I prefer the concert version of "God tree", the whole stage was like a giant tree in that spacious stadium, Hua stood high above (the middle part of the tree), looking down and singing. I bet you would love that performance, too.
Love your reaction n thank you. When I first heard 华晨宇 sing this song, it really scared me. Extremely dark, extremely heavy and foreboding. Very disturbing images. Yes, images of the 2004 catastrophic tsunami came to mind. The feeling of being surrounded and being crashed and being cold! Bone-chilling...... 华晨宇 was at another level when he sang this song at the Singer 2020. But strangely he came in 5th?! 🤷♀️ Waiting eagerly for your reaction to 降临
Enjoyed all of your reactions and comments of Hua’s performances. You give great perspectives and creative ideas on where he could perform his songs. Yes many of his songs are made for big and or special events and he is bold enough to showcase his creations on a competition shows. It’s his chance to show how one can compose music in a unconventional ways and to learn from other great artists. Less concerned about the outcome.
As always very much enjoyed your reaction! It’s very possible the lyrics were changed because of censorship, the names of his songs Madhouse and 7 P were both changed because of censorship in Singer. I really hope you react to Arrival next as it’s so totally different, I really liked the Singer version. Hua composed Arrival in 2018 I think, anyway long before he composed Sacred Tree although he designed Arrival as a sequel of Sacred Tree. Sacred Tree is about tsunami, reckless destruction of earth by humans, Arrival is about rebirth of everything after destruction. 3rd song is New World. Looking forward to your next reaction. Happy New Year 2021!
I love your reactions. Thank you and thanks a lot for the english subs. 😊 Him singing this song on a cliff would be great. Looking forward to your Arrival reaction.
Always so excited to see your interpretation of Hua's art! You guys have really good points to discuss. I loved when you said he should perform this on a cliff, he actually went in Ireland last year and I believe he said he got inspired for "God Tree" there. When I first heard this song it reminded me of the viking's music. So beautiful and enchanting ❤️
Great insight and observation lads👍👍 thanks for checking out “God Tree/Sacred Tree”. He has this innate ability to just emote vocally without moving much and his body of work since his first album has been bold, progressive and provocative in the face of Chinese mainstream audience. You have reacted to “Seven Personalities” right? He performed that to end his Singer 2020 journey 😆. That’s how bold he is in terms of music and art. Hua Hua was very much influenced by British rock bands like Muse, Radiohead and Queen. Can you believe that he performed Muse’s “Knights of Cydonia” in his first concert in 2014, after winning Superboy 2013? That time he hasn’t yet released his debut album. The confidence Hua Hua has in terms of music is very appealing. Thanks again lads for sharing Hua Hua 🙏🙏
You have expressed some of the feeling I get from this song. This song is a very big and in fact should not be performed in this kind of competition. This is an art piece. However, Hua Chengyu sang this song for his Martians and people who can accept the music. He is really very outstanding.
Once again I just love your reaction. you are full of ideas for where he can sing Sacred Tree (God Tree) Waiting for your next one of HuaHua! Stay safe
Love the cave idea. I could see him performing in an Indigenous canyon like on the Navajo reservation. Maybe somewhere on sacred grounds, of course tribal approved. Is there somewhere in China like this? en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antelope_Canyon OR maybe at the biggest wonders of the world. I could also see him performing in destroyed by humans places. He is magical and could bring so much attention to the destruction of the earth even more by doing this. Risky I know, just a thought, probably not possible as all countries hide these areas.
Good reaction, but are you guys watching this on your phone? Such a shame...get a proper screen and headphones so you can appreciate his artistry fully.
Really? The lyrics were wrong??? You are the first to comment on that, and obviously i have no way of telling. I think i know 5 different signs. So envious... please check the english translation if that is off too. Looking forward to Arrival now... Both songs are ment for the outdoor concerts. Wish to be there
Yes, there are some lyrics, what he sang is not same with the lyrics shown on the screen, maybe the lyrics are sensitive? So It was changed by the show. Such as: 1"45"-1"48": The lyrics on the screen are 无疑心愿（undoubtedly wish） The correct lyrics sung by Hua Chenyu is "无一幸免" (no one survived) 2'38": The lyrics on the screen are “孩童被问”（childen being asked） Hua Chenyu sings "孩童被困” (children being trapped) The meaning of the lyrics are totally different.
