Only a fool would think that he's bothered about us ... Somebody powerful has given him all the documents for exposure.. probably a wronged business man. Adani took businesses that NEVER belonged to him by force !! This is the price that Modani will pay for wrong doings😂😂
@@leonash1808 Short-selling is not the problem. But creating a scare to force a market crash, in order to execute that short, is indeed manipulation. Hindenberg is bear version of Harshad Mehta. Mehta was encouraging market sentiment to raise prices for his long positions. HBerg is discouraging market sentiment to drive down prices for short positions.
Short selling is not illegal but defaming institutions or Corporates without proper evidence and causing loss to all investors is not correct..sitting in US, throwing mud on Indian companies and institutes,and considering oneself to be beyond any scrutiny is height of arrogance and also can cause major losses to retail investors as well as foreign investors wanting to invest in our country
The real question is not about SEBI. The real question is about the trustworthiness of USA based so called investigative entities and credit rating agencies. I am really disappointed that these entities are just a lot of zero value gas that tries to promote an agenda. I think we should start ignoring them.
Prof. RV Sir, Short seller is someone who has already taken a position in the market by shorting the share and will buy when the Share price will come down.
5:53 he din’t understand short selling. 1)Hindenburg will borrow stocks at 100 2)Sells at 100 3) release the news 4) stock price goes to 80 5) buy stock from market for 80 6) return the stock to owner and keep the difference of 20 as profit
There are lot people like Anil Singhvi of Zee Business and many other business news channels can explicitly explain about Short selling/Long/Short position taking in day/futures trading. This is America's business " earn by any means "and Indian Opposition's business " cry louder when ever there is a chance ".
Somebody is making an Allegation ..Why cant the Government initiate a probe on the allegation instead of saying its politically motivated.. When disclosures are very stringent for publically listed companies , the same should apply to the SEBI Chief .. Apart from her investments in the IIFL fund ..we should know how she was running a consulting firm on the side (both in Singapore and India)and who the Clients were..
Short selling involves borrowing a security whose price you think is going to fall and then selling it on the open market. You then buy the same stock back later, hopefully for a lower price than you initially sold it for, return the borrowed stock to your broker, and pocket the difference. Without knowing such a simple definition how Prof RV was professor at Management institution?
Dear Prof Suraj Kumar, IIM should have hired you instead of Prof. RV! While your "simple" definition may be technically correct, it might have lost to lesser mortals of PGURUS audience. Prof. RV's simpler definition (while technically inaccurate) catches the spirit of the deal accurately. It may be one of the reasons why he was a popular professor at IIM and still has successful blogs even after retirement.
But things get complicated, when you force a market crash, by spreading canards, that too on behalf of some other actor like Kingdon capital, and take a cut. Hindenberg is no activist. He is an agent of other short-seller, masquerading as an activist.
My understanding of short selling is that Hindenberg would have already forward sold Adani at 90 and will then bring down current price of say 100 to 80 by releasing its damning report. Then it would buy at the crashed price at say 80 and settle its forward sale at 90. So Hindenberg would make a profit of 10 in this way.
How can Hindenburg make an ENQUIRY? They can only make a STUDY. Every company aims to expand its operations and revenue. Sadly for us Hindenburg chose to expand in to India.
Iyer ji.Appreciate your concern for eradicating corruption in higher places.But criticising NDA rule based on a foreign controvercial agency is unfortunate.
I dont agree that share market should be ignored, the number of retail investors directly and through mutual funds have gone up considerably and now NPS and LIC are also investing much more funds in markets..if there is a loss, it affects many today compared to 90s..
Shree Iyer, as recommended by Prof RV, I wish and pray P Gurus become a popular global channel, propelled and directed by you, championing Indian interests. Let us dream this, work for this and achieve this in the next couple of years. !!!@
What happened to Professor RVs I thought he was sick according to what shreeji said yesterday I'm glad to see that he's well or was this recording before he got sick
Iyer, Rahul contacts Hindenberg to do an article on Indian stocks/markets. Rahul supplies some cash + info. Info is validated by Hindenberg. Prepares an article. Rahul spices it salt and pepper. Before release of report Rahul + friends take a short position in the stock/markets. News released. Rahul amplified it. Short position covered after the stock/markets fall. Now is there a crime? What is the crime? Who is the perpatrator of the crime? Who is the enforcer of the law? What are they doing? Have they done anything before? If not, what is to be done?
