The first girl is literally asking for actual criticism and all they were giving her is "Nah I dont want to hear anything from you" She was also singing extremely good wtf
@@nickmiller1744 I saw through it personally, I was surprised a lot of people in the comments felt the way you did. I see why, she did make me feel bad at first but I watched it so many times that now I can see through it lol. I won't argue that she has a nice voice though.
Danabana exactly she really wasn't bad at all. They're just out of touch bc they think that style is dead? But like why does it matter? Idk but they were trippin
I feel like she’d THRIVE in live musicals. She can get really emotional and has the right sorta energy. I can’t remember what musical this is, but it’s a retelling of a Greek mythology in some sort of American 20’s setting, with jazz music. She’d be perfect for that kinda musical.
They could have been way more supportive; the guest judge (Patti Lupone, maybe?) was totally right, she would be great on stage. They should have encouraged her more instead of just telling her she’s not good enough.
it really irritates me when non-musicians who don't sing think they can comment on someone "not having their voice together." Yes, i am talking about simon. I don't care how much money he is worth or how long he has been in the industry, he is a money and power hungry person who doesn't know a thing about being a musician apart from earning money. He had no right to stop the audition when it was going well because it "wasn't the right style" It hurt me to see her so upset. She didnt need that
That first woman was probably a paid actress. Speaking from experience as someone who has tried out for American idol and has seen behind the scenes of how they stage things. Honestly a lot of these bad auditions are probably paid actors. Which would explain why they feel UNREAL
@rene ruiz when I auditioned if someone made it, they would walk them back to where everyone was in line and pose them in line to get shots of them "waiting to audition" and they would tell them what to say and put who they wanted around them and made sure no logos were showing. Camera men would come by while you waited and tell you things to say, pick loud people out of line and interview them. When you audition you audition 3 at a time in front of a random judge who is not famous. The famous judges are not there. That part is just for TV. They dont ask you to do a different song. They dont tell you why they dont like you. You walk up 3 at a time, they point at you and you sing, then you walk away unless they like you. I auditioned in Atlanta. In August (on my bday August 22nd in 2017) it was in a park outside. It basically took all day. You can have people wait in line with you, but anyone not auditioning gets sent very far away. My husband was told to gi sit on a hill with other spouses friends and parents. He said he could barely see me. I found out that day that you could audition online beforehand, and if they like you they will ask you to come at an specific time and film you waiting in line (even though they had an appointment and didn't wait) and then audition you. There were hundreds of people there. Some people dressed and acted ridiculously. I was in line a few people behind a very loud obnoxious girl who couldn't sing. She was filmed a few times. I think she was a paid actress.
Not anymore. On America's Got Talent he is nicer than he was on American Idol. I remember on American Idol , he forgot that his mike was on and he said after a contestant had just made it through to Hollywood "We are going to need a bigger stage". The woman who had sent through the next round was overweight but she had an amazing voice. If I remember correctly, the woman heard what Simon said. She ended up forgiving him. She didn't win the show but she is now a famous gospel singer. Her name is Mandisa. The next season he was much nicer to contestants who were overweight.
I think American Idol doesn't always know how to spot potential. I have read about several celebrities who was turned down by American Idol judges or didn't make it in front of the judges at all who are amazing. Amber Riley who was on Glee and did Broadway was rejected, so was Naya Rivera from Glee, Hillary Scott from Lady Antebellum and so was Tori Kelly. Clearly American Idol doesn't always recognize talent when it's right in front of them.
That is true! Look at Chris Daughtry, Simon said NO to him. I remember watching that live, thinking WTFF?!?!?!?!? He still made it through but didn't win. He finished 7th, I think. The band Fuel, actually asked him to be their frontman. To which he turned down and created his own band. People like Adam Lambert and James Durbin are prime examples too. They had amazing voices but didn't win. They still get hate and people saying, JUST BECAUSE YOU CAN SING HIGH NOTES DOESN'T MEAN YOU CAN SING. Which is BS, because we know they can. They should have won, yet they got robbed. James losing to someone who FORGOT the lyrics. Which usually sends you home. It's sent so many amazing singers home but not that time. Thankfully now, they're both frontmen of amazing bands. Adam with Queen and James is in Quiet Riot now. Where are the winners? Who knows, they fell of the map years ago. Main reason I stopped watching the show, it's totally rigged.
@@GPXgirl I agree. Some of the winners are doing well such Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood. And then you have winners like Taylor Hicks or Phillip Phillips who haven't put out any music in awhile. Even Jordin Sparks hasn't done much in awhile. Although she did have a baby and she got married a couple of years ago.
The second girl is actually an actress. Her name is Sarah Goldberg. She was just messing with her friends and they said she should go to the show and act like shes crazy. She made it. She made everyone believe, she’s crazy.
i tought she was acctually a ''psycho'' (Please don't get me wrong, i know a psycho wouldn't react like that and be very emotional, but i think you get what i mean.) or something, like really crazy, or mental issues. but i've searched, i didn't see anything!
