And no I don't speak Dutch, TH-cam is messed up and translated the video to Dutch ⬇️Scotty’s Top DIY Tools: 1. Bluetooth Scan Tool: amzn.to/2nfvmaD 2. Mid-Grade Scan Tool: amzn.to/33dKI0k 3. My Fancy (Originally $5,000) Professional Scan Tool: amzn.to/31khBXC 4. Cheap Scan Tool: amzn.to/2D8Tvae 5. Basic Mechanic Tool Set: amzn.to/2tEr6Ce 6. Professional Socket Set: amzn.to/2Bzmccg 7. Ratcheting Wrench Set: amzn.to/2BQjj8A 8. No Charging Required Car Jump Starter: amzn.to/2CthnUU 9. Battery Pack Car Jump Starter: amzn.to/2nrc6qR ⬇️ Things used in this video: 1. Common Sense 2. 4k Camera: amzn.to/2HkjavH 3. Camera Microphone: amzn.to/2Evn167 4. Camera Tripod: amzn.to/2Jwog8S 5. My computer for editing / uploading: amzn.to/2uUZ3lo 🛠Check out the tools I use and highly recommend ► goo.gl/rwYt2y 🔥Scotty Shirts and Merch ► goo.gl/pTAeca Subscribe and hit the notification bell! ► goo.gl/CFismN Scotty on Social: Facebook ► facebook.com/scottymechanic/ Instagram ► instagram.com/scotty_the_mechanic/ Twitter ► twitter.com/Scottymechanic?lang=en
I can't even imagine how hot it is in Texas today, felt like 106 here in Missouri today, and just got a bunch of rain so breathing outside sucks lol . Either way great channel Scotty
The Honda motors are worth cleaning up and everyone and their brother inlaw makes aftermarket. Won't give you 10 cents for a Ford. Chevy and Honda are about the aftermarket and parts swaps between models thru centuries. Older Benz same way.
I have a 99 CRV 175,000 miles and love it! Mechanic boyfriend turned me on to it. I was always a Toyota Camry fan, but I love my CRV. I am now a Honda fan with Toyota a close 2nd.
Bro you have a scion in your profile pic.. Who are you kidding (Yes its a cheaper toyota, diffrent build quality, especially toyota penny pinching more than honda)
My thoughts exactly. Put the Toyota 6spd transmission (from 2017) in the new Honda CR-V with the 2.4L engine and you have a winner. It would probably outlast the owner LOL!
I used to have a rav4 and loved it. But as a Honda crv owner now I can totally agree with you Scotty. Very comfortable ride. Very reliable, great on both a local runabouts or on the motorway. Loads of space for my granddaughters and the dogs. I have the 2.4litre lx diesel 2012. Only got 64k on the clock.. Only problem I have is because its constant 4wd I tend to go through tyres quite a lot. But other than that it's very easy on my wallet. Keep em comming Scotty.
Transmission is still hanging in there, the driveshaft on the other hand has been replaced 3 times. And my power steering rack recently went out but it still rolls. Frame is starting to rust heavy underneath also but other then what I mentioned it starts up and goes. Yes always have my oil changed by or during the 4,000 mile mark
I had a Toyota RAV4 and I loved it. It never had any mechanical issue. I’ve recently decided to replace my car by another RAV4 2019. When I did the test drive I thought that the engine was so loud tbat would probably give me headache during long trips. Additionally the car had this recall pending which seemed pretty serious. So I drove the CRV and I thought it was a better drive, much quieter drive.
The CR-V was on my list back in 2012 when I was looking for a pre-2006 cheap reliable AWD vehicle. After comparing the CR-V to others of the time, I went with a late model 2004 RAV4 4wd 5sp with the updated 2.0vvti engine (German model). It out performed the CRV and had better handling than the Honda CR-V of that year. Also the RAV4 (4.1 & 4.2) was waaay better with it's AWD performance than the Honda's back then. Still driving it today with 210tkm on it so far. Does great in Austria and the German Alp's in winter too.
We bought a 2004 Rav-4 new, then sold it for a 2013 CR-V new. The Rav looked better imo; had the window switch go bad, but that's it. Nothing is wrong on the CR-V but the trans worry me. Shoulda bought the Rav-4 in 2013.
We were going to get the CR-V. I love its quirky but conservative looks, how practical it is, how non-taxi like the car was and how smooth it was compared to the raspy sounding Rav4. The ONLY reason I didn't land up getting the CR-V was because at the time (2016), the CR-V was having a major vibration issue with the CVT transmission that was causing the car to vibrate when in drive at a stop. I thought it was no big deal until we rented a 2015 Zipcar CR-V and we experienced first hand the very same issue. And wasn't a small vibration. It was even noticed by my wife in the passenger seat. So just to play it safe, we went with the Rav4. Though I will say, as taxi-like the Rav4 is, I am at 40K miles and not even a single issue with it.
I've owned two. A 2001 that got rear-ended and totaled while it was parked ( it could still drive though, popped my spare on it and drove it in my driveway until the next morning) Now I own a 1998. I absolutely love the Crv, it's quirky, and great ride!
I’m shooting to find a 2013 CRV! -trying to make it my son’s first car. Scotty helped me realize all-WD on that car is not only unnecessary but potentially more problematic to maintain & more $ if problem occurs. Do u agree? Did u get EX or LX etc? And do u regret which trim you chose?
Someone needs to put you back on TV, I love watching your videos. My wife has a 2017 CR-V LX (base model, no frills) that just turned 36,000 miles and I appreciate your knowledge of these vehicles as well as helping me save money.
I never knew why our CRV shuddered sometimes. Almost always around 40mph at a slow acceleration rate. Now we know thanks to Scotty! We'll just live with it.
We have a same issue with our 2012 CRV. There is really no way to fix it for the long term so the Honda dealership replaced ours with a Remanufacture transmission by Honda under the Extended warranty.
