5 Times Survivor Players Made Underrated Dumb Moves 4.0

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 17 พ.ย. 2024

ความคิดเห็น • 99

  • @RoccoL-se9it
    @RoccoL-se9it ปีที่แล้ว +61

    About Aubry’s vote. One other person who crossed a name out when voting was Carolyn in 44. She crossed out Lauren’s name and wrote Danny. In a podcast with RHAP, Carolyn said that the producers wouldn’t give her a new piece of parchment. I’m assuming that’s what happened with Aubry. I guess Aubry could’ve took more time to scratch it out but idk.

  • @SpanishFly120
    @SpanishFly120 ปีที่แล้ว +83

    I'm glad that the Aubrey thing got talked about. It's crazy thinking how the crossed out name cost her Scott, Julia, and Jason by extension's trust/votes. It goes to show, when you're voting...make sure you're certain before you write a name down.

    • @frida.7831
      @frida.7831 ปีที่แล้ว +14

      It just shows how bad was Scott at the game that he didn't think in FTC about writing Aubrey's name and then crossing it out

    • @uglyaniimals
      @uglyaniimals ปีที่แล้ว +7

      @@frida.7831LMFAO THIS WOULDVE BEEN SO MEAN

    • @gurubishisama
      @gurubishisama ปีที่แล้ว +10

      This is the move that more than anything else lost Aubry the game.

    • @SpanishFly120
      @SpanishFly120 ปีที่แล้ว +4

      @@LanceDa510 Yes, they WERE bitter towards Aubrey. That's because Aubrey made them bitter towards her. Jurors don't start out bitter, somebody makes them that way, and to blame the Jurors for being bitter is deny responsibility to the person who made them bitter. After all, if somebody walked up and punched you in the face, you'd be angry. That's not your fault, it's the fault of the jackass who punched you.

  • @esinger23
    @esinger23 ปีที่แล้ว +128

    I agree that Michaela’s blindside was premature

    • @kingofthorns203
      @kingofthorns203 ปีที่แล้ว +17

      It's one of those moments that is great in isolated context but did nothing to advance the games of anyone involved for the rest of the season except for Hannah

    • @casswashwash1070
      @casswashwash1070 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@kingofthorns203But she wasnt apart of it 😂 so you were tight it did nothing for those involved

  • @nuckertix
    @nuckertix ปีที่แล้ว +32

    michaela’s blind side still pisses me off lmao i love her and to see her go out to a dumb move sucked

    • @noahs5636
      @noahs5636 ปีที่แล้ว +14

      And even worse she just barely missed out on being part of the jury. We were robbed of a Michaela jury speech!

    • @nectaroftheswans
      @nectaroftheswans ปีที่แล้ว

      LITERALLLYYY… I was so pissed

    • @Tuturial464
      @Tuturial464 9 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Don’t make yourself a target then

  • @MoonshineIsis
    @MoonshineIsis ปีที่แล้ว +11

    I know things could always have changed since then, but as for the parchment: Carolyn implied in her medium dive they weren't going to give her another parchment when she crossed out a name.

  • @TheChamp33
    @TheChamp33 ปีที่แล้ว +29

    Next suggestion:
    - Jefra not agreeing with Spencer & Tasha to flip on Tony.
    - Nick not voting out Ben knowing him and Michele would be on the bottom.
    - Danny not listening to Frannie for taking anyone out from the Taki 3 in the Final 8.
    - Erik not playing his immunity idol after Russell played his on the merge vote. I know he was blindsided with huge numbers, but Galu was barely quiet about it and barely anyone talked to him.
    - Karen telling Tom the plan to blindside him & the guys at the Final 7.
    Edit: Instead of the Karen one (since he already did that one), I’ll say Kass voting out Spencer instead of Woo where both Spencer & Tony would’ve taken her to the end if they won or Kass not voting out Spencer before the jury in Cambodia. If she would’ve done that, she would’ve lasted longer for sure that season with having allies on both sides still.

