agreed wheein has finesse to her technique.. solar's vocals are more powerful she can hit them notes on command. but in queendom tho, when they sang i miss you..it was refreshing to hear a composed Solar.. her vocal runs and texture..so smooth as silk
@@liamseravali2291 Wheein has the best technique. Solar forces the high notes too hard sometimes. It is better now but you can hear how she strained the notes a lot when the group was younger
@@Faeriiexx if you say that in the beginning Wheein was the best, i agree. But now, she Isn't. Solar get 90% of the high parts when Wheein can go higher. Why? Because Solar TODAY has the best technique. I think you are confusing strainig with supporting. Because Solar clearly don't support some notes she do but her technique is CLEARLY good enough to not strain that.
And even then they’re incomparable since Wheein has a beautiful clear voice with really good nuanced technique not only in her (very strong) belting but also in her superbly controlled head voice and (possibly?) whistle notes while Solar has amazing power in her belt to really round out their sound and give an extra oomph to the climaxes of the song AND BOTH ARE AMAZING IN DIFFERENT WAYS.
Aaaaand this is why we don't have a Main and Lead Vocalist in Mamamoo. They're literally on par with each other and talent just oozes outta both of them! The *only* difference is their techniques and actual vocal colors.
@@rebsmind8973 that's a common misconception actually, but Mamamoo truly don't have Main and Lead titles. Officially their positions are Solar: Leader, Vocal Moonbyul: Rap, Performance Wheein: Vocal, Performance Hwasa: Rap, Vocal This is how they debuted, and they still occasionally use it for intros. But no, Solar is the Leader, but not the main vocal🤷🏻.
so true... there are more accomplished main vocalists like eunji who have wider range but no one belts with the volume and force of yong...wheein is my fave kpop vocalists so yah Moomoos still win 🤣
If we're talking pure technique, solar sounds like she's pushing her chest voice up to belt the higher notes, which gives them more weight and power but also sounds more strained. wheein, on the other hand, is a lot more connected between her chest/mix/head, so the higher notes sound lighter, cleaner, and free. different techniques for different purposes. wheein has the upper hand from a classical standpoint, but they're both still killer vocals.
Rosh Lepz Wheein’s vocals in a technical stand point are actually better, so it gives her the upper hand. They are both phenomenal vocalists, with only minor things to touch on. Wheein is amazing as it it, as is Solar.
@Nehal Imran this was 2 months ago but ok So what i meant is Wheein's voice is higher in terms of hitting notes. This called tessitura or natural range of someone's voice. Wheein hit high notes easily from Solar because Wheein's voice range NATURALLY higher than Solar in terms of HITTING notes. I don't if u understand what i say but yeah its okay if u don't get it
The good thing is that we do not have to choose between them, because they are part of the group MAMAMOO, which is extraordinary because it is composed of four singers whose voices and interpretations are extraordinary. The tone and versatility of the voices of these four talented singers completes in a perfect way. Interpretations are simply unforgettable. I love MAMAMOO
Solar is my bias but Wheein’s voice is my favorite it’s so fluid and effortless and while she can’t belt as wide and clear as Solar, Solar can’t give the same effect that Wheein does in a ballad. She’s my favorite female voice in kpop
the reason why Solar's in charge of the high notes was because her voice is so powerful, it doesn't lose power even when she hit those high notes. they both are great tho.
@@kingjimin9165 we don’t accept ot1 stan in our fandom. no one says who’s better overall. they have their own specialty. Yong’s better at belting, Whee’s better at whistle. go cry about it.
My bias is solar I had heard them sing live a few times. Tbh wheein was born with a better voice, which will make u feel so relaxed. Like so many artist had said, wheein has very good and unique vocal. While solars vocal is very great too. But apparently, she made a lot of hard works to be able to sing the high keys and so. Its obvious that wheein can sing the high and low key more comfortable than solar. Hence, they both have good vocals, but wheeins is slightly better:) Anyways,i really appreciate solar. She is literally the most hard working, who practice the most among the 4.
It's also because Wheein started singing when she was still young while Yong only started improving her vocals during her 20s but still both of them have their own vocal colors
Wheein is just a natural born singer. Her pitch and ability to manipulate her voice is amazing. But Solar has such a strong voice. And I can tell that Solar has worked really hard to get to where she is now. Both are extremely talented. Two of the best female singers in kpop.
btw, in 2020 1TheK made a top 5 female vocalists in general(not just kpop vocalists). Wheein is 3rd and is the only Kpop idol in the list. powerful belts aren't what make a singer good.
Wheein is more like the RNB style, the control and agility is effortlessly the best. While Solar has this huge range and sustainability, she's a tough singer. All in all, I love them both.😍
I kind of find this funny. Lol comparing them is like comparing gold with another gold but are different in form. Solar is usually belting high notes because she has a very powerful and strong vocals which is more good and impactful in belting high notes. While Wheein is more on falsetto and breathy like AG and when she hits high notes, it's heavenly but you know, powerful and strong is more suitable for belting higher notes. Solar's voice can be soft and sweet but she is more expert on belting high notes. Wheein's voice is breathy and is more expert in soft and honey-like voice. But as a vocalist, tbh, Wheein is more versatile that's why she is known as the vocal backbone. She can go from low to high notes in a second and she can be breathy and soft and then make her voice firm and strong in a second as well. Even Solar and their CEO accepts the fact that she is a very good singer. And once, solar once said that if they were a hamburger, Wheein would be the meat. She is said to be the member who can harmonize very well to all the voices of the three members so of you listen carefully to their songs, usually, her voice is the backing voice to harmonize the sounds. And don't forget the "dolphin note", she did that. Solar? No words is needed since she is well recognized by many in public while Wheein is underrated compared to her... BOTH ARE GOOD AND BOTH ARE THE BEST ON THEIR OWN EXPERTISE.
unfortunately the casual listener thinks that powerful belt = best vocalist overall. in 2020 1TheK made a top 5 female vocalists in general(not just kpop vocalists). Wheein is 3rd and is the only Kpop idol in the list. powerful belts aren't what make a singer good.