I was a judge on a small scale singing contest. And there usually isn't time to give back feedback, and it gets TIRING. If you give one person feedback you'd have to give it to everyone too...
@@Ruby-Rosales But that doesn't mean that they should've let her go when she clearly has amazing talent . At least give her a chance instead of pushing a really good singer away and possibly discouraging her from singing .
@@Ruby-RosalesTrue but, I know they weren't really looking for her type of style of singing but it doesn't mean that they should legit discourage her from singing when she had amazing talent . They shouldn't have been that rude to her when her voice was amazing , just not the right style .
We all had that moment as kids, when we quarreled with a parent or sibling, knew we lost, tried a glamorous doorslam exit and the damn door didn't open or slam shut as wanted ... Worse if the other person laughed their ass off watching this scene unfold.
I have social anxiety and during my audition I had to sing a really high note and I panicked and my voice cracked and then I had a panic attack and started crying and the director let me try again at the end :) I got a good role but I still cringe thinking about it. Btw this was in march 😅
Don't worry. I had a panic attack auditioning for my talent show in 8th grade, crying and voice cracks, the whole shebang. Most embarrassing part? I volunteered to go first. And I too, cringe at that memory.
I cried. Didn't get a part. Tried out for the play and because my friend wanted a part I knew I would get so I tried out for a different part and I didn't get cast as a talking part. Ended up quitting and idk if I'll do theatre when school starts again
@@bigdog3695 I'll probably do it but I just want to cut a toxic friend out of my life who pressured me into not trying out for her part. ( She kinda sucked btw she over did everything )
American idol, then and now is centered around views.. I was going to audition for them here in August but the rules are insane and if you read about it, it’s crazy. You can be the best singer and not go through, you can be the worst singer and make it to the live shows. Before you even make it onto the tv screen, you have 4/5 auditions and they’re in front of the producers not the celebrity judges
Tristan: Are you a bad singer? Get a vocal coach Tristan: want to learn to start singing? Get a vocal coach Tristan: want to improve your voice? Get a vocal coach Tristan: Have you got cancer? Get a vocal coach! Tristan: Literally dying? Get a vocal coach!
The first woman was amazing, first off... but when she was leaving she reminded me of Lily in Hannah Montana when she’s like “I’m leaving... here I go.... halfway to the door... nearly there...” 😅
@@cassidy2098 Lol We figured out the whole formula for the show if Simon doesn't like you then no one can. They have just been playing Simon says this whole time. That joke actually made me laugh for quite a bit
Didn't really think she was unique though. Some of the Patreon people Tristan reacts to, aren't bad either, but they don't have that kind of radio voice where you could distinguish them from other artists.
Oh no...I always find the second-hand embarrassment too bad to watch these. Edit: Wow, thanks for the likes! I'm glad I'm not the only one 😂 And yes, I too have a TH-cam channel - if you would like to check it out then that would be very much appreciated ☺️
Litterally the first girl was beautiful, had an AMAZING voice and courage, some people would probably think she was dramatic or something, but I think that’s so wrong, I think she stood up for herself in a very brave way😊❤️
The Voice is a much better competition IMO because they stick to and understand your style and actually give you MUSICAL advice instead of telling you what you need to look like and what kind of attitude you need.
Well the difference between american idol and the voice is there names but also american idol is for forming a star someone who looks and acts the part whereas the voice focuses on the voice not appearance making a star like that
@@suds-p Because there is no way to give generic advice when someone needs a lot of guidance to develop their voice. The less adept someone is at singing, the more they need personalised input and often reassurance. 'See your doctor' is also general advice, but still correct whatever is wrong with you medically. I'm still not sure what OP's point is.
@@oldvlognewtricks That's fair. Wouldn't chalk up OP's point to more than commenting on the fact that he mentioned vocal coaches for almost every performance
Ashanti (the first girl) had been on the show before and made it far. That is why she didn't make it through- is because she didn't develop her own style or improve
Singers listening to their own voices to improve is the equivalent of digital artists flipping the canvas to look for mistakes. Thank you for coming to my TED Talk
The thing is, people have to understand that shows like American Idol are catered for ratings and ENTERTAINMENT, not talent. If talent is the only barometer for singing in American Idol, Tori Kelly would have either won the show long ago or at least gone quite far. At least Tori Kelly succeeded way more than many contestants on these shows and even collaborated with Jacob Collier. That is a true testament of her great singing ability - someone in the class of Collier would not want to collaborate with mediocre singers :P
Just discovered you and your channel and charm. You are awesome and real. Love your smile, and I love your interpretation and commentary. Very constructive. Thank you!
