The chart at 0:22 is misleading. While it shows the U.S. has more migrants in total, it overlooks population size. For instance, Saudi Arabia's 13.5 million migrants make up nearly 40% of its population, and Germany's 15.8 million migrants constitute nearly 20%. In contrast, the U.S.'s 50.6 million migrants are only around 15% of its population.
This was proven to be faulty and lying number. It is from a GOP report which is known to fluff numbers. They literally said that teaching students who are poor in English cost $78 billion last year. That is a straight up lie with no source for that number. They keep citing "sources and reports" but never share what those sources and reports are.
Well according to FAIR a very far right conservative organization they cost US taxpayers $150 billion. And they contribute over $250 billion to the economy. Were you get those figures?
"It cites studies by the hawkish Center for Immigration Studies, which found that the annual cost to care for and house illegal immigrants #COULD reach up to $451 billion. It separately cites estimates from the Federation for American Immigration Reform, which advocates for lower immigration levels, that the annual net burden as of 2022 is more than $150 billion." Didn't want to tell the whole truth, huh?
this "source" says that teaching kids who don't know english very well in school costs Americans 78 billion dollars a year, like that's a real number....
@@SkywalkerDavis Is there something wrong with immigrating legally to a country? You must forgive me, whenever I've gone to someone else's country I always went into their country legally, respected their laws, and remembered that I was a guest in their country.
@DRJ-ytp well why my initial thought would be to say pay them more thats not always possible, I'd say it's one of those jobs where managment needs to change becuase they have made the employees miserable with too much micro managing over them so work sucks, and so that company needs to change how employees are treated during the workshift, also sounds like it might be a case where the pay sounds decent at first when an employee is hired but then the employee realizes they are doing the work of 2 employees and the company is being greedy, rather than pay more they need to hire more employees so each employee has less of a workload so they arnt frikken miserable, for example in construction you can't just pay hire wages and expect an employee to do twice the roofing and singling a person can only do so much, rather allot of employees i know would gladly accept a few dollars less to have HALF the workload put on them, thier body, the stress is too much at company i your area regardless of pay.
Why you call them immigrants. They are “illegal immigrants”. An immigrant can easily be misunderstood for someone here legally. Also when you compare illegal immigrants to “US born workers” this makes no sense. You should compare illegal immigrants with o US citizens which makes more sense. Your argument is good but it clearly emphasizes certain words that can make the average reader confused
You need a civic lesson. The correct term is undocumented immigrants not illegal immigrants. If you ever got a speeding ticket, you committed a misdemeanor thereby your terms you’re also an illegal criminal because that’s what an undocumented immigrant has committed, a misdemeanor. By the way, these immigrants are asylum seekers which is not illegal. I never believed in open borders. What Reagan did, forgiving millions of illegal immigrants, making them legal was wrong because it just encouraged the behavior and created a bigger problem, created an indentured servitude in this country for the oligarchs in this country. There was a correct way to bring immigrants to work the fields, the meat packing plants and hospitality jobs, which American workers refuse to do. That’s the H2a, H2B visas. They work for period of time, pay their taxes and go home. However, the Oligarchs would have to pay legal wages which they’re too greedy to do.
This is just a reminder that today you most likely ate something that went through the hands of an undocumented person. When they are gone, who will be working to feed you, and at what cost?
Democrats asked this same question when they didn't want to end slavery in America. Americans, need to start WORKING if they want to eat and stop supporting people who want to illegally come to this nation without going through the legal process like many legal citizens have done.
This video is disingenuous and incredibly bias. Also doesn’t talk about the financial and social hardships illegal immigration causes in American cities.
Then the best solution would be to present these people with a pathway to citizenship. Then they wont be undocumented and theyw ill be paying income tax. Win-Win for everybody.
@@PenguinTac0s The way our economy is constructed and human greed pushes these “slavery practices.” People often complain about the cost of living, are they willing to pay more for products because of their political beliefs?
Stop perpetuating the narrative that America depends on slave labor for its survival. Many countries don't use slaves, and they're just fine and have much lower cost of living.
@@SkywalkerDavisDon’t worry, that labor will be automated shortly. Some restaurants such as McDonald’s have been testing it out already. A $30 minimum wage would be a great incentive to push it out to more restaurants.
While Trump was denouncing illegal immigration in public, his company relied on undocumented immigrants: they built Trump's golf courses. Feel like Donny is dumping again?
@@agexien Ari Shapiro talks with former Trump National Golf Club employee Victorina Morales and her lawyer, Anibal Romero. They say the golf course knowingly hired undocumented workers and covered it up.
@@agexien This has been known for years, long before Trump entered politics. If you need evidence, you can find it online or, if ya like, reach out to a spokesperson for the Trump organization.
Between mass deportation and the imposition of tarifs, relief from rising prices will be short-lived. What a paradox considering it was the promise of lower costs that attracted many people to Trump.
