Yep. This movie is why Stephen Spielberg picked him to be Amon Goethe in Schindler's list. Not that Nazis should be seen as beautiful. But, because he could convey the range. Loved both movies. ❤️
Yes but it was the norm then.you married money or were a servant.its a nobrainer No career women back then women did not work they ran houses. They were not even allowed to vote until the suffregettes Even up to 50s most women were housewives.
He's quite emotionless, whereas Catherine is so overjoyed to see him that she's bouncing off the walls. And DEAR LORD Ralph Fiennes is indeed very fine in this.
Heathcliff seems to be inhuman here: a dark knight, a messenger - he's like something surreal. He becomes devilish in his extreme cruality but becomes the more humane in his passionate love.
Blast.Indeed.His revenge.But it did not last long..he suffered still. Anyway, what did he see in her. This Cathy is so lame.Makes no impression.Wrong portrayal?
i think Heathcliff is THE victim, yes he's Unforgivable, but yet we can't really judge him!! even Hareton didn't face all the crualty Heathcliff has passed through and he was savage and Indomitable, what if he had to faced torture, humiliation and hate as his master did!!
Oranaise311318, i know that Heathcliff suffered greatly in his youth since even before entering Wuthering Heights as a child, BUUUUUT, if I was the author myself, I WOULDN´T MAKE HEATHCLIFF CRUEL TO THOSE WHO HAD NOTHING TO DO WITH HIS SUFFERING, EVEN IF HE HAD SUCH FEELINGS OF HATRED TOWARDS THEM!! UNFORTUNATELY, EMILY BRONTE, DISSAPOINTS ME GREATLY IN THIS! I KNOW THAT THE BRONTE SISTERS SUFFERED TERRIBLY AND MAYBE UNIMAGINABLY IN LIFE, HOWEVER, I DON'T KNOW WHY EMILY TAKES SUCH PLEASURE IN INDUCING CRUELTY AND VIOLENCE IN WUTHERING HEIGHTS. TO TELL THE TRUTH, SHE IS VERY SADISTIC, IMHO. HARETON, DIDN'T SUFFER MUCH CRUELTY FROM HEATHCLIFF, AND THE ONLY REASON FOR THIS IS THAT HARETON IS THE PERSONIFICATION OF HEATHCLIFF'S YOUTH, AND BECAUSE INSTEAD OF SEEING HIS FATHER IN HIS FACE, HE SEES THE FACE OF CATHERINE IN HIM; MORE AND MORE EVERY DAY. THAT IS WHY HE DIDN'T DO HIM MUCH HARM, AND HE WAS THE ONLY ONE WHO SHOWED SADNESS AND TEARS WHEN HEATHCLIFF DIED.
We have to understand that this is set in 1800s where loving someone mattered little, especially if it is a poor man. Even in our times, people mary for money so we cannot judge them... sometimes its the only way to survive
This is why masterpieces like Wuthering will never quite appeal to your average romantic, who wants to surround herself with cheery lovely level people and notions, happy endings and star-crossed crushes. If you read it expecting to 'feel affection' for people-it's no wonder it unsettled you. Why? It pricks your lovely bubble. You can't understand or sympathize with their love, because you expect things to be within your reasonable bubble. You're a little of a flatlander and that works for you.
I think some people are trying to distinguish good and evil when it comes to Heathcliffe and Catherine. There is no good or evil, just mutual and self destructing human nature.
@annwyn17 Heathcliff was never unattractive in the novel,except right before his death. In fact,at this point in the novel Nelly describes Heathcliff as handsome,athletic and even looking than Edgar Linton.
I never noticed that Ralph changed the dialect to more “posh” and less northern, for this wealthy version of Heathcliff. An intentional acting choice, but I wonder if people actually did that when they climbed social ranks.
Yes in fact they did try to change they way they spoke. I actually really like that decision Ralph made, and that his Heathcliff falls back into the Northern accent a little as he's dictating the letter to Linton.
