Omg I legit burst out laughing at that clip from Hum Dil De Chuke Sanam. I love how you've moved beyond just talking about films and also about questions on life. And YES. PREACH 👏 ABOUT 👏 THOSE 👏 SHITTY 👏 GENDER 👏 ROLES 👏 I see so many of my friends falling for the bad boy abusive boyfriend since we glorify that so much and this insane hypervigilantism around a woman's body and her decisions. Bollywood exaggerates all of it. Thanks again for an amazing, fulfilling video. Love them!
i dnt think HDDCS is ''projecting '' it.....what was shown in that clip...it happens in every rural part of india....so bollywood isnt exactly promoting that, its just reflecting the society. And yea rest of the part of the video, I agree to them
Such a bliss! Do people like you exist? You understood the idea of love and explained in such simple words! Indian cinema has always exaggerated the idea and a lot of people do stalk thinking that it will get them their SOULMATE! Nice to find your channel and especially you! All the best and yeah, Subscibed!
Very logically explained. I'm also beginning to make short films related to day life and other vlogs and sketches. Trying to keep it as human as possible.
At 5:24 SRK in DDLJ teasing Kajol with her Bra and in very next scene "Mein aik Hindustani hun aur mein jaanta hun aik Hindustani Larki ki izzat kia hota hai" WTF? This is hilariously confusing! No-pun-intended
aam Aadmi , " Bollywood , why do you make such crappy movies?" Bollywood , " Newton dekhi ?" Aam Aadmi, " nai " Bollywood , " Judwa 2 dekhi ?" Aam Aadmi , " Haan..." Bollywood , " bus Isiliye!!"
Aam aadmi: bollywood, why do you make such crappy movies? Bollywood: kyon ki log wohi pasand karthe hain Aam aadmi: bollywood, sach bathaoh!!! Bollywood: Haaa haa chal boltha hoon😠. Hum intne saalomse movies banarahe tho poora ka poora movie distribution/market hum khudh control karte hain, aur hum acchey quality movies ko theatre mein nahi aane dete thaaki zyadha se zyadha log buddhu ban baitein. Lekin mujhe ye bathaon, tum "Aam aadmi" hoke aisi smart questions kabse poochne lage? Tumhe acche/bure films mein pharak kaise patha? Aam aadmi: jabse 4g data plans aur ghar mein internet lagi, tabse thoda thoda smart bannelaga. Newton jaise movies dekkhe thoda socially aware bana-bhi. Bollywood: Haa mujhe patha hain, lekin tujhe baaki sab Aam logon ki tharah yeh nahi patha ki Bollywood aur Independant Indian Cinema mein pharak hain. Isi liye Newton jaise independant films ke bare mein mujhe se baath kar rahan hain. Vaise movies mere bas ke baath nahi. Bus hindi movie hone ke nathe tuj jaise chootiye aisi independant movies ko bhi humaare bollywood category mein dalke critisize karthe hein. Is mein humara kya bigada? In fact humara compliment hua ki tum Newton ko bollywood material maanha 😆 So thank you!
As a 16 year old i epitomised the whole notion of love the way bollywood has always portrayed. But now as a relatively woke 24 year old, i would laugh my ass off if any guy would act cheesy or would punch him hard if he tries being Rahul to my Anjali!
🤣🤣, same here. Actually as per pur films the guy should be pro in all the things like hum dil de chuke sanam bande ko patang udana bhi aana chahiye pro level pe 😝
@@dragonbane44 In what way? To divide the already divided communities further? In large part that's what they have done in the West. India needs reform but not in the name of a toxic ideology as so called "social justice".
Most under rated Indian youtube channel. That is the thing I want for Bollywood critics to do. Question things question the system. Tell the problems, pledge for a change but most of them are paid reviews anyway. Thanks for another good video.
You should watch Premam (Malayalam movie) Edit: I removed Arjun Reddy from the comment as I was a stupid 17 year old when I made that comment and I highly regret it.
Arjun Reddy? Seriosuly? That movie just proves the narrators point that you can get away with abuse if you are rich and handsome. The girl has no dialogues until they have sex dude! All we can see is a submissive terrified girl who becomes attached to the hero due to stockholm syndrome!
5:42 'Rules: Pyar ka superhit formula' was one of my childhood favorites and is an underrated gem of a movie. Thanks for including this one amidst all these absurd love stories.
At 3:16 you have included the poster of "When Harry met Sally". It's not a typical Romantic movie. It does not start with love at first sight or stalking or something else you mentioned. It's the opposite. It starts with the pair not going well with each other, clash of opinions. Then they dont even spend time with each other, they don't even become friends in the first place. They become friends gradually and after 5 or 10 years after they first met. They don't fall in love all of a sudden. It's a good movie among the other posters you've included. This is for the people who haven't seen the movie and think that it's a crappy movie. It's not. I'm not blaming the creator for this mistake. He might not have noticed it. Great content by the way. All the best to the channel.