@john15008 Trying to "Trim the FAT" of the government was a joke anyway considering the majority of America's spending is in entitlements. It's going to take hundreds of billions of dollars to remove these illegal immigrants over 10 years, which is basically another funded war over a decade ON TOP of the expenses of an approaching REAL WORLD WAR. Yeah..... it's over from a variety of angles.
You work for 42yrs to have $2m in your retirement, Meanwhile some people are putting just $20k in a meme coin for just few months and now they are multi millionaires. I pray that anyone who reads this will be successful in life
Well explain thank you for bringing up this video Financial education is indeed required for more than 80% of the society in the country as very few are literate on the subject. The value of the US🇺🇸dollar is declining due to inflation, but it is increasing in comparison to other currencies and commodities such as gold and real estate. I'm worried that rising inflation will cause my 550k in my retirement funds to lose value, But with the help of Mrs Maria I hit 220k this week from my investment of 45k, I am truly grateful for all the knowledge and nuggets you have given me over the past few months.
Stop perpetuating the narrative that America depends on slave labor for its survival. Many countries don't use slaves, and they're just fine and have much lower cost of living.
At the restaurant I once worked, illegal workers were making much more than me and were getting as twice as many hours because the employer didn't have to keep them below 40 hors to avoid paying them benefits, so they were making much more than me and were much likely to buy a house than their legal peers. I couldn't even afford a car with that job while all of them could.
This is why we have the homeless in the first place. All these survival jobs that can be used to help you get back on your feet are occupied by slaves.
That's a lie! They receive more money than legal Americans in forms of welfare. Some are getting $5K in food assistance, rental assistance, free cell phones, etc.
@Boxagami that is very cute. Even legal immigrants have very limited access to services they are taxed to fund. Even if they are eligible, the amount of documents they need to provide is disgusting amount.
@@zard1214Notice how you don't provide a pick of data or a source, legal immigrants don't ever make up 20% of the taxes paid in this country. You just keep making things up, even this video debunks that
Employers know what was coming and they should have prepared and it cost us more to take care of them. The employers must pay their employees and follow labor laws.
While Trump was denouncing illegal immigration in public, his company relied on undocumented immigrants: they built Trump's golf courses, got diapers yet?
Okay. How about it means that people must take accountability for entering an economy legally. We are not allowed to have modern day slaves. Have a social security number. Pay your taxes. Etc.
The largest occupational category for undocumented workers is the *service industry*, with 34 percent of the undocumented labor force employed in service jobs, followed by Management, Business, Science, and Arts (19 percent) and Natural Resources, Construction, and Maintenance (18 percent).
If he's successful the people better blame him, Ramaswamy House GOP and Senate GOP. Musk supported keep immigrants here from the get go so he gets a pass. These politicians refuse to change the laws into employers have to pay both domestic and immigrants the same wage, that would reduce the likelihood of a business hiring them over Americans. Immigrants should be allowed to unionize without penalty.
Imagine less people applying for your job; applying to live in your apartment; and less people competing with you over groceries…. The economy will boom..
@magicxsquare_ Or....imagine a economy in which it's adult population is aging and aren't reproducing enough to sustain their labor force. So a shrinking labor force as entitlements expenditure increase means YOU'RE IN TROUBLE.
Imagine millions of strange people running around next to your 5 yr old daughter, your wife, your mom. When they get arrested, the judges just let them out without consequences. So they revisit your daughter when she turns 10.
CNBC should be asking Trump and Musk WHY do they want to tank the American economy? What Trump wants to do is actually bad for the stock market. Everything will tank on the NYSE and Nasdaq and the other stock exchanges.
and cut it out with the BS fear mongering, the YOUNG people will come back into the workforce and spend money in the communities. How about you report on how many teens and people in their early 20s are unemployed right now?
Stop perpetuating the narrative that America depends on slave labor for its survival. Many countries don't use slaves, and they're just fine and have much lower cost of living.
If only they could get legal status overnight and pay taxes, that the proper way to not have irregular migrants and avoid a recession. But it's clear that improving the economy is not the idea behind this
and when your labor force continues to shrink due to a lack of reproduction as your working population ages and reaches retirement age increasing entitlements, would you support a economy collapse?
The economy will not be hitting hard, and only the businesses will be hitting hard. The total business money which these illegal immigrants in California is about 14 billion dollars, and to curb the illegal immigration, US spends about 130 billion dollars in California. So overall, economy is in loss and business is in profit which is short term .
Stop perpetuating the narrative that America depends on slave labor for its survival. Many countries don't use slaves, and they're just fine and have much lower cost of living.
Most won't stay. The work isn't worth the risk (i.e. $20 a day picking onions at 30 cents per 50 lb bag), get ready for your grocery prices to sky rocket to $5/onion, $15/lb of chicken...not to mention they are the bulk of construction workers after a natural disaster and why we see many states not rebuilt from last years destructions. Oh, L.A. will have a heck of a time rebuilding.
Stop perpetuating the narrative that America depends on slave labor for its survival. Many countries don't use slaves, and they're just fine and have much lower cost of living.