The book was written in a time where women were obedient to men. But Cathy was very fierce and proud, and full of her love for Heathcliff. But Juliette Binoche does not fit her at all. I prefer the 2009 version, that Cathy is more similar than this one. She just giggles and hummles and is irritating aaaalll of the time.
Help me out here, I can't remember, do they (Cathy & Heathcliff) kiss or do anything physical with each other in the book? :o 'Cause I seem to recall that's one of the things that made it so tragic, they never expressed their love in any other ways than with words. But I could be wrong. ^^
But writing away this kind of destructive maelstrom of love is writing away the essence of life, the cold unfeeling core of it - some of the most amazing emotions and forces in life are also deadly and can ruin what they touch as much as they cause it to flourish. The selfish, demanding, all-encompassing love that more complex people experience is a horrid thing, but also a searingly vivid thing that, ultimately, none would want to miss. And missing out you are - as Emily Bronte would tell you.
@countrypanda94 I agree, but Cathy is not only going on a handsome basis, she also chose Linton because he's rich, and like she said before , marrying Heathcliff would have make her look bad. Which in my opinon was stupid, if she loved him, then nothing should have stopped her. But Cathy is selfish.
I cannot help but notice how Catherine tries to unite Heathcliff and Linton's hands together around 4:28. What she tries to unite in this moment will in the end destroy all three of them.
I don't understand how no one has mentioned the actress who plays Cathy's total failure at hiding her accent?? It is extremely off putting and makes her portrayal even more unbelievable. Cathy in the 2009 BBC version, although to nice is a much better Cathy and Tom Hardy as Heathcliff = Total win :)
@s2LaDolceVita Heathcliff doesn't blame others for being the DIRECT reason of his lost love, but as an indirect ones! the society, the pitiless Hindley who almost determinated his character, by torturing and comdamning him to be a subalterne by forbidding him to learn, then Catherine who prefered a Situation in society in stead of her big love, her soulmate (as she said i'm heathcliff) combined to her death and the suffering it caused him! and Mr Lincon who always despised him and stole Catherin
Ks4173, actually, those lines sound like they're being said by Emily Bronte. Since she's narrating (and has written the book), those lines can still be applied to Heathcliff, although they apply just as much to Catherine as they do to Heathcliff. With Bronte saying them, and that shot of Catherine while they're being said, maybe the director wanted to convey the fact that whoever says them can be interchangable. With Bronte saying them, she's actually saying it for both characters. I think :)
For the most part I didn't like this version although I have it on dvd. I didn't care for Juliet Binoche's interpretation. There are parts of her performance that I really like but not enough to make this a favorite.
Heathcliff seems to be so in love that he seems to be loving cathy beyond herself. It's quite difficult to depict this kind of love which Heathcliff and Cathy shared. Like tracy said, it's a love of selfish people. The love Heathcliff has for her, makes him destructive but i'd rather think that it's his nature and not his love for her that compels him to be like this...
Money weighs more than love. I would rather have a man who loves me and looks at me as if I was his own separate gem, than one who may be rich but cruel.
Back then you would have died of starvation. Women did not work or permitted too back then so how could you survive. You either married money or be a servant. Women were not allowed to vote until suffragettes 1920s. Women were mostly housewives up till 1950s
@StineTP I don't think any relationship could relate to Cathy and Heathcliff's. It's more than just on and off. They have loved each other forever and will always stay that way. They are one. They can't be separated. Not by marriage, and not by death. I'm sorry if you don't agree. This is only my opinion.
it was a huge deal back then to stay in your class. probably the equivalent to coming out of the closet now of days...though ppl. do it many will obstain from it and live a life they don't want to.
