Conversation with a Shia Sister | Ustadh Hassan Shemrani
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 13 ธ.ค. 2024
- Ustadh Hassan Shemrani responds to questions from a Shia sister about tawhid during a live Clubhouse session.
Don't forget to comment, like and subscribe. Turn notifications on to make sure you don't miss our latest content.
Our website: www.twelvershia...
Twitter: @SunnahDiscourse
Facebook: Facebook.com/SunnahDiscourse
TikTok: @sunnidefense
Instagram: sunni.defense
You can now financially support us via our GoFundMe campaign:
www.gofundme.c...
![ค้าง (STILL) - GEMINI [ OFFICIAL MV ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Ftxx3hk5vkU/mqdefault.jpg)
The shia sister appears to be forthright and honest. I believe she's seeking the truth. May Allah (swt) guide her and others like her.
@@Shah_007_01 okay grave worshipper
Write out the abbreviation.
Hindus too say they don’t worship idols.
We can talk all day with sincere shia, they deserve to know the truth. There are some shia scholars even who atleast gave up shirk and biddah according to pre safavi traditions. Change happens slowly.
May Allah guide her completely to His true deen
Shia men need this level of patience to learn or discuss anything like this sister. Amazing she is in her scholarly behaviour of adking a question and then having laser focus.
non taqiyah shi'a women hate shi'a men, apostasy is high and int he west they want to leave tehm... they see true Islam from Sunnis and get shocked!
The Shia laymen is more intellectual than their scholars. Most of their laypeople don’t know what their scholars actually believe, they just think they “love Ali”.
Alhamdolillah- what an intelligent question and an equally intelligent answer. Love the ummah for the sake of Allah SWT ❤️
Very articulate response by ustadh shemrani. I hope many shias watch this. JazakumAllah Khair.
@@rahmtube2885
1. ذكر عليا العبادة - this hadith is a fabrication, not a sahih hadith! Dhikr of Allah is 'ibadah, not that of the creation, you mushrik.
2. Our salawat are send to the Prophet (saws) via an angel, we pray TO Allah FOR the Prophet (saws), we don't pray TO the Prophet (saws) asking him for madad.
May ALLAH GIVE ARE SHIA BROTHERS AND SISTER HIDAYAT & COME TO SUNAT OF MOHOMMED SWS WAY
اللهم بارك فيكم و يزيدكم في علمك
A very vibrant and beautiful thumbnail
The reason why calling upon other than Allah is shirk is because when u call upon someone who is not present it means you believe they are ALL HEARING and ALL SEEING and can hear the whispers of a million people in their hearts at the same time, this quality is for Allah ALONE.
What you said is wrong. If one was to call upon a saint, that does not mean they have to be all-hearing and all-seeing. For example, I could say that Allah causes them to hear my call. Now, you can say that this is mistaken and baseless, but it is not Shirk according to your argument.
@@ibmsulaymani "They ask for needs which require divine power"
Everything requires divine power. So, by this logic, asking assistance from anyone would be Shirk, since anything any creature does to help requires divine power.
So, I have a question for you: when does asking assistance become Shirk? Does become Shirk when the one asked does not have the ability to help?
@@anonymousperson1904 so u have just said they are all hearing and all seeing but Allah gave them that power, firstly u have to prove that Allah did in fact give them that power. Secondly, if we go by your logic then there is no limit as to the superpowers we can attribute to any Tom, Dick and Harry aslong as we add the clause ' by Allahs permission'
Istighatha is not only shirk in Uloohiya but also shirk in asma wa sifaat. Whether one can hear or not, we cannot ask for something which only Allah can do. E.g. only Allah can help outside of apparent 'Asbaab'. Even if a person is alive, you cannot ask them for something only Allah can help with e.g. asking for children, asking for istighfar, asking for rain. That is worship.
@@mesutozil7903 I didn't say that they were all hearing or all-seeing. I said that Allah causes them to hear my specific call. This is not the same as hearing absolutely everything. Similar to how all Muslims believe that wherever you are, if you send salaam on the prophet, it will reach him.