@@agexien Your elected officials poor spending habits and terrible foreign policy is why you'll NEVER see a lower cost of living. Stop trying to blame that on immigrants.
These bookworm arguments about inflation going up because of a lack of what should be illegal (cheap labor) have been constantly disproven by the fast food industry. Businesses will charge what they CAN regardless of their input costs. A textbook can’t run a business or a country.
Lets see how many Americans, line up to pick those tomatoes. My guess is zero, since they're outside is hot weather, don't get paid min. Wage, and zero benefits. Waste of tax payer money while increasing cost of good and shortages of food a trifecta. Glad I don't live in states seems overly expensive.
Stop perpetuating the narrative that America depends on slave labor for its survival. Many countries don't use slaves, and they're just fine and have much lower cost of living.
Legal immigration services is backed up for years and America is facing a labor shortage NOW in jobs Americans are too good for! Your nation's increasing interest payment on national debt means there's no room for a stalled economy. So, what's your solution?
@@plebbit You don't pay unskilled workers "fair wages". They have no technical or creative value. Anybody off the street can fill those laborer positions.
As a legal immigrant, the deportation of illegal immigrant makes sense. When someone just jumps a fence and starts demanding same rights as citizens, while people follow rules of the land, contribute to economy and taxes don't get those rights. I want to make sure the legal system is made better but if you break the law, you should get penalized for it.
Why do everyone in here pretend they know than the experts in the video ? Having said that i definitely think the border and immiy system do need some work. The currey situation is unsustainable.
People are willing to pay a price to have their nation and culture preserved. Next to deportations, the US should also make English the sole national language of the United States.
This video misses a lot Of key points.. but I will say stop saying the the jobs are not desirable and that nobody wants to work the truth is you guys shamed a lot of people for doing trade work (BLUE COLLAR WORK) told them they need to go to college and get into IT and now IT is being taken over by AI we have a lot of people that are unemployed with college degrees (DEBT)and you wanna pay them $14 an hour to work on the farm how about we get back into treating people like normal human beings paying a livable wage and also treating them how to work agriculture and construction start with the highschoolers trust me if we can get kids to stop worrying about TikTok and being streamers and get them to actually wanna do something that helps their community they will do it and if you saying that they don’t I can tell already that you don’t work with kids. Yall just wanna pay immigrants dirt rather than pay Americans livable wages to do the same work?
Democrats are essentially bringing back a form of economic exploitation by referring to illegal immigrants as "undocumented." When undocumented workers were deported in the past, such as during Eisenhower's administration, farmers adapted by investing in mechanized harvesting equipment, solving the labor problem without relying on cheap, exploitable labor. Similarly, industries like construction offer good-paying jobs that Americans are fully capable of doing. However, employers often choose to hire illegal workers because they can pay them significantly less, undermining wages and opportunities for American workers. This system not only exploits undocumented individuals but also harms the broader economy by suppressing fair wages and discouraging investment in sustainable labor solutions.
ok lets think about. we take to example 100k ppl catch em deport em . now we go to neightboor friendly country and saying, "here u have to take it?" now lets scale it higher maybe 1mio or 10.....
does whoopi goldberg's printing press produce all the counterfit $20 bills in the united states under motioned demurrer of overdue library fines to keep all people in their twenties out of the library ?
Who will do the jobs of these illegal immigrants that are doing arduous jobs like in agricultures? If you think the homeless people will do it, guess again! Homeless population uses being homeless as an excuse just to not work but expect handouts. They choose to stand by street lights holding up a signs, looking pitiful and desperate, hoping to get a handout by the passing cars. If TANGERINE wants to do something about homelessness, then put them to work in jobs that illegal immigrants were doing!
Stop perpetuating the narrative that America depends on slave labor for its survival. Many countries don't use slaves, and they're just fine and have much lower cost of living.
Solution in others conutry Inmigrants have permisssion only for the season agriculture,contruction,hotel,restaurant when season finish they go home according with these country the worker young people they can have babies in this country the only sign for work that America need it.
Democrats never wanted to end slavery dude. They asked the same questions about ending slavery and who would pick the food crops. Don't support slavery of illegals.
You're doing a fantastic job! Just a quick off-topic question: I have a SafePal wallet with USDT, and I have the seed phrase. (mistake turkey blossom warfare blade until bachelor fall squeeze today flee guitar). How should I go about transferring them to Binance?
I didn’t know this, but Nevada is open about spending money on illegal immigrants. They outright pay for their tuition if they are in the university, but not for US born students. My friend has to work 3 part time jobs to afford tuition and living expenses while illegal students in her class gets free ride.
I do agree the spending on illegals vs. citizens is dumb, but we do need them for the economy and some industries. This is going to hurt more then help, there needs to be thoughtful laws and programs, but unfortunately that not really what politics and the government is now days. Get ready for life in America to get much worse for about everybody.