I also watched Masaan because some "INTELLIGENT" people praised it... and that movie was Boring Confusing Meaningless and about some uninteresting rendom people. I like intelligent and innovative movies but Masaan was nothing and being praised unnecessarily by some people.
I'm happy that there are people who actually understand what crap Bollywood has been providing us in the name of love. Thank you for making this video. ❤️❤️
This is pretty spot on, man, especially the ways in which the idea of 'true' love sometimes translates into something disturbing. Just one thing I'll point out is that while the importance of verbal communication needs to be emphasised, human beings have a tendency to communicate more through body language than through words, and while Bollywood has exaggerated it, intuitiveness and other forms of non-verbal communication, especially in couples which have been together for a some time, is perfectly acceptable and natural.
Love is a skill that needs time and patience.....and if you think you aren't getting any better in it.........Ranbir Kapoor appears in the background 😂😂
Not only does this flawed narrative of love impact our approach to love, it is also the other way around. An earlier video showed how not only cinema affects society but it is also the society which affects cinema.
I loved how you took up the movie 'Rules'. This flop of a movie is actually a good one, and not thaat bad. It's my mom's favourite movie, and I thought she was crazy, until I watched it again last week, after a gap of almost 8 years. Way ahead of it's time and brought a woman with desires into limelight, which was unique in 2003. Amazing stuff man, keep it up !
Hi, there is a film called rashomon that I indent to talk about, a film that I think was way ahead of its time in terms of cinematic techniques, its cinematography and editing was so beautifully done that when you watch it, it feels like the film is flowing like a fluid, also I think the film raises a lot of philosophical questions and makes you think, akira kurosawa was one of the very few film makers of his time that were trying to attempt depth in their films. This is utterly irrelevant from the video, but I am curious about knowing your views on the film please.
This day I found this channel, I am astonished to see such a channel exists, and such content was there on TH-cam. Now I am questioning why we are going backwards.
Now all Indians, Pakistanis, Bengalis and Sri Lankans have weird ideas and expectations of love. People do not realise how much Bollywood has destroyed people’s perception on marriage.
This is one of the best videos I've come across in recent times. This dude talks real, I'm glad there are like minded people with the ability to explain what is what! You've got a subscriber in me bruh! Cheers.
Finally someone said what was in the heart of many people about how pathetically love is portrayed in Indian movies. Loved your video, full credits for the effort. Keep up the good work.
I just so love your soothing voice😊 This essay was superbly humane. Just reveals your own harmony with your life and emotions💞 (And thanks a lot for digging up all those new memeworthy reactions. Honorable mention: "Meri aankhon mein dekho Nandani, OH MY GOD, vo pyaar nahi he" 😂😂😂 He is sooo shocked, he forgot to look shocked! 😂😂😂)
Watched it again today, away from wife ( college time love ) for 3 months due to coronavirus, made me think a lot deeper this time. Thanks for creating this.
It was only after falling in love for the first time in teenage years that I realised that I have been fed lies by Bollywood all my growing up years...
Me too...I was having a crush on a girl and thinking that I love her....I never approached her but always stalked her...And also was heartbroken even without proposing...Don't know how and I also cried...Lol I am just a sick person or was
As much as I agree with the most parts of your explanation, I feel you have shown only one side of the coin. Films, definitely affect and influence society but the process happens the other way round too. Films are a reflection of the society, as firstly, they are made by people emerging from the society itself and secondly those very films are the ones which people choose to go and watch. Having said that, I'm happy about the fact that there is an evident change in the society with the second decade of this century. Thanx to Internet and the power to choose the content you would want to watch at any time you want.
The films they made is not the reflection of our society I think u don't understand the because of this shit movies most of the teenage comit suicides(nas kaatlunga) and all that.
Absolutely correct. People go around thinking that everything is made up. Every movie we see is rooted in reality in some way. Takes observation to know.
This was a very well made video. What amazed me was the myriad issues you touched ; consent, appropriateness and of course the deep philosophical insights that you provided. Keep up the good work.
Just came across your video. And I would like to point out wherein you mentioned about this delusion that when in love we won't have to express anything but the other person will himself/herself know. I can tell you that I have myself done this past. And guess movies do have major impact in our lives. These things are not possible in real life. Communication is a major part of any relationship. The other person in not Parmatma that he/she will know everything going on in our minds. And these can sometimes be a reason of breaking down a relationship. Thank Goodness, I realized this.
Romanticism movement was inclined towards the artistic expression of one's own inner feelings, thoughts, motivations, etc. I'd say it was much less to do with sex than you're indicating it be
Much awaited video on Romanticism. Marvellous one. It can't be denied that these movies affected us thoroughly over the years. The idea of love is imposed on us by these movies in the manner they wanted. No one tried to experiment. Though I think that Imtiaz somewhere changed the way we used to see love stories but at the same time he lacks many things you mentioned in your video. I wish you would bring out your version of love on-screen some day. And again fabulous video. Good work. Thanks.