Chantal Prins but like Gordon makes comments though, like reasonable complaints. “It’s raw, it’s undercooked” he’s harsh but at least he has some type of feedback. Simon just says “you’re bad because you’re bad” I still love him but like he doesn’t give feedback
I knew a girl who auditioned for Am Idol (a pretty decent R&B talent). Turns out, you don’t even get to see “The Judges” right off, you have to go through preliminary tryouts first. She got a No in the first round, but the guy next to her who was in a chicken costume obv just there for laughs got through. It’s an entertainment show, but one that doesn’t necessarily require singing.
Please react to Alec Benjamin! He's such a good underappreciated artist who deserves all the praise he can get. You and him even follow each other on Insta!
I've auditioned for AI a couple of times. Never made it through the first round. It's super hard to make it through these shoes. I have also tried AGT and The voice. Same thing. Super hard to get on. AI pulls people for shock and entertainment value though.
1st one pissed me off. A respectful, beautiful person who just came on the show looking for experience? I've seen these judges be nicer to people that are rude and disrespectful. Wow.
She got experience on the show twice before in previous seasons. She didn’t make it that far either time. And here she was trying to get on the show yet again. That’s why they didn’t let her through, not because she was bad.
That First Lady LITERALLY could be a animated Disney princess.. her speaking voice is literally flawless.
Right, I thogiut that too
Tiana!!!
I hope she didn’t give up singing after this audition
RIGHTTT
IKR
The first girl is literally asking for actual criticism and all they were giving her is "Nah I dont want to hear anything from you"
She was also singing extremely good wtf
Yeah It's not fair
chewy I don’t care I’m 4 months late to reply
They should give her the advice she wants, they should learn the facts before they be that bitchey
True (Corona Time ) 😉
Talents shows are absolute shit tbh.
pxstel_boba• I stopped trusting Simon after the Marcelito Pomoy incident. He’s just as shitty as all the others lol.
the first girl would definitely go far in like broadway or any musical theatre group no doubt acting and singing
She was a terrible actor 😂
SAOSURVIVE don’t really agree she kinda moved me
@@nickmiller1744 I saw through it personally, I was surprised a lot of people in the comments felt the way you did. I see why, she did make me feel bad at first but I watched it so many times that now I can see through it lol. I won't argue that she has a nice voice though.
Nick Miller right 😂 I was moved
No she wouldn't, her voice wasnt that good and she probably cant dance
The first girl should audition for some acting roles because I was moved lmao
Danabana exactly she really wasn't bad at all. They're just out of touch bc they think that style is dead? But like why does it matter? Idk but they were trippin
i think it was stupid of them to say “it’s too old-fashioned” lmao
mayzee exactly like what does that even mean
Broadway is a good idea too
I feel like she’d THRIVE in live musicals. She can get really emotional and has the right sorta energy. I can’t remember what musical this is, but it’s a retelling of a Greek mythology in some sort of American 20’s setting, with jazz music. She’d be perfect for that kinda musical.
That first girl broke my heart. She deserved more. She had a beautiful voice. And she needed real advice.
They could have been way more supportive; the guest judge (Patti Lupone, maybe?) was totally right, she would be great on stage. They should have encouraged her more instead of just telling her she’s not good enough.
Jordie Madison it’s Carole Bayer Sager
fr
agreed, tbh if I was a judge on there I would've said yes!
it really irritates me when non-musicians who don't sing think they can comment on someone "not having their voice together." Yes, i am talking about simon. I don't care how much money he is worth or how long he has been in the industry, he is a money and power hungry person who doesn't know a thing about being a musician apart from earning money. He had no right to stop the audition when it was going well because it "wasn't the right style" It hurt me to see her so upset. She didnt need that
That first woman was probably a paid actress. Speaking from experience as someone who has tried out for American idol and has seen behind the scenes of how they stage things.
Honestly a lot of these bad auditions are probably paid actors. Which would explain why they feel UNREAL
@rene ruiz when I auditioned if someone made it, they would walk them back to where everyone was in line and pose them in line to get shots of them "waiting to audition" and they would tell them what to say and put who they wanted around them and made sure no logos were showing. Camera men would come by while you waited and tell you things to say, pick loud people out of line and interview them. When you audition you audition 3 at a time in front of a random judge who is not famous. The famous judges are not there. That part is just for TV. They dont ask you to do a different song. They dont tell you why they dont like you. You walk up 3 at a time, they point at you and you sing, then you walk away unless they like you. I auditioned in Atlanta. In August (on my bday August 22nd in 2017) it was in a park outside. It basically took all day. You can have people wait in line with you, but anyone not auditioning gets sent very far away. My husband was told to gi sit on a hill with other spouses friends and parents. He said he could barely see me. I found out that day that you could audition online beforehand, and if they like you they will ask you to come at an specific time and film you waiting in line (even though they had an appointment and didn't wait) and then audition you. There were hundreds of people there. Some people dressed and acted ridiculously. I was in line a few people behind a very loud obnoxious girl who couldn't sing. She was filmed a few times. I think she was a paid actress.
