Who will do this? Hawkers & needy customers both are being benefitted by these temporary shops though roads are partially blocked. Moreover some individuals are being benefitted also.
Cause and Effect is again shifting towards leftist politics. You remove the hawkers, you pave the way for the advent of communists hahaa. TMC is digging its grave, bengal has a history of proletariat politics.
@@pumbagaming6342 kisko insult kiya bhai. Isly bolte hai padh likh liya kar har jagha comments me ulta sida na bola kar. Savidhan ke article ke according koi bhi indian bharat ke kisi bhi rajya me rah sakta hai or apna business chala sakta hai jivan yapan kar sakta hai. Samjha unpad kahike .ab dobara bihari bihari mat karna kisi comments me.nahi to kahi phir najar aaya to phir kuch bol duga muh full jayega
Ekbar gariahat theke evacuate kora hoyechhilo... Tader kasba new mkt e rehabilitate kora holo.... Tatey ki holo. Purono jayga natun lokey dokhol kore nilo.... Abar rehabilitate korle abar dokhol hobe.. . Its a Never ending cycle....
Thik hoyech . Sob bairer lok esey zamidari chalache, footpath rasta dokhol kre illegally business krche..ki moja . R amra Kolkata desh bashi hoye amdr sob facilities sob bairer lok niye jache . Kno ? Bihari , BANGLADESHI eisob bairer lok hatao
Khub bhalo koreche,70% dokan guli khotta Maura bhaiyaa der chilo, sudhu rasta bondho Kora na , public er sathe dadagiri o korto ai khotta Maura bhaiyaa guli, jeno suor gulir baba ra eder jomidari diye geche, very nice 👍 job , hat's off to our CM Didi rupi Rani rashmoni ke
@@DebjaniChakravartyogulo oder Baper rasta noy🙂🙂🙂🙂 Kokhono Sondhe belay office chuti hole Hatibagan, New Market -er Rastay gye dekhben..... Protidin manushder ki hal hochche...... Rastata oder Baper noy.... Amra sobai Tax dei Sundor Kolkata dekhar jnno R hmmm ekta kotha boli ... Ami TMC supporter noi..... Amio 1000 takar birodhi..... Kintu valo kaj k obossoi valo bolte sikhun..... 🙂
I am seeing fothpath shop from past 30 years past 30 years they wear poor still they are poor they will be poor upcoming 100 years is better to evacuate all... 😂😂😂😂
DiDi , what is your thoughts about eviction of Raja Bazar , Park Circus , Mallick Bazar etc where majority are your Dudhal Gai Vote Bank I.s. Encouragement by Dudhal Gai ?
Didi thik order diyeche. Gota kolkata jure didir Vai ra taka niye abangali der, bihari der footpath a dokaner byabsa koriye didir e kabor toiri karar byabostha koreche.
Eviction in fronts of Grand-Oberoi Hotel foot paths, New Empire cinema hall (1969 Shamta Prasad, Chirodiner) front, around New Stuart Hogg Market, Sealdah Prachi hall-Loreto School front (Dui bon; in the '80's I remember buying texts from Sealdah footpath hawkers, like Krishna Chandra's Gopal Bhar & Tabla-r darpan),...must be evicted, and IF possible, some place for them to continue business for their family rozi-roti! Don't bulldoze / bargain here, Didi. There was Sealdah, now my Maa is dead, me an orphan.😢
TMC's encroachment into hawkers' shops and businesses isn't a good sign given the history of leftist politics in West Bengal. If such encroachments are unplanned, unorganised and arbitrary without taking into conginsance the rights of hawkers, their grievances will find expression in movements led by leftists in west bengal. If they are being removed without a proper plan being formulated for their rehabilitation or providing them with some alternate source of employment, they will development look for those parties who that are quite vocal regarding working class rights. This is indeed a legacy or a continuation of 34 year long era of marxist politics in Bengal and that's why only CPIM could replace TMC in near future. TMC should focus on providing these evicted persons with some other source of employment or attract more investment in private sector else a proletariat movement is awaiting Bengal. This change in status quo doesn't seem favourable or promising.😂
It reflects desperate situation , failure to deliver, total failure of governance. She should be ashamed and resign. Failue of everything and just blame center is not good enough though center has a role to play. The huge cost of election is a heavy burdon on people and without acccountablity these election in India has a meaning that is licence to misgovern, corruption. Why public must carry the burdon of huge number of parasites ? We would rather be happy with different system like ancient Indian monarchy. So call democracy must go ,need an elected king like king Gopala of Pala dynasty .
