In one of the camp endings the player remembers all the way back to forest when Pony is talking about he infected Doggy because Willow forced him. So I don't believe this theory is true but it is a great theory.
1. The hunt is not cannon 2. It was confirmed that finley themself, the locations, easter eggs, and notes are cannon but the time travel is not. 3. All endings are cannon on their own timelines
Last time I heard a theory so complex, it was 2 years ago, you got talent man, the only problem is that Minitoon said the time travelling wasn't canon, but everything adds up. Amazing theory.
1 hunt is completely not canon other than locations 2- factory split it in 3, as the player straight up dies if they save noone 3- hidden ending isn’t the main or true timeline as all timelines for book 2 are canon 4- eddy and Finley were together for the south ruins expedition, which is their connection
But I’m surprised you watch my video, also it was videos like yours and other creators like Kreek craft who inspired me to make these types of videos so thx for that 😁
1st: The time travel is no canon, only the locations are. 2nd: The Detective had an objective or a reason to stay unstead of leave, (like Alleys, Station, School, Metro, Carnival, Mall, Outpost, Plant, Refinery, Ship, Camp and Lab)
Even though most of the base info you’ve used are debunked and non-canon confirmed by Minitoon, it’s still a good theory! I’ve never thought of this before, but it’s still an interesting thing to think about!
when u said that finley is selfish that also explains why he said finders keepers and throws the egg at us cuz he wanted it for himself not to share with it
Actually, about ur theory in 1:56 , if we did take bunny from the metro, then Decay wouldnt even be here, which is supposed to be canon cuz minitoon said he will eventually add in a book 3 based on Decay or smth and it also kinda does contain loads of info about piggy lore.
Wow, just wow. I am speechless, i can't fathom how good the editing of the video is and your theory, it actually makes sense to be honest! I think it's a really good theory!
this could be true if the time travelling was cannon, and what if the hunt (canonically) set place in between 3 - 4 so when he hit us with the golden egg he sent us to safe place and that's why we didn't know what was happening so George had to wake us up.
lots of stuff to debunk while finley and the locations are canon, the time travel aspect is not a canonical occurence. There is no timeline to be ruined when the thing that does so doesn't even exist. the hunt is a seperate timeline on itself. For station, you dont go to a station with intentions of getting help, hearing your best friend from the speakers and then going out. As for metro, bunny was immediately infected in decay, seeing the uninfected as infected. She would have killed us so fast in the train. Also "Help find mr p faster"??? Mr p flew away with his helicopter to the plant, not to the carnival. in factory, the whispers come from insolence eyes. Yeahh... finley doesnt have any relation with tio. great video though, i love that flawed theories are slowly coming back, dont be ashamed because its no diffferent than the kreekcraft theories we used to feast on in 2020 and 2021
Although some parts to this may not work as the Hunt is apparently not canon, I absolutely LOVE this theory! It's been about 2 years since we uad deep theories on Piggy like this, and we appreciate the time you took to make this. Although it may not be true, I'll just pretend it is, simply because its an entertaining theory. Good theory video 👏
This could give a small explanation to the ending scene in the decay chapter where the speaker says that the timeline of book 1 could have gone very differently. Either this is teasing something new coming or it’s just more intercity teasing
fr extra chapters aren’t even canon and how is Finely the antagonist if he isn’t the one who controls minds? How? And he didn’t even start the infection. That’s like saying “Mimi works for the insolence because moles like to dig underground and in the hidden ending cutscene the infected rose up from the ground” when most of them aren’t even moles
Finley: ok guys I’m so done with life, I’m gonna *breathes* walk now 2024: *not enough air to breath because Finley accidentally breathed too much oxygen and now Earth is splitting apart because Finley also walked too hard*
Actually all the notes and stuff is cannon and so is Finley so there is nothing stopping this theory except for the fact that we don’t know WHEN he took us
@@Imagetwagon the notes and finley are indeed canon, but they have nothing to do with the time travelling. The time travelling and our quest to help finley isn't canon, but everything else is
@@slaoqeubotoaq well if finely is cannon and we arw cannon that would mean that we are opening all these doors and attracting all these monsters at once however the infected will always be targeting someone til theres no one left so if they weren’t targeting us then they would have targeted other pll possibly making a paradox of ether getting ataced or not Also if we got knocked out at the end and we were in the past that would mean we couldn’t have been doing what we were doing at said time making a paradox
@@danielfelipecorreamontano7085 Actually minitoon said all endings are canon but on different timelines, but everyone (including minitoon) basically has a consent that "ok hidden ending is the true one let's forget about the rest". He did that because the ending doesnt affect Intercity And that scene of Breakout was bc minitoon wanted to show us a bit of Tigry and Willow after that timeline in specific
![[#2024MAMA] G-DRAGON - 무제(Untitled, 2014)+POWER+HOME SWEET HOME+뱅뱅뱅+FANTASTIC BABY | Mnet 241123 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Ox29z5Nf1Uk/mqdefault.jpg)
Btw I don’t hate Finley I actually like the character, I just had this idea of floating in my head 😅
In one of the camp endings the player remembers all the way back to forest when Pony is talking about he infected Doggy because Willow forced him. So I don't believe this theory is true but it is a great theory.