So she probably was a broadway actress then.
@@annabellematice5163 wow, that's really interesting.
ye i did sense a lot of acting from her
Wow I've always wondered how the audition process for these shows go...
Also, Happy day before your Birthday🎂! 😂
“Simon is being unnecessarily rude here” yeah that’s his thing 😂
Saw this comment at the exact moment he said that...
Not anymore. On America's Got Talent he is nicer than he was on American Idol. I remember on American Idol , he forgot that his mike was on and he said after a contestant had just made it through to Hollywood "We are going to need a bigger stage". The woman who had sent through the next round was overweight but she had an amazing voice. If I remember correctly, the woman heard what Simon said. She ended up forgiving him. She didn't win the show but she is now a famous gospel singer. Her name is Mandisa. The next season he was much nicer to contestants who were overweight.
It's one of the few things I really really love him about
There is actually a German equivalent to him in German "talent" shows, Dieter Bohlen.^^
True
The first woman... It felt like a movie scene, very dramatic 😯
I think she stated that it all was an act and that she is an actress too. But sadly I can't find the article
I think she'd be better off in broadway. She's got the skills for that and an amazing voice
The dramatic music hahah
Exactly. Why can’t she audition to be an actor?
It almost seems to me like she was a paid actress, but also, not a regular tv actress but a soap opra / theater because of the way she was acting
Shanty: What do I need to improve?
Judges, sweating: Your voice sucks
She was so great.
This is why Simon trying to rebrand himself as a woke anti-bully now is hilarious.
I think American Idol doesn't always know how to spot potential. I have read about several celebrities who was turned down by American Idol judges or didn't make it in front of the judges at all who are amazing. Amber Riley who was on Glee and did Broadway was rejected, so was Naya Rivera from Glee, Hillary Scott from Lady Antebellum and so was Tori Kelly. Clearly American Idol doesn't always recognize talent when it's right in front of them.
That is true! Look at Chris Daughtry, Simon said NO to him. I remember watching that live, thinking WTFF?!?!?!?!? He still made it through but didn't win. He finished 7th, I think. The band Fuel, actually asked him to be their frontman. To which he turned down and created his own band. People like Adam Lambert and James Durbin are prime examples too. They had amazing voices but didn't win. They still get hate and people saying, JUST BECAUSE YOU CAN SING HIGH NOTES DOESN'T MEAN YOU CAN SING. Which is BS, because we know they can. They should have won, yet they got robbed. James losing to someone who FORGOT the lyrics. Which usually sends you home. It's sent so many amazing singers home but not that time. Thankfully now, they're both frontmen of amazing bands. Adam with Queen and James is in Quiet Riot now. Where are the winners? Who knows, they fell of the map years ago. Main reason I stopped watching the show, it's totally rigged.
Also jack Avery of why don’t we was rejected
Ashley Downey Naya Rivera is crzy talented i don’t c how they don’t c this
@@Bri-jy5wu I agree. She didn't even make it to the judges. She auditioned in front of the producers and so did Amber Riley.
@@GPXgirl I agree. Some of the winners are doing well such Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood. And then you have winners like Taylor Hicks or Phillip Phillips who haven't put out any music in awhile. Even Jordin Sparks hasn't done much in awhile. Although she did have a baby and she got married a couple of years ago.
The first girl's speaking voice sounded like belle from beauty and the beast.
More like Tiana from The Princess and The Frog
a p r i l x o a b e l x o Yep, definitely Tiana
She was faking that's why
I was thinking that she could be a Disney princess, too. lol
@@aprilxoabelxo you're just saying that cuz she's black lol
The second girl is actually an actress. Her name is Sarah Goldberg. She was just messing with her friends and they said she should go to the show and act like shes crazy.
She made it. She made everyone believe, she’s crazy.
Payton Rivera yeah. When you search for her on youtube or google, you can see her
I really doubt it's the actress. Although the do have the same name, most of your information is correct aside from her being the actress.
WAIT WHAT ??!?!
old comment but that takes balls of steel my man. that girl is a great actress.
i tought she was acctually a ''psycho'' (Please don't get me wrong, i know a psycho wouldn't react like that and be very emotional, but i think you get what i mean.) or something, like really crazy, or mental issues. but i've searched, i didn't see anything!
The first girl would be a lot happier on Broadway *then* with these racks
Than
I agree.
YUP!!
I agree I would rather audition for Broadway than American idol anytime
Soaribb she’s famous now look up “Ashanti”
This video should be called, “Tristan Exposing American Idol For 17 Minutes”
This made me laugh😂😂😂good one
Acually 17 min and a couple seconds
Or just 18 minutes.
