Kim Hongjoong is the member you pointed out in the bucket hat! He's a 98 liner and is the second oldest, as well as the leader of ATEEZ. He's really the founding block of ATEEZ-- He started out wanting to write music and actually submitted a few pieces to KQ because they're the company of Block B who he really enjoyed. It took about a year, but they found the music and brought him on board, and ultimately decided to start a group. When he was brought in be had no experience in singing, rapping, or dancing, but is now the leader of ATEEZ, one of their rappers, and has composed the songs Aurora, Sunrise, Horizon, and Good Lil Boy. He also has lyric writing credits for most of their discography with Mingi, the deep voiced rapper. He has a HUGE stage presence, and does really well with both blending into the choreography when he needs to as well as standing out when he's center. Just fyi, he's the pretty one that held the flag in Treasure at the beginning and also the one in the red that called himself a pirate king in Pirate King! (You can usually tell he's about to rap because he typically puts in a little laugh right before his bit, but moreso in their bsides rather than their title tracks.)
They did their training in America for some time😌 Their performances are very powerful 🔥 Tbh.... ATEEZ is a group that all members can be called as main dancers 😌
What I love about ATEEZ is that synchronisation isn't their aim, they manage to be so unique yet stay cohesive as a dance unit with so much damn swag - keep in mind they're like four months old here 😭they really emulate the emotion of each song and it really translates to their live performances (it's also why they're known as stage kings!) Loved this reaction 💛
I recommend an ATEEZ guide by ETINY whether you react to it on camera or not (but I would love to see your reaction). It’s really helpful, has a lot of info and it isn’t stereotypical like most of the guides, it showcases boys really well. The one in bucket hat is our precious, talented leader Kim Hongjoong 🥰❤️ Can’t wait to see more of your ATEEZ reactions! 😄❤️
Finally someone who just appreciates Ateez as a whole..its not just choreo, its Theater!! I found them before their debut as KQ fellaz..they have a couple of performance videos/ covers and I was hooked..They later debuted as Ateez..Thank heavens. Can you tell I love them. 😘
IIRC, Ateez were sent to LA for a while during training to work on dance. The group is really into the performance art of everything all the way down interesting makeup and theatrics. They're a fun group to follow; you never really know what they'll do next.
Waiting for further ateez reactions. And if you want to you can also check out the their predebut performances which they performed as "KQ Fellaz" . The choreographies are hip hop kinda style.
Hala Hala is such an iconic Ateez song~ Their stage presence is unreal and they truly bring their performances to life. Even the outfits are iconic, they still reference these outfits in several other of their mvs/title tracks. Love the ateez reactions! It would be amazing if you delved into the members too and checked out a guide of them!
the one in bucket hat is hongjoong, the leader :) my favorite in this one is sa(ta)n, his facial expressions and style of dancing were made for hala hala ❤❤
Not a dancer so I like when dancers react to Ateez. I know I'm missing a lot; I'm just in the corner say, looks great. Everyone sees something different. Thanks for adding your sight to my understanding.
Thank you for the reaction!! Ateez are definitely performers. this dance practice doesn't even scratch the surface of their potential ALSO from your other videos i learned that you're a fan of pirates? or the concept of pirates but if that's so you should definitely watch their "WIN" performance from the fellowship concert in seoul which is on their own channel (since the whole staging and the concept of that performance is pirates and epic ones at that.)
If she does Say My Name next i will live and die at the same time that song is a total masterpiece. Ep 2 was really so crazy. Then illusion and wave U AINT READY I AINT READY NONE OF US BE READY
Ateez honestly the best 4th gen performers in my opinion. They're stage presence and energy is unmatched!!! And the fact that haters say they overdance like HUH??? They're probably used to mediocre performances that they forget what actual performers look like lmao
2:25 yes they are indeed really dedicated to their concept and performance, even their facial expressions are the best i've ever seen in kpop, they are so good most of the times they look possessed (especially san and hongjoong) lmao
Say My Name next please. :) can't wait for you to react to their live performances. We all call them possessed for a reason, especially when they perform Hala Hala. 😍
Love that you're doing more reactions to Ateez!! I don't know if you ever do reactions to live stages, but I'd highly recommend checking them out performing their stuff live. Especially songs like HALA HALA and Wonderland because of how powerful they are, but also songs like Illusion where you can see how much they really dedicate themselves to whatever concept they're going with at the time, like you said! :>
Excellent reaction, I loved how you spotted the same intricacies in the dancing that I did on first watch. Hala Hala was the first Ateez video I watched and yes Hongjoong stands out, so much swag, so much stage presence and then the other one I noticed was San. I thought it was the best mv video I had ever seen, so much power.
