Which is The Strongest Material? Carbon Fiber Vs. Aluminum Vs. Steel | Hydraulic Press Test!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 พ.ค. 2019
- Go to NordVPN.com/hydraulicpress to get 75% off a 3-year plan and use code HYDRAULICPRESS to get one extra month free.
Which is the strongest material? Carbon fiber, aluminium, steel or stainless steel? We will use our 150 ton force sensor and 150 ton hydraulic press to find out! Cable box vs. our press
Our second channel / @beyondthepress
Our fan shop www.printmotor.com/hydraulicp...
/ officialhpc / hydraulicpresschannel
Do not try this at home!! or at any where else!!
Music Thor's Hammer-Ethan Meixell - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
Big thanks to NordVPN for sponsoring today's video! Go to NordVPN.com/hydraulicpress to get 75% off a 3-year plan and use code HYDRAULICPRESS to get one extra month free.
That computer demonstration was low-key the best sponsor message I've seen on TH-cam for NordVPN.
Why do you forgot Titanium?
Just wanted to say that my kids and I really enjoy your videos! We especially like the end sequence when crushing the play doh characters. Keep on crushing it.
That was a great VPN advert and is exactly how it works, I can't use VPN as I have a bad back and I can't carry the 8 ft steel ring around with me 😜
@@TheExBx Thanks for the support! I think we should do new compilation of all the playdoh animals :D
Use a thermal camera when crushing so we can see how materials heat up when deforming.
I think they did once
Yeah, they did, on the steel crushing too like this.
Yeah, and if he can make a strength-deformation curve so we can calculate the energy.
@@johntheux9238 anything he touches that starts off with curves is usually flat by the end of the video.
Sorry, I'll show myself out. 😀
yes
Strukk-urtal? Struck-Ural? Struck-tuh-rahl!
I Amp Soo Pry Sedd.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
This is how to say it: Struck'churl
So funny but so down to earth...love the channel !!
@@moojuice369 I bet others would have had edited it out, but it was pretty good take... so.
0:53 carbon fiber
2:12 aluminium
3:21 steel
4:27 structural steel
6:15 nordVPN
edit : thanks for the likes
Hero of our time
😂👍🏻
8:49 Monster
Thank you mate
wow thanks, this fucking channe3l makes 15s worth of content 10min, i dont know why
*_The strongest material is Hydraulic Press Machine itself_*
Dian Kurniawan iya bener pak hahaha
Haha bener,
Facts
Dian Kurniawan Nord VPN is strongest.
@Blood Orange Sun end of the world
I don't think carbon fiber is supposed to have that high compression strength. It's the tensile strength it's good at.
high modulus carbon fiber is specifically developed
for compression strength because there is almost no buckling.
The more you know. Thank you!
@@johntheux9238 the industries which use composite are mainly aeronautics and areospace. HTS fibres are designed to sustain high tensile loads, not compression. For instance, the blades of ultrafan engines, which i happen to work on. "Almost no buckling" - You cant say that, and you know it. 1- It all depends of "lenght / surface" ratio of your structure. 2- In composite structures, you always end up with defects, plies waving, wrinkling, air voids and resin pockets ... as result of the curing process of the lamina. These defaults will ultimately lead to buckling around them or delamiation / failure if your structure is short and bulky.
@@BeenuZz Yeah but there is no comparison with steel, not only the modulus is higher but it's also lighter so you can make it thicker.
@@johntheux9238 yep for tension. But in compression, steel is superior because it is ductile.
1:01 Carbon fiber 13.880 T
2:39 Aluminum 28.900 T
3:27 Steel 38.980 T
4:35 Structural Steel 63.880 T
@Joseph Coon
Thx🙏
Thank you !!
You have to factor in the weight of each though, for it to make sense.
@@MichaelMadno you don't. Steel is stronger. Always will be.
If only oceangate knew
NordVPN must have payed 1M for that awesome ad.
Carbon fiber vs aluminum vs steel
Winner: *NordVPN*
Carbon fiber is strong in tension, not in compression. You tested the compression strength of the binding agent rather than the tensile strength of the carbon fibers.
This also gives me an idea for a future video: Build a jig to test the tensile (pull) strength of bare carbon fiber strands with your press.
Yes, carbon fiber vs human hair vs Anni's leggings
Even in tension it's only strong in the fiber direction and only if it's not braided.
I thought the same exact thing.
He can name the new channel "Beyond The Stretch" channel.
high modulus carbon fiber is specifically developed
for compression strength because there is almost no buckling.
@swiss exactly
Turns carbon fibre into exploded cigar from Looney Tunes cartoon 😀
Genius observation stacked with hilarity.
3:00 The story of every happy marriage "So, my wife was right."
Forget everything I just love your accent 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Hahaha
Hahaha
Hahaha
That was one of the better sponsor shout-outs I've seen in a long time!