My 2008 CRV does the same thing around that speed. I mean it doesn’t bother me I just take my foot of the gas and it goes away but once I get past 40 mph it goes away
Hi Scotty. I have bought both the Honda 2.0 Auto and the 2.4 Auto secondhand, that both juddered only under very light acceleration, and only just before changing into 3rd gear. But the problem was 100% ELIMINATED by replacing the Automatic Transmission Fluid. Both cars. It's easy to do. They both run like a dream now. No juddering, no attention to torque converter required. I intend to now replace the ATF at the same time as the engine oil change, instead of relying on the manual's relatively infrequent ATF service schedule.
Does anyone feel like Scotty Kilmer, while amazing, makes videos about literally everything? Why Honda is better than Toyota? Why Toyota is better than Honda? Yet somehow it all makes sense when you watch it lol
So it turns out I'm not the actual Dale Gribble, but a clone of him. The original Dale Gribble is a super-warrior from the year 2087. The second me, i.e., I, was created to help the first me fight the invading Mongol armies.
I bought a used 2012 CR-V last November with 94k miles on it. I have almost 111k miles on it now and it's been a great vehicle so far, drives like it's brand new! Mine is an EX-L trim so it has leather and a lot of options and the previous owners definitely took care of it. I can see why people like these cars, I took mine on a roadtrip in late June and it did great! Good car for around town too, it feels a little slow on the highway until you get the engine into the higher rpms when making a pass but around town it's actually really peppy.
Scotty... as a 2014 RAV4 owner I'd love to see an in depth video about the inline 4 and transmission combo in that generation! I have 100k Kms ~ 62k miles...
Spot on Scotty! If anybody out there is worried about the transmission shudder don't be. Just let off the gas when it shudders and then resume speed. Been driving our 2002 CRV for over 3 years and saved $1000s in transmission repairs. Good driving to you all...
Honestly I just went and got my tranny flushed and it fixed that issue I have, I have 50k on the odo and got my tranny flushed like 2k miles ago, when or if the shuddering comes back, I’m probably gonna put some anti slip fluid in there, cured my old Kia from sinking thousands into a new tranny rebuild lol
I bought a 2012 CR-V 3 weeks ago. I suspected it was engine mounts that needing replacing. Haven't had it looked at but it definitely shudders around 30 mph while accelerating. I''ll try your tip about letting off the gas and see if it works!! Thank you!
Scotty, you should do a video series about what vehicle years you should avoid and what years you should definately get for different vehicles, or at least different makes of vehicles. Because even GM had some good years for vehicles.
I just bought a 2014 Rav4. It drives great, acceleration is great and cornors great. I wouldn't trade it in for a cr-v to end with transmission problems.
I had a Rav4 as a loaner vehicle for about a week and it drove and rode great, the AWD system worked really well even in the 10 inches of snow that we luckily got while I had the Rav4, excellent timing to be able to really test the Rav4's AWD system. With the crappy tires installed from the factory I say it did remarkably well. Would I buy one? No, I actually like the Highlander a little better, more room and a V6 which Toyota dropped from the Rav4 a few years ago, but the Highlander does great as well and even more comfortable being a larger car. If I were in the market for a new car I'd be in a Highlander.
@@JSPHTRS If you spend $1000-2000 for the trip, at least you get a vacation out of it. Unlike spending that amount at your local dishonest mechanic and HE gets the vacation.
I have a 2010 Rav 4 and I intend to drive it until the wheels fall off just to see how long it really lasts. Currently at 117,000 miles and still runs like new!
@@terrencebanton9080 He's not far off. 97 for the United States and they were all LX models. They had been in Japan prior so they could have been released in 95 as a 96 model for Japan.
@@terrencebanton9080 production of the JDM 96 CR-V began in 95. USDM CR-V LX was released in 96 for the 97 model year. USDM CR-V EX, and MT were released in 97 for the 98 model year. USDM CR-V SEs were released in 99 for the 2000 model year. I don't know as much about the EDM models, but I read somewhere that they didn't get them in England until the 98 model year.
I enjoy watching your videos and find them very helpful. I’ve driven and purchased Toyotas since 1979, I have owned many Celicas, Camrys and one Corolla, but have owned Honda as well, I have to be honest I hated my Honda. The Honda to me was much more sluggish and brakes always needs replacing, could not wait to get rid of the Honda, bought a new Toyota.
Thanks for all the great advice Scotty.... since I've been listening to your videos I have repaired my headlights with your recommended headlight restoration kit, changed fluids, cleaned my mass air intake sensor and now I'm going to get some gum out cleaner.
I’ll take an older Rav 4 equipped with the V6 any day over the CRV. Too bad Toyota doesn’t offer them with the V6 anymore, they were actually pretty fast SUVs.
Scotty, I agree with you. I have a 2007 Honda CRV. I use it to tote my boat. after about 17 years I had the compressor replaced, condenser, the control arms and fixing to have struts done. Great car!! About 123k miles
I have both cars and they are 4th gen. I agree with Scotty in the most part but I personally prefer my RAV4 over the CRV because its more peppy and rugged. The CRV is primarly used to transport my elderly parents because of the lower ground clearance.
Have to say though Scotty, my wife and I picked up the 2018 RAV4 and it is the smoothest vehicle I have ever driven, it floats on the road! Very comfortable
I had a 2017 CR-V EX and recently traded for a 2019 RAV-4 XSE. The CR-V is a good vehicle but I am not a fan of that 1.5 turbo engine. Unfortunately, if you want any of the nicer amenities, then you must opt for CR-V models equipped with this engine. By contrast, I love my RAV4 more each day and enjoy it's styling and power. I have no regrets!
I just bought my 2004 CR-V about 3 weeks ago. I was immediately drawn to how spacious the cab is and how it's laid out. Then I drove it and man! These things are actually fun to drive! My daily driver of 100 miles per day in sunny Atlanta has been my 2013 Nissan Rogue. It's just past 250,000 miles and needs some front end work I've got to handle. So I basically just wanted a get me by to drive to work whilst I begin the arduous task of rebuilding the front end. But wow! I never expected it to be as nice as it is. Also a very good looking vehicle as well.
