Oh you didnt know there were people who lived to tell the tale? You need to sit down and maybe read the countless books about it and if thats too hard you can watch one of the many documentaries where survivors are interviewed. You could get yourself a clue...seeing as you have none.
Not one body found. Their own experts found only “anomalies” The government provided funds for the excavation which were curiously refused… Fact is that 100 Churches have been destroyed, were is the law anti Christianophobia???
Making up lies about an identifiable group, for the purpose of getting them killed, is not protected speech. It is Genocide (Stages 1. Classification, 2. Symbolisation, 4. Dehumanisation, 6. Polarisation, 10. Denial).
If denying some aspect is against the law then embellishing and exaggerating it should be as well. Including claiming there are mass graves. Even claiming graves without digging them up.
No one denys the residential schools existed, but they do deny the vast exaggeration of them as all bad as depicted by Indigenous activists and other ignoramuses.
Compulsary attendance stopped in 1942. Residential schools were operational until 1997, not mandatory. Rather that trying to impose draconian laws have the RCMP investigate. Open honest transparency is the only way forward. Until then it is viewed as a money grab.
@@JEdwarrd taken by the RCMP in all likelihood would be under the request of social services into the foster system. That continues to this day. That's a fact.
@@oledudiest If you were educated on the topic, you would know that the foster system is just a continuation of the residential school. Curious what makes predatory clergy moral or enlightened?
Not until all the sites have been explored and cause of death confirmed if any remains are found. These people wouldn't even be around if it wasn't for education. I find it truly incredible that 70+ old natives have such a great memory to recall all that so called abuse.
Yaaaa we should ask white women who lived during the great depression on how many kids did they sold away. its the equivalent of Asking rape victims Pics or it did not happen.
I find it incredible that Catholics lied, hid & destroyed evidence for years, while abusing children globally and you think you have any basis to lecture. LOL
@@JEdwarrd that’s projection. I was told that there were masses graves. So, please show the evidence. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. I want to know for certain.
Regardless of where you stand on the issue, you should be very afraid of a government attempting to criminalize one side of a debate. Just because the government is on your side today, there's inevitably going to be a government that opposes you in the future. And when that day comes, do you want to live in a country that criminalizes certain opinions?
I understand where she's coming from. And I do think it's not cool to argue against any proven tragedy in history. However, being able to make laws against what people can and cannot say will always be a violation of rights and will set a bad precedent. Where will it end? These days, you can say just about ANYTHING is "hate speech" or "damaging". And besides, if you're so upset about historical tragedies, don't you wanna know who is out there denying them? Or is it truly better to use legislation to silence people for your own comfort and pride?
Blaire White taught me where I draw the line: making up lies about an identifiable group. The wider your audience; the greater your obligation to fact-check things you've heard, or surmised.
This is very divisive leadership. If i were in her riding, i would be ashamed and request instead of focusing on criminalizing words and conversation, how about she focus on legislation that keeps ACTUAL CRIMINALS IN JAIL and prevent crime?
I lived between 2 reserves, spoke with many elders who were grateful for the opportunity of attending residential schools, saying they enjoyed it. I'm sure there were some bad ones, however, the Natives don't hold the monopoly on suffering. Residential schools have existed for centuries, throughout Europe, and long before the first Native stepped foot in one. My White, English step father had to attend one, where he was physically and sexually abused back in the day. I am sick and tired of the race card and victimhood being played. A little while ago I seen a poster calling for "Day scholars" to make their claim for monetary compensation. Day scholars, who attended "residential school" from 9 am to 3 pm, then went home to Mom and Dad.....Seriously? The nonsense proposed by this "MP" is creating animousity. Here's a question, is the title of "Indigenous" reserved only for people with brown skin? Since the Scottish people inhabited Scotland, crossing over from Europe at the same time as the Aboriginals did from Eurasia, wouldn't that make the Scots "Indigenous" too? If so, then they suffered conquest by the English for far longer than the aboriginals of Canada have. Many centuries in fact. So, where's the "Truth and reconciliation" for my ancestors, my cultural heritage? Do the aboriginal people of Canada care about the Scottish people and what they went through? Probably not.....so why should I care about their ancient past? Same/same, no?