This is a good theory!!!! OH MY- 🎉
1. The hunt is not cannon
2. It was confirmed that finley themself, the locations, easter eggs, and notes are cannon but the time travel is not.
3. All endings are cannon on their own timelines
By canon they mean like the main storyline yknow
@@SomeObjectShow1338You know what he meant
The hunt was canon. In the castle map, there are multiple insolence notes and draw in the bedroom, about TIO and Mr. Stitchy.
@michelmse19 that's why I said the MAPS are cannon but the time travel isnt.
@@michelmse19 It's just to tell a bit more about the Insolence
btw mimitoon confirmed we went to the station to find someone not to escape and time travel isn't cannon
minitoon said the time chapter is canon.
@@StupidYTDude only the area not the Time Machine
@@Redto504 oh ok
yes the map is canon but also Finley is canon, mentioned in one of his streams and the mansion chapter end cutscene
And also the bots @@Redto504
Last time I heard a theory so complex, it was 2 years ago, you got talent man, the only problem is that Minitoon said the time travelling wasn't canon, but everything adds up. Amazing theory.
I appreciate it mate😁
1:56 good point, but bunny was infected... so player could die
Even thought Minitoon said the Time Traveling was not canon, I LOVE this theory. I can’t wait to see all the next theories you got cooking up!👌
4:28 NAHHH I CAN'T TAKE THE BROS AVATAR ANYMORE💀💀💀💀💀
Halloween🎃
1 hunt is completely not canon other than locations
2- factory split it in 3, as the player straight up dies if they save noone
3- hidden ending isn’t the main or true timeline as all timelines for book 2 are canon
4- eddy and Finley were together for the south ruins expedition, which is their connection
I’m aware of that now everyone’s telling me this but either way👍
But I’m surprised you watch my video, also it was videos like yours and other creators like Kreek craft who inspired me to make these types of videos so thx for that 😁
2:03 the reason we can split the timeline is because minitoon just thought it would be a cool idea lol
0:58 thanks for adding this in because I was so confused on which ending was canon.
1st: The time travel is no canon, only the locations are.
2nd: The Detective had an objective or a reason to stay unstead of leave, (like Alleys, Station, School, Metro, Carnival, Mall, Outpost, Plant, Refinery, Ship, Camp and Lab)
“Time travel is no canon” get your winning smile ass out of here and get some grammar
@@JohnFKennedyforeverPoor bro
@@JohnFKennedyforever If the time travel of Time was really canon, trust me it would have changed everything we use to know.
In Metro, Bunny purposefully wanted to stay (to fight the infected according to her) , so we couldn't really take her with us even with the option
@@mattpro1318 ok but that’s not what I was replying to you about
Even though most of the base info you’ve used are debunked and non-canon confirmed by Minitoon, it’s still a good theory! I’ve never thought of this before, but it’s still an interesting thing to think about!
when u said that finley is selfish that also explains why he said finders keepers and throws the egg at us cuz he wanted it for himself not to share with it
In a minimoon episode minitoon revealed that
1. Hunt is not related to the storyline
2. Mansion was set before the infection
BUT FINLEY STILL EXISTS😊
You mean infection 🤓👆
@@EpikDucks-o1x I said infection
Its been a long time since i Heard a theory good like this keep the good work bc thats a w one
Actually, about ur theory in 1:56 , if we did take bunny from the metro, then Decay wouldnt even be here, which is supposed to be canon cuz minitoon said he will eventually add in a book 3 based on Decay or smth and it also kinda does contain loads of info about piggy lore.
