French election chaos, Rachel Reeves orders finances review and Nigel Farage, MP | The Daily T
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ส.ค. 2024
- In a shock result, the second round of French elections delivered a victory of sorts to the left-wing New Popular Front alliance, pushing Marine le Pen’s National Rally into third place behind the centrists. But with no group winning a majority in parliament, President Emmanual Macron now faces some difficult choices.
To discuss what it means for France, Europe and the UK’s fledgling government, Kamal and Camilla are joined in the studio by French journalist Charlotte Kan and The Telegraph’s resident Parisian Adelie Pojzman-Pontay.
Plus, how has Prime Minister Keir Starmer fared in his first few days in government? The new Cabinet is off to a flying start, but Kamal and Camilla notice a familiar name that keeps cropping up: Tony Blair. We also have a dispatch from Nigel Farage’s victory tour around his new constituency of Clacton.
#farage #france #elections
Read more here: www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2024...
00:00 Intro
07:52 French elections chat
28:00 Rachel Reeves speech analysed
How France deals with Islam is the real question but they are too afraid to even mention it.
“Deals with Islam”? The far right is actually the real danger. That’s why they are projecting their fear based ideology onto a minority group.
Yes, - it's not about economics. It's about racial and religious replacement and cultural anihilationi
I’m 61 and I’m fearful of this country becoming an Islamic state. Look at Lebanon religious demographics in the late 70’s and now!
Absolutely correct. Strange that none wanted to mention the most obvious: th-cam.com/video/b4VJofC_PFA/w-d-xo.htmlsi=Z4eUf62QuZhHyyR5
@@MrMarktheblueit started with the dismemberment of thousands of years old civilisational state Bharat (India) and the creation of Jihadist Pakistan in 1947.
Why are European democracies not allowed or denied their right to remain who they are .....India is Indian , China is Chinese, Japan is Japanese but heaven for bid a European country who allows and facilities people from other countries who they have welcomed and at the same time not wishing to lose their sense of who they are its a complete joke.
Low birth rates
Perhaps former colonial people have a claim to French citizenship?
Homogeneous countries still have partisan politics and identities.
As for India, there are huge sectarian divisions over religion and the caste system, whereby some minorities are seen as less Indian.
China also has multiple ethnic identities, Han, Manchu, Tibetan, Uighurs, Bai, Pumi, etc, and two major languages Mandarin and Cantonese.
Had they not become indepent they might have had a claim to French citizenship, but independent countries have no claim to anything.
@@user-cu5nw7kq5b Why do people use colonization as a reason as to why the colonized HAVE a right to move to the colonizers native land? I'm actually curious...
That's the masonic plan.
The “far far far left” should stop calling the right “far right”
exactly this ..!
33.2% every third French, the majority in the countryside voted RN. And the left and the center allied in no time against the strongest block shouting FAR right. That attitude of the center and the left is FUNDAMENTALIST and is organised by a media machine.
The two round voting system is HEAVILY biased towards coalitions. Same as the two round presidential system. The union of the right is unavoidable. The Patriots for Europe group will help rebrand Le Pen, Kickl, Babits, Salvini, maybe Fico and others who join. And the cordonne sanitaire that prevented the union of the right will be broken.
Definitely 💯 %
Gibberish! Far far far left is calling far left as far right!
@@feydrautha80 The peoples republic of far far far left hate the far far far left peoples republic, with a passion
Kamal: "without immigration they'd be no growth' Maybe once that was true, when we had people more of our Christian culture. I don't care about growth if it means those coming don't give a tuppenny toss about our culture, our traditions, our cultural holidays our values and our way of life.
I would rather be poor ,as in 1950 at least we where happy.
here here.
Cos he is the problem. Nigeria for Nigerians. Egypt for Egyptians. Europe for everyone.
Spot on 👍
Half a pound of tuppenny rice
Half a pound of treacle
That's the way politics goes
Pop does the weasel
God I can't watch anymore "4 days of labour" and the commentator "I love it" so much for independent analytical journalism.
Good summary.
We know how much of a raging lefty she is from her shows on GBNews. They tried to balance the channel out by getting her on board, but she is uber left wing.
This guy bugged me so much with his close mindedness, everytime his mouth opened all I heard was 'agenda'
They “love it” because they are yet to be aware what hit them. Maybe they will when it becomes UKSthan and all too late😳❗️❗️
@@williamward3047that because he loves Jihadism.