You would be indigenous to Scotland…Harper would’ve called you an old stock Canadian. You should be free to state your point, though. We indigenous do share this tragedy with other cultures, too.
@@shhh3185 But we're not "Indigenous" . That's the point. To be indigenous something needs to originate in that place. The Aboriginal people of North America did not originate in North America, they migrated from Eurasia. The people of Scotland aren't Indigenous to Scotland because they Migrated from Europe at the same time. I know the definition has changed to suit the narrative, but in reality it's a lie. Here's a thought, the Aboringinal people of North America and those of Siberia all share a common ancestry....So instead of the Self segregation of reserves and archaic treaties, why don't we all accept that we're all migrants of some point of time, come together as one national family? Times are getting tough in this world, people are coming to OUR country, burn OUR flag, and threatening OUR people with death, so we if a time to come together ever existed, it's now my friend.
I'm not a negative person in the way this is going . I'd just like to know where is the forensic evidence. It was a tragedy ,even with the whites and even Asians that attended residential schools
From Wikipedia (so don't blame me for sensing the pattern)......."Leah Gazan was born in Thompson, Manitoba[2] to Abraham (Albert) Gazan[5] and Marjorie Anne Lecaine.[6] According to Gazan, both her parents are "survivors": her maternal grandmother, Adeline LeCaine, is Lakota, and her maternal grandfather is Chinese,[7] while her paternal grandparents are Jewish.[8] Gazan's father, born at The Hague, South Holland in 1938, was two and a half years old when the Germans invaded Holland, and spent the remainder of the war in hiding, sheltered by Dutch families.[9] Gazan's paternal grandmother, Gina Gazan, spent time in a concentration camp."
The truth does not fear investigation nor does it require the force of law to uphold it. Lies do. And that’s exactly what this residential school hoax is
@@logicalpolice Why do Christian's abuse children? Google also says Christianity is a religion when there is overwhelming historical evidence it is a cult which your ancestors were a part of.
There was residential schools for all children in Canada and the common wealth period. All races children were harmed in those days and still do today.❤
Freedom of speech is every Canadians right, regardless of whether or not radical fanatics agree with what you are saying or not. You have a problem with what happened then chase down,punish, and "reconcile" with the Catholic Church, not people that have a different view than you do, stop blaming citizens of Canada for what happened in the past.
Indigenous lives are the evidence. A life expectancy 10 years less than yours on average in the same country. Controlling thought and removing free speech isn't the solution though.
@@geester2123 Indigenous people are becoming successful despite discrimination, resource theft, poisoned water, kidnapping, abuse...but not everyone is able to manage multigenerational trauma the same way. Why not fight for accountability or justice?
@@nuxkaminanot my fault their mom drinks while pregnant. And if you want to live your traditional way, stop begging for handouts and go clarify water the way your ancestors used to do
It’s so fruitless to just point out 350 year old mistakes by invaded indigenous groups, rather than acknowledge the truth of what is said. Yes likely other mistakes happened but they do not erase those in residential schools.
In the words of David Lee Roth in "Just a Gigolo" - I ain't got no body. The scam is up. Besides....on the death of Jesus and his leaving the apostles, Jesus says: John 16:22 “So with you: Now is your time of grief, but I will see you again and you will rejoice, and no one will take away your joy.”
Jordan Peterson flies to Russia to show how Patriotic he is while lying about the criminal code of Canada... You should really pick another talking point.
I could give you an estimate. But if the NDP finds this comment in a couple of years and decides that that estimate is too low, this comment might land me in prison.
I see the intent but no, this bill will never pass. Not in its current form. And I’m an intergenerational survivor. We can’t force folks out of racism, hatred, and ignorance. We just have to keep affirming the truth and heal without them, and survivors are free to seek their reparations. We already have a new holiday, one that upsets me every year for over a week… so much is being done now and healing is going to take more time.