Scotty, I just found your videos Bro and enjoy listening to your opinions. I just bought a 2011 CRV with 89,000 miles and I love it! It runs great right now but I did not know of the accuator problems. Hopefully, I will not have this problem for a few years.
It really depends on which exact models you compare too. Toyota made v6 Rav4s from 2006-2012 that were genuinely fast and would definitely outrun the CR-Vs. Toyota also now makes hybrid Rav4s that get awesome gas mileage. The Rav4s tend to be better off-road/in less than ideal driving conditions, and the full size spare tire on the older ones is a big plus for me, and the fact that it's on the rear door opens up more space under the floor boards. The Rav4 was originally intended for active, young people that wanted something more practical for daily driving than a truck that would also fit more stuff and be better off road than a typical sedan/hatch. To me the CR-V was intended more for people that wanted a car that sat up higher, had better visibility, had the cool styling of an SUV, and could fit lots of cargo
"as the old ones went out they just bought another one and they were still happy" i suppose that also applies to that one guy who bought like five chrysler vans because his wife liked them
Wow you are so good at what you do educating the public. I listen to you all the time and wish you understood Medicare the way you understand cars. Thanks for all you know and all you teach us
When test driving both vehicles, the Honda seemed more smooth but when going into the corners it feels like tipping over compared to the RAV4. The RAV4 is just so stiff and every bump you feel no matter how small. Not too mention the CR-V doesn’t have a very flat cargo space when all the seats are put down.
Yes! Only because I have one. 2005 Honda CR-V Manual Transmission. 205k miles on the original motor with a recently replaced clutch. I’ve never had an issue with it because of preventative maintenance.
I am usually a fan of the 2005 to 2006 Honda CR-V's with the EX or EX-L trim and standard 4WD. It has the similar 2.4 L four-cylinder engine with 156 to 160 horsepower and they are both equipped with the five-speed automatic transmission. Those older CR-V's are still on the road as of today and they handle better than a RAV4. I have some close friends that own a 2002 CR-V, but only with the four-speed auto.
I have a 2014 Honda crv EX-L with 56,000 miles on it no problems at all change my oil when it get to the miles some people saying they're not reliable but they're are . I grew up around Hondas ,acura, chevys and Toyotas. Honda makes some good reliable vehicles but I love my SUV its very spacious and comfortable.
I love my automatic braking on my 2018 RAV4 Limited. All the bugs were worked out on this particular model. I like to buy vehicles that are "perfected" through years of imperfect design, then updated to perfection. I'll be driving it for another 20 years. CRV's have lots of road noise inside.
2012 CRV owner, the only "issues" I've ever had (and I put "issues" in quotations because the car still ran fine, just a tiny bit of noise) were a small axle seal leak, a wheel bearing replaced, and belt tensioner replaced. Never ever stalled, or had anything fail or had anything fall apart. Sometimes the bluetooth connection to my android would be erratic, but that's it.
This is why Toyota is better overall; everything has no weakness. Honda on the other hand has transmission weaknesses. If only Honda could iron out their transmissions, they could be better than Toyota. Source: Scotty :)
It’s funny if Chevy has a problem with the transmission Scotty says it’s pure junk. If Honda has a transmission issue he says it’s only $3500 to fix it.
SCrobbe this car can still go with this problem. Also, Chevy have problems with their engines. I have a 3 cars, 2014 Chevy Cruze, 2016 Chevy Equinox, and a 2015 Honda CR-V. Both of these Chevys I’ve replaced the engine and transmission. The Honda, which has way more miles than my two Gm products have never had a problem.
2014 CR-V with 2.2 litre turbo diesel - what a dream car, aside from the shuddering locker torque converter, which was resolved with a transmission fluid change and firmware update
Oddly enough, I drive the same exact car. Same color combo, trim level, and everything. I love my CR-V. Yes they only make the CR-Vs in automatics nowadays at least here in the states. I have seen some of the newer models overseas that are equipped with a manual transmission. Mine is AWD also
In my experience Toyota is geared more towards comfort and quiet, and Honda more towards road feel and handling, I personally prefer our Camry versus our Accord in everyday driving here in Florida, the Camry is quieter and smoother, both 4cyl engines.
My wife had a Corolla when we started dating and I thought those seats were hard as a rock. I told her to return it (it was a lease). The cr-v I bought is way more comfortable to drive.
Talking about the shudder in the crv trans. I bought instant shudder fix at auto zone $9.00 completely corrected the problem. Just need to be sure the trans is not a CVT. Call Honda w/Vin # to be sure.
My wife's 2012 Honda CR-V AWD never had any torque converter shutter... very smooth. It may have had a reflash from the dealership, however. I am very happy with it for the most part... I just wished it had a 6 speed auto trans since the 5 speed can be really doggish at highway passing speeds. This is something that Honda remediated with their excellent and class leading CVT transmission later on.
I had a 2001 crv slush box ...300k+ original engine and tranny and it was driven like a tank Honda's are the only cars I drive without buying breakdown cover
Scotty’s dream vehicles: Honda engines installed into Toyota Camry, Corolla, and/or RAV4 lowered with race suspension..! I’m willing to bet he has engine swapped all of above hiding them behind his garage...lol..! Thanks for the honest videos and not selling out like most do..!
I don't know, I'd probably stick to models made after 2001. There were valve seat problems on certain engines with first generation. It costed a fortune to fix and would happen repeatedly. I think you had to keep adjust valve seat clearance or something like that. Better just to replace those engines. Nice little SUV though, fun to drive.
Hey Scotty, I love your videos and would love to see some on old Dodge trucks. I just bought a 1989 D150 5.2 liter 318 automatic, and want to rebuild it myself. I'm not a mechanic, and need all the help I can get. Thanks bud.
I have the 3rd generation 2009. Bought it new and it’s a wonderful reliable ride. The longer you keep a Honda if well maintained and paid off, it will reward you with reliability. I am always sad to say goodbye to my Honda’s because they never let me down. Learn how to do your brakes, fluid changes, tire rotations yourself too and bond with it😎. The only thing that bugs me is that the catalytic cover rusts away earlier than expected, and you only have to use a long hose clamp to keep it closed.