Please provide them on the centre of J.N.Road that would be best solution.Do you they will agree to shift or rehabilated ?Di you think they are poor people?Do you thing they are sun of this soil?Tax payer,then no body has any right to encroach pavement.
Hawkers ,specially in Newmarket , Gariahat,hatibagan etc are not poor. Rather they are richer than shop owner. All illegal hawker should be evicted. No alternative arrangements to be made.
"The only way forward, if we are going to improve the quality of the environment is to get everybody involved.' - Richard Rogers "Social security faces financial problems down to road because of demographics.' - John S Tanner.
This is a right and strong step, otherwise ENTIRE BENGAL , MAIN TRADING CITY AND FOOTPATH HAS ALREADY ENCROACHED....KOLKATA, HOWRAH, KHARAGPUR,HALDIA, DURGAPUR, SILIGURI, ASANSOLE, BARAKPUR, ...ENTIRE MARKET CAPTURED BY BIHARI,....OUR YOUTH IS PORIJAYEE...PRABASI..JAGO BANGALI.
শিয়ালদহ স্টেশনের চারপাশটা আগে খালি করা প্রয়োজন
হাঁটা যায় না একদম😢
Tik
Park circus
Sealdah area te to 90 % bihari r jharkhandi footpath dakhol kore bose ache.
Who will do this?
Hawkers & needy customers both are being benefitted by these temporary shops though roads are partially blocked.
Moreover some individuals are being benefitted also.
Good work
আমি Gariahat এ থাকি , এই দেখে অবস্থ হয়ে গেছি 😅😅😅😅😅
Khub sundor bolechhen sobai.
Cause & Effect. If the Cause ( Unemployment) is not removed, Effect (Unauthorised Shops) cannot be wiped out.
Cause and Effect is again shifting towards leftist politics.
You remove the hawkers, you pave the way for the advent of communists hahaa.
TMC is digging its grave, bengal has a history of proletariat politics.
জন্ম নিয়ন্ত্রণ দরকার
Etodine ekta darun kaj korchhen CM . Kolkata-,ke Hawker city bale keu keu . Bedakhal footpath ager abasthay pele manush khushi habe. How. Stn -er entrance kabe hawker- mukta habe ?
CPIM k vote debe ora chaap nis na aabar cpim aasbe
পিলপিলে জনসংখ্যা হলে এই হবে
Good Kolkata
Next action must be taken against illegal toto.
Kolkata ta puro Bihari te bhore gache. Howrah ta bihar
And ROHINGIYAS?????
evar SAB BHAGABE BIHAR JHETIYE
@@preeteshkumarbanerji2943central army ki korche jodi ato rohinga chole asche ???
@@Dkkahar-e2z : Yehi problem hai tum log ka. Tum jaha jate ho ..unko insult karte ho.
@@pumbagaming6342 kisko insult kiya bhai. Isly bolte hai padh likh liya kar har jagha comments me ulta sida na bola kar. Savidhan ke article ke according koi bhi indian bharat ke kisi bhi rajya me rah sakta hai or apna business chala sakta hai jivan yapan kar sakta hai. Samjha unpad kahike .ab dobara bihari bihari mat karna kisi comments me.nahi to kahi phir najar aaya to phir kuch bol duga muh full jayega
Ekbar gariahat theke evacuate kora hoyechhilo... Tader kasba new mkt e rehabilitate kora holo.... Tatey ki holo.
Purono jayga natun lokey dokhol kore nilo.... Abar rehabilitate korle abar dokhol hobe..
. Its a Never ending cycle....
good decision
Footpath jano hawkerder babar sampotti...foot pathe cholte daina pothikder...footpath theke naamiye dai pothikder...
Howrah bridge and bagri market a action nin
❤
SAFE PUBLIC FOOTPATH WAKING
eto dine state government khub valo kaj korche
Thik hoyech . Sob bairer lok esey zamidari chalache, footpath rasta dokhol kre illegally business krche..ki moja . R amra Kolkata desh bashi hoye amdr sob facilities sob bairer lok niye jache . Kno ? Bihari , BANGLADESHI eisob bairer lok hatao
Sob natok.