Solar is a full healthy belter not everything is about mix voice, solar has a well balanced mix voice as wheein in the upper belts, she's just a power based singer and her mix is perfect reminds me of whitney's
in a span of 7 years, Solar was able to work her way up from being a weak vocalist, to becoming one of the country’s best. imagine the talent we would’ve lost had she continued with being a flight attendant
If you listen well. You'll probably choose those two. They both have their own way of singing highnotes. 💓 i love them both. 💓 but wheein's high pitched voice was always giving me chills. 💓 I love angel line 😳 I love my yongsun 💞 but my wheein is now in my heart 💕 MAMAMOO FOREVER 😭💓
So Solar has more power--no surprise there. That's why she's the Main Singer in Mamamoo. That doesn't mean that some people don't prefer the quality of Wheein's voice (I'm one of those people). Besides, Wheein's epic dimple makes it an easy call for me to choose a bias! Both Solar and Wheein are half of the reason Mamamoo is the coolest group ever!
Solar is not main singer, she's vocals and leader Wheein is vocals and performance Hwasa is vocals and rap Moonbyul is rapper and performance But that's their debut. We all know that should change to all 4 of them being vocals, visuals, rappers, and performers
overall > power belts. Wheein is wanted more from other singers to make feats/colabs. she's 1 of the most wanted in Kpop. when Park Bom from 2ne1 listened Mamamoo, she wanted Wheein to appear as a feat in her solo song(Wheein only sing 1 verse cause it was solo song for Park Bom and added Wheein as feat the last minute). she didn't choose Solar but Wheein. btw, Wheein has won 2-3 times in Duet Festival, and the 1st time was in 2015 and with rapper partner. Solar hasn't won.
@@SapiaNt0mata Don't bring Solar down like that. My bias is Wheein but Solar is successful in her own ways. Both Wheein and Solar are extremely talented even if their vocal techniques are different.
@@krovae1521 look what the op said "So Solar has more power--no surprise there. That's why she's the Main Singer in Mamamoo" when you say that someone is the main singer it means that the others are inferior since they're not main. my comment is made to match the original comment. if it wasn't like this i wouldn't reply as i did.
i think solar sings like those soul singers when she belts - strong and powerful; while WheeIn belts like a pop singer - soft and angelic. Both beautiful and complement each other
Just saying that wheein effortlessly belted a whistle note in 'woo hoo'. I think Wheein has the better voice, but who are we kidding its mamamoo. They all are so fucking talented!
Wheein’s high notes definitely sound more effortless and free, where as Solar’s contain more power and they come swinging in heavier. They are both fantastic singers, part of the same group. I love all four of these MAMAMOO girls
@@moonlightespt3818 Not from what I hear. Solar’s high notes aren’t as loose or have the ability to be agile. Wheein’s are from my standpoint. Their high notes are both great. Maybe we are just hearing different things.
@@1Love2Live3Laugh You have heard wrong, solar high notes are more open/resonant/full, wheein is a more agile singer? I agree but what does that have to do with their belting technique? Solar is the most expanded belter she's a power based vocalist while wheein is a r&b ballad type of style
@@moonlightespt3818 I said nothing about technique? I never said anything about who the better belter was. From what I am hearing, Solar’s high belting notes just sound heavier. That’s not a bad thing, I love the sound of her belts. And they can definitely be resonant and they are great. Wheein’s sound less restrained and as if she can do anything with them, like they have room to run and go anywhere. That’s why I brought up the agility. This is my opinion, based on this video. You’re not going to change my mind on this.
@@1Love2Live3Laugh Yes you did about their high belts technique, Solar's high belting sounds full/rounded/rich/more open and resonant, wheein's sound is not less strained cause solar doesn't strain neither does wheein, wheein's belts are not like that neither, she's indeed an agile singer but i rarely have seen complex runs/transitions from her belting, i clarified why your statement/info was wrong, you can have your opinion but what i said it's a fact you can't change that
Wheein is technically better, naturally gifted, feels the music and adjusts as to not strain her voice. Solar is naturally gifted to but utilizes a different technique that isn’t always good for her voice. Both are great vocalists, but my fav is Wheein.
They cannot be compared! If you take out 1 of the 2 from Mamamoo, no other singers could fill the gap. That's how 'destiny' brought them together and formed the best vocal group of all time in Kpop. There may be 5 Ailee in one group but the harmony and artistry that Mamamoo have will be second to none.
Both are good. I really enjoy Solar's belts up to C#5, despite the pushing. Above that I prefer Wheein, her tone is nicer and she sounds much less strained.
solar worked hard so she could hit those high notes, while wheein was gifted. Solar has the power and wheein is like a calming wind that blows in a cold morning. They compliment each other well, thats why MAMAMOO stans are the winners here.
for someone like Wheein it's easy to get more power in belts. all she has to do is open her mouth more. make a scream with closer mouth, and then open your mouth as much as you can and see how louder your scream is. the same applies to singing.
fr me...................both hhahahaXD 1- their voice color diff. 2-their both technique diff. 3-their powerful voice also diff. 4-their way hit the note also diff. 5-and the sound get produced also different. thats why i choose both bcs they both angel line slay it together hehehe.. #i just state a fact tho~
This is why MAMAMOO won't be replace with any groups. I mean... just listen to that pure unique powerful voice. No wonder they are the Angel Line. Now YOU KNOW.
They both have lovely voices and great skills. Let’s talk about technique. From a singer’s point of view (having sung with choral groups from 4-250 members, sometimes with a symphony) I humbly share: First of all, reaching high notes takes regular practice and relaxing both mind and body. The more you relax your entire body, especially your neck, face, lips, jaw, throat, chest, shoulders, the easier air will flow for vocal cord manipuation. They both do this most of the time... until they reach a certain point where they no longer relax. Where Wheein succeeds more is in controlling power (as in force of air flow plus volume) - this is harder to achieve than full blast power. Solar’s voice can strain and distort when various muscles tense up at higher registers, though this can also happen with Wheein. The struggle starts with not warming up the vocal cords enough (it happens sometimes), eating junk food and drinking soda, milk and/or caffeine before a performance (which we’ve seen them do on MMTV), not getting enough rest (sigh), then allowing self-doubt or nervousness result in tension in the body that affects singing. They can hit those notes, but they worry about it. Solar has shown this worry when she joked about high notes in Queendom. No worries lead to more relaxed body and singing. If you have ever played drums you’ll know what I mean about power and control. It’s harder to hit a snare drum with much less force yet still be heard distinctly, like in jazz drumming style. Being able to do so also requires alot of practice. My wish for Solar is that she learns to control her power and volume and to relax more at higher registers. She’s certainly capable and just needs to be consistent.