For me, love is the highest level of intimacy that adds value to our lives and gives us comfort. Someone who accepts and likes us the way we are. People who love each other help us become the best version of ourselves. And this is very rare to find but not impossible. For this we should be open to meeting someone and be present by removing all the stereotypes.And if you don't get it, then work on yourself. Do anything that makes you happy. You will definitely get it sometime.
great analysis. keep up the good work. Btw, recently, I had to do a case study in my class about a product in any industry(I am doing Industrial & Production Engineering). So I chose to do a case study of Gangs Of Wasseypur. And your video helped a lot to provide artistic analysis. So, thanks for that.
Great video as always. My suggestion: Start a parallel channel with the same content in Hindi as well. I want to share these videos to many people but many of them are not comfortable with English.
Man 'o Man, where were u buddy? Twice/Thrice in a week I used to check your channel to find a new video. Please make don't go away for so long and keep making videos more frequently, your ardent follower.
I have watched other videos made by you and this was the best! I felt that in most of your videos you analyze films based on technical aspects of filmmaking and citing examples to explain those technical concepts and elaborate their application. In This video, however, you engage with questions of representation .i.e representation of love, of gender and how that shapes viewers' mindsets. Thanks for that! I would also like to add that Bollywood cinema propagates a narrow idea of who can be in a relationship or in love, usually young males and females. Same sex love, or love between older people is disastrously represented or is completely absent.
This is something that we discuss everyday. There are so many stories about India but Bollywood thinks that the only topic that is worth making a movie is LOOOOOVVVVVEEE. I've taken a break from Bollywood after 'Jagga Jasoos' because I can't waste my money watching these half-arsed movies. I prefer to watch movied that're coming on Amazon Prime, like Trapped and Death in the Gunj. But no more of this mainstream horseshit until Bollywood realises what a skewed reality they're portraying. Thanks for making this video!
It's slowly changing my friend. There has been more variety added in Bollywood and thankfully people are accepting the change. Movies with new ideas are getting better
The reason is simple. These filmmakers in Bollywood live mostly lavish lives and have zero clue about the lives of the common man. They have ample time for love, relationships, breakups and such nonsense since they don't have to worry about jobs, financial security and education that an everyday man faces. So for them love is the only topic in life these other issues can be lived without.
I know there are very few who can or I should say want to think this way. people have a tendency to follow others. They look for a pre-built path to go on. amazing video, kudos to you !!
Wow, awesome video. One request though, I am French and watching your videos because I am interested in Indian culture, especially cinematic. I would be so grateful if you could add some English subtitles to the parts in Hindi. Thanks!
@@CinemaBeyondEntertainment I HOPE YOU'LL READ IT. Hi Vinit. Huge Admirer. Just got this great news of 2.0. So, just had a humble request this time pls review 2 movies 1. Ek main air ekk tu 2. Lagaan And if you get time review some satyajit ray movies also. I really think only you are capable of dissecting ray cinema totally & answer that: Did he make cinematic poetry or just poverty p*rn disguised as artistic cinema that can be exported to the west in an attempt to win international awards. Please do answer this question. A whole new generation wants to know the REAL meaning of RAY cinema from a person who actually understands cinema. Please be very brutally honest.
This might have been the best video I've ever seen on TH-cam! Truth has become a hard slap on cheeks rather than evoking a sense of enlightenment. You've spoken the truth. And I'm thankful to know there are people who think the same way as I do. 🙌❤️
I'm not Indian, but since I started watching Bollywood films I really loved them and I deeply respect and appreciate the amount of work and effort that goes into a production of a Bollywood film. They're master pieces. There's truly nothing like Bollywood films. That being said, you're absolutely right and spot on with your analysis. One other thing that really strikes me with all Bollywood films that some audience might run the danger of believing would occur in their realities, is just the profound amount of coincidences and conveniences that end up working out in the protagonist's favour. All the protagonist has to do, is just be brave and take risks on an adventure and everything will somehow always work out in the end, exactly how he/she wants it. In some films it gets to a point where you think: "Come on, I know this is a movie, but even for a movie's standard this is gone too far". No matter where the two potential lovers go and what they do, fate somehow brings them back (it's just meant to be). I'm sure some people believed in this at some point and soon were very disappointed to find out that's just not reality.
Wow you brought up some amazing points. This notion of finding the most flawless person and falling in love with them is ridiculous! Reality is far from perfect.
A great analysis, needless to say. But I don't think that bollywood movies ruined love because of the way they portrayed love. Yes, the way they portrayed, and continue to portray, love is not real. But, many people watch movies because they are not real, because they display something which serves as a respite from the real world, an escape. At least, that's how cinema watchers approached movies in the beginning. Bollywood destroyed the notion of love because they keep on showing the same thing again and again and because there was no one who could show love in the real way, in mainstream cinema. According to me, we need both realistic and "imaginary make-believe" cinema in our industry running parallelly with equal amount of target audience in the box office. But I agree that it has to some extent, distorted our concept of love in the real life.