    • @SuperSmithersGalaxy
      @SuperSmithersGalaxy ปีที่แล้ว +1

      I believe he recently talked about Karen and Tom in a recent video, either this same series or the “when players destroyed their game” series.

    • @TheChamp33
      @TheChamp33 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@SuperSmithersGalaxy Thank you for pointing it out because I know it was a video of him saying that, but I didn’t know which one.

    • @kingofthorns203
      @kingofthorns203 ปีที่แล้ว +4

      Ciera ruined her Cambodia game too when she voted out Woo over Spencer.

    • @TheChamp33
      @TheChamp33 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@kingofthorns203 Yeah both of them could be on this list, however, for Ciera’s case, having Savage saying that fake vote is going to be her… that would make anyone not work with him long term so I don’t blame her on that.

    • @frida.7831
      @frida.7831 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      Don't know about the first Kass vote. The only chance she had to win was against Woo.

  • @moonstoone6546
    @moonstoone6546 ปีที่แล้ว +57

    I think an underrated dumb move is just Scot & Jason's mistreatment of Tai. If Scot and Jason maybe, just maybe, treated Tai a little better, they'd have a chance at making it farther in the game. Don't get me wrong, they're losing no matter what happens, but treating Tai with some respect could inch them farther in the game.

    • @lerdog
      @lerdog ปีที่แล้ว +10

      And that ends up being Brad's undoing on S34 too

    • @memeview2566
      @memeview2566 ปีที่แล้ว

      Didn’t Jason get as far as he could?

    • @anonymousperson3023
      @anonymousperson3023 ปีที่แล้ว

      It's not a dumb move though. That's just a misjudgement. If you call that a dumb move, then literally everything would be considered a dumb move

  • @Julian-lz5pd
    @Julian-lz5pd ปีที่แล้ว +28

    THANK YOU for bringing up the Aubry thing. Imo, she lost the game right there. She very clearly painted herself as untrustworthy

    • @Julian-lz5pd
      @Julian-lz5pd ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@LanceDa510 Right but there's a difference between regular Survivor distrust and actively painting yourself as someone who can't/won't make a decision when it's crunch time

  • @NickWuebker
    @NickWuebker ปีที่แล้ว +8

    Peridiam, I got an idea for a series for you. Ethanimale did a similar video on his channel for Big Brother and I think it would be interesting to see you try something similar. How Survivor Winners Could Have Lost. With Ethanimale’s video on this topic, he found the one moment for each Big Brother winner where they could’ve sunk their whole game had it not gone the way it did. I think there are moments like that for each Sole Survivor where the game could’ve immediately gone belly up for them. A couple examples being if Yul doesn’t get Penner to flip in Cook Islands or if Natalie doesn’t get Shambo to flip in Samoa.

  • @XanderMatthews-nv9zf
    @XanderMatthews-nv9zf ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Apparently in Season 28 Cagayan Jefra told Jeremiah before tribal council that she wasn’t willing to flip on her alliance and that he was the target. One of Jeremiah’s allies Spencer had an idol and played it on himself that tribal.
    Had Jeremiah said something and tried to get Spencer to play the idol for him then Woo would have gone and he has a decent chance at getting to the end.

  • @HeelBJC
    @HeelBJC ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Bubba was being CLASSLESS.
    Seriously though, the volume with which Bubba conveys this to Chris while his tribe is standing a foot away from him will never cease to amuse me. And then the confessional after where he says he was "trying to mouth 'merge'" is the kicker.

    • @rafiuddin5360
      @rafiuddin5360 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      It was a soundbite edited in after the fact. He actually mouthed ”merge” very quietly

  • @queenaddi
    @queenaddi ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Carolyn confirmed on RHAP that the producers dont let them get new parchment.

    • @thatguyallen3580
      @thatguyallen3580 ปีที่แล้ว

      That’s super dumb imo, they obviously have tons on hand, and like Peridiam said, what if they just ripped it up into a thousand pieces? They would literally have to give you one, right?

