what a wonderful talk, when i was 4-5 we left Manhatten and moved to Virginia, to a small town outside Richmond, where me and my little band of hunter - gatherers roamed about the countryside. one day we exploring a road when we picked a un welcome friend-a german shepherd clearly stalking us. we huddled and we felt that we had to do something, we csme across a constuction crew working on the road and we pointed to the dog and they shooed it away. did i mention to my parents at dinner of my little adventure? maybe, maybe not, either way my parents would never would put limits on how far i could go with my friends, it never would have occured to them, but that was the 1950's
I think its cause we cant take risks in school u don’t think outside the box your cupped in it not seeing your talents being told to go to college graduates be a lawyer but thats not your passion thats what society thinks And in school we don’t learn the things we want to be cause were constantly told what to be
I love the talk because I have a 4 and 8 year old right now. It's very difficult raising them in this world where everyone is so afraid of the boogie man jumping out from around the corner.
Oh? That's interesting. They've changed the name from 'Modern Childhood Is Strange'. But that was clearly the crux of Amir's point! Now the title on TH-cam is 'How Industrialization Changed Childhood' What's it going to be next week?
"Naturalistic fallacy" ?? Living naturally is a fallacy? Once again "gong back to nature" implies a regression, an impossible one at that. That humans have no choice but to be dragged into the tech-death kind of living... and that it is somehow progress. We are as much nature as a tree. The added faculty of self-reflection does not one bit mitigate or eliminate the fact that our bodies, minds, emotions have the same needs they have for tens of thousands of years. The lack and distortion of such needs is sorely evident in Western culture and society today. Ms Amir is to be lauded for her talk in principle, but there is this flaw in perception, undoubtedly part of the conditioning she was born into and has not yet questioned.
"Common Sense" is quaint and parochial until it can be vetted by the Scientific Method. That is what all "Soft Sciences" may strive to become, a means to answer the really difficult problems that Physics and Mathematics can't resolve by themselves.
This is not shaming. This compares anthropology's perspective of cultural differences; maybe you are unfamiliar with this concept. Check it out. It is fascinating how anthropologists use this lens to look at the different issues of the world and society issues. This talk was excellent and so informative. I had an unstructured play, and I am very grateful for it. There must be a balance, and parents must teach children how to live as adults correctly because some children lead each other blindly. This is how children get pulled into the wrong crowds. Thanks for this talk!
what a wonderful talk, when i was 4-5 we left Manhatten and moved to Virginia, to a small town outside Richmond, where me and my little band of hunter - gatherers roamed about the countryside. one day we exploring a road when we picked a un welcome friend-a german shepherd clearly stalking us. we huddled and we felt that we had to do something, we csme across a constuction crew working on the road and we pointed to the dog and they shooed it away. did i mention to my parents at dinner of my little adventure?
maybe, maybe not, either way my parents would never would put limits on how far i could go with my friends, it never would have occured to them, but that was the 1950's
"...allow you to do mistakes" is a bingo in your talk, bravo!
This video pretty much sums up why I began to hate going to school by middle school. I think we keep kids cooped up for way too many hours everyday.
I think its cause we cant take risks in school u don’t think outside the box your cupped in it not seeing your talents being told to go to college graduates be a lawyer but thats not your passion thats what society thinks And in school we don’t learn the things we want to be cause were constantly told what to be
I love the talk because I have a 4 and 8 year old right now. It's very difficult raising them in this world where everyone is so afraid of the boogie man jumping out from around the corner.
Thank you for the amazing talk
The talk makes lot of sense to me.
замечательная девушка, спасибо огромное за видео :)
wow..insightful.
Oh? That's interesting. They've changed the name from 'Modern Childhood Is Strange'.
But that was clearly the crux of Amir's point!
Now the title on TH-cam is 'How Industrialization Changed Childhood'
What's it going to be next week?
I genuinely remember when the street light came on was the time to head home, and there were no cell phones. Those were the days.
You are describing a Montessori environment.
wow...
Kids need to go outside and play in their neighborhood. That's real unstructured play 😂😂😂😂
Wonderful but this is also pretty much what Maria Montessori observed 100yrs ago
"Naturalistic fallacy" ?? Living naturally is a fallacy? Once again "gong back to nature" implies a regression, an impossible one at that. That humans have no choice but to be dragged into the tech-death kind of living... and that it is somehow progress. We are as much nature as a tree. The added faculty of self-reflection does not one bit mitigate or eliminate the fact that our bodies, minds, emotions have the same needs they have for tens of thousands of years. The lack and distortion of such needs is sorely evident in Western culture and society today. Ms Amir is to be lauded for her talk in principle, but there is this flaw in perception, undoubtedly part of the conditioning she was born into and has not yet questioned.
Just Google "naturalistic fallacy"
I agree
ure beautiful
The social sciences are so quaint. Where else can you get a degree by describing common sense with jargon?
"Common Sense" is quaint and parochial until it can be vetted by the Scientific Method. That is what all "Soft Sciences" may strive to become, a means to answer the really difficult problems that Physics and Mathematics can't resolve by themselves.
This would have been a good video except for the C-section and formula shaming.
The only shame felt from c-sections or formula feeding comes from guilt/regret that you didn’t make an informed choice you were proud of
This is not shaming. This compares anthropology's perspective of cultural differences; maybe you are unfamiliar with this concept. Check it out. It is fascinating how anthropologists use this lens to look at the different issues of the world and society issues. This talk was excellent and so informative. I had an unstructured play, and I am very grateful for it. There must be a balance, and parents must teach children how to live as adults correctly because some children lead each other blindly. This is how children get pulled into the wrong crowds. Thanks for this talk!
just need to swap Western with American and you're good.