Yeah, you guys are right but close enough 😂
Oh you again ... I know you...
i felt bad for the first girl, the script they gave her must’ve been so long and hard to memorize
Well that took a turn 😂😂💀
Mmmm tru
Humour Lvl : 100
They had us in the first half ... Not gonna lie
Omg lol haha 😂😂😄😁😂🤣
the first girl i felt like she was auditioning for a Netflix series
Pretty much lol
😂
🤣🤣
She kinda looks like Toni from Riverdale
That second girl is me interviewing for a job I have no experience for. 🤣🤣
Joeii James ME TOOOOOOOOO
This got me dead😂😂
😂😂😂 TEACH MEEE I CAN LEEEAARRNN!!!
Meee🤣🤣🤣🤣
Omg this comment 😭
No one:
Literally no one:
Not even Simon Cowell:
Tristan: *SeE tHaTs WhY yOu NeEd A vOcAl CoAcH*
@Sara Himeur that means I'm a vocal coach that works hollistically
😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣
Hey, is this guy a vocal coach?
@@lathanandrews417 do you mean Tristan? If you do, yes he is
I feel bad for the first girl, she did nothing wrong.
Eddie knotts I know right
And they were rude as hell
Eddie knotts She was 10 years too early. If she auditioned today, her speech would’ve gone viral & she would’ve gotten a massive online following.. :(
They probably denied her bc of her race. 🙄
Mikayla Bentley I don’t think that’s it the same race as her didn’t want her either
no matter how cringey the audition is, tristan always finds something nice and constructive to say. it’s the sweetest thing 🥺
Ikr
"she put all her energy and eggs in the wrong basket"
more like she put all her energy in the wrong door
DOPE BOY INSTANASTER lol I was wondering if I was the only one who noticed that.
Lol
LOL
She was looking for advice, they couldn’t give it to her and they said no
How tf is that fair ?
I was a judge on a small scale singing contest. And there usually isn't time to give back feedback, and it gets TIRING.
If you give one person feedback you'd have to give it to everyone too...
@Bella star youve never had to sit still for 12+ hours listening to hundreds of people sing per day... even the sweetest people get cranky
@@Ruby-Rosales But that doesn't mean that they should've let her go when she clearly has amazing talent . At least give her a chance instead of pushing a really good singer away and possibly discouraging her from singing .
@@elizabeththirkapersaud5547 they were looking for a pop star not a Broadway star. Her style doesnt suit idol, but it does suit stage.
@@Ruby-RosalesTrue but, I know they weren't really looking for her type of style of singing but it doesn't mean that they should legit discourage her from singing when she had amazing talent . They shouldn't have been that rude to her when her voice was amazing , just not the right style .
The first girl could be an actor, plus she could sing she just needs a little more training.
캐시디Cassidy she is an actress it was fake
@@hannah-sofia8304 who is she?
@@ET-oq7gt I think her name is Ashanti J'aria...
캐시디Cassidy she should be on broadway.
And with her voice, i think she fits broadway. But what they said about her, is just. sad. Unfair
I feel bad for the first girl
2nd girl I cringed
3d girl high self esteem got crushed real quick but what ever
T TNT ‘esteem’ ... but yes I agree
Did you just say self steam????
@@regcla6667 yes i corrected it dw
someone: dies
tristan: bet that wouldn’t have happened if he had a really good vocal coach
I want that on my plaque
olivia c I LOVE this
😂😂
OMG yes!
So true
"I remember when I was a really bad singer-"
"It was this morning"
*_Queen Cat_*
Shes gonna kill everybody in 2 words hahha 🤣
right now is when I was bad at singing
@@TarynM716 haha same :(
@@TarynM716 same 😂🎤
The first woman sounds like a Disney Princess 👑
Has the first woman ever tried acting, she would be really good.
11 months later I’m back 9k likes now
IKR? She’s a good singer and and she should be an actress. The judges rationale for turning her down was confusing.
Zeze Is_amazing heard she was actually an actress.
For real haha
Omg roasted lmao
@@fatimagazali8222 what is her name
The second person's dramatic exit was totally ruined when the door wouldn't open😂
Omg that killed me
We all had that moment as kids, when we quarreled with a parent or sibling, knew we lost, tried a glamorous doorslam exit and the damn door didn't open or slam shut as wanted ...
Worse if the other person laughed their ass off watching this scene unfold.
@@ichmeiner4531 oh my God, yes! That has happened to me so many times, almost always with someone to witness it😂😅
Yeah I felt so bad for her when they happened 😂
@@emilypotts5896 really she was obnoxious
I have social anxiety and during my audition I had to sing a really high note and I panicked and my voice cracked and then I had a panic attack and started crying and the director let me try again at the end :)
I got a good role but I still cringe thinking about it. Btw this was in march 😅
my ear itches intensely they weren’t auditioning for American idol, probably for a local production lol
Don't worry. I had a panic attack auditioning for my talent show in 8th grade, crying and voice cracks, the whole shebang. Most embarrassing part? I volunteered to go first. And I too, cringe at that memory.
