It makes you wonder if he did leave like the governor offered maybe they could've met up with Abraham and went to terminus and would've been a little more prepared and together
Damn. This kind of vid takes me back in 2010-2016 when I was obsessed with TWD and there was an amazing youtuber (forgot his name) whose channel was entirely centered on commenting each comic issues as they came out. Good times.
The whole series was S tier lol. I binged read the entire series in like a month. Had to literally force myself to stop reading some nights cuz it was sooo good and the cliffhangers just make you want to immediately read the next issue to see what happened lol.
I experienced the walking dead through the compendiums and my ranking would be: 4: Volume 2 (Issues 49-96) Broadly speaking this volume was downtime, winding down from the prison attack and gearing up for the saviors war. It's got good Character moments but besides Alexandria and No Way Out there's nothing that major that happens. 3: Volume 4 (Issues 145-193) This was everything from the Whisperers post Spike Deaths to the conclusion. I stopped caring about the Whisperer stuff after Alpha bites it, I wasn't super invested in the Commonwealth arc, but the conclusion was strong and there were many shocking deaths that kept me wanting to read more. 2: Volume 3 (97-144) For the Savior stuff alone, beginning with the shocking deaths of Glenn and Abraham, this Volume deserves Runner up. Savior stuff was much more interesting and fast paced than in the TV Show. The set up to the Whisperer War was good too loved the Spike Deaths and Alpha is a worthy villian. 1: Volume 1 (Issues 1-48) I mean, duh. Kirkman did an amazing job setting up the series and introducing the world of the walking dead from Rick waking up to the prison. Than the Governor comes in. Still the best villian the series has had and the Woodbury arc concluding with the Prison Attack is peak Walking Dead in both the comics and the show. Nothing after could top it.
I was in middle school when twd hit the fan, so I never really understood the complaints until quarantine. Read the books and re watched and by God, everyone was right.
I made it my mission after watching the second season with my dad to found them in stores like a game. I have only not found volume 28. I love this comic series and read it all the time.
For me personally 22 is much higher. Seeing this new world be reintroduced to us and catching up with our characters is so interesting. The worldbuliding is great. I like the introduction of new characters like magna and her group and dante. Not revealing everything thats happened over the like 3 years at once builds on curiosity. I like Seeing where our characters are. I love following Carls story the most probably. I love the creative systems the characters have in place to deal with issues and their commradary thoughout it all. Seeing everything theyve built is dope.The tension building with the whisperers is done great and presents itslef as genuinely intresring and mysterious new threat. I especially love Jesus vs the whisperers. Its spooky. I love how everything feels fresh. This issue is basically a new beginning which is the main thing i love. The old era of twd ended and now something new excited was coming along. It didnt just feel like a continuation but of something new and unique.Another big factor is that everyone is now united 4 communites officially stand as one. All of our favorite characters allied. We got to be thrown back into this world with all of our characters in ways weve never seen before with more elements being added to advance the story even more.
I'm a fan of the final volumes only because of the way we get a proper ending to all the legacy characters save for "Negan" which was a little upsetting but seeing he is still alive in that time and has a grave for "Lucille" is enough plus i doubt "Negan" would want you seeing him as an old softy, it also serves to prop Carl up as this larger than life "Hero of the trials" just like his dad. But everyone has their own tastes, I'm just so upset how they botched the show, had it been with another network like HBO i feel they could have adapted Kirkman's work far better. I understand the show is a standalone from the comics using the comics as reference but it kind of fell short because of it not to mention writer/producer/actor issues and quarrels. Could've gone down with one of the greats, but hey at least the comics will go down that way. Really good tier list @Koroto TV
don’t want to ask too much of you but would really like to see a ranking of every single episode. don’t worry if you don’t want to waste half a year doing it
I’m almost done with the first compendium and I wish Shane was in the comics more I really liked him in the show just wish he didn’t die so fast in the comics!!!
When I was getting into the comics, the store owner told me to start with the latest volume and go back. I just so happened to start with volume 17. Back in 2013 that was the latest volume.