My opinion is that both can hit very high notes. But as for Wheein, her voice is really special, so she often gets more lines. Solar, in the other hand, has less lines and therefore can store energy to be unleashed in high notes. At the same time, Hwasa's voice is very suitable to wash or wake your ears before they start their songs, so she is often tasked to be the first one to sing. Last but not least, Moonbyul is so cool in her rap and dance and therefore she's the performance damdang in the group. I love the fact that after a few years since their debut, there is no real fixed position for them in the group. They have grown to be able to change their roles among themselves, in case if the particular song suits someone more.
Solar’s notes are more powerful and full/whole and consistent, while wheein is more light and thin, that’s why wheein is more soulful when singing ballad, while solar is more emotional when singing ballad. Both vacals are stable and skilled.
I appreciate anyone with techinical background in music to "educate" people on the Internet. Just please don't forget it needs more effort to deliver knowledge to people with different background and preferences. In my humble opinion after following many discussions, thinking techniques is objective or undisputable is also a part of these arguments as I see vocal coaches following different pedagogies give inconsistent opinions and preferences. Then, there are too many aspects in terms of techniques and how to give scores and weights of them and calculate an overall number to judge who is better itself is a big challenge, not to say to convince eveyone. A lot of technical terms defined in music are not as well-defined as in physical science about measurements with quantifiable units, and most of the time are related to senses, which are different from person to person. Another situation is that the instrument of each singer or the ear/brain of an audience is unique. Using the same technique requires different efforts for differnt singers so sometimes better control seems to be more fair in some situactions. An angelic voice described by an audience might not sound the same for another one since different persons have different angels in their mind. For example, Solar's voice is my ultimate bias and it really takes time for me to appreicate others' voices but their harmony are something else that I love the most. So, I found it hard to understand people saying Solar is shouting or pushing or straining as they all sound angelic, warm, sweet, and like honey in my ears and beg her to yell at me more (I am a normal pervert as Solar 🤣) For me, her techniques are the best as I feel more connected to them since she can easily manuplate my emotion to make me laugh 😆or make me cry 😭. Now, almost in the end of 2021, hope eveyone who loves Mamamoo to continue to support them and wish one day they can literally start a world tour and visit international moomoos again.
I love when solar belts, it gives me goosebumps all over every time, but I love the sound of wheein's voice when she just sings, not necessarily high notes, so both
WheeIn is clearer and Solar is manlier in general. So that's why they chose Solar to do the roar part in most song while WheeIn to do the chorus part... However, Solar has a lot of reputation on her voice but WheeIn doesn't which makes me always feel sad. I don't even have a bias in MMM despite being a moomoo for years... but WheeIn is always my first one to think of
I feel like Wheein give the enough amount of high notes, while Solar some times becomes too loud or noisy a bit.. so for me Wheein is my taste, but i love how Solar flirts when she sings ah i die literally 🥺❤️
I feel like sometimes Solar's power takes over lol.....not sure if that's what you mean, but I also prefer Wheein's vocal tone and quality. They are both so talented though
For someone who has a sensitive hearing, that overpowered vocal can really be a pain. So yeah, I prefer Wheein since she is more stable in controling her vocal.
Fun Fact: Solar got rejected on a lot of companies especially big companies since she is not that good at singing before..But because she really wants to become a singer she practice really hard and now we have our high notes slayer Kim Yongsun..😊
@@afrinsayed5902 It's not a lie though..She said it in a show ( forgot which but it's 2016)..She said that she is not really good at singing like now which is why she got rejected..She can sing but not enough to get hired on some companies..
@@yuki48121 and actually she was on a street singing contest where a staff from an entertainment company acknowledged her and said she should persue singing career . And when solar heard that she became interested in music career .If she was a bad singer then why would a staff from entertainment agency say that to her . She was mostly rejected in other companies because she was too old for becoming a trainee . because most of the kpop idols start at a very early age.I don't know where you heard that but solar said herself that since she was old most company rejected her...
Fun Facts too: It's an open book that KPOP agencies ONLY TAKE TRAINEES in there EARLY TEENS or LATE TEENS. SOLAR was already in her 20's when she started auditioning to agencies. It's only RBW took the chance to TAKE HER EVEN IF SHE'S OLD BECAUSE THEY SAW A TALENT IN HER TO MAKE IT. Fun Facts too: It's an open book Solar DOESN'T have the VISUAL(she should have the Standard GG Look set up by a lot of KPOP companies) THAT'S WHY SHE GOT REJECTED. EVEN there CEO tells them UPFRONT THAT THEY DON'T HAVE THE VISUALS. Fun Facts too: Solar was born to sing WHY WOULD ANYONE OFFER her to become a singer if she doesn't have the the talent. Fun Facts too: It's an open book that ANYONE who wanted to be a KPOP Idol NEEDS TO TRAIN for many YEARS Even If You Already Knows How To Dance or Sing So Like WHEEIN was NOT EXEMPTED TO THAT RULE. WHEEIN was already in training in other agencies IN HER EARLY TEENS(before going to RBW to be a Trainee again) she had already the experiences(her skills singing and dancing had been more developed), WHILE SOLAR AT THAT TIME was in High School/College trying to finished her studies, SO WHEN SOLAR WAS TAKEN IN BY RBW, SOLAR HAD TO WORK HARD TO CATCH UP with the others WHO HAD ALREADY BEEN TRAINING FOR YEARS.
I see you all prefer wheein than solar. But let's not compare them please. They are both good 😕. I think Wheein's voice is naturally gifted while Solar worked on it. Solar worked hard for her vocals to be good, was rejected by 40+ companies but she never gave up until she become a part of MAMAMOO. And to those people who says that solar pushes so much it's because she has deeper and rounder voice while wheein has a sharp voice. You are not a true moomoo if you compare these beautiful girls. We will support them no matter what. Mamamoo fighting
All these people saying how wheein and solar are equals... lol. You all KNOW that wheein doesn't get half the credit that solar does. Everyone insisting they are equals, you know that nobody treats them like equals.