Don’t worry about SEBI ! Worry about the fellows who appointed the SEBI chief. Institutions are only as good as the people who manage them. What were their intentions ?
@6:01 I am not sure what Professor RV said about short selling. The aim of short seller is to borrow the shares of a stock from a brokerage and sell it in open market (market rate or current stock price), release the short report that they are short X Stock. if the market thinks their thesis has any validity they will also sell the shares until the management responds point by point on short thesis. if company fails to do so they short seller can buy the stock for much cheaper price and give back stock to brokerage and close their short position. There by making spread (sold price - bought price) they don't make much unless market agrees with them some times it can go opposite direction then they can loss lot of money.
Many have mentioned about my "short sales comment" Two reasons --Time constraint since Iyer wanted to close in 30 min plus it is simple expln for dummies//Did not want to go into details//Hope this clarify
Can the research enterprises use the data without informing/seeking permission & publish reports without approval from the data source. Secondly are their objectives open to public. What is the role of government in which the such enterprises are registered.
@@vatsalaprsoni808 bullshit. Adani has trampled over lots of businesses that NEVER belonged to him. This is the price Modani will pay for the wrongdoings. Adani is hated in the business community bcos he's muscled and taken over other ppls family business forcibly... U would hate him too if he did it to you 😂
@@vatsalaprsoni808 , it's SEBI chief is facing the flak for covering up ADANI's dirt ... the matter still rests with Adani bcos she's involved with Adani via her offshore holdings and that Ahuja guy who is on the Adani board. Looks like u missed what the entire episode is about. Ask yourself who has given Hindenburg such private documents which would only be available to Indian govt or tax authorities or somebody in Singapore bcos the offshore dealings were from Singapore.
@@kurshymaster3408 America has been a superpower for the last 100 years. They have destroyed every country that challenged them,, When Japan challenged them, they destroyed them,, When USSR challenged them, they broke them into 17 pieces,, When Iraq raised its head, they destroyed them Nowadays it is China's turn. For the last 100 years, American industrialists have dominated the top ten industrialists of the world,, Out of the top 10, 8,,9 are only American industrialists, no one else is far away,,, When China's "Jake Ma" secured the third position, ""lobbying" started against him and he had to run away,, America's strength is its industry, it controls the whole world on the strength of technology and business,, If any country or industrialist will compete or challenge them, they will destroy them by spending billions of rupees,,, In the last five years, Indian industrialist "Adani" has reached a high position He was flying high,,, last year he had become the second largest industrialist of the world,, if this pace had continued, he would have become the world's largest industrialist in 2024,, the world looks towards India,, India is running a campaign of "Make in India",, India is a very big market,, if India becomes self-reliant in the coming 20 years then,, America,, Europe,, China,,, Arab world will have to bear huge losses,, Indian rupee will keep getting stronger against dollar $,,, Lobbying has started in India too,,, there is no dearth of "Pappus" in every country,,, Media can be bought,,, TH-cam,, Facebook,, Google,,, Twitter, all these platforms belong to America, it can run a campaign against anyone whenever it wants,, In India There is no dearth of fools, Pappus, Jaichands, traitors, All this is not easy in China, there is no democracy there, It is not easy to spread propaganda, lies, China itself is stopping India from progressing. There are more challenges for "India" in the coming times, America had spent billions, trillions of dollars in raising organizations like "Taliban" against Russia in Afghanistan, It is even easier to destabilize India, there is no dearth of traitors and treacherous people here, look at the statements of some of the leaders here, they are openly working like foreign agents, judges are sold, media is sold, leaders are for sale, India cannot become a "superpower" until the people of India "wise"" become clever,, India is a very big market, no country would want "India becomes self-reliant" so the governments that say such things will have to be toppled,, Foreign powers want a "mixed" government in India,,, who are always afraid of the government falling,, If there is a corrupt government, they can make policies, rules and laws according to their own wishes,, it will be easy to do business in India,, on necessary conditions,, India has a stable and strong government for the last ten years,, There is trouble,, it is making its own industrialists strong,, their wings will have to be clipped, the strength of any country is its "industrialists" who market the skills and things of their country abroad,, The government's job is to protect their interests,,, If today "" Adani, Ambani, Tata, Mahindra are challenging the world, then are these traitors of our country who are celebrating their destruction not foreign agents?? Recognize him, he is the same Jaichand. This Jaichand is such a poisonous snake in the sleeve that he finds happiness in every anti-India thing. They are not ready to accept any data or report related to the progress of the country, but if they see anything against the country anywhere, they go mad with happiness. The media is helpless, it is for sale, it will not question these traitor leaders, It will not bring out the truth, But we are not helpless.......
