The Sig P322 VS The KelTec P17
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 ก.ย. 2024
- A head to head of some of the most popular 22lrs on the market today. Does a bigger price tag mean better?
Merch Shop: family-firearm...
Facebook: / familyfirearmreviews2022
Patreon: www.patreon.co...
Instagram: / familyfirearmreviews
Redditt
/ familyfirearmreviews
/ 9mmshooters
I have both. For me, the P17 is more reliable and more accurate. Both great .22s
Ok, Think I will stay with my P17 and I liked it so much, I bought another one 4 months later! I have over 1000 rounds through both guns and Never had any malfunctions at all except a few Dud Rounds! I shoot only CCI MINI Mags, 40 grain, copper Clad Bullets! Great shooting guns with that fixed barrel and great trigger!
I've thrown federal, CCI, Aguila, Remington...all in my p17 and it eats pretty much everything. Shot 100's and 100's of rounds through it and only a couple malfunctions so I can't complain!
After a few hundred rounds, the p 17 has really smoothed out for us.
I have them both and The Kel-Tec does better and the magazines we're only like $15
Aguila Super Extra 40 grain HV and CCI 40 grain Minimags run flawlessly in my wife's P17. She confiscated it. She will allow me to shoot a mag or 2 if I help her reload. I have another on order. CT red dot and slide from Keltec waiting on my bench. I have a good bit of Winchester 22lr on hand and only shoot it in the manually operated guns.
Lauren did the same she always steals the good ones hahah.
P17 is good 22LR. I had no failures .
Great family review! I have the P17 for about a year and just installed the factory slide with the Crimson Trace optic. Love it even more. Keep 'em coming!
They have an optic ready p17 now. The slide is super lightened now.
winchester .22's suck big time..cci mini maf all the way, worth every penny.p17 ! best deal out there. using old sticky crap doesnt help.
Why i like the P17
15 ounces with 17 rounds
The mag is dummy proof so you cant load the rounds wrong unlike the P322 if you load them wrong will lead to failures.
I can swap the red dot slide back to the oem slide in seconds if need be.
So edc i would use the iron sight slide, then at the range, swap to the red dot slide.
And the P17 is $200 as low as $179 when on sale vs $400 for the P322
The Kel-Tec is the better pistol.
I think you are the only ones I've ever seen on here. Have trouble with the Kel Tec
There will always be one. Ours has since smoothed out.
I had the same problem when I used other brands of ammo until I switched to CCO only. It shoots like a sewing machine.
cheap old ammo will crap out on anything
With that many malfunctions on the p17 you need to send it back to be worked on. It’s free and covered 100% by warranty. They will pay for 2-day shipping all you have to do is send it to em and wait to get it back. I was really impressed with their customer service as well. I didn’t have to wait on hold and the lady I spoke to was extremely helpful and professional not to mention kind and sweet.
I own both of these guns and really like both of them, but I wind up shooting the p17 a lot more because, with good ammo, it never has any problems. I have gone out and put 1000 rounds through it with no problems unless I get a dud bullet. The sig is a little more prone to jamming. P17's also a breeze to clean and for me, more accurate. I'm 6'6" with a big hand - p17 feels better for a large hand. Back in the day, I use to chuckle at Keltec, now I have 3 that I love - sub-2000 which is just plain fun, pmr30 22 mag, which runs high velocity ammo with such accuracy I can get a 1 inch grouping at 75 yards, and the p17 which is as accurate as I could hope fror a little concealable and doesn't feel like a small gun in my hand.
Everyone, please stop using Winchester 22 ammo. If nobody buys it they will stop making their junk.
I chose the P17 just on its reputation vs the Sig, and I have not been disappointed. It runs everything I put throughout (not Winchester). The P17 has much better reviews and it’s cheaper.
I stopped buying Winchester ammo years ago because it was garbage I only shoot Remington cci aguila,the new Remington golden bullets in the bucket are very good bulk 22lr now since they were bought by a new company seems like the quality is back
Yeah, the Golden Bullets and Thunderbolts have both been solid for a while vs years ago when you couldn’t trust them.
P17 ALL DAY
Pretty sure we agree as well
P 17 just because it’s the one I have. It’s at a good price. Super light. 3 mags. Put a compensator on it just because I could. And it’s so ugly that it’s beautiful type of deal. Glad I got one.
Once broken in my P322 is AMAZING!!!!!
Keep it up. The variety of the channel is getting good!
