Felt really forced though just so they could say that she has a life of her own too when 95% she’s only the Chinese bff who also talks about Chinese stereotypes all of the time. But since it’s coming from her, it seems ok.
haha each character deserves their own character growth! I love this song so much its so romantic ! i have recently made a cover of La Vie en rose on my channel. if you can check it out and lemme know what you think there it would make my day! th-cam.com/video/23nXYJIpxY0/w-d-xo.html . have a nice day!
Nah all they do is use her to insult and slander china and asian people because u can't call it racism when it's someone insulting their own race :/ also the actress they employed isn't even chinese, she's clearly korean which shows how little they care
That's like a foreigner (from any country) coming to NYC and singing New York New York. Most of us would welcome it bc that is a form of flattery. Especially, if they have as lovely a voice as Ashley Park & sung it so genuinely. I don't understand why & how some people can't see the beauty in the gesture.
Without context, this scene looks like it's about a woman falling in love with her friend as she listens to her sing, which is honestly so much better than the absolute garbage we got.
for real like why did the ppl stop walking just to hear her sing la vie en rose,, in paris it's really ain't like that everybody be minding their own biz 😭
@@i4kook749 Right😭 Imagine if you were in some random park in a suburban neighborhood and somebody started singing. I would run away from that immediately
aw sweet! I love this song so much its so romantic ! i have recently made a cover of La Vie en rose on my channel. if you can check it out and lemme know what you think there it would make my day! th-cam.com/video/23nXYJIpxY0/w-d-xo.html . have a nice day!
Yh lmao it's absolutely shit. Nobody would stop in the street to listen to such a local song. And they use mindy in such an insulting way to asian people🤢
I don’t usually cry and I don’t throw that word around lightly. But Mindy’s singing in this scene touched something in me and actually made me tear up a little.
When I met my fiancee, we went to Paris and found ourselves eating lunch, this was 20 years ago. An accordian player and singer were doing the tour of the cafes down the road. I asked them to play this for her. You want the distillation of Paris - it's this song. The series doesn't quite get Paris right all the time but this, this is spot-on.
every rendition is awesome! Ashley Park singing finally got recognized! I love this song so much its so romantic ! i have recently made a cover of La Vie en rose on my channel. if you can check it out and lemme know what you think there it would make my day! th-cam.com/video/23nXYJIpxY0/w-d-xo.html . have a nice day!
I literally love Ashley Park, she was stunning in mean girls on Broadway and in the Ratatouille the musical special, but they did her so wrong with this character. The racism especially.
Ashley Jini Park sang this better than 73 years ago. You would think that this song came from her heart. I love it.... the feelings, the emotions, everything 💕. “La Vie en rose” is a French song that was written in 1945 by French singer Édith Piaf (19 December 1915 - 11 October 1963) and released as a single in 1947.
I SCREAMED when i first saw her I dont know her name but i know that she was Gretchen in Mean Girls and her voice is AMAZING. Gosh i loved her singing this song.
Heard this on Emily in Paris. This is such a beautiful song and the way she sang it gave me chills. I dont even know any French but I think that made it even more captivating for me 💕 just beautiful...
Second fav version of this song.. how i met your mother's version is still on the top of my list.. But have to admit.. there's some kinda magic in this song.. so soothing and beautiful!
@@ahmednasir1583 maybe.. but HIMYM is a mood in itself.. also i like himym version better because her voice is softer n calming.. which is my preference
The show its self is trash but even tho this scene didnt make sense at all I liked it. She needed a full character ark and this didnt help but it's my favorite moment. But yeah the show is still garbage and a bad representation of asian culture French culture and LGBT people and Poc.
Quand il me prend dans ses bras Qu'il me parle tout bas Je vois la vie en rose Il me dit des mots d'amour Des mots de tous les jours Et ça m'fait quelque chose Il est entré dans mon cœur Une part de bonheur Dont je connais la cause C'est lui pour moi, moi pour lui dans la vie Il me l'a dit, l'a juré, pour la vie Give your heart and soul to me and life will always be la vie en rose
I love how the old comments are full of praise for her sining talent, but the newer ones are just taking the piss for the sake of it. if you don't like it and its not your thing fine, whatever no one is forcing you to watch. also of corse Paris isn't like this in reality (similar but not entirely accurate) the show is painting a romanticised picture of Paris, so obviously there going to sing one of Frances most classical and famous songs. I swear people liked the show until hating became more fashionable.