Well... the film is relly nice but this one doesnt rilly work... do u have another link so that i could watch it full.... i'm studying the book but without the elements which are missing in this part because its bugging, i cant grasp the full meaning and confirm my theories upon it... Thank you in adv... Hope u can help me out! xoxo Fallen
I need to read chapter 9 for school, but there is a problem. I'm from the netherlands and this book is quite difficult for me, so i thought for me to understand that chapter it is smart to watch een part of te movie, but does anyone know witch part of the film that is ?? PLEASE HELP ME Greets from the netherlands :D
lol-seriously-i have the book-we have to read it for school-and i can`t understand the book so good so i wanted to c the movie but coundn`t find it-but thanks to u i guess i`m now ahead of the whole class:Dthanks-aain-lol
I thought it was only I who didn't like Juliet Binoche's interpretation of Cathy! To be honest there's something about her that puts me off besides her flat interpretation!
@@lorannegrech2614 You're not alone. It pains me to say it, because I love Juliette Binoche. She's a very strong actor. But I run hot and cold on her interpretation of Cathy. Juliette is an actor who can transmit great depth of feeling. She is at her most effective here in scenes, like the soliloquies "I am Heathcliff" and "Why am I so changed?" in which she's given the opportunity to express her own obsessive love for Heathcliff. And herself. I do respect that in the 1992 version Heathcliff and Cathy's last conversation is actually full of anger and brutality, as there's also a lot of these emotions in their connection. The scene gets across that's there's as much self love in their obsessiveness as there is actual love between them. Juliette is effective in these moments. But in my view, she has more trouble convincingly getting across the wildness and capriciousness that are also part of Cathy's character. The giggling doesn't really transmit this for me; it ends up making Cathy appear more shallow of character rather than running or denying her feelings. I try not to come down on her too much about her accent problems. This waa Juliette's first film in English and it would really have been a tough part to navigate in a foreign language in any case. But it's true that her accent is also distracting. She doesn't physically resemble Cathy to me either. But kudos to her for her efforts. I feel Juliette was miscast but she tried. She would go on to much greater things later on.
omg, i feel the same way as you! i read the book and i hated it...i watched the movie and i also hated it. it was just dismal and dour. i wanted to like it but i couldn't ......reading english literature is tedious....i like happy romantic stories. i hate the romance between heithcliff and catherine. the only good part of the story was when heithcliff died.
i can just imagine this being the story before harry potter; voldemort being intensely in love with a woman who he can never be with and feeling terribly bitter about it that he has never gotten over it thus the reason for his hatred against the world... of course that would never happen but it would've made it so much more interesting if it were the case...
yes ..but we would all be so if we had received such treatment...like kicking a dog over and over every day and then being shocked when it bites..dont you think?
Poor Edgar. To have a wife who doesn't love him... and poor Isabella to have a husband who doesn't love her... What a mess. Still, Catherine should have let her love for Heathcliff remain in the past when she married Edgar and devote herself to him. To know that his wife was cheating on him with Heathcliff and didn't love him as she did Heathcliff, and yet he still dearly loved Catherine in spite of it - that's a true man worth keeping. Catherine is an idiot for abusing poor Edgar.
Does anyone else think the building chosen to be Wuthering Heights is all wrong? Too grand, the wrong period and very unlike Top Withens, the farm which is believed to be the model for W.H.
Ralph Fiennes looks so intense and passionate in this movie, and yet he looks cruel and cold at the same time. Brilliant acting
The best picture of Wuthering Heights Ever ! Ralph Fiennes and Juliette Binoche are both playing beautifully! Thanks so much for posting.
Only Ralph could pull of creepy and sexy at the same time.
Yep. This movie is why Stephen Spielberg picked him to be Amon Goethe in Schindler's list. Not that Nazis should be seen as beautiful. But, because he could convey the range. Loved both movies. ❤️
She does not love Edgar because he is handsome. She loves Edgar because she values the social status that comes with Edgar.
yes, but she does it for a good cause. She may have been seduced by wealth, but her objective was to rid Heathcliff of Hindley
Yes but it was the norm then.you married money or were a servant.its a nobrainer No career women back then women did not work they ran houses. They were not even allowed to vote until the suffregettes Even up to 50s most women were housewives.
God this is sooo passionate. That kiss. You don't get lads like Heathcliff in the real world. God his eyes are intoxicating!!!
