Even Pavarotti has been judged badly and even been booed off the stage, it's part of being an artist, sometimes people love what you do and sometimes they don't. So if you wanna live in a fairy tale life where everyone loves Tarja and everything she sings, even if she sang rap, then again this public comments page is not for you cause clearly there's a bunch of people right now writing comments of dislike to her cover right here, not just me, that's if you can open your eyes a little more.
Tarja's beautiful voice is not suited to this song, and the bluesy piano backing isn't either. As a musician and someone who likes to experiment and improvise, I understand the creative license for doing such things - but the energy, grunge and definitive dark energy of the song is sort of ruined by this version.
As a fan of Tarja and Nirvana.... I actually love this version, I understood what she was trying to do.... I know is a grunge song.. but if you notice she is in a beauty pageant or something and the way she sang it it's just perfect for it.. And the piano is very good... She is not the only one that make some soft cover out of a heavy song. She is the best!!
Sou fã de Nirvana, já havia assistido diversas vezes esse vídeo (e nunca me canso!) "SLTS" ficou maravilhosa na voz dela, eu particularmente a-p-a-i-x-o-n-e-i porque a Tarja deu outra interpretação e acredito que se o Kurt estivesse vivo ele sentiria um imenso orgulho desse cover, mas entendo quem não curte, afinal não é obrigado todos gostarem, como dizem "Gosto é igual cu, cada um tem o seu".
I absolutely love this version. If ur gonna compare then Nirvanas is obviously going to be the best, but i just love the way she sings this and with the piano. Its a great version.
As much as I like Tarja. Sorry in my opinion Sharon den Adel did a better cover than that. If Tarja wants to do a cover I think it is better off if she chooses a song that suits her singing style. But hey that is just a opinion.. she can do whatever the hell she wants.
She isn't "copying", she's doing a cover. She's paying homage. Personally, I think Kurt might have been very flattered if he knew his song was going to be honoured by such a beautiful singer.
I was afraid this video but now i don't know why... She's the midas of music and everything she touch (sing ;p ) become gold. My godess from many many years
Nossa acho q é a unica forma de eu conseguir ouvir uma musica propria de nirvana sem tirar no meio dela! Voz perfeita! Tarja topa combinações bem diferentes e gosto disso! Nunca fui la muito fá de nirvana mas ficou lindo!
its very interesthing for me to listen of the covers that Tarja has played as solist and with nightwish its beautiful listen her voice with all those contrasts
I agree that this is not Tarja's territory. Whether or not you like or dislike Nirvana is irrelevant. Nirvana is one of the MOST influential bands in the history of rock music, a fact that many critics worth their salt will agree with
I like to hear different takes on popular songs, It's always nice to hear someones spin off. Like it or not It is still better then nothing. I personally like it, why shouldn't I?, it is good.
Don't get me wrong, I am a huge fan of Tarja's, but this cover was a huge slap in the face to her once amazing career. I had hoped that after she was removed from Nightwish she would get back on her feet and continue to amaze us, but sadly I am begining to think that without Tuomas guiding her, she has nothing left to give us.
As much as I love Tarja, this isn't any good and a little bit awkward to watch. I'd rather go back to her Slipknot or Rammstein arrangements from Wacken 2016, that are actually outstanding and exiting.
She looks stunning!! I love her voice soooo much!!! I dont think she should of done this but it actually doesnt sound as bad as I thought it would xDD You go girl!!!
I find this very interesting. Tarja's voice is amazing. I'm sure all the nirvana fans that don't like classical music, are stabbing themselves in the ears at listening to this. However, lil tid bit to think about. To think about, not comment, or give your opinion about. Should nirvana not feel honored that someone like this took their song, covered it, and made it their own?
There are some rock songs that Tarja can cover perfectly in a heavy style, like Still of the Night for example or Supremacy, but this isn't too bad but I can see why people don't like it. Keep in mind though that this was made to sound different. People dont like it because it doesnt sound like the original, all in all it's not a bad performance but it just doesnt seem to do justice to the original song. All in all i still find it good but maybe not well suited.