I saw ATEEZ and got so shookt. I needed to stan in a matter of minutes or I would've died. XD there's just no one at their level for me. They're crazy good.
i love your commentary so much!! i don't know why it gets me motivated even though it's not about me lmao 😭. you have a new subscriber! loved the video! 🤍
In hala hala live stage u'll see some members got demonic facial expression, yess they're not only dancing on stage but also acting! As i mentioned in your previous ateez reaction, they definetely have everything required to be the best group of 4th gen! Love your reaction to them ....❤❤❤
Hala Hala got me OBSESSED with them, it is to this day my favorite Ateez song bc they just killed it and the outfits and vibe of hala hala is just so good. And it really showed their ability to dance and perform, it might be one of my favorite choreos as well.
Dance theory and music theory lessons with Thina and Ateez? Sign me the hell up! I've noticed some of the things you were explaining (the stop motion in particular) but I never had words to explain it and just though "AAHH the thing! they're doing The Thing! I love The Thing!" every time. I hope you check out some of their live performances of their songs because they go just as hard as they do for the practice versions while singing live and it is just *chef kiss* a wonderful experience. I can't wait for more of your reactions to Ateez and I hope you keep loving them
Its funny you should mention how good the performance aspect of this is because they call themselves performers rather than idols. Also their choreography isn't always perfectly synchronised as they all have quite distinct styles but personally I think this & their facial expressions when they dance really adds to the overall performance.
Mind you that this is just their first comeback. Please react to "Say My Name" MV next. It is the title track of the EP Album Treasure Ep. 2, including this song HALA HALA. You may follow this guide throughout their discography: Treasure EP.1: All to Zero Title Tracks: Treasure, and Pirate King Treasure EP.2: Zero to One Title Tracks: HALA HALA, and Say My Name Treasure EP.3: One to All (2019) Tracks with MV: Wave, Illusion, and Aurora Treasure EP.Fin: All to Action (2019) Title Track: Wonderland Treasure Epilogue: Action to Answer (2020) Title Track: Answer Zero: Fever Part.1 (2020) - NEW ERA Title Tracks: Inception and Thanxx
I knew you would love this one because of the dance. This is my favorite song of Ateez. Love to see your reaction to their 2020 mama battle performance. They are battling for the kingdom with Stay kids and the boyz. The all have 3 big performances and then a triangle fight wit 1 member of each group. Stray kids performed Victory song and omg all 3 performances where like watching a movie. I don't know much about the boyz but it was good to.
You would probably love their KQ Fellaz Performance videos. They're short videos and full of amazing choreography. Im sure people have already recommended them lol. But there are 3 of them and then one with Yunho by himself with backup dancers. They just showcase how talented they are as a group for sure. I was so excited to see you react to this song!
Can’t wait for you to react to ATEEZ resent videos. Don’t get me wrong I really like their old songs like HALA HALA and Pirate King. But since then they have improved a lot visually and musically wise. As I said can’t wait for you to react to their most recent stuff😇
I remember when I first saw Hala Hala performance video on twitter.. that 1 :28 short clip really snatch my heart.. freaking smooth and cool..this is one of the time twitter kpop fancam introduce me to some cool artist for me..💓💓💓💓
I would love to watch a guide reaction! I especially recommend 'A Helpful Guide to Stanning ATEEZ' by ETINY, it's pretty long but it is top notch in getting you to know Ateez as a group and individually. Also for any future Ateez reactions you do I would 100% recommend checking out the dance practice or a live stage to go with it. Ateez is honestly one of the best new(ish) groups for having amazing choreographies.
i really really want you to react to their MAMA peformance but they performed Answer and Inception which you haven't seen yet bc those came out this year. Also I have a feeling Hongjoong will be your bias hahah! You keep noticing him since your Pirate King reaction. he's the leader and he was born in 1998!