Yep, not at all a High-Pressure sales pitch. 😁
NoordVPN
These are the kind of tests I like.
Last piece was a flex pipe, designed to move easily. They are used in car exhausts to allow movement and prevent cracking.
You tell so nicely about your sponsors! Usually I skip part of video where youtuber tells about sponsor of the video but I always watch your amazing demonstrations! This is how ads should look like 😂
Need more fiber in your diet?, hydraulic press channel has you covered!
the way that piece of steel bent and even burned was so interesting !
Yeah, how much energy?
It looks delicious
I have spoken English my whole life, yet you say structural better than I do lol
Interesting test of compressive strength. I like how you chose similar cross-section tubes for the test. However, you need to specify which alloys of structural steel, stainless steel, aluminum and carbon fiber that you used. Strength varies greatly among the different alloys within each material type. Also, the carbon fiber composites aren't expected to be very strong in compression.
Since paper explodes when crushed have you tried crushing sandpaper? Different grits? Wonder if there might be different explosions for different grits.
Almost as strong as Anni’s Dead Lift Record!
3:02
the wife is always right even if she was wrong.
Guess 7 ton isn't much of a difference
Lessons every husband leaerned.
I miss the way you used to start each test - "And here we go!"
Always great videos. Thanks for your efforts.
You need a new channel to test tensile strength. Call it "Beyond the Stretch" channel.
Why NOT CALL IT SRETXH YOR ASSBOLE
The goatse channel.
@@tsaszymborska7389 I go back to dark web. Its easier to explain for FBI.
Should be, "BEYOND THE PRESS"
For extra content, you could do a review of Anni's models, eg "models of 2018".
(And "structural" is difficult for English people to say, too.)
The last one was interesting. The first 4 took a massive amount of pressure to start crushing, but once it started, the pressure required got smaller and smaller as it continued to be crushed, but the last one took a very small amount of force to start crushing, but as it continued to crush it actually required a whole lot MORE pressure to keep crushing. Interesting to say the least.
Would love to see how reinforced concrete and other "standard" building materials stack up in this test.
That was honestly the best NORDVPN demonstration :D
I really get a positive vibe from hearing Lauri speak in his uplifting way of speaking! Anni is cute too. I remember she once repeated the word "paper" with a really long "pay" :-))
You successfully made your sponsor ad entertaining enough not to skip over. Well done!
Hello from 2023. Please don't build submersibles with carbon fiber to go see the titanic.
Very nice, but I would like to have seen titanium.
Wtf Bro haha its too expensive 😐😐😂
That nordvpn ad was amazingly creative lol good job!
The problem with carbon fibre (or any other laminated composites) is that we have to design and make them for specific purposes.
It's the geometry of the unit that provides the strength (usually tensile), otherwise it's just a block of resin with fibres in it.
" Yeah so back to crushing stuff " 😂🤣
Compared to what and by what is always the question.
Strength per kg - CF followed by Aluminium.
Strength per area - Steel followed by Aluminium.
Strength per unit price - Steel then Aluminium.
Stiffness - Steel followed by CF.
The Nord VPN part was the best. You should make super bowl commercials for next super bowl!
This was the coolest sponsor video I've seen yet... I usually skip this part.. but not on this channel 👍
For extra content You should use the force sensor and make the ranking of the hardest extremely dangerous creatures to deal with :)
I'm with you from the beginning. Keep up the good work !!! Greetings from Poland !!
Me at 4am: which material is best
your nord vpn explanation was great :D
Great job keeping the sponsor interesting with the press example 👍
Maybe with the steel, one of the sides was slightly bent which would cause it to fail far faster when putting downward force like that on it
that was the best VPN ad I've seen
I would like to see two magnets
Very very super strong.
And repeal against both magnets not attract the two magnets like to see how much pressure can it take to touch two of those magnets make sure you weld them so they won't move
That probably won't work because magnets can lose their magnetic property when superheated (arc welder for example).
No need to weld it. Put the one below in heavy piece of iron and another one is automatically attached to the metal in the hydraulic press so if they are really strong magnets they should not move. But then again magnets also lose their magnetic property on high pressure so it might require as much force as you expect.
You know why I said, we'll ?. If it's a real strong magnet. It will find its way to go back because the magnetic force always find a way to go back north or South
@@richardadamson3643 if its being heated super hot for a long time (which will be the case if you're keeping two magnets welded), the magnetic property is permanently lost.
It sounds like they should do it any good talking politics of a damn magnet LOL
Now THIS is how you do an in-video ad-spot.
4:07 LMAO HAHAHAHAHAHAHA YOU MADE MY DAY xD
Small toes
Structural
"How's that new diet going?"
Me: 3:50
Your wife is right.
And if you're smart enough, you know that your wife is right even when she is wrong.
It would be nice to do these tests with the material in the horizontal plane to see the bending strength. Also, with flat plate and C section tubes similar in shape to that of spars in an airplane wing.