Honestly, I could judge and be mean, but the movie took my mind off of things. I think it's really sweet and inspiring in a way. (this comes from a Greek woman who literally lives 20 mins away from the parthenon and has heard people stereotyping her culture in all the wrong ways. So,yeah I get the whole "it's not the real Paris" thing too)
There's no way this would have been taken seriously in Paris, people would have, at best passed by without a second glance or laughed zt her for being such an embarassing american cliché
This is the equivalent of if somebody went to Korea with a whole choir and started singing all the themes from squid game in the middle of a Town square
![🎤 ไปกันต่อออ! จับฉลากร้องเพลง x P’ #XXSIVK [EP.2] (1/2) เพลงของใครจึ้งสุดน้าา 💓🎤 #MXFRUIT](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/mLI_K0sAS4o/mqdefault.jpg)
'Imagine someone coming to New York and singing Sweet Home alabama'. Yeah, whack.
I just watched that video, yeah, it's whack
it is weird
JUST WATCHED THAT
yeah u should sing empire state of mind duh
That's.. Why I'm here 😂😂
I love how they gave the friend her own plot that doesnt have anything to do with Emily. And tbh, it's a better plot than Emily's.
Felt really forced though just so they could say that she has a life of her own too when 95% she’s only the Chinese bff who also talks about Chinese stereotypes all of the time. But since it’s coming from her, it seems ok.
haha each character deserves their own character growth! I love this song so much its so romantic ! i have recently made a cover of La Vie en rose on my channel. if you can check it out and lemme know what you think there it would make my day! th-cam.com/video/23nXYJIpxY0/w-d-xo.html . have a nice day!
@@stefanie_irl But isn't the show built on stereotypes...?
@@stefanie_irl the fact that the writers arent even asian make it worse
Nah all they do is use her to insult and slander china and asian people because u can't call it racism when it's someone insulting their own race :/ also the actress they employed isn't even chinese, she's clearly korean which shows how little they care
Imagine you're in a park in busy London and some random person starts singing wonderwall for no reason.
Thats what this is
LMAOOO- OH GOD
Supercalifragilistic* 😂😂😂
What's wrong with that and What's wonderwall??
That's like a foreigner (from any country) coming to NYC and singing New York New York. Most of us would welcome it bc that is a form of flattery. Especially, if they have as lovely a voice as Ashley Park & sung it so genuinely. I don't understand why & how some people can't see the beauty in the gesture.
@@Abbigirl316 Neither can I. I don't understand the disapproval people feel for such a gesture. Who are they trying to impress?
how can someone sing such a beautiful song that’s inherently french and sound so incredibly american.
Lmao accent 😎
Bcos she's not french
and she wasn't even American
it's the pop music variations that do it. i facepalmed.
imagine going to germany and singing 99 luftballons
PFT -
Or Marmor Stein und Eisen bricht😆
i would
I'm planning on doing that
Me from Germany: 😀
the amount of second hand embarrassment i’m getting from these fictional characters is shameful
honestly I got alot of secondhand embarrassment from the show but it was also entertaining sometimes aksdk
Es una serie algo rara pero la mierda entretiene xd
Without context, this scene looks like it's about a woman falling in love with her friend as she listens to her sing, which is honestly so much better than the absolute garbage we got.
I JUST THOUGHT THIS
yes yes yes yes
@Tanisha Patel lol how is it not bad
@Tanisha Patel it's bad but it's sort of a guilty pleasure for me to watch stuff like that
i’ve never seen this show and never will watch it, what ends up happening? what’s the context? are they good friends ?
Is it weird that I would've preferred a TV series of Mindy's life like her life in China and France rather than a TV show about Emily?
she not white.. end of discussion
Not weird at all. I would have too.