Please react to their pre debut dance performances. There are 3 then a solo by a member Yunho who is a main dancer ( but they are all main dancers as far as I'm concerned) they are amazing. They are about 2 mins max each so you can fit all of them into one video.
Now im BEGGING for you to react to their predebute performances cz their performance skills level is CRAZY in them just type ateez performance video I , II & III its just 3 videos 1 min long each
I know you probably don’t want to add another group to your list but... You mentioned here that watching the music video was like watching a movie, and if that’s something you’re into then perhaps you could check out ONEUS at some point? Their song COME BACK HOME in particular is my favourite kpop release this entire year; it has stunning choreo & vocals & a really interesting concept that they play through like an actual film throughout the video. Anyway, thanks for more ATEEZ!!!! I love this song and dance very much and I’m so glad you reacted to it :)
Literally San has to be one of, if not the, best krumper in all of K-pop. His body control is absolutely insane. Also remember that whole thing about me saying that you should see a live? Yeah. You should lol. Or even San just going off on this song at Idol Radio (when he didn't have to). Hala Hala is one of my favorite songs of theirs.
When they perform this song San (the one who threw his hat in the dance practice) always breaks his mic because of how hard he dances
lol i didnt know that
@@iquinze1513 i didn't either until i saw some clips on instagram
I forget who (I think it was Yeosang) said it had to be a whole line of its own in the budget. He was joking but it really doesn’t feel like he was.
She said that she would watch ateez chronologically so does that mean Say My Name is next?!! omg I can't wait for that😆😆
the one in the hat that you asked for is Kim Hongjoong. He is the leader, rapper and the composer. He composed almost all of Ateez's songs.
and he was the mullet guy on the MV before
Hongjoong and mingi wrote lyrics for almost all of the songs, however hongjoong only composed a couple of bsides in their albums :)
They are known for their performances.
Everytime ateez goes for a show or competition they are termed as the "The global performance idol group"
Kim Hongjoong is the member you pointed out in the bucket hat! He's a 98 liner and is the second oldest, as well as the leader of ATEEZ. He's really the founding block of ATEEZ-- He started out wanting to write music and actually submitted a few pieces to KQ because they're the company of Block B who he really enjoyed. It took about a year, but they found the music and brought him on board, and ultimately decided to start a group. When he was brought in be had no experience in singing, rapping, or dancing, but is now the leader of ATEEZ, one of their rappers, and has composed the songs Aurora, Sunrise, Horizon, and Good Lil Boy. He also has lyric writing credits for most of their discography with Mingi, the deep voiced rapper.
He has a HUGE stage presence, and does really well with both blending into the choreography when he needs to as well as standing out when he's center. Just fyi, he's the pretty one that held the flag in Treasure at the beginning and also the one in the red that called himself a pirate king in Pirate King! (You can usually tell he's about to rap because he typically puts in a little laugh right before his bit, but moreso in their bsides rather than their title tracks.)
I highly recommend you to watch the stage for this song. The stage presence just go a thousand times higher, you'll love it
They did their training in America for some time😌 Their performances are very powerful 🔥
Tbh.... ATEEZ is a group that all members can be called as main dancers 😌
Periodt ^^
@@someone-8784 yup💅
I think they trained in LA Millenium center for a month not a year
wait they did??#!!#!#
@@junghwanso6721 YES! They did. You can search up KQ fellaz, the series, which they filmed during their training
What I love about ATEEZ is that synchronisation isn't their aim, they manage to be so unique yet stay cohesive as a dance unit with so much damn swag - keep in mind they're like four months old here 😭they really emulate the emotion of each song and it really translates to their live performances (it's also why they're known as stage kings!)
Loved this reaction 💛
Please react to the ateez guide by ETINI. It's called 'A Helpful Guide to stanning Ateez '.
YESSS THE BEST GUIDE EVER
BEST GUIDE EVER
I recommend an ATEEZ guide by ETINY whether you react to it on camera or not (but I would love to see your reaction). It’s really helpful, has a lot of info and it isn’t stereotypical like most of the guides, it showcases boys really well. The one in bucket hat is our precious, talented leader Kim Hongjoong 🥰❤️
Can’t wait to see more of your ATEEZ reactions! 😄❤️
Finally someone who just appreciates Ateez as a whole..its not just choreo, its Theater!! I found them before their debut as KQ fellaz..they have a couple of performance videos/ covers and I was hooked..They later debuted as Ateez..Thank heavens. Can you tell I love them. 😘
I LOVE HOW HER EYES GET BIGGER WHILE WATCHING IT
IIRC, Ateez were sent to LA for a while during training to work on dance. The group is really into the performance art of everything all the way down interesting makeup and theatrics. They're a fun group to follow; you never really know what they'll do next.