@@TwoMusketeersReaction Thank you for taking your time to explain how. Interesting, but so weird. Its a chinese show for chinese speaking people. Everyone can spot it the way you did. Silly. But then again, its the first time ive heard anybody comment about it. Good job! And yes, i for one expect you to work yourselves through ALL of the recommendations. Then ill have some more.....
@@TwoMusketeersReaction like you said maybe due to sensitive lyrics. HuaHua likes to sing according to his feelings, same song with many versions. Another thing is he admitted sometime he do forget the lyrics😅 so just sing what feels like right 😆. Mandarin speaking Martians always teased him during his concerts. Please check out others mandarin reactions. Terima kasih.
神樹～很壯麗磅礡的藝術性歌曲～❤
这是世界级的音乐了
海口那場我剛好在現場，上完廁所來不及回位置，低聲單音鋼琴持續蕩漾在整個體育館，我自己是非常喜歡，壓抑又澎湃
The beggar and the King, sing with the Fans.I am sure you guy will love it. 2017 concert.
华晨宇当之无愧的史上最年轻的歌王！
這是我最喜愛的歌曲之一，完完全全營造出地球毀滅末日的氣氛，大氣磅礡，隔著螢幕的震撼力已足以抓著每個人的神經，更何況是現場的懾人威力是何等驚人，相信在他2019海口演唱會現場可真正感受到。
很敬佩他獨特而帶有使命感的音樂理念，將音樂帶至另一層面高峯，打破純粹抒情娛樂的舊有框框，重新改寫了音樂的可能性與定義，無邊無界的創意於他的音樂湧現，締造出音樂藝術之絕美境界。
期待下一首的“降臨”，完整顯現這系列史詩式的創作。
推荐2019海口演唱会的版本。因为体育场的空间非常大，这首歌的效果才真的体现出来了，虽然收音没有歌手版的清楚，但是声效和感觉更棒！
演唱会的版本更震撼
花花不用去到山洞都可以在幾秒鐘裏面賣完演唱會的票了🙂
谢谢你们反应这首歌！我认为这是华晨宇最有艺术性的作品之一，整首歌像一部大制作电影，像海啸一样汹涌磅礴，充满画面感。花花说神树和降临一定要一起听，循环听，因为它们是阴阳双生曲，一个是世界末日，一个是万物重生。就像阴阳太极图，前者在毁灭的同时孕育着希望，后者在生命的降临中潜藏黑暗。既包含了环保的主题，但又不止于此，是很有哲理深度和艺术风格的作品。顺便，歌曲里面的背景和声是华晨宇亲自设计和录制的，下一首降临也是，所有的和声都是他自己变换各种音色唱出来的，太了不起了！
嗨嗨你们好呀，神树 刚刚看到有人comment了 在2019的演唱会，记得去看哦⊙∀⊙！我第一次听到现在依然是很震撼的，他的歌曲从流行音乐升华到了艺术层面😳
只有花花能超越他自己！有时候他的歌给我的感觉就是应该静静地欣赏而不是让我们去唱... 因为我没有那么好的唱功所以每次都有拉牛上树的feel😂 每一次听都会很激动，深深地沉浸在歌曲中，这种感觉是很棒的😆
最爱的还是他对音乐的坚持，谢谢你们的reaction，也期待听到更多的好声音🌹
太喜歡這首👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
推介一定要看2019演唱會版，真的這種地方才能完美😍👍
花花曾属说过让我最感动的话：我唱歌不是想告诉别人我歌唱技巧很好或者做到怎么样唱到什么音，相反，我希望你们能忘掉我的歌唱技巧，去感受音乐本身，而且我在唱到动情时候我甚至不考虑什么声乐技巧，我甚至不在乎技巧。 （原话肯定记不住了[害羞]大概是这个意思）
谢谢你们专业的分析。这首歌会有很多画面，有海啸，末日的感觉。华晨宇真的要夸奖，多年前他唱的地球之盐he wrote to the God.
A very powerful singer. No matter where he sings his music sounds fantastic.
I prefer the concert version of "God tree", the whole stage was like a giant tree in that spacious stadium, Hua stood high above (the middle part of the tree), looking down and singing. I bet you would love that performance, too.
Yes, the live concert performance was stunning. The visuals dramatically reinforced the message of the song. Breath-taking!
Love your reaction n thank you.
When I first heard 华晨宇 sing this song, it really scared me. Extremely dark, extremely heavy and foreboding. Very disturbing images. Yes, images of the 2004 catastrophic tsunami came to mind.