Ha. Labour have to put up now. Watch farage laugh all the way to the next elections.
thorn In labour's side, farage is
From a historical perspective she's more a centrist.
Funny how we always appear to have a far right wing but never a far left wing, it's always just 'left'
The guest literally says "far left" at 10:30 in the video.
The guests pointed out the Left Alliance was a combination of centre left parties and the hard left. The difference is the far-left tend to accept the label, whereas fascists seem to think "fascism" is an insult.
a far left winger is a revolutionary committed to overthrowing the capitalist state. The far right wing are heirs of Hitler and Mussolini.
Far far far left.
He left are all fascists
Le pen isn't hard right or even right wing
Ur mother took the hard one
I believe the British term for people like Le Pen is "nutter"
No they are not, but the leftist fascists will do anything to remain in power. Falsehood is what they use to convince people they are the right choice.
Nope. She s a socialist.
She's a populist with some right wing ideas.
When most politicians talk all I hear is "bla bla bla bla "
It might be six reform MPs one coming from Northern Ireland
Tell me more
@@BobWilliamson-to3xp isn’t there an MP from TUV, closely allied to Reform?? Or was until Farage endorsed two other candidates. TUV have Reform logo with TUV.
5 with a TUV allied MP who will be acting as Reform whip.
I was wondering how his party landed, 🇨🇦
I was wondering how his party landed. 🇨🇦
Is Britain REALLY in for five years of stable government? The cracks are appearing already.
I sincerely hope not, the rate of undocumented people being admitted to the U.K terrifies me.
"culture of conflict" in France, spot on!!
NIGEL..FARAGE. IS. ONE. VERY. GOOD. AND. VERY. VERY. GOOD. MAN. OF. UK. PEOPLE. 😊😊😊😊
time will tell, he was a disgrace before when he was elected MEP. caused a expense scandal, along with other things.
Why hard left not far left? Noticing this more and more. It's always one way when it's about the word far.
France is officially in recession and has been since May. Only Canada is doing worse. Personally, I've put my Paris apartment up for sale since the elections were called. I have 2 other passports - 🇺🇸 and 🇨🇭 - a son in Spain 🇪🇸 and work online. Bank accounts already transferred abroad, perfectly legally. I'm a very middle income earner, save that I own my apartment, have my own business. A minimum wage of 1600 euros means I'd go bankrupt if I wanted to hire someone. My retirement age is already 67, has been since previous president Hollande.
Can’t imagine anyone having a U.S. passport and not choosing to live in the US if they are still of working age/need. Earn in the US, retire in the EU.
If only Putin had not invaded Europe and destabilized the world economy.
Cool story.. I’m doing the exact same thing in reverse. I’m moving from Hungary to France because of this election outcome. Already transferred my $43 million in assets to French banks.. Will be putting all my business there.
Owning an apartment in one of the most important cities isn’t middle income. lol middle income is struggling to get by
@@conr2141ur a retard
Nigel Farage is The only Hope The UK Has Left#.
Reform is pushing the same economic policies as Liz Truss, so if that's "hope" I'll take despair instead.
He can promise anything because he's not in power. When pressed on how he'll achieve his aims he folds like a broken deckchair.
Scotland and NI don't reckon so. They are wide awake and don't need reformed by the Clacton crusader.
Reform parliament and get rid of the mediaeval pantomime rehtoric. Do that and the 4 nations won't need hope.
From my activist experience with UKIP and Reform over the last thirty years the electorate who identify as being on the Right are not generally prepared to engage in activism. Those of the Left are prepared to engage in political activism to get what they want and they are successful too. In short, those on the Right should not be looking to what Reform can do for them but what they can do for Reform. Those of a Right wing persuasion need to find their cojonnes and engage in activism or they will be crushed and they only have themselves to blame.
Nigel Farage would destroy the UK economy. Don't be fooled by populist drongos.
😂😂😂🎉😂
THE REVOLUTION HAS BEGUN.
I’m so sick and tired of people tossing about the far right this the far right that. It’s a very inaccurate labeling
of people grouping any one with mild or moderate conservative beliefs in with far right anarchism. Just because people want to hold on to their culture and history and be patriotic doesn’t mean they are far right extremists. Seems to me they the far right has cause and reasons to become violent but they haven’t it’s the far left extremists who have exhibited violence against not only Jewish people but British white Anglo-Saxon
people let’s start talking about that more often instead of kowtowing to the far left extemists and terrorists supporters. Get a bloody clue!!!