I cried. Didn't get a part. Tried out for the play and because my friend wanted a part I knew I would get so I tried out for a different part and I didn't get cast as a talking part. Ended up quitting and idk if I'll do theatre when school starts again
@@nevergonnagivesomeofyouup7335 you should give it a chance, you could redeem yourself
@@bigdog3695 I'll probably do it but I just want to cut a toxic friend out of my life who pressured me into not trying out for her part. ( She kinda sucked btw she over did everything )
Tristan getting mad at the judges for 18 minutes
*18 minutes
@@oliverprince5530 thank you
@THE LUCKE CHARMER 😂 you're cool I just rounded
Ah yess the sweet, even 800
@@Trickster44 yess
Damn... I really wanted him to react to Ariel the holistic vocal coach
That had me dead 🤣
*"i'M a HoLiStIc VoCaL cOuCh"*
Dead
She’s a fake character anyway. She said so herself
‘I’m NoT A NuMbEr I’m A HuMaN BeInG’
the first girl is actually a good singer. simon literally doesn’t know what he’s talking about, i would listen to her all day.
He litterally owns one of the biggest record companies in the world. I think he does know what hes talking about
You do know that it was staged right? They were all acting
shariah mckenzie
stupid tings😋😋
first girl: *sings great*
judges: you dont have what we are looking for
second girl: *sings badly*
judges: you have to sing to be an american idol
?
alê ribeiro damn
They are all dumbasses tbh
American idol, then and now is centered around views.. I was going to audition for them here in August but the rules are insane and if you read about it, it’s crazy. You can be the best singer and not go through, you can be the worst singer and make it to the live shows. Before you even make it onto the tv screen, you have 4/5 auditions and they’re in front of the producers not the celebrity judges
“Don’t ask them because they don’t know” 😂
Tristan: Are you a bad singer? Get a vocal coach
Tristan: want to learn to start singing? Get a vocal coach
Tristan: want to improve your voice? Get a vocal coach
Tristan: Have you got cancer? Get a vocal coach!
Tristan: Literally dying? Get a vocal coach!
Hotel, trivago, get a vocal coach
ItsmeErritheFirst 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Tristan: dead? Get a vocal coach!
Homicidal liu Vocal Ghost lol
2:40 they really did that girl dirty with the dramatic music 😂
Thanks for the likes, it’s all I got going for me in life🙏
😂 it felt like a soap opera
It felt scripted lol
😂😭👍
I was only half watching but listening, and the first girl should definitely do voice acting! She has a lovely speaking voice!
The first woman was amazing, first off... but when she was leaving she reminded me of Lily in Hannah Montana when she’s like “I’m leaving... here I go.... halfway to the door... nearly there...” 😅
I feel like all the judges just go with what Simon says. The first girl wasn't that bad
Wasnt that bad?? Lol she was goooood
i mean simon says amirite
@@cassidy2098 Lol We figured out the whole formula for the show if Simon doesn't like you then no one can. They have just been playing Simon says this whole time. That joke actually made me laugh for quite a bit
It's the fox! P
Didn't really think she was unique though. Some of the Patreon people Tristan reacts to, aren't bad either, but they don't have that kind of radio voice where you could distinguish them from other artists.
He's so kind, instead of laughing or giving criticism he actually gave good advices, just love him 😍😍
That first girl was so good wtf kind of crack are the judges on???
Tristan telling people to get a vocal coach for 17 minutes
Oh no...I always find the second-hand embarrassment too bad to watch these.
Edit: Wow, thanks for the likes! I'm glad I'm not the only one 😂
And yes, I too have a TH-cam channel - if you would like to check it out then that would be very much appreciated ☺️
Me too! Sometimes it is so bad that I actually have to look away from the screen.
@@Opheliamamars Same!!
For real.. :')
I'm cringing the entire time it's awful but I can't stop watching
I usually just skip 10 seconds in so I'm at least at the end of the awful parts.
I’m living for Tristan dragging the show and the judges😂
The first clip....🙄 I felt like I wash watching a soap opera
Salena Adkins nice pun tehe
I was like, wow, she would be good, in a drama.
Same😂😂
she was actually good but a bit dramatic
Was*
I would like a compilation of Tristan singing in the beginning of his videos, and then listen to it when i’m trying to fall asleep
Yessss
i see u everywhere
Pourya Bigonah Haha I watch your videos!
@@arielalevi8535 u from israel?
@@mikaelap8792 yes
*Everybody minding their own business*
*Tristan on a megaphone:* THIS IS WHY YOU NEED A VOCAL COACH!
To the woman who did the weird hand movements.....James Charles is QUAKING 😂😂
Lmao 😂
😂😂😂
That first audition sounded really scripted 😂😂😂 the music certainly doesn’t help
All these damn “reality” shows are. Like Tristan said, it is a drama competition between people who can sing.
