The high notes in this can not be compared with anyone .. Altough Jimin's highnotes suprises me everytime and jungkook's and jin's voice drives me crazy but V has a baritone and knowing this .. its litterally very hard for someone to sing this high with this kind of deep voice ... Everytime I listen to this I get a feeling of respect for Taehyung
For a Baritone in KPOP, V has widest vocal range (as per real vocal analysts) of Eb2 ~ D6 (3 octaves, 5 notes and 1 semitone), which means he has potential of hitting high octaves with ease.
@@lll2282 see this is what I hate the most .. why do you stan only one ? Like yes JK's voice is definitely heaven but this is Stigma and it ain't has a single bit of his voice,right ? He himself won't like it that you are only and only his stan. Like for example: If it's about a sexy brain we should say Namjoon but some of the solo stans would name their bias instead .. woah!!
Honestly I genuinely believe this song is for his siblings. Hear me out. In this particular album, all of their solos were personal, like really personal. Jungkook talks about his love for his hyungs, jimin talks about his struggle to genuinely smile, jhope talks about his appreciation for his mother, suga talks about his deep love for music, namjoon talks about his inner hatred and jin talks about his struggle with success. All of these are extremely personal. But its only taehyungs song that we never got the backrgound story of. And i believe its because it is related to his siblings, something that is extremely personal and private. Taehyung, like the majortity of the members, prefers to keep his siblings private to protect their identity. That being said, him refering to "my brother" and "my sister" is no coincidence. As we all probably know, stigma refers to a mark of disgrace. Taehyung probably sees himself as a 'disgrace' in the eyes of his siblings as he's not able to be their in person and 'protect' them physically like older siblings are expected to. His grandmother passed away this particular year as well, so him not being able to attend the funeral as the oldest son would have been a sign of 'betrayal' in his siblings eyes, even if they understood the reasons why he couldnt be there. Taehyungs 'sin' is that he went to pursue his dream as an artist leaving his family behind. Thats why no matter what he does, he cant 'erase it or hide it.' Taehyung values family. So the wound that this situation has given him only gets 'deeper and deeper.' His 'heart hurts everyday.' Siblings dont care much for money or wealth or success. Theyre proud and theyre happy, but more than that they just want their brother in their life. Deep down the love is there, but the situation makes it very hard for siblings to actually form strong bonds especially if this seperation happnens in their teen years- thats when people change and grow the most. Im not saying that they dont love him, but it would be hard to speak to someone you barely even know anymore or who barely even knows you now (as tae eluded to in his vlive how it’s been a long time since he’s spoken to his siblings). Anyway, this song really just hits in the feels. I have 4 siblings and my older brother left us to go work when we were younger. Im just speaking on the knowledge that i know how his siblings would feel and that the guilt that taehyung feels is normal. When you miss out in being in your siblings life at an early stage, it would make anyone feel sad especially if that was never what you intended for to happen. So conclusion? Taehyung is apologising to his siblings in this song and hopes that they will one day forgive him for becoming someone that they have trouble reaching. I think its a beautifully tragic song and it hits close to my heart. BTS is always deep with their music. Also this was just my take on it anyway, what’s yours? Guess we'll never really know unless taehyung tells it to us straight tho
This is so accurate and sad... He always says how much he loves his family.. I even remember when during a vlive he said that his younger brother don't talk to him that much and he feels really bad about it... But now i think its all fine.. You can see in his vocation vlog he went out with his bro and spend his holidays with his family instead of going outstations.
@Vanilla Cheesecake I don't think so... I mean, if he were gay, why would he apologize to his siblings about it, and who is he addressing when he said that someone else took the blame for it?? There are a lot of meanings and theories to it that any one of them could be right or wrong.
@Vanilla Cheesecake I can see why though. It's very deep, but something tells me that the meaning of the song might be something else. An example, might just be because he did something very wrong in his past that he deeply regrets.
Even with Jungkook, Jimin, and Jin being able to hit all those high notes, and they really can! No one, and I mean no one in the group has the massive range that V has. Seeing that his natural tone is baritone and he is able to hit that note at the end tells me how big his range is... Taehyung is such an old soul...and his enduring love for all music makes me admire him more. Seeing how he himself has said that Erik Benet (Halle Berry's ex husband) is one of his favorite singers...more admiration...
