As an Asian immigrant I found rural southerners to be apprehensive at the beginning but become very warm neighbors with a bit of understanding. I live in California now and people are much more rude and trapped in their own heads.
We had a Vietnamese refugee family come to Wilkes-Barre when I was at Kings, We raise food and furniture and Winter clothes for them , Catholic charities were their sponsor.
Glad you enjoyed the rural South. I'm not quite from the South. I'm from the Appalachian mountains of WV. For us in rural America, we have a history of being abused by outsiders. In my state, coal companies came in and ruined the land and economy. It's tough because our experiences have made us a lot less trusting at first. Now, we have folks from CA and NY taking advantage of our low cost of living and driving up the property values, and some talk about how ignorant we are. I understand your point about CA. Many folks there don't even try to understand or empathize with their fellow American.
@@nuclearwessels2078 When I lived in Vietnam, we knew all our neighbors' families, what they did for work, and even their extended families for two blocks over. Sometimes I yearn for that sense of community here in the US and I think I'll only find it in rural areas. Many CA folks spend a lot of time consuming information online not to find insight but to look down on others who spent their time elsewhere.
@@nuclearwessels2078 I lived on a large commune in rural East Tenasee in the 1970s. They were Vegan, in an uninformed way, and the food simply was not sufficient for a 13-year-old boy to remain healthy on. So I used to sneak off and bum food off the neighbors. They checked every stereotypical box for "hillbillies," drank moon shine, chewed tobacco, possessed and used guns, but they were so nice to me, despite their own poverty. Plus, I enjoyed experimenting with those vices myself. Ever since then, though I am every bit the West Coast urban educated leftist, I have had a soft spot for the Appalachians. Sadly, dispste the fact that the left has always proclaimed that working class and poor people of all races and location should unite, there are certain"Culture war"issues that hold us back. And that powers that be, unfortunately, like to play on and distract us with those, to keep us divided.
As a white person who visits tons of rural areas for work, the locals are typically apprehensive about all newcomers/visitors at first, regardless of race. Then, when they get to know you, most are very sweet and welcoming.
I am a Black liberal College educated individual and trust me White rural folks have a lot to be upset about and blaming them for the insanity in the world is crazy! How about we listen to each other for a change instead of labeling each other racist because we have different views. Wake up put the poison of arrogance down and try some compassion and love for each other instead. One Luv 🙏☀️
When social media - entertainment- schools-colleges-government-press is control my majority of liberals. Republicans have the Supreme Court. That’s it.
I am a black person neither Liberal or Conservative but they are to blame for many of their situations. One example is ACA they were so against it.. Started a Tea Party movement like it 1770’s. They were uninsured and couldn’t even afford their basic medicine and many rural clinics were closing due to NO funding so Obama put out the ACA Guess what it got passed ALL Democrats and with the help of 2 Republicans both women… Now what happened the uninsured rates went down drastically and POOR people in Arkansas and Kentucky both white and black benefited from this…. Fast forward they voted for people in the house and Senate that want to take away their healthcare. This is just one example now as a brother in college educated you don’t remember this👏🏽
I’m a 26 year old black woman who worked on a farm in a white rural area for over a year in south Louisiana. Not once did I ever feel uncomfortable or discriminated against. The owners are what these men would call “White Christian Nationalist” and they call me their adopted daughter. They call me for my birthday and I still go back to visit. They would literally tell me they love me every day before I would leave for the day, and I knew they meant it. It really baffles me to see that these guys really believe what they are writing. I’m not saying there aren’t people out there like that, however I don’t believe for one second that is the majority of white rural America. I also grew up in a white rural area, I did not experience what they are describing in any capacity.
In my experience as a black man who worked in rual America for over 20 years. 99.9% of people you meet couldn't care less about skin color. Charactor, morals, work ethic, thats what rual America cares about. Of course, every group had its undesirables, but to write off an entire group over 2 or 3 idiots makes zero sense.
Yep, came to the US, started up a business in the ethanol industry. The only people I still call and check up on are the original people I met, when I had to startup in a very rural part of Kansas. Saw through that nonsense when I was given a warning about the "racism" present in rural areas. It's unreal the level of self hate whether it be black, brown or beige than from the folks in the cities and offices. When I told them I intended to hire and trust someone who had a understanding of the land to start my business, regardless of credentials or education, because that makes sense in the field; I was immediately scoffed at and they told me I'd fail. That same phrasing explained to my business manager when I hired him was common sense. My old man raised me to always approach situations with humility and understand if you are privileged in wealth, you need to be in step with your understanding of different situations, and give grace where due, since no man is greater than the other under the Lord. These people are the definition of hubris and cringe. Same type of people always talking about therapy but never going themselves, really going, since they're scared to even face what's broken, let alone begin to fix it. Never understanding the first step has to come from themselves, it's not possible otherwise.
I agree . So comforting to read comments like yours . I hear people like those in mainstream media telling lies day after day repeating lies as facts I gotta think they are paid to do that it’s so awful! Thank you for speaking up. I want to do that more and not be silenced. These types are smug and so convinced it’s spooky
Tell that to them: Rev. Clementa C. Pinckney (41) - the senior pastor of the church and a South Carolina state senator. Cynthia Hurd (54) - a manager for the Charleston County Public Library system. Rev. Sharonda Coleman-Singleton (45) - a church pastor, speech therapist and track coach at Goose Creek High School. Tywanza Sanders (26) - a recent graduate of Allen University, where he earned a degree in Business Administration. Ethel Lance (70) - a church sexton who had worked at the church for over 30 years. Susie Jackson (87) - a longtime member of the church and cousin to Ethel Lance. Depayne Middleton Doctor (49) - a minister at the church and retired manager for the U.S. Department of Commerce. Rev. Daniel Simmons (74) - a pastor who served at several churches. Myra Thompson (59) - a Bible study teacher at the church.
This discussion is useless as it has no purpose but to denigrate foes who have because they and does who are the have nots because the haves are achievers.
As an old, Progressive white guy who for decades lived in a poor, white, rural community, and found many of its inhabitants to be ‘salt of the earth’ people whom I admired, and who had my respect, I find this kind of attitude mortifying, shades of Hillary’s ‘Basket of deplores !’
Yeah - I am aslo an old white guy who has lived in rural communities - in fact I was raised on a farm myself - for years I considered myself a progressive/anarchist/socialist - but being allied with city liberals in the past I have to admit was a struggle.
The guns and the clinging to them is real. Ask the NRA and all the money it gives to politicians. And religion in politics is real. Ask Mike Johnson. Ask the courts in Alabama.
As a red man who has live in rural Oklahoma and Texas. The only place I was ever discriminated against was when I lived on the south side of Houston which has a lot of Democrats.
I'm a brick layer, im a black farmer, I'm a red man, I'm an Asian immigrant, I'm a Christian conservative, I'm a trans Haitian migrant and even I KNOW that these two are the racists, we're the good guys!
Liberals always decide what white, rural people are thinking, while they sit at home and talk to each other. Why don't they interview white rural people?
I think it’s the false narrative of America/hollywood/whiteness which falsely depicts that ALL white people actually live like the white people on TV..(upper middle class suburban). I think this makes the avg working class white person (who lives like Roseanne) feel ignored. This group, the actual majority is kept hushed. I think Bernie appealed to them, but the elites would not allow.
Im a white midwestern christian conservative American male. If you stopped there you still wouldnt know anything about me, my family, or my people. I am angry about what I see, because I see democracy being trampled. I went to college, we have those here. The Midwest is humble; just because we're quiet doesn't mean we aren't educated.
Glad to hear that you're angry about the man who tried to overturn the 2020 election and keep himself in power through lies and violence. Glad to hear you're against turning over even more power to the corporate oligarchs that already control our lives.
I'm so glad you are angry about Jan 6th I too join you in that. I mean democracy was attacked that day. We need to be careful to make sure it doesn't happen again.
Agree, I am a JAMAICAN Black man and I love Trump. New York Attorney General and Alvin Bragg just wanted to destroy The Donald they are financed by George Soros.
@@Mahatmajenkins . . . no surprise. It's like they just can't help themselves. I guess it's just in their nature. and then one day for no reason at all. . . they cry out in pain as they strike you!
A lot of racism. High suicide rates, drug abuse rates, and domestic violence. Mental health crisis and lack of access to healthcare due to Republican blockades.
@@Apostate1970 I hate it that you have a point. This may be a good time for all of us to remember what Churchill said about democracy being the worst form of government - except for all the other forms that have been tried.
The idea that lefties - like BLM, Antifa, MSNBC, the DSA, the Harvard faculty, and Keith Olbermann - are accusing conservatives of being *angry* is both tragic and hilarious.
Thank-you The Hill Finally a united episode from a perspective that makes sense 👏🏾...And this is from a black woman out of Massachusetts. MSNBC is a poison to this country.
I’m black and recently had a discussion with a white gentleman about moving to a particular place. He said there were too many white Christians there. I pressed him on what do I have to fear from them and what crimes are they going to commit against me. (I also used to live in South Central Los Angeles years ago so I know about living in a high crime area and WHO really commits these crimes.) He had no answers.
If an area is heavily populated with a certain demographic, then obviously, the crime will reflect that specific group doing the crime. Just like The majority of crime in corporations is done by a yt people because of the majority is white due to racism.
I'll admit in the 1990s I moved to a Christian town and had been brainwashed by the TV they were going to bully me for not being Christian. I got bullied but only for normal things lol.
I grew up in a very white, rural town in Utah. There were no black people, but there were a couple Hispanics and some Polynesians. Let me tell you, they were all super popular! And when a Ute family moved in with a son my age, we all had crushes on him. We just loved anyone who was different - but I bet liberals would say that's racist too somehow. You just can't win with them! 😂
For the same reason so many people across the world are risking their lives to illegally immigrate to the US, despite the US being “racist, fascist, and oppressive”.