Umm as much as I love them, I'm gonna have to stop u there. Wheein is literally just as appreciated as all the members, or even more. She is the only member ranked in the top 5 best vocalist of seoul, and her songs chart well even when she doesn't promote. Having sang many osts and having the most collabs, she is well known by the general public, and under every mamamoo video, the comments are flooded with her name.
If you look in the comment section of the songs that are very vocally demanding Wheein is praised like at least 85% of the time lol (see "I miss you" performances). I think it would be more accurate to say that majority of people favour Wheein's vocal however in terms of overall popularity Solar beats her.
Yeeees, Wheein is the most talented member in Mamamoo and one of the most talented in the industry. She is the best voice and also is the best dancer in mamamoo, but i dont understand why the people thinh that solar and byul have those tittles if is so clear for me.
both of them can hit the high notes but since solar’s voice is more deep (i guess? wheein is more high pitched) and powerful she’s in charge of the high notes more. i do really like solar’s high notes but falsetto and uniqueness of a vocal wise i prefer wheein’s voice uwu and wheein can hit the high notes too :)))
Solar has the heavier voice, and does carry more weight as she ascends. Wheein has the lighter voice, and sheds a bit more weight as she ascends. So technically, Wheein is better. But Solar is more "appealing" as it sounds more heroic than Wheein's.
I prefer listening to Solar’s voice, but I think Wheein is better technically. Either way they are both queens who deserve all the recognition in the world.
I think that the fact that Solar is not naturally gifted like Wheein at singing, and that she can still pull of those high notes with such a powerful voice, makes her slightly better than Wheein. BUT Wheein is such a good and strong singer as well.
Solar's voice is very powerful and also not very high pitched. Wheein's voice is high pitched but also very clear yet powerful. This is the reason why Solar's high notes sound so dynamic. Even if she sings a high note which is not extremely high, it sounds very powerful. But wheein, in my opinion, has a better technique. Not saying Solar has a bad one. All girls of Mamamoo are talented singers :)
Wheein is a gifted type, you can see that how she effortlessly hit those notes; while Solar is effort type, thousands of practices make her sooooo powerful to hit those notes. I love all of them😭😭😭 MAMAMOO is the best💜💜💜💜
![Which opponent scared Whee In? [Singing Battle / 2016.12.21]](/img/n.gif)
Wheein is more the naturally gifted type, when Solar is more the effort type. As a result, both are great.
So true
Lmao high notes take effort for anyone
TRUE
I do think Wheein sings like she has sung like this since she was born.
yes..true 😍
The one from mamamoo wins ♡
Yaasss!
That female member actually
The beautiful one totally wins.
The one that does the high notes
I love all the replies in this comment ❤️❤️❤️
Wheein best techique
Solar powerful voice
Both for me
Wtf?? Solar Has the best technique of course. Thats why she got the main high note in 90% of the songs.
agreed wheein has finesse to her technique.. solar's vocals are more powerful she can hit them notes on command. but in queendom tho, when they sang i miss you..it was refreshing to hear a composed Solar.. her vocal runs and texture..so smooth as silk
@@liamseravali2291
Wheein has the best technique. Solar forces the high notes too hard sometimes. It is better now but you can hear how she strained the notes a lot when the group was younger
@@Faeriiexx if you say that in the beginning Wheein was the best, i agree. But now, she Isn't. Solar get 90% of the high parts when Wheein can go higher. Why? Because Solar TODAY has the best technique. I think you are confusing strainig with supporting. Because Solar clearly don't support some notes she do but her technique is CLEARLY good enough to not strain that.
@@liamseravali2291 as if listen to whee in in MAMAMOO Songs then youll really have a brain
When you really just came here just to see Solar and Wheein belt high notes not caring about the comparison
Same 😂
this is me
i just wanna enjoy some mamamoo vocals, no matter which of the four XD
omg your profile picture is really great lol
THIS LMAO
I love how mamamoo cant be compared with anyone anymore so you just had to resort to mamamoo vs mamamoo lol
Hehehe
And even then they’re incomparable since Wheein has a beautiful clear voice with really good nuanced technique not only in her (very strong) belting but also in her superbly controlled head voice and (possibly?) whistle notes while Solar has amazing power in her belt to really round out their sound and give an extra oomph to the climaxes of the song AND BOTH ARE AMAZING IN DIFFERENT WAYS.
RIGHT?
mamamoo is so damn talented
Vs little mix
Aaaaand this is why we don't have a Main and Lead Vocalist in Mamamoo. They're literally on par with each other and talent just oozes outta both of them! The *only* difference is their techniques and actual vocal colors.
Wheein my bias
@@roxylipz2672 my bias too😅
isn't solar the main vocal?
@@rebsmind8973 that's a common misconception actually, but Mamamoo truly don't have Main and Lead titles. Officially their positions are
Solar: Leader, Vocal
Moonbyul: Rap, Performance
Wheein: Vocal, Performance
Hwasa: Rap, Vocal
This is how they debuted, and they still occasionally use it for intros. But no, Solar is the Leader, but not the main vocal🤷🏻.
@@reneesalinas ooooh i see, thank you
Wheein is so stable and effortless but who can belt like Solar??
That’s why in mamamoo, you have no biases.
Wheein can belt better than solar
Exactly
so true... there are more accomplished main vocalists like eunji who have wider range but no one belts with the volume and force of yong...wheein is my fave kpop vocalists so yah Moomoos still win 🤣
@@ArtyomAnna wheein wins
@@badbada3003 stop pushing solo stan behaviour pls
If we're talking pure technique, solar sounds like she's pushing her chest voice up to belt the higher notes, which gives them more weight and power but also sounds more strained. wheein, on the other hand, is a lot more connected between her chest/mix/head, so the higher notes sound lighter, cleaner, and free. different techniques for different purposes. wheein has the upper hand from a classical standpoint, but they're both still killer vocals.
MayBe because soLar trained in her 20s already.
Wheein is my bias. I hope she'll be aggressive next time.
