Ningning is a great vocalist, with very precise and mastered vocals. She have a neutral tone voice and she's is not belting oriented like Winter for example, but her voice is imposing with its foundation, particularly in the low register, and immediately reveals that we are dealing with a main vocalist
Winter’s voice is not belting oriented. She’s straining her voice for the metallic effect. Her vocal damage is so serious that her “belting” is very hard to listen to. It actually hurts my ears. She also breaks her voice more and more often now. Her vocal regress is very alarming.
Ningning is so aware of SM's incompetency and their xenophobic tricks, that she has no trust in them whatsoever. She would rather sing too early than waiting for an audio guide that may never come. I really feel bad for this girl and all the foreign idols under SM.
Thats some obsessive unhinged take from a clip of ningning singing early 😂 can we stop with all the consipracy crap and actually focus on ningnings amazing vocals?
Literally every idol that's not Korean @@zeekiam7879 they get less lines, screentime and actually SM has a couple of idols that sued them for the mistreatment
aespa canta ao vivo o TEMPO TODO, inclusive nos shows e sempre é igual a versão de estúdio, é ridículo se surpreenderem com isso, sem duvida o melhor vocal atualmente, só bate de frente com Red Velvet e mamamoo, e ainda tem hater que jura que não 🤡
I love Ningning so much but for me at least this doesn’t prove that they were “all” singing live. I have no doubt they try to sing as many parts as possible but this was a tiny slip up. Still love Aespa and Ningning! SM needs to bring back their idols singing live on music shows again, I miss those days sooooo much 🥲
It is sad when an idol singing a short phrase and everyone goes crazy… and praises her for “great” singing as if she sung anything remote close to being vocally difficult… the level of musical expectation has really sunk so low…
Because she sound like the recording it self and in this song, the first lane start as the instrument start. So it's a bit tricky for idol cause when they have in ear problem they won't know the timing when the music start
When she realized she sang early she went like "HOLD ONNNN-"
Yea😂
She's one the best vocalists I've ever heard.
Don't know why sm doesn't want them to sing live
Seriously
if they keep singing live, it will damage their vocal
@@sstellaar bruh
@@Joonpathy what bruh?
Finally someone understand@@sstellaar
NingNing is the excellent singer that's bad at lip sync 😂
btw she looks xtra pretty on giant screen !
I prefer singers to be bad at lipsyncing than be good at it honestly😅
@@danissegomez7953 sure you do
It's called backtrack dear
@@Nitaeah-j1kmhm
Ning² is going to be a powerhouse. She already fit with BoA and Wendy for the song Time After Time.
ning squared
I love that you squared ningning’s name😭
@@bbybottlesv-ug1cg I giggled for a nearly inappropriate amount of time when I saw it first.
HELP😭
Big diva! BoA is the best soloist ever to me. Wendy such a vocal queen.
Best vocalist 💕
@FIGHTFAN777It's her/his opinion💀
Her opinion go and cry @FIGHTFAN777
Ningning is a great vocalist, with very precise and mastered vocals. She have a neutral tone voice and she's is not belting oriented like Winter for example, but her voice is imposing with its foundation, particularly in the low register, and immediately reveals that we are dealing with a main vocalist
Winter’s voice is not belting oriented. She’s straining her voice for the metallic effect. Her vocal damage is so serious that her “belting” is very hard to listen to. It actually hurts my ears. She also breaks her voice more and more often now. Her vocal regress is very alarming.
of all members, she will be the most sensitive when it comes to criticisms about their vocals.. cuz she is the main vocal❤
both ning and win are main vocalists now on sm's official page :P
Goosebumps. Ning is one of the best singers of 4th Gen. She sounds like a siren, so enchanting.
I’m obsessed with her voice I haven’t heard anything like. I’m hypnotized ❤
Ningning is so aware of SM's incompetency and their xenophobic tricks, that she has no trust in them whatsoever. She would rather sing too early than waiting for an audio guide that may never come. I really feel bad for this girl and all the foreign idols under SM.
SM is xenophobic towards whom? that's new to me
Thats some obsessive unhinged take from a clip of ningning singing early 😂 can we stop with all the consipracy crap and actually focus on ningnings amazing vocals?
Me too
@@zeekiam7879 take a look at how they treated their past chinese artists + ningning too
Literally every idol that's not Korean @@zeekiam7879 they get less lines, screentime and actually SM has a couple of idols that sued them for the mistreatment
Ning Ning 🦋amazing main vocal
Proving aespa sing live at concerts!
Her voice is amazing
0:19 wow, Ningning is so stunningly pretty!
Love her so much no joke❤❤❤
ningning is the best
Talented kind and gorgeous ❤❤❤
man she’s pretty
She’s one of the best vocalist in kpop idk what ppl say
NingNing's voice do not need auto tone
No matter she nailed it ❤❤
Proud of my girl😍❤️🔥
Don't doubt the NingNing!
SM the best visual and vocal
This proof that they singing live... not just some stupid lip syncing...
Adorable
I remeber when people were hating on aesoa for not singing live during their rookie era and here they are 😂❤
Nining ❤
aespa canta ao vivo o TEMPO TODO, inclusive nos shows e sempre é igual a versão de estúdio, é ridículo se surpreenderem com isso, sem duvida o melhor vocal atualmente, só bate de frente com Red Velvet e mamamoo, e ainda tem hater que jura que não 🤡
why do u put a fake eyebrow on her face for the preview photo 😅
JULY 14TH MY BDAY... WOOOO
💕💕💕
Girl slammed whole hybe ggs with this 💀✨
IT DOES LIKE STUDIO VER😭
Anyone who know where the full video can be watched?
💕💕💕💕💕💕💕
Can anyone please send me the link to the full performance because i cannot find it. Thank you
Not related but. She looks like lee sung kyung here..
I love Ningning so much but for me at least this doesn’t prove that they were “all” singing live. I have no doubt they try to sing as many parts as possible but this was a tiny slip up. Still love Aespa and Ningning! SM needs to bring back their idols singing live on music shows again, I miss those days sooooo much 🥲
11th commandment: Don't mess with SM idols/artists when it comes to singing
SM water
2 weeks later HYBE groups will do the same what Ningning does. Although, it would be a member with fake live vocals.
Ningning is so bad at lip syncing ❤😂
It is sad when an idol singing a short phrase and everyone goes crazy… and praises her for “great” singing as if she sung anything remote close to being vocally difficult… the level of musical expectation has really sunk so low…
Ok
hold on tight 🤢🤢
?
im surprise she is praised for this, it is an amateur mistake
Because she sound like the recording it self and in this song, the first lane start as the instrument start. So it's a bit tricky for idol cause when they have in ear problem they won't know the timing when the music start
Do u know how in ear work on artist? What it sounds like when they use it?
@@jmjcross6883 it sounds like you are coping. She mess up like an amateur
@@TheLastS209 sakarepweh Da susah ngmng ama org beginima da dijelasin ge bebel
@@TheLastS209so doesn't seniors who messed up lol
so glad i was able to witness this 🥹🥹🥹❤️