I know u kinda did make just a theory but still, 🤷
Wow, just wow. I am speechless, i can't fathom how good the editing of the video is and your theory, it actually makes sense to be honest! I think it's a really good theory!
Thx I’m glad you enjoyed it 😃
This would’ve worked so well if it wasn’t for time traveling not being canon.
I always like when people try to make a game mechanic only meant to be a game mechanic make sense in the lore
the moment he got to the amnesia part it immediately sounded like he didn't know what he was talking about
Litteraly “time traveler: kicks a rock, the timeline” moment
this could be true if the time travelling was cannon, and what if the hunt (canonically) set place in between 3 - 4 so when he hit us with the golden egg he sent us to safe place and that's why we didn't know what was happening so George had to wake us up.
Thats what I was going to add but I forgot 😅
@@DaJ4K3 lol no wonder
lots of stuff to debunk
while finley and the locations are canon, the time travel aspect is not a canonical occurence. There is no timeline to be ruined when the thing that does so doesn't even exist. the hunt is a seperate timeline on itself.
For station, you dont go to a station with intentions of getting help, hearing your best friend from the speakers and then going out. As for metro, bunny was immediately infected in decay, seeing the uninfected as infected. She would have killed us so fast in the train. Also "Help find mr p faster"??? Mr p flew away with his helicopter to the plant, not to the carnival.
in factory, the whispers come from insolence eyes. Yeahh... finley doesnt have any relation with tio.
great video though, i love that flawed theories are slowly coming back, dont be ashamed because its no diffferent than the kreekcraft theories we used to feast on in 2020 and 2021
Let this guy become a doctor
bro you should make a theory channel about piggy man
thats what almost 5 years of piggy hyperfocus gets you (i am clinically insane)
i see someone else who's stuck with piggy for years on end collecting as much info as you can get on it
@@beofficer believe it or not i did not pay attention at all with the lore during book 1. I only ever caught up with it in the book 2 release hiatus
Although some parts to this may not work as the Hunt is apparently not canon, I absolutely LOVE this theory!
It's been about 2 years since we uad deep theories on Piggy like this, and we appreciate the time you took to make this.
Although it may not be true, I'll just pretend it is, simply because its an entertaining theory. Good theory video 👏
finley could also be the reason for the (in universe) redesigns of characters, putting the player inside a universe where everything looks nicer
Amazing theories 😮
Ohhhh, more piggy lore, i like it (๑˃̵ ᴗ ˂̵)و❤❤❤❤❤❤
Awesome Theory
This could give a small explanation to the ending scene in the decay chapter where the speaker says that the timeline of book 1 could have gone very differently. Either this is teasing something new coming or it’s just more intercity teasing
Although everyone is saying it’s not possible cus it’s canon, it could just be another universe, because this theory is pretty good.
since minitoon confirmed time travel doesn’t exist / isn’t canon in piggy, this could be a good headcanon/au for piggy instead! :3
my mind is blowed with lore rn
buddy just pulled this theory out his ass😂
fr extra chapters aren’t even canon
and how is Finely the antagonist if he isn’t the one who controls minds? How? And he didn’t even start the infection. That’s like saying “Mimi works for the insolence because moles like to dig underground and in the hidden ending cutscene the infected rose up from the ground” when most of them aren’t even moles
@@L3001-r6ddecay is Canon tho
@@L3001-r6dim pretty sure some of them are cannon
my brain is melting rn, i wacth alot of gametheory but this is too much
I was having trouble myself as well😭
I feel like more choices could make the game better
Minitoon said that the Hunt chapter is not cannon.
Good analysis man!
Finley could’ve stopped the infection because he has a Time Machine what an absolute idiot
What app or site you use for do video like that ?
Capcup, I’m getting better at editing
capcut? I also use capcut
Bro i love this, u gotta be the Piggy MatPat other than Kreek ❤
Bro had the most interesting theroy i’ve ever seen in piggy’s theroy’s history
Nah, it was actually clowny and Dinopiggy this while time
Really interesting theory!
I don't agree with this but the editing is top tier!