I love my 08 crv one of the best cars I've ever owned just hit 115k on it.only done regular maintenance in 5 yrs since I've owned it.brakes tires battery and fluid changes and that's all in 5 yrs .car runs like a dream.
And no I don't speak Dutch, TH-cam is messed up and translated the video to Dutch
⬇️Scotty’s Top DIY Tools:
1. Bluetooth Scan Tool: amzn.to/2nfvmaD
2. Mid-Grade Scan Tool: amzn.to/33dKI0k
3. My Fancy (Originally $5,000) Professional Scan Tool: amzn.to/31khBXC
4. Cheap Scan Tool: amzn.to/2D8Tvae
5. Basic Mechanic Tool Set: amzn.to/2tEr6Ce
6. Professional Socket Set: amzn.to/2Bzmccg
7. Ratcheting Wrench Set: amzn.to/2BQjj8A
8. No Charging Required Car Jump Starter: amzn.to/2CthnUU
9. Battery Pack Car Jump Starter: amzn.to/2nrc6qR
⬇️ Things used in this video:
1. Common Sense
2. 4k Camera: amzn.to/2HkjavH
3. Camera Microphone: amzn.to/2Evn167
4. Camera Tripod: amzn.to/2Jwog8S
5. My computer for editing / uploading: amzn.to/2uUZ3lo
🛠Check out the tools I use and highly recommend ► goo.gl/rwYt2y
🔥Scotty Shirts and Merch ► goo.gl/pTAeca
Subscribe and hit the notification bell! ► goo.gl/CFismN
Scotty on Social:
Facebook ► facebook.com/scottymechanic/
Instagram ► instagram.com/scotty_the_mechanic/
Twitter ► twitter.com/Scottymechanic?lang=en
This is how you do TH-cam CC: WRONG!!!
I can't even imagine how hot it is in Texas today, felt like 106 here in Missouri today, and just got a bunch of rain so breathing outside sucks lol .
Either way great channel Scotty
Dutch Scotty!?! Sweeeet!
Scotty Kilmer what do you think about the cvt transmissions Honda makes nowadays?
The Honda motors are worth cleaning up and everyone and their brother inlaw makes aftermarket. Won't give you 10 cents for a Ford. Chevy and Honda are about the aftermarket and parts swaps between models thru centuries. Older Benz same way.
Scotty blink twice if Honda has you hostage
(Wears sunglasses)
Sam Z 🤣🤣
(wears sunglasses" lmaoo😂😂😂😂
you are soooooo funny!!!!
😂
😂😂😂😂😂
And since its Monday! I'm giving away this Honda CR-V!
🤣🤣🤣
Haha 😂
Let's ask that someone from NH to give it away
Dam. If only lol.
with a toyota rav4 engine
My wife loves her '99 Rav4 with stick. It's still her daily driver and extremely reliable.
I have a 99 CRV 175,000 miles and love it! Mechanic boyfriend turned me on to it. I was always a Toyota Camry fan, but I love my CRV. I am now a Honda fan with Toyota a close 2nd.
Toyota and Honda are the only cars my family owns. Both are very reliable.
That's true
Jorge Lopez Nissans are extremely reliable too I got a Z and a G both at 90k running like brand new and timeless looks
Same here with us..👍
Bro you have a scion in your profile pic.. Who are you kidding
(Yes its a cheaper toyota, diffrent build quality, especially toyota penny pinching more than honda)
@@modelotimefoo323 no
So buy a Honda CR-V with a Toyota automatic transmission; or buy a Toyota RAV4 with a Honda 2.4 L engine.
My thoughts exactly. Put the Toyota 6spd transmission (from 2017) in the new Honda CR-V with the 2.4L engine and you have a winner. It would probably outlast the owner LOL!
Philosophical question. I would take the Toyota transmission in the Honda.
The 2.4 l i v tech honda engine is the best engine ever made. I think so
@@outworkthework Can you really do that place a Toyota transmission into a Honda car?
How can it be done? Switching out the Honda lousy automatic transmission for an Aisin?
I used to have a rav4 and loved it. But as a Honda crv owner now I can totally agree with you Scotty. Very comfortable ride. Very reliable, great on both a local runabouts or on the motorway. Loads of space for my granddaughters and the dogs. I have the 2.4litre lx diesel 2012. Only got 64k on the clock.. Only problem I have is because its constant 4wd I tend to go through tyres quite a lot. But other than that it's very easy on my wallet. Keep em comming Scotty.
I’ve been a mechanic for about 14 years now I went to school five years just wanted to tell you I’m a big fan 😎😎😎🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓
Toyota or Honda???
@@evelynstewart1504 Both. They are both great cars
Scotty you are biggest star in Kazakhstan! Friday is Scotty Kilmer day
Kazakhstan is the No. 1 exporter of potassium!
Along with Borat??
@@Gzsy BORAT
Just don’t visit Kazakhstan Scotty, you can’t speak your mind or you will be imprisoned, I’m surprised they even allow them to watch your videos.
Казахстан ? Это Казахстан , да ?
2001 crv, 325000 miles and still going strong.
Hows the transmission and motor been keeping up on the maintenance on it?
Transmission is still hanging in there, the driveshaft on the other hand has been replaced 3 times. And my power steering rack recently went out but it still rolls. Frame is starting to rust heavy underneath also but other then what I mentioned it starts up and goes. Yes always have my oil changed by or during the 4,000 mile mark
Mine was close .....was driving superb but the dreaded arch rust got out of control so had to scrap it .....regret it badly :(
Ugly car.
I’d rather buy two good looking ones.
😱 tips on how to keep them strong?
My mom bought a 2019 CR-V and we’ve had it for a couple months, and we love it thus far
@Sean Barry can you update us your CRV, any issues and mileage now?