Its been 5 yrs. but this is still my fave Tae solo song!!! The fact that he wrote this lyrics and they never disclose the meaning behind this song, keep me up at night sometimes. I know that this could be a song inspired by his storyline in BTS HYYH but it could also be a song with much deeper personal meaning towards Tae. I really love to give him a big warm hug everytime I listen to it. This was such an underrated masterpiece!! 💜
do u have any interpretations of what the lyrics could mean to Tae? I read so many and i'm clueless which makes more sense. Maybe it could be a mix of both..
@@angelawang4660 It has 2 ways of perceiving in my sight, first coming out to his family but not being accepted and only being defined by that to himself or in the eyes of his family. Second, He left to pursue his dream at an early age when his siblings were also young, and now he regrets not being there for them and he and his siblings not growing up to be closer, and him not being able to protect them by being there and he feels like he is a sinner in their eyes. I definitely think it's the second one being the closest because he has always been a family oriented person and he wanted to be there for his siblings.
@@zunairaimtiaz4783 Dude first one is more accountable here. I just don't see how this can be relating to not being there for his siblings, why would that be a "Stigma" and why would you say "are calling me a sinner?" These are quite harsh words for a boy to have on his conscience, just because he pursued a career as a music artist and he had to commit his whole life to it. Beside he was taking care of his family by earning considering they were poor in the beginning so that was for their own good in some ways. And his siblings still had their parents to care for and support them. I'm sure they were thrilled for their brother's success and I'm sure that Tae was still a loving brother to them as often as he could be. I've never heard of any of the other members expressing guilt for not always being there for their siblings because of having to leave home to become a trainee (apart from Hobi maybe, I think he may have mentioned it at his sister's wedding, but it certainly didn't make him a "sinner").
@@arya.07 Exactly. At first i thought it might be about guilt of being an idol, but in 2015 Tae and his brother were talking a lot and in 2017 Tae said that his brother avoids talking to him so obviously something serious happened between them in 2016 and that’s when this song was written. In this song he said “are you calling me a sinner” to his brother, so it sounds like whatever confession he made (he describes making a confession at the first verse and revealing a secret that is killing him to keep) his brother called him a sinner for that confession. It sounds a lot like an lgbt song. The other members are close with their siblings even with busy schedules so it’s definitely deeper than that with Tae’s case. Also, right after this songs release date is when Tae started wearing a lot of LGBT pride gear which is what a lot of people do after coming out so…. i really don’t know, maybe it is about being lgbt… if it’s about leaving his siblings why cant he just say it ? Also, Namjoon confirmed that it’s about Tae’s real life and extremely personal so it’s not written for HYYH.
@@มาช่า-ญ9ณ Omg I've been meaning to reply to you for soo long but I wasn't able to for some reasons idk, but thank goodness I finally can. I appreciate your reply a lot, and tysmm for the timeline and facts, cause I didn't know about it. Many people interpret him not talking to his bro with him not being on good terms because of his busy trainee and idol life, but if he was on great terms even after debuting, then suddenly he wasn't and then this song comes out, then the first reason isn't valid at all. And suddenly he's using all the lgbtq terms living in a homophobic country, wearing lgbtq stuff, calling himself sinner and crime and stuff, his bro isn't talking, saying some famous lgbtq lines after coming out (I think Tae once said 'I'm still me' that the main character said in a movie after coming out, but I'm not sure whether Tae or JK said that. I watched that clip long ago and can't find it rn). And yeah you're right, most members, firstly, have good relationships with their siblings, despite some being busier than Tae, and secondly, reveal the meaning of their songs, even if it's very personal and controversial for S. Korea (Suga talked about mental health problems in his song even if it's such huge of a taboo there). Besides, I'm sure Tae, or at least Namjoon knew how this song would be interpreted as, as an lgbtq song, and even tho they support the community, them being associated with lgbtq could ruin their career in S. Korea, considering back then they didn't have a lot of international support, and imo, if this song wasn't about lgbtq, then they would've quickly explain the meaning and clear doubts, but still they didn't and that doesn't make sense if it is about Tae not being there for his bro. But honestly, even tho most chances are that this song is about lgbtq, we can't be 100% sure (tho I am like, 95% sure). Edit - That was so long but heyy, are you Swiftie?