I have no time with the P17. But I had the Sig and had leading issues bad after 30 rds. Sig finally after 7 months of me sending in and not happy they took gun back and refunded me. Tools and Target channel had same issues with Sig
We have not had leading issues yet. We do bore brush it after every trip to the range. Sorry your P322 didn't work out. We do like our p17. It didn't start that way for me, but it grew on me.
It was actually painful to watch how many problems you had with the P17. This pistol seems to perform much better in all the other TH-cam videos I’ve watched - and that’s a LOT of them.
Theirs a dud in every batch. If you watch our 1000 round review ours smoothed out in the end. It definitely doesn't like Remington golden bullets haha.
@@FamilyFirearmReviews Tell me about it! I have one open bucket that’s nearly full and a high percentage won’t even chamber in some of my bang-sticks! Plus another bucket still sealed and I’m wondering what delightful surprises await me in that one.
Mine runs very well with cci mini mags .... Maybe 1 stove pipe after 5 or 6 mags.
I do not have a Sig p322 I did have a Walther P22 and a Kei tec p 17. I like the P17 more than the P22. The only thing I have about the P17 is it's very ammo picky it's picky with ammo. The ammo I have had no issues with in it are Aguila 49 high velocity and Armscore 36 grain high velocity and Remington golden bullet
The TH-cam channel tools and target said that's the sig p322 had a bad problem with leading up the barrel.and sig never fixed the issue and he is a sig fan on everything but the p322
We have heard that but have not had any issue with ours so far
And the gun shop will say to NOT use lead ammo ....
Just found your channel. Very well done. Thank you !
Keep rocking your thing 👍😎
Thank You!
I have 2 p17s with crimson trace Optics from keltec
The sig p322 Leads up the barrel the kel tec does not
Not all of them, I have had my P322 for over 8-months and I have shot over 5,000 rounds through it with no leading issues
We have not had any issues with ours as well.
In any review of any 22 I don’t get too excited with a hiccup or two. 22 ammo can be very finicky indeed. I think you reviewed both firearms very fairly. I do like the simplicity of the P17. There is a difference in price, but in the scheme of things it’s really not significant. For me I like the P17. BTW I own two of them. Cheers!
I own the keltec p17 love it have shot several hundred rounds with various ammo standard velocity and high velocity maybe a couple feeding issues and light primer strikes but overall the gun preforms great you can pick one up now at Grabagun for $180 comes with 3 -16 round mags great value 👍
GARBAGE IN; GARBAGE OUT. ~ 1800 rounds in 3 different P17's, no malfunctions with Sellier & Bellot 40 gr ammo. You get what you pay for.
Agree. But we like to test will all kinds of different ammo.
sig wont admit to bad early 322 and I wouldnt own one
has it been fixed yet ???
Great video guys! I have the Keltec P17 recently adding the factory red dot with matching slide. I might have about 2000 rounds through it. I certainly find it runs well with CCI Mini-Mag ammo, and can be unreliable with other brands. Although when it dirty the slide doesn’t always take a round into battery so you have to bump the rear of the slide. Your video sure makes me want to try the P322!
We love out p322 and out p17. Great training firearms for sure! The taurus TX22 is also a great training aide foe concealed carry.
Excelent review
The P17...
It says high velocity ammo only for p17
Yep but most people are going to run what they have and cheap stuff. Why build a cheap gun and require expensive ammo? 🤔
9/19/23 the sig is running around 400 on sale the keltec is 199
Your wife's a great shot.
She's pretty amazing!
I would be tempted to lean towards the P17, if it came with an optics ready slide. I believe I like the P322; yes, it's ammo finicky, and you really need to load the magazines carefully, as well as clean the barrel frequently, but otherwise it just seems to be the better of the two.
Kel Tec, put an optics ready slide on the P17, and we'll talk.
P.S. Replace the fiber optics on either the front or back of the P322, and you should have less problems sighting the irons. Suggestion: red fiber optics on the back and green up front; but I'm not an optometrist, so that's up to you.
The new p17s have an optic ready slide. You should check them out. Thanks for checking out the channel!
The P17 has a dummy proof mag and loads like a center fire. Cant load them wrong at all. The P322 and the TX22 you CAN load them wrong which will cause failures.
I have the red dot slide on my P17 and i like it. I also like the fact that i can swap the red dot slide out for the iron sight in seconds if need be. For your edc, i would use the iron sight slide because the red dot is not in the way, when i go to the range, i put the red dot on.
Cant do that with any other gun. If your red dot fails, you can't use the iron sights unless its designed to co-witness.
But this P17 with cci mini mags, it runs GOOD
P17 is half the price of the Sig
100%
This one..