People of France will read a book 50 years down the line that “THERE WAS A FRANCE” in their new country “ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF FRANCE”….
France - Your days are over.
La Ila ilililaah… 😂😂😂😂
THEY ARE NOT THE " FAR RIGHT"!!! THEY ARE JUST RIGHT!!!
Is this the Telegraph or the Guardian? When asked what the host thought of the first days of a labour government, she said, "I'm loving it." This is a Conservative journalist, supposedly. On top of this her co host said "frankly without migration we wouldn't have had any economic growth". What absolute rubbish. I think I'll watch Guardian podcasts in future. This is the worst of the Right. I just wish we could vote these out too.
Kamel could hardly tell the truth about immigration which is just repeating the Bank of England misplaced and inaccurate ideology that all immigration is good whereas the truth is, integrating new arrivals if they are even willing to integrate, costs an eye watering £90 billion, with strains across all the infrastructure.
This situation in France 🇫🇷 proves that First passed the post works well compared to this Frankanstine parallement in France 🇫🇷 lol 😂
On 35% of people voted for labour but they won 75% of seats some would say were not even a real democracy anymore.
Rubbish
Except that: Lib Dems 13% of votes 61 seats; Reform 14% of votes 5 seats.
@@davidjohns4745
Except that, 62% of the UK electorate do not want the right wing either….60% in 2019
@@trevaudio||Fairly consistent then, given a myriad factors at play now
It's all rigged.
lol.. “if I lose it’s cheating!” .. whine harder
@@conr2141 Your'e wrong, I'm not rooting for anyone. None of them are worth voting for, the whole system is rigged. They are all puppets getting their orders from the WEF, so they can implement The UN Agenda 2030, where we all own nothing and are (apparently) happy.
@@conr2141 Yeah but the French electoral system is actually designed ("rigged") to prevent extremist parties from gaining a majority. Multi-round elections facilitate strategies like tactical voting and bloc formation for the express purpose of favoring centrist and liberal coalitions in the final tally.
🤡
Yes it's to maintain the Globalists Agenda...CONTROL.
National Rally is not far Right but Deep Right.
Voters can decide for thesmselves where political parties are on the map.
'Deep' because they live in caves, and come out blinking into the light, when they hear the Farage Foghorn of Ignorance?
Why does camilla talk so much and suck all the oxygen out of the room
Decades of practice speaking with her mouth full. See Willy Brown for details.
NR beat all parties on the national vote at around 37%.
I don't think this lady (host) understands how the french 2 round system works... And her "analysis" is all over the place. Also the « expert » is pretty off the mark. Because we have a 2 round voting system doesn’t mean there’s anything « proportional » involved. The final result this time is quite exceptional and so now they (the different groups) will have to learn to make compromises to move forward. Anyways, journalists and their experts really shouldn’t talk « on air » about stuff the don’t understand
All these experts 😂😂😂
MISTER. NIGEL. FARAGE. IS ONE. VERY. INTELLIGENT. MAN. OF. UK. PEOPLE.
He’s more in touch with Brits than the rest of the other MPs.
This is an exciting opportunity for the French to reunite around the
classical ideas of the Enlightenment, such as Liberty, Equality
and Democracy, built on common ground.
This discussion raised an important issue, where does money come from?
What is the history of central banking, and the global financial system?
Why is every single country in the world in debt?
Another important issue is how we can overcome
our dependence on fossil fuels which are running out,
and also fresh water....
Can we overcome self-destruction?
Beneficiaries of overseas colonies were usually a small number of merchants looking for safety in their travels from their own govt. Not the general population. Countries which have been self governing for over 50 years are not due welfare at the cost of current tax payers. By denying welfare to economic migrants, it insures people who do arrive in Europe are self funding. This is a typical expectation in other countries outside Europe. A number of countries would also expect immigrants to arrive with a minimum amount of capital, like $100k, in return for a visa .
What an ignorant discussion. Nothing was said about the link between excessive immigration and islam and cultural decline. Waste of time.
Because it's a ludicrous scaremongering tactic.
As for British culture, there's more culture in a newly made yoghurt.
They pretend like they know something.
@@sasserineleave then
Why did that hard-faced woman shake head violently when she uttered the name Marine Le Pen at 00.15?