Thank you!! Thank you!! Finally somebody addresses the gigantic Mamoth of Bollywood representation of askewed love out in public. This video is a must watch for every teenager along with Sex-Ed. It will definitely draw a line between creepy and romantic
Exactly, this has caused average Indian mentality ruined.
Yes people think srk is the best actor and better than Irrfaan khan, Manoj Bajpaye
@@bhaveshyadav5580 srk himself says he's an average actor
@@KrishanKumar-ec1ch was dilip Kumar a great actor?
@@KrishanKumar-ec1ch yes
@@H00o0DA1 dilip kumar is jihadi
Somebody tag this video to karan johar !
vipin gangwar karan johar ko isse movies ki alava kuch athe nahi hai
He will walk away in between saying Pyaar Dosti hai
Actor of the shining
Also to Imtiaz Ali. They're both stuck up over finding " the one".
He doesn't care until people keep spending money on shitty movies.
the look that salman gave aishwarya was as if he found out she was a serial killer😂😂
to phir problem kya hai ?
Mihir zzz hahhahaa
Lol yeah
Mihir zzz Yeah!!🤣😂
😂😂😂😂😂
Such a mature video... kudos to the maker!
yo wtf banker op here i didnt expect lmao this is a jackpot
Omg I legit burst out laughing at that clip from Hum Dil De Chuke Sanam. I love how you've moved beyond just talking about films and also about questions on life. And YES. PREACH 👏 ABOUT 👏 THOSE 👏 SHITTY 👏 GENDER 👏 ROLES 👏 I see so many of my friends falling for the bad boy abusive boyfriend since we glorify that so much and this insane hypervigilantism around a woman's body and her decisions. Bollywood exaggerates all of it. Thanks again for an amazing, fulfilling video. Love them!
i dnt think HDDCS is ''projecting '' it.....what was shown in that clip...it happens in every rural part of india....so bollywood isnt exactly promoting that, its just reflecting the society. And yea rest of the part of the video, I agree to them
That cracked me up so bad 🤣🤣
Such a bliss! Do people like you exist? You understood the idea of love and explained in such simple words! Indian cinema has always exaggerated the idea and a lot of people do stalk thinking that it will get them their SOULMATE! Nice to find your channel and especially you! All the best and yeah, Subscibed!
Very logically explained. I'm also beginning to make short films related to day life and other vlogs and sketches.
Trying to keep it as human as possible.
Mr IY that ar boy friend
Mr IY
Bhai har channel ke har video me tere comments hi hote hai😂😂😂
This is a sophisticated way of saying " Good video, But check my channel" 😂😂
aisa lgta h ki youtube ki galiyon mein raedi (cart) pe bech rha h ye apna channel
no offense
Ok
Nicee
Shukriya Shukriya Shukriyaaa ! :D
*facepalm*
Prashant Sachan I just paused the video at 7.16 only to read this comment...
Love shown in Maanjhi: The mountain main is what love stands for
😂
At 5:24 SRK in DDLJ teasing Kajol with her Bra and in very next scene "Mein aik Hindustani hun aur mein jaanta hun aik Hindustani Larki ki izzat kia hota hai" WTF? This is hilariously confusing! No-pun-intended
Kyuki karan johar chu hai
DDLJ is the worst movie of Shahrukh Khan(Im a fan)
@@GirishNair16 Aditya chopra is the writer and director
Umair Javed
Different characters maaannnn!
If you are hating him like this,
means he has done great acting in that character.
Doesnt mean he cant have a fuckin sense of humour. Get a grip
aam Aadmi , " Bollywood , why do you make such crappy movies?"
Bollywood , " Newton dekhi ?"
Aam Aadmi, " nai "
Bollywood , " Judwa 2 dekhi ?"
Aam Aadmi , " Haan..."
Bollywood , " bus Isiliye!!"
but there are people who didnt see both expecting both will be crappy instead they choose anime ....
Aam aadmi: bollywood, why do you make such crappy movies?
Bollywood: kyon ki log wohi pasand karthe hain
Aam aadmi: bollywood, sach bathaoh!!!
Bollywood: Haaa haa chal boltha hoon😠. Hum intne saalomse movies banarahe tho poora ka poora movie distribution/market hum khudh control karte hain, aur hum acchey quality movies ko theatre mein nahi aane dete thaaki zyadha se zyadha log buddhu ban baitein. Lekin mujhe ye bathaon, tum "Aam aadmi" hoke aisi smart questions kabse poochne lage? Tumhe acche/bure films mein pharak kaise patha?