  • @levikatriel
    @levikatriel ปีที่แล้ว +2

    I know you talked about how Cole telling Ben and Lauren about Jess’s advantage was dumb, but so was Jessica using it against Devin, thus guarenteeing that Joe’s idol gets flushed. If she used it on Allen or Ashley then (this would not have happened but Jessica did not know that) maybe Joe would win Devin over and save an idol. This could have prevented the pagonging that season.

  • @HeyMyNameIsJared
    @HeyMyNameIsJared ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Notification squad!
    What a great start to the day. Nothing fills the Survivor off season void like a new Peridiam video

  • @JMoney615
    @JMoney615 ปีที่แล้ว

    Thanks for the content during these dry times.

  • @M3plusYOU
    @M3plusYOU ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Carolyn said they wont give you a new parchment even when she begged

    • @M3plusYOU
      @M3plusYOU ปีที่แล้ว +1

      On her most recent interview with RHAP

    • @kingofthorns203
      @kingofthorns203 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@M3plusYOU Maybe the rules were different prior? Koah Rong was filmed almost ten years ago (if you can believe it)

    • @ashen_roses
      @ashen_roses ปีที่แล้ว

      I can't tell you how angry I am that you're kinda right- it HAS been eight years and a few months

  • @kingoftheh1ll4
    @kingoftheh1ll4 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    A couple more dumb moves I thought of:
    1. S28 when Jefra doesn't flip on Tony after he votes out LJ, instead she sticks with her alliance to vote out Jeremiah and then gets blindsided herself at the next Tribal Council.
    2. I'm not sure if you already covered these, and they're not really underrated, but they are dumb. In S16, both Ozzy and Jason having idols and not playing them, especially Jason. Ozzy was just blindsided, and Jason was on the bottom. He should've played his idol for himself, but he didn't. Also, by extension, Natalie sending him to Exile, and giving him a chance to find the idol was dumb. However, she managed to fix it and blindside him, so props to her.
    3. Again, not sure if you covered this one, but Kass flipping in S28 just because she didn't like Sarah's attitude was really dumb, and effectively screwed her over. She only reached the F3 because she was a goat, but then she got voted out anyways.

  • @SuperSmithersGalaxy
    @SuperSmithersGalaxy ปีที่แล้ว +9

    Aubrey’s vote is so frustrating, because she is definitely an intelligent player, so she should have seen the repercussions coming a mile away. But I suppose she maybe didn’t even think to ask for another parchment in the moment, who knows.

    • @memeview2566
      @memeview2566 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Caryln also did this in 44, and in a podcast she said they wouldn’t give her a new parchment

  • @Fauix
    @Fauix ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Got one for ya in the future, in Second Chance, Spencer trying to jury blackmail Jeremy in front of the jury. According to later interviews, many members of the jury lost a lot of respect for Spencer after that and basically torpedoed his own chance of winning the jury.

  • @Ori_Kohav
    @Ori_Kohav ปีที่แล้ว +14

    Another note about Bubba, and his alliance, sticking to said alliance played horribly against them challenge-wise, since it meant keeping Rory, who was a severe liability to their morale.
    It’s also pretty dumb to base an alliance solely on age.

    • @freddytang2128
      @freddytang2128 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      well they needed 5 people for the first vote. And after the first vote, the alliance of 5 was formed, everyone have incentive to stick to the alliance. If they break the alliance by voting out someone in the 5, everyone else would lose trust and turn on each other, just like what happened to Brad in blood vs water

    • @Ori_Kohav
      @Ori_Kohav ปีที่แล้ว

      @@freddytang2128 the problem with that is they neglected the challenge factor, so they threw themselves into a minority, and were too reliant on cracks in the opposing tribe, on top of guaranteeing that the younger men flip on them. That’s why you shouldn’t rush into alliances so early, especially with clear liabilities.
      That alliance only made sense for Rory and Chris. For Chad, Sarge, and Bubba, it was an idiotic decision.