I had a Toyota RAV4 and I loved it. It never had any mechanical issue. I’ve recently decided to replace my car by another RAV4 2019. When I did the test drive I thought that the engine was so loud tbat would probably give me headache during long trips. Additionally the car had this recall pending which seemed pretty serious. So I drove the CRV and I thought it was a better drive, much quieter drive.
“How hard is it to find a good, honest mechanic?”
Car in Scotty’s video has license plates from New Hampshire. Scotty lives in Houston.
😭
Looks like whoever owns the car is late paying registration by 20 years according to the sticker.
Good eyes ! 99 😂
I think it's an old license plate he uses to hide the real one, bc I've seen 4 vehicles with a new Hampshire licenses so far..
You can clearly tell that the Hampshire license plate is put up above another license plate
@@Drskopf That makes sense with all the "live free or die" references around scotties place
Sportier driving experience: Honda
Longer life for vehicle, comfortable ride: Toyota RAV4
Both are good vehicles just what suits your life style.
Idk, from my experience, a 2014 (I think) Traverse has a combination of the two attributes. Sporty, but reliable, but OnStar is annoying.
Then again the traverse was very well cared for, so...
@@rydoggo A comedian has entered the thread!
@@MaestroTJS more reliable than a caravan that's for sure, though.
@@rydoggo I don't know how Chrysler can make something for 10+ years and still have it be an unreliable P.O.S.! Shameful.
I have a 2019 Honda CRV and I LOVE IT.
I always take a moment to stare at my car 😌
Same
oil dilution?
@@jeremywestwood3769 Nope because I bought the LX 2.4L
oil dilution problems...should have bought toyota its way better
Arnie Cardenas s wish I could afford a new crv
The CR-V was on my list back in 2012 when I was looking for a pre-2006 cheap reliable AWD vehicle. After comparing the CR-V to others of the time, I went with a late model 2004 RAV4 4wd 5sp with the updated 2.0vvti engine (German model). It out performed the CRV and had better handling than the Honda CR-V of that year. Also the RAV4 (4.1 & 4.2) was waaay better with it's AWD performance than the Honda's back then. Still driving it today with 210tkm on it so far. Does great in Austria and the German Alp's in winter too.
We bought a 2004 Rav-4 new, then sold it for a 2013 CR-V new. The Rav looked better imo; had the window switch go bad, but that's it. Nothing is wrong on the CR-V but the trans worry me. Shoulda bought the Rav-4 in 2013.
Rev up your comfortable runabout vehicles !
Gabriel Oropeza Did he make that up or is that what it means?
@@MrHuck I've heard it was Comfortable Reliable Vehicle but I can't confirm.
Gabriel Oropeza Hahahaha that’s awesome
MrHuckabst no that’s what it actually means.
The right one is Compact Recreational Vehicle. But here in my country someone calls it Cost Reduction Vehicle.
Just found your channel recently and have been binge watching every video! amazing content with clear cut video! Keep the Videos coming!!!!
We were going to get the CR-V. I love its quirky but conservative looks, how practical it is, how non-taxi like the car was and how smooth it was compared to the raspy sounding Rav4. The ONLY reason I didn't land up getting the CR-V was because at the time (2016), the CR-V was having a major vibration issue with the CVT transmission that was causing the car to vibrate when in drive at a stop. I thought it was no big deal until we rented a 2015 Zipcar CR-V and we experienced first hand the very same issue. And wasn't a small vibration. It was even noticed by my wife in the passenger seat. So just to play it safe, we went with the Rav4. Though I will say, as taxi-like the Rav4 is, I am at 40K miles and not even a single issue with it.
I don't even like SUV type cars but I just love listening to Scotty's no bull advice. Top geezer.
I've owned two. A 2001 that got rear-ended and totaled while it was parked ( it could still drive though, popped my spare on it and drove it in my driveway until the next morning) Now I own a 1998. I absolutely love the Crv, it's quirky, and great ride!
My wife drives a 2013 crv and I drive a 2013 rav4. Have to say Scotty nailed it on every comparison aspect of the crv to the rav4
I’m shooting to find a 2013 CRV!
-trying to make it my son’s first car.
Scotty helped me realize all-WD
on that car is not only unnecessary but potentially more problematic to maintain & more $ if problem occurs.
Do u agree?
Did u get EX or LX etc? And do u regret which trim you chose?
very informative...i've learnt quite alot just by watching your videos, simple and straightfoward. respect from Malawi(Africa)
Someone needs to put you back on TV, I love watching your videos. My wife has a 2017 CR-V LX (base model, no frills) that just turned 36,000 miles and I appreciate your knowledge of these vehicles as well as helping me save money.
How is your CRV now? Any issues and mileage now?
WOW. I changed the oil and filter in my 2001 CR-V today with 240,000 miles on it. This is my 1st non-USA car I have owned. Glad I found your channel.
Do you have a manual transmission or an automatic on your CR-V?
I never knew why our CRV shuddered sometimes. Almost always around 40mph at a slow acceleration rate. Now we know thanks to Scotty! We'll just live with it.
You know I recently purchase one and been experiencing the same issue and been trying to figure out what to do to fix it...happen between 40 to 50 km
We have a same issue with our 2012 CRV. There is really no way to fix it for the long term so the Honda dealership replaced ours with a Remanufacture transmission by Honda under the Extended warranty.
My 2008 CRV does the same thing around that speed. I mean it doesn’t bother me I just take my foot of the gas and it goes away but once I get past 40 mph it goes away
Yep that happened with one of my Honda Odyssey’s
Me too,what is the best solution for that shudder or shaking to disappear.😢
Hi Scotty. I have bought both the Honda 2.0 Auto and the 2.4 Auto secondhand, that both juddered only under very light acceleration, and only just before changing into 3rd gear. But the problem was 100% ELIMINATED by replacing the Automatic Transmission Fluid. Both cars. It's easy to do. They both run like a dream now. No juddering, no attention to torque converter required. I intend to now replace the ATF at the same time as the engine oil change, instead of relying on the manual's relatively infrequent ATF service schedule.