So which parties have supported the deep sea port in kerala. Both parties taking the credit for completion of the port which is best ports at this moment in India
Pl comment about Rahul who is crying about to resign seriously chairman n advice to investors not invest in Indian market which is ultimate destruction of india economy
There is need to break the monopoly of NSE. We need to as many as 6 stock exchange and they should be connected to each other by law. Every exchange should be owned by different owner. Citizens should be allowed to trade in all 6 and software to care of best deals. This itself will bring lot of stability in stock market. We need to chalange the mindset of govt of having single or two exchange. Today technology can do this very easily. Competition brings fairness in business.
Prof R Vaidyanathan You claim IIM pedigree so Why do you misguide people on the simple definition of short selling I’m sure you know it is not making money if the price comes back but buying future contracts Why should anyone blindly support SEBI people. Are you certain they are clean like your narrative suggests (Couched caution notwithstanding)
The prof often goes completely off-topic, but those off-topic stories are great fun, and I look forward to them. This time he unfortunately pretty much stuck to the topic. Boring.
They have no business to make a report. Unless they have been prompted.
Is is short selling illegal? If you cannot play a bouncer ball then you have no right to be a batsman.
Only a fool would think that he's bothered about us ... Somebody powerful has given him all the documents for exposure.. probably a wronged business man. Adani took businesses that NEVER belonged to him by force !! This is the price that Modani will pay for wrong doings😂😂
@@leonash1808 Short-selling is not the problem.
But creating a scare to force a market crash, in order to execute that short, is indeed manipulation.
Hindenberg is bear version of Harshad Mehta. Mehta was encouraging market sentiment to raise prices for his long positions. HBerg is discouraging market sentiment to drive down prices for short positions.
@@leonash1808 Short selling is illegal if it is you who is manipulating thus.
Short selling is not illegal but defaming institutions or Corporates without proper evidence and causing loss to all investors is not correct..sitting in US, throwing mud on Indian companies and institutes,and considering oneself to be beyond any scrutiny is height of arrogance and also can cause major losses to retail investors as well as foreign investors wanting to invest in our country
The real question is not about SEBI.
The real question is about the trustworthiness of USA based so called investigative entities and credit rating agencies.
I am really disappointed that these entities are just a lot of zero value gas that tries to promote an agenda.
I think we should start ignoring them.
Please ignore and stand in queue to get US visas for your family and earn dollars like PGGuru. LOL.
Pl ask why Rahul is crying
Hindenberg must do a report on UK water companies.
@@vatsalaprsoni808 Also a report on the sunnak and his corrupt wife evading taxes in UK. LOL.
Hope Professor RVs wishes come true. PGURUS certainly deserves a space on the TV.
Prof. RV Sir, Short seller is someone who has already taken a position in the market by shorting the share and will buy when the Share price will come down.
SEBI is not above the rules. Common people have to provide every proof time and time again, be it KYC or other dealings,
5:53 he din’t understand short selling.
1)Hindenburg will borrow stocks at 100
2)Sells at 100
3) release the news
4) stock price goes to 80
5) buy stock from market for 80
6) return the stock to owner and keep the difference of 20 as profit
He said it correctly. Please listen again.
@@mohitkumbhat he said
Release the news
Bring down the price
Buy low
Wait for price to go up
This is not short selling
Oh please 🙄 he knows more about short selling than you will ever know! He is putting it simply for the sake of audience.
Yes very intresting to hear Prof RV.
There are lot people like Anil Singhvi of Zee Business and many other business news channels can explicitly explain about Short selling/Long/Short position taking in day/futures trading. This is America's business " earn by any means "and Indian Opposition's business " cry louder when ever there is a chance ".
Somebody is making an Allegation ..Why cant the Government initiate a probe on the allegation instead of saying its politically motivated..