This is all fine and dandy however this does beg the question: Will Americans come in and fill the gap in those industries working the low wages provided to immigrants with most likely little to no benefits and poor working conditions? My guess, probably not. We Americans would want a livable wage in these industries, with reasonable benefits, and safe working conditions, something that is already in decline any how. With that said, it would come at cost with higher cost of living and not to mention the astronomical cost to detain immigrants to deport them. Just my two cents whatever that is worth.
Stop perpetuating the narrative that America depends on slave labor for its survival. Many countries don't use slaves, and they're just fine and have much lower cost of living.
The chart at 0:22 is misleading. While it shows the U.S. has more migrants in total, it overlooks population size. For instance, Saudi Arabia's 13.5 million migrants make up nearly 40% of its population, and Germany's 15.8 million migrants constitute nearly 20%. In contrast, the U.S.'s 50.6 million migrants are only around 15% of its population.
04:04 - Illegals pay 96.7B in taxes but they cost cost taxpayers $451 billion per year.
Source: Committee on Homeland Security.
And u heard this from infowar?
This was proven to be faulty and lying number. It is from a GOP report which is known to fluff numbers. They literally said that teaching students who are poor in English cost $78 billion last year. That is a straight up lie with no source for that number. They keep citing "sources and reports" but never share what those sources and reports are.
Well according to FAIR a very far right conservative organization they cost US taxpayers $150 billion. And they contribute over $250 billion to the economy. Were you get those figures?
"It cites studies by the hawkish Center for Immigration Studies, which found that the annual cost to care for and house illegal immigrants #COULD reach up to $451 billion. It separately cites estimates from the Federation for American Immigration Reform, which advocates for lower immigration levels, that the annual net burden as of 2022 is more than $150 billion."
Didn't want to tell the whole truth, huh?
this "source" says that teaching kids who don't know english very well in school costs Americans 78 billion dollars a year, like that's a real number....
America is a country, not a labor market.
What a ridiculous comment. Do you even know how your economy works?
What happened to "we voted for Trump because he's a business man"? 😂
Country and labor market aren’t mutually exclusive.
@@SkywalkerDavis Is there something wrong with immigrating legally to a country? You must forgive me, whenever I've gone to someone else's country I always went into their country legally, respected their laws, and remembered that I was a guest in their country.
Every illegal deported means 1 more job for an American. Thats what it means.
You are not that smart obviously
In my area, companies keep trying to hire local workers but have problems with absenteeism, high turnover, etc. What’s your solution to that issue?
@@DRJ-ytpu let the market do what its supposed to do. Iether pay more or go out of business
@DRJ-ytp well why my initial thought would be to say pay them more thats not always possible, I'd say it's one of those jobs where managment needs to change becuase they have made the employees miserable with too much micro managing over them so work sucks, and so that company needs to change how employees are treated during the workshift, also sounds like it might be a case where the pay sounds decent at first when an employee is hired but then the employee realizes they are doing the work of 2 employees and the company is being greedy, rather than pay more they need to hire more employees so each employee has less of a workload so they arnt frikken miserable, for example in construction you can't just pay hire wages and expect an employee to do twice the roofing and singling a person can only do so much, rather allot of employees i know would gladly accept a few dollars less to have HALF the workload put on them, thier body, the stress is too much at company i your area regardless of pay.
It's fine; a lot of MAGA want these jobs. So, they will be filled and they will spend more when not living off gov assistance. lol
😂😂😂
I need some maga to come do my garden every week. Asap
Derrr that good one! You gradiate from them fancy LA county high schools?
*de tuk er jerrrbs* !!!
MAGAs don’t work…..why do you think 🤔 they have time for the Rallies
Trumps all talk. These politicians don’t give af about you guys.
Just like you all talk on comment
We know Trump don’t care ……I didn’t Vote for the Toad 🐸🐸🐸
Get ready for cost of living to go up AGAIN
That is nonsense
@@5818fa1ah yes, let's expect european decendants working in tech to go work farm jobs. Lol
i'm willing to pay more.
If that's nonsense my friend than I invite you to go pick fields and dig ditches for the same amount they get paid
Plan 2025 in effect
Why you call them immigrants.
They are “illegal immigrants”. An immigrant can easily be misunderstood for someone here legally.
Also when you compare illegal immigrants to “US born workers” this makes no sense. You should compare illegal immigrants with o US citizens which makes more sense.
Your argument is good but it clearly emphasizes certain words that can make the average reader confused
What do yo expect from corporate media? They are the PR department of Shareholder Supremacy.
You need a civic lesson. The correct term is undocumented immigrants not illegal immigrants. If you ever got a speeding ticket, you committed a misdemeanor thereby your terms you’re also an illegal criminal because that’s what an undocumented immigrant has committed, a misdemeanor. By the way, these immigrants are asylum seekers which is not illegal. I never believed in open borders. What Reagan did, forgiving millions of illegal immigrants, making them legal was wrong because it just encouraged the behavior and created a bigger problem, created an indentured servitude in this country for the oligarchs in this country. There was a correct way to bring immigrants to work the fields, the meat packing plants and hospitality jobs, which American workers refuse to do. That’s the H2a, H2B visas. They work for period of time, pay their taxes and go home. However, the Oligarchs would have to pay legal wages which they’re too greedy to do.