Hello, i have noticed the vapour/smoke of heat during the press. Basically the heat accelerated the process ( atoms jiggling ) So im wondering whether cooling down the materials would give a better result. And thanks for the great videos.
I only came here for todays extra content
Could the stainless steel have folded more perfect👌🏼 Good stuff guys👍🏽
Remember compression is not the only type stress. There's also tensile stress and shear stress. You can also consider other things such as temperature, corrosion, abrasion, etc...
Ah. That's how VPN works. I'am going to build a metal ring around my PC myself!
7:27 Riley Reid 😂😂😂
I guessed;
7.5 tonne for carbon fibre
12 tonne for aluminium
30 tonne for stainless steel
40 tonne for steel (this one was before hearing your guess) :)
12, 15, 17, 22 tonnes for the last thing (indecisive after the last embarrassment)
...................................WOW!
(These were typed as each came around to being crushed, hence the 'live' reactions).
What were the cross sectional areas and shapes of each of the materials? The thickness of the walls and dimensions of the shape do make a difference for how they perform.
As you noticed all she shapes failed due to local buckling rather than a straight compression failure.
I built a 6 story hotel and they used 5×5 steel columns to support the main load. Weight bearing was minimal and steel decking filled with concrete had no chance of folding them columns.
Best NVPN ad ever 😁👍🏼
Marcelo Castro lol you sure about that?
Carbon fibre hulls for deep sea submersibles is really a bad idea...it's only useful in aircrafts. Maybe that's why you don't ask an aircraft designer to build a submarine!
I love how your wife and father come along to watch and support, that's so awesome, great video to watch
i liked when the ball monster tipped back making it look like it was like "what is that above oh shit that is not good "
Love the way you pronounced structural steal! 🤣😂😂 For real though, your English’s has gotten better over the years! You guys rock!
I like the way you spelled steel while criticizing someone else's English!
@@arturoharvey9733 🤣 touché… lol it could have been autocorrect but your right. I’ll give you that.
Can you try that with tungsten.
Nice request
Do test between bolts
strength 8.8 ,12.9 and arp? That would be nice to see!!!
Can I just say that is the best ad on a show I have watched 😂 well done still not going to get it though
Hey hydraulic press channel! Hey I would be interested in knowing the before crush and after crush temperature of each material! Thanks for the quality videos! Ride ride ride!
Totally awesome video guys, I was amazed at when the material hit its peak, how quickly it continued its demise, mind blowing 🧨🧨🧨🧨💥💥💥💥great video as always, from the land down under 👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🦘🦘🦘🦘
It's called catastrophic failure.
I would like to say that, the result of the carbon fiber can vary as it's a "layered material". The compressive strength will decrease or increase based on the orientation of the layers/fibres.
This is the funniest ad i have seen on the channel , continue like that ! X)
this is what happened to the sub,
Accent is on point
The best demonstration I've seen on sponsors!
The way this guy did the advertisement for his sponsor is the greatest thing I've ever seen!
Who came here after watching the new Dr Stone episode?
If only oceangate saw this video
Love how you make the info about the sponsor entertaining:)
Cool that you testet my suggestion. I said bike frames in carbon, aluminium and steel^^
You married a smart woman! I love your videos, and appreciate the entertainment you add to them like the bit at the end haha
Hahshahshahabhs
yeah, i think he meant Structural Steel
Whats the thickness of each material? I wanted to try it in fea. Also in what material is the bed and ram your hydraulic press have?
Can you put I-beams of different materials, laterally, in your press, and crush??
His accent 😂😂
Try to get pipes in different materials but all with the same wall thickness, to make a good comparison :D
Nice video 👌🏼👍🏼
I’d like to see you try this same demonstration with magnesium alloy since it is stronger and lighter than aluminum
I would like to use a strong material to make traction gears without damaging their pins, what do you advise me !! please advise
“Iam suppriized”
The floor is the strongest!
The uniformity of how the aluminum collapsed on itself was very satisfying. I love when things are uniform.
What do you do with the stuff you just squished? That stainless steel looked really cool after you pressed it
Vibranium anybody??
Conclusion of this video: Jet fuel can't melt steel beams :)
Did you know you can't light propane with a lit cigarette? But when mixed with oxygen it will cut thru 6 inch solid steel with a cutting torch? Just something to think about.
Can you get your hands on a thermal camera and film the internal heat generated during compression. It would be interesting to see how and where the heat starts to build up.
How about a video like that with thermal imaging?
why don't you press huge size springs!
Or anything made out of spring steel, one of the strongest.
@@johntheux9238 that will be great.
waiting....
@@rohanbhattarai2247 Elastic energy is strength multiplied by elongation so if it's 4 times stronger than regular steel the elastic energy is 16 times higher, that will really explode.
That's unfair. Use same dimensions to compare Materials not weight.
So...If i build a camper out of 1/4" sheet aluminum with 2" aluminum square tubing it should be strong enough???