Stigma opened up a wound that never healed in me..... 4 years ago a lady names miss Deb, was like a Grama to me, she was so kind and loving.... But she was diagnosed with cancer...she lived past what they said she would.... But one day I was at her house and she always had roses in her yard, I had a funny feeling and collected them because they were so beautiful, that was the last time I ever saw her......my mother told me that she had passed away. I forgot to tell her I loved her that day, I wish I would go back and tell her she meant so much to me.... But this song reminded me of that pain and I cried for the first time in 4 years about it, but afterwards I finally acknowledged what had happened and I could begin to heal.....thank you Kim Taehyung, you helped me heal and to remember to cherish the ones I love...because like those rose petals, everything is temporary.
Kim Taehyung, ты зачаровал нас утонченными глубинами своего восхитительного голоса. Это по новому индивидуальное и прекрасное видение жизни трепетно и волнительно . 2024
His voice is already so deep and he hits those high notes perfectly Well i know that you know that i know that we all know that we all TRIED to sing it. Ofc... i tried.... and every time his voice sounds deep or low i ended up singing it on a high note. But. Then I tried singing it on a normal tone and kinda low (to try to match him) and well i sounded like i have a cold. -___-
Ok, I am looking like, am I the only one seeing this. Being loyal to Jin, but I still love you…whaaaaaat. Anyway, they had me going for a min. That was my laugh for the week.
I remember a year ago listening to this trying to learn it by heart in Korean. After listening closely for a month and studying korean pronunciation, I finally learned it. Ha.
This song is so deeply personal to me, this album came out in one of the darkest times in my life, my entire family was falling apart and I, as the eldest daughter, was sort of forced to hold everything together... My mother fell into a deep depression where she tried to khs many times in front of me, my brother started hanging with a really rough crowd and began stealing and taking drugs while my father decided he wanted to move on in life without us.... It crushed me, I felt so alone and ashamed that nothing i could do would help us... everyone around me just said to me " be strong for your family" but no one offered any help... they just watched me lose myself from a distance, while we struggled to put food on the table at home. All our family friends turned their backs on us and we became the laughingstock of our church. I was so far away from everyone I cared about; I'd never felt so alone in my life. Every day was a battle to keep my head up and move on with my life but reassembling was proving to be so much harder than people made it out to be. This song was my cry for help, it spoke to me in ways no other piece of art has. In fact, this entire album encompassed exactly how I felt and how I still feel today while dealing with the after effects of the situation. The wings album is a tragically beautiful masterpiece, everyone can relate with at least one song in the track list, which Is sad but let us all draw together and find comfort in each other. That's why I love BTS so much... Wings opened our eyes to our pain and allowed us to lay all our hurt in front of our eyes, the follow up series Love Yourself reminded us that even though we are hurting and flawed, we still deserve to be loved and cared for ♥️
I hope you are doing well now!! As an eldest daughter and the current situation that I am in right now, I literally cried while reading your comment. You are right, BTS songs validate our feelings in a way no other artists have done. We are in this together, let's keep fighting!! More love and power to you from a fellow army 💟
Some people see this song as just a song. But the meaning behind the song is so so personal and deep that it makes me cry to comprehend it. Taehyung's songs always have these heavy messages that comes straight from his heart. I believe he was having a hard time when writing this song.
Kim Taehyung, ты зачаровал нас утонченными глубинами своего восхитительного голоса. Это по новому индивидуальное и прекрасное видение жизни трепетно и волнительно . Спасибо тебе ТАЛАНТ с большой буквы.2024
Taehyung's voice is so unique in every way, I have never seen or heard anyone else with a voice like his. His voice is usually so beautifully deep that when he did that high note I got genuinely shocked and replayed that moment over and over. The fact that not only him but every single member are so good at controlling their voices according to the song. One second their voices can be all cheerful and the next they can be deep and emotional.
Kim Taehyung, ты зачаровал нас утонченными глубинами своего восхитительного голоса. Это по новому индивидуальное и прекрасное видение жизни трепетно и волнительно . 2024
Ok, I got my new obsession today, aka BTS, and Taehyung's voice struck a cord in me. So soft, so soothing, so deep... I could fall asleep while listening to his voice.