@@thezoinksguy some they did some they didn't. I think they just made a lot of changes and wanted to mix it up from the comics, killing characters sooner or later or having ones that died really early on live or new characters that weren't even in the comics
Such a great channel easy sub. love your commentary and takes. Always warms my heart to have people showing love to the walking dead comics. Question for you have you read Kirkmans other great series invincible? Would love to hear your thoughts on that one if you have. Great content 👍
I'm really wierd, when I first read through the comics, as someone who knew so much about what was gonna happen, how long it was gonna be and binge read the series the commonwealth arc was for a while my favourite arc of the comics and I still love it though my current favourite part of the comics is the entire negan arc
i like how he says "if you know you know" and "if you read it you know what i'm talking about" like once every 5 min, and i have no fucking clue what's he's talking about so i just have to suck it up lmao
@@KorotoTV I think it would be a weird choice but I wouldn't ve totally against it. Season 11 has been fairly lacklustre when it comes to major character deaths. Aldin's death was pretty disappointing
Fear the Hunters is definitely A tier, but in comparison to the show it's hard. Because the resolution at Terminus is dope but it's a dumb plot device at the end of S4 to get everybody together again. But Fear the hunters is fucking sick. It feels like sheer horror in a horror series. It's a simple stand alone story and it starts with us being scared of them and then flipping it around to us being scared of our main characters.
the show has so many moments where you have to suspend that disbelief wayy more than the comic, like you said them all meeting at terminus and another i can think of is morgan finding that map abe left behind, but honestly i think if you just go with it it makes for a better and more gripping story, s4b where they're all travelling separately is some of the best of the show imo and them meeting at the farm was perhaps more realistic but more boring
i dont think its a dumb plot device. the comic version of rick meeting glenn and back together with everyone is not bad, but doesnt really give much beside a reunion
Volume 1 was kinda boring to me and I can't feel anything besides the show did it so much justice. It's one of the few times I feel like the show blew the comics out of the water. But it's not like there are no redeeming qualities, the writing is witty and creative, the characters are all pretty interesting, and unlike the show, every character that is important gets a lot of time to show us their personality. Carl killing shane was a carefully made scene that would progress Carl's character. It would groom him for the horrible setting. The 2 issues where they go to the neighborhood and they find out it's filled with zombies is where the pacing falls flat. It's the only reason I think the show did it better.
⚠️Huge potential spoilers for last part of season 11. Somewhat likely these are true, so open at your own risk⚠️ In the comic, Lori and Judith are both shot at the prison - rumors say that Rosita and Coco are getting that death sometime in 11C.
Spoilers, I guess? Originally there were rumors/spoilers that both Rosita and Coco (her baby) would get Lori and Judith's death from the comic. Obviously, that didn't turn out to be entirely correct though.
Andrew Lincoln wanted to leave the show so I can't be mad at the show for him not being in it, and I think they did a really great job of keeping the show interesting without him and utilising a lot of the rest of the characters a lot better. No one can replace him but I didn't struggle to watch the show without him because it was still better than season 7 and 8. Obviously it wouldve been better if he was still in it, but season 9 is still one of my favourite seasons, but if it weren't for Rick's final episodes it probably wouldn't be
My old man memory doesn't remember what rumors I mentioned and I don't want to watch myself ramble for an hour lmao, but I might've been talking about Rosita. There were rumors that she'd get Lori's death from the comics - so both her and the baby get shot.
⚠️Huge potential spoilers for last part of season 11. Somewhat likely these are true, so open at your own risk⚠️ In the comic, Lori and Judith are both shot at the prison - rumors say that Rosita and Coco are getting that death sometime in 11C.
Moral of the video : the comics did 98% of everything better than the show after Shane’s death. They really dropped the ball with the prison arc in the show
28 characters lived in the prison, only 10 got out. That’s insane, The Governor arc is more then likely my favorite
The governor changed Rick forever, destroyed his home, killed half of his group, and practically strengthened him to face any threat on the road.
@@ellcaf He was the bad guy catalyst for Rick, almost every major group has that bad guy who changed everyone into toughening up.