Does she violently shake her head when saying Kier Starmer? No, then she'd genuflect.
Housing targets will never be hit.....are they planning to arrest the owners of house building companies if they miss a target? Is there a target on migration? Are there going to be departmental arrests if a migrant target isn't met? There a lot of "we're going to do this" and "we're going to do that" saying this stuff is easy.....delivering is difficult. If just saying the stuff is "Hitting the ground running" then there will be a lot of very deluded Labour voters fairly soon. I suspect we will get more money spent, little delivered, more abuse of the word "mandate" and lots of excuses about how they have inherited the UK at it's worst since the 50's.
"they have inherited the UK at it's worst since the 50's."
With housing more unaffordable than at any time in nearly TWO HUNDRED YEARS ..!!
But they are actually trying unlike the Tories
@@peterjermey7235 yes they are.........we will have fewer prisoners (don't remember that in their manifesto) when what we actually need are fewer criminals......but don't worry because the police are hard at work babysitting protesters of issues that aren't even in the UK........and we will have fewer illegal migrants because they will just term all migrants legal and of course that won't attract more migrants....I guess the 1.5 million new homes is actually for the migrants.
America has too few parties, and Britain, France and other democracies of their type have too many parties.
Labour need to concentrate on what they're doing not what everyone else is doing
How to explain something without actually explaining nothing…..ask these two French journalists
They never mentioned the biggest problem and threat in their country.
Politics is like explaining experimental theology.
If Le Pen is a Far Right Party, who is the Right Party in France?
"Re-calibration" lol
Unfortunately this podcast is Croque Manure
Don’t listen to it then. Simples
Marine Le Pen far right? I think she is centre right.
There is a disconnection between the politician elites and the people
Putin again, Jesus... are u guys getting paid everytime u mention Putin
If it’s Left it’s fair Left no question about it.
If they call the Right fair Right then no difference between them 😅
The French have borrowed so many English words. The word for the weekend is le weekend, but in Quebec it is fin de semaine, literally 'end of week' or 'look" used in the fashion sense such as Spring's new looks. Only fair I suppose since we've borrowed so many of theirs.
Of the two French ladies, the first one doesn’t seem ‘very French’ nor very English either…whither that Gallic charm? Maybe a bit too boastful bordering on a certain arrogance…And her colleague has picked up more than two instances of ‘the glottal stop’ indicative of the English company kept.
Why aren't there far right coalitions ?
46:14 Nigel Farage
Refuse the resignation? How does that work?
the president rejects their resignation. Theoretically, it doesn't matter but the president is still in charge.
"Je refuse"
"Oui, monsieur le président"
Resignation is just a formal legislative procedure under the present parliamentary circumstances.
There will not be be anything left of France
Did Nigel throw any bombs on the first day or will he keep his power dry?
What should make Le Pen “far” right?
Mmm croque monsieur....
There is NO HARD RIGHT IN FRANCE. STOP THE MISNOMER.
E U Is on its way to being over FANTASTIC ✨️
I liked Camilla Tominey better on GB News. This a bit more like 'News by a committee', boring. She's just better than this.
Stop calling them far right they are the French people speaking up for there country the ones who actually love there country, just like the REFORM party in England and the people who follow them
Listenibg to Bkaur? Why not, he amd his family have made millions in politics/contacts. Rewarding. Perhaps it could rub off on the peasants?
Has Camilla joined the Met on the sly?
Wow! This is a person who used the usual “verboten” terminology! …”far-left” and “ hard left.” Let’s hope she doe#n’t get disappeared!
Can we talk about the brain drain half a million Brits emigrated last year. I see many more going.
If we are to build all this housing stock will it effect house prices.
How do we rain in the price of housing it's become unaffordable for younger people.
Obvious, they will be on benefits.
@@pennymcneela7095No benefits if they are white Brits . Money only goes to illegals
Look around a little before talking. In western Australia, flats are vacant for a couple of days. Housing issues is pretty global.
@@stevenpace892 made worse when governments put up illegals migrants in hotels and give them houses /flats, while native populations are given nothing . Since when are criminals ( because that is what being an illegals migrant is ) are compensated with free housing while local population pays taxes and gets nothing in return? Something is wrong . Very very wrong
@@stevenpace892 Yes - that's correct (from another Australian).
Labour in the National interest, since when?