@@rarevidz100 who isn’t?
Yes... a spin off please...
Atleast Ashley's voice is being appreciated
This scene literally makes no sense
for real like why did the ppl stop walking just to hear her sing la vie en rose,, in paris it's really ain't like that everybody be minding their own biz 😭
@@i4kook749 Right😭 Imagine if you were in some random park in a suburban neighborhood and somebody started singing. I would run away from that immediately
@@i4kook749 As someone from Paris, people would shout "TA GUEULE !" or sigh very loudly :D
She had a beautiful voice
@@samanthahussey6231 la vie en rose is the most cliche French song you can ever sing, no one would stop just to listen to it
This song is magical . I first heard it from Monte Carlo and fell in love with it .
I actually heard it first from lady gaga and I just loved it and now again I fall in love with this version as well ❤️😌😌
Sameeee
Madonna singing this live and with a tiny guitar made me realize I was French in my past life.
aw sweet! I love this song so much its so romantic ! i have recently made a cover of La Vie en rose on my channel. if you can check it out and lemme know what you think there it would make my day! th-cam.com/video/23nXYJIpxY0/w-d-xo.html . have a nice day!
Same ,monte Carlo was so good
Ashely is so witty, talented and beautiful. 🥰
i cant tell if the people in the comment section are being sarcastic or serious.
Dead serious, this show and its characters are terrible
I think theyre only commenting on the singing, which isnt too bad 🤔 the show is tho lolol
The singing is honestly terrible but the idea of seeing a random person sing something romantic in a romantic place kinda makes sense to me.
@@brylemendoza4858 if this is terrible I want to know what you think is good 🥴
Seriously sarcastic or sarcastically serious
She has a wonderful voice, fantastic presence too 🌵💗
Imagine going to Alabama and you start singing Sweet Home Alabama in the middle of a town now that that is what the producers think this scene is
If you actually did this in Alabama (coming from someone who lives in Alabama) people would either laugh or think you were on drugs
@@chelseamelissa6615 or think you married your cousin lmao
@@chelseamelissa6615 Have you ever been to a college bar in Alabama… clearly not. Lol.
She is from the mean girls musical from Broadway
Oh yeah now that u mentioned it
*I love how Mindy enjoying herself and feel for it* ❤️
God this is so cringey. The people who made this show (and the ones commenting) have NEVER been in Paris lmaooooo
Yh lmao it's absolutely shit. Nobody would stop in the street to listen to such a local song. And they use mindy in such an insulting way to asian people🤢
@@thelambsauce1701 Honestly all the comments on this video are making me so mad ahhhhhhh
I think theyre only commenting on the singing, which isnt too bad 🤔 the show is tho lolol
Her voice is good I really don’t get what the problem is
Her rendition made me tear up - it was so beautiful.
It gives me the feels in the tummy too
I wish her rendition of the song would be her EP single!
Agreed, I teared up watching this scene it was beautiful
Every.damn.time 🥰
B r u h
It was cringy
wish they made this into a single, I wna listen to it literally every hour of everyday😭😭😭
Come to France girl u will love it!
MARIAJOSE M literally been my dream since I was little!! 😭
@@user-lj8jt4mr4f I went to Paris once. It was amazing, even down to the pastries like in this series..
My thoughts exactly!
@@MsZoedog66 can't wait until I can finally go! omg!!
this comment section is being sarcastic right
nope, just culturally ignorant which is exactly the audience this show craves
@@Sarcasmses ironic
Mindy has a really beautiful singing voice.
Mindy (Ashley Park) she was Gretchen in mean girls on Broadway
I don’t usually cry and I don’t throw that word around lightly. But Mindy’s singing in this scene touched something in me and actually made me tear up a little.
HELLO
Ashley Park has the voice of an angel. I love her version of Le Vie En Rose. I listen to it all the time. May she forever be BLESSED.
I feel kinda bad for these actors who were involved in such an embarrassing dumpster fire of a show. Only a little though.