    • @freddytang2128
      @freddytang2128 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      @@Ori_KohavI think hindsight is very 20/20. Most challenges in Vanuatu were not that physical, to give the women a fair chance. There weren’t any like weight lifting challenge or anything. So it’s hard to say what count as challenge strength. You can easily say a cohesive team is more useful in challenges. Rory screwed up that 4x4 puzzle but aced the slingshot challenge so you can’t say Rory is an obvious challenge liabilith

    • @Ori_Kohav
      @Ori_Kohav ปีที่แล้ว

      @@freddytang2128 except that he is. His constantly negative attitude really hurt the team’s morale. That’s why he became a target in the first place. He’s too hotheaded.
      In fact, the sole reason he was any positive in the slingshot challenge was the coffee he got in the reward. Without coffee, he’s just a negative hothead.
      P. S.
      It’s not about strength. It’s about contribution, which Rory had much less of than the younger men, especially Brady.

    • @XanderMatthews-nv9zf
      @XanderMatthews-nv9zf ปีที่แล้ว

      Brook, Brady and both Johns had already formed the fit 4 so if the far 5 doesn’t form it’s entirely possible Sarge and Chad could get caught in a pre merge wood chipper
      better to enter the merge at a numbers disadvantage than not make the merge at all

  • @tyfraserweeks9216
    @tyfraserweeks9216 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    For Underrated Dumb Moves 5.0 please make the entire video every time Laurel chose not to take out Dom/Wendell during the merge of Ghost Island.

  • @daveferguson4697
    @daveferguson4697 ปีที่แล้ว

    Ciera telling tyson where the jdol was, then flipping to haydens side, and then acting surprised when they couldn’t find an idol the next episode

  • @booshbear
    @booshbear ปีที่แล้ว +1

    and lets remember to THANK Danielle for making that dumb move !

  • @XanderMatthews-nv9zf
    @XanderMatthews-nv9zf ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Season 26 was my first season so I remember a lot of it clearly and the 5th elimination of the season deserves a mention
    So the Fans lost immunity again after Allie and Hope were voted out and Shamar was med-evaced and they’re down to 7 left with a majority of Michael, Matt, Laura, Sherri and Julia with Eddie and Reynold on the outs
    So Matt and Michael decide to vote out Laura in order to try to win more challenges which is dumb on several levels
    1. It leaves both tribe outsiders (Eddie and Reynold)still in the game when they very clearly had no interest in working with the Fans tribe who flip to Corinne and Malcolm at the merge. Reynold doesn’t trust them to flip and burns his idol at this tribal.
    2. It alienates Sherri who has a close relationship with Laura and makes her fell on the outs as well as making Sherri and Julia feel like they’re on the bottom
    3. It is the 5th elimination of the season-you have every reason to assume a swap is coming and you only NOW decide it’s time to win challenges, with an expected 2 more elimination until swaps traditionally happen (final 14) and 2 outsiders with one of them holding an idol and decide to take out the woman that’s in your alliance just cause she doesn’t have muscle.

  • @jag519
    @jag519 ปีที่แล้ว

    Caroly asked for new parchment and was told no

  • @wunjo2166
    @wunjo2166 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    so by Aubry doing that, she lost all the trust Scot and Julia had in her, Scot prolly rallied that with Jason, potentially losing her 3 votes in the final tribal, with those 3 votes, is could have been a 5-2-0 win for her, I don't think that this was the only thing that lost her those 3 votes, but it definitely made it apparent that she was on the opposition to those 3 which I think they based their game off of for the rest of the season making them have resentment. This could be the simplest answer for why Aubry lost by a big majority in the final tribal when she played a really really good game and what I think is the single move that lost her the game.

  • @MrGombaonfire
    @MrGombaonfire ปีที่แล้ว

    I think a really underated dumb move is at the final 7 of nicaragua when benry tried to get the votes on fabio because even if he succeeded he looses an ally anx a potential jury vote and shows that he doesn't really have any loyalties making his next rounds even harder.