When disclosures are very stringent for publically listed companies , the same should apply to the SEBI Chief ..
Apart from her investments in the IIFL fund ..we should know how she was running a consulting firm on the side (both in Singapore and India)and who the Clients were..
Shree Iyer ji - prof RV is always full of praise for Sachin , surely not without reason . Let’s see him one day if you do t mind . 😊
Short selling involves borrowing a security whose price you think is going to fall and then selling it on the open market. You then buy the same stock back later, hopefully for a lower price than you initially sold it for, return the borrowed stock to your broker, and pocket the difference.
Without knowing such a simple definition how Prof RV was professor at Management institution?
Dear Prof Suraj Kumar, IIM should have hired you instead of Prof. RV! While your "simple" definition may be technically correct, it might have lost to lesser mortals of PGURUS audience. Prof. RV's simpler definition (while technically inaccurate) catches the spirit of the deal accurately. It may be one of the reasons why he was a popular professor at IIM and still has successful blogs even after retirement.
Not necessarily he knows.Even those in financial industry doesn't know.
But things get complicated, when you force a market crash, by spreading canards, that too on behalf of some other actor like Kingdon capital, and take a cut.
Hindenberg is no activist. He is an agent of other short-seller, masquerading as an activist.
JAI HIND, BHARAT MATA KI JAI.
Namaskar Shreeji and Prof Rvji 🙏💐
My understanding of short selling is that Hindenberg would have already forward sold Adani at 90 and will then bring down current price of say 100 to 80 by releasing its damning report. Then it would buy at the crashed price at say 80 and settle its forward sale at 90. So Hindenberg would make a profit of 10 in this way.
🙏🏼👍Jai Hind Jai Bharath
RV ji ur a lot sensible person on this Channel
Great talk !
What else do you expect from our internal enemies.. (TRAITOR I N D I A ALLIANCE)
Correct Sir
no common man knows the truth. we can just speculate
How can Hindenburg make an ENQUIRY? They can only make a STUDY. Every company aims to expand its operations and revenue. Sadly for us Hindenburg chose to expand in to India.
Absolutely right Sir.trying to find a needle in the hay stack.
Iyer ji.Appreciate your concern for eradicating corruption in higher places.But criticising NDA rule based on a foreign controvercial agency is unfortunate.
Why they dont report on US companies is it is in their jurisdiction and hence can be taken to court..
I dont agree that share market should be ignored, the number of retail investors directly and through mutual funds have gone up considerably and now NPS and LIC are also investing much more funds in markets..if there is a loss, it affects many today compared to 90s..
Shree Iyer, as recommended by Prof RV, I wish and pray P Gurus become a popular global channel, propelled and directed by you, championing Indian interests. Let us dream this, work for this and achieve this in the next couple of years. !!!@
Fine defense of Madhavi and Sebi against Hindenburg. On any account,you will never find fault with Sebi. Psychophancy.
What happened to Professor RVs I thought he was sick according to what shreeji said yesterday I'm glad to see that he's well or was this recording before he got sick
Iyer,
Rahul contacts Hindenberg to do an article on Indian stocks/markets. Rahul supplies some cash + info.
Info is validated by Hindenberg. Prepares an article. Rahul spices it salt and pepper.
Before release of report Rahul + friends take a short position in the stock/markets.
News released. Rahul amplified it. Short position covered after the stock/markets fall.
Now is there a crime? What is the crime? Who is the perpatrator of the crime? Who is the enforcer of the law? What are they doing? Have they done anything before? If not, what is to be done?
What about the information?
Don’t worry about SEBI ! Worry about the fellows who appointed the SEBI chief. Institutions are only as good as the people who manage them. What were their intentions ?
Last few sessions with Prof Vaidyanathan there is lag in the video.Please check the bandwidth.
It is pain to watch Prof.R.V's video, which is stopping most of the time. Plz take corrective action.
These reports are good to get information to public but there must be someone having vested interest in particular.
The vested interest is Kingdon Capital.
Hindenberg is no activist. Their whole MO, is to spread canards, force a crash, and make money.