Tori Amos did it in this style. I like all three known versions. They all have their certain qualities about them... Nirvana with the raw power, Tarja with the operatic, and Tori with her particular style.
Vote for Tarja everyone on europetourismboard. Right down to the page there's a poll called vote for europes best..... Click ther and then vote for Tarja. Please people vote. She's close to winning :)
Would yoiu guys just get over it already? Seiously if you guys are really fans you would love everything she sings. Jeez...seriously it dosent matter who made the song if she sings it it's a work of art with her voice.
Yeap, me too. I wish she would play this song again :) And besides, the lyrics, the place she is....it's like she is mocking it with the song. "It's fun to lose and to pretend" "With the lights out it's less dangerous, Here we are now, entertain us, I feel stupid and contagious" like moking the fashion show, "I'm worse at what I do best, and for this gift I feel blessed" you know, people often underestimate her when comes to her sing. I think the choice to do the cover was very personal.
I love Tarja's singing. I like "Smells Like Teen Spirit" by Nirvana. So I figured "win", right? Well, by the same token I love chocolate ice cream and I like beer, but I don't like a big scoop of chocolate ice cream IN my beer. That's what we have here ladies and gentlemen. Two good things that do NOT go together.
I like that black and blue dress she's wearing.
97AlanD I see what you did there
97AlanD I see what you did there
97AlanD Get it! XD
lol
LOL
Even Pavarotti has been judged badly and even been booed off the stage, it's part of being an artist, sometimes people love what you do and sometimes they don't. So if you wanna live in a fairy tale life where everyone loves Tarja and everything she sings, even if she sang rap, then again this public comments page is not for you cause clearly there's a bunch of people right now writing comments of dislike to her cover right here, not just me, that's if you can open your eyes a little more.
Tarja's beautiful voice is not suited to this song, and the bluesy piano backing isn't either. As a musician and someone who likes to experiment and improvise, I understand the creative license for doing such things - but the energy, grunge and definitive dark energy of the song is sort of ruined by this version.
As a fan of Tarja and Nirvana.... I actually love this version, I understood what she was trying to do.... I know is a grunge song.. but if you notice she is in a beauty pageant or something and the way she sang it it's just perfect for it..
And the piano is very good...
She is not the only one that make some soft cover out of a heavy song. She is the best!!
Sou fã de Nirvana, já havia assistido diversas vezes esse vídeo (e nunca me canso!) "SLTS" ficou maravilhosa na voz dela, eu particularmente a-p-a-i-x-o-n-e-i porque a Tarja deu outra interpretação e acredito que se o Kurt estivesse vivo ele sentiria um imenso orgulho desse cover, mas entendo quem não curte, afinal não é obrigado todos gostarem, como dizem "Gosto é igual cu, cada um tem o seu".
HAHAHAHA i didnt even notice that! i cant stop laughing!!!!!!!!!!!
Versão mais linda que eu já ouvi dessa musica. A Tarja conseguiu transformar esta em uma versão elegante "clássica ".
I absolutely love this version. If ur gonna compare then Nirvanas is obviously going to be the best, but i just love the way she sings this and with the piano. Its a great version.
As much as I like Tarja. Sorry in my opinion Sharon den Adel did a better cover than that. If Tarja wants to do a cover I think it is better off if she chooses a song that suits her singing style. But hey that is just a opinion.. she can do whatever the hell she wants.
that was so low coming from Tarja..hope this was the 1st & last time she did something like that..damn
Am I the only one who likes this version ?
+chopantura the version is awesome i would like a version well recorded....and well singed
well, I don't dislike it. It's nice. But I don't love it.
Actually, this is the only version I like :)
Yes you are
My god, today I fell more in love of that stunning voice!!!! She can sing everything, that voice knows no limits...
Holy God !!! Even the birds are flying away from that rendition.
So this is what HELL is going to sound like 24/7/365.
Only the ugly crows and Ravens.
lol, at the end , you can ear a kid crying ^^
Huh, I can understand some of the lyrics...
She's doing it wrong.