  • @Lintu107
    @Lintu107 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    On a long list of terrible allies, Cole is definitely very high up there.

    • @kingofthorns203
      @kingofthorns203 ปีที่แล้ว

      He's really gorgeous though. I'd forgive him quicker than Jessica did...

  • @Quetzal00358
    @Quetzal00358 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Can't wait for Peridiam's 60.0 version of this video until every move in the show's history is covered
    (This is a joke by the way. I love your videos)

  • @dyeager152
    @dyeager152 6 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I wonder if Aubry wrote a curse word would they have to give her a new parchment

  • @jonnysforlife1697
    @jonnysforlife1697 ปีที่แล้ว

    Maybe for the next players that have destroyed their own games and players that have made underrated dumb moves videos, you can include players from Australian Survivor and Survivor South Africa

  • @heatherparisi8250
    @heatherparisi8250 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Hannah really got her revenge on everyone who voted out Michaela lol

  • @Aobyy
    @Aobyy ปีที่แล้ว

    Random video idea but top 5 emotional immunity wins from losing tribes. Inspired from brains tribe finally getting a win in season 28

  • @joshuaclemons2137
    @joshuaclemons2137 ปีที่แล้ว

    I see Jay at my gym every week lol....

  • @Ori_Kohav
    @Ori_Kohav ปีที่แล้ว +4

    I don’t recall if you already mentioned it, but in episode 2 of season 30, Will made a very dumb decision.
    He had 2 options. Either play his part in the split-vote by voting Nina, or side with Nina and Vince by voting Jenn. Instead, he voted Vince, and put himself on the outs of both sides.
    His reason? He didn’t like a certain comment Vince made about him. That clearly shows he has the mental age of a brat. An impulsive decision due to being as sensitive as a sand castle. We’ve seen another such decision from him later on, with Shirin.

  • @maley2552
    @maley2552 ปีที่แล้ว

    Do Jefra not flipping on Tony in Cagayan and Joining Spencer & Tasha. Because wasnt that convo right after or before Tony blindsided LJ?

  • @seekerjaytee1063
    @seekerjaytee1063 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Jay was low-key one of my favorite players ever entertainment wise lol

  • @TJKlimoski
    @TJKlimoski ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Jay deserves a 2nd chance imo. Such a crazy bad move, but would love to see if he understands that mistake and can play better the 2nd time around.

    • @kingofthorns203
      @kingofthorns203 ปีที่แล้ว

      Have you seen him on the Challenge? He's just done ok but I know he did a few upsets at eliminations

  • @XanderMatthews-nv9zf
    @XanderMatthews-nv9zf ปีที่แล้ว

    It’s a very small move but the Final 18 vote of Season 26 where the 6 person majority splits the vote to try to dodge Reynolds’s idol and therefore split the vote on Hope and Eddie? which doesn’t guarantee the idol will be flushed out?
    Which is yknow the like ENTIRE point of splitting the vote
    Like getting rid of the idol is a very pivotal thing to do if you are in the majority and to just willingly pass up the opportunity is nothing short of stupid

  • @ajl9772
    @ajl9772 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Rory was able to do so? I seem to remember him being the first guy voted off at the merge. I think the girls were gonna stick together, but Bubba could have bought himself some more time. He didn't have the social game that Chris had to get himself all the way to the end.
    It was a bad move for Danielle, but not awful. Aras was the only person who could even compete with Terry. Everyone knew Terry making it to the end was game over. Really, it's the next vote that I deem was terrible for both Shane and Danielle. They end up voting for each other when they were the only people they could possibly beat. Danielle lost the game there but was oblivious to that fact.
    Well Jay was aware of the risk. I agree though, it was far too early to do it.
    I hated this move on everyone's part. Cole running his mouth, Ben and Lauren alienating Cole from working with them. Cole again for denying it when it was obvious it was him.
    Carolyn confirmed in a recent interview that you can't get new parchment. She tried when she changed her mind on who she was voting for, but the production made her stick to it. Aubry's downfall started here. All she had to do was black it out completely. If someone asked, she could just say she messed up his name or something. It might sound easy to just tear up the parchment, but I'd be careful to piss off the powers that be lol.