Savannah a lot of the bad or awkward auditions on AI are paid actors
He’s the brad mondo of singing and vocal coaching 😂
Lmao that's why I love them both
The first one was not bad but when she started her "inspiring speech" it got cringey
Braveheart is Quaking
Temmie164 I heard from the original video that she was (maybe not anymore) an actor.
It gave me secondhand embarrassment
Temmie164 and I have no clue if that was staged even 🤷🏼♀️
I was waiting for the first girl to say: "and scene, thank you"
Litterally the first girl was beautiful, had an AMAZING voice and courage, some people would probably think she was dramatic or something, but I think that’s so wrong, I think she stood up for herself in a very brave way😊❤️
I’m auditioning for American idol in September lol wish me luck
Girl I subscribed
Me too!
Jessica Alejandra
Good luck!!
Good luck Jessica ☺☺
Same , I'm kinda nervous tho
Tristan: singing in the style of "I hate Devon".
Hahahahahahahhahahahahah🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
FUCK YOU DEVON YOU PIECE OF SHI-
@@kimcollins702 stop lmao
i wonder if devon realises that every single person who watches tristan hates his guts
JustaLovelyFangirl NEVER GONNA STOP
The Voice is a much better competition IMO because they stick to and understand your style and actually give you MUSICAL advice instead of telling you what you need to look like and what kind of attitude you need.
Well the difference between american idol and the voice is there names but also american idol is for forming a star someone who looks and acts the part whereas the voice focuses on the voice not appearance making a star like that
people who can't sing:
tristan: "just take a vocal coach!"
siria. Uh-huh. What’s your point?
@@oldvlognewtricks He just gives out the same advice every time xP
@@suds-p Because there is no way to give generic advice when someone needs a lot of guidance to develop their voice. The less adept someone is at singing, the more they need personalised input and often reassurance.
'See your doctor' is also general advice, but still correct whatever is wrong with you medically.
I'm still not sure what OP's point is.
@@oldvlognewtricks That's fair. Wouldn't chalk up OP's point to more than commenting on the fact that he mentioned vocal coaches for almost every performance
Ashanti (the first girl) had been on the show before and made it far. That is why she didn't make it through- is because she didn't develop her own style or improve
Tenko_deserved_life 69 no one had provide any prove, if you don’t know what are you talking about just stop.
@@fuyoutube5708 Dude, you just have to watch it, it was like a fucking soap opera, no way in hell that was real
The first one sounded like Elsa with that "little" speech
The second girl though. Oop.. If you want to learn how to sing go to a vocal coach girl not American Idols 🙄🙈...
The first girl was so good she belongs on Broadway
Singers listening to their own voices to improve is the equivalent of digital artists flipping the canvas to look for mistakes. Thank you for coming to my TED Talk
The thing is, people have to understand that shows like American Idol are catered for ratings and ENTERTAINMENT, not talent. If talent is the only barometer for singing in American Idol, Tori Kelly would have either won the show long ago or at least gone quite far.
At least Tori Kelly succeeded way more than many contestants on these shows and even collaborated with Jacob Collier. That is a true testament of her great singing ability - someone in the class of Collier would not want to collaborate with mediocre singers :P
Timliu92 who tf is Jacob Collier?
Kurama XII a musical god
Couldn’t agree more !
This is how many times Tristan talked about getting a vocal coach
⬇️
new drinking game: take a shot every time Tristan says "vocal coach" 💀
Do you want us all to die?!
Is anyone else seeing Tristan's soft side in this video? he's sooo cutee
*is it just coincidence that I just spent the last week watching those bad auditions... Tristan did you just read my mind?*
Sofia Romberg SO DID I!!!
Yep, same xD
Me too!!!
Same!
I have the biggest flippin’ crush on you lol you’re so sweet and genuine. Your constructive criticism is so nice! 🖤😭
THE FIRST GIRL Her speaking voice is AMAZING LIKE LET IT GOOOOO LET IT GOOOO CANT HOLD IT BACK ANY MOREEEEEE
Ok the first one felt like idk she just sounded SO scripted. I'm not the only one for sure? Right?
Sometimes thay send payed actors in to audition for.... Dramatic affect? Idk but that's maybe why.
Right
Please react to the Holistic vocal coach Ariel. I think you're going to see her skills from academic perspective 😤😤
X factor > American idol
@@niamhrtditchfield2348 they both are shit
@@kousheesuman1719 yes but idol is more shit. X factor used to be kinda good
Tristan is so sweet he makes me think I can sing with lessons 😭😭😭😭
You can.
“You’re not a style of singing”
So true
Edit: thanks for the likes!