More than half the comments under this video are participating in stage 10 of genocide: "The perpetrators of the genocide deny having committed their crimes. Victims are often blamed. Evidence is hidden and witnesses are intimidated."
We need Indigenous representatives in parliament no what party gets in, heck be nice if fhere was an Indigenous leader to take over, someone who's not curupt like the feds, province, municipality, and Chief and council. Just a dream....crown lands are noe provinces and all tjey want is to reap the resources, well seems like...
George Orwell's 1984 occurring in real time.
Still waiting for this supposidy irrefutable evidence...
Oh you didnt know there were people who lived to tell the tale? You need to sit down and maybe read the countless books about it and if thats too hard you can watch one of the many documentaries where survivors are interviewed. You could get yourself a clue...seeing as you have none.
@@garettdoornwaard4822 Hahah I met lots of survivors, but brainwashed going to be brainwashed.
I'm still waiting for fascists to be honest about their behaviour.
Will you be honest?
@@JEdwarrd I see the mind virus has spread incredibly quick in this line.
@@Bardic_Entropy-pu3rv Why did the Führer abuse his niece?
Why does Trump brag about abusing his daughter?
Not one body found.
Their own experts found only “anomalies”
The government provided funds for the excavation which were curiously refused…
Fact is that 100 Churches have been destroyed, were is the law anti Christianophobia???
Papal Bull is why they call BS, bull lies sounds like what you are talking about!
@@carolharquail9131 grow up. Accept reality.
@@Alfonso-gp9mk sorry thousands of bodies were found check your facts
@@Alfonso-gp9mk Define what the Doctrine of Discovery is please..... You want to run your mouth, so back it up.
FREEDOM OF SPEECH IS A RIGHT YOU CAN'T BE CHARGED FOR YOUR THOUGHTS
Making up lies about an identifiable group, for the purpose of getting them killed, is not protected speech.
It is Genocide (Stages 1. Classification, 2. Symbolisation, 4. Dehumanisation, 6. Polarisation, 10. Denial).
There is freedom of speech, you just can't say anything
@controlfoodcontrolthepeopl5627 lol so true
Awe "Billie Sherman" real unique for a sock puppet account.
@JEdwarrd lol spoken and said like a true uneducated woke Liberal you people are pathetic at best
If denying some aspect is against the law then embellishing and exaggerating it should be as well. Including claiming there are mass graves. Even claiming graves without digging them up.
No one denys the residential schools existed, but they do deny the vast exaggeration of them as all bad as depicted by Indigenous activists and other ignoramuses.
Where are the bodies.
I'm indigenous. Live in Sask. Where are the damn bodies bro.
Ironic, you all said the same thing about the Pickton farm.
The world found out what liars you all are.
@@thefringeminorityreport4797 You tear down your own people.... are you that desperate to be a "pick me", that you have no self respect?
@@JEdwarrdevidence.
@@Ironknuckle100 You all said the same thing about the Pickton farm.
The world found out what liars you all are.
Compulsary attendance stopped in 1942. Residential schools were operational until 1997, not mandatory. Rather that trying to impose draconian laws have the RCMP investigate. Open honest transparency is the only way forward. Until then it is viewed as a money grab.
Perhaps you should engage with actual facts about how children were taken by the RCMP. Not given up, as you want to suggest.
@@JEdwarrd taken by the RCMP in all likelihood would be under the request of social services into the foster system. That continues to this day. That's a fact.
@@oledudiest If you were educated on the topic, you would know that the foster system is just a continuation of the residential school. Curious what makes predatory clergy moral or enlightened?
@@oledudiest don't feed the troll
Proof.
Not until all the sites have been explored and cause of death confirmed if any remains are found. These people wouldn't even be around if it wasn't for education. I find it truly incredible that 70+ old natives have such a great memory to recall all that so called abuse.
Yaaaa we should ask white women who lived during the great depression on how many kids did they sold away.
its the equivalent of Asking rape victims Pics or it did not happen.
I find it incredible that Catholics lied, hid & destroyed evidence for years, while abusing children globally and you think you have any basis to lecture. LOL
@@Okimâwsorry I only believe evidence.
