Not only is ur music highly technically polished and skilled, it is totally unique. I have never heard anything sound like this before. Totally unprecedented
thank god for the algorithm. i am listening to this again, just before bed, thanks to YT suggesting it...could not remember if i had listened to it already...
@@averynhiell: I agree, but overall I think this is a fantastic composition, and I say that as an appreciator of fugues. As for a climax, my go-to measuring stick for such is always the middle section of Bach's _Contrapunctus VIII_ where we finally arrive on the dominant and all the subjects weave together a haunting climax to the entire piece.
Thanks a lot! I would feel honoured. Here is the score: musescore.com/user/28825706/scores/9169905 If you upload it anywhere, please send me a link so I can appreciate it. (=
@@averynhiell Hello, i've tried sending you the link here though i think it gets automodded? anyways i uploaded it to musescore my nickname being Cristhianmcam
@@KlausMorstHi! (: Thank you, I like it. I noticed you changed the melody in some parts. I have little experience with arrangements. Did you change them for playability purposes? I find the new melodies quite pleasing! ^^
@@averynhiell Glad you liked it! i had thought i sent it like a month ago but the comment does get eliminated if it has a link, I first changed the registers of several parts so it'd match the register of the instruments, in the cello part there were low B1s in several parts that i switched to a B2, i then tried to fill up the spaces where instruments would not play for too long, i tried using the motifs that have already appeared on the piece like on measure 61, the cello and viola parts i composed them based on what was directly before, and the violins were originally lower parts that i had brought up and it sounded really good, but i also took a bit of liberty to compose some others melodies on top, measure 69 i added the extra melody in the second violin, top of the other 3 regular motifs which blends into the other, measure 86-88 i completely recreated it, i really struggled with that one since it sounded off everytime i tried anything but i came up with something pleasant at the end, and M.114 might be my favorite because of the 2nd violin's melody, might be a bit exaggerated or out of style but i thought it would fit overall, there are other changes but they are minor details and i did them on whims. In terms of playability would be more so coordination between the string players since they need to sync up a lot of 16th notes, but i played the cello part and it was a lot less difficult than what it seems so i'm sure the other parts are all right, though i'll have to see when i actually play it with other string players lol.
@klausmorst Hi! I’m sorry I haven’t replied, TH-cam didn’t notify me about your reply. :( Thank you for the extensive explanation! That’s very interesting, especially because I’m studying instrumentation at the moment. Have you learnt instrumentation with a professional teacher or just casually?
btw, i was reading in another post a discussion with a man offering to perform or record your stuff live on a piano...i know of two diff women in ukraine that also do that, and, allegedly, affordabley
@@eytonshalomsandiego Hi, thank you! Are the names of the two Ukrainian women Polina Chorna and Marina Pierova by any chance? What’s the name of the person you mentioned?
Not only is ur music highly technically polished and skilled, it is totally unique. I have never heard anything sound like this before. Totally unprecedented
Wow, thank you so much! This is exactly what I am aiming for. (=
thank god for the algorithm. i am listening to this again, just before bed, thanks to YT suggesting it...could not remember if i had listened to it already...
@@eytonshalomsandiego Thank you! ^^
Absolutely beautiful fugue subject! Came across this while reviewing the pianist's past performances, and loved it.
Thank you so much! I appreciate it. ɛ›
Beautiful
@@manyids2 Thanks a lot! (=
Amazing and beautiful.
Thank you so much! (=
Very nice!
Thank you! ^^
Wonderful - all in all. But it needs a real Baroque climax! You have re-entered Bach;'s mind. CPE - I think!
Thank you! (:
Yes, I also think a clearer climax would make sense.
@@averynhiell:
I agree, but overall I think this is a fantastic composition, and I say that as an appreciator of fugues. As for a climax, my go-to measuring stick for such is always the middle section of Bach's _Contrapunctus VIII_ where we finally arrive on the dominant and all the subjects weave together a haunting climax to the entire piece.
@@hoon_sol Thanks a lot! And thank you for the tip. ^^
Extremely fine, I would add a slightly longer and more dramatic peroration. It's more memorable than the D minor one.
Thank you so much! Yes, I’m often told that my peroration is too sudden. I’m trying to work on it. ^^
Meraviglia❤
Grazie!
Hello! I love your fugue! Do you mind if i make a string quartet arrangement of it?
Thanks a lot! I would feel honoured. Here is the score:
musescore.com/user/28825706/scores/9169905
If you upload it anywhere, please send me a link so I can appreciate it. (=
@@averynhiell Hello, i've tried sending you the link here though i think it gets automodded? anyways i uploaded it to musescore my nickname being Cristhianmcam
@@KlausMorstHi! (: Thank you, I like it. I noticed you changed the melody in some parts. I have little experience with arrangements. Did you change them for playability purposes? I find the new melodies quite pleasing! ^^
@@averynhiell Glad you liked it! i had thought i sent it like a month ago but the comment does get eliminated if it has a link, I first changed the registers of several parts so it'd match the register of the instruments, in the cello part there were low B1s in several parts that i switched to a B2, i then tried to fill up the spaces where instruments would not play for too long, i tried using the motifs that have already appeared on the piece like on measure 61, the cello and viola parts i composed them based on what was directly before, and the violins were originally lower parts that i had brought up and it sounded really good, but i also took a bit of liberty to compose some others melodies on top, measure 69 i added the extra melody in the second violin, top of the other 3 regular motifs which blends into the other, measure 86-88 i completely recreated it, i really struggled with that one since it sounded off everytime i tried anything but i came up with something pleasant at the end, and M.114 might be my favorite because of the 2nd violin's melody, might be a bit exaggerated or out of style but i thought it would fit overall, there are other changes but they are minor details and i did them on whims.
In terms of playability would be more so coordination between the string players since they need to sync up a lot of 16th notes, but i played the cello part and it was a lot less difficult than what it seems so i'm sure the other parts are all right, though i'll have to see when i actually play it with other string players lol.
@klausmorst Hi! I’m sorry I haven’t replied, TH-cam didn’t notify me about your reply. :(
Thank you for the extensive explanation! That’s very interesting, especially because I’m studying instrumentation at the moment. Have you learnt instrumentation with a professional teacher or just casually?
makes me want to cry, as JSB so often does.....i have always been moved by A minor...now i am a bit afraid of listening to the D minor...
Wow! This is all I want for my music to do. Thank you so much!
This is the finer, because of the the mixture of slow and quick between the head and tail parts of the subject.
@@MartinSmithMFM Thank you! ^^
You are a genius! Kudos!
Thank you so much! (=
Nice piece. Is this meant to be played by 2 pianists? A lot of the parts seem impossible to play by 1 person simultaneously.
Thank you! Yes, this is a duet. The pianist recorded the primo and the secondo separately.
Could be for organ with some adjustments.
btw, i was reading in another post a discussion with a man offering to perform or record your stuff live on a piano...i know of two diff women in ukraine that also do that, and, allegedly, affordabley
@@eytonshalomsandiego Hi, thank you! Are the names of the two Ukrainian women Polina Chorna and Marina Pierova by any chance? What’s the name of the person you mentioned?
@@averynhiell i believe so , but i have to look it up, its on a you tube comment from a year ago, i will look...Polina very much rings a bell...
@@eytonshalomsandiego Yeah, that would be interesting to know. ^^