Does anyone feel like Scotty Kilmer, while amazing, makes videos about literally everything? Why Honda is better than Toyota? Why Toyota is better than Honda? Yet somehow it all makes sense when you watch it lol
So Scottie can make Honda and Toyota to compete for bigger Cheques................
Lol he tell the true either way ho honda and Toyota
LOOKS LIKE HONDA IS PAYING SCOTTY MORE THAN TOYOTA!!!
David Owen YES HE DID!
Either that or he's trying to get a raise. ;)
Maestro_T Toyota better start listening
😅
He did mention weak automatic transmission tho
So it turns out I'm not the actual Dale Gribble, but a clone of him. The original Dale Gribble is a super-warrior from the year 2087. The second me, i.e., I, was created to help the first me fight the invading Mongol armies.
Love all your videos, this one made my day I'm torn between rav 4 and CRV, I prefer long life and reliability rather than speed. Thanks man!
Rav 4 is known to chew through tires, gonna cost you a fortune more over the lifetime of the vehicle
I think they’re both ugly.
I’d rather buy two good looking cars than be stuck with either of them.
I bought a used 2012 CR-V last November with 94k miles on it. I have almost 111k miles on it now and it's been a great vehicle so far, drives like it's brand new! Mine is an EX-L trim so it has leather and a lot of options and the previous owners definitely took care of it. I can see why people like these cars, I took mine on a roadtrip in late June and it did great! Good car for around town too, it feels a little slow on the highway until you get the engine into the higher rpms when making a pass but around town it's actually really peppy.
Scotty... as a 2014 RAV4 owner I'd love to see an in depth video about the inline 4 and transmission combo in that generation! I have 100k Kms ~ 62k miles...
Spot on Scotty! If anybody out there is worried about the transmission shudder don't be. Just let off the gas when it shudders and then resume speed. Been driving our 2002 CRV for over 3 years and saved $1000s in transmission repairs. Good driving to you all...
Honestly I just went and got my tranny flushed and it fixed that issue I have, I have 50k on the odo and got my tranny flushed like 2k miles ago, when or if the shuddering comes back, I’m probably gonna put some anti slip fluid in there, cured my old Kia from sinking thousands into a new tranny rebuild lol
I bought a 2012 CR-V 3 weeks ago. I suspected it was engine mounts that needing replacing. Haven't had it looked at but it definitely shudders around 30 mph while accelerating. I''ll try your tip about letting off the gas and see if it works!! Thank you!
Didn't work for my 2014... needed new torque converter and also ended up having to replace a solenoid
Scotty, you should do a video series about what vehicle years you should avoid and what years you should definately get for different vehicles, or at least different makes of vehicles. Because even GM had some good years for vehicles.
I did it, I bought a Honda CR-V 2006 yesterday! I am very impressed with it.
I just bought a 2014 Rav4. It drives great, acceleration is great and cornors great. I wouldn't trade it in for a cr-v to end with transmission problems.
I was just thinking the same
What year are those CRVs with transmission issues?
I had a Rav4 as a loaner vehicle for about a week and it drove and rode great, the AWD system worked really well even in the 10 inches of snow that we luckily got while I had the Rav4, excellent timing to be able to really test the Rav4's AWD system. With the crappy tires installed from the factory I say it did remarkably well. Would I buy one? No, I actually like the Highlander a little better, more room and a V6 which Toyota dropped from the Rav4 a few years ago, but the Highlander does great as well and even more comfortable being a larger car. If I were in the market for a new car I'd be in a Highlander.
That CRV has New Hampshire plates!! Are people driving cross-country to have you fix their cars Scotty!!! LOL
Francobnyc
Probably worth it tbh
@@JSPHTRS If you spend $1000-2000 for the trip, at least you get a vacation out of it. Unlike spending that amount at your local dishonest mechanic and HE gets the vacation.
I’m starting to see license plates from Florida, California here in Houston
He puts those plate on a few cars he's shown - customer privacy I guess :)
@@stefanavic6630 Right in one.
I have a 2010 Rav 4 and I intend to drive it until the wheels fall off just to see how long it really lasts. Currently at 117,000 miles and still runs like new!
I've had a 2013 CRV - 2.2 diesel -EX.. 6 speed manual 4WD for a couple of months & it pulls my caravan like a train.... Best car I've ever had
Looks like crv is all cvt transmission now. Scotty says cvt no bueno!
remogaggi82 Honda makes their own that are pretty good. Jatco are the ones to avoid.
I'd be more scared of that oil dilution issue on the new little turbo 4 earth dreams motors on the newer CRVs that I would be of that cvt
Wrong 1998 was the year Scotty Kilmer Honda CR-V was introduced in 1998 not 1995.
@@terrencebanton9080 He's not far off. 97 for the United States and they were all LX models. They had been in Japan prior so they could have been released in 95 as a 96 model for Japan.
@@terrencebanton9080 production of the JDM 96 CR-V began in 95. USDM CR-V LX was released in 96 for the 97 model year. USDM CR-V EX, and MT were released in 97 for the 98 model year. USDM CR-V SEs were released in 99 for the 2000 model year.
I don't know as much about the EDM models, but I read somewhere that they didn't get them in England until the 98 model year.
I enjoy watching your videos and find them very helpful. I’ve driven and purchased Toyotas since 1979, I have owned many Celicas, Camrys and one Corolla, but have owned Honda as well, I have to be honest I hated my Honda. The Honda to me was much more sluggish and brakes always needs replacing, could not wait to get rid of the Honda, bought a new Toyota.
Thanks for all the great advice Scotty.... since I've been listening to your videos I have repaired my headlights with your recommended headlight restoration kit, changed fluids, cleaned my mass air intake sensor and now I'm going to get some gum out cleaner.
I'm on the same journey!
My crv 2008 has 203k miles and still feels like new it’s crazy
I’ll take an older Rav 4 equipped with the V6 any day over the CRV. Too bad Toyota doesn’t offer them with the V6 anymore, they were actually pretty fast SUVs.