@@Ironknuckle100 Evidence that you were abused as a child? It's obvious just reading your comments.
@@JEdwarrd that’s projection. I was told that there were masses graves. So, please show the evidence. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. I want to know for certain.
Regardless of where you stand on the issue, you should be very afraid of a government attempting to criminalize one side of a debate.
Just because the government is on your side today, there's inevitably going to be a government that opposes you in the future. And when that day comes, do you want to live in a country that criminalizes certain opinions?
Wise words. Governments change, but legal precedent and jurisprudence endure.
When questioning becomes illegal, so becomes telling the truth.
The pendulum always swings the other way… simple to see for some, yet hard for others to see.
Democrat women were cheering COVID mandates in 2020. Only to cry foul when RoeVWade was overturned not long after.. 🤣🤷♂️
I understand where she's coming from. And I do think it's not cool to argue against any proven tragedy in history. However, being able to make laws against what people can and cannot say will always be a violation of rights and will set a bad precedent. Where will it end? These days, you can say just about ANYTHING is "hate speech" or "damaging".
And besides, if you're so upset about historical tragedies, don't you wanna know who is out there denying them? Or is it truly better to use legislation to silence people for your own comfort and pride?
Blaire White taught me where I draw the line: making up lies about an identifiable group.
The wider your audience; the greater your obligation to fact-check things you've heard, or surmised.
It's not comfort or pride. It's about powerful people dividing us into the groups we are born into..
what a load of crap
Stop insulting yourself, I'm sure you have one reddening quality.
Are you another Putin bot, paid to stir up hate in our comment sections?
YES, yes you are.
@@JEdwarrdGot your 5$ from trudeau for this comment?
@@JEdwarrd what is a reddening quality???. it sounds racist to me
How about no?
Freedom of speech
Good grief. We should add claims without irrefutable evidence to the criminal code
Jordan Peterson made millions off lying about the criminal code.
put down the fire water chug-a-lug
This woman should not be in politics.
This is very divisive leadership. If i were in her riding, i would be ashamed and request instead of focusing on criminalizing words and conversation, how about she focus on legislation that keeps ACTUAL CRIMINALS IN JAIL and prevent crime?
I lived between 2 reserves, spoke with many elders who were grateful for the opportunity of attending residential schools, saying they enjoyed it. I'm sure there were some bad ones, however, the Natives don't hold the monopoly on suffering. Residential schools have existed for centuries, throughout Europe, and long before the first Native stepped foot in one. My White, English step father had to attend one, where he was physically and sexually abused back in the day.
I am sick and tired of the race card and victimhood being played. A little while ago I seen a poster calling for "Day scholars" to make their claim for monetary compensation. Day scholars, who attended "residential school" from 9 am to 3 pm, then went home to Mom and Dad.....Seriously?
The nonsense proposed by this "MP" is creating animousity.
Here's a question, is the title of "Indigenous" reserved only for people with brown skin? Since the Scottish people inhabited Scotland, crossing over from Europe at the same time as the Aboriginals did from Eurasia, wouldn't that make the Scots "Indigenous" too?
If so, then they suffered conquest by the English for far longer than the aboriginals of Canada have. Many centuries in fact. So, where's the "Truth and reconciliation" for my ancestors, my cultural heritage?
Do the aboriginal people of Canada care about the Scottish people and what they went through? Probably not.....so why should I care about their ancient past? Same/same, no?
@lancegraham4865 nice, was thinking that what you stated about your step father was probably happening too. That this is not race isolated.
You would be indigenous to Scotland…Harper would’ve called you an old stock Canadian. You should be free to state your point, though. We indigenous do share this tragedy with other cultures, too.
