but I stopped watching because of the AI voice over
Same it's so annoying
I feel like I recognize the original this voice is based off of, but I can’t place it.
He doesn’t speak English dude
@@romeovoigt makes more sense if so
@@slyvixx he’s Russian, he said he trying to learn English.
Щищ handmade я уже подумал твои видео берут другие, но потом понял что это второй канал)
You could probably make really good Beamng mods
Two very different fields. Would not unless they put in the work like anyone else who wants to make them.
@@Sellanen22i mean like modeljg the cars
@@2WLITL still, very different fields. Just because someone is good at driving a car doesn't mean theyre good at driving on controller.
While this is a great example of the differences between reality and game physics. There are some main things to take into account which can cause the differences we see in this video. Starting off with the fact in the game the simulation is simulating the car as using both metal, plastic, glass, and rubber. While the clay model is mainly composed of clay, which is a lot more malleable than metal making it a lot more easier to bend and deform. Which I think is acceptable for the scale of which this is at compared to a model comprised of mainly metal. There are other factors to that play a major role in the differences but I don't think people wanna read a entire full on break down in the comment section lol. But this video was really nice and I applaud you for your hard work and your willingness to destroy something you worked so hard on lol.
0:34 I thought you were playing forza😭😭😭
Me too 😭😭
I liked and subbed this is insane dedication man!
Well, for starters, the impact speeds of your crashes are very different. Secondly, the material of your clay model deforms 100% uniformly, while BeamNG actually simulates different materials and the car models also have a very complex anatomy. Had your clay model had a massive metal chunk of an engine in the front, the crash damage would have appeared very differently. I'd argue that BeamNG gives the much more realistic crash deformations. BUT: the car you're using is obviously a mod in the game, and as such, can't claim to be recreated super realistically, either. Finally, building on the previous point, it is absolutely possible to set up the mesh simulation in BeamNG in a way so that the wheels on the car can deform, too. But again, real rims aren't made from clay and won't just squish, either.
TL/DR: there is absolutely nothing scientifically valid about your testing and comparison method. Other than: it's a red Mitsubishi (we'll generously ignore the different body kit).
Still: for spending so many hours on handcrafting the car model (which indeed looks superb, great craftsmanship!) and then destroying it for making this video, you absolutely deserve a like, good Sir! 👍
Replying so he pins this. Video is misleading but the craftsmanship is amazing on the mitsu.
did you take in factors like metal densities, plastic densities, where and what ALL the parts are located and made of? And the biggest factor is the speed variations? real MPH vs scale MPH (or KPH... meh.)? Just saying there are literally thousands of variables to take into account. other than that, your skill at making that model car from scratch.... AMAZING!
while not 100% accurate, this was so cool and I'd love to see you crash more car models in the future
i will definitely support you, you make very cool cars
Each vehicle in Beam-NG has different J-beams. A J-beam is basically like a hitbox in very simplified terms. The vehicles made by Beam-NG have the most accurate J-beams also, Beam-NG hasn't added scratch marks and dirtiness to cars yet, but they are planning to add them to a future update. And if we are being real, not all cars are made out of clay. But your videos are great and creative, and I don't really get why people are getting so mad for something that was probably made for fun and not to be taken seriously.
Very cool video and how similar the crashes was. Maybe one day we dont need as much expensive real crash test when we have the engine for the PC.
It is shocking that you just made it with your OWN HANDS!!!!! You are very talented
now i really want to make a car like that great vid. A few tips would to be to maybe even up the sped a bit but either way nice vidio
bro threw thew model car at 200 mph and the beamng one was driving at like 30 or 40, not a fair comparison at all dude.
yea this film is pretty shit, and he talking about damage from the side when in beamg 1st. its car from mod, 2 new spawned car vs totally destroyed shit from totally different material, damn this man have no clue what he talking about xD
This is not yelp
Can you guys have some respect this guy? wasted his time effort just for people to talk shit about his work? You guys need some respect.
@@Toast_Steeler horrible job. Wrong materials, wrong speeds, proportions, conditions. No.
@Chamba_Noob Bud hating on him even tho he tried doing it
3:48 is giving me RS6 vibes
Pov kerosene starts to play...
love it❤ i need more vid like this!
very acuratte model, taking consideration that ingame the engine held a bit of the chasiss bending and even tho the clay car was perfectly built , it didnt had the engine block to pair some of the iompact
i would love to buy your cars man, this is honestly amazing to watch
Please make more of these crashes there so cool
Yo I’m pretty sure that u take this video from Russian TH-camr called Head Made. U just translate that video.
That’s cool
You make a car into a clay and then a crash is realistic
Bruh the thumbnail is a Mitsubishi car
I bet you took a long time on that I bet that.
The plasticine represents actual particles and paint scratching beaming will one day hopefully add that effect to a good level
R.I.P. Car 😢 pls rebuild it it needs to live
love your video's. the skill you have making the cars is amazing. enjoy watching them get wrecked as well.😂😂😂👍👍👍
im pretty sure he didnt make them
@@cdfgjrvbdjhvjdr2429I mean why he showed it
Mikemethecariain🇧🇩
⚰️⚰️⚰️⚰️⚰️⚰️⚰️⚰️⚰️⚰️⚰️⚰️⚰️⚰️⚰️⚰️⚰️
@@cdfgjrvbdjhvjdr2429 did you even watch the video??