**I BECAME AN ARMY BECAUSE OF THIS GUY** AND NOW HE IS MY BIAS AND I LOVE HIM SO MUCH, LAST WEEK I CRIED BECAUSE I KNEW I CANNOT SEE HIM IT'S REALLY SAD BUT I WILL SUPPORT HIM, AT LEAST HE LOVES ME AS A FAN AND I AM SO PROUD THAT HE IS MY BIAS💖
Same here I know it is so silly yet I cry at times realising that I can never meet them. Yet I still hope to meet them cuz no one knows destiny. So don't lose hope.
I was really upset today..... Because my mom told me that we are being transferred I couldn't believe what she said and left for my school crying my heart out and when I told that to my bestie she also cried very miserably and now after that am just jamming to this song..... I don't know why it gives me a little relief...
S solos tae 1.stigma 2.singularity 3.scenery 4. Sweet night Tae loves 's' words❤😅 Edit: woah 58 likes army borahae on this 1000th day of borahae. Edit 2: y'all I didn't expect this many likes , thank you. Also , I know there are other solos of tae , I have commented only the titles starting with the letter s. I purple you 💜 hwaiting!🌷
i feel like as an lgbt army this song resonates with me and all my lgbt armies. like im not saying he is a part of the community or anything but if you read the lyrics and think about internalised homopobia and growing up in a homophobic country a lot of things make sense. i mean even the title... i'm notforcing a sexuality on him, so don't take it that way, it just really touched me
No don’t apologize. The best art is art that speaks to people in different ways. The best part about music is that it can be there for us in the way we need it most.
Damn it's so sad that no one bothers or corrects a person if they wrote smth like 'BTS' future wives are so lucky' but you've to put up a whole disclaimer before saying that Taehyung might be gay, just so you don't get attacked, just goes on to show how close minded people can be... I hope these double standards change one day
I came back to this song because I was confused about my feelings. I started to read the comments and a lot of y’all mention that it speaks to y’all as lgbt. and honestly now I see why. I’ve been struggling to know my own sexuality and hearing this again is very relatable now. I feel that if I ever come out to my parents and siblings I will feel rejected, I’ll feel as if I have sinned. ‘Are you calling me a sinner?’ Really hit home. That’s exactly how I feel right now.
I hope you know that you aren’t obligated to come out, and I hope you know that if you want to come out, it’s better to do it when you’re ready. Don’t put so much pressure on yourself to come out or to figure out your sexuality. Take all the time you need in the world to figure it out. It could come to you today, tomorrow or a long time from now, just don’t put so much pressure on yourself and remember that you’re loved. Always. I love you 💜
@@jointhejincult5425 thank you, really. I really needed to hear that... woah omg thank you for your words, I’ll be sure to take my time. I’m glad there’s armys like you :) take care and you are loved too !💜💜
One thing else, if you’re not sure of your family’s reaction to you coming out or if you know it’s going to be negative, I suggest that you come out when you are in a stable place. As in, if they kick you out, you at least have somewhere to go. I know that it’s a very hard thought. But better safe than sorry. I plan to do the same thing. I don’t know what my mom feels about lgbtq. Her reaction to it is pretty…meh. Meh is not enough for me to come out to her. Stay safe :) best of luck to you 💜
i personally feel like taehyungs voice and vocal range is very underrated. i mean, yes, recognise him for his low voice but god, his high notes astonish me every single time. and the fact that he can go calm and soothing also is so beautiful 💜
omg I'm literally crying I'm speechless Jesus this is so damn deep and meaningful thank you so much to the songwriter, to the producer, to the lyricist and obviously to our wonderful tae, who gave everything to the feeling of this perfect song .