IDK if elite applies to 99.9% of academics. In terms of social status or economic/knowledge output. We've got over 75% of our undergrad courses taught by adjuncts who may as well be uber drivers. On the other hand the actual professors are all gaming the system of scientific journals to defend their careers to the detriment of virtually every field of knowledge. I can't say where the money goes but I've worked inside the homes of the admins and they're the most out of touch people I've ever met who aren't major shareholders. I understand why post-secondary education is the ideal divide-and-conquer boundary to politicians. In my experience public education programs people to be uncritical and orthodox and nobody before college tells you that all the 'objective' stuff you're being taught is an intentional choice by someone with their own an agenda. I wouldn't swear that its the result of conspiracy, but whether its intentional or not the result is a separation of the tools for becoming class conscious from the sectors of the economy who could make the best use of it. TLDR: Its a dysfunctional system and the unequal distribution of the suffering it causes it exploited by politicians to keep people divided. Its not performing its role for our society or our economy but its absurdly profitable and unlikely to change any time soon.
I grew up around "rural whites" and still am proud to call some of them friends today. They are angry because they see their country moved away from a merit-based society to one that gives preferences to people based on race and gender. They are angry because they see their country in chaos with the borders open and no consequences for people who break the law.
@@tedgemberling2359 Luck can be part of success, but don't pretend that behavior doesn't impact outcomes. And even if it's true that not all merit is rewarded or that certain peoples/ethnicities/demographics were held back in the past, that's not a reason to abandon reality and pretend that human outcomes are not predicted by certain behaviors. We know certain behaviors have a higher probability of good life outcomes than others. For example, graduating high school, not having kids out of wedlock/uncommitted relationships, never getting involved with the law, and always working a full-time job are more likely to produce good life outcomes than those doing the opposite. Those are simple "merit-based" behaviors that virtually every able-bodied American can do.
@@scratchpenny of course behaviors affect success. But even the ability to make good choices can be a matter of luck to some extent. The problem in America is that people with lots of money can afford to make mistakes. If you're poor you can't. Every mistake you make threatens to destroy your entire life.
Being honest, as the black male behind our group, it has been the working class rural white Americans who have been more cordial and accepting of me here in the Midwest. Having friends and relationships with them have been fruitful, and eye opening. Have there been some issues? Sure. But for the most part they've been minimal. The places I've felt most "out of place" is when I've tried to participate in the activities that take place in the wealthier, gentrified urban areas. These people, if they have a problem with minorities, maybe aren't the most vocal, but they control access to certain spaces. And when you're not welcome, they may not openly say it, but you know it.
that's because classism is a much stronger force than racism (in fact you could even argue that due to the circumstances/history in the US, our current racism is born out of classism because the two were associated for so long), but notice how you never hear them talking about classism.
@@justsomenobody889 Yeah can agree with that. It's partial. Because how could they know my class? I don't dress poorly. So they make the assumption based off the first obvious "marker". These people are class focused, but their assumptions are usually coupled with other "-isms". Like the white woman who was asked in a news interview about voucher programs for "inner city/urban" families, and her response was "Well, I'm not racist but..."
@@justsomenobody889 I'm definitely into the "conspiracy" that the timing of all of this race-based stuff and gender-based stuff isn't a coincidence. Right after occupy Wall Street, where people got really angry about the elites media Company started blasting out stories about race and gender and all of that. You could trace it all back to the aftermath of that protest. I really do think it was those people pulling the strings with media that brought us here. At the same time we had that Yuri Bezmeno stuff going on, so you had this perfect group of people who are just coming of age who could implement this.
I encourage you to guard your health. your back, knees, hands, feet, and so-on. I know you work hard. Leave some health left for when you're older like me. Having done all that, of course...I also encourage you to "Keep the Faith".😇
I'm a brick layer, im a black farmer, I'm an Asian immigrant, I'm a Christian conservative, I'm a trans Haitian migrant and even I KNOW that these two are the racists, we're the good guys!
@@SixOneNiner23 Yes, the menticide is being done on both sides. Your neighbor isn't your enemy. The people telling you your neighbors are your enemy, ARE the enemy.
If you know anything about neoliberalism over the last 40+ years you understand that non-urban Americans (it's not just white folk) have legitimate socio-economic grievances born of material decline (cost of living, inflation, de-industrialization, etc.).
Yet they choose to show their grievance through hating the immigrants or non-Christians. Really weird approach to fight the power, by attacking the less powerful.
Urbanites do not respect independent culture and ethics. With the exception of global warming they don’t appreciate the natural world and the idea that humans are caretakers of the earth.
yes, it's a specific demographic that they identify as "whites". You know that one people , the only one that actualy decided they were equal in rights and dignity, should have a say in decision making, and wanted decent work conditions. the pains in the arse.
I have heard enough opinions from Jessica to assume that she would agree with the author on all points, but am pleasantly surprised that she gets it right this time
Because she's "lived in a small town" and has "worked in those jobs" ..... which I don't believe for a second, but I'm glad she can at least see what people like that actually have to deal with on a daily basis.
She was definitely respectful and thoughtful here. Both Jessica and Brie are very intelligent even if they would both like to see a socialist country. (I'm not socialist but I totally understand wanting to see more economic fairness in society.)
I’m FBA from DC and LA who now spends time amongst rural Whites and can tell you these elites are so far out of touch it’s ridiculous. this is going to be a MAJOR issue in the coming months and years.
Dana Loesch wrote a 2016 book about the disconnect between the coastal elites and middle America: Flyover Nation: You Can't Run a Country You've Never Been To.
Rural white Christian female farmer - a little humility goes a long ways in checking your ego and biases. This is just an "attempt" at pitting urban vs rural and fanning the only flames they know how - FEAR. Us rural folk have no time for such nonsense. We are living the good life in peace.
I am a Hispanic man living in rural Texas. Never in 30 years living here have I experienced personal racism. On the other hand, I experienced it twice living in the Twin Cities, Minnesota living there 10 years.
Grew up with that kind of a sibling, older than me BTW Always obsessed with being a "step ahead" of others, always them being different, always you being "same", always when you decide to make a change and turn the page "you were fine but small changes in behavior were required", you must always be similar enough for them to compare but different enough for them to feel superior When that's no longer the case, you must put up with every bit of right on spot imagined or invented BS measure for "just in case" And now, 30 years later it finally clicked - either me, him, or both were adopted. Grandma hinted at my father's health and frankly don't care if it was him, mom, or both, really don't care about the reasons or story behind Regardless, my point being - they're obsessed and unhealthy individuals. Obsessed with change, and obsessed with "making a difference" even when there's no need for that Always be careful about the someone's inner need for thinking highly of themselves. If there's something my life has thought me it's that - normal people are able to withstand self-criticism and allow to not think self-highly all the time. These people aren't
@@343Films Oh we've got all the dystopias. Elon Musk trying to make Terminal Man while warning about I, Robot while Skynet is lecturing us about racism and I wonder about the internet itself originally called the "galactic" world wide web and it's normalization of weird stuff like Childhoods End. You name the dystopia we're probably there. Even old ones look at the west trying to chase the White Putler Whale. We've got the Biden reverse Oedipus's out there both of them.
Those "uneducated" people they are referring to (farmers, mechanics, construction workers, truck drivers etc) are far more intelligent than them. It reminds me of a comedian named Jerry Clower who once said "these people are obviously educated beyond their intelligence" referring to elitist fools.
Like my parents, these people have common sense and have their acts together. And that’s far more valuable than having “ knowledge”. ( Not that my patients didn’t have that as well). But first and foremost, they had their “ s…it” together.
The rural South traditionally has had more extreme racism than any other part of the country. Of course, racism has also run rampant throughout the WHOLE of America
@@SagesseNoir as the south has become more Republican over time, it has become less racist. Most working class poor white folk don't have time to worry about "racial issues" like these urban libs do writing books with completely subjective opinions based on their own biases.
@@Tdonn25 The racism of the South has become less EXTREME or at least less OVERT due to the achievements of the Civil Rights Movements, and subsequent achievements made possible by the Civil Rights Movement. But it was largely because these achievement happened on Lyndon Johnson's watch (i.e. during a Democrat Administration) that the conservative wing of the Republican Party began gaining ground and eventually wining over the south. Perhaps the first signs of this was with the Barry Goldwater campaign whose platform called for the rescinding of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. And even President Johnson (himself a Texan) reportedly admitted that with the passage of the Civil Rights Act of 1965 the South would be lost from the Democratic Party for a generation. That's proved to be an understated. During and after the Black Freedom movement many southern whites felt that the Democratic Party was no longer their party. But over time the Republican Party, which was once the more liberal of the two parties, became the most conservative and overtly racist, and the Democratic party became the more "liberal" and, let's say, covertly racist. (Yes, there is liberal racism. Old news to most Black people. But that's another conversation.)
@@SagesseNoir >Of course, racism has also run rampant throughout the WHOLE of America I live in New Mexico and I've never seen it. Growing up in Las Cruces I didn't know the darker kids were hispanic I thought they just played outside a lot. I knew any 1 of them could get the highest grade in class. We had a single gangster kid but he was not at all the darkest kid. I've always felt welcome in hispanic stores and towns like Hatch that are over 70% hispanic. No this isn't my pic it's a meme. I think this is a Democrat thing as pointed out. Only now is Cruces a heckhole with your open borders. Thanks.