And just as a side point, we don't believe that Allah is a physical being that receives sound waves. This would mean that He is passive and affected by creation. Rather, we believe that for Allah to be all-hearing is for Him to know all audible things, and for Him to cause all sounds.
"firstly u have to prove that Allah did in fact give them that power"
No, because that's not the point. Like I said, you can say that this belief is mistaken and baseless, but that does't mean it's Shirk.
"if we go by your logic then there is no limit as to the superpowers we can attribute to any Tom, Dick and Harry aslong as we add the clause ' by Allahs permission'"
No, there are certain things exclusive to Allah, such as creation, or knowledge of the reality of the divine essence etc. And again, to say things have superpowers is not Shirk. If I said x person can fly, this is a wrong and false belief, but it is not Shirk.
Why are Shias always trying to justify asking other than Allah SWT for help?? What has the ummah come to.
@Dark_Lord, I would suggest you get a better understanding of the Sunni position on this by actually looking at what the Ulema actually say on this. You seem to have a warped view of it. As if the Quran is a person. It's not that at all. It's that your reading it will be what intercedes for you. Again look up actual shuyook and what they say. Not what apparently is your wrong view.
Its not even asking them for help the whole issue is that Sunnis make up their own concept of Shia's. Its asking help to Allah directly through those that are most beloved to Allah. If this my brothers and sisters is Shirk then so is someone else making dua for you on your behalf. And Allah knows best!
@@kaskovic1993 how can u ask for help from dead person and how are you different from christians. Ask help from Allah only not his creation.
As far as the language thing, Tawasil (intercession) is basically done in Arabic, the actual official dua tawasil is of course done in Arabic, and there is also a belief of simply sending greetings to the person with the understanding that of course the greeting is always returned, so at the most basic level you can say salaam alaykum ya hazrat Zahra or Ali etc. also, the idea is not that they necessarily have any specific power to answer prayers or to convey a message like a secretary, the idea of the intercession is asking them to pray for you with the understanding that they have a very lofty status due to their righteousness, etc., like in the same way that you could ask any person that you know to remember you in their prayers, that’s the idea. Plus, beyond that at the very highest levels, it transcends such things, it’s not about asking for a specific desire to be fulfilled or anything like that, it’s about an opportunity for and connection, for that matter, even when we are praying to God, the suffocation at the highest level has absolutely nothing to do with requesting specific things, it is only an opportunity to become focused and close to the divine and become overwhelmed with the greatness of God and such.
Jazak Allahu khayr
We need more of these Q&A session! please do more of these and record them and upload them here. A great convo! please keep up the great work
I couldn't agree more
@@rahmtube2885 Get away Rafeda
@@rahmtube2885 maybe if you watched the full video, he clearly explained your points
What is the discord server
So could we just have conversations with Ustadh, what platform is this on?
Asalamuailaykum good work
Okay serious question. Does saying O Allah (SWT) in the name of your Prophet (s) (who you've sent to manking as a guide) forgive my sins count a shirk? Or does it fall in the same category as "for the sake of the Ahl al Bayt as Hassan mentioned? 13:30
Assalaamu alaikum guys I’m first
What i am trying to understand is what the Sister mend with the event in Mi'raaj ,which is full of ghaib and a special event , with to invoking ( IstiGhaatha ) Others then Allah Azza wa Djall ?. And This is the problem i think they make Inferences that do not really fit.
They are naive. They blind follow ayatoilets.
@@rahmtube2885 you should not come with made up Hadeeth ! worshipping other then Allah is Shirk , and you want to say that the Prophet (Alaihi Assalaatu wa Assalaam) said it !! try again and come with some solid proves ( from the Qur'an ) without calling names please .
As-salamu alaykum
Jazaak'Allahu Khayran 💕
Allah has given the task to mikhail to regulate rain but we don't ask for rain directly from mikhail we ask Allah. The point here is even if prophets and messengers have been given the ability to help us we can't ask for help from them.
Where is Shemrani bto in a recent time?
Even shias read la haula wala quwaa...then don't they understand? None has power except him?
The shia sister needs to ask the same question to Dr Syed Ammar Nakshawani and find out his answer.