Akdom thik. Onno state theke ese nijeke hero bhabhe. Narendra Modi ji nd Mamta didi jindabad. ❤
Ar amra je onno state e giye kaj korchi tar ki hobe?didi ke bolun age bangladeshi ar rohingya muslim der tarate.taholei everything will be fine.
Khub bhalo koreche,70% dokan guli khotta Maura bhaiyaa der chilo, sudhu rasta bondho Kora na , public er sathe dadagiri o korto ai khotta Maura bhaiyaa guli, jeno suor gulir baba ra eder jomidari diye geche, very nice 👍 job , hat's off to our CM Didi rupi Rani rashmoni ke
এইরকম অবৈধ দখলদারদের উচ্ছেদ রাজ্যের সর্বত্র হওয়া দরকার তবেই প্রশাসনের উপর আস্থা জম্মাবে।
নির্দিষ্ট কিছু জায়গায় হলে প্রকৃত সমস্যার সমাধান হবে না।
এটা আরও আগে করলে ভাল হত। যাই হোক এখনও ভাল হয়েছে।
Bhogoban koruk khub taratari apnar ba apnar husband er job cholay jak, or whatever unemployed hoi bati hatay 1000 taka jothashto
@@DebjaniChakravartyogulo oder Baper rasta noy🙂🙂🙂🙂
Kokhono Sondhe belay office chuti hole Hatibagan, New Market -er Rastay gye dekhben..... Protidin manushder ki hal hochche...... Rastata oder Baper noy.... Amra sobai Tax dei Sundor Kolkata dekhar jnno
R hmmm ekta kotha boli ... Ami TMC supporter noi..... Amio 1000 takar birodhi..... Kintu valo kaj k obossoi valo bolte sikhun..... 🙂
Right decision
Very happy..
Plz bihari bhagao
Bihari bhagao cholte paare kintu bihar theke bangali hotale ki hobe? Lokko lokko bangali porijayi sramik,tader hotale ki hobe?
Aami bihari 😢😢😢😢
@@pramit7745 lokko lokko bengali porijaye sramik hoye bihar punjab rajasthan e kaaj korche, bihari tarale bihar bangali tarabe,takan ki hobe? Ta chara,amra shobai indian kono difference nei, ami chaina kono illegal bangadeshi ekhane ashe buisneds koruk.
এটা হচ্ছে হিন্দু হকার উচ্ছেদ, যেই খিদিরপুর, মেটিয়াবুরুজ, এন্টালী, পার্কসার্কাসের কথা উঠলো অমনি টুক করে উচ্ছেদ অভিযান শেষ।
Chokh khule dekh Sob Jaigai Bulldozer cholche Jaatpaat Nirbiseshe, Eta Bangla, Gutkaland na
Thik bolechen eder muslim der uchhed korar khomota nei
SABAI KE VAGAO HINDU BA MUSLIM JEI ZABORDOKHOL KORECHE ABAR SURU HOBE
@@Sonarpura-BSB আপনাকে কে খবর দিলো? কোন কোন মুসলিম এলাকাতে উচ্ছেদ হয়েছে, বলুন দেখি?
এখানে হিন্দু-মুসলিমের প্রশ্ন আসে না অবৈধভাবে যে দখল করবে তাকে উঠে যেতে হবে
ঠিক করেছে সরকার. 😂😂 ভোটের আগে 500 বাড়িয়ে দিলেই এরা শান্ত হয়ে যাবে... 😂😂 খুব ভালো পদক্ষেপ সরকারের
Right decision by Government. 👍
উচ্ছেদ নয়, অগোছালো হকারদের নির্দিষ্ট জায়গায় গুছিয়ে বসার ব্যবস্থা।
Khub vlo decision neyechilo. Voy peye pichiye gelo
Bihari hotau bangla bachao
Rajabazar jaa toke hatiye debe
Ato soja bhai hatao
@@avishekshaw6448shob hoyche ebar aroo hotbe dekte thak😁 bar bar bjp ke vote diye mowja?? Bare bare gughu gughu tumi kheye jao dhan.