Not sure how it handled, but acceleration-wise, that thing was the sleeper of sleepers among SUV's. Can't even believe they sold it.
Absolutely agree! I'm on my 2nd Honda CRV. I'll never go elsewhere.
Had for a few years, the first generation of the Toyota Rav4 2 doors 5 Mt. I'm looking forward to buy one again. Never had a problem with it.
Scotty, I agree with you. I have a 2007 Honda CRV. I use it to tote my boat. after about 17 years I had the compressor replaced, condenser, the control arms and fixing to have struts done. Great car!!
About 123k miles
I have both cars and they are 4th gen. I agree with Scotty in the most part but I personally prefer my RAV4 over the CRV because its more peppy and rugged. The CRV is primarly used to transport my elderly parents because of the lower ground clearance.
Very likable video. He gets to the point. Gives the good, the bad, and the ugly. And makes it entertaining. Thumbs up.
Have to say though Scotty, my wife and I picked up the 2018 RAV4 and it is the smoothest vehicle I have ever driven, it floats on the road! Very comfortable
I have an 03 5 speed 292,000 miles and its still amazing, I'll never sell it!
I had a 2017 CR-V EX and recently traded for a 2019 RAV-4 XSE. The CR-V is a good vehicle but I am not a fan of that 1.5 turbo engine. Unfortunately, if you want any of the nicer amenities, then you must opt for CR-V models equipped with this engine. By contrast, I love my RAV4 more each day and enjoy it's styling and power. I have no regrets!
I just bought my 2004 CR-V about 3 weeks ago. I was immediately drawn to how spacious the cab is and how it's laid out. Then I drove it and man! These things are actually fun to drive! My daily driver of 100 miles per day in sunny Atlanta has been my 2013 Nissan Rogue. It's just past 250,000 miles and needs some front end work I've got to handle. So I basically just wanted a get me by to drive to work whilst I begin the arduous task of rebuilding the front end. But wow! I never expected it to be as nice as it is. Also a very good looking vehicle as well.
Thank you for all the good tips!
i like Toyota rav4 being high to go over the snow. i seen those CRV,s stuck in the snow here in NYC. Rav4 better.
"Unless you've been eating too many hot dogs and doughnuts"
You're talking about me...
FAT
😶
Scotty, I just found your videos Bro and enjoy listening to your opinions. I just bought a 2011 CRV with 89,000 miles and I love it! It runs great right now but I did not know of the accuator problems. Hopefully, I will not have this problem for a few years.
Thanks- very informative and entertaining👍
It really depends on which exact models you compare too. Toyota made v6 Rav4s from 2006-2012 that were genuinely fast and would definitely outrun the CR-Vs. Toyota also now makes hybrid Rav4s that get awesome gas mileage. The Rav4s tend to be better off-road/in less than ideal driving conditions, and the full size spare tire on the older ones is a big plus for me, and the fact that it's on the rear door opens up more space under the floor boards. The Rav4 was originally intended for active, young people that wanted something more practical for daily driving than a truck that would also fit more stuff and be better off road than a typical sedan/hatch. To me the CR-V was intended more for people that wanted a car that sat up higher, had better visibility, had the cool styling of an SUV, and could fit lots of cargo
"as the old ones went out
they just bought another one
and they were still happy"
i suppose that also applies to that one guy who bought like five chrysler vans because his wife liked them
Wow you are so good at what you do educating the public. I listen to you all the time and wish you understood Medicare the way you understand cars. Thanks for all you know and all you teach us
When test driving both vehicles, the Honda seemed more smooth but when going into the corners it feels like tipping over compared to the RAV4. The RAV4 is just so stiff and every bump you feel no matter how small. Not too mention the CR-V doesn’t have a very flat cargo space when all the seats are put down.
i build honda crvs for a living thanks for the review scotty!
Whereabouts?
@@timothyandrewnielsen Alliston ontario
Which do you think is the best year for the Cr-v for their automatic transmission and all the other issues?
@@staresce yes I need to know too lol
@@staresce 2016
I'ts like I'm moving into a parallel universe where Scotty promoting Honda's now instead of Toyota
Yes! Only because I have one. 2005 Honda CR-V Manual Transmission. 205k miles on the original motor with a recently replaced clutch. I’ve never had an issue with it because of preventative maintenance.
Love my 2012 CR-V and haven't had a single problem with regular maintenance, but I think they started putting CVTs in around 2014.
I get confused if I listen to all your videos when I buy car. I am so confused than before 😀
Same 😂
I am usually a fan of the 2005 to 2006 Honda CR-V's with the EX or EX-L trim and standard 4WD. It has the similar 2.4 L four-cylinder engine with 156 to 160 horsepower and they are both equipped with the five-speed automatic transmission. Those older CR-V's are still on the road as of today and they handle better than a RAV4. I have some close friends that own a 2002 CR-V, but only with the four-speed auto.
Do your friend with the older crv 4 speed auto have that shudder vibration with the transmission?
@@joepearlzz8504 I am not too certain about this.
I have a 2014 Honda crv EX-L with 56,000 miles on it no problems at all change my oil when it get to the miles some people saying they're not reliable but they're are . I grew up around Hondas ,acura, chevys and Toyotas. Honda makes some good reliable vehicles but I love my SUV its very spacious and comfortable.
I love my automatic braking on my 2018 RAV4 Limited. All the bugs were worked out on this particular model. I like to buy vehicles that are "perfected" through years of imperfect design, then updated to perfection. I'll be driving it for another 20 years. CRV's have lots of road noise inside.
Scotty, the 2019 rav4 hybrid is amazing vehicle. Quiet, silky smooth and 40 mpg !
With decents pep (0-60 7.3 seconds) and much improved EAWD in this gen. Does the trick nicely for light offloading and winter driving here in Canada 😀
Me: Scotty mentioned me in his latest video!
Friend: What? When?