@@Drak976 Racism is an AMERICAN thing, and has existed BEFORE either Democrat or Republican parties even existed. Now, I don't know what you have SEEN in New Mexico, but I know racism runs rampant throughout the USA, and has for centuries. And it infests both political parties. Moreover, Latin people have a long history of social struggles against racism in New Mexico, the southwest generally, and other parts of the USA. In short, I think you are misinformed whatever you may or may not have seen
I grew up in a very rural part of the country. Lived and worked in the city and couldn't wait to get out. What these urban elites forget is the very people they hate are the same people who provide the food, fuel and even water for these idiots. To a man these working class rural people are more down to earth and sensible than any of the urban elites. Those deplorable, ignorant folks have to be masters of several trades. Horticulture/agronomy, animal husbandry, electrician, carpenter, mechanic, veterinary medicine, and first responder. emergency service worker if something goes bad. Most of these urban types wouldn't last a day working either on a farm or in any agricultural based business. Book smart but can't change a lightbulb without supervision.
the Morning Joe clip was infuriating to watch. I was born and raised in the Mississippi Delta and this is precisely why there is rural rage...elite attitudes exactly like this. My family is full of blue collar workers (including some with college degrees that instead ultimately chose blue collar jobs) and I am proud of that and wouldn't switch places with any of the clueless elites like I see on Morning Joe. I appreciate Jessica and Amber speaking up against this terrible take on rural people.
I've done both; in fact, I've done all three. I went into the military at 17. I worked as a blue collar guy for about half my adult life. Anything from washing dishes, unloading box cars, stuffing printed circuit boards, factory work, auto mechanic. The second half, after attending a Big Ten University, I worked in the white collar world. Honestly, that's the order I'm the most proud of; military, blue collar, white collar.
I grew up a very large city which has had a Democratic Mayor for the last 90+ years, and I graduated from a liberal arts college. Can MSNBC identify what fuels MY rage?
The civil war is being raged using racism as a tool of urbanization to eliminate rural and suburban communities. This is pure propaganda and hypnotic lies. Native American tribes are rural. Talk about that one. Native American communities are not racist. Globalists use this myth of racism to destroy within.
I've been on a Native reservation. The rate of racial slurs towards me was unprecedented. To be fair towards them, the people around that reservation were quite racist towards them.
It's no secret that the US government experiments on dividing and conquering its own people before unleashing these tactics on other countries in order to destabilize them from within and insert their CIA backed stooges into power. They then use these same tactics to gaslight voters into believing that these coups and wars are a good thing - again using the same tactics they use to divide people here in order to create an endless source of "others" with which to power their forever wars.
@@benpeterson7530 I have lived and worked on reservations most of my adult life. Oklahoma tribes are generous yet experience state sponsored racism at unprecedented levels. If you had genocidal acts imposed upon you, how do you embrace trust? Respect moves bidirectional. There are many non Indigenous working successfully within and without because of a love of the earth. Think about that one please
@@denisevarner7308 I agree with you. I've spent a small amount of time on a reservation in central South Dakota. It's very poor. I'm not saying that those slurs towards me were not based on how others have treated them. It was reactionary, but I'd still consider that to be racist.
Your first sentence doesn’t even make sense. White flight and redlining were racist and kept minorities out of the suburbs. The urbanization you speak of isn’t even happening cities are crumbling meanwhile new suburbs steal funds from urban areas disproportionately. Sit this one out you are clearly out of your league.
I don't know why they think insulting half of the country and preaching to the choir will get them a win. I know they can't help themselves because they really do think we are a basket of deplorables.
Or orthodox Catholics who pray the Rosary and follow the teaching of our faith. We have the FBI coming to Mass. They send Apostates to Mass to attempt to not stand out . FYI boys you stand out .
@@marekbrodowski7225 Yes, but Christianity is a religion. A Nationalist is just a person who strongly identifies with their own nation and vigorously supports its interests. So if I identify as someone with these characteristics, does that make me evil? If so, how?
Do they mean the people in Martha's Vineyard that will not take in the invaders they support ..The National Guard was called fast when they showed up there
The authors despise the ranchers, farmers, truck drivers, fork lift operators, bakers, butchers, and clerks who are filling their grocery stores with food everyday.
they want control over all that. They don't have it yet. These people have too much power, so they represent a high risk of rebellion, a counter power, trucks that can act like tanks, tractors, weapons, the ability to block the food supply, and food independance for themeselves. Every last impacting revolt that scared the "elites" came from them : yellow vests in France, trucker convoy in Canada, farmers in the EU. This is a problem for them, and those Yt tend to go directly to places of powers when they are unhappy, unlike other people that will attack the next village, or a christmas parade...
I grew up in very rural central Florida in the 50's, 60's and 70's. My Dad was a rocket engineer at Cape Canaveral but had grown up on a working farm in Ohio and we had a modest working beef cattle operation in my youth until i left for the Marine Corps and then Engineering College and Dad was transferred to Vandenberg AFB in Cali in '77. My Dad instilled a strong work ethic and individualism traits within me that I have carried throughout my personal/academic life and professional career. It definitely pisses me off to see those traits denigrated by the coastal elites..who have probably never milked a cow or raised cattle to see them slaughtered to feed the public. As for my education, I scored a perfect 2400 on my SAT's in '75 and have both undergrad and grad Engineering degrees from two Top 20 Engineering Colleges and have had a 36 year career with two large American defense contractors. Trump has my vote in November.
This is why I can't support student debt relief. Go to an overpriced academy that teaches to "problematize" a lower class, then legislate the lower class to pay for it after graduation.
I believe investing in students is a investment into the future, clamping a heavy debt with a steep interest onto them will only hampering the growth of the nation.
A lot of people go to college to learn how to develop new crops, machinery, and infrastructure that people of all classes rely on. So maybe don’t throw away the baby with the bath water.
I live in one of the 20 largest cities in Ohio. Despite being relatively suburban vs rural, nearly 35% of the population is non-white. I can tell you from firsthand experience that my neighbors are kind, caring and respectful of each other. There is no "rural rage"? What irritates many of the folks I've spoken to since 2020 or so is the entire failure of the Federal govt to respect the will of the people. Ohio is considered a ruby red state, but we overwhelmingly legalized cannabis last fall. This is entirely incompatible with the comments of these authors. If Ohio was populated with "Christian Nationalists", this wouldn't have been possible. Only recently have academics and media pundits so horribly misrepresented Midwestern voters. Sorry folks, but few Americans can take seriously those who don't drive themselves to work each day or know the price of a gallon of milk or a loaf of bread. Everyday Americans are truly struggling and have finally determined that neither party serves their interests. I'm over 50 and I have watched the ruling class perpetually fail to deliver on campaign promises. Biden has been warned ad nauseum that his unconditional support of Israel will cost him reelection, but I'm certain that his campaign will be genuinely shocked when it actually comes to pass (and I voted for that fool of a politician in 2020.)
What a great way to bring this divided nation together, by dehumanizing a large group of people that you've obviously never even talked to before. Bravo.
I can’t even fathom the complete lack of self awareness of these people. If you substitute urban black people, how does that go over. Complete contempt is an understatement!
it's dehumanization, and it goes further than it seems. It amongst many other things. All this racial targeting , dehumanizing, scapegoating that has been happening for a few years, and not just in the USA.
Isn't rage- is irritation & a desire to be left alone. Watching society crumble and personal responsibility falling away while they are accused of being the problem by the people who are causing the problem.
And this, friends, is why we have an Electoral College. Keeps the "flyover country" from being totally unrepresented. Oh, and BTW, I do have a college degree.
Yeah they warned y’all. And most people keep believing the lies from both parties. Conservatives claim libs are brainwashed without having absolutely no self reflection. Conservatives aren’t free thinkers, they’re just the other side of the coin. If you don’t agree with maga conservatives that n every single issue they cast you out as a traitor or claim you’re brain dead. I can’t get behind parties who’s supporters are simply just playing for teams. Unfortunately I thought republicans were a bit more logical and open minded. But they’re just like Dems in that anyone who even slightly disagrees with them is casted out.
As a rural physician, the only things we have in common is a skepticism for buildings higher than four stories, an enthusiasm for firearms and a hatred for government overreach.
it does. It reminds me of the UN list of signs forgoing events that happened in Germany, and Rwanda, and Bosnia, and Zimbabwe......another "usual" thing is also happening, the targets refuse to see it or believe it. They brush it off until it's too late.
What are you talking about? Miami was blue 53 to 46 Biden. Just about every major city in Florida went blue. Rural area went red. But I'm not sure about this video opinion is THE standard for white rural voters.
@@cassiescornerreviews6884 women and girls are more likely to liberal because of the males wiring of the brain of being a protector of their family with the testosterone in them
@@cjmacd07 the mayor of Miami is a Republican from Latin America,Cubans and Venezuelans were key in flipping Florida red because they know the horrors of communism
It never ceases to amaze me how these over educated metro elites are so condescending who create these sweeping generalizations on any group that does not agree with their beliefs.
I believe the thinking of the authors is that there is a sort of a nest, a hive, of hatred that just needs to be purged. Once sunlight is thrown on this dark underbelly, America will be the land of the free, unbigoted, and voting according to their value system (mostly likely focused on the value of CARE). It is not a serious to attempt to understand rural American, the midwest, the economics of the rustbelt, or any wider economic and labor issues (like the fact that cheap labor overseas may end up being more exploitative of workers there, creating more injustice) that inform the choices of conservative voters or Trump voters. The authors believe in a cartoon, which they think they can defeat with their own cartoonish virtue politics.
To these people, you are not "educated" unless you have a piece of paper saying you are. Only from a college or university though. If you took gender studies and got a degree, they consider you educated. If you want to trade school and mastered the intricacies of the electrical workings of a skyscraper, you are not educated. God for bid if you learnt mechanics the old-school way of just tinkering around with cars. You could disassemble and reassemble their automobile, but you didn't study Shakespeare so you're not educated even though what you can do is actually empirically important. I can't stand the term educated.
@@italia689 educated means "spent time memorizing", for the most part. It speaks more to study ethic than it does intelligence. The kids with the best grades in school were almost never the wisest.
We voted for Obama thinking he would represent the working class. He didn't things got worse for us. Then we voted for Trump things got better our value as workers increased because of supply and demand. Then Biden came in and labor is now getting devalued because more workers less pay less workers better pay simple math. Now the company I work for is starting to try to find ways to get rid of people by enforcing rules that were never enforced so they can replace us with cheaper labor. Thanks Biden.