  • @eastonburnor4018
    @eastonburnor4018 ปีที่แล้ว

    Bubba made a mistake but also got very unlucky

  • @itzwakk335
    @itzwakk335 ปีที่แล้ว

    4:53 the final immunity was extremely favorable to the women tho so she probably could have beat him

  • @Dj-bt4yp
    @Dj-bt4yp ปีที่แล้ว

    Is the diamond in ur intro supposed to look like a plumbob from the sims?

  • @goldengrill769
    @goldengrill769 ปีที่แล้ว

    Ami never gets talked about Survivor most pretty girls but she should be.

  • @TheChamp33
    @TheChamp33 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Definitely agree with Danielle, she wasn’t going to beat the rest of the Final 5 possibly including Shane.

  • @funbrain1308
    @funbrain1308 ปีที่แล้ว

    Where is the BB pre-season content....

  • @antoniomarcos2504
    @antoniomarcos2504 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Talking about the DanielleDL case: I agree that was a bad move from Danielle's part but I dont know if it actually leds to a Danielle win very often. Aras goes 6, Shane goes 5. At four terry probably wants to get rid of people who are better in challenges because he wins against anybody in the end. I can see Terry and Courtney voting for Danielle, trying to keep cirie as the weaker in challenges, at this point cirie and danielle could make a tie voting for courtney (which led to a danielle loss but she is forced to do it because otherwise she goes home, cirie obviously wants to take out courtney at this point and reach F2 with danielle)
    So if danielle goes home at 4, i can see terry winning FI or maybe courtney who takes cirie leading to a cirie win, OR courtney out at 4, Danielle takes cirie to the end and loses to her.
    Concluding, probably was better for danielle to go with terry and courtney, but more than likely she loses no matter what, in that scenario neither Terry and Courtney(i believe she had the perception of cirie being weaker in front of the jury than danielle) where incentivized to take danielle to F3 because she was the second best challenge competitor out of the 4

    • @XanderMatthews-nv9zf
      @XanderMatthews-nv9zf ปีที่แล้ว

      Wouldnt they vote Cirie out at F5- the only reason Shane got voted out in the actual season was because of the trio of Aras, Cirie, Danielle and Terry having immunity.
      If Aras is out at 6 then Terry-Courtney-Danielle control the game and Cirie was a way bigger threat than Shane.

    • @antoniomarcos2504
      @antoniomarcos2504 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@XanderMatthews-nv9zf But shane is more capable of winning an immunity. And im not sure Cirie was actually a bigger treat than shane. I can see Shane winning a jury vote over cirie

  • @jewski6852
    @jewski6852 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    The Michaela move was the correct move at the time

  • @soulrichy3311
    @soulrichy3311 ปีที่แล้ว

    i would love to see a list of returning players that didn’t do too bad, but you wish you would’ve seen more from them. players like skupin, gervase, and possibly jenna from S1&S8

  • @bkorth21
    @bkorth21 ปีที่แล้ว

    I love the videos but I do have a suggestion. I would keep any of these series’s to 2 parts. Being a weekly watcher, it gets kind of stale after watching 4 weeks straight worth of the same format and idea. I suggest keeping it to 2 parts.. or to spread apart the episodes.

  • @janetjohnson7279
    @janetjohnson7279 ปีที่แล้ว

    🌻✨✨🌻

  • @brianwilliams766
    @brianwilliams766 8 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Hates the Bx3 season. Their casting of the brains tribe never made sense. It was filled with nothing but crazy and a lack of common sense.

  • @sinisterwolf89
    @sinisterwolf89 ปีที่แล้ว

    Imo Ozzy deserved to win, he was the real survivor. In the real world a tribe would have to value the provider more than the politician. Ozzy was also eliminated due to his reputation in other season he played in. Yul played a great game, there is no denying that. Overall Ozzy was robbed due to his age.