We are all illegal immigrants who stole the land from the indigenous people of this land.
Crimigrants
This is just a reminder that today you most likely ate something that went through the hands of an undocumented person. When they are gone, who will be working to feed you, and at what cost?
The homie Jesus picked it with pride!
man thats racist, thats what you think of illegals
I live in Arizona most of my food comes from Mexico.
Democrats asked this same question when they didn't want to end slavery in America. Americans, need to start WORKING if they want to eat and stop supporting people who want to illegally come to this nation without going through the legal process like many legal citizens have done.
@@Boxagami No one is going to work for 9$ an hour in a field. Youre psychotic
This video is disingenuous and incredibly bias. Also doesn’t talk about the financial and social hardships illegal immigration causes in American cities.
Very liberal video that pushes pro slavery rhetoric
Then the best solution would be to present these people with a pathway to citizenship. Then they wont be undocumented and theyw ill be paying income tax. Win-Win for everybody.
@@PenguinTac0s The way our economy is constructed and human greed pushes these “slavery practices.” People often complain about the cost of living, are they willing to pay more for products because of their political beliefs?
@@madinkan there’s already a path to citizenship if they do it the right way
CNBC is and always a anti-Trump channel.
deportation would hurt more then help
Stop perpetuating the narrative that America depends on slave labor for its survival. Many countries don't use slaves, and they're just fine and have much lower cost of living.
Trump better strive to pay 30$ an hour for people in the food industry.
☝️☝️☝️ASAP
Why ? That is nonsensicle.
Otherwise, you support slavery of illegals, RIGHT?
@ryanvazquez2301 Unskilled workers don't deserve $30 an hour.
@@SkywalkerDavisDon’t worry, that labor will be automated shortly. Some restaurants such as McDonald’s have been testing it out already. A $30 minimum wage would be a great incentive to push it out to more restaurants.
While Trump was denouncing illegal immigration in public, his company relied on undocumented immigrants: they built Trump's golf courses. Feel like Donny is dumping again?
where is your evidence?
@@agexien Ari Shapiro talks with former Trump National Golf Club employee Victorina Morales and her lawyer, Anibal Romero. They say the golf course knowingly hired undocumented workers and covered it up.
@@agexien This has been known for years, long before Trump entered politics. If you need evidence, you can find it online or, if ya like, reach out to a spokesperson for the Trump organization.
One immediate effect of this is the American workers will get the wages we deserve instead of paying migrants under the table
Who going to pick up your fruit and vegetables
Ah yes, mega corps love giving Americans raises.
@@JorgeGomez-c2f Even arab countries are doing fine with legal immigration.
@leos1023 Sorry bubba, your money will continue to devalue the more your government spends and "WHAT YOU DESERVE" isn't realistic.
cite evidence that the low paid jobs they do will cause your wage to go up!
Consider the massive reduction in welfare, food stamps, crime. The future is looking positive for USA.
"illegals" don't get welfare or food stamps. MAGAs commit more crime than any undocu.
The US government are the no 1 criminals in the world 😂
Illegal immigrants do not qualify for welfare, foodstamps, and they contribute less crime per capita (barring the fact that they entered illegally).
❤❤❤❤❤
Between mass deportation and the imposition of tarifs, relief from rising prices will be short-lived. What a paradox considering it was the promise of lower costs that attracted many people to Trump.
MAGA is too stupid to understand your comment
@john15008 Trying to "Trim the FAT" of the government was a joke anyway considering the majority of America's spending is in entitlements. It's going to take hundreds of billions of dollars to remove these illegal immigrants over 10 years, which is basically another funded war over a decade ON TOP of the expenses of an approaching REAL WORLD WAR. Yeah..... it's over from a variety of angles.
You work for 42yrs to have $2m in your retirement, Meanwhile some people are putting just $20k in a meme coin for just few months and now they are multi millionaires. I pray that anyone who reads this will be successful in life
Well explain thank you for bringing up this video
Financial education is indeed required for more than 80% of the society in the country as very few are literate on the subject. The value of the US🇺🇸dollar is declining due to inflation, but it is increasing in comparison to other currencies and commodities such as gold and real estate. I'm worried that rising inflation will cause my 550k in my retirement funds to lose value, But with the help of Mrs Maria I hit 220k this week from my investment of 45k, I am truly grateful for all the knowledge and nuggets you have given me over the past few months.
Maria davis program is widely available online..
How
..? Am a newbie in crypto investment, please can you guide me through on how you made profit?
I'm glad to write her tay I do hope she will help handle my paycheck properly
Can I start with as low as $1000
Wall Street and business leaders better wake tf up and NOW!!
Stop perpetuating the narrative that America depends on slave labor for its survival. Many countries don't use slaves, and they're just fine and have much lower cost of living.
can we focus on the humanitarian parolees and crime committing illegal immigrants first please?