He tried, but ultimately, he sold out for the sake of politics and ACA was a fake win and giveaway to the industry. Industry profits increased and it did little to fix most of the root issues. Republicans have done worse than nothing for their part. It’s inexcusable that this is one of the issues that most Americans agree on, but politicians are too concerned with offending the profits on their donors to fix the problem.
How about you be honest, that bill was more than likely tied to other issues that have nothing to do with health insurance. You can’t be disingenuous and pretend that democrats were trying to give people a single topic bill. They always tie BS into those hills and act as if republicans are the bad guys for shooting down bills with many added things to it
I've seen street interview videos on TH-cam where college students are asked where food comes from, and they literally think that it originates from a grocery store. They have no concept of food production.
@@NEILL0608 . . .racist is a made up word to demonize white people. Let all these non-white countries open up their borders to all colors and creeds from all around the world. How many organizations are there that promote and advocate for white people? Now how many organizations are there to promote and advocate for "people of color"?
Wish that could have been a segment on MSNBC. I'm an old DC plumber who retired and moved to Bedford Pennsylvania. I can tell you these people are union Democrats. Steel, Coal and factories are gone. There's a bar down the street called the Democrat. A lot of trump signs in this neighborhood. Thank you both that was good.
Calling those people "liberal elites" is a compliment that I don't give them. They are actually the opposite of both "liberal" (in the classical sense)... and "elite". YT won't let me give an accurate description...
or to pass the Civil Rights Act of 1964 or the Immigration Act of 1965 when the white population was around 90%. It doesn't add up and now more and more white people are taking notice.
I'm half Japanese, half white born in Minnesota. I grew up in small city in northern Wisconsin where my mother, my sister, and I were the only Asians for most of my life. My neighbors never treated us any different than anyone else in town.
I'm about 99% white and about 1% native American. I grew up in a small town of 1,000. I'm not Christian or racist. My wife is a legal immigrant from Indonesia. I consider myself conservative, but not a republican.
@campursarian (scratches head) conservative, but not republican why that's just impossible challenges the whole world view given to me by the suits on television could they have been lying all along...
The barn needs painted, all y'all! We raised 9 full-sibling children on our diversified farm. We've had farm customers from all over the world (mostly students or professors or the hardest working Hispanic people you ever met). What's this rage garbage? Working in a garden will take it right out of you! Send those authors out here and see if they can keep up with us old folks. We've had 4 legal Haitian Humanitarian Parolees live with us starting last July. They are very black and we are white with blue eyes. We all get along fine. Once they get their SSN and work authorizations they are working full time in the city before moving to their own housing. Government, please just leave us all alone. I didn't vote for Trump first time around but I sure will now.
Ask Trump how many awards he’s won for helping the black communities. He has never pandered, and said he carries hot sauce around. I’ve never in my life seen so many white people call other white’s racist!!! They have some major skeletons they’re relentlessly trying to hide.
As an Asian immigrant I found rural southerners to be apprehensive at the beginning but become very warm neighbors with a bit of understanding. I live in California now and people are much more rude and trapped in their own heads.
We had a Vietnamese refugee family come to Wilkes-Barre when I was at Kings, We raise food and furniture and Winter clothes for them , Catholic charities were their sponsor.
Glad you enjoyed the rural South. I'm not quite from the South. I'm from the Appalachian mountains of WV. For us in rural America, we have a history of being abused by outsiders. In my state, coal companies came in and ruined the land and economy. It's tough because our experiences have made us a lot less trusting at first. Now, we have folks from CA and NY taking advantage of our low cost of living and driving up the property values, and some talk about how ignorant we are. I understand your point about CA. Many folks there don't even try to understand or empathize with their fellow American.
@@nuclearwessels2078 When I lived in Vietnam, we knew all our neighbors' families, what they did for work, and even their extended families for two blocks over. Sometimes I yearn for that sense of community here in the US and I think I'll only find it in rural areas. Many CA folks spend a lot of time consuming information online not to find insight but to look down on others who spent their time elsewhere.
@@nuclearwessels2078 I lived on a large commune in rural East Tenasee in the 1970s. They were Vegan, in an uninformed way, and the food simply was not sufficient for a 13-year-old boy to remain healthy on. So I used to sneak off and bum food off the neighbors. They checked every stereotypical box for "hillbillies," drank moon shine, chewed tobacco, possessed and used guns, but they were so nice to me, despite their own poverty. Plus, I enjoyed experimenting with those vices myself. Ever since then, though I am every bit the West Coast urban educated leftist, I have had a soft spot for the Appalachians.
Sadly, dispste the fact that the left has always proclaimed that working class and poor people of all races and location should unite, there are certain"Culture war"issues that hold us back. And that powers that be, unfortunately, like to play on and distract us with those, to keep us divided.
As a white person who visits tons of rural areas for work, the locals are typically apprehensive about all newcomers/visitors at first, regardless of race. Then, when they get to know you, most are very sweet and welcoming.
I am a Black liberal College educated individual and trust me White rural folks have a lot to be upset about and blaming them for the insanity in the world is crazy!
How about we listen to each other for a change instead of labeling each other racist because we have different views.
Wake up put the poison of arrogance down and try some compassion and love for each other instead.
One Luv
🙏☀️
When social media - entertainment- schools-colleges-government-press is control my majority of liberals. Republicans have the Supreme Court. That’s it.
Absolutely. And we may be surprised to find out our views are not all that different.
Everyone is entitled to their own opinion. But not to their own truth.
I am a black person neither Liberal or Conservative but they are to blame for many of their situations. One example is ACA they were so against it.. Started a Tea Party movement like it 1770’s. They were uninsured and couldn’t even afford their basic medicine and many rural clinics were closing due to NO funding so Obama put out the ACA Guess what it got passed ALL Democrats and with the help of 2 Republicans both women… Now what happened the uninsured rates went down drastically and POOR people in Arkansas and Kentucky both white and black benefited from this…. Fast forward they voted for people in the house and Senate that want to take away their healthcare. This is just one example now as a brother in college educated you don’t remember this👏🏽
❤
I’m a 26 year old black woman who worked on a farm in a white rural area for over a year in south Louisiana. Not once did I ever feel uncomfortable or discriminated against. The owners are what these men would call “White Christian Nationalist” and they call me their adopted daughter. They call me for my birthday and I still go back to visit. They would literally tell me they love me every day before I would leave for the day, and I knew they meant it. It really baffles me to see that these guys really believe what they are writing. I’m not saying there aren’t people out there like that, however I don’t believe for one second that is the majority of white rural America. I also grew up in a white rural area, I did not experience what they are describing in any capacity.
You are correct: They DID love you.
Welcome to Cosco I love you. JK I couldn't help it.
They're actually talking about Racist people that live in Rural areas so stop confusing yourself with the nice ones.
You are more likely to run into what they are saying rural people are in the cities than in rural areas.
@@tonytay4320 I believed that for years. No they aren't. Their mask has fallen off.
I'm an Hispanic in a Rural white\black community...never had a problem,,,rural living is not cities,,we have community values
In my experience as a black man who worked in rual America for over 20 years. 99.9% of people you meet couldn't care less about skin color. Charactor, morals, work ethic, thats what rual America cares about. Of course, every group had its undesirables, but to write off an entire group over 2 or 3 idiots makes zero sense.
Yep, came to the US, started up a business in the ethanol industry. The only people I still call and check up on are the original people I met, when I had to startup in a very rural part of Kansas. Saw through that nonsense when I was given a warning about the "racism" present in rural areas. It's unreal the level of self hate whether it be black, brown or beige than from the folks in the cities and offices. When I told them I intended to hire and trust someone who had a understanding of the land to start my business, regardless of credentials or education, because that makes sense in the field; I was immediately scoffed at and they told me I'd fail. That same phrasing explained to my business manager when I hired him was common sense.
My old man raised me to always approach situations with humility and understand if you are privileged in wealth, you need to be in step with your understanding of different situations, and give grace where due, since no man is greater than the other under the Lord. These people are the definition of hubris and cringe. Same type of people always talking about therapy but never going themselves, really going, since they're scared to even face what's broken, let alone begin to fix it. Never understanding the first step has to come from themselves, it's not possible otherwise.
Well said!
I agree . So comforting to read comments like yours . I hear people like those in mainstream media telling lies day after day repeating lies as facts I gotta think they are paid to do that it’s so awful! Thank you for speaking up. I want to do that more and not be silenced. These types are smug and so convinced it’s spooky
Tell that to them:
Rev. Clementa C. Pinckney (41) - the senior pastor of the church and a South Carolina state senator.
Cynthia Hurd (54) - a manager for the Charleston County Public Library system.
Rev. Sharonda Coleman-Singleton (45) - a church pastor, speech therapist and track coach at Goose Creek High School.
Tywanza Sanders (26) - a recent graduate of Allen University, where he earned a degree in Business Administration.
Ethel Lance (70) - a church sexton who had worked at the church for over 30 years.
Susie Jackson (87) - a longtime member of the church and cousin to Ethel Lance.
Depayne Middleton Doctor (49) - a minister at the church and retired manager for the U.S. Department of Commerce.
Rev. Daniel Simmons (74) - a pastor who served at several churches.
Myra Thompson (59) - a Bible study teacher at the church.
This discussion is useless as it has no purpose but to denigrate foes who have because they and does who are the have nots because the haves are achievers.
As an old, Progressive white guy who for decades lived in a poor, white, rural community, and found many of its inhabitants to be ‘salt of the earth’ people whom I admired, and who had my respect, I find this kind of attitude mortifying, shades of Hillary’s ‘Basket of deplores !’
👏 👍
agreed Sir!
Exactly!
Yeah - I am aslo an old white guy who has lived in rural communities - in fact I was raised on a farm myself - for years I considered myself a progressive/anarchist/socialist - but being allied with city liberals in the past I have to admit was a struggle.
The feelings were always there among the Libs but when Hillary said that it made it OK for their feelings to turn to hate.
Obama talked about them clinging to their guns and religion, Hilary called them Deplorables. Out of touch much?