@@shhh3185 But we're not "Indigenous" . That's the point. To be indigenous something needs to originate in that place. The Aboriginal people of North America did not originate in North America, they migrated from Eurasia. The people of Scotland aren't Indigenous to Scotland because they Migrated from Europe at the same time. I know the definition has changed to suit the narrative, but in reality it's a lie. Here's a thought, the Aboringinal people of North America and those of Siberia all share a common ancestry....So instead of the Self segregation of reserves and archaic treaties, why don't we all accept that we're all migrants of some point of time, come together as one national family? Times are getting tough in this world, people are coming to OUR country, burn OUR flag, and threatening OUR people with death, so we if a time to come together ever existed, it's now my friend.
This is why the NDP is spinning its wheels.
I'm not a negative person in the way this is going . I'd just like to know where is the forensic evidence. It was a tragedy ,even with the whites and even Asians that attended residential schools
Why are you spamming the comments? You are not an honest person.
@@JEdwarrd you are, bot
@@JEdwarrd Is the hypocrisy beyond your feeble mind?
@JEdwarrd you responded to almost every comment here. Why so motivated?
@@MitchKelly-m3y Great deflection, in yet none of you "real" people can engage with history & engage intellectually. Funny that.
Policing personal beliefs.
Way to go NDP.
You can have personal beliefs.
But your obligation to fact-check goes up proportionately with your audience.
From Wikipedia (so don't blame me for sensing the pattern)......."Leah Gazan was born in Thompson, Manitoba[2] to Abraham (Albert) Gazan[5] and Marjorie Anne Lecaine.[6] According to Gazan, both her parents are "survivors": her maternal grandmother, Adeline LeCaine, is Lakota, and her maternal grandfather is Chinese,[7] while her paternal grandparents are Jewish.[8] Gazan's father, born at The Hague, South Holland in 1938, was two and a half years old when the Germans invaded Holland, and spent the remainder of the war in hiding, sheltered by Dutch families.[9] Gazan's paternal grandmother, Gina Gazan, spent time in a concentration camp."
she's a 7th generation holocaust survivor.
Oy vey goy stop noticing!
A crime? GFYS
Exactly what the Vatican says to abuse victims.
@@toaster3822 go to jail bwahaha
@@CheyTraverse92 Canada would never condone such insanity.
this is not hatred when you tell the truth
where are the bodies
when were they exhumed
all it takes is a simple google search to learn about pretty much anything! its 2024, no excuse for ignorance!
@@CheyTraverse92 google says there were none found in Kamloops.
The truth does not fear investigation nor does it require the force of law to uphold it. Lies do. And that’s exactly what this residential school hoax is
@@logicalpolice Why do Christian's abuse children?
Google also says Christianity is a religion when there is overwhelming historical evidence it is a cult which your ancestors were a part of.
@@logicalpolice What does google tell you about Epstein?
The queen disappeared with 10 of them on a picnic once… never came back to school after that.
Zero evidence of this.
Not just bodies need to be found, child mortality was lower for all groups than today.
There was residential schools for all children in Canada and the common wealth period.
All races children were harmed in those days and still do today.❤
Freedom of speech is every Canadians right, regardless of whether or not radical fanatics agree with what you are saying or not.
You have a problem with what happened then chase down,punish, and "reconcile" with the Catholic Church, not people that have a different view than you do, stop blaming citizens of Canada for what happened in the past.
Where is the evidence.
I havent seen any bodies yet.
Indigenous lives are the evidence. A life expectancy 10 years less than yours on average in the same country. Controlling thought and removing free speech isn't the solution though.
@@nuxkaminamaybe an unhealthy lifestyle has something to do with that. Always the victim.
@@geester2123 Convert you drinking water to industry waste water.
Lets hear your excuses...
@@geester2123 Indigenous people are becoming successful despite discrimination, resource theft, poisoned water, kidnapping, abuse...but not everyone is able to manage multigenerational trauma the same way. Why not fight for accountability or justice?
@@nuxkaminanot my fault their mom drinks while pregnant. And if you want to live your traditional way, stop begging for handouts and go clarify water the way your ancestors used to do
More woke NDP big brother bs.
THERE WERE NO BODIES. PP BETTER VOTE AGAINST THIS
It’s so fruitless to just point out 350 year old mistakes by invaded indigenous groups, rather than acknowledge the truth of what is said. Yes likely other mistakes happened but they do not erase those in residential schools.