@@zyan786 bhai bjp te atu voye kano
Isly bolte hai thora padh likh liya kar or jakar article ke bare me pada le.humesa unpad hi rahega 😂
সরকারের জায়গা ছেড়ে দেওয়া হোক সরকারি জায়গা নেওয়া হবে না মা মাটি মানুষ জিন্দাবাদ মমতা ব্যানার্জি জিন্দাবাদ
সাদা শাড়ির চক্রান্ত ও নাটক বাজী 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Metiabruz,rajabazar kobe faka hobe ????
Thik koreche
মানুষ সুযোগ সন্ধানী l
যতই দেবে ততই নেবে l
রাস্তা বুজে রোজগার ????
এটা কলকাতার মার্কেট
কটা বাঙালি ব্যবসায়ী দেখলাম কে জানে
Right decision didi jindabad
Haan bhai park circus station khubi jaam 😢
This was very much needed. Hawkers think that roads and footpaths are their property. We need cleaner roads and empty footpaths.
Buro kakur matha kharab hoy ga6 bol6 central theke order as6 😂😂 central theke CAA NRC asle sei somay astay andolan koren mosai 😂
Sahi ha foothpath me Chalna mushkil Hogya ha
I am seeing fothpath shop from past 30 years past 30 years they wear poor still they are poor they will be poor upcoming 100 years is better to evacuate all... 😂😂😂😂
Traffic movement improve korun. Private bus bishon slow chole commission khawar jonno. State transport chai Delhi Bombay er moto
হকার উচ্ছেদ নয় হিন্দু উচ্ছেদ হচ্ছে বোঝা দায়।
ঠিক বলেছেন
DiDi , what is your thoughts about eviction of Raja Bazar , Park Circus , Mallick Bazar etc where majority are your Dudhal Gai Vote Bank I.s. Encouragement by Dudhal Gai ?
ei sob jayga gulo west bengal e pore na.....mongol grohe pore
Right decision 👍
98 % bihari, rajasthani, jharkhandi, marwari. Keu gorib byabsayi noy. Sab abangali byabsayi bangali der takar jor a soriye boseche. Sab tolo. Bsngali bachao.
Only educated person new Gen will understand this .....very bad step from #mamta_Banerjee shame on this typ of mentality
Ami Kolkata Basi Hisabe Bolchi Hawker Der Theke Tola Nito To Police Ta Hole Thana Gulo Buldozar Dite Guriya Dik
Ai san মানুষটা বেআইনি ভাবে বসলে কি নিজের হয়েযায়
hoeche bhalo....kintu pujor agei to abar sob fire asbe....jodi na fire ase tokhon bojjha jabe.
Didi thik order diyeche. Gota kolkata jure didir Vai ra taka niye abangali der, bihari der footpath a dokaner byabsa koriye didir e kabor toiri karar byabostha koreche.
Airport 1 no. মসজিদ সংলগ্ন ফুটপাথ সংলগ্ন এলাকা কী হবে!!!
90 % Bihar and UP se aya vagao eder k onlu bangali business korbe
ছোট করে বসা যাবে না আবার পরে বাড়ি নিবে একদম পরিষ্কার চাই
যে সব ভায়েরা হপ্তা তুলে পেট চালাত তাদের কি হবে?😂😂
Unregistered business Ara r jara registered a6e tader thake besi kama6e
Kitna..din..chalega.eisa..busines.koi.na..koi..sarkar..ayega..tutna.hi.
Eviction in fronts of Grand-Oberoi Hotel foot paths, New Empire cinema hall (1969 Shamta Prasad, Chirodiner) front, around New Stuart Hogg Market, Sealdah Prachi hall-Loreto School front (Dui bon; in the '80's I remember buying texts from Sealdah footpath hawkers, like Krishna Chandra's Gopal Bhar & Tabla-r darpan),...must be evicted, and IF possible, some place for them to continue business for their family rozi-roti! Don't bulldoze / bargain here, Didi. There was Sealdah, now my Maa is dead, me an orphan.😢
Raja bazar aar park circus ta bishesh jagai. Keno nei kono eviction
TMC's encroachment into hawkers' shops and businesses isn't a good sign given the history of leftist politics in West Bengal. If such encroachments are unplanned, unorganised and arbitrary without taking into conginsance the rights of hawkers, their grievances will find expression in movements led by leftists in west bengal.
If they are being removed without a proper plan being formulated for their rehabilitation or providing them with some alternate source of employment, they will development look for those parties who that are quite vocal regarding working class rights.