...Resident Briben called them 'dOmEsTiC tErRoRiStS'.
...Ol 'Lunch Pail Joe', the Poor Coal Mining Trucker from Scranton.🥴
He said that about the People is the Wyoming Valley, Pa. All those Anthercite coal mine towns. Folks back home really appreciated that. Not.
Briben called them nethandrals and white supremes , FJB
The FBI. Has targeted " Radical Roman Catholics " the FBI. Definition of those Catholics pray the Rosary and follow the Catechism of the RCC.
The guns and the clinging to them is real. Ask the NRA and all the money it gives to politicians. And religion in politics is real. Ask Mike Johnson. Ask the courts in Alabama.
As a red man who has live in rural Oklahoma and Texas. The only place I was ever discriminated against was when I lived on the south side of Houston which has a lot of Democrats.
I'm a brick layer, im a black farmer, I'm a red man, I'm an Asian immigrant, I'm a Christian conservative, I'm a trans Haitian migrant and even I KNOW that these two are the racists, we're the good guys!
Liberals always decide what white, rural people are thinking, while they sit at home and talk to each other. Why don't they interview white rural people?
I think it’s the false narrative of America/hollywood/whiteness which falsely depicts that ALL white people actually live like the white people on TV..(upper middle class suburban). I think this makes the avg working class white person (who lives like Roseanne) feel ignored. This group, the actual majority is kept hushed. I think Bernie appealed to them, but the elites would not allow.
"Man on the street" interviews have become so rare. We need to bring them back.
They live in a bubble
@@pmberkeleymark dice does them once in a while
Too guilt- inducing to face them.
The real extreme threat are the two racists calling the farmers racists.
Marxist Communist tactics.
nicely said
Right. Talk about angry talkers. You could hear the seething vehemence in their oun tone.
How many non-white friends do you have? LOL
They're jews btw
Rural communities are the only place where people still have some brains.
Im a white midwestern christian conservative American male. If you stopped there you still wouldnt know anything about me, my family, or my people. I am angry about what I see, because I see democracy being trampled. I went to college, we have those here. The Midwest is humble; just because we're quiet doesn't mean we aren't educated.
Absolutely! We are humble and educated and don't suffer fools.
The US is not a democracy (majority rule, thank God) but a constitutional republic.
Glad to hear that you're angry about the man who tried to overturn the 2020 election and keep himself in power through lies and violence. Glad to hear you're against turning over even more power to the corporate oligarchs that already control our lives.
I'm so glad you are angry about Jan 6th I too join you in that. I mean democracy was attacked that day. We need to be careful to make sure it doesn't happen again.
@@JayAshkevron As long as we don't have another stolen election JeremyS, there won't be another January 6th!
As a black man myself, the most racist places I have seen are liberal states like California, New York, Illinois and Massachusetts.
Massachusetts is really racist simply because it's still segregated
That's how those people "confess"... they point the finger elsewhere, when they should be looking in a mirror.
New York (city) is literally the bum hole of this country
They are bigots toward anyone with a Southern accent.
No doubt. Liberal cities are the only place where segregation still happens.
Rural white rage ……….. yawn. I think the authors are the ones with rage. They need some therapy.
they're both eligible to return to israel
@@MahatmajenkinsAbsolutely spot on. People need to wake up to the professional victims Mentally..
Agree, I am a JAMAICAN Black man and I love Trump. New York Attorney General and Alvin Bragg just wanted to destroy The Donald they are financed by George Soros.
Their regular therapy sessions are not working.
@@Mahatmajenkins . . . no surprise. It's like they just can't help themselves. I guess it's just in their nature.
and then one day for no reason at all. . .
they cry out in pain as they strike you!
Hmmm, white rural america, no racism, little crime, helping thy neighbor, not such a bad place.
A lot of racism. High suicide rates, drug abuse rates, and domestic violence. Mental health crisis and lack of access to healthcare due to Republican blockades.
According to those two guys, voting is a threat to Democracy.
Likewise, people who call themselves "patriots" or "Constitutionalists" are threats to democracy.
When enough people vote against their own interests it is.
America is a Republic! 🙏✝️❤️🤍💙🇺🇸
@@Apostate1970 I hate it that you have a point. This may be a good time for all of us to remember what Churchill said about democracy being the worst form of government - except for all the other forms that have been tried.
We are a constutional republic
The idea that lefties - like BLM, Antifa, MSNBC, the DSA, the Harvard faculty, and Keith Olbermann - are accusing conservatives of being *angry* is both tragic and hilarious.
Confession through projection
Jan. 6 don't forget they were ANGRY.
You mean Harvard anti-semite University😅
that's a lot of unrelated stuff thrown into one.
@@Peter-km7hb
Projection, you mean fake anti-semitism.
Thank-you The Hill Finally a united episode from a perspective that makes sense 👏🏾...And this is from a black woman out of Massachusetts.
MSNBC is a poison to this country.
I’m black and recently had a discussion with a white gentleman about moving to a particular place. He said there were too many white Christians there. I pressed him on what do I have to fear from them and what crimes are they going to commit against me. (I also used to live in South Central Los Angeles years ago so I know about living in a high crime area and WHO really commits these crimes.) He had no answers.
If an area is heavily populated with a certain demographic, then obviously, the crime will reflect that specific group doing the crime. Just like The majority of crime in corporations is done by a yt people because of the majority is white due to racism.
I'll admit in the 1990s I moved to a Christian town and had been brainwashed by the TV they were going to bully me for not being Christian. I got bullied but only for normal things lol.
I grew up in a very white, rural town in Utah. There were no black people, but there were a couple Hispanics and some Polynesians. Let me tell you, they were all super popular! And when a Ute family moved in with a son my age, we all had crushes on him. We just loved anyone who was different - but I bet liberals would say that's racist too somehow. You just can't win with them! 😂
Why is everyone living in cities trying to move to rural America?
Because they effed up said cities with their voting.
to escape the fascist anti-American local governments....
For the same reason so many people across the world are risking their lives to illegally immigrate to the US, despite the US being “racist, fascist, and oppressive”.
Exactly! During covid I don't know how many vehicles with out of state plates I saw in my rural hick town
To get out of the jungle.
Amazing how much lower the crime rate is in rural areas considering how hateful everyone is supposed to be.
Low Population
@@tonytay4320. That has nothing to do with crime rate.
@@MetalDetroitI lived in a Dense Area population less then 500-1000 where we know just about everyone several different towns the crime is VERY LOW.
Most crime occurs in red states
@@Admiralty86 In Democrat run cities.
States have no control over cities.
Love it when elite academia thinks they can tell us how we think
Conservatives do not think, they parrot.
they're both eligible to return to israel
Wow. Way to prove their point for them :)
They don't even know what a woman is, not exactly an authority on anything!
IDK if elite applies to 99.9% of academics. In terms of social status or economic/knowledge output. We've got over 75% of our undergrad courses taught by adjuncts who may as well be uber drivers. On the other hand the actual professors are all gaming the system of scientific journals to defend their careers to the detriment of virtually every field of knowledge. I can't say where the money goes but I've worked inside the homes of the admins and they're the most out of touch people I've ever met who aren't major shareholders.
I understand why post-secondary education is the ideal divide-and-conquer boundary to politicians. In my experience public education programs people to be uncritical and orthodox and nobody before college tells you that all the 'objective' stuff you're being taught is an intentional choice by someone with their own an agenda. I wouldn't swear that its the result of conspiracy, but whether its intentional or not the result is a separation of the tools for becoming class conscious from the sectors of the economy who could make the best use of it.
TLDR: Its a dysfunctional system and the unequal distribution of the suffering it causes it exploited by politicians to keep people divided. Its not performing its role for our society or our economy but its absurdly profitable and unlikely to change any time soon.
I grew up around "rural whites" and still am proud to call some of them friends today. They are angry because they see their country moved away from a merit-based society to one that gives preferences to people based on race and gender. They are angry because they see their country in chaos with the borders open and no consequences for people who break the law.
yep
And that barely scratches the surface of the deep, systemic insanity that progressives deliver.
"A merit-based society"? There's a lot of merit that was never rewarded in America. A lot of success is based on luck.
@@tedgemberling2359 Luck can be part of success, but don't pretend that behavior doesn't impact outcomes. And even if it's true that not all merit is rewarded or that certain peoples/ethnicities/demographics were held back in the past, that's not a reason to abandon reality and pretend that human outcomes are not predicted by certain behaviors. We know certain behaviors have a higher probability of good life outcomes than others. For example, graduating high school, not having kids out of wedlock/uncommitted relationships, never getting involved with the law, and always working a full-time job are more likely to produce good life outcomes than those doing the opposite. Those are simple "merit-based" behaviors that virtually every able-bodied American can do.
@@scratchpenny of course behaviors affect success. But even the ability to make good choices can be a matter of luck to some extent. The problem in America is that people with lots of money can afford to make mistakes. If you're poor you can't. Every mistake you make threatens to destroy your entire life.
These two guys husbands? They're definitely liberal elite racists! The biggest racists are always the ones screaming racism all the time 😠
Or like Trump, whining all the time that he is being persecuted…
Lenin, Stalin & Trotsky said very similar things about the rural working class before murdering millions of them.
they are eligible to return to israel
Surprised that the YT mods let this one fly. They hate people who actually know their history.
These are just their descendants trying to pull off the same thing.
Spotted the kulak.
Those like the writers of this book thought that they were going to be in charge but were the first to go to the ditches.
Being honest, as the black male behind our group, it has been the working class rural white Americans who have been more cordial and accepting of me here in the Midwest. Having friends and relationships with them have been fruitful, and eye opening. Have there been some issues? Sure. But for the most part they've been minimal. The places I've felt most "out of place" is when I've tried to participate in the activities that take place in the wealthier, gentrified urban areas. These people, if they have a problem with minorities, maybe aren't the most vocal, but they control access to certain spaces. And when you're not welcome, they may not openly say it, but you know it.