Who is Hindenburg?? 😡😡😡
@6:01 I am not sure what Professor RV said about short selling. The aim of short seller is to borrow the shares of a stock from a brokerage and sell it in open market (market rate or current stock price), release the short report that they are short X Stock. if the market thinks their thesis has any validity they will also sell the shares until the management responds point by point on short thesis. if company fails to do so they short seller can buy the stock for much cheaper price and give back stock to brokerage and close their short position. There by making spread (sold price - bought price) they don't make much unless market agrees with them some times it can go opposite direction then they can loss lot of money.
Namaskaram Sri Iyar Sir.
Many have mentioned about my "short sales comment" Two reasons --Time constraint since Iyer wanted to close in 30 min plus it is simple expln for dummies//Did not want to go into details//Hope this clarify
Short selling means selling at current price and buying when its down. Example : sell at 100 first and buy at 70.
Can the research enterprises use the data without informing/seeking permission & publish reports without approval from the data source. Secondly are their objectives open to public. What is the role of government in which the such enterprises are registered.
Government doesn't have much role. Even if case is filed it will not be stand in judiciary since courts supports open data policies.😮
Blackrock
How does Sachin look like? this query was there with me for very long and Prof RV mentioned that he is shy and will not come front of camera :-)
U turn by Pgurus after the markets rejected the Hindenburg report 2.0 ?
This guy clearly does not understand what short selling is.
Who is funding Hindenburg to research and making reports on Indian matters?
Soros
@@vatsalaprsoni808 bullshit. Adani has trampled over lots of businesses that NEVER belonged to him. This is the price Modani will pay for the wrongdoings. Adani is hated in the business community bcos he's muscled and taken over other ppls family business forcibly... U would hate him too if he did it to you 😂
@@kurshymaster3408 you need to go research before babbling away non sensical comment...this talk is about hindenberg and SEBI.
@@vatsalaprsoni808 , it's SEBI chief is facing the flak for covering up ADANI's dirt ... the matter still rests with Adani bcos she's involved with Adani via her offshore holdings and that Ahuja guy who is on the Adani board. Looks like u missed what the entire episode is about. Ask yourself who has given Hindenburg such private documents which would only be available to Indian govt or tax authorities or somebody in Singapore bcos the offshore dealings were from Singapore.
@@kurshymaster3408 America has been a superpower for the last 100 years. They have destroyed every country that challenged them,,
When Japan challenged them, they destroyed them,, When USSR challenged them, they broke them into 17 pieces,,
When Iraq raised its head, they destroyed them
Nowadays it is China's turn.
For the last 100 years, American industrialists have dominated the top ten industrialists of the world,, Out of the top 10, 8,,9 are only American industrialists, no one else is far away,,,
When China's "Jake Ma" secured the third position, ""lobbying" started against him and he had to run away,,
America's strength is its industry, it controls the whole world on the strength of technology and business,,
If any country or industrialist will compete or challenge them, they will destroy them by spending billions of rupees,,,
In the last five years, Indian industrialist "Adani" has reached a high position He was flying high,,, last year he had become the second largest industrialist of the world,, if this pace had continued, he would have become the world's largest industrialist in 2024,, the world looks towards India,,
India is running a campaign of "Make in India",, India is a very big market,, if India becomes self-reliant in the coming 20 years then,, America,, Europe,, China,,,
Arab world will have to bear huge losses,, Indian rupee will keep getting stronger against dollar $,,,
Lobbying has started in India too,,, there is no dearth of "Pappus" in every country,,, Media can be bought,,,
TH-cam,, Facebook,, Google,,,
Twitter, all these platforms belong to America, it can run a campaign against anyone whenever it wants,,
In India There is no dearth of fools, Pappus, Jaichands, traitors,
All this is not easy in China, there is no democracy there,
It is not easy to spread propaganda, lies, China itself is stopping India from progressing.
There are more challenges for "India" in the coming times,
America had spent billions, trillions of dollars in raising organizations like "Taliban" against Russia in Afghanistan,
It is even easier to destabilize India, there is no dearth of traitors and treacherous people here, look at the statements of some of the leaders here, they are openly working like foreign agents, judges are sold, media is sold, leaders are for sale,
India cannot become a "superpower" until the people of India "wise"" become clever,,
India is a very big market, no country would want "India becomes self-reliant" so the governments that say such things will have to be toppled,, Foreign powers want a "mixed" government in India,,, who are always afraid of the government falling,,
If there is a corrupt government, they can make policies, rules and laws according to their own wishes,, it will be easy to do business in India,, on necessary conditions,,
India has a stable and strong government for the last ten years,,
There is trouble,, it is making its own industrialists strong,, their wings will have to be clipped, the strength of any country is its "industrialists" who market the skills and things of their country abroad,, The government's job is to protect their interests,,,
If today "" Adani, Ambani, Tata, Mahindra are challenging the world, then are these traitors of our country who are celebrating their destruction not foreign agents??