Me: 4:04
2012 CRV owner, the only "issues" I've ever had (and I put "issues" in quotations because the car still ran fine, just a tiny bit of noise) were a small axle seal leak, a wheel bearing replaced, and belt tensioner replaced. Never ever stalled, or had anything fail or had anything fall apart. Sometimes the bluetooth connection to my android would be erratic, but that's it.
Love seeing the (old) NH plates!
This is why Toyota is better overall; everything has no weakness. Honda on the other hand has transmission weaknesses. If only Honda could iron out their transmissions, they could be better than Toyota.
Source: Scotty :)
Zoran don't forget oil dilution issues and ac compressor problems
It’s funny if Chevy has a problem with the transmission Scotty says it’s pure junk. If Honda has a transmission issue he says it’s only $3500 to fix it.
SCrobbe this car can still go with this problem. Also, Chevy have problems with their engines. I have a 3 cars, 2014 Chevy Cruze, 2016 Chevy Equinox, and a 2015 Honda CR-V. Both of these Chevys I’ve replaced the engine and transmission. The Honda, which has way more miles than my two Gm products have never had a problem.
Wondering if you could talk about the Honda Pilot vs Toyota Highlander? I appreciate your videos.
2014 CR-V with 2.2 litre turbo diesel - what a dream car, aside from the shuddering locker torque converter, which was resolved with a transmission fluid change and firmware update
The old Rav 4 V6 though is a freaking rocket.
MMC4009 That thing was a sleep all day. My guess is those Ravs were killing Lexus sales of there small SUV.
My sister’s got one of those, and I’m always taken off guard by how quick that thing is, and I drive a 5.7l tundra lol
Which years are you thinking?
@@LukeSimpson
2006 up to I think 2011. Im estimating. The v6 model did the 1/4 mile in under 15.0 easily.
Randy Jackson if you get the hybrid
Honda 2.4! "Honda makes the best engines in the world" - Scotty, 2019
1.5 are garbage. Lack of operating temperature in cooler climates
It's the K series but not Earth Dreams.
Don`t the 2012-2014 Honda Crv and Accord engines have issues ?
@@billwill1337 Not as far as I know. The early 2010s Accord engines sold in Aus are solid
Oddly enough, I drive the same exact car. Same color combo, trim level, and everything. I love my CR-V. Yes they only make the CR-Vs in automatics nowadays at least here in the states. I have seen some of the newer models overseas that are equipped with a manual transmission. Mine is AWD also
Just bought a great running 2005 RAV4, has 120k miles on it and drives like its new. I love it. CRV is great too.
In my experience Toyota is geared more towards comfort and quiet, and Honda more towards road feel and handling, I personally prefer our Camry versus our Accord in everyday driving here in Florida, the Camry is quieter and smoother, both 4cyl engines.
My wife had a Corolla when we started dating and I thought those seats were hard as a rock. I told her to return it (it was a lease). The cr-v I bought is way more comfortable to drive.
@@ST-dd6ny you should compare corolla to civic
What do you think about the 2019 version of the crv vs 2019 RAV4?
Talking about the shudder in the crv trans. I bought instant shudder fix at auto zone $9.00 completely corrected the problem. Just need to be sure the trans is not a CVT. Call Honda w/Vin # to be sure.
My wife's 2012 Honda CR-V AWD never had any torque converter shutter... very smooth. It may have had a reflash from the dealership, however. I am very happy with it for the most part... I just wished it had a 6 speed auto trans since the 5 speed can be really doggish at highway passing speeds. This is something that Honda remediated with their excellent and class leading CVT transmission later on.
Sorry to break it to you but the Rav 4 is much nicer than the CR-V
LOL
I'll take a RAV4 all day long. Don't like driving around worrying about when my transmission is going to fail.
Exactly, I worry more about the transmission, the motor will last a life time if you keep up with the maintenance on it
I had a 2001 crv slush box ...300k+ original engine and tranny and it was driven like a tank Honda's are the only cars I drive without buying breakdown cover
Scotty’s dream vehicles: Honda engines installed into Toyota Camry, Corolla, and/or RAV4 lowered with race suspension..! I’m willing to bet he has engine swapped all of above hiding them behind his garage...lol..! Thanks for the honest videos and not selling out like most do..!
2001 crv 240,000 mi. runs beautifully,,,just drove from Pittsburgh,Pa. to Panama[central america] & back!! not a whimper!!
Scotty you're dead wrong here. My daily is a 1998 RAV4 that's built like a rock. Unlike those CRV POJs.
Is that one of those, "LIVE FREE OR DIE" vintage license plates?
I don't know, I'd probably stick to models made after 2001. There were valve seat problems on certain engines with first generation. It costed a fortune to fix and would happen repeatedly. I think you had to keep adjust valve seat clearance or something like that. Better just to replace those engines. Nice little SUV though, fun to drive.
Hey Scotty, I love your videos and would love to see some on old Dodge trucks. I just bought a 1989 D150 5.2 liter 318 automatic, and want to rebuild it myself. I'm not a mechanic, and need all the help I can get. Thanks bud.
Only 2012 CR-Vs, or does this apply for 2012-now models?
CRV: CVT transmission, turbo, and oil dilution. RAV4 much more reliable long term.
Recent ones? Yeah. He's talking about overall.
I'll take a camry or corolla over the honda.
Their cvt's are really good. Very reliable
Honda's 4 cylinder engine is world renowned.
I'll take a Crv over a Rav 4 any day. I've had mine for over 7 years and zero problems.
I have the 3rd generation 2009. Bought it new and it’s a wonderful reliable ride. The longer you keep a Honda if well maintained and paid off, it will reward you with reliability. I am always sad to say goodbye to my Honda’s because they never let me down. Learn how to do your brakes, fluid changes, tire rotations yourself too and bond with it😎. The only thing that bugs me is that the catalytic cover rusts away earlier than expected, and you only have to use a long hose clamp to keep it closed.
I love my 08 crv one of the best cars I've ever owned just hit 115k on it.only done regular maintenance in 5 yrs since I've owned it.brakes tires battery and fluid changes and that's all in 5 yrs .car runs like a dream.