The feeling of being surrounded and being crashed and being cold! Bone-chilling......
华晨宇 was at another level when he sang this song at the Singer 2020. But strangely he came in 5th?! 🤷♀️
Waiting eagerly for your reaction to 降临
很喜歡你們對花花歌曲的理解和分析，他的歌曲都有很深的意義。還有部分字幕錯了是因為電視台為了通過審查會特地改掉一些他們覺得比較敏感的歌詞，甚至個別歌名都會改掉。建議可以搜一下原版歌詞來看。期待你們的下一個reaction video。
谢谢你，之后我也看了原版歌词。电视台好严格哦！不过因为我们是华人，我们听得懂，无损我们对这首歌的理解。
Sangat sangat suka,👍👍👍👍👍
Kamu tahu bahasa malayu kah? Terima kasih.
@@TwoMusketeersReaction saya orang Indonesia 🇮🇩
@@carlina8814 OIC, so kamu ialah jiran kami. 😂😊thanks for your support!
Enjoyed all of your reactions and comments of Hua’s performances. You give great perspectives and creative ideas on where he could perform his songs. Yes many of his songs are made for big and or special events and he is bold enough to showcase his creations on a competition shows. It’s his chance to show how one can compose music in a unconventional ways and to learn from other great artists. Less concerned about the outcome.
真担心喇叭会冒烟勒 ，舞台灯光效果真的很棒 歌唱更不用说了已经要唱到最高境界 。
我也希望有机会可以在更大的舞台（或不一样的舞台）听华晨宇演唱这一首神树。期待下一首《降临》的reaction！
As always very much enjoyed your reaction!
It’s very possible the lyrics were changed because of censorship, the names of his songs Madhouse and 7 P were both changed because of censorship in Singer.
I really hope you react to Arrival next as it’s so totally different, I really liked the Singer version. Hua composed Arrival in 2018 I think, anyway long before he composed Sacred Tree although he designed Arrival as a sequel of Sacred Tree.
Sacred Tree is about tsunami, reckless destruction of earth by humans, Arrival is about rebirth of everything after destruction. 3rd song is New World.
Looking forward to your next reaction. Happy New Year 2021!
I love your reactions. Thank you and thanks a lot for the english subs. 😊 Him singing this song on a cliff would be great. Looking forward to your Arrival reaction.
Always so excited to see your interpretation of Hua's art! You guys have really good points to discuss. I loved when you said he should perform this on a cliff, he actually went in Ireland last year and I believe he said he got inspired for "God Tree" there.
When I first heard this song it reminded me of the viking's music. So beautiful and enchanting ❤️
Wow, thank you for like our reaction video. 😊😊
这首歌和降临就象是太极图。 黑的地方有白点和白的地方有黑点。 神树虽然给人的感觉是毁灭可是也有给人希望（never give up). 期待你们对《降临》的reaction。 hint: 这首歌他带了锁的吊坠和在《降临》他带了钥匙的吊坠。 ❤️🌹🌹
Great insight and observation lads👍👍 thanks for checking out “God Tree/Sacred Tree”. He has this innate ability to just emote vocally without moving much and his body of work since his first album has been bold, progressive and provocative in the face of Chinese mainstream audience. You have reacted to “Seven Personalities” right? He performed that to end his Singer 2020 journey 😆. That’s how bold he is in terms of music and art.
Hua Hua was very much influenced by British rock bands like Muse, Radiohead and Queen. Can you believe that he performed Muse’s “Knights of Cydonia” in his first concert in 2014, after winning Superboy 2013? That time he hasn’t yet released his debut album. The confidence Hua Hua has in terms of music is very appealing.
Thanks again lads for sharing Hua Hua 🙏🙏
华晨宇与国际视觉艺术家沈伟合作的经典作品《声希》可能是你们想找的艺术作品 但说实话我没有看懂 希望你们的专业可以帮忙解读一下 加油 th-cam.com/video/W6AOvvkwNdE/w-d-xo.html
Enthusiastic reaction. Can try Hua Hua's music festival videos.
有机会的话可以去看看今年演唱会版本的神树 配上今年的舞台效果真的好好看 强推👍👍👍
You have expressed some of the feeling I get from this song. This song is a very big and in fact should not be performed in this kind of competition. This is an art piece. However, Hua Chengyu sang this song for his Martians and people who can accept the music. He is really very outstanding.