His mass deportations have nothing to do with looking out for Americans this is all about looking out for his wealthy billionaires.
I actually like to see how American people do the landscape job and how well they do. So we can compare the quality of it.
Millions of people across the country do their own landscaping. Just say you're lazy
Almost every landscapers I have seen are Hispanic. I don't remember seeing any Caucasians at all.
That one racist comment there buddy? What a shame Americans can't do landscaping?
US citizens do do landscaping.
Always some Chang or Chicano crying on deportation videos 😭🤧🤧☔️
JD Vance thinking illegal immigrants buy houses instead of build them is probably the dumbest thing he’s ever said or maybe even thought
At the restaurant I once worked, illegal workers were making much more than me and were getting as twice as many hours because the employer didn't have to keep them below 40 hors to avoid paying them benefits, so they were making much more than me and were much likely to buy a house than their legal peers. I couldn't even afford a car with that job while all of them could.
You not make no sense. You ancient Chinese bot?
There is an army of homeless people in the US who should step to fill any voids in the unskilled labor market!
This is why we have the homeless in the first place. All these survival jobs that can be used to help you get back on your feet are occupied by slaves.
@@agexien Are you a bot?
They aren't here legally. Do we have laws or not?
Exactly!!!
❤❤❤❤
I rather pay double to not see even one illegal immigrant.
Exactly!!! Many countries don't use slaves, and they're just fine and have much lower cost of living.
He won't. They pay taxes but barely take advantage of public services.
That's a lie! They receive more money than legal Americans in forms of welfare. Some are getting $5K in food assistance, rental assistance, free cell phones, etc.
Somebody has been lying to you.
@Boxagami that is very cute. Even legal immigrants have very limited access to services they are taxed to fund. Even if they are eligible, the amount of documents they need to provide is disgusting amount.
@@5818fa1it's true. They're still paying taxes like FICA and gas taxes.
@@zard1214Notice how you don't provide a pick of data or a source, legal immigrants don't ever make up 20% of the taxes paid in this country. You just keep making things up, even this video debunks that
Employers know what was coming and they should have prepared and it cost us more to take care of them. The employers must pay their employees and follow labor laws.
Continous misrepresentation illegals not illegals
4:45 Taking everything the Heritage Foundation ghoul says at face value? This video is a joke.
it means los angeles and california will be shifted to greenland
While Trump was denouncing illegal immigration in public, his company relied on undocumented immigrants: they built Trump's golf courses, got diapers yet?
Okay. How about it means that people must take accountability for entering an economy legally. We are not allowed to have modern day slaves. Have a social security number. Pay your taxes. Etc.
Exactly!!!
The largest occupational category for undocumented workers is the *service industry*, with 34 percent of the undocumented labor force employed in service jobs, followed by Management, Business, Science, and Arts (19 percent) and Natural Resources, Construction, and Maintenance (18 percent).
If he's successful the people better blame him, Ramaswamy House GOP and Senate GOP.
Musk supported keep immigrants here from the get go so he gets a pass.
These politicians refuse to change the laws into employers have to pay both domestic and immigrants the same wage, that would reduce the likelihood of a business hiring them over Americans.
Immigrants should be allowed to unionize without penalty.
You're not current on the news. The only immigrants that Musk likes are the H-1B visa holders. He's ok with deporting ALL other immigrants.
right
in another news: *Mar A Lago looses 90% of its staff*
😂All these Rich People Employ them ….poor people don’t hire them- that’s for sure 🤔🤔
USA can do fine with legal immigration as arab countries do , they make large part of workforce there .
Imagine less people applying for your job; applying to live in your apartment; and less people competing with you over groceries….
The economy will boom..
100% facts. Dont forget less people straining the economy through hospital visits paid for by taxpayers as well as welfare programs
@magicxsquare_ Or....imagine a economy in which it's adult population is aging and aren't reproducing enough to sustain their labor force. So a shrinking labor force as entitlements expenditure increase means YOU'RE IN TROUBLE.
Imagine millions of strange people running around next to your 5 yr old daughter, your wife, your mom. When they get arrested, the judges just let them out without consequences. So they revisit your daughter when she turns 10.
What jobs? As a janitor, farm worker, brick layer? Are you going to do any of those jobs cause I damn sure am not.
@@user-7bz31a20 Xenophobia at it's finest.
"We need to exploit them for cheap labor"
❤❤
This is the the beginning of the end.
Agreed!
This will have a massive effect on the US economy....
@@yesolue and you'd think the Americans would know better
CNBC should be asking Trump and Musk WHY do they want to tank the American economy? What Trump wants to do is actually bad for the stock market. Everything will tank on the NYSE and Nasdaq and the other stock exchanges.
Maybe you'd feel more cozy in Beijing, where others are just like you and accept everything they're told?
Glenn Greenwald - Trump landslide Win explained
and cut it out with the BS fear mongering, the YOUNG people will come back into the workforce and spend money in the communities. How about you report on how many teens and people in their early 20s are unemployed right now?