Aam aadmi: jabse 4g data plans aur ghar mein internet lagi, tabse thoda thoda smart bannelaga. Newton jaise movies dekkhe thoda socially aware bana-bhi.
Bollywood: Haa mujhe patha hain, lekin tujhe baaki sab Aam logon ki tharah yeh nahi patha ki Bollywood aur Independant Indian Cinema mein pharak hain. Isi liye Newton jaise independant films ke bare mein mujhe se baath kar rahan hain. Vaise movies mere bas ke baath nahi. Bus hindi movie hone ke nathe tuj jaise chootiye aisi independant movies ko bhi humaare bollywood category mein dalke critisize karthe hein. Is mein humara kya bigada? In fact humara compliment hua ki tum Newton ko bollywood material maanha 😆 So thank you!
Reletable.....
Maine judwa 2 nhi dekhi hai, but newton cinema hall me jake dekhi hai
@@rituchowdhury4755 dude so fucking true
This video is more important after Kabir Singh.
How ?
Even kabir singh was a surgeon
@@punyam6913
0:01-9:09
Y guys never question an Bollywood filmmaker only south director did this is an problem u never ask rape jokes from 3 idiots this we always separated
?
As a 16 year old i epitomised the whole notion of love the way bollywood has always portrayed. But now as a relatively woke 24 year old, i would laugh my ass off if any guy would act cheesy or would punch him hard if he tries being Rahul to my Anjali!
🤣🤣, same here. Actually as per pur films the guy should be pro in all the things like hum dil de chuke sanam bande ko patang udana bhi aana chahiye pro level pe 😝
To your anukriti , you mean ? 😜
Woke? I see the cancer of social justice warriors has infected India as well... :(
@@bluebirdman8185 If you ask me, India needs it.
@@dragonbane44 In what way? To divide the already divided communities further? In large part that's what they have done in the West. India needs reform but not in the name of a toxic ideology as so called "social justice".
Most under rated Indian youtube channel. That is the thing I want for Bollywood critics to do. Question things question the system. Tell the problems, pledge for a change but most of them are paid reviews anyway. Thanks for another good video.
Alcoholics refer to "Love at first sight." 😂
So damn funny
Great video. I believe Wake up Sid is the only movie which I've seen where the love story is beautifully shown.
lunchbox too was realistic and brilliant..
You should watch Premam (Malayalam movie)
Edit: I removed Arjun Reddy from the comment as I was a stupid 17 year old when I made that comment and I highly regret it.
Harshith Suryaprakash, I've watched Premam. I agree with you, great movie. Yet to watch Arjun Reddy.
Dhruvin Rathod but superficial makeup. And I bet she's a better actor than her performance in wake-up sid
Arjun Reddy? Seriosuly? That movie just proves the narrators point that you can get away with abuse if you are rich and handsome. The girl has no dialogues until they have sex dude! All we can see is a submissive terrified girl who becomes attached to the hero due to stockholm syndrome!
Somewhere the bollywood habit has also seeped into pre wedding videos.
Oh boy are those cringey.
Bc isme bollywood ki galti h had h bc 🖕
How sad that movies like Kabir Singh getting success rather than newton..
I don't what's the problem with Indian audience..
The same actor made haider but dude that was flop
@@vishwajeetnandyaduraj4804 mass element + heroism
5:42 'Rules: Pyar ka superhit formula' was one of my childhood favorites and is an underrated gem of a movie. Thanks for including this one amidst all these absurd love stories.
It is my favorite too
Don't include Darr in the list because the male lead was a psychopath so the stalking can be understood
Yes it's a different film
That ' Sukriya Sukriya ' blew my mind .. oh god.. i laughed so hard... Anyone else ??
Yes 😂
It depressed me, the contextual juxtaposition of it in this video.
At 3:16 you have included the poster of "When Harry met Sally".
It's not a typical Romantic movie.
It does not start with love at first sight or stalking or something else you mentioned.
It's the opposite. It starts with the pair not going well with each other, clash of opinions.
Then they dont even spend time with each other, they don't even become friends in the first place. They become friends gradually and after 5 or 10 years after they first met. They don't fall in love all of a sudden.
It's a good movie among the other posters you've included.
This is for the people who haven't seen the movie and think that it's a crappy movie.
It's not.
I'm not blaming the creator for this mistake. He might not have noticed it.
Great content by the way.
All the best to the channel.
But love shown is MASAAN was decent
utsav kumar completely agree
utsav kumar but 99% Bollywood is not masaan
Agreed. Masaan is one of the best Hindi cinemas but most underrated my mainstream
I also watched Masaan because some "INTELLIGENT" people praised it... and that movie was Boring Confusing Meaningless and about some uninteresting rendom people. I like intelligent and innovative movies but Masaan was nothing and being praised unnecessarily by some people.
@@vegavisiaai2321 What ?? Tu pehla Banda hoga jisse Masaan pasand nhi aayi.. I loved it..