@@ellcaf that’s what made him ruthless once he encountered the marauders and the hunters
It makes you wonder if he did leave like the governor offered maybe they could've met up with Abraham and went to terminus and would've been a little more prepared and together
@@jeremyscungio16 that’s the tv version…they’re talking about the comic version
Vol 8 literally killed half the group that shit was crazy
Hershel and Billy didn't deserve this. Axel's death hit me hard too. Not to mention Tyreese's.....
@@silentgamer2434 and the Ben and Billy story wasn’t even during the prison kirkman was sick and just kept killing the group 😭😭
You're right prison arc was the best arc. Alexandria's arc before pre-negan is amazing too.
Damn. This kind of vid takes me back in 2010-2016 when I was obsessed with TWD and there was an amazing youtuber (forgot his name) whose channel was entirely centered on commenting each comic issues as they came out. Good times.
Trevschan i think
@@jacobfroese3485 that's it!!!!!!!! Thanks man i had completly forgotten his name
Watching this makes me wanna drive to the library and pack as many volumes in my car as possible like I used to. Nostalgia trip!!!
DO IT! 🙌
When I was reading it I had to actually limit myself to four volumes per trip since I wanted to make the experience last
Lmao, this is me with every piece of entertainment that I enjoy.... for all of 2 days and then I devour it 😂😂
@@KorotoTV Bro. Idk what you've read or seen but read Berserk, you'll shit....
this is such an asshole thing to do unless you can actually read it all in a few days
Bro I was not ready for Vol 8. Shit was so gruesome
“I love you so much” Ricks last words to Judith. Oof
I just read Volume 32 last week and damn did that ending mess me up but also it was incredible.
The whole series was S tier lol. I binged read the entire series in like a month. Had to literally force myself to stop reading some nights cuz it was sooo good and the cliffhangers just make you want to immediately read the next issue to see what happened lol.
S tier in its entirety? wow thats some low standards
I experienced the walking dead through the compendiums and my ranking would be: 4: Volume 2 (Issues 49-96) Broadly speaking this volume was downtime, winding down from the prison attack and gearing up for the saviors war. It's got good Character moments but besides Alexandria and No Way Out there's nothing that major that happens. 3: Volume 4 (Issues 145-193) This was everything from the Whisperers post Spike Deaths to the conclusion. I stopped caring about the Whisperer stuff after Alpha bites it, I wasn't super invested in the Commonwealth arc, but the conclusion was strong and there were many shocking deaths that kept me wanting to read more. 2: Volume 3 (97-144) For the Savior stuff alone, beginning with the shocking deaths of Glenn and Abraham, this Volume deserves Runner up. Savior stuff was much more interesting and fast paced than in the TV Show. The set up to the Whisperer War was good too loved the Spike Deaths and Alpha is a worthy villian. 1: Volume 1 (Issues 1-48) I mean, duh. Kirkman did an amazing job setting up the series and introducing the world of the walking dead from Rick waking up to the prison. Than the Governor comes in. Still the best villian the series has had and the Woodbury arc concluding with the Prison Attack is peak Walking Dead in both the comics and the show. Nothing after could top it.
I was in middle school when twd hit the fan, so I never really understood the complaints until quarantine. Read the books and re watched and by God, everyone was right.
I'm gonna eventually read the comics and come back to this!
I made it my mission after watching the second season with my dad to found them in stores like a game. I have only not found volume 28. I love this comic series and read it all the time.
Lmao just yesterday I had finished watching your ranking of the seasons. Perfect timing!
For me personally 22 is much higher. Seeing this new world be reintroduced to us and catching up with our characters is so interesting. The worldbuliding is great. I like the introduction of new characters like magna and her group and dante. Not revealing everything thats happened over the like 3 years at once builds on curiosity. I like Seeing where our characters are. I love following Carls story the most probably. I love the creative systems the characters have in place to deal with issues and their commradary thoughout it all. Seeing everything theyve built is dope.The tension building with the whisperers is done great and presents itslef as genuinely intresring and mysterious new threat. I especially love Jesus vs the whisperers. Its spooky. I love how everything feels fresh. This issue is basically a new beginning which is the main thing i love. The old era of twd ended and now something new excited was coming along. It didnt just feel like a continuation but of something new and unique.Another big factor is that everyone is now united 4 communites officially stand as one. All of our favorite characters allied. We got to be thrown back into this world with all of our characters in ways weve never seen before with more elements being added to advance the story even more.