They won't do that type of work
Exactly!!!
The Mexican get 350 a week plus free food and housing and healthcare! I don’t get that much how can this be ??
Simon looks well suited for picking grapes.
Now we migrants to rebuild LA.
Stop perpetuating the narrative that America depends on slave labor for its survival. Many countries don't use slaves, and they're just fine and have much lower cost of living.
If only they could get legal status overnight and pay taxes, that the proper way to not have irregular migrants and avoid a recession. But it's clear that improving the economy is not the idea behind this
Will melania get deported as well ?
She is a legal immigrant, so it wouldn’t affect her
bad :)
Does Melania compete with you for a janitor job?
I'm not a republican but I fully support them with their stance on illegal immigration. ENOUGH IS ENOUGH!
and when your labor force continues to shrink due to a lack of reproduction as your working population ages and reaches retirement age increasing entitlements, would you support a economy collapse?
@@SkywalkerDavis Automation is destroying the labor force anyways
@@TheMurliprasad Automation increases productivity, making products and services cheaper. Creative destruction is apart of the process of innovation.
@@SkywalkerDavis For that reason young Americans should be given incentives to get married and procreate. If it comes to banning abortion, so be it.
The economy will not be hitting hard, and only the businesses will be hitting hard.
The total business money which these illegal immigrants in California is about 14 billion dollars, and to curb the illegal immigration, US spends about 130 billion dollars in California.
So overall, economy is in loss and business is in profit which is short term .
Next they will complain about housing and food prices or reductions in SS
Stop perpetuating the narrative that America depends on slave labor for its survival. Many countries don't use slaves, and they're just fine and have much lower cost of living.
Most won't stay. The work isn't worth the risk (i.e. $20 a day picking onions at 30 cents per 50 lb bag), get ready for your grocery prices to sky rocket to $5/onion, $15/lb of chicken...not to mention they are the bulk of construction workers after a natural disaster and why we see many states not rebuilt from last years destructions. Oh, L.A. will have a heck of a time rebuilding.
Stop perpetuating the narrative that America depends on slave labor for its survival. Many countries don't use slaves, and they're just fine and have much lower cost of living.
@@agexien Your elected officials poor spending habits and terrible foreign policy is why you'll NEVER see a lower cost of living. Stop trying to blame that on immigrants.
These bookworm arguments about inflation going up because of a lack of what should be illegal (cheap labor) have been constantly disproven by the fast food industry. Businesses will charge what they CAN regardless of their input costs. A textbook can’t run a business or a country.
Lets see how many Americans, line up to pick those tomatoes. My guess is zero, since they're outside is hot weather, don't get paid min. Wage, and zero benefits. Waste of tax payer money while increasing cost of good and shortages of food a trifecta. Glad I don't live in states seems overly expensive.
So cool ! we need this urgently in Europe !
Small price to pay for a storage problem.
What does it mean? Hundreds of billions of dollars spent for a campaign promise that will NEVER be achieved.
I dont invest in the absurdity of Trump. The town drunk, mentally ill person...makes more sense.
Wonder how long Americans will last picking grapes.
Stop perpetuating the narrative that America depends on slave labor for its survival. Many countries don't use slaves, and they're just fine and have much lower cost of living.
So you are saying is that less illegals means less inflation?
I love how they keep saying “these companies can lose their immigrant workers” …. Nope, their ILLEGAL immigrant workers
Legal immigration services is backed up for years and America is facing a labor shortage NOW in jobs Americans are too good for! Your nation's increasing interest payment on national debt means there's no room for a stalled economy. So, what's your solution?
Good now pay should increase
Exactly!!!
@hectortoledo5914 Because Americans are all fighting over those prosperous positions in field work, construction and hospitality, right? 😂
@@SkywalkerDavis They would be if those careers paid a fair market wage instead of being staffed by indentured servants being underpaid.
@@plebbit What's a fair wage for a laborer position that doesn't require a certificate or a degree?
@@plebbit You don't pay unskilled workers "fair wages". They have no technical or creative value. Anybody off the street can fill those laborer positions.
“Unauthorized immigrants”? Absolute clown show. 😂😂
They're not authorized
As a legal immigrant, the deportation of illegal immigrant makes sense. When someone just jumps a fence and starts demanding same rights as citizens, while people follow rules of the land, contribute to economy and taxes don't get those rights. I want to make sure the legal system is made better but if you break the law, you should get penalized for it.
Make America Mexico again ❤
Why do everyone in here pretend they know than the experts in the video ? Having said that i definitely think the border and immiy system do need some work. The currey situation is unsustainable.
I think we need to do what we need to do in 2025 ‼️
The fact that nobody talks about the forbidden book called The Gilded Nexus of Prosperity speaks volumes about how people are stuck in a trance
I used some techniques from that book to make money, and I can truly say I'm earning more now
I know about that book, my father told me about it
I can't find the book on Amazon. Do you have a direct link, Andrew Tate?