2:38 I'd give 5 dollars to know what that bird sitting on the light scaffold is thinking?
This is just not tarja's best. She's good at what she does but the cover takes away from the point of the original
I think that the strong contrast and the absurd of the version gives it a new meaning, I like it.
who gave that child permition to cry during the song?!
people are mad because it´s Nirvana ... it´s HOLY ... ntl she did quite beautiful ... i give her the thumps up ...
this version is good and very similar to tori amos version only that tori amos did it better ^^
This is not a karoke competition.This is her version of the song,and i love it!!
I like Tarja..but this no!!!Let the grunge be grunge!
+SageFox of you don't like grunge doesn't mean that's bad. ok? the only ignorant here is you.
Why? WHY? Oh god, why this song at a fashion show, and why Tarja Turunen singing it?!?
Kurt cobain is better
Cobain is shit singer and shit guitarist also
Wow, I clicked this link with fear. But this was actually really awesome.
tarja without nightwish is just not worth listening to. actually new singer floor jansen is even better than her.
I'll pray for you, for you and that disgusting mouth of yours
shes doing the 'hello hello' part all wrong ;
I actually loved it because I never believed it could be done! Always wondered what the song will sound like, now I know.
Exactly. So proud of her for doing so, too.
She isn't "copying", she's doing a cover. She's paying homage.
Personally, I think Kurt might have been very flattered if he knew his song was going to be honoured by such a beautiful singer.
At 3:08 a child cries... Poor babe, got traumatized.
whats wrong with the people who disliked this, i think its a nice contrast to the original!!!!
Its very unique just as Kurt was..
Tarja is the best!
It's one of the best SLTS covers!!!
If i was a baby and i have been there while Tarja is singing I would have cried too cause i find it so beautiful
I was afraid this video but now i don't know why... She's the midas of music and everything she touch (sing ;p ) become gold.
My godess from many many years
Nossa acho q é a unica forma de eu conseguir ouvir uma musica propria de nirvana sem tirar no meio dela! Voz perfeita! Tarja topa combinações bem diferentes e gosto disso! Nunca fui la muito fá de nirvana mas ficou lindo!
Perfect
Tarja, you're so beautiful and your voices........
No commentes
It's just Perfect
ok i will use them well :D
THANKS! ^^
Tarja Turunen + Nirvana! my favorite moment!
5 stars :D
I love this version so much. I love her voice with the piano.
This is amazing!!!
I don't know what everyone is talking about. I like this version. :3
I love everything that she does
"A little" you're so kind.
He must have killed him self for the second time.
its very interesthing for me to listen of the covers that Tarja has played as solist and with nightwish its beautiful listen her voice with all those contrasts
whatever you say I like this cover,Tarja makes everything better
I like it! Great piano and Tarja's voice is very cool. I'm a huge Nirvana fan and you can't top the original in my opinion, but this is cool.
I like this. It's something unique. Way different then all the other covers I've heard.
Best version ever!
que buena version !!!
I agree that this is not Tarja's territory. Whether or not you like or dislike Nirvana is irrelevant. Nirvana is one of the MOST influential bands in the history of rock music, a fact that many critics worth their salt will agree with
OMFG! THIS IS SICK!
@J7Joel - well, i`m sure he`s been turning and twisting in his grave when this was recorded... jesus fucking christ, make this stop... ;(
im sorry I realy like this its different and shows how talented she is
Love nirvana.... love nightwish.... love tarja.... GREAT VERSION WITH A BEAUTIFUL VOICE :)!!!! greetings from argentina !
why you got to be hating? its her version of the song, and its lovely.
I like to hear different takes on popular songs, It's always nice to hear someones spin off. Like it or not It is still better then nothing. I personally like it, why shouldn't I?, it is good.
Don't get me wrong, I am a huge fan of Tarja's, but this cover was a huge slap in the face to her once amazing career. I had hoped that after she was removed from Nightwish she would get back on her feet and continue to amaze us, but sadly I am begining to think that without Tuomas guiding her, she has nothing left to give us.
imo tarja can pull anything of - love her always.