The discussion about fallout from the French election was excellent! I think the French for smorgasbord is smorgasbord with a gallic accent (quite possibly with a whiff of garlic also). R (Australia)
Where are they going to find construction workers and builders and the other trades to create all these homes?
They have them already.
@@lesleylamybut they do not work; only slur at locals, steal, rape and cry victim hood
France, like many other countries, suffers from a poverty of spirit. This is confused for a poverty of material wealth but objectively France is materially wealthy. The USA is much farther down this path. After all, the poorest people get housing, food, hot and cold running water, toilet and bathing facilities. The king of France in the 1800’s didn’t have this real material wealth available to the poorest people today. We need human contact not stuff.
Nice analysis
The municipalities will have a property tax windfall
camilla , no thanks
EU - POOTIN 2-0
Si on demande à Gabriel Attal de rester pour l instant, c est, comme lui même l a annoncé, les Jeux Olympiques de Paris étant très proches en France, logiquement un minimum de stabilité des institutions, de la Sécurité Intérieure est nécessaire cet été
nhs consultants/staff also work in the private sector how will that reduce nhs backlog?
Camilla. Oh. Nuff said 👍
Good for the UK?! Good luck wrestling Ireland for international investment.
So sorry, no sound on TH-cam.
Sad for France. RIP 💔 🙏
We are going to have 5 years of whinging from the Telegraph. Readership is falling rapidly. The Telegraph is no longer relevant.
Far Right v coalition of far left left and centrists……
not Far Left.
This box ticker for telegraph doesn't want "native' interests being paramount he wamts minority privilege that he enjoys.
Without boat people there would be no growth said the guy who refuses to call X by its proper name.
Makes his own reality?
NATIVIZM..OMG WHAT NEXT
Left right centre's!!!
Clarify...wtfooeey
Small Module Reactors Canada produces these, and they have been proposed to power AI Data Center's because of the amount of power they demand.
REFORM all the way….become a member 🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧
The French Popular Front is led by a guy so far left that he makes Corbyn look sane. And his views on Putin's war on Ukraine are no different to Le Pen.
stop with the labeling
Wtf is 'hard right'
what an eye sore of a set 😕😕😕😕😕😕😕😕
X a silly name, Kamel?
Very Beta to keep talking about how they may be laughing at your pronunciation. Their English has a French accent too. So what?
Got the sound! Had to leave and then come back.
It is about imagination and invasion of the Islam ☪️ that the point
The far right is the far right, just as a lemon is a lemon. Those who support extreme right-wing views often lack understanding. Economically, right-wing ideology favours small government and aims to preserve the status quo, while being socially conservative. The far right, however, tends to blame immigrants for various issues and proposes policies that could lead to brain drain and capital flight due to instability.
The centre-left aims to balance the economy, health, education, economic growth, and investment in people. Currently, most economies are struggling with large deficits caused by Covid-19. The major issue today is housing, where both left and right have failed, leading to widespread anger worldwide. Don't vote for a party that will tank your economy. Look at what Truss did in the UK. No thanks.
If the centre left aim to do that why do they always miss?
Trump 2024 and 2028!
Good grief. Scribes.
Telegarbage....just like the USA news
Croq Monseur 🥪 😋
FARAGE FOR P.M.
What a rubbish show. A whole lot of boring waffle about stuffthat has little relevance to british patriots.
Farage work??? ... when did he ever turn up to actually do any when he was an MEP?? ... why will it be different noe he is an MP??
The British Electoral system is brutal, but efficient at creating effective governments, the French system is theoretically better in every way, but in practice is simply worse.
I was in two minds about FPTP and PR but after seeing what happened to the French with there version of PR.
Even with the extraordinary effort that Nigel has put in only just to get a handful MPs in showed a great unfairness but I think a needed one.
To keep the flavour of the day not to sweep all before it example Israel and Palestinians before that it was BLM.
Theoretically theory coincides with practice. In practice it doesn't 😂😂😂
The British system favours Oxbridge duffers and the South of England
Forcing people into cooperation is good practice. That is the key to a successful system. Just as important as effective governments.
@@terencespragg5708
What PR system are in two minds about ? There is more than one
What happened to one day voting with paper and only citizens voting ? Who changed the voting laws ?
TOMMY ROBINSON 27TH
RN gets its strength from "no compromise", but equally it is a fatal flaw. Intelligent opponents can, and should, fight them by working with each other. Compromise is almost always the wise course.