Great Video, Vinit Meshram .
I'm happy that there are people who actually understand what crap Bollywood has been providing us in the name of love. Thank you for making this video. ❤️❤️
Kami ky h
Wow such a great work mate. I'm sharing this my wife who is crazy about these movies. :D
Let us know how she reacted 🤣
@@DHRUVANK007haha.. I backed out thinking of alimony
Superbly presented by this gentleman.I think you are an introvert and deep thinker.
brilliant!!
there is a lot of effort put in writing, editing and most importantly referencing. Such work can put any of the 'TV shows' to shame.
This is pretty spot on, man, especially the ways in which the idea of 'true' love sometimes translates into something disturbing. Just one thing I'll point out is that while the importance of verbal communication needs to be emphasised, human beings have a tendency to communicate more through body language than through words, and while Bollywood has exaggerated it, intuitiveness and other forms of non-verbal communication, especially in couples which have been together for a some time, is perfectly acceptable and natural.
OMG , Your writing man, so tight, each every sentence on point
That Shukriya reference XD
Love is a skill that needs time and patience.....and if you think you aren't getting any better in it.........Ranbir Kapoor appears in the background 😂😂
The best Love story -
Before Trilogy.
Beautifully explained. All these things keep hitting my brain when I see the way love stories are represented in movies. Thanks😃
Not only does this flawed narrative of love impact our approach to love, it is also the other way around. An earlier video showed how not only cinema affects society but it is also the society which affects cinema.
I've seen the most beautiful romance in the Linklater trilogy, Before Sunrise, Before Sunset and Before Midnight.
Dark Commentor 2 yeah bro ..that is a such underrated master trilogy
It was dope....It was really adorable
Yes truly.
Totally agree. And also in BLUE VALENTINE
laughed so hard after your statement that the guy accepted her love and the shukriya shukriya song came!Great timing
I loved how you took up the movie 'Rules'. This flop of a movie is actually a good one, and not thaat bad. It's my mom's favourite movie, and I thought she was crazy, until I watched it again last week, after a gap of almost 8 years. Way ahead of it's time and brought a woman with desires into limelight, which was unique in 2003. Amazing stuff man, keep it up !
This is my favorite analysis from Vineet. Your videos will remain for ever. Om Shanti
Hi, there is a film called rashomon that I indent to talk about, a film that I think was way ahead of its time in terms of cinematic techniques, its cinematography and editing was so beautifully done that when you watch it, it feels like the film is flowing like a fluid, also I think the film raises a lot of philosophical questions and makes you think, akira kurosawa was one of the very few film makers of his time that were trying to attempt depth in their films. This is utterly irrelevant from the video, but I am curious about knowing your views on the film please.
This day I found this channel, I am astonished to see such a channel exists, and such content was there on TH-cam. Now I am questioning why we are going backwards.
He is no more. 🥺
Excellent portrayal of the facade that is Bollywood romantic movies. Great channel and looking forward to more.
Now all Indians, Pakistanis, Bengalis and Sri Lankans have weird ideas and expectations of love. People do not realise how much Bollywood has destroyed people’s perception on marriage.
This is one of the best videos I've come across in recent times. This dude talks real, I'm glad there are like minded people with the ability to explain what is what! You've got a subscriber in me bruh! Cheers.
So true... RIP vinit. Somehow someone actually said these atlast.
Finally someone said what was in the heart of many people about how pathetically love is portrayed in Indian movies. Loved your video, full credits for the effort. Keep up the good work.
Isliye hollywood love story bhut kam banata h 😂
this video was so ahead of its time man
I just so love your soothing voice😊 This essay was superbly humane. Just reveals your own harmony with your life and emotions💞
(And thanks a lot for digging up all those new memeworthy reactions. Honorable mention: "Meri aankhon mein dekho Nandani, OH MY GOD, vo pyaar nahi he" 😂😂😂 He is sooo shocked, he forgot to look shocked! 😂😂😂)
Watched it again today, away from wife ( college time love ) for 3 months due to coronavirus, made me think a lot deeper this time. Thanks for creating this.
Few departures from the normal narrative are Chalte Chalte,Yuva,Tamasha, Saathiya. Great vid man!
Fee Crux tamasha first half was good but second half was Shit
@@ejasulhaq8726 tamasha is overrated ? Lol thats why you don't deserve good movies.
Tamasha may not be greatest film but it is not overrated
LMFAO, "what alcoholics refer to as 'Love at first sight'" hilarious,!
Never in a million years could I think a Desi channel would be so damn amazing...bravo sir bravo
loved this video especially the last line you said if you are not getting good in love don't worry no one else is either.
I'm so glad to have discovered your channel.
OH MY GOD!I loved this! Your channel is easily one of my most favourites on youtube. Thanks man :)
This all because of non-sensical Yash Raj films.
flash Yash Raj films slap different bro
flash people in Russia, Mexico, Iran, UK and Canada love our movies
It was only after falling in love for the first time in teenage years that I realised that I have been fed lies by Bollywood all my growing up years...