She's pouring her soul out and that's why its soooo gooood. 😍😍
Fell in love w this song coz of her cover 😍
Imagine someone coming here to Australia and singing “Waltzing Matilda” 😂
What are you on about? It’s just a joke love.
When I met my fiancee, we went to Paris and found ourselves eating lunch, this was 20 years ago. An accordian player and singer were doing the tour of the cafes down the road. I asked them to play this for her. You want the distillation of Paris - it's this song. The series doesn't quite get Paris right all the time but this, this is spot-on.
Paris isn’t this song 😂
-an annoyed Parisian
This sent shivers throughout my body that it made me tear up. Ashley Park did Edith Piaf justice. I'm sure she's applauding her from above.
Its really amazing, her voice it’s soo sweet 🤗
My second favorite cover behind the one The Mother did on HIMYM
I have heard many versions of this song but I am in love with this one in Emily in Paris. Sung beautiful by her. ❤️❤️❤️❤️
It’s TV people. Basically this lady has a fandamntabulous voice and she does a very French song justice.
I don't know why everyone's hating this scene. If you don't like it, then don't watch it. Simple as that.
someone please make a 1 hour compilation of this 😭😭 i’d love to listen to that while doing my homework 🙏
Yes Please !!
Hope we can get the full version of this one without the instruments its really good 🥺❤
God this is awful. Edith piaf is spinning in her grave at this merde
OMG STOP BWAHA
Right 😭 it's so bad and her american accent /hurts/
it's not that bad. She sings in a very American way, so it sounds strange.
Try doing better and then talk
The first I fell in love with this song is when I heard it from How I Met Your Mother’s mother. I teared up listening to Mindy’s rendition.
When does it play in HIMYM? I think I vaguely recall it being in the show now you mention it.
@@michaelpaton4091 season 9 Ep 16
@@lex4701 Thanks!
@@michaelpaton4091 No prob! Happy rewatching :D
every rendition is awesome! Ashley Park singing finally got recognized! I love this song so much its so romantic ! i have recently made a cover of La Vie en rose on my channel. if you can check it out and lemme know what you think there it would make my day! th-cam.com/video/23nXYJIpxY0/w-d-xo.html . have a nice day!
Best rendition of this song ever!
I was so shocked at this scene. I love it so much
I literally love Ashley Park, she was stunning in mean girls on Broadway and in the Ratatouille the musical special, but they did her so wrong with this character. The racism especially.
What's a beautiful voice and great choice of a song
0:43 don’t mind me just leaving this here
?
@@Existential_Bread7
The point where she starts singing, so you don‘t have to listen to the babbling before that.
as a French she sings very well even better than some singers in singing shows like the "new stars" or others clearly
J'adore ... Limite émouvant ... Une belle voix ....🤔 Bravo !!
This is like going to Brazil and singing "Garota de Ipanema" in the streets
What a great scene. Ashley Park is amazing. This is just beautiful.
Ashley Jini Park sang this better than 73 years ago. You would think that this song came from her heart. I love it.... the feelings, the emotions, everything 💕. “La Vie en rose” is a French song that was written in 1945 by French singer Édith Piaf (19 December 1915 - 11 October 1963) and released as a single in 1947.
I SCREAMED when i first saw her
I dont know her name but i know that she was Gretchen in Mean Girls and her voice is AMAZING.
Gosh i loved her singing this song.
Exactly she sanged so well I wish we get a whole song 🤭
She’s not Gretchen in mean girls tho
@@mahis5363 in Broadway
Like the WHAT IS WRONG WITH MEEEE??
Im pretty sure that was her
Her name is Ashley Park. She has done a bunch of Broadway musicals
she is Ashely Park
Acho que já ouvi umas 100 vezes e não enjoo. Perfeita!
Me and my lovely wife got goosebump on this scene. So great.
That was a great rendition
Great scene would it be without stupid surroundings and fake drama-kindofpeople apporachings😘
Lov he voice btw
It is my favorite version of this song. No instruments to get in the way of her voice
Heard this on Emily in Paris. This is such a beautiful song and the way she sang it gave me chills. I dont even know any French but I think that made it even more captivating for me 💕 just beautiful...