@@HuyNguyen-nc1twjust type the title in google search
Aww yes and because you aren't because you simply read something
People are willing to pay a price to have their nation and culture preserved. Next to deportations, the US should also make English the sole national language of the United States.
This video misses a lot
Of key points.. but I will say stop saying the the jobs are not desirable and that nobody wants to work the truth is you guys shamed a lot of people for doing trade work (BLUE COLLAR WORK) told them they need to go to college and get into IT and now IT is being taken over by AI we have a lot of people that are unemployed with college degrees (DEBT)and you wanna pay them $14 an hour to work on the farm how about we get back into treating people like normal human beings paying a livable wage and also treating them how to work agriculture and construction start with the highschoolers trust me if we can get kids to stop worrying about TikTok and being streamers and get them to actually wanna do something that helps their community they will do it and if you saying that they don’t I can tell already that you don’t work with kids. Yall just wanna pay immigrants dirt rather than pay Americans livable wages to do the same work?
"Laws for thee but not for me"
The next 4 years
Democrats are essentially bringing back a form of economic exploitation by referring to illegal immigrants as "undocumented." When undocumented workers were deported in the past, such as during Eisenhower's administration, farmers adapted by investing in mechanized harvesting equipment, solving the labor problem without relying on cheap, exploitable labor. Similarly, industries like construction offer good-paying jobs that Americans are fully capable of doing. However, employers often choose to hire illegal workers because they can pay them significantly less, undermining wages and opportunities for American workers. This system not only exploits undocumented individuals but also harms the broader economy by suppressing fair wages and discouraging investment in sustainable labor solutions.
Exactly!!! Many countries don't use slaves, and they're just fine and have much lower cost of living.
ok lets think about. we take to example 100k ppl catch em deport em . now we go to neightboor friendly country and saying, "here u have to take it?"
now lets scale it higher maybe 1mio or 10.....
⭐️
let’s go trump
You'll be crying in less than a year because you're a plebe.
Go where ?
Nice
does whoopi goldberg's printing press produce all the counterfit $20 bills in the united states under motioned demurrer of overdue library fines to keep all people in their twenties out of the library ?
Phoenix AZ is about to be amazing. just need to get the Californians out of here next
FAFO baby
Who will do the jobs of these illegal immigrants that are doing arduous jobs like in agricultures? If you think the homeless people will do it, guess again! Homeless population uses being homeless as an excuse just to not work but expect handouts. They choose to stand by street lights holding up a signs, looking pitiful and desperate, hoping to get a handout by the passing cars. If TANGERINE wants to do something about homelessness, then put them to work in jobs that illegal immigrants were doing!
Stop perpetuating the narrative that America depends on slave labor for its survival. Many countries don't use slaves, and they're just fine and have much lower cost of living.
Solution in others conutry Inmigrants have permisssion only for the season agriculture,contruction,hotel,restaurant when season finish they go home according with these country the worker young people they can have babies in this country the only sign for work that America need it.
Trump hasn't changed at all. Trump talks and dreams stupidly big, always.
Let's learn the hard way!
Democrats never wanted to end slavery dude. They asked the same questions about ending slavery and who would pick the food crops. Don't support slavery of illegals.
they'll eventually go after legal immigrants too.
You're doing a fantastic job! Just a quick off-topic question: I have a SafePal wallet with USDT, and I have the seed phrase. (mistake turkey blossom warfare blade until bachelor fall squeeze today flee guitar). How should I go about transferring them to Binance?
Such a hateful country
I didn’t know this, but Nevada is open about spending money on illegal immigrants. They outright pay for their tuition if they are in the university, but not for US born students. My friend has to work 3 part time jobs to afford tuition and living expenses while illegal students in her class gets free ride.
I do agree the spending on illegals vs. citizens is dumb, but we do need them for the economy and some industries. This is going to hurt more then help, there needs to be thoughtful laws and programs, but unfortunately that not really what politics and the government is now days. Get ready for life in America to get much worse for about everybody.
This is all fine and dandy however this does beg the question: Will Americans come in and fill the gap in those industries working the low wages provided to immigrants with most likely little to no benefits and poor working conditions? My guess, probably not. We Americans would want a livable wage in these industries, with reasonable benefits, and safe working conditions, something that is already in decline any how. With that said, it would come at cost with higher cost of living and not to mention the astronomical cost to detain immigrants to deport them. Just my two cents whatever that is worth.
Your followup video for this should read, "Now Hiring-USA"
Stop perpetuating the narrative that America depends on slave labor for its survival. Many countries don't use slaves, and they're just fine and have much lower cost of living.
Chloe's vocal fry is annoying.
That vocal fry screams "I'm a strong woman who doesn't need a man". In other words, pure arrogance and d!ckheadedness.
Exactly!!!
@agexien lol by complaining we can defeat this phenomenon!
$30 for food workers? How about you learn a trade or go to school 🙄🙄
The 30$ an hour could pay for both of those things . ... Even with scholarships you still have other things you might need for school 🎒📓📓📚📖
MAGA