As much as I love Tarja, this isn't any good and a little bit awkward to watch. I'd rather go back to her Slipknot or Rammstein arrangements from Wacken 2016, that are actually outstanding and exiting.
Perfect!!
please ask a real soprano to sing metal.......
we all shod be greatfull for her gift.
Simply, both Tarja and Nirvana are too awesome to be compared.
The only song tarja destroyed
I like it, she has a beautiful voice (:
I love this one *.*
She looks stunning!! I love her voice soooo much!!!
I dont think she should of done this but it actually doesnt sound as bad as I thought it would xDD You go girl!!!
The best part about this video is that you can find it by searching for Tarja smells :P.
i like this cover
I love Nirvana but I think that Tarja did a good job, too. It's original and I appreciate originality.
at first i didnt really like it. but now i listen to this song every day
I love you Tarja!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I find this very interesting. Tarja's voice is amazing. I'm sure all the nirvana fans that don't like classical music, are stabbing themselves in the ears at listening to this. However, lil tid bit to think about. To think about, not comment, or give your opinion about. Should nirvana not feel honored that someone like this took their song, covered it, and made it their own?
wow sounds awsome
There are some rock songs that Tarja can cover perfectly in a heavy style, like Still of the Night for example or Supremacy, but this isn't too bad but I can see why people don't like it. Keep in mind though that this was made to sound different. People dont like it because it doesnt sound like the original, all in all it's not a bad performance but it just doesnt seem to do justice to the original song. All in all i still find it good but maybe not well suited.
Is Supremacy a cover? I actually thought it was an original Tarja song.
extremely perfect voicee!!! :D
I want a recorded version of this song.
Shut up everybody, Tarja is perfect and this song is beautiful when she is singing it!
simpre linda tarja turunen!!!!!!!
Tori Amos did it in this style. I like all three known versions. They all have their certain qualities about them... Nirvana with the raw power, Tarja with the operatic, and Tori with her particular style.
Vote for Tarja everyone on europetourismboard. Right down to the page there's a poll called vote for europes best..... Click ther and then vote for Tarja. Please people vote. She's close to winning :)
Tarja,that song is not written as a lullaby...
Oh the pink dresses of the models
I love this version of Teen Spirit
I love Tarja :)
Tarja + Nghtwish = La mejor banda de todos los tiempos
Loved her dress.
Would yoiu guys just get over it already? Seiously if you guys are really fans you would love everything she sings. Jeez...seriously it dosent matter who made the song if she sings it it's a work of art with her voice.
Mi amor Tarja, no sabia que tambien interpretarás a Nirvana smell like teen spirit. forever TARJA, FOREVER NIGHTWISH!!!!
Wow! No me imagine que Tarja cantaria esa cancion... Genial cancion, pero no me imaginaba...
Tak tohle mi přijde ponižující. Takový formát, aby zpíval na nějaké stupidní přehlídce, a ještě převzatou písničku...
yeah i have that album. it wasn't bad, i just felt like it was missing something. but thanks for the suggestion
damn
what has been heard
can never be unheard :(
Yeap, me too.
I wish she would play this song again :)
And besides, the lyrics, the place she is....it's like she is mocking it with the song.
"It's fun to lose and to pretend" "With the lights out it's less dangerous, Here we are now, entertain us,
I feel stupid and contagious" like moking the fashion show, "I'm worse at what I do best, and for this gift I feel blessed" you know, people often underestimate her when comes to her sing.
I think the choice to do the cover was very personal.
She rocks
gah.... now i need to listen to the REAL version to get this tragedy out of my head. god what a butchery...
I love Tarja's singing. I like "Smells Like Teen Spirit" by Nirvana. So I figured "win", right? Well, by the same token I love chocolate ice cream and I like beer, but I don't like a big scoop of chocolate ice cream IN my beer. That's what we have here ladies and gentlemen. Two good things that do NOT go together.
yayy
tarja, i love you forever
wow shes beautiful
Tarja can sing everything and Nirvana's songs too!!! This version sounds better than original.
hahahah FUNY! :D:D:D:D:D