My faves are something to fear, made to suffer, days gone bye, safety behind bars and the whisperer war
can't wait to see your rankings!
I'm a fan of the final volumes only because of the way we get a proper ending to all the legacy characters save for "Negan" which was a little upsetting but seeing he is still alive in that time and has a grave for "Lucille" is enough plus i doubt "Negan" would want you seeing him as an old softy, it also serves to prop Carl up as this larger than life "Hero of the trials" just like his dad. But everyone has their own tastes, I'm just so upset how they botched the show, had it been with another network like HBO i feel they could have adapted Kirkman's work far better. I understand the show is a standalone from the comics using the comics as reference but it kind of fell short because of it not to mention writer/producer/actor issues and quarrels. Could've gone down with one of the greats, but hey at least the comics will go down that way. Really good tier list @Koroto TV
Meh, the only point where the show botched it was seasons 7-8
don’t want to ask too much of you but would really like to see a ranking of every single episode. don’t worry if you don’t want to waste half a year doing it
I've done that 😂
I’m almost done with the first compendium and I wish Shane was in the comics more I really liked him in the show just wish he didn’t die so fast in the comics!!!
When I was getting into the comics, the store owner told me to start with the latest volume and go back. I just so happened to start with volume 17. Back in 2013 that was the latest volume.
Most of the OGs died in the first 5 seasons
Yeah, the show really didn't handle the OG group too well. At least the comics had a few more of them last longer throughout.
@@thezoinksguy some they did some they didn't. I think they just made a lot of changes and wanted to mix it up from the comics, killing characters sooner or later or having ones that died really early on live or new characters that weren't even in the comics
@@thezoinksguy meh, both have their pros and cons but both are overall pretty good
@@demon_hawkeye5269 The show has way more cons than the comics
@@thezoinksguy only in seasons 7-8, anywhere else the show and comic are basically neck and neck
Such a great channel easy sub. love your commentary and takes. Always warms my heart to have people showing love to the walking dead comics. Question for you have you read Kirkmans other great series invincible? Would love to hear your thoughts on that one if you have. Great content 👍
Haven’t read it, but watched the show - loved every second of it! Trying to hold off reading it because I want to experience it blind 😄
@@KorotoTV lol really respectable reason. I really think the show is great as good as the best re-enactment moments in Twd series
For this comic I think I'd have to have a different ranking system, like "YAY", "BRUTAL", "NOO", "WTF?"...
9:10 Nope, Volume 4 is so underrated, easily a top 10 volume, arguably top 5 imo
I'm really wierd, when I first read through the comics, as someone who knew so much about what was gonna happen, how long it was gonna be and binge read the series the commonwealth arc was for a while my favourite arc of the comics and I still love it though my current favourite part of the comics is the entire negan arc
i like how he says "if you know you know" and "if you read it you know what i'm talking about" like once every 5 min, and i have no fucking clue what's he's talking about so i just have to suck it up lmao
I'm start to like your Twitch Clip Channel more than your main Channel
Lmao no way 😂😂
This channel's a mess 😂
@@KorotoTV It's not a Mess :)
I still hate it how TV show didn't do any justice to the comic's Prison arc. There were multiple attacks which amounted to nothing.
Been waiting for this video
Pressing F so hard for Rick 👉🏻👈🏻
What were the rumours mentioned surrounding the Judith death?