MalcomX knew..
that's because classism is a much stronger force than racism (in fact you could even argue that due to the circumstances/history in the US, our current racism is born out of classism because the two were associated for so long), but notice how you never hear them talking about classism.
@@justsomenobody889 Yeah can agree with that. It's partial. Because how could they know my class? I don't dress poorly. So they make the assumption based off the first obvious "marker". These people are class focused, but their assumptions are usually coupled with other "-isms". Like the white woman who was asked in a news interview about voucher programs for "inner city/urban" families, and her response was "Well, I'm not racist but..."
@@justsomenobody889Lol, it's almost like race and class are coupled in America... Or is it "their culture".
@@justsomenobody889 I'm definitely into the "conspiracy" that the timing of all of this race-based stuff and gender-based stuff isn't a coincidence. Right after occupy Wall Street, where people got really angry about the elites media Company started blasting out stories about race and gender and all of that. You could trace it all back to the aftermath of that protest. I really do think it was those people pulling the strings with media that brought us here. At the same time we had that Yuri Bezmeno stuff going on, so you had this perfect group of people who are just coming of age who could implement this.
Thank you ladies for commenting on these 2 horrible men. I'm a white rural bricklayer voting for Trump
I encourage you to guard your health. your back, knees, hands, feet, and so-on. I know you work hard. Leave some health left for when you're older like me. Having done all that, of course...I also encourage you to "Keep the Faith".😇
You're a winner 🙄🤮
@@toberman3914. You don’t get it. You’ll never get it.
I'm a brick layer, im a black farmer, I'm an Asian immigrant, I'm a Christian conservative, I'm a trans Haitian migrant and even I KNOW that these two are the racists, we're the good guys!
Why Trump?
And yet they scratch their heads as to why Trump resonates with rural America.
No - this only confirms the hypothesis.
Rural America supports a birther, who thinks there are good people on both sides in Charlottesville. Of course.
@@Geewasrightboth sides were his fed friends
@@JezaJames *Frisco has an entire HS, where NO students test at GRADE level MATH*
*THOSE are future DEMOCRAT'S, WHY BIDEN won the youth vote in CA!*
@@SixOneNiner23 Yes, the menticide is being done on both sides. Your neighbor isn't your enemy. The people telling you your neighbors are your enemy, ARE the enemy.
If you know anything about neoliberalism over the last 40+ years you understand that non-urban Americans (it's not just white folk) have legitimate socio-economic grievances born of material decline (cost of living, inflation, de-industrialization, etc.).
You sound like an academic.
Yet they choose to show their grievance through hating the immigrants or non-Christians. Really weird approach to fight the power, by attacking the less powerful.
@@JezaJames I'm a small town subcontractor who reads books.
@@JezaJamesyou sound like a elitist to think only people who go to college can’t read.
Urbanites do not respect independent culture and ethics. With the exception of global warming they don’t appreciate the natural world and the idea that humans are caretakers of the earth.
Have tom schiller and paul wadman seen the protests happening all over the world? It's not just Americans that are enraged.
yes, it's a specific demographic that they identify as "whites". You know that one people , the only one that actualy decided they were equal in rights and dignity, should have a say in decision making, and wanted decent work conditions. the pains in the arse.
I have heard enough opinions from Jessica to assume that she would agree with the author on all points, but am pleasantly surprised that she gets it right this time
Because she's "lived in a small town" and has "worked in those jobs" ..... which I don't believe for a second, but I'm glad she can at least see what people like that actually have to deal with on a daily basis.
Maybe she had a taste of whatever Anna Kasparian had that made her start questioning certain leftist dogmas
Same here
Her take took me by surprise, that’s for sure.
She was definitely respectful and thoughtful here. Both Jessica and Brie are very intelligent even if they would both like to see a socialist country. (I'm not socialist but I totally understand wanting to see more economic fairness in society.)
Rural folks produce the food. Rural folks transport the food. Rural folks can stop doing that!
Rural folk can survive. Urban folk cannot.
The coastal elites need food more than rural folks need Hollywood or Broadway!
And they will stop when pushed too far.
They should of stopped years ago
Illegal immigrants pick the food and slaughter it yet rural folks don't like them much.
I’m FBA from DC and LA who now spends time amongst rural Whites and can tell you these elites are so far out of touch it’s ridiculous. this is going to be a MAJOR issue in the coming months and years.
They're not out of touch but blatant liars and evil hypocrites. The US doesn't have years.
Most people in the rural South born post 1965 Civil Rights movement really do judge by actions and character.
The Rural South is the FBA Homeland.
Dana Loesch wrote a 2016 book about the disconnect between the coastal elites and middle America: Flyover Nation: You Can't Run a Country You've Never Been To.
They aren't remotely out of touch but calculated, evil liars and hypocrites.
What does FBA stand for?
Rural white Christian female farmer - a little humility goes a long ways in checking your ego and biases. This is just an "attempt" at pitting urban vs rural and fanning the only flames they know how - FEAR. Us rural folk have no time for such nonsense. We are living the good life in peace.
Amen😉
I am a Hispanic man living in rural Texas. Never in 30 years living here have I experienced personal racism. On the other hand, I experienced it twice living in the Twin Cities, Minnesota living there 10 years.
They really think they’re better than everyone else
They refer us to FLY OVER states, they for sure think they are better than us.
It's always great to get the opinion of the white people who claim they're not white people.
I can't tell if they believe their own BS or are just grifting to sell books to the elite?
they are eligible to return to israel
Grew up with that kind of a sibling, older than me BTW
Always obsessed with being a "step ahead" of others, always them being different, always you being "same", always when you decide to make a change and turn the page "you were fine but small changes in behavior were required", you must always be similar enough for them to compare but different enough for them to feel superior
When that's no longer the case, you must put up with every bit of right on spot imagined or invented BS measure for "just in case"
And now, 30 years later it finally clicked - either me, him, or both were adopted. Grandma hinted at my father's health and frankly don't care if it was him, mom, or both, really don't care about the reasons or story behind
Regardless, my point being - they're obsessed and unhealthy individuals. Obsessed with change, and obsessed with "making a difference" even when there's no need for that
Always be careful about the someone's inner need for thinking highly of themselves. If there's something my life has thought me it's that - normal people are able to withstand self-criticism and allow to not think self-highly all the time. These people aren't
What if two white conservatives wrote a book called "Black Urban Rage" how do you think the left and MSNBC would react to that? lol
My thoughts exactly
"The purpose of propaganda is to make one set of people forget that other sets of people are human."
-Aldous Huxley
We are truly living in a Brave New World society with undertones of 1984.
It’s the same thing Trudeau did with the truckers. He slandered them to the whole world.
@@343Films Oh we've got all the dystopias. Elon Musk trying to make Terminal Man while warning about I, Robot while Skynet is lecturing us about racism and I wonder about the internet itself originally called the "galactic" world wide web and it's normalization of weird stuff like Childhoods End. You name the dystopia we're probably there. Even old ones look at the west trying to chase the White Putler Whale. We've got the Biden reverse Oedipus's out there both of them.
This is just one more way to divide Americans. We need to be united and stand together.
Proof ANYONE Can Be Published, even if there's not a functioning brain in their heads!
Those "uneducated" people they are referring to (farmers, mechanics, construction workers, truck drivers etc) are far more intelligent than them. It reminds me of a comedian named Jerry Clower who once said "these people are obviously educated beyond their intelligence" referring to elitist fools.
Like my parents, these people have common sense and have their acts together.
And that’s far more valuable than having “ knowledge”. ( Not that my patients didn’t have that as well).
But first and foremost, they had their “ s…it” together.
True
"educated beyond their intelligence", that is so spot on
@@realitycheck6333Mark Twain called them Mugwumps
Yea when is the last time you had racial and political clashes in rural areas? That only happens in democrat run cities
The rural South traditionally has had more extreme racism than any other part of the country. Of course, racism has also run rampant throughout the WHOLE of America
@@SagesseNoir as the south has become more Republican over time, it has become less racist. Most working class poor white folk don't have time to worry about "racial issues" like these urban libs do writing books with completely subjective opinions based on their own biases.
@@Tdonn25 The racism of the South has become less EXTREME or at least less OVERT due to the achievements of the Civil Rights Movements, and subsequent achievements made possible by the Civil Rights Movement. But it was largely because these achievement happened on Lyndon Johnson's watch (i.e. during a Democrat Administration) that the conservative wing of the Republican Party began gaining ground and eventually wining over the south. Perhaps the first signs of this was with the Barry Goldwater campaign whose platform called for the rescinding of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. And even President Johnson (himself a Texan) reportedly admitted that with the passage of the Civil Rights Act of 1965 the South would be lost from the Democratic Party for a generation. That's proved to be an understated. During and after the Black Freedom movement many southern whites felt that the Democratic Party was no longer their party. But over time the Republican Party, which was once the more liberal of the two parties, became the most conservative and overtly racist, and the Democratic party became the more "liberal" and, let's say, covertly racist. (Yes, there is liberal racism. Old news to most Black people. But that's another conversation.)
@@SagesseNoir >Of course, racism has also run rampant throughout the WHOLE of America
I live in New Mexico and I've never seen it. Growing up in Las Cruces I didn't know the darker kids were hispanic I thought they just played outside a lot. I knew any 1 of them could get the highest grade in class. We had a single gangster kid but he was not at all the darkest kid. I've always felt welcome in hispanic stores and towns like Hatch that are over 70% hispanic. No this isn't my pic it's a meme. I think this is a Democrat thing as pointed out. Only now is Cruces a heckhole with your open borders. Thanks.
@@Drak976 Racism is an AMERICAN thing, and has existed BEFORE either Democrat or Republican parties even existed. Now, I don't know what you have SEEN in New Mexico, but I know racism runs rampant throughout the USA, and has for centuries. And it infests both political parties. Moreover, Latin people have a long history of social struggles against racism in New Mexico, the southwest generally, and other parts of the USA. In short, I think you are misinformed whatever you may or may not have seen
I grew up in a very rural part of the country. Lived and worked in the city and couldn't wait to get out. What these urban elites forget is the very people they hate are the same people who provide the food, fuel and even water for these idiots.