I seen in a old video, he gave the same answer, if you want I can find it, Inshallah, it was on the topic of jinns i think and he discussed shirk, but we make dua only to Allah, no one else, I'm a Shia myself, and not all of us make direct dua to Ali, only Allah. I am still researching Shia and Sunni, please make dua for me brother
@@Shah_007_01 well I've been shia...and I don't like the idea of shiasm that everyone... except shia will burn in hell for eternity.....even the other sects of muslims....that doesn't makes any sense....how can someone who worships allah will go to hell.... that's an absurd ideology of shiaism
The man isn't educated. I've watched a few of his videos and like Yasser khabith, he makes illogical statements and false historical statements
@@user-vc8wi7ff1j I highly doubt Dr Syed Ammar Nakshawani to be uneducated especially when he has a Doctorate. And giving false statements while sitting on the mimbar is a big sin which I highly doubt he will commit. He gives proofs and historical facts of everything he talks about.
@@iammustafa777 syed ammar...who runs from debating sunnis?...are you kidding me?
Could we get the full video? Thanks
@@rahmtube2885 Which hadith is this? How has it been graded by the scholars?
@@rahmtube2885 Tell me where to find this hadith, so I can see its grading and read it for myself. If it is sahih, I will trust it.
@@rahmtube2885 Oh, and we do not pray to the Prophet, we pray only to Allah.
@@rahmtube2885 This is false that the hadith were written a century after the Prophet (pbhuh). Rather, every single sahih hadith has an unbroken chain all the way to the Prophet (pbuh). As for Abu Hurairah (ra), he used to spend all of his time with the Prophet while the other companions used to be busy with their work. In addition, the Prophet (pbuh) prayed to Allah for strengthening Abu Hurairah's memory. Also, Abu Hurairah (ra) used to teach other people what he learnt from the Prophet (pbuh), whereas the other companions used to be busy with other work, with Ali (ra) working for the Khalifah.
Mashallah you dealt with her like a man with respect 😊
I know that sister, shes a decent person
Pray for her. May Allah guide every sincere shia
MA brilliant content however the audio in this video and the bayat ul ghadeer video is horrendous.. I'm looking forward to future videos but please adjust the sound quality before uploading. JazakAllah Khair
She's very astute. I really enjoyed this video.
We Shia pray to Allah and to Allah alone the Ahlul Bait are our best examples and have the best prayers Allah sent down with Angel Gabriel for us I don't understand why people put down the holy family and lower their status
Have you listened to the entire conversation? He’s not putting the best family down, he’s putting them in their correct place. Allah SWT knows best.
Why do shias elevate the status of the prophets family to a state where they're greater than prophets???
Subhanallah.
Immamah concept of shia isn't even mentioned in the Quran clearly yet Allah praised the prophets clearly
There is day and night difference between Shia beliefs and what Ahlul bayt believed and practiced.
Imagine this, let us say for the sake of this Fadal bin Ali, babul Hawaij, hears your call. Let us say somebody came and shot you on the leg and that is the reason for you call. What will Fadal do?
1. Answer the call on his own and help you against the person who shot you.
2. Intercede to God on your behalf and say such and such called my name because somebody shot him. Help him God.
Two of the most advantageous way to you. Now is the delama. How about if you shot that person a year ago, killed his family, etc and here for retribution?
Will Fadal know about this and all the soup that went in to make this and many other things happen?
If yes, what is the difference between him and God?
What is the use of him praying and making good deeds if he is busy with the needs of creations day and night? Where is the peace?
More importantly what is the need for God?
*This simple logical thinking shows the craziness of Shiasm and any belief that calls anyone Other than God.*
There is no doubt that Twelver Shia authorities (not all Shia laymen, may Allah guide them away from Shi'ism) not just pray to other than Allah, they even encourage their followers to pray directly to other than Allah where Allah is not even mentioned, we made numerous videos proving that:
th-cam.com/video/qQdJtlAD50U/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/V97K6KIkbzE/w-d-xo.html
As an ex Christian you guys remind me exactly of Catholics who pray to saints in order to reach god because they were pious men
Very nice
Even magic wishes from shaytaan are granted with the permission of Allah.