Can't wait for beam to simulate crushing rims and wheels in between fenders. some vehicles have colliders where tires can catch on fenders like T-series and pre runner d-series trucks but not every vehicle has it
Is your voice ai? Asking if it's ai i use it too because it's good and natural
Using plastic vs metal and the plastic version going 10x faster isn’t going to do it justice
Don’t spoil the video with the “ coming up “ part of it at the start pls it makes it uninteresting not hating, but just a suggestion but still your videos are cool
This is a underrated video
mix a little zinc powder with the clay, then your damage look's like steel
You used the evo 9 interior on the one you made at home
You should’ve put a Lego mini figure inside the model car
I think he should get more attention from these vedios I think he deserves better😢
Man I'd love this stuff if it weren't for the ai voice
I think its crazy beamng is still only beta version and already so good
4:18 mitsudestroyishi
I would say, if you were to do this again, try to match the reverse speed of the Plasticine car with the speed of the one in BeamNG, I bet the damage would be similar then. If we were to take the plasticine version and apply that same reverse speed scaled up to the IRL counterpart or the BeamNG counterpart the reverse speed would have been like 80mph to 100mph in reverse which I don't think there are cars that can do that without any modifications.
how do I start making models like those? Where should I start?
The biggest flaw in Bean is that things don't separate.
It hurts destroying sutch a beauty...
can you make the tesla or waymo?
I need these models in my life
wasting money on toys ❌ saving money ✔
The raw materials probably costed him more than a Diecast replica so not really
Do you sell them?
Can you crash a car with fixable damage and then make a rebuild vidoe for it?
Using same model would destroy it’s structure integrity that’s why that are different
Can you do drivecsX please its almost like beamng Drive
5:26
next time try compairing it to a real car
Where did you get that mod in beamng?
You should’ve made a car from beamng for a better crash comparison
Bro put so much work and effort into making that car and then just destroyed it
beamng drive also simulates the panel materials. such as steel, plastic, etc... your clay model car is weaker in comparison to those materials. that is also why in beamng the wheels didnt break like the model.
No, they don't.
Beamng does not 'simulate' different chassis materials. The only difference that these have on deformation is what sound they make when they scrape.
Can you do the 58 Plymouth😢 please I'm begging you
Koenigsegg jesco pls 🥺
the one with the pole gave me flashbacks...
Can you explain how the pole hit the car so hard when its not even moving?
The real problem in this experiement is that the launcher doesn't let go of the car, so it squeeezes it against the wall
I can watch this with this voice bro, I just cant
whats the car called
U cant compare a toy car with a simulation that is simulating a life size car. Mass, force is all different
The lancer is my favourite street car.
is that the fh5 garage
3:56 audi rs6 memorial
@lemonissogood true
The toy cars in the future:
The reason the tures arnt bent us because it didnt hit with enough force. Also this video doesnt even have s good camprison because your using A toy car. Toy cars get damaged easily. ( Running your toy car is a eall or dropping it won't do anything) But of course the force you did was like 100 miles an hour in toy version scale....so like. Edit some cars can fet cut in half. Also its beam....its still in beta after 13 years. Give the game time ong. Thank you.
you're using a mod car, and mod cars are not of the same quality as the cars in the base game (different mesh quality, realistic deformation... etc)
I don't think it's accurate to compare Clay to the materials actually used to build the different parts of the car. This is fun to watch but it isn't accurate at all. No to talk about the mods of beamng. Modders use models to built diferent types of cars which is will break similarly which wouldn't happen in real life is that specific car.
Bro destroyed his own creation just for our entertainment
and people hate him because he use ai voice
Your videos are beamng drive but in toy form
This hurts my feelers 😥😥🤣
Quality of mod is the main factor
Let’s pay respects for his plaster car
Your car was not changed out I’m the last test that’s why it snapped plus it’s not even close to being able to be realistically compared since you use clay, against wood and other speeds then in beamng, and since it’s not different materials in the different parts like wheels you can’t say it’s not realistic when the beamNG wheels don’t bend the same way buddy.
the forza plate nicce
⚠️🤬THIS IS FAKE HE STOLE THIS VIDEO FROM TH-cam CHANNEL “HANDMADE” UNSUBSCRIBE HIM🤬⚠️
That car model isn’t made by beamng devs
It’s made by a person who published it in the internet
So it won’t be as good as the beamng devs
all of that for u to not get the speeds right
This guy is cheating. He’s using this clay from another guy that made this video. How did he know how to make cars like these? This guy is cool.😅
3:47 kerosene intensifies
for those wondering where the cars are if ur in beamng its a crappy modland mod
He didn’t repair the beamng one every crash so it doesn’t look the same
I wish you would just use your own voice, the ai slop makes this nearly unwatchable
Re builed it pls
problem is the car is a mod and might not be as accurate
You are comparing a Modded Beamng vehicle to a hand made toy. This is completely irrelevant as a test method
Play CarX drift racing 2 because there is no car damage😂
UT oh I think I crashed my car!!!!😅😅😅😅😂😂😂
I am sorry dude but I can't deal with the AI voice....potentially good video but I can't watch this...can you use an actual voice please?
aint realistic with the model or the game remember theres a strong ass engine in the car
Audi Rs6 Reference
cool