Rosh Lepz Wheein’s vocals in a technical stand point are actually better, so it gives her the upper hand. They are both phenomenal vocalists, with only minor things to touch on. Wheein is amazing as it it, as is Solar.
And WheeIn's voice is naturally higher than Solar
@Nehal Imran this was 2 months ago but ok
So what i meant is Wheein's voice is higher in terms of hitting notes.
This called tessitura or natural range of someone's voice. Wheein hit high notes easily from Solar because Wheein's voice range NATURALLY higher than Solar in terms of HITTING notes. I don't if u understand what i say but yeah its okay if u don't get it
@Nehal Imran as u can hear Solar give more effort than Wheein when hitting the same notes which mean Wheein's voice is naturally higher
The good thing is that we do not have to choose between them, because they are part of the group MAMAMOO, which is extraordinary because it is composed of four singers whose voices and interpretations are extraordinary. The tone and versatility of the voices of these four talented singers completes in a perfect way. Interpretations are simply unforgettable. I love MAMAMOO
Good one!
Solar is my bias but Wheein’s voice is my favorite it’s so fluid and effortless and while she can’t belt as wide and clear as Solar, Solar can’t give the same effect that Wheein does in a ballad. She’s my favorite female voice in kpop
That's why they all complement each other
the reason why Solar's in charge of the high notes was because her voice is so powerful, it doesn't lose power even when she hit those high notes. they both are great tho.
@@kingjimin9165 we don’t accept ot1 stan in our fandom. no one says who’s better overall. they have their own specialty. Yong’s better at belting, Whee’s better at whistle. go cry about it.
@@nuckesantiago
Don't use your energy on that troll... Ain't worth it!
@@ungegreier1802 after their 2nd comment I was like, "nah"
@@kingjimin9165 Imao we don't want you here. You go cry about it
@@uthrapriya7030 wheein is queen
Deal with it
I personally love Wheein's voice the most. She's one of my favourite vocalists overall
The winner is us
The most legit comment on here
obviously
YES!
YES
Yes either way our ears get blessed
LOL mamamoo are actually legendary these high notes were all glorious
My bias is solar
I had heard them sing live a few times. Tbh wheein was born with a better voice, which will make u feel so relaxed. Like so many artist had said, wheein has very good and unique vocal. While solars vocal is very great too. But apparently, she made a lot of hard works to be able to sing the high keys and so. Its obvious that wheein can sing the high and low key more comfortable than solar. Hence, they both have good vocals, but wheeins is slightly better:) Anyways,i really appreciate solar. She is literally the most hard working, who practice the most among the 4.
Emre Yucelen San Dersi? Did u watch this voice analysis video?
I didn't know that--thanks
It's also because Wheein started singing when she was still young while Yong only started improving her vocals during her 20s but still both of them have their own vocal colors
I agree on this
I can sense that solar ranks last in dancing that's why she works hard... whereas wheein has superb sharp dance moves
Wheein is just a natural born singer. Her pitch and ability to manipulate her voice is amazing. But Solar has such a strong voice. And I can tell that Solar has worked really hard to get to where she is now. Both are extremely talented. Two of the best female singers in kpop.
all Wheein has to do is open her mouth more and she will have power like Solar, and she will be able to do it easier.
btw, in 2020 1TheK made a top 5 female vocalists in general(not just kpop vocalists). Wheein is 3rd and is the only Kpop idol in the list. powerful belts aren't what make a singer good.
Wheein is more like the RNB style, the control and agility is effortlessly the best. While Solar has this huge range and sustainability, she's a tough singer. All in all, I love them both.😍
I kind of find this funny. Lol comparing them is like comparing gold with another gold but are different in form.
Solar is usually belting high notes because she has a very powerful and strong vocals which is more good and impactful in belting high notes. While Wheein is more on falsetto and breathy like AG and when she hits high notes, it's heavenly but you know, powerful and strong is more suitable for belting higher notes.
Solar's voice can be soft and sweet but she is more expert on belting high notes. Wheein's voice is breathy and is more expert in soft and honey-like voice.
But as a vocalist, tbh, Wheein is more versatile that's why she is known as the vocal backbone. She can go from low to high notes in a second and she can be breathy and soft and then make her voice firm and strong in a second as well. Even Solar and their CEO accepts the fact that she is a very good singer. And once, solar once said that if they were a hamburger, Wheein would be the meat. She is said to be the member who can harmonize very well to all the voices of the three members so of you listen carefully to their songs, usually, her voice is the backing voice to harmonize the sounds.
And don't forget the "dolphin note", she did that.
Solar? No words is needed since she is well recognized by many in public while Wheein is underrated compared to her...
BOTH ARE GOOD AND BOTH ARE THE BEST ON THEIR OWN EXPERTISE.
WheeiN even puts color to byul's rap. Her adlib runs..
I really liked your “gold” analogy! ACCURATE AF
unfortunately the casual listener thinks that powerful belt = best vocalist overall. in 2020 1TheK made a top 5 female vocalists in general(not just kpop vocalists). Wheein is 3rd and is the only Kpop idol in the list. powerful belts aren't what make a singer good.
Wheein in my heart 🙆❤
Wheein is just a big ball of awesome!
Wheein is PRECIOUS!!
Wheein has beautiful color in her voice. She can do a lot of beautiful runs. She doesn't just belt and has strong control of her voice.
Wheein's technique is better but Solar's voice is more powerful. Both have great voices, so either way u can't go wrong.
They both have resonance up to C#5; Wheein’s mix is more balanced though.
Solar is a full healthy belter not everything is about mix voice, solar has a well balanced mix voice as wheein in the upper belts, she's just a power based singer and her mix is perfect reminds me of whitney's
I just thought Wheein is more heady while Solar is more chesty
Both.. Angel line
in a span of 7 years, Solar was able to work her way up from being a weak vocalist, to becoming one of the country’s best.
imagine the talent we would’ve lost had she continued with being a flight attendant
Wheein:
-can do sexy and cute concept
-funny beagle but shy too
-great singer
-great dancer
-great Rapper
My bias?
*Mamamoo*
My bias in mamamoo? Yes
MOOMOOS WIN WOOHOO!
Woo hoo!
Woohoo!