Waiting for further ateez reactions.
And if you want to you can also check out the their predebut performances which they performed as "KQ Fellaz" . The choreographies are hip hop kinda style.
I second the predebut performances just for additional points on them acting like a dance/performance group.
🙋♀️ yup!!
Ateez are dance kings, also I'd love to see you react to a Ateez guide but it's totally fine if you choose to watch it on your own
When this song was realesed they were underground K-pop group. After wave and wonderland comeback many more people found about them.
I recommend watching their live performance of The Black Cat Nero on Immortal Songs. Such a great performance
Saaaaaame
She did a reaction to the song already but not the live performance
Hala Hala is such an iconic Ateez song~ Their stage presence is unreal and they truly bring their performances to life. Even the outfits are iconic, they still reference these outfits in several other of their mvs/title tracks. Love the ateez reactions! It would be amazing if you delved into the members too and checked out a guide of them!
The gut with the bucket hat is Hongjoong The leader of ATEEZ and second oldest of ATEEZ
Finally ATEEZ known to be monster rookies that blew away all kpop fans brain.😍
the one in bucket hat is hongjoong, the leader :) my favorite in this one is sa(ta)n, his facial expressions and style of dancing were made for hala hala ❤❤
Not a dancer so I like when dancers react to Ateez. I know I'm missing a lot; I'm just in the corner say, looks great. Everyone sees something different. Thanks for adding your sight to my understanding.
5:13 THANK YOU, finally someone who recognize how awesome is that V formation!! I'm a dancer too and it makes me go in awe every time I see it
It’s like MAGIC for our eyes, and chocolate😜
_xthina
San throwing his hat gives me goosebumps every time because he's about to kill it!
I think Say My Name might be my favorite choreography for Ateez. You should check out the MV and dance practice 😁
Thank you for the reaction!! Ateez are definitely performers. this dance practice doesn't even scratch the surface of their potential ALSO from your other videos i learned that you're a fan of pirates? or the concept of pirates but if that's so you should definitely watch their "WIN" performance from the fellowship concert in seoul which is on their own channel (since the whole staging and the concept of that performance is pirates and epic ones at that.)
if you watch a guide, I recommend the one by ETINI with the rainbowish thumbnail. it's a bit long but the most updated and accurate one 💖
'createez' omg I love that!!! You have such awesome insights that's for your reactions!
Yes Ateez is awesome, you should react to their live performance
Hala hala live is something else! I hope you watch it soon
If she does Say My Name next i will live and die at the same time that song is a total masterpiece. Ep 2 was really so crazy.
Then illusion and wave
U AINT READY I AINT READY NONE OF US BE READY
the bucket hat guy are the mullet guy, he's hongjoong
All groups commit. Ateez are just god-level performers.
Girl Ateez is the future of kpop, they're just on another level glad you're reacting to them, react to some guide too they're funny af.
Kim Hongjoong is the one you were talking about! He is the leader of the group, a composer, and a main rapper. Also my bias sooooo :)
Ateez honestly the best 4th gen performers in my opinion. They're stage presence and energy is unmatched!!! And the fact that haters say they overdance like HUH??? They're probably used to mediocre performances that they forget what actual performers look like lmao
2:25 yes they are indeed really dedicated to their concept and performance, even their facial expressions are the best i've ever seen in kpop, they are so good most of the times they look possessed (especially san and hongjoong) lmao
Say My Name next please. :) can't wait for you to react to their live performances. We all call them possessed for a reason, especially when they perform Hala Hala. 😍
the one who threw the hat was San. HE’S SUPER GREAT WITH KRUMPING!!!!!!! one of the best .
Yes,you are correct their dedication to their craft is truly admirable.they can sing,they can rap,they dance well.they are good in live performances.
YES! It's no more "Creative" but "CREATEEZ"! Thank you for reacting to HALA HALA ^^ !