Judges hearing good singer:its not that good
Judges hearing a sad story:this is winner
Truth
tristan lowkey promoting his brand through the video. “find a good vocal coach”
MayMay's channel I started to wonder about whether this was really just a lowkey genius marketing video lol
Is it just me or the 1st clip looked like the girl was performing an act from a movie...It looked a scene from a movie
She’s probs a theatre kid
Its all illusion yeah a bratz movie teehee
no one:
literally no one:
not a single human:
*lOoK aT tHe FiRsT gIrLs VoIcE*
she starts talking like a disney star
i auditioned for AGT last December, it was such a weird, fake experience
liam even watching that show makes me cringe. You can tell it’s mostly fake
Don't leave us hanging like that, give us the weird story!!
HB I agree!
@@HB-ey2dk I agree too
Tell us the whole thing!!
Lemme save u 18 min
Tristan: Get a vocal coach
Sriyan Gaming
Haha. Lol thanks 😂
I want the first girl in a "where are they now?" segment...
Apparently she was an actress
The VOCALS at the start TRISTANNNN
Do more covers pleaseeee
Tristian should be a judge on these shows he would be wayyy better than all the celebs and actually give helpful advice to the ppl
Tristan should be a judge on American idol, he would be the only one to know what he’s talking about
Adam Lambert was good when he judged a season of idol auditions. Very constructive feedback from Adam.
Nah he wouldn't be entertaining enough, he's too nice
That 3rd girl is a comedian, Mary Roach, the whole thing was a bit. She even broke character and started laughing for a second around 16:59
Half of the bad
voices are hired for drama
its just nadia **pretends to be surprised**
How do you know? Is Mary Roach her real name?
@@goldenangele7913 she wrote a thing on reddit or some other forum that I remember reading
If she is acting she's amazing!!! I need to see her in movies!!
*BUT WHAT ABOUT ARIEL THE HOLISTIC VOCAL COACH*
Hahaha
YOU WANT TO HEAR SOME METALLLL
Bethany MacFarlane-Barrow YOU WANT TO HEAR ME *ROOOAR*
Yessssssss,people keep asking,he keeps ignoring them! I thought he was going to do it in this video:/
she was on x factor uk
Just discovered you and your channel and charm. You are awesome and real. Love your smile, and I love your interpretation and commentary. Very constructive. Thank you!
Simon is so rude. he has always been like that. He always gets away with it
It’s unnecessary and makes me want to lose respect.
Girl with flaws he is just like gordon ramsay... i love it😂
Chantal Prins but like Gordon makes comments though, like reasonable complaints. “It’s raw, it’s undercooked” he’s harsh but at least he has some type of feedback. Simon just says “you’re bad because you’re bad” I still love him but like he doesn’t give feedback
It’s for ratings lmao
It’s a show. Its what they’re told to do
I knew a girl who auditioned for Am Idol (a pretty decent R&B talent). Turns out, you don’t even get to see “The Judges” right off, you have to go through preliminary tryouts first. She got a No in the first round, but the guy next to her who was in a chicken costume obv just there for laughs got through. It’s an entertainment show, but one that doesn’t necessarily require singing.
"Your friends aren't really honest with you"
When I sing in front of my friend she tells me to shut up and that I sound like a sever rat-
Well at least she's being honest and not lying to you 🤣
His reactions are the best I swear. Also very humble!
IT'S A DRAMA COMPETITION BETWEEN PEOPLE WHO SING
-TRISTAN
The first girl is a good actor and singer lmao.
Dude, I love your profile pic and name. Im a severe Potterhead.⚡🏰🚂
What I’ve learned from this video, is that Tristan recommends getting a good vocal coach
I think Tristan is pop as a genre of music. He’s just so out there and really in your face
God how I love this comment
“In a way that’s not gonna crush your soul” made me laugh for some reason
Please react to Alec Benjamin! He's such a good underappreciated artist who deserves all the praise he can get. You and him even follow each other on Insta!
Yesss finally someone's rooting for my boy Alec too lol 🙌
Yass, Alec is incredible, love all his songs, and his voice is so special... He needs to react to him!
YASSS OMG
Ibk ikr
Ibk he’s so amazing, I’d love a reaction!!❤️
I've auditioned for AI a couple of times. Never made it through the first round. It's super hard to make it through these shoes. I have also tried AGT and The voice. Same thing. Super hard to get on. AI pulls people for shock and entertainment value though.
I only got to the second round and it's terrifying! But half these people don't deserve the chance. Good luck on your next audition!
Reality TV is all the same. American reality TV is one step crazier.
1st one pissed me off. A respectful, beautiful person who just came on the show looking for experience? I've seen these judges be nicer to people that are rude and disrespectful. Wow.
She got experience on the show twice before in previous seasons. She didn’t make it that far either time. And here she was trying to get on the show yet again. That’s why they didn’t let her through, not because she was bad.
Nobody:
Not a single soul:
Tristan: *face of disgust* yeah, she's got a pretty good voice in there