If you listen well. You'll probably choose those two. They both have their own way of singing highnotes. 💓 i love them both. 💓 but wheein's high pitched voice was always giving me chills. 💓 I love angel line 😳 I love my yongsun 💞 but my wheein is now in my heart 💕 MAMAMOO FOREVER 😭💓
Both is a great singer of course, but I really like wheein's voice.
Wheein, yes. 💙
So Solar has more power--no surprise there. That's why she's the Main Singer in Mamamoo. That doesn't mean that some people don't prefer the quality of Wheein's voice (I'm one of those people). Besides, Wheein's epic dimple makes it an easy call for me to choose a bias!
Both Solar and Wheein are half of the reason Mamamoo is the coolest group ever!
Solar is not main singer, she's vocals and leader
Wheein is vocals and performance
Hwasa is vocals and rap
Moonbyul is rapper and performance
But that's their debut. We all know that should change to all 4 of them being vocals, visuals, rappers, and performers
The other half are byulie and hwasa 🤣
overall > power belts. Wheein is wanted more from other singers to make feats/colabs. she's 1 of the most wanted in Kpop. when Park Bom from 2ne1 listened Mamamoo, she wanted Wheein to appear as a feat in her solo song(Wheein only sing 1 verse cause it was solo song for Park Bom and added Wheein as feat the last minute). she didn't choose Solar but Wheein. btw, Wheein has won 2-3 times in Duet Festival, and the 1st time was in 2015 and with rapper partner. Solar hasn't won.
@@SapiaNt0mata Don't bring Solar down like that. My bias is Wheein but Solar is successful in her own ways. Both Wheein and Solar are extremely talented even if their vocal techniques are different.
@@krovae1521 look what the op said "So Solar has more power--no surprise there. That's why she's the Main Singer in Mamamoo" when you say that someone is the main singer it means that the others are inferior since they're not main. my comment is made to match the original comment. if it wasn't like this i wouldn't reply as i did.
i love them both but Wheein is more stable with technique and Solar is powerful.
So it turns out theres no winner i love it
Wheein😘
Okay but Solar's Eb5 was beautiful
wheein!!!!
They're both extremely talented but I honestly prefer Wheein.
i think solar sings like those soul singers when she belts - strong and powerful; while WheeIn belts like a pop singer - soft and angelic. Both beautiful and complement each other
Just saying that wheein effortlessly belted a whistle note in 'woo hoo'. I think Wheein has the better voice, but who are we kidding its mamamoo. They all are so fucking talented!
Wheein’s high notes definitely sound more effortless and free, where as Solar’s contain more power and they come swinging in heavier. They are both fantastic singers, part of the same group. I love all four of these MAMAMOO girls
Solar high notes are more free
@@moonlightespt3818 Not from what I hear. Solar’s high notes aren’t as loose or have the ability to be agile. Wheein’s are from my standpoint. Their high notes are both great. Maybe we are just hearing different things.
@@1Love2Live3Laugh You have heard wrong, solar high notes are more open/resonant/full, wheein is a more agile singer? I agree but what does that have to do with their belting technique? Solar is the most expanded belter she's a power based vocalist while wheein is a r&b ballad type of style
@@moonlightespt3818 I said nothing about technique? I never said anything about who the better belter was. From what I am hearing, Solar’s high belting notes just sound heavier. That’s not a bad thing, I love the sound of her belts. And they can definitely be resonant and they are great. Wheein’s sound less restrained and as if she can do anything with them, like they have room to run and go anywhere. That’s why I brought up the agility. This is my opinion, based on this video. You’re not going to change my mind on this.
@@1Love2Live3Laugh Yes you did about their high belts technique, Solar's high belting sounds full/rounded/rich/more open and resonant, wheein's sound is not less strained cause solar doesn't strain neither does wheein, wheein's belts are not like that neither, she's indeed an agile singer but i rarely have seen complex runs/transitions from her belting, i clarified why your statement/info was wrong, you can have your opinion but what i said it's a fact you can't change that
Wheein is technically better, naturally gifted, feels the music and adjusts as to not strain her voice.
Solar is naturally gifted to but utilizes a different technique that isn’t always good for her voice.
Both are great vocalists, but my fav is Wheein.
Angel line will always win
Wheein voice is perfect👌👌👌
They cannot be compared! If you take out 1 of the 2 from Mamamoo, no other singers could fill the gap. That's how 'destiny' brought them together and formed the best vocal group of all time in Kpop. There may be 5 Ailee in one group but the harmony and artistry that Mamamoo have will be second to none.
Both are good. I really enjoy Solar's belts up to C#5, despite the pushing. Above that I prefer Wheein, her tone is nicer and she sounds much less strained.
This is what you call a luxury problem. 😅
Wheein sings an Eb6 near the end of Woo Hoo.
solar worked hard so she could hit those high notes, while wheein was gifted. Solar has the power and wheein is like a calming wind that blows in a cold morning. They compliment each other well, thats why MAMAMOO stans are the winners here.
for someone like Wheein it's easy to get more power in belts. all she has to do is open her mouth more. make a scream with closer mouth, and then open your mouth as much as you can and see how louder your scream is. the same applies to singing.
wheein
fr me...................both hhahahaXD
1- their voice color diff.
2-their both technique diff.
3-their powerful voice also diff.
4-their way hit the note also diff.
5-and the sound get produced also different.
thats why i choose both bcs they both angel line slay it together hehehe.. #i just state a fact tho~
Technically wheein is better
@@badbada3003 so?💀
@@nah4266 just saying
@@badbada3003 lol k
i lov angel line!!!!!!!! so good!!!!
My baby Wheein
This is why MAMAMOO won't be replace with any groups.
I mean... just listen to that pure unique powerful voice. No wonder they are the Angel Line.
Now YOU KNOW.
Wheein eats high notes for breakfast
Wheepup all the way!
Anyways it's a win to have such powerful vocalists in one girl group!
They both have lovely voices and great skills. Let’s talk about technique. From a singer’s point of view (having sung with choral groups from 4-250 members, sometimes with a symphony) I humbly share:
First of all, reaching high notes takes regular practice and relaxing both mind and body. The more you relax your entire body, especially your neck, face, lips, jaw, throat, chest, shoulders, the easier air will flow for vocal cord manipuation. They both do this most of the time... until they reach a certain point where they no longer relax.