To a man these working class rural people are more down to earth and sensible than any of the urban elites. Those deplorable, ignorant folks have to be masters of several trades. Horticulture/agronomy, animal husbandry, electrician, carpenter, mechanic, veterinary medicine, and first responder. emergency service worker if something goes bad.
Most of these urban types wouldn't last a day working either on a farm or in any agricultural based business.
Book smart but can't change a lightbulb without supervision.
Exactly!
Well said.
the Morning Joe clip was infuriating to watch. I was born and raised in the Mississippi Delta and this is precisely why there is rural rage...elite attitudes exactly like this. My family is full of blue collar workers (including some with college degrees that instead ultimately chose blue collar jobs) and I am proud of that and wouldn't switch places with any of the clueless elites like I see on Morning Joe. I appreciate Jessica and Amber speaking up against this terrible take on rural people.
I've done both; in fact, I've done all three. I went into the military at 17. I worked as a blue collar guy for about half my adult life. Anything from washing dishes, unloading box cars, stuffing printed circuit boards, factory work, auto mechanic. The second half, after attending a Big Ten University, I worked in the white collar world. Honestly, that's the order I'm the most proud of; military, blue collar, white collar.
Good on you guys make sure you give Biden a walloping in November@@tetedur377
The authors will earn money by selling hate. It's not difficult to understand their purpose.
they are eligible to return to israel
@@Mahatmajenkins 🤔
It's worse than that bro.
Yep, just another woke way to virtue signal.
I grew up a very large city which has had a Democratic Mayor for the last 90+ years, and I graduated from a liberal arts college. Can MSNBC identify what fuels MY rage?
Nope. You don’t fit the narrative.
The civil war is being raged using racism as a tool of urbanization to eliminate rural and suburban communities. This is pure propaganda and hypnotic lies. Native American tribes are rural. Talk about that one. Native American communities are not racist. Globalists use this myth of racism to destroy within.
I've been on a Native reservation. The rate of racial slurs towards me was unprecedented. To be fair towards them, the people around that reservation were quite racist towards them.
It's no secret that the US government experiments on dividing and conquering its own people before unleashing these tactics on other countries in order to destabilize them from within and insert their CIA backed stooges into power. They then use these same tactics to gaslight voters into believing that these coups and wars are a good thing - again using the same tactics they use to divide people here in order to create an endless source of "others" with which to power their forever wars.
@@benpeterson7530 I have lived and worked on reservations most of my adult life. Oklahoma tribes are generous yet experience state sponsored racism at unprecedented levels. If you had genocidal acts imposed upon you, how do you embrace trust? Respect moves bidirectional. There are many non Indigenous working successfully within and without because of a love of the earth. Think about that one please
@@denisevarner7308 I agree with you. I've spent a small amount of time on a reservation in central South Dakota. It's very poor. I'm not saying that those slurs towards me were not based on how others have treated them. It was reactionary, but I'd still consider that to be racist.
Your first sentence doesn’t even make sense. White flight and redlining were racist and kept minorities out of the suburbs. The urbanization you speak of isn’t even happening cities are crumbling meanwhile new suburbs steal funds from urban areas disproportionately. Sit this one out you are clearly out of your league.
"The people who do not vote like me are a threat to democracy", this is priceless. Talk about being blind to your own prejudices.
No, the people that vote for aspiring dictators that are endorsed by Nazis are a threat.
I don't know why they think insulting half of the country and preaching to the choir will get them a win. I know they can't help themselves because they really do think we are a basket of deplorables.
"CHristian Nationalist" is anyone that believes in God. Not government.
Or orthodox Catholics who pray the Rosary and follow the teaching of our faith. We have the FBI coming to Mass. They send Apostates to Mass to attempt to not stand out . FYI boys you stand out .
Nope
Nationalism refers to nation not religion
@@marekbrodowski7225 Yes, but Christianity is a religion. A Nationalist is just a person who strongly identifies with their own nation and vigorously supports its interests. So if I identify as someone with these characteristics, does that make me evil? If so, how?
Do they mean the people in Martha's Vineyard that will not take in the invaders they support ..The National Guard was called fast when they showed up there
The authors despise the ranchers, farmers, truck drivers, fork lift operators, bakers, butchers, and clerks who are filling their grocery stores with food everyday.
they want control over all that. They don't have it yet. These people have too much power, so they represent a high risk of rebellion, a counter power, trucks that can act like tanks, tractors, weapons, the ability to block the food supply, and food independance for themeselves. Every last impacting revolt that scared the "elites" came from them : yellow vests in France, trucker convoy in Canada, farmers in the EU. This is a problem for them, and those Yt tend to go directly to places of powers when they are unhappy, unlike other people that will attack the next village, or a christmas parade...
Nope.
Glad to see that you both agree about how disgusting this book is and how MSNC should not be promoting the views of those twisted authors.
How many have READ the book? It only came out on February 27. Any discussion of a book you've not read is an uninformed discussion.
We are the carbon footprints that they want to reduce.
💯
I grew up in very rural central Florida in the 50's, 60's and 70's. My Dad was a rocket engineer at Cape Canaveral but had grown up on a working farm in Ohio and we had a modest working beef cattle operation in my youth until i left for the Marine Corps and then Engineering College and Dad was transferred to Vandenberg AFB in Cali in '77. My Dad instilled a strong work ethic and individualism traits within me that I have carried throughout my personal/academic life and professional career. It definitely pisses me off to see those traits denigrated by the coastal elites..who have probably never milked a cow or raised cattle to see them slaughtered to feed the public. As for my education, I scored a perfect 2400 on my SAT's in '75 and have both undergrad and grad Engineering degrees from two Top 20 Engineering Colleges and have had a 36 year career with two large American defense contractors. Trump has my vote in November.
This is why I can't support student debt relief. Go to an overpriced academy that teaches to "problematize" a lower class, then legislate the lower class to pay for it after graduation.
Thank you for a clear take.
I understand your view but it is the working class and rural kids who are the ones getting out the student loans.
I believe investing in students is a investment into the future, clamping a heavy debt with a steep interest onto them will only hampering the growth of the nation.
Upper class people don't take out loans for school. They just pay for it. Never forget that.
A lot of people go to college to learn how to develop new crops, machinery, and infrastructure that people of all classes rely on. So maybe don’t throw away the baby with the bath water.
I live in one of the 20 largest cities in Ohio. Despite being relatively suburban vs rural, nearly 35% of the population is non-white. I can tell you from firsthand experience that my neighbors are kind, caring and respectful of each other. There is no "rural rage"?
What irritates many of the folks I've spoken to since 2020 or so is the entire failure of the Federal govt to respect the will of the people. Ohio is considered a ruby red state, but we overwhelmingly legalized cannabis last fall. This is entirely incompatible with the comments of these authors. If Ohio was populated with "Christian Nationalists", this wouldn't have been possible.
Only recently have academics and media pundits so horribly misrepresented Midwestern voters. Sorry folks, but few Americans can take seriously those who don't drive themselves to work each day or know the price of a gallon of milk or a loaf of bread. Everyday Americans are truly struggling and have finally determined that neither party serves their interests.
I'm over 50 and I have watched the ruling class perpetually fail to deliver on campaign promises. Biden has been warned ad nauseum that his unconditional support of Israel will cost him reelection, but I'm certain that his campaign will be genuinely shocked when it actually comes to pass (and I voted for that fool of a politician in 2020.)
But why did you vote for him? I couldn't if he was the ONLY one running. Which I think is the leftist plan
When you look at those two dorks, you know they didn’t actually go out and research
They have a weird demeanor about them. They have lived their life in a bubble.
@@jimmyers8167 Most likely Broke Back Mountain fans too.........
So you didn't read the book then. 😅
@@Andrei-sg7lu "Cheap books" can be found at goodwill........
What a great way to bring this divided nation together, by dehumanizing a large group of people that you've obviously never even talked to before. Bravo.
They are the ones dividing the nation
I can’t even fathom the complete lack of self awareness of these people. If you substitute urban black people, how does that go over. Complete contempt is an understatement!
Confession through projection. They are exactly what they are accusing others of being.
it's dehumanization, and it goes further than it seems. It amongst many other things. All this racial targeting , dehumanizing, scapegoating that has been happening for a few years, and not just in the USA.
Isn't rage- is irritation & a desire to be left alone. Watching society crumble and personal responsibility falling away while they are accused of being the problem by the people who are causing the problem.
"You know how the media lies about us. They lie about black America too." An old man I was talking to in eastern Kentucky.
Agreed. - an old woman in Louisville,KY. 😁
Professional liars and dividers. Haters.
great quote, I think I'll use this one. thanks!
Ole girl actually understands on this one. Amber is on target as usual.
She is from rural Iowa as she has said a few times
I lived in Seattle almost half my life...F cities and the sheeple mindset
This is the “deplorables” all over again 😂
A failed coup IS deplorable. 😅
Skelator was He-man's uncle?
@@rockbottom8502 unfortunately ☠️
@@he-mansuncle7661 Kind of like Darth Vader was Luke Skywalker's father
@@freemarley639 The coup happened in Nov, 2020.
My rage comes from being treated as the enemy my whole life cause the color of my skin and liberals having issues with it.
Rural America feeds you and puts clothes on your back. Without rural America you wouldn’t have food, lumber, and clothes.
What happens when your a brown rural voter who is MAGA?
Pat yourself on the back for resisting media brainwashing
Your american
We are a Constitutional Republic NOT a democracy. The word democracy doesn't appear anywhere in the Constitution.
The founding fathers detested the idea of a democracy. These people know that.
WRONG. We are a Constitutional Democratic Republic.
Didn't know is this true
@@patriciapowell6047 Read the Constitution. It mandates a republican form of government, democracy is not mentioned.