Thanks for the reaction! I love your detailed explanation so much! Looking forwards to more ATEEZ
Love that you're doing more reactions to Ateez!! I don't know if you ever do reactions to live stages, but I'd highly recommend checking them out performing their stuff live. Especially songs like HALA HALA and Wonderland because of how powerful they are, but also songs like Illusion where you can see how much they really dedicate themselves to whatever concept they're going with at the time, like you said! :>
REACT MOOOORE TO ATEEZ PLEASEEEEEE
Guys, she is slowly becoming an Atiny 🥺✨👏🏽
I feel it!
Excellent reaction, I loved how you spotted the same intricacies in the dancing that I did on first watch. Hala Hala was the first Ateez video I watched and yes Hongjoong stands out, so much swag, so much stage presence and then the other one I noticed was San. I thought it was the best mv video I had ever seen, so much power.
One thing to remember
when Ateez go they go HARD
Thank youu for reacting Ateez ❤
Yes! I love this reaction... I will look forward to more Ateez reaction 😊
You're slowly creeping into becoming an Atiny and I'm not complainin'
You had me dead 'createez' 😭😭 that's exactly what they are!
Say my name it’s one of my favorites can’t wait for you to react to it... HALA HALA to me it’s ICONIC!!!! They are such an amazing group
I saw ATEEZ and got so shookt. I needed to stan in a matter of minutes or I would've died. XD there's just no one at their level for me. They're crazy good.
ATEEZ is literally THAT group. They are insane
i love your commentary so much!! i don't know why it gets me motivated even though it's not about me lmao 😭. you have a new subscriber! loved the video! 🤍
In hala hala live stage u'll see some members got demonic facial expression, yess they're not only dancing on stage but also acting! As i mentioned in your previous ateez reaction, they definetely have everything required to be the best group of 4th gen! Love your reaction to them ....❤❤❤
Thank you so much for reacting to them.. I hope you will become an Atiny someday hehehe.
Hala Hala got me OBSESSED with them, it is to this day my favorite Ateez song bc they just killed it and the outfits and vibe of hala hala is just so good. And it really showed their ability to dance and perform, it might be one of my favorite choreos as well.
Please react to Ateez's Wonderland and its dance practice!!!! It's got a lot of intense stomps and it's my favourite Ateez song
YOU GOTTA WATCH THIS LIVE THE FACIALS ARE MAD
Hala Hala was my introduction to Ateez and I've never looked back.
Thanxx for the reaction.. Don't forget to see they perform in mama2020 😊
I love that somehow I’m always early to your Ateez reactions. Again, very excited that you’re reacting to Ateez!
Im not watching yet but she will definitely go shock lol. Okey lets watch
Dance theory and music theory lessons with Thina and Ateez? Sign me the hell up! I've noticed some of the things you were explaining (the stop motion in particular) but I never had words to explain it and just though "AAHH the thing! they're doing The Thing! I love The Thing!" every time.
I hope you check out some of their live performances of their songs because they go just as hard as they do for the practice versions while singing live and it is just *chef kiss* a wonderful experience. I can't wait for more of your reactions to Ateez and I hope you keep loving them
Periodt. This review is EVERYTHING. I love you so much, Thina
ateez stage performance is insane please check it out they are 4th gen great performer
So excited for more of your reactions to Ateez!!!They are a unique and different group and their effort is always 110%. Still amazes me to this day ❤️
YASSSS waiting for more ateez content 😘
Would definitely recommend to watch ateez(kQ Fellaz) performance video 1, 2,3 its their pre-debut dance routines
They give their all in every performance, that´s why they are loved ♥
The song that makes me stan ateez and this is the first song I ever watched by ateez.
yes more appreciation for the tiny man hongjoong!!
Its funny you should mention how good the performance aspect of this is because they call themselves performers rather than idols. Also their choreography isn't always perfectly synchronised as they all have quite distinct styles but personally I think this & their facial expressions when they dance really adds to the overall performance.
You should react to Say my name by Ateez too!! ❤
ateez really out here being the theatre kids of kpop
Mind you that this is just their first comeback. Please react to "Say My Name" MV next. It is the title track of the EP Album Treasure Ep. 2, including this song HALA HALA.