Me too...I was having a crush on a girl and thinking that I love her....I never approached her but always stalked her...And also was heartbroken even without proposing...Don't know how and I also cried...Lol I am just a sick person or was
As much as I agree with the most parts of your explanation, I feel you have shown only one side of the coin. Films, definitely affect and influence society but the process happens the other way round too. Films are a reflection of the society, as firstly, they are made by people emerging from the society itself and secondly those very films are the ones which people choose to go and watch. Having said that, I'm happy about the fact that there is an evident change in the society with the second decade of this century. Thanx to Internet and the power to choose the content you would want to watch at any time you want.
The films they made is not the reflection of our society I think u don't understand the because of this shit movies most of the teenage comit suicides(nas kaatlunga) and all that.
Absolutely correct. People go around thinking that everything is made up. Every movie we see is rooted in reality in some way. Takes observation to know.
He does mention how the movies derive the concepts of Romanticism
I discovered you late...you are awesome , its 2021 and you seem the best movie critic in youtube.
to fir problem Kya haiii?????
Main prem ki diwani hoon.... AWESOME!!!! It's so accurate man...
kageyama tobio to tumhe kya problem hai? Chalte bano
kageyama tobio Kanan Gill reference?
Bilal Aslam hell yeah man!
the problem is we who want to change our views on movies
This was a very well made video. What amazed me was the myriad issues you touched ; consent, appropriateness and of course the deep philosophical insights that you provided.
Keep up the good work.
Just came across your video. And I would like to point out wherein you mentioned about this delusion that when in love we won't have to express anything but the other person will himself/herself know. I can tell you that I have myself done this past. And guess movies do have major impact in our lives. These things are not possible in real life. Communication is a major part of any relationship. The other person in not Parmatma that he/she will know everything going on in our minds. And these can sometimes be a reason of breaking down a relationship. Thank Goodness, I realized this.
I wish this video was an hour long. Your voice is very soothing and rejuvenating.
Romanticism movement was inclined towards the artistic expression of one's own inner feelings, thoughts, motivations, etc. I'd say it was much less to do with sex than you're indicating it be
Hey Vinit... I am so glad I found this channel... You are rational, brutal and to the point... Keep making videos please.
Your videos are so good...They deserve millions of views...
Much awaited video on Romanticism. Marvellous one.
It can't be denied that these movies affected us thoroughly over the years. The idea of love is imposed on us by these movies in the manner they wanted. No one tried to experiment. Though I think that Imtiaz somewhere changed the way we used to see love stories but at the same time he lacks many things you mentioned in your video.
I wish you would bring out your version of love on-screen some day.
And again fabulous video. Good work. Thanks.
I suddenly feel disgusted for the idea I was carrying about love. Bollywood has ruined the idea of my love. I think I need to start over.
For me, love is the highest level of intimacy that adds value to our lives and gives us comfort. Someone who accepts and likes us the way we are. People who love each other help us become the best version of ourselves. And this is very rare to find but not impossible. For this we should be open to meeting someone and be present by removing all the stereotypes.And if you don't get it, then work on yourself. Do anything that makes you happy. You will definitely get it sometime.
great analysis. keep up the good work.
Btw, recently, I had to do a case study in my class about a product in any industry(I am doing Industrial & Production Engineering). So I chose to do a case study of Gangs Of Wasseypur. And your video helped a lot to provide artistic analysis.
So, thanks for that.
This is very quickly becoming a favorite channel of mine.
Just keep on doing what you do dude...Amazing! Criticism and analysis of cinema especially in the Indian context is very important.❤
Very apt! Thanks Vinit !
Only people like you can save bollywood from the downhill.
NEVER HAVE I EVER SEEN A VIDEO MORE PERFECT THAN THIS.
I WORSHIP THIS CHANNEL NOW.
PEACE, BROTHER.
MAY THE FORCE BE WITH YOU, ALWAYS.
Perfect Man!! Seriously Perfect video!!
I'm getting school of life vibes from your videos. Love how easily you are able to dismantle these long held notions. +1 Subscriber 😉
Shukriya shukriya blew my mind 😀
you deserve a lot more recognition. A LOT MORE .
A channel Worth Subscribing.. Nice Content and work
Your perception and the way you articulate your thoughts is commendable. Please upload more such videos!
Great video as always.
My suggestion: Start a parallel channel with the same content in Hindi as well. I want to share these videos to many people but many of them are not comfortable with English.
You do a very good analysis of movies either hollywood, bollywood or any other in every video.
Man 'o Man, where were u buddy? Twice/Thrice in a week I used to check your channel to find a new video.
Please make don't go away for so long and keep making videos more frequently, your ardent follower.
Much needed channel. Kudos my man.