Once again I just love your reaction. you are full of ideas for where he can sing Sacred Tree (God Tree) Waiting for your next one of HuaHua! Stay safe
So glad that you like our reaction. Thanks!
Love the cave idea. I could see him performing in an Indigenous canyon like on the Navajo reservation. Maybe somewhere on sacred grounds, of course tribal approved. Is there somewhere in China like this? en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antelope_Canyon OR maybe at the biggest wonders of the world. I could also see him performing in destroyed by humans places. He is magical and could bring so much attention to the destruction of the earth even more by doing this. Risky I know, just a thought, probably not possible as all countries hide these areas.
藝術推介：「開火」演唱會2019
推荐你们也听《降临》。《降临》和《神树》就像太极的两极，可以循环听，向死而生。华晨宇的歌，有太多不同风格，有大气的，有细腻的，你们上网随便搜，有空听听，会有不同惊喜哦。另外建议你们尽量看演唱会版本，万人体育场才能装得下华晨宇的歌哈哈。
是的，这首歌已经排着队up咯！Up了之后记得来支持我们哦！😊
@@TwoMusketeersReaction 等着呢！
@@TwoMusketeersReaction 我等到一年都过去了，reaction在哪儿呢 😂
@@chunjuanlaile 哈哈哈哈哈！好夸张！如果我告诉你是明天中午12点，你信吗？
@@TwoMusketeersReaction 那好吧，睡一觉醒来差不多就是明天中午啦
你去看他的斗牛MV、很好看
2019年在火星演唱会首次听到，非常震撼！
MV 可以看这个Fanmade：th-cam.com/video/S5NLBntmU8E/w-d-xo.html 蛮有feel
神树特别适合剪MV，这个也很好 th-cam.com/video/0OG0CaCHpAs/w-d-xo.html
中國電視台會因為一些字不能再電視出現，所以會把字改掉，例如歌名瘋人院，七重人格歌名都被更改。
🌸🌸👍
神树，降临
这是花花一个把立意放大到“世界级”代表作。
歌手版在音质和画面上都有保障。
🌸🌸👏👏😍
推荐不插电魂斗罗
如果是华晨宇关于环境保护的歌曲。还有一首叫地球之盐 也推荐你们去听哦~th-cam.com/video/FhmFcQIkIzs/w-d-xo.html
这首要配mv..
其实歌词不是错了，是故意改的，因为有些敏感词在电视不能播，电视台会改掉一些词变成谐音
很配复仇者联盟 哈哈
我估計你們沒辦法買到演唱會門票。只能用秒來形容。
Good reaction, but are you guys watching this on your phone? Such a shame...get a proper screen and headphones so you can appreciate his artistry fully.
IMHO歌手版神树在鄙人这边意义真的只是没出专时候的音源而已...这个舞台对于这首歌真的...有点小
Reaction fake monk pls..
Really? The lyrics were wrong??? You are the first to comment on that, and obviously i have no way of telling. I think i know 5 different signs. So envious... please check the english translation if that is off too. Looking forward to Arrival now... Both songs are ment for the outdoor concerts. Wish to be there
They're referring to the Chinese lyrics on Singer 2020. The English translations are pretty accurate
Yes, there are some lyrics, what he sang is not same with the lyrics shown on the screen, maybe the lyrics are sensitive? So It was changed by the show.
Such as: 1"45"-1"48": The lyrics on the screen are 无疑心愿（undoubtedly wish）
The correct lyrics sung by Hua Chenyu is "无一幸免" (no one survived)
2'38": The lyrics on the screen are “孩童被问”（childen being asked）
Hua Chenyu sings "孩童被困” (children being trapped)
The meaning of the lyrics are totally different.
@@TwoMusketeersReaction Thank you for taking your time to explain how. Interesting, but so weird. Its a chinese show for chinese speaking people. Everyone can spot it the way you did. Silly. But then again, its the first time ive heard anybody comment about it. Good job! And yes, i for one expect you to work yourselves through ALL of the recommendations. Then ill have some more.....
@@CC-sr2ec you are welcome. And thanks for your support.
@@TwoMusketeersReaction like you said maybe due to sensitive lyrics. HuaHua likes to sing according to his feelings, same song with many versions. Another thing is he admitted sometime he do forget the lyrics😅 so just sing what feels like right 😆. Mandarin speaking Martians always teased him during his concerts. Please check out others mandarin reactions. Terima kasih.
花花说神树这是个废嗓子的歌
真的，打从灵魂深处的呐喊，很耗嗓子。