Madonna sang this life with a banjo... nothing beats that version. But love this show.
Second fav version of this song.. how i met your mother's version is still on the top of my list..
But have to admit.. there's some kinda magic in this song.. so soothing and beautiful!
I think Mindy deserves to be on top because she sung it without any instrument while the mother had a ukulele but that is just my opinion
@@ahmednasir1583 maybe.. but HIMYM is a mood in itself.. also i like himym version better because her voice is softer n calming.. which is my preference
True i like Tracy's version alot too it's very raw and natural
The show its self is trash but even tho this scene didnt make sense at all I liked it. She needed a full character ark and this didnt help but it's my favorite moment. But yeah the show is still garbage and a bad representation of asian culture French culture and LGBT people and Poc.
This is a magical moment! I can feel the love and even Paris! 💛
I LOVED THIS SCENE HER VOICE IS AMAZINGGGGG
I love the way emily looked at mindy. 😍
💕🎶Love this part😍
Quand il me prend dans ses bras
Qu'il me parle tout bas
Je vois la vie en rose
Il me dit des mots d'amour
Des mots de tous les jours
Et ça m'fait quelque chose
Il est entré dans mon cœur
Une part de bonheur
Dont je connais la cause
C'est lui pour moi, moi pour lui dans la vie
Il me l'a dit, l'a juré, pour la vie
Give your heart and soul to me
and life will always be
la vie en rose
Mindy was the best character written in Emily in Paris, It's even better than "Emily"
Ahmm why does this make me tear up?? Beautiful rendition
Love this! Loving the series!
I love how the old comments are full of praise for her sining talent, but the newer ones are just taking the piss for the sake of it. if you don't like it and its not your thing fine, whatever no one is forcing you to watch. also of corse Paris isn't like this in reality (similar but not entirely accurate) the show is painting a romanticised picture of Paris, so obviously there going to sing one of Frances most classical and famous songs. I swear people liked the show until hating became more fashionable.
Is a such beautiful song! II even got emotional🥰
The fact that I’ve loved Ashley since 2018 ? :O
Se vocês puderem ficar curtindo ao longo do tempo meu comentário para eu sempre lembrar desse momento ficarei agradecida😍, sempre me arrepioooo
As a French person who has been in in Paris on multiple occasions, I certify this scene unacurate
But clearly this is a documentary 😢
Awww Mindy!
Bruh, it’s the kids hugging her for me 😂
loveeee her voiceeee!!!
I loved so much!
Beautiful~! Chills and tears :)
I LOVED THIS PART. 😭😍
BEAUTIFULLY DONE!
just saw it on 3 Oct and OMG I love this scene
Even I fell in love with it her voice really suited the song 😭
“omg it’s so cring-“ 💥🔫😐 it was a nice moment in the show alright /hj
this show gave the word cringe the most validation ever
Imagine going to Portugal and randomly start singing "apita o comboio"
Can they pleeassseeee put this on ITunes!? PLEASE!!
SING IT, Mindy
Loved it!!
Guys! Ashley made a MV of this song. Go check it on her youtube channel
Imagine coming to Brazil and signing "the girl from Ipanema"
imagine going to India and singing the title track of slumdog millionnaire
I love her voice fr
Fav scene so far 😍
what in the american disrespect is this
WOWWWW I liked her voice😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
I love this scene♡♡♡
omG iTs gRETCHEN-
Honestly, I could judge and be mean, but the movie took my mind off of things. I think it's really sweet and inspiring in a way.
(this comes from a Greek woman who literally lives 20 mins away from the parthenon and has heard people stereotyping her culture in all the wrong ways. So,yeah I get the whole "it's not the real Paris" thing too)
There's no way this would have been taken seriously in Paris, people would have, at best passed by without a second glance or laughed zt her for being such an embarassing american cliché
This will be my favorite version
This is the equivalent of if somebody went to Korea with a whole choir and started singing all the themes from squid game in the middle of a Town square
I checked it twice and Ashley Park is an awesome singer
I want her spinoff. She has a bigger story to tell