Ahhhhh, Ralph. The most convincing heathcliff. And the best looking - and sounding
He's quite emotionless, whereas Catherine is so overjoyed to see him that she's bouncing off the walls.
And DEAR LORD Ralph Fiennes is indeed very fine in this.
Es la mejor version de cumbres borrascosas... Fiennes es maravilloso.. gran actor... y HERMOSO...
Heathcliff seems to be inhuman here: a dark knight, a messenger - he's like something surreal. He becomes devilish in his extreme cruality but becomes the more humane in his passionate love.
2nd time I've watched this, love the emotional roller coaster of words and cinematography !!
i love how heathcliff take his revenge
Blast.Indeed.His revenge.But it did not last long..he suffered still. Anyway, what did he see in her.
This Cathy is so lame.Makes no impression.Wrong portrayal?
Feels so bad for her husband.He knows what going on but cant really do anything.
i think Heathcliff is THE victim, yes he's Unforgivable, but yet we can't really judge him!! even Hareton didn't face all the crualty Heathcliff has passed through and he was savage and Indomitable, what if he had to faced torture, humiliation and hate as his master did!!
Oranaise311318, i know that Heathcliff suffered greatly in his youth since even before entering Wuthering Heights as a child, BUUUUUT, if I was the author myself, I WOULDN´T MAKE HEATHCLIFF CRUEL TO THOSE WHO HAD NOTHING TO DO WITH HIS SUFFERING, EVEN IF HE HAD SUCH FEELINGS OF HATRED TOWARDS THEM!! UNFORTUNATELY, EMILY BRONTE, DISSAPOINTS ME GREATLY IN THIS! I KNOW THAT THE BRONTE SISTERS SUFFERED TERRIBLY AND MAYBE UNIMAGINABLY IN LIFE, HOWEVER, I DON'T KNOW WHY EMILY TAKES SUCH PLEASURE IN INDUCING CRUELTY AND VIOLENCE IN WUTHERING HEIGHTS. TO TELL THE TRUTH, SHE IS VERY SADISTIC, IMHO. HARETON, DIDN'T SUFFER MUCH CRUELTY FROM HEATHCLIFF, AND THE ONLY REASON FOR THIS IS THAT HARETON IS THE PERSONIFICATION OF HEATHCLIFF'S YOUTH, AND BECAUSE INSTEAD OF SEEING HIS FATHER IN HIS FACE, HE SEES THE FACE OF CATHERINE IN HIM; MORE AND MORE EVERY DAY. THAT IS WHY HE DIDN'T DO HIM MUCH HARM, AND HE WAS THE ONLY ONE WHO SHOWED SADNESS AND TEARS WHEN HEATHCLIFF DIED.
@@Janillo2782 This quote from the film The Heiress sums up Heathcliff perfectly for me;
'How can I be this cruel? I have been taught. By masters.'
LOL how Isabel just leaves Heathcliff and Cathy alone. Can't she see the chemistry between them and try to stop Cathy for cheating her brother?
We have to understand that this is set in 1800s where loving someone mattered little, especially if it is a poor man. Even in our times, people mary for money so we cannot judge them... sometimes its the only way to survive
This is why masterpieces like Wuthering will never quite appeal to your average romantic, who wants to surround herself with cheery lovely level people and notions, happy endings and star-crossed crushes.
If you read it expecting to 'feel affection' for people-it's no wonder it unsettled you. Why? It pricks your lovely bubble. You can't understand or sympathize with their love, because you expect things to be within your reasonable bubble. You're a little of a flatlander and that works for you.
I have a copy of wuthering height dated 1938. I love that book
I think some people are trying to distinguish good and evil when it comes to Heathcliffe and Catherine. There is no good or evil, just mutual and self destructing human nature.
Ralph! Oh, Ralph! You are wonderful! 😍
I can never blame Isabella for 'falling in love' with Heathcliff right there, him looking like THAT. I so would.
"You look very fit" - damn right!
haha that moment when the two guys hold hands is SOO awkward!