Recognize him, he is the same Jaichand.
This Jaichand is such a poisonous snake in the sleeve that he finds happiness in every anti-India thing. They are not ready to accept any data or report related to the progress of the country, but if they see anything against the country anywhere, they go mad with happiness.
The media is helpless, it is for sale, it will not question these traitor leaders,
It will not bring out the truth,
But we are not helpless.......
As long as there are OGW, these nonsense reports keep coming.
Burkhee is making a big thing! Questions Mr Pi
OMG PGuruji your guest doesn’t even know how short sell works and he is lecturing on Hindenburg.
They went after many USA corporates.
Mr RV video as always stops and distubing🙂
Hidden Bug hidden agenda?
Common man like me is least bothered about this matter.
Collective Bajan of R.V.
No Indian group does this sort of research and advise and expose if any thing not followed legal and did against the interest of public and investors?
There are many. Previously reports were released on companies like Infosys, BSE, MCX etc..Creates chows for few days.😢
What about Madhabi Buch accepted the allegations?
PLZ BRING SACHIN FOR FACE TO FACE INTRODUCTION...!!!
Would like to see Sachin..
All top brokers should unite and bring up price top level than hinden and cong will keep quite
He is a big modi bhakth
No one will believe these people.
They r misguiding the investors
Do you mean Hidenberg's report is factual? If so come out with analysis before attributing motives to people/professionals
So which parties have supported the deep sea port in kerala. Both parties taking the credit for completion of the port which is best ports at this moment in India
Currupt SEBI
False provoking
Why india to worry about hindunburg n rahul is given data to make a tool kit to kit india
Pl ask Rahul
Pl comment about Rahul who is crying about to resign seriously chairman n advice to investors not invest in Indian market which is ultimate destruction of india economy
If it had happened without Rahul Gandhi announcing the hindenberg report then Bharat would have believed the report.
There is need to break the monopoly of NSE. We need to as many as 6 stock exchange and they should be connected to each other by law. Every exchange should be owned by different owner. Citizens should be allowed to trade in all 6 and software to care of best deals. This itself will bring lot of stability in stock market. We need to chalange the mindset of govt of having single or two exchange. Today technology can do this very easily. Competition brings fairness in business.
PGurus is definitely source of current affairs analysis etc. for me. I have stopped watching so called main stream media.
Papus wants to create sensation. Brainless for good! Things!!!!
Video of Professor require more attention since max times are hang only voice is coming
Ankther bjp dallla....
Don't you think what ever he remarked about compliance, Reliance , accounts management, share market etc. Are correct. He has spoken frankly.😮
Very good analysis n advice for us indians
Prof R Vaidyanathan
You claim IIM pedigree so
Why do you misguide people on the simple definition of short selling
I’m sure you know it is not making money if the price comes back but buying future contracts
Why should anyone blindly support SEBI people. Are you certain they are clean like your narrative suggests
(Couched caution notwithstanding)
Not claim. It is reality. Even many in industry doesn't know the ABCD of short selling.
Short selling is it kegal
Yes, of course. Just that you sell at current prices and buy when prices go down.
P guru Hindi Mai bolenge jyada reach mileage / vaidynathan sir achieved Hindi bolte hain 😅
Why your videos always getting stuck all the times ... do some better infra for video interaction
The prof often goes completely off-topic, but those off-topic stories are great fun, and I look forward to them. This time he unfortunately pretty much stuck to the topic. Boring.
There has to be some link between hindenburg and some Indian politicians and media people.
Is Rahul Gandhi blemish free?
R V Analysis is totally biased and lopsided. Lacks ethics.
Just like Harshad Mehta accused Narsimha Rao, Hindenberg is accusing Madhabi Buch.
He is a great bore.
Indian media should do a report on Hindenburg