Terrifying and revolting
Where are the bodies
Zero bodies. Facts.
In the words of David Lee Roth in "Just a Gigolo" - I ain't got no body. The scam is up.
Besides....on the death of Jesus and his leaving the apostles, Jesus says:
John 16:22 “So with you: Now is your time of grief, but I will see you again and you will rejoice, and no one will take away your joy.”
Mmmm....no. no i dont think so. Residential schools were real bad. Compelled speech is also real bad.
Jordan Peterson flies to Russia to show how Patriotic he is while lying about the criminal code of Canada...
You should really pick another talking point.
Agreed, restricting speech isn't the solution. People need to talk about it to learn.
@@JEdwarrd You reek of desperation.
@@JEdwarrdfascist
@@fbsfgr Ironic you use that word considering our countries history... as you refuse to engage with history.
Taking your tongue away.
I don't believe the Earth is round and I don't believe Santa exists. Uh-oh! I may be charged. The list can go on and on.
1950 what happened
cabbalistic codes gematria codes lets go
Canada has indians?
NdP decides to finally do something for the Indigenous people. They could have forced Liberals to do so much more over the years.
How does this help indigenous people find jobs or get an education or drink clean water? Are those things less important than ending free speech.
@fbsfgr i agree clean water safe living conditions paramount
Literally SCANDALOUS the Indigenous communities don’t have access to drinkable water!!!!
@@nonasmith2405 but you're praising the NDP for ignoring those issues and putting this divisive control first. Hypocrite..
@fbsfgr it's sarcasm I personally find your response inane
She isn’t even fully “indigenous” herself either..
ALSO THE RACISM AND DISCRIMINATION...ADD THAT TO THE CRIMINAL CODE!!!
Nope
@@emdrw4650 racism is against the charter unless you're discriminating against white people. Look it up
How many died?
I could give you an estimate. But if the NDP finds this comment in a couple of years and decides that that estimate is too low, this comment might land me in prison.
@@cherkovision The sarcasm alone will get you arrested, no doubt!
😂😂😂
I see the intent but no, this bill will never pass. Not in its current form. And I’m an intergenerational survivor. We can’t force folks out of racism, hatred, and ignorance. We just have to keep affirming the truth and heal without them, and survivors are free to seek their reparations. We already have a new holiday, one that upsets me every year for over a week… so much is being done now and healing is going to take more time.
It will pass because our democracy puts parties first and people second.
😂😂😂😂
I think its a great idea, too much weird denialism and extremism going on in Canada.
No, too much of lies and woke propaganda.
Not one single body has been found. Not one.
More than half the comments under this video are participating in stage 10 of genocide:
"The perpetrators of the genocide deny having
committed their crimes. Victims are often
blamed. Evidence is hidden and witnesses
are intimidated."
Okboomer
About time
Are you programmed to say that?
A needed Bill to present.
A bill that doesn't represent. I ask again where are the bodies. Quick Google yahoo godaddy search shows no bodies especially in Kelowna
I salute the NDP for this step from the bottom of my heart. Crimes in silence should never taken place. It is injuries to the sense of justice.
Not one body, not one evidence of the alleged genocide.
@@Alfonso-gp9mk it is not a good habit to deny crimes indeed.
@@BahaaIz what crimes?
@@Alfonso-gp9mk residential school crimes against first nations
this is necessary
So is evidence.
Professional victimhood
Freedom of speech is necessary.
We need Indigenous representatives in parliament no what party gets in, heck be nice if fhere was an Indigenous leader to take over, someone who's not curupt like the feds, province, municipality, and Chief and council. Just a dream....crown lands are noe provinces and all tjey want is to reap the resources, well seems like...
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
If that happened they would actualy investigate and find no bodies.
@@Beeni-wello777 but your democracy is broken.
Whacko!
What a joke, they got caught lying and making up stories. Now they wanna make calling out their lies against the law. What an honorable people.
@@feyfrost8783 you think indigenous people want this? Politicians do it for themselves only.