Where Wheein succeeds more is in controlling power (as in force of air flow plus volume) - this is harder to achieve than full blast power. Solar’s voice can strain and distort when various muscles tense up at higher registers, though this can also happen with Wheein.
The struggle starts with not warming up the vocal cords enough (it happens sometimes), eating junk food and drinking soda, milk and/or caffeine before a performance (which we’ve seen them do on MMTV), not getting enough rest (sigh), then allowing self-doubt or nervousness result in tension in the body that affects singing. They can hit those notes, but they worry about it. Solar has shown this worry when she joked about high notes in Queendom. No worries lead to more relaxed body and singing.
If you have ever played drums you’ll know what I mean about power and control. It’s harder to hit a snare drum with much less force yet still be heard distinctly, like in jazz drumming style. Being able to do so also requires alot of practice.
My wish for Solar is that she learns to control her power and volume and to relax more at higher registers. She’s certainly capable and just needs to be consistent.
lmao we've reached a point where we're comparing group members and not group vs group
Wheein 🌺🌺🌺🌺🌺☃️☃️☃️☃️☃️☃️☃️
Solar and Wheein can both belt high notes in different styles and that's the reason why MAMAMOO really harmonize.
My opinion is that both can hit very high notes. But as for Wheein, her voice is really special, so she often gets more lines. Solar, in the other hand, has less lines and therefore can store energy to be unleashed in high notes.
At the same time, Hwasa's voice is very suitable to wash or wake your ears before they start their songs, so she is often tasked to be the first one to sing. Last but not least, Moonbyul is so cool in her rap and dance and therefore she's the performance damdang in the group.
I love the fact that after a few years since their debut, there is no real fixed position for them in the group. They have grown to be able to change their roles among themselves, in case if the particular song suits someone more.
How can anyone prefer one over the other? I love both equally, all plus Hwasa and Moonbyul, esp together ❤
All of member mamamoo are the winner for me 💕💕💕
Conclusion: both are incredible singers.
Solar’s notes are more powerful and full/whole and consistent, while wheein is more light and thin, that’s why wheein is more soulful when singing ballad, while solar is more emotional when singing ballad. Both vacals are stable and skilled.
I appreciate anyone with techinical background in music to "educate" people on the Internet. Just please don't forget it needs more effort to deliver knowledge to people with different background and preferences. In my humble opinion after following many discussions, thinking techniques is objective or undisputable is also a part of these arguments as I see vocal coaches following different pedagogies give inconsistent opinions and preferences. Then, there are too many aspects in terms of techniques and how to give scores and weights of them and calculate an overall number to judge who is better itself is a big challenge, not to say to convince eveyone. A lot of technical terms defined in music are not as well-defined as in physical science about measurements with quantifiable units, and most of the time are related to senses, which are different from person to person. Another situation is that the instrument of each singer or the ear/brain of an audience is unique. Using the same technique requires different efforts for differnt singers so sometimes better control seems to be more fair in some situactions. An angelic voice described by an audience might not sound the same for another one since different persons have different angels in their mind. For example, Solar's voice is my ultimate bias and it really takes time for me to appreicate others' voices but their harmony are something else that I love the most. So, I found it hard to understand people saying Solar is shouting or pushing or straining as they all sound angelic, warm, sweet, and like honey in my ears and beg her to yell at me more (I am a normal pervert as Solar 🤣) For me, her techniques are the best as I feel more connected to them since she can easily manuplate my emotion to make me laugh 😆or make me cry 😭. Now, almost in the end of 2021, hope eveyone who loves Mamamoo to continue to support them and wish one day they can literally start a world tour and visit international moomoos again.
I love when solar belts, it gives me goosebumps all over every time, but I love the sound of wheein's voice when she just sings, not necessarily high notes, so both
fantastic group
WheeIn is clearer and Solar is manlier in general. So that's why they chose Solar to do the roar part in most song while WheeIn to do the chorus part... However, Solar has a lot of reputation on her voice but WheeIn doesn't which makes me always feel sad. I don't even have a bias in MMM despite being a moomoo for years... but WheeIn is always my first one to think of
Wheein
Anyway it is great Mamamoo have 4 different vocals. 4 of them can be recognized! I love such mixing among groups. They are unique.
Wheein is just amazing ❤
WHEEIN❤❤❤❤❤
Wheein is my bias but Mamamoo is Mamamoo, they’re all amazing vocalists!
I feel like Wheein give the enough amount of high notes, while Solar some times becomes too loud or noisy a bit.. so for me Wheein is my taste, but i love how Solar flirts when she sings ah i die literally 🥺❤️
I feel like sometimes Solar's power takes over lol.....not sure if that's what you mean, but I also prefer Wheein's vocal tone and quality. They are both so talented though
@@terrirocklover7957 no you’re right sometimes Solar's power takes over.. in all honesty they all great and their voices mix perfectly
For someone who has a sensitive hearing, that overpowered vocal can really be a pain. So yeah, I prefer Wheein since she is more stable in controling her vocal.
Fun Fact: Solar got rejected on a lot of companies especially big companies since she is not that good at singing before..But because she really wants to become a singer she practice really hard and now we have our high notes slayer Kim Yongsun..😊
Really? Wow!
That's a huge lie WTF. She was rejected because she was "too old" to be a trainee. She started out in her 20 which is past most agency's debut age.
@@afrinsayed5902 It's not a lie though..She said it in a show ( forgot which but it's 2016)..She said that she is not really good at singing like now which is why she got rejected..She can sing but not enough to get hired on some companies..
@@yuki48121 and actually she was on a street singing contest where a staff from an entertainment company acknowledged her and said she should persue singing career . And when solar heard that she became interested in music career .If she was a bad singer then why would a staff from entertainment agency say that to her . She was mostly rejected in other companies because she was too old for becoming a trainee . because most of the kpop idols start at a very early age.I don't know where you heard that but solar said herself that since she was old most company rejected her...
Fun Facts too: It's an open book that KPOP agencies ONLY TAKE TRAINEES in there EARLY TEENS or LATE TEENS. SOLAR was already in her 20's when she started auditioning to agencies. It's only RBW took the chance to TAKE HER EVEN IF SHE'S OLD BECAUSE THEY SAW A TALENT IN HER TO MAKE IT.