This is indeed a legacy or a continuation of 34 year long era of marxist politics in Bengal and that's why only CPIM could replace TMC in near future.
TMC should focus on providing these evicted persons with some other source of employment or attract more investment in private sector else a proletariat movement is awaiting Bengal.
This change in status quo doesn't seem favourable or promising.😂
It reflects desperate situation , failure to deliver, total failure of governance. She should be ashamed and resign. Failue of everything and just blame center is not good enough though center has a role to play. The huge cost of election is a heavy burdon on people and without acccountablity these election in India has a meaning that is licence to misgovern, corruption. Why public must carry the burdon of huge number of parasites ? We would rather be happy with different system like ancient Indian monarchy. So call democracy must go ,need an elected king like king Gopala of Pala dynasty .
More jak hawker tao footpath e bosa cholbe na
Thik korche hocker sorao city clear and clean koro
Please provide them on the centre of J.N.Road that would be best solution.Do you they will agree to shift or rehabilated ?Di you think they are poor people?Do you thing they are sun of this soil?Tax payer,then no body has any right to encroach pavement.
Hawkers ,specially in Newmarket , Gariahat,hatibagan etc are not poor. Rather they are richer than shop owner.
All illegal hawker should be evicted. No alternative arrangements to be made.
Bihar thke esecho , bihar e fherot jao 😂😂
Need one team for take care about road clean and clearance.
खिदिरपुर में भी ऐसा होना चाहिए❤
Howrah station premises
Also
Entire premises ate occupied by vendor
সব জায়গায় ই করা দরকার এবং এই অভিজানটা চালিয়ে যেতে হবে থামলে চলবেনা
সব জায়গায় হচ্ছে না তো।
ফুটপাতে ব্যবসা করতে কে অনুমতি দিয়েছে এদেরকে?
Momota didi er
Lok ra,,, katmani khaye footpath ea bujness korte diache
শিয়ালদা স্টেশন কালিপুরা হোক যাই হোক এটা আগেই করা উচিত ছিল এখন খুব ভালো লাগছে মা মাটি মানুষ জিন্দাবাদ মমতা ব্যানার্জি জিন্দাবাদ
Good❤❤
Black shirt wala ladhka bht Accha baat bola hai
সঠিক সিদ্ধান্ত
Kothay jabi manea behar chola jabi
Khidderpore rajabazaar topsia metribruz ei no action 😂
Besh hoyexhe
"The only way forward, if
we are going to improve
the quality of the
environment is to get
everybody involved.'
- Richard Rogers
"Social security faces
financial problems down
to road because of
demographics.'
- John S Tanner.
Abar dokan dar dadara mal gulo dokaner vitore rakhte vabe barandai nay ?
140 koti lok , 50 buchar pora 300 koti lok hoba,
DiDi , What is your thoughts about evictions of Hokar as a CM of Trinamool Congress ?
Hokar tule dau mamunira hele dule jabe kata bara khujcte
Business allready dull dekha diyeche.
অভাগা যেদিকে যায় সাগর শুকাইয়া যায় 😢
Joy bangla
Joy bangla
Bihari hotao
Bihari hotao
This is a right and strong step, otherwise ENTIRE BENGAL , MAIN TRADING CITY AND FOOTPATH HAS ALREADY ENCROACHED....KOLKATA, HOWRAH, KHARAGPUR,HALDIA, DURGAPUR, SILIGURI, ASANSOLE, BARAKPUR, ...ENTIRE MARKET CAPTURED BY BIHARI,....OUR YOUTH IS PORIJAYEE...PRABASI..JAGO BANGALI.
"In a country well governed,
poverty is something to
ashamed of.
In a country badly
governed, wealth is
something to be ashamed
of."
- Confucious.
Ek doo din
দেখে খুব ভালো লাগলো ধন্যবাদ
Bihari hatao
bondo kano holo RESTART AGAIN
Mamata hye hye hye hye 😂😂
What do the people of Kolkata... illegal is illegal.
এটা নিউমার্কেট না এখানে বাঙালিরা মার্কেট করতে গেলে বাঙ্গালীদের হেনস্থা করা হয় হিন্দি ভাষাতে এখন কি হলো হিন্দি কথা কেন কোথায় খুব তাড়াতাড়ি
Now i will vote to TMC ❤
😅