Finley: ok guys I’m so done with life, I’m gonna *breathes* walk now
2024: *not enough air to breath because Finley accidentally breathed too much oxygen and now Earth is splitting apart because Finley also walked too hard*
THIS IS SUCH A GOOD THEORY
Top evil characters:
1 FINLEY!!!! 💀
2 TIO
3 Mr Stitchy
4 Mr p
i believe the knight in the hunt chapter is probably not infected.
Thats why tio is in the piggy universe
it was him the all time...
Nice theory but I believe we are able to change time-line bc yk... we can?
"It's been -Finley- all along"
Imagine if one day the insolence teams up with the player to stop finley from destroying the universe
I like this theory
The hunt isn't canon BUT the locations we visit are
Good theory (but hey that just a theory A GAME THEORY)
Question when finely took us in time when was that
If anyone doesn't like this, it's just a theory, A GAME THEORY-
That was so confusing 😭
The time traveling isn't canon, only Finley and his personality
SO UNDERRATEEEEEEEEDFF
2:33 Vsauce mentioned
What if Piggy is supposed to be a representation of covid🧐
No, because when minitoon made Piggy as a joke covid was only starting, but it wasnt a global lockdown yet
@@slaoqeubotoaqbut 2020 was when Covid spread everywhere
@@christianguzman-beltran-dh2yc yeah but when piggy released covid wasnt as big as it would be
In book 1 chapter 7 bunny was infected so thats why we can’t bring her or we’ll die to
that makes a lot of sense
THE LORE!
bro what are these copy and paste ah comments:
"1. ThE TiME TravELLinG Is NoT CANoN
2. OnLY tHE MaPS ANd nOtES arE CAnON"
Eddie tells Finley that something's bad's gonna happen so that's just the thing I gotta tell you just to complete that If people don't think that
A canon event(nah jk that was 1 year ago)
1 HOUR AGO!?
COOL!
4:23 I'm WAY more bothered about how you gave the weapons to tigry and not willow to be honest
cuz tigry better
@@Kry-robloxyt how much did Tigry pay you to say that
is as easy as just assuming neither the hunt nor the rb battles are canon, problem solved
i sitil think it’s mr p or tio but good thorey
I did NOT ruin the timeline >:[
Yes u did 😡
@@TheRealQuackQuack >:[
@@DatFinIey64 hey you when yo skin comeing out
@@MyatheBlade22 Never
Yeah yeah right -_-
It’s game theory and piggy
Why is fucking finley hurt us at end of hunt event
The time travelling isn't canon
Actually all the notes and stuff is cannon and so is Finley so there is nothing stopping this theory except for the fact that we don’t know WHEN he took us
@@Imagetwagon the notes and finley are indeed canon, but they have nothing to do with the time travelling. The time travelling and our quest to help finley isn't canon, but everything else is
@@slaoqeubotoaq wait doesn’t that create a paradox
@@Imagetwagon no?
@@slaoqeubotoaq well if finely is cannon and we arw cannon that would mean that we are opening all these doors and attracting all these monsters at once however the infected will always be targeting someone til theres no one left so if they weren’t targeting us then they would have targeted other pll possibly making a paradox of ether getting ataced or not
Also if we got knocked out at the end and we were in the past that would mean we couldn’t have been doing what we were doing at said time making a paradox
Um Decay already came out dud
what is bro yapping about😭😭😭
:0
It -it all males sense now…
Hmmm....
what
the hunt is not canon
It is, but the time travel aspect is not.
@@yutubechannel-Y only finley as a character is canon because he makes a cameo in the mansion chapter
Wtf Wenda is doing here
@@Hol1dayNoelle Finley, the maps, the easter eggs and the notes are canon
So the kingdom is actually canon because it’s where Tio lives and you can find drawings and a plushy of Mr Stitchy
Meh
Hidden Ending was never confirmed to be canon
Bruh, it is , at the end of breakout we can see tigry walking with willow with his purple scarf and black jacket, HIDDEN ENDING IT IS CANONN'¡¡¡¡
That's just a lie
Me when I spread misinformation:
The Breakout Chapter
@@danielfelipecorreamontano7085 Actually minitoon said all endings are canon but on different timelines, but everyone (including minitoon) basically has a consent that "ok hidden ending is the true one let's forget about the rest". He did that because the ending doesnt affect Intercity
And that scene of Breakout was bc minitoon wanted to show us a bit of Tigry and Willow after that timeline in specific
Bro had the most interesting theroy i’ve ever seen in piggy’s theroy’s history