Huge potential spoilers for last part of season 11⚠️
Apparently Rosita is getting the comic Lori & Judith death
@@KorotoTV I think it would be a weird choice but I wouldn't ve totally against it. Season 11 has been fairly lacklustre when it comes to major character deaths. Aldin's death was pretty disappointing
Covid prolonged the release of the season 10 finale by 6 months! Then the 10C bonus episodes were just whack
if anything we agree on the snow
Fear the Hunters is definitely A tier, but in comparison to the show it's hard. Because the resolution at Terminus is dope but it's a dumb plot device at the end of S4 to get everybody together again.
But Fear the hunters is fucking sick. It feels like sheer horror in a horror series. It's a simple stand alone story and it starts with us being scared of them and then flipping it around to us being scared of our main characters.
the show has so many moments where you have to suspend that disbelief wayy more than the comic, like you said them all meeting at terminus and another i can think of is morgan finding that map abe left behind, but honestly i think if you just go with it it makes for a better and more gripping story, s4b where they're all travelling separately is some of the best of the show imo and them meeting at the farm was perhaps more realistic but more boring
i dont think its a dumb plot device. the comic version of rick meeting glenn and back together with everyone is not bad, but doesnt really give much beside a reunion
It's not dumb at all
Volume 1 was kinda boring to me and I can't feel anything besides the show did it so much justice. It's one of the few times I feel like the show blew the comics out of the water. But it's not like there are no redeeming qualities, the writing is witty and creative, the characters are all pretty interesting, and unlike the show, every character that is important gets a lot of time to show us their personality. Carl killing shane was a carefully made scene that would progress Carl's character. It would groom him for the horrible setting. The 2 issues where they go to the neighborhood and they find out it's filled with zombies is where the pacing falls flat. It's the only reason I think the show did it better.
Can someone send me a link to buy all the hard back volumes? I can only find paper back ones and also I can't ever find the colored ones
What were the rumors about Judith and Lori?
⚠️Huge potential spoilers for last part of season 11. Somewhat likely these are true, so open at your own risk⚠️
In the comic, Lori and Judith are both shot at the prison - rumors say that Rosita and Coco are getting that death sometime in 11C.
15:50 what are the rumours?
Spoilers, I guess?
Originally there were rumors/spoilers that both Rosita and Coco (her baby) would get Lori and Judith's death from the comic. Obviously, that didn't turn out to be entirely correct though.
15:44 what rumors?
Difficult task because they are all so good
That is an understatement 😅😬
Oooohhh fuck yeah.
When are you gonna make a tier list of all the characters
Maybe very soon 👀
@@KorotoTVNot to sound annoying but when is very soon?
I think for both show and comic post prison to no way out is the best run of the entire story
For the show I would agree, but for what I feel works for the story and themes as well as for my own personal taste I disagree for the comic
Andrew Lincoln wanted to leave the show so I can't be mad at the show for him not being in it, and I think they did a really great job of keeping the show interesting without him and utilising a lot of the rest of the characters a lot better. No one can replace him but I didn't struggle to watch the show without him because it was still better than season 7 and 8. Obviously it wouldve been better if he was still in it, but season 9 is still one of my favourite seasons, but if it weren't for Rick's final episodes it probably wouldn't be
You doing invincible?
I haven't read the comic, so probably not. I absolutely loved the show and kind of want to remain blind for the rest of the story 😄
What was the rumor? 😅
My old man memory doesn't remember what rumors I mentioned and I don't want to watch myself ramble for an hour lmao, but I might've been talking about Rosita. There were rumors that she'd get Lori's death from the comics - so both her and the baby get shot.
the show is so much better compared to the comics
What are the rumours?
⚠️Huge potential spoilers for last part of season 11. Somewhat likely these are true, so open at your own risk⚠️
In the comic, Lori and Judith are both shot at the prison - rumors say that Rosita and Coco are getting that death sometime in 11C.
@@KorotoTV ohhh I'm not gonna read that 😂 I thought you meant about Lori or Sarah Wayhe Callies in season 3
F
AHHHHHHHHHHHH ur so cute
Wtf??
I didnt love the end of the series unfortunately
Moral of the video : the comics did 98% of everything better than the show after Shane’s death. They really dropped the ball with the prison arc in the show
the last volume is the best.
F
F
F