May Allah bless you ustadh
11:50 This doesn't sound like tawheed.
Why doesn’t it sound like tawheed. We are sending peace towards the prophet peace be upon him who hears of it through the angels who deliver it to him. Sounds a lot like tawheed to me.
JazakALLAHukhairan
بارک الله فیکم استاد حسن
You guys should really start making some videos about ahmadiiyas and refuting them they are one of the biggest and popular heresies right now
That's incorrect. Qadyanism is nowhere as influential as Shi'ism. Shi'ism has an entire state behind it and countries that are majority Shia. We are a team of volunteers, we don't have the time or resources to go after ever sect, especially not against a sect that emerged from the Indian subcontinent where its primary sources are written in Urdu. There are millions of Urdu speaking Muslims in the world who should take up this task, not our already over-burdened team.
@@SunnahDiscourse well brother actually there has been a huge rise in ahamdiyyas they literally change the mind of revert brothers to join their deviant sect they have grown bigger then jus urdu speaking they are starting to pop up everywhere and they always slowly trick sunni converts into their heresy. It's worth checking out is all I'm saying.
@@SunnahDiscourse qadianism is big in canada a revert brother here came to our mosque and one of our brothers were able to correct some of the wrong beliefs they had told him . But its huge in canada and they dont call themselves "ahmadi" they call themselves just muslim so to the layman non muslim they dont know the difference 🙄
Sorry but your response was basically just saying that there are different opinions between shia scholars… Ammar has his opinion and gave his reasoning. Just cuz there may be a different opinion from a different scholar does not make it wrong 😂
Ebn Hussein is a beast MashaAllah
on the note of "allah can do whatever he wants"
Brother said there's no evidence for giving authority to Abiya or ahlul bait...
considering your statement absolutely true..... believing in something without evidence != (is not equal to) Shirk....it may b considered ignorance but not shirk...
actual problem with these kind of aqida is not that there's simply absence of evidence... coz if that was the case only thing you could say about these people are that they are ignorant
real problem is that allah clearly stated that he does not take any partner...and these people (believer of istigasha) invoke their masters in the matter that is only the right of Allah for ex. Ask for child, rizq etc...and thay way they make partner them in to Qadar of allah s.w.t
may allah guide us
This is from clubhouse 😂😂
لا حول ولا قوة إلا بالله
She is a layman, but she is a heavily brainwashed layman. She was parroting the same silly regurgitated arguments: "oh, we don't say that we worship them; oh we don't say that they are gods, therefore its not shirk" - which is what she has been brainwashed with against the simple fitri call to tawhid of dua (which is to call upon/make dua directly to Allah alone without involving any intercessor; establishing a one-to-one spiritual relatiship thru dua to Allah alone without involving others in between). She is parroting the same hoops and loops around this simple and clear command BECAUSE of course she didn't come up with this herself, this is exactly what she has been brainwashed with (i.e, such silly preconcieved notions and arguments against the simple invitation of tawhid of dua). She is not understanding a simple fact: what people SAY they do does not have anything to do with what they ACTAULLY do. Catholics (like shia/sufis) use the same silly analogies "oh, we don't worship the saints; oh we don't say they are gods" whilst IN ACTUALITY they turn to saints and pray to them in the same manner that people turn to and pray to gods, in the same manner that people worship and venerate spirits with humiliation of the heart towards supernatural spirits/gods (universally known as 'worship') - the only difference is in the use of variable (the word 'god' or the word 'saint', the word 'worship' or the word 'veneration' - what is in the name when the underlying belief and intentions are the same?).