@@CharlesGaynor-rz6en It's not.
Why don't they just call us "human animals"?
Give them time. They will.
They already look at us as a herd to be managed, not as a self-governing citizenry.
Meh, ask your fellow evangelicals who give them the right to do so.
And this, friends, is why we have an Electoral College. Keeps the "flyover country" from being totally unrepresented. Oh, and BTW, I do have a college degree.
That's the problem. They are over represented and holding the nation back with their grievances.
Malcolm X warned Black People about Liberals. & Everybody else for that matter.
Malcolm X warned us about all white people, Liberal and Conservative.
Today...Jessica and Amber fit the description.
Yeah they warned y’all. And most people keep believing the lies from both parties. Conservatives claim libs are brainwashed without having absolutely no self reflection. Conservatives aren’t free thinkers, they’re just the other side of the coin. If you don’t agree with maga conservatives that n every single issue they cast you out as a traitor or claim you’re brain dead. I can’t get behind parties who’s supporters are simply just playing for teams. Unfortunately I thought republicans were a bit more logical and open minded. But they’re just like Dems in that anyone who even slightly disagrees with them is casted out.
@@NEILL0608 Dang Neill, where would you be today if not for white folk? Africa ? I guess there is no slavery there now , Right ?
Like Alfred North Whitehead said, “the thoughts of an illiterate man may not be much but at least they are his own”.
As a rural physician, the only things we have in common is a skepticism for buildings higher than four stories, an enthusiasm for firearms and a hatred for government overreach.
It’s really scary watching these people marginalize sectors of our population. Reminds me of what happened to the Jewish people in Germany.
This is how it starts... By first creating the "us vs them" mentality. Then it's dehumanizing them. You can guess what comes after that.
Don't be deceived. They are doing that to Jews again.
You mean. Like the 2 jewish authors. The same as the majority of people spreading the anti white message
it does. It reminds me of the UN list of signs forgoing events that happened in Germany, and Rwanda, and Bosnia, and Zimbabwe......another "usual" thing is also happening, the targets refuse to see it or believe it. They brush it off until it's too late.
Except they were a minority.
That doesn't explain why Miami went red and it also doesn't explain why you get males still in school are becoming more conservative
Males in school becoming more conservative is probably due to tempon dispensers in their bathrooms.
i don't know about Miami, but I think I can explain the guys going red...
It's all the hatred from "the other half" who are going more blue.
What are you talking about? Miami was blue 53 to 46 Biden. Just about every major city in Florida went blue. Rural area went red. But I'm not sure about this video opinion is THE standard for white rural voters.
@@cassiescornerreviews6884 women and girls are more likely to liberal because of the males wiring of the brain of being a protector of their family with the testosterone in them
@@cjmacd07 the mayor of Miami is a Republican from Latin America,Cubans and Venezuelans were key in flipping Florida red because they know the horrors of communism
It never ceases to amaze me how these over educated metro elites are so condescending who create these sweeping generalizations on any group that does not agree with their beliefs.
I believe the thinking of the authors is that there is a sort of a nest, a hive, of hatred that just needs to be purged. Once sunlight is thrown on this dark underbelly, America will be the land of the free, unbigoted, and voting according to their value system (mostly likely focused on the value of CARE). It is not a serious to attempt to understand rural American, the midwest, the economics of the rustbelt, or any wider economic and labor issues (like the fact that cheap labor overseas may end up being more exploitative of workers there, creating more injustice) that inform the choices of conservative voters or Trump voters. The authors believe in a cartoon, which they think they can defeat with their own cartoonish virtue politics.
What are you gonna do? Load us into cattle cars?
don’t give them any ideas
@@billyshears2032 I'm sure they've already thought of it.
@@utah_koidragon7117 they don’t build fema camps for nothing
I knew a guy that wanted to separate the coastal states from the red states.
Eventually
To these people, you are not "educated" unless you have a piece of paper saying you are. Only from a college or university though. If you took gender studies and got a degree, they consider you educated. If you want to trade school and mastered the intricacies of the electrical workings of a skyscraper, you are not educated. God for bid if you learnt mechanics the old-school way of just tinkering around with cars. You could disassemble and reassemble their automobile, but you didn't study Shakespeare so you're not educated even though what you can do is actually empirically important. I can't stand the term educated.
People think "educated" means "smart."
The college anti-Semitism hearing debunks that idea.
@@italia689 educated means "spent time memorizing", for the most part. It speaks more to study ethic than it does intelligence. The kids with the best grades in school were almost never the wisest.
I wonder if these guys go to farmers markets in NYC and DC. Or are they afraid that the goat cheese and heirloom tomatoes are filled with rage?
What they really hate is middle class!!!
Rural people hate the lower class so much that karma made them join the lower class. I think it's funny asf.
@libertas5005 take your meds you dont grasp reality.
Well, now _I'm_ outraged--at these self-righteous, elitist, judgmental, intellectual snobs.
We voted for Obama thinking he would represent the working class. He didn't things got worse for us. Then we voted for Trump things got better our value as workers increased because of supply and demand. Then Biden came in and labor is now getting devalued because more workers less pay less workers better pay simple math. Now the company I work for is starting to try to find ways to get rid of people by enforcing rules that were never enforced so they can replace us with cheaper labor. Thanks Biden.
He tried. He fought to give insurance for over 300 million uninsured. The republicans fought him tooth and nail refusing everything. Be honest.
He tried, but ultimately, he sold out for the sake of politics and ACA was a fake win and giveaway to the industry. Industry profits increased and it did little to fix most of the root issues. Republicans have done worse than nothing for their part. It’s inexcusable that this is one of the issues that most Americans agree on, but politicians are too concerned with offending the profits on their donors to fix the problem.
But, but mean tweets! Orange mean tweets!
Wait, who did that and when, and who fought back? Lol now YOU be honest.@@bblwarrantydepartment981
How about you be honest, that bill was more than likely tied to other issues that have nothing to do with health insurance. You can’t be disingenuous and pretend that democrats were trying to give people a single topic bill. They always tie BS into those hills and act as if republicans are the bad guys for shooting down bills with many added things to it
Hmmm I wonder how these city people who claim this get their food??
They never factor that into the equation
It comes from the grocery store! Of course!
I've seen street interview videos on TH-cam where college students are asked where food comes from, and they literally think that it originates from a grocery store. They have no concept of food production.
Just because a rural person might be a farmer that grows food, has nothing to do with the farmer not being a racist.
@@NEILL0608 . . .racist is a made up word to demonize white people.
Let all these non-white countries open up their borders to all colors and creeds from all around the world.
How many organizations are there that promote and advocate for white people?
Now how many organizations are there to promote and advocate for "people of color"?
Where did all the violence happen over the last 4 years? Urbania!!
Wish that could have been a segment on MSNBC. I'm an old DC plumber who retired and moved to Bedford Pennsylvania. I can tell you these people are union Democrats. Steel, Coal and factories are gone. There's a bar down the street called the Democrat. A lot of trump signs in this neighborhood. Thank you both that was good.
Agreed. I grew up in that neck of the woods. Those people were once the backbone of the Democratic party.
The Democrat party has been taken away from them by the far Left but they still want their votes come election day.@@qbitz08
Calling those people "liberal elites" is a compliment that I don't give them.
They are actually the opposite of both "liberal" (in the classical sense)... and "elite".
YT won't let me give an accurate description...
I will Give MSNBC Credit they never give up on their Bulls-it
Imagine saying that half the country is a threat to democracy because they also are able to advance what they want through democracy.
they are eligible to return to israel
I know! Rural whites aren't trying to remove anyone off primary ballots. Weird.
or to pass the Civil Rights Act of 1964 or the Immigration Act of 1965 when the white population was around 90%. It doesn't add up and now more and more white people are taking notice.
I'm half Japanese, half white boy fromArkansas. Do I get a pass? 🤣🤣🤣
I'm half Japanese, half white born in Minnesota. I grew up in small city in northern Wisconsin where my mother, my sister, and I were the only Asians for most of my life. My neighbors never treated us any different than anyone else in town.
You get half a pass. LOL
Can't believe I finally agreed with Jessica on something. Sent a shiver up my spine.
Right.......
This is easily an example of that "conspiracy theory" about The Great Replacement.
Yes, the solutions these authors propose perfectly into that "conspiracy theory."
Booshie coastal elites...
Bougie*
@@Christopheromoan Bourgeoisie* :D
They are pretty booshie too
Tiny hats
We are deplorable Christian outlaw nationalist we are taking our country back
I'm about 99% white and about 1% native American. I grew up in a small town of 1,000. I'm not Christian or racist. My wife is a legal immigrant from Indonesia. I consider myself conservative, but not a republican.
Good, here's a cookie.
@@libertas5005 Nice to see you contributing in a positive way, can I have one too?
@@big0bad0brad😅
@campursarian
(scratches head) conservative, but not republican
why that's just impossible
challenges the whole world view given to me by the suits on television
could they have been lying all along...
@@libertas5005why be rude? What purpose does it serve?
The barn needs painted, all y'all! We raised 9 full-sibling children on our diversified farm. We've had farm customers from all over the world (mostly students or professors or the hardest working Hispanic people you ever met).
What's this rage garbage? Working in a garden will take it right out of you! Send those authors out here and see if they can keep up with us old folks.
We've had 4 legal Haitian Humanitarian Parolees live with us starting last July. They are very black and we are white with blue eyes. We all get along fine. Once they get their SSN and work authorizations they are working full time in the city before moving to their own housing. Government, please just leave us all alone.
I didn't vote for Trump first time around but I sure will now.
Ask Trump how many awards he’s won for helping the black communities. He has never pandered, and said he carries hot sauce around.
I’ve never in my life seen so many white people call other white’s racist!!! They have some major skeletons they’re relentlessly trying to hide.
What he means by less education really means less indoctrinated.
These people live in an echo chamber, and have zero self awareness of how destructive, and abhorrent their divisive rhetoric is.