@annwyn17 Heathcliff was never unattractive in the novel,except right before his death. In fact,at this point in the novel Nelly describes Heathcliff as handsome,athletic and even looking than Edgar Linton.
i can't watch this movie without crying...
I never noticed that Ralph changed the dialect to more “posh” and less northern, for this wealthy version of Heathcliff. An intentional acting choice, but I wonder if people actually did that when they climbed social ranks.
They did; Oscar Wilde got rid of his Irish accent for that reason
Yes in fact they did try to change they way they spoke. I actually really like that decision Ralph made, and that his Heathcliff falls back into the Northern accent a little as he's dictating the letter to Linton.
@@Tabroxfcc This is absolutely true, but Oscar also spent much of his adult life outside Ireland as well
@@TabroxfccDid he have one
Where did he get all his money
For the longest time, I thought Cathy was telling Heathcliff to "Go away." haha
TRUE,
i hate how they dont stick to the book when they perfectly easily could.
The book was written in a time where women were obedient to men. But Cathy was very fierce and proud, and full of her love for Heathcliff. But Juliette Binoche does not fit her at all. I prefer the 2009 version, that Cathy is more similar than this one. She just giggles and hummles and is irritating aaaalll of the time.
He's good for this role, but she is so aloof looking all the time, I just don't find her Cathy moving.
Their are some important differences but as film adaptations go it is faithfull enough.
"you look very fit"
couldn't have said it better myself!
Withering hiegjys is a horrible dark depreessing house
Help me out here, I can't remember, do they (Cathy & Heathcliff) kiss or do anything physical with each other in the book? :o 'Cause I seem to recall that's one of the things that made it so tragic, they never expressed their love in any other ways than with words. But I could be wrong. ^^
Sad she loves Healthcliff but he never comes only when its too late iam glad he came though for cathy . I wish i would meet my healthcliff one day
thnx for this movie!
been looking for it for hourss!thnks!
E: "Do you like poop?"
H:*While looking at Catherine* "Yes."
E: "HA! He said he liked poop!"
what the hell shes sooo happy that he came back then she goes running to her husband without even saying any thing to him
But writing away this kind of destructive maelstrom of love is writing away the essence of life, the cold unfeeling core of it - some of the most amazing emotions and forces in life are also deadly and can ruin what they touch as much as they cause it to flourish. The selfish, demanding, all-encompassing love that more complex people experience is a horrid thing, but also a searingly vivid thing that, ultimately, none would want to miss. And missing out you are - as Emily Bronte would tell you.
@countrypanda94 I agree, but Cathy is not only going on a handsome basis, she also chose Linton because he's rich, and like she said before , marrying Heathcliff would have make her look bad. Which in my opinon was stupid, if she loved him, then nothing should have stopped her. But Cathy is selfish.
É UM CLÁSSICO LINDO DEMAIS E INESQUECÍVEL!
I cannot help but notice how Catherine tries to unite Heathcliff and Linton's hands together around 4:28. What she tries to unite in this moment will in the end destroy all three of them.
Best love 💕 story ever
Man, Edgar looks so ugly compared to Heathcliff's raw, savage beauty!
Cathy is insane!!!
I don't understand how no one has mentioned the actress who plays Cathy's total failure at hiding her accent?? It is extremely off putting and makes her portrayal even more unbelievable. Cathy in the 2009 BBC version, although to nice is a much better Cathy and Tom Hardy as Heathcliff = Total win :)
Juliette Binoche has an EXCELENT ENGLISH!
I agree, her accent is off-putting and it makes her sound like a foreigner rather than a girl born and raised in England
Many mentioned the irritating accent, XChezza.