And, she again parrots the same sufi/shi/catholic-style arguments: "but, we don't have the intention to worship" - well, of course you DO have the intention to worship. Do you have the intention to invoke when you invoke others besides Allah? Of course you do. Well, guess what? Invocation IS worship. What you are doing here is: first you suit to your own brainwashed subjective definition of what constitutes worship and then you use THAT in your argument to say you don't have the intention for it - what a ridiculous fallacy! The moment you intend to religio-ritually INVOKE something (e.g, for help in relief of a life calamity, for provision, for children, for madad in troubles - i.e, al-dua), you have automatically INTENDED TO WORSHIP (because invocation IS worship); [what, are you telling me the one invoking has no intention of invoking? what non-sense is that?]. How many times was she told by the ustadh "Dua IN AND OF ITSELF is a form of worship" - but she kept on parroting and saying "oh, I understand you sentiments bla bla bla". No, it's not a sentiment what ebn hussein was saying. It was a brutal fact. And, what rather you (i.e, the sister) did was plain brainwashed regurgiation of sentiments and utter sillyness against simple calls just like brainwashed Christians argue against tawhid for trinity.
This guy claims he left shiism cuz they worshipped graves,but no Shia believes that imams are capable of doing anything without the permission of Allah, of course we only ask Allah and Allah only ,and that's the tawasol ,even if I ask Ali I'm not asking it from him I'm asking him to make dua for me because of his status, stop lying about shias,
Ali R.A is dead ask help from Allah only because they is no barrier between you and Allah why will you go through his creation. What is the difference between you Aqedah and christians.
Did she permitted you to upload her video because according to clubhouse you need to ask the person before recording? You people don't have have basic ethics and manners.
Where did you get this information that it was uploaded without her permission?
It is a public platform it is our room.
@@SunnahDiscourse You were just invited into the room. It was not your room. Secondly, you still ask your guest the permission for recording nor did she agree or knew about this. Don't make such poor excuses.
@@yaskhan5831 I know that sister.
@@tanveerahmed1526 she didnt sound like a shy introvert who'd care being recorded. Proof is u are here complaining, while she isn't.(stop being that annoying 'brother')
When you walk-in to Radio or Tv shows, you dont expect not being broadcasted.
Lets not dwell into legal matters you understand urself.
A person who swears by Allah that a particular person who disagrees and also a muslim bro is worse than a donkey . Ustaz? 🤦♂️
Nice try (and damage control). But it isn't just a disagreement, the person you try to defend lied about THREE Sahabah in ONE lecture (citing Sufi-Rafidi fabrications): th-cam.com/video/GgtfrhQ5jLQ/w-d-xo.html
First get educated, if you were a shia first you should know the answer. Why did people in Egypt when they were under the dictatorship of Firoaun ask help from God?
Allah sent them Prophet Musa, to help the people.
So the people who seeked help in Prophet Musa are non-muslims?
The Imams are guides they are not our God or our Prophet. They only made sure that the teachings of Prophet Muhammad carried on. They are the ahlulbayt of Prophet Muhammad, we believe only Allah can give use what we will.
But imagine if the family of Prophet Muhammad request God that this person wants this.
Recall back the event of Khybar, Allah gave Imam Ali the power to open the gate of khybar with his hands. Its really shameful knowing that you were Shia but you turned against. Don’t you feel a tremble in your heart?
In this world loving Ali is a crime you get killed for it, not everyone is worth to have the love of Ali and his family in their hearts as they are the most trustworthy people ever in this world.
Thank God your not a shia anymore its a shame to call you a shia.
Saudi Arabia are Sunnis look at them they sold themselves to the enemies of Islam for the sake of wealth. Those people are your example of real muslims🙄
Imam Mahdi will come, then we will see who was right or wrong.
Bro what is ur name on clubhouse to flow you
We are not currently on Clubhouse, we were invited to speak on a platform that is not our own.
@@SunnahDiscourse I think it would be a good idea to start , may Allah reward Hassan for his work . We need more from him and we would love to hear from more often 👏👏
@@SunnahDiscourse you guys need to be there it is best place to discuss anything in clubhouse.
Sura Maidah verse 55, proof of Imam and thier authority!!!
Your only guardians are Allah, His Messenger, and fellow believers-who establish prayer and pay alms-tax with humility.
Where does it mention your 12 imams, their infallibility or supernatural abilities?
@@youtubeowl9544 when the quran says no impurities can touch the ahlulbayt, its sayng they are infallible.
@@AdamTaghavi1 That’s talking about the wives of the Prophet SAW. Don’t be jahil.
Word maula has more than 1 meaning. Context dictates which meaning to be used.