You may follow this guide throughout their discography:
Treasure EP.1: All to Zero
Title Tracks: Treasure, and Pirate King
Treasure EP.2: Zero to One
Title Tracks: HALA HALA, and Say My Name
Treasure EP.3: One to All (2019)
Tracks with MV: Wave, Illusion, and Aurora
Treasure EP.Fin: All to Action (2019)
Title Track: Wonderland
Treasure Epilogue: Action to Answer (2020)
Title Track: Answer
Zero: Fever Part.1 (2020) - NEW ERA
Title Tracks: Inception and Thanxx
It's Inception and Thanxx
@@clovergirl1783 Thanks! (edited now)
YEA HALA HALA
I knew you would love this one because of the dance. This is my favorite song of Ateez. Love to see your reaction to their 2020 mama battle performance. They are battling for the kingdom with Stay kids and the boyz. The all have 3 big performances and then a triangle fight wit 1 member of each group. Stray kids performed Victory song and omg all 3 performances where like watching a movie. I don't know much about the boyz but it was good to.
Oh God yes yes yessss. ATEEZ. WE NEED MOREE. MERRY CHRISTMAS
You would probably love their KQ Fellaz Performance videos. They're short videos and full of amazing choreography. Im sure people have already recommended them lol. But there are 3 of them and then one with Yunho by himself with backup dancers. They just showcase how talented they are as a group for sure. I was so excited to see you react to this song!
Can’t wait for you to react to ATEEZ resent videos. Don’t get me wrong I really like their old songs like HALA HALA and Pirate King. But since then they have improved a lot visually and musically wise. As I said can’t wait for you to react to their most recent stuff😇
I remember when I first saw Hala Hala performance video on twitter.. that 1 :28 short clip really snatch my heart.. freaking smooth and cool..this is one of the time twitter kpop fancam introduce me to some cool artist for me..💓💓💓💓
I would love to watch a guide reaction! I especially recommend 'A Helpful Guide to Stanning ATEEZ' by ETINY, it's pretty long but it is top notch in getting you to know Ateez as a group and individually.
Also for any future Ateez reactions you do I would 100% recommend checking out the dance practice or a live stage to go with it. Ateez is honestly one of the best new(ish) groups for having amazing choreographies.
i really really want you to react to their MAMA peformance but they performed Answer and Inception which you haven't seen yet bc those came out this year. Also I have a feeling Hongjoong will be your bias hahah! You keep noticing him since your Pirate King reaction. he's the leader and he was born in 1998!
Please react to their pre debut dance performances. There are 3 then a solo by a member Yunho who is a main dancer ( but they are all main dancers as far as I'm concerned) they are amazing. They are about 2 mins max each so you can fit all of them into one video.
You have a thing for our tiny leader, Kim Hongjoong. He's the one you've pointed out in all of your reactions.
aaaa thanks for reacting to them again, u should react to A.C.E too you’ll love them🥺
Each time I watch your videos, I see more posters in the background
SAN is possessed!!!!!
and we are here for it
Now im BEGGING for you to react to their predebute performances cz their performance skills level is CRAZY in them just type ateez performance video I , II & III its just 3 videos 1 min long each
I know you probably don’t want to add another group to your list but... You mentioned here that watching the music video was like watching a movie, and if that’s something you’re into then perhaps you could check out ONEUS at some point? Their song COME BACK HOME in particular is my favourite kpop release this entire year; it has stunning choreo & vocals & a really interesting concept that they play through like an actual film throughout the video. Anyway, thanks for more ATEEZ!!!! I love this song and dance very much and I’m so glad you reacted to it :)
Maybe starting from their pre-debut dance performances when they were still known as KQ fellaz. Love your reactions and your breakdown on the choreos.
Literally San has to be one of, if not the, best krumper in all of K-pop. His body control is absolutely insane. Also remember that whole thing about me saying that you should see a live? Yeah. You should lol. Or even San just going off on this song at Idol Radio (when he didn't have to). Hala Hala is one of my favorite songs of theirs.
Check out Jongho's vocal. He's a maknae but he doesn't act like one and his vocal is crazy. Also how your skin is so clear and glowing
ATEEZ=legends🔥
I definitely recommend say my name and win dance practices. Nah honestly all of their coreos are amazing lol
Please please react to ATEEZ Win Live Performance in Seoul!! 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻 it’s hella good
YES that stage is iconic 🙌🏽
13:53 And that's what makes them stand out
Thank you for reaction Please react to live stage