@s2LaDolceVita Heathcliff doesn't blame others for being the DIRECT reason of his lost love, but as an indirect ones! the society, the pitiless Hindley who almost determinated his character, by torturing and comdamning him to be a subalterne by forbidding him to learn, then Catherine who prefered a Situation in society in stead of her big love, her soulmate (as she said i'm heathcliff) combined to her death and the suffering it caused him! and Mr Lincon who always despised him and stole Catherin
Ks4173, actually, those lines sound like they're being said by Emily Bronte. Since she's narrating (and has written the book), those lines can still be applied to Heathcliff, although they apply just as much to Catherine as they do to Heathcliff. With Bronte saying them, and that shot of Catherine while they're being said, maybe the director wanted to convey the fact that whoever says them can be interchangable. With Bronte saying them, she's actually saying it for both characters. I think :)
Juliette binoche was the perfect pick for this role...
Lol these comments are hilarious.
For the most part I didn't like this version although I have it on dvd. I didn't care for Juliet Binoche's interpretation. There are parts of her performance that I really like but not enough to make this a favorite.
I think this Linton is far more too arrogant which makes him a little more rude...than the one in the book...I dunno..that's just my opinion...
Does the movie follow the book directly or is it a lot different from the book?
Heathcliff seems to be so in love that he seems to be loving cathy beyond herself. It's quite difficult to depict this kind of love which Heathcliff and Cathy shared. Like tracy said, it's a love of selfish people. The love Heathcliff has for her, makes him destructive but i'd rather think that it's his nature and not his love for her that compels him to be like this...
It was his upbringing.
A love story of selfish people. Quite unique
@Panthinoe
yeah, i dont remember them doing anything which is why i was surprised that in the movie, they're so intimate so early on
Thanks so much for uploading! xoxo.
Money weighs more than love. I would rather have a man who loves me and looks at me as if I was his own separate gem, than one who may be rich but cruel.
Back then you would have died of starvation. Women did not work or permitted too back then so how could you survive. You either married money or be a servant. Women were not allowed to vote until suffragettes 1920s. Women were mostly housewives up till 1950s
@StineTP
I don't think any relationship could relate to Cathy and Heathcliff's. It's more than just on and off. They have loved each other forever and will always stay that way. They are one. They can't be separated. Not by marriage, and not by death.
I'm sorry if you don't agree. This is only my opinion.
I relate to the story. The love of my life got murdered 46 yrs ago n im waitin to be with him. He died, i lived. Even in death we talk to each other
Heeeeey, where Cathy was riding with Isabella, is that the Pemberly estate from the 2005 Pride and Prejudice?
7:29 “Go away.”
it was a huge deal back then to stay in your class. probably the equivalent to coming out of the closet now of days...though ppl. do it many will obstain from it and live a life they don't want to.
Well... the film is relly nice but this one doesnt rilly work... do u have another link so that i could watch it full....
i'm studying the book but without the elements which are missing in this part because its bugging, i cant grasp the full meaning and confirm my theories upon it...
Thank you in adv... Hope u can help me out!
xoxo Fallen
heathcliff reminds me of kazuya mishima from the tekken franchise...similar childhood
me too! Its like all these words mixed up!
I need to read chapter 9 for school, but there is a problem. I'm from the netherlands and this book is quite difficult for me, so i thought for me to understand that chapter it is smart to watch een part of te movie, but does anyone know witch part of the film that is ?? PLEASE HELP ME
Greets from the netherlands :D
She's like Dr. Giggles shut the hell up lol
😂😂😂
Файнс с вечным автозагаром 😂
lol-seriously-i have the book-we have to read it for school-and i can`t understand the book so good so i wanted to c the movie but coundn`t find it-but thanks to u i guess i`m now ahead of the whole class:Dthanks-aain-lol
But it almost doesn't matter considering how spot on Ralph Fienes is as Heathcliff.
heh, the first thing that came to my mind after hearing it.. of course he did, it was heathcliff's quote, not cathy's.
does anyone know the name of the tune that Catherine plays on the harpsichord?
yeah they look sooo similar. i always get those two mixed up.
I love Fines in this version, but Binoche is just too colourless
I thought it was only I who didn't like Juliet Binoche's interpretation of Cathy! To be honest there's something about her that puts me off besides her flat interpretation!