I have watched other videos made by you and this was the best! I felt that in most of your videos you analyze films based on technical aspects of filmmaking and citing examples to explain those technical concepts and elaborate their application. In This video, however, you engage with questions of representation .i.e representation of love, of gender and how that shapes viewers' mindsets. Thanks for that! I would also like to add that Bollywood cinema propagates a narrow idea of who can be in a relationship or in love, usually young males and females. Same sex love, or love between older people is disastrously represented or is completely absent.
Such an underatted channel he is not roasting bollywood just like other youtubers. He is really stating the factss
This is something that we discuss everyday. There are so many stories about India but Bollywood thinks that the only topic that is worth making a movie is LOOOOOVVVVVEEE. I've taken a break from Bollywood after 'Jagga Jasoos' because I can't waste my money watching these half-arsed movies. I prefer to watch movied that're coming on Amazon Prime, like Trapped and Death in the Gunj. But no more of this mainstream horseshit until Bollywood realises what a skewed reality they're portraying. Thanks for making this video!
Amazon prime add more bad movies than some good movies!
Pramit Chatterjee well said man. This is want I am doing now
It's slowly changing my friend. There has been more variety added in Bollywood and thankfully people are accepting the change. Movies with new ideas are getting better
The reason is simple. These filmmakers in Bollywood live mostly lavish lives and have zero clue about the lives of the common man. They have ample time for love, relationships, breakups and such nonsense since they don't have to worry about jobs, financial security and education that an everyday man faces. So for them love is the only topic in life these other issues can be lived without.
@@adityakulkarni7889 bollywood fiction movie nhi banta h isliye bollywood ko gali padti h bas
I know there are very few who can or I should say want to think this way. people have a tendency to follow others. They look for a pre-built path to go on.
amazing video, kudos to you !!
Wow, awesome video. One request though, I am French and watching your videos because I am interested in Indian culture, especially cinematic. I would be so grateful if you could add some English subtitles to the parts in Hindi. Thanks!
+Dustin Billon Sure Dustin!
@@CinemaBeyondEntertainment I HOPE YOU'LL READ IT. Hi Vinit. Huge Admirer. Just got this great news of 2.0. So, just had a humble request this time pls review 2 movies
1. Ek main air ekk tu
2. Lagaan
And if you get time review some satyajit ray movies also. I really think only you are capable of dissecting ray cinema totally & answer that: Did he make cinematic poetry or just poverty p*rn disguised as artistic cinema that can be exported to the west in an attempt to win international awards. Please do answer this question. A whole new generation wants to know the REAL meaning of RAY cinema from a person who actually understands cinema. Please be very brutally honest.
This might have been the best video I've ever seen on TH-cam! Truth has become a hard slap on cheeks rather than evoking a sense of enlightenment. You've spoken the truth. And I'm thankful to know there are people who think the same way as I do. 🙌❤️
I'm not Indian, but since I started watching Bollywood films I really loved them and I deeply respect and appreciate the amount of work and effort that goes into a production of a Bollywood film. They're master pieces. There's truly nothing like Bollywood films. That being said, you're absolutely right and spot on with your analysis. One other thing that really strikes me with all Bollywood films that some audience might run the danger of believing would occur in their realities, is just the profound amount of coincidences and conveniences that end up working out in the protagonist's favour. All the protagonist has to do, is just be brave and take risks on an adventure and everything will somehow always work out in the end, exactly how he/she wants it. In some films it gets to a point where you think: "Come on, I know this is a movie, but even for a movie's standard this is gone too far". No matter where the two potential lovers go and what they do, fate somehow brings them back (it's just meant to be). I'm sure some people believed in this at some point and soon were very disappointed to find out that's just not reality.
lol
Glad to know India also has youth like you
This video deserves to be in trending ❤️
yet again brother... you did it... it was awesome
Video is amazing ... Completely logical. Even i think I ll write a article in marathi to promote this video n so the thought
Wow you brought up some amazing points. This notion of finding the most flawless person and falling in love with them is ridiculous! Reality is far from perfect.
A great analysis, needless to say. But I don't think that bollywood movies ruined love because of the way they portrayed love.
Yes, the way they portrayed, and continue to portray, love is not real. But, many people watch movies because they are not real, because they display something which serves as a respite from the real world, an escape. At least, that's how cinema watchers approached movies in the beginning.
Bollywood destroyed the notion of love because they keep on showing the same thing again and again and because there was no one who could show love in the real way, in mainstream cinema.
According to me, we need both realistic and "imaginary make-believe" cinema in our industry running parallelly with equal amount of target audience in the box office.
But I agree that it has to some extent, distorted our concept of love in the real life.
This has to be your best video so far.
Thank you!! Thank you!! Finally somebody addresses the gigantic Mamoth of Bollywood representation of askewed love out in public. This video is a must watch for every teenager along with Sex-Ed. It will definitely draw a line between creepy and romantic