Likewise, Man Kuntu Maula, Fahaza Ali un Maula, are you ok to translate Maula as protector here? No, here ull say it means leader (which is wrong). So context is important.
Ayat Mubahila, sura Ale Imran ayat 41. Allah(swt) said, to bring your women, sons and more importantly "Your selfs". So now go and see who went with Rasool(pbuh) to mubahila, and if this doesnt show you thier infalliability nothing will, cause your hearts are not with Allah(swt).
When Rafhidi call Hussain Ali Redha Abbas Zainab Fatma then why are Iranians Iraqis sick with cancer heart diabatese covid and why they are poor and why sanctions on Iran are not lifted because these Shia Ayatullahs tell their followers to ask Ahle bait and they will give u anything where in fact they have given them nothing Allah says in sura Fatir ayat 13 14 15 If u ask these dead people of graves they cannot hear nor Reply nor own anything as small as kitmeer
Then Allah says If anything afflicts u there is no one who can remove it except Allah
When you ask any Shia to prove AQEEDAH from QUR'AN. They will provide INCOMPLETE or indirect verses from QUR'AN and using HADITHS and TAFSIRS is the only way to prove WILAYAH, IMAMAH, SHIA KALIMAH etc etc.
Ustadh? Dont make me laugh
Means teacher
*best* *Anti* *Majos* *channel*
She was doing good up till ebn hussein got disconnected then she folded back onto her self to justify her rafidism
I smell Taqiyya
You were never a shia because a real shia would never leave Imam ali and his teachings which are teachings from the Prophet (pbuh) which are teaching from Allah. Period!
If Shiism is from the teachings of Allah, where is the clear proof for the Twelver Shia concept of imamah in the Qur'an?
I agree that a true shia will never leave the teachings of Imam Ali AS - and the authentic teachings of Imam Ali AS aligns perfectly with the creed of Ahlussunnah wal Jamaah.
@@SunnahDiscourse from the Quran? Haha from the Quran all the time we see in a mutawatir Hadith Muhammed (saw) says to Ali “you are to me as Harun was to musa” and when we look at the Quran in surah taha verse 32 musa says to Allah “let Harun share my task” therefore Harun is to musa the sharer of his task and since Ali is to Muhammed (saw) as Harun was to musa Ali is also the sharer of Muhammed’s (saw) task proving Ali’s Imamate
I challenge you to refute this @Sunnah Discourse
Lol, so the one who leaves a certain cult was never a part of that cult?😂😂😂
@@ayatollahkhamenei8768 this Quran is with Ali and Ali with Quran? Says who?
This is such a cheap tactic (edited it). Uploading content without the permission.
Such a haram act.
Stop following Amr ibn a'as (la) techniques
And on top of that, Not all Shia scholars believe in Istighasa. Some believe , some do not. That doesn't mean shia islam is wrong.
In shitte ideology, we do not believe in oppressors and usurpers and believe in only Ahlul-Bayt and good companions of prophet like Ammar, Salman, miqdad, abu dhar etc. We believe in Imamah and have Jafari fiqh. You can enjoy your way of understanding. Our shia islam is beautiful and we love and live it.
Where did you get this information that it was uploaded without her permission?
@@yaskhan5831 she is a close friend of mine
@@TahirHussainMir24 by the way, Hindus and Christians also think their way of understanding their religion is beautiful. Does not mean they are correct
@@yaskhan5831 We believe in Quran, Sunnah of prophet, Ahlul-Bayt. What's wrong with that.. it's good.
You people believe in those who usurped tye rights of Fatima zahra. Who made her angry. When 3rd caliph was to be chosen, imam ali rejected Seerat e shekhain which means rejected abu bakars and umars caliphate. The only major difference between you and us is we follow Ahlul Bayt and you follow the usurpers who usurped their rights
@@TahirHussainMir24 you believe in shirk. You believe Ali is a god. The same Ali (your version) that could not protect his wife. You are not a muslim
Shia sister ???looooolll. She s sunni .the shia are the followers of ahl el bayt.ahl el bayt are banou chaiba. There is no shia because the shia must follow banou chaiba