@@lorannegrech2614 You're not alone. It pains me to say it, because I love Juliette Binoche. She's a very strong actor. But I run hot and cold on her interpretation of Cathy.
Juliette is an actor who can transmit great depth of feeling. She is at her most effective here in scenes, like the soliloquies "I am Heathcliff" and "Why am I so changed?" in which she's given the opportunity to express her own obsessive love for Heathcliff. And herself. I do respect that in the 1992 version Heathcliff and Cathy's last conversation is actually full of anger and brutality, as there's also a lot of these emotions in their connection. The scene gets across that's there's as much self love in their obsessiveness as there is actual love between them. Juliette is effective in these moments.
But in my view, she has more trouble convincingly getting across the wildness and capriciousness that are also part of Cathy's character. The giggling doesn't really transmit this for me; it ends up making Cathy appear more shallow of character rather than running or denying her feelings. I try not to come down on her too much about her accent problems. This waa Juliette's first film in English and it would really have been a tough part to navigate in a foreign language in any case. But it's true that her accent is also distracting. She doesn't physically resemble Cathy to me either.
But kudos to her for her efforts. I feel Juliette was miscast but she tried. She would go on to much greater things later on.
Because Juliette Binoche, who plays Cathy, is French.
that was a sad, dry kiss...it had no passion what so ever
@countrypanda94 Have you read the book? According to it, Linton is handsome whereas Heathcliff is not!!
Such an Intense love❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥
The First Time they make love, 💥... .
🌄
omg, i feel the same way as you! i read the book and i hated it...i watched the movie and i also hated it. it was just dismal and dour. i wanted to like it but i couldn't ......reading english literature is tedious....i like happy romantic stories. i hate the romance between heithcliff and catherine. the only good part of the story was when heithcliff died.
For some reason, when I first read withering heights, I thought Nelly what black...
Cathy needs more passion! 3:45 was pathetic! (Ralph's awesome!)
I AGREE
i can just imagine this being the story before harry potter; voldemort being intensely in love with a woman who he can never be with and feeling terribly bitter about it that he has never gotten over it thus the reason for his hatred against the world...
of course that would never happen but it would've made it so much more interesting if it were the case...
well said HannahAndKristiin....what a big mistake in the movie!!
Did Cathy loose vitginity with Heathcliff?
ugh she says two year...
it was three.
That face Heathcliff keeps making keeps reminding me of Zoolander. I dont really know why but it does.
Why did I read this.........
and it is said while cathy is dying not when she moves
where can i see the new pBS version?
@Panthinoe
i think they hug and kiss just when cathy's gonna die...
Can't stand the way this actress plays Cathy.
i dont think this cathy is better than the otters
Edgar is way too puncey & non where near as "delicate" as he is in the novel.
Por favor façam dublagem em português
That's exactly what i was thinking. She's so stuck up.
Cathy with a French accent. hmmm
Fiennes IS PERFECT..GREAT..!!!!!!!!
and Binoche is good..just fine..i like her...!
but not as heathcliff
rock that harpsicord
yes ..but we would all be so if we had received such treatment...like kicking a dog over and over every day and then being shocked when it bites..dont you think?
is that even english??
Poor Edgar. To have a wife who doesn't love him... and poor Isabella to have a husband who doesn't love her... What a mess. Still, Catherine should have let her love for Heathcliff remain in the past when she married Edgar and devote herself to him. To know that his wife was cheating on him with Heathcliff and didn't love him as she did Heathcliff, and yet he still dearly loved Catherine in spite of it - that's a true man worth keeping. Catherine is an idiot for abusing poor Edgar.
She should never have married Edgar in the first place. A lot of lives wouldn't have been ruined if she hadn't.
Does anyone else think the building chosen to be Wuthering Heights is all wrong? Too grand, the wrong period and very unlike Top Withens, the farm which is believed to be the model for W.H.
It was the location, not the building that was Bronte's inspiration.
I've visited it, recently. Scenery around there is breathtaking.