Fun Facts too: It's an open book Solar DOESN'T have the VISUAL(she should have the Standard GG Look set up by a lot of KPOP companies) THAT'S WHY SHE GOT REJECTED. EVEN there CEO tells them UPFRONT THAT THEY DON'T HAVE THE VISUALS.
Fun Facts too: Solar was born to sing WHY WOULD ANYONE OFFER her to become a singer if she doesn't have the the talent.
Fun Facts too: It's an open book that ANYONE who wanted to be a KPOP Idol NEEDS TO TRAIN for many YEARS Even If You Already Knows How To Dance or Sing So Like WHEEIN was NOT EXEMPTED TO THAT RULE. WHEEIN was already in training in other agencies IN HER EARLY TEENS(before going to RBW to be a Trainee again) she had already the experiences(her skills singing and dancing had been more developed), WHILE SOLAR AT THAT TIME was in High School/College trying to finished her studies, SO WHEN SOLAR WAS TAKEN IN BY RBW, SOLAR HAD TO WORK HARD TO CATCH UP with the others WHO HAD ALREADY BEEN TRAINING FOR YEARS.
I see you all prefer wheein than solar. But let's not compare them please. They are both good 😕. I think Wheein's voice is naturally gifted while Solar worked on it. Solar worked hard for her vocals to be good, was rejected by 40+ companies but she never gave up until she become a part of MAMAMOO. And to those people who says that solar pushes so much it's because she has deeper and rounder voice while wheein has a sharp voice. You are not a true moomoo if you compare these beautiful girls. We will support them no matter what. Mamamoo fighting
All these people saying how wheein and solar are equals... lol. You all KNOW that wheein doesn't get half the credit that solar does. Everyone insisting they are equals, you know that nobody treats them like equals.
BIG FACTSS.. I will say tho that I think after the I miss you performance in queendom our wheepup is getting more recognized :))
Umm as much as I love them, I'm gonna have to stop u there. Wheein is literally just as appreciated as all the members, or even more. She is the only member ranked in the top 5 best vocalist of seoul, and her songs chart well even when she doesn't promote. Having sang many osts and having the most collabs, she is well known by the general public, and under every mamamoo video, the comments are flooded with her name.
If you look in the comment section of the songs that are very vocally demanding Wheein is praised like at least 85% of the time lol (see "I miss you" performances). I think it would be more accurate to say that majority of people favour Wheein's vocal however in terms of overall popularity Solar beats her.
Yeeees, Wheein is the most talented member in Mamamoo and one of the most talented in the industry. She is the best voice and also is the best dancer in mamamoo, but i dont understand why the people thinh that solar and byul have those tittles if is so clear for me.
both of them can hit the high notes but since solar’s voice is more deep (i guess? wheein is more high pitched) and powerful she’s in charge of the high notes more. i do really like solar’s high notes but falsetto and uniqueness of a vocal wise i prefer wheein’s voice uwu and wheein can hit the high notes too :)))
Solar has the heavier voice, and does carry more weight as she ascends. Wheein has the lighter voice, and sheds a bit more weight as she ascends.
So technically, Wheein is better. But Solar is more "appealing" as it sounds more heroic than Wheein's.
Yrah, I agree with you and that's why they sound so perfect when the two of them are harmonizing.
delilah wheein is just *chief's kiss*
I can't close my mouth while watching this.....
To be fair, they complement each other very well.
Interviewer: So who is the main vocalist in mamamoo??
4 of them: MAMAMOO
둘다 재능 있는 애들이 노력까지 한 케이스...... 한마디로 괴물보컬들이쥬...ㅎ
Whee In has unique voice but Solar's high notes are sharper than Whee In's high notes i think.
Jennie’s Diamond Tank I guess it’s because solar has a rounder Vocal than Wheein who Got more thinner ..
Wee In's singing manner is more relaxed in general. That's why her notes have softer sound.
@@raynatumbeva780it also had to do with her tone which is softer than solars
@@3332226 Yeah, Wheein's voice sounds thinner, so it's a little bit annoying to me when she goes highnotes.
@@anhta3962 then don't listen lol
They’re both great but Wheein makes it sound super easy.
Bruh I love how our fandom is so healthy like we didn’t end up fighting but praising them both💕💕
both! ANGEL LINE !!!!!!
I don’t think it’s a good idea to make this into a competition. They’re both awesome in different ways ❤️
Both🙌🏻😍
I prefer listening to Solar’s voice, but I think Wheein is better technically. Either way they are both queens who deserve all the recognition in the world.
We are so lucky to have them both in one group. Solar, Wheein and Hwasa are the best vocal combination in kpop history.
solar = powerhouse vocal
I think that the fact that Solar is not naturally gifted like Wheein at singing, and that she can still pull of those high notes with such a powerful voice, makes her slightly better than Wheein. BUT Wheein is such a good and strong singer as well.
Wheein is my bias but Im not offended.
it's hard for me to assimilate the amount of talent in just one group
they're both amazing and incredibly gifted (all 4 of them actually)
Solar's voice is very powerful and also not very high pitched. Wheein's voice is high pitched but also very clear yet powerful. This is the reason why Solar's high notes sound so dynamic. Even if she sings a high note which is not extremely high, it sounds very powerful. But wheein, in my opinion, has a better technique. Not saying Solar has a bad one. All girls of Mamamoo are talented singers :)
Wheein is a gifted type, you can see that how she effortlessly hit those notes; while Solar is effort type, thousands of practices make her sooooo powerful to hit those notes.
I love all of them😭😭😭 MAMAMOO is the best💜💜💜💜
かっけえよ姉さん、、大好きだ！💖💖💖
You should have showcased from A4 and more C5s and C#5s could have been nicer to show Wheein consistence. Nice video anyways 💓
When they have no one to compare this level of talent, they compare MAMAMOO vs MAMAMOO🤣❤️
VOCAL QUEENS INDEED power group🔥
MAMAMOO members can only be compared to themselves. That's what I call talent.
Moonbyul for the win especially in cleopatra game jk😂 but seriously both are really good and that's what make mamamoo a vocal queen