Sis don't worry honestly I can't relate to what I said be us old army Stan new army and a quick heads up don't fall for everything u see on the internet unless bts makes it clear :)
I was listening to this in class with my headphones on and when tae said “are you calling me a sinner” my friend had shouted yes and I started laughing and told him Good times
@@adelynejimenez8895 i think they're just stating that they said yes for something different at the exact time like a coincidence they didnt actually hear it
one thing i love about BTSs songs is that they're open to interpretation, and ur not wrong what ever u relate it to, i relate it to depression and anxiety, however thats mu opinion, everyone has their own opinion and this is what i love abt their songs, they value everyone and are considerate of everyones feelings 🥺🧡
숨겨왔어 I tell you something 그저 묻어두기엔 이젠 버틸 수가 없는 걸 왜 그땐 말 못 했는지 어차피 아파와서 정말 버틸 수가 없을 걸 Now cry 너에게 너무 미안할 뿐야 또 cry 널 지켜주지 못해서 더 깊이 더 깊이 상처만 깊어져 되돌릴 수 없는 깨진 유리 조각 같아 더 깊이 매일이 가슴만 아파져 내 죄를 대신 받던 연약하기만 했던 너 그만 울고 tell me something 용기 없던 내게 말해봐 “그 때 나한테 왜 그랬어?” “미안” 됐어 내게 무슨 자격 있어 이래보라고 저래보라고 너에게 말하겠어 더 깊이 더 깊이 상처만 깊어져 되돌릴 수 없는 깨진 유리 조각 같아 더 깊이 매일이 가슴만 아파져 내 죄를 대신 받던 연약하기만 했던 너 I’m sorry, I’m sorry I’m sorry ma brother 숨겨도 감춰도 지워지지 않어 “Are you calling me a sinner?” 무슨 말이 더 있겠어 I’m sorry, I’m sorry I’m sorry ma sister 숨겨도 감춰도 지워지지 않어 So cry Please dry my eyes 저 빛이 저 빛이 내 죄를 비춰줘 돌이킬 수 없는 붉은 피가 흘러내려 더 깊이 매일이 죽을 것만 같아 그 벌을 받게 해줘 내 죄를 사해줘 제발
I've really never felt this way about a song before, it's insane how so many years of pain and fear can be described in a short song like this. This really is how it feels when you feel like a walking, breathing punishment to the ones you love the most, yet the more you try to hide yourself, the deeper the wound gets.
Hi, I'm new to TH-cam, step FatmaNur I live in turkey. I share FMV videos. I'm trying to spread happiness with my videos ...... and am trying to entertain as many people as possible ...... ♡ Would you support me if I ask? Check out a channel, don't support me if you don't like it, but if you like it please support me💜💜💜💜💜
oh my god this song hits home for me. Apparently in this song Taehyung talks about how he sees himself as a disgrace because when his grandmother passed away and he wasn't able to be at her funeral, so it makes him feel like he betrayed his family. I can relate to this so much because my grandmother passed away but because of covid I didn't get to her as much before she passed. I was so sad and disappointed with myself and I thought it was all my fault. I feel like I betrayed my grandmother because I didn't get to see her. Now she is in heaven and she probably thinks I betrayed her😭😭😭
Taehyung's voice is doing things to my heart that I can't explain. Sometimes his voice hits freaking low notes that don't even exist, sometimes it's raspy and manly af and then there are times like this.... when he does high notes and it's enough to kill me
I notice that a lot of ppl in the comments are saying how this speaks to them from the perspective of someone queer, but then them saying that they're not saying they think Taehyung is queer or forcing him to be. But why is thinking he could be queer in someway disrespectful? And why do the people who think he's straight and say so and are not putting the same kind of thing abt how they're not going to force him to be anything and not getting any backlash from it? It's not a bad thing to be queer, and no one's forcing him to be. This comment section is really something.
great comment. its so rude when people assume that all members are straight. as an lgbt person myself, it was so hard for me when everyone assumed i was straight. i’m not assuming his sexuality but IF he is queer then i hope fans assuming his sexuality doesn’t hurt him. also, real armys shoudnt get offended over the possibility that he might not be straight. some of these comments are really proving some fans don’t love the members for who they are, they love their own version of the members. i don’t care if the members are straight, bi, gay etc and fans shouldn’t care either, we should just care about their happiness
@@invisiblestring4234 I completely agree with you, I'm closeted myself ( too scared to come out rn) and it's so hard when ppl are constantly assuming this thing about me bc it's considered normal or whatever to be cishet. There is so much pressure as it to be a certain way, I can't believe the amount of pressure that gets added once someone becomes famous. They're still people and should be aloud to make mistakes, live their truth, and be happy. I think sometimes people forget that.
I do agree that a lot of comments “defending” this song from having lgbtq+ undertones are lowkey and probably unintentionally homophobic. But the reason people presume any of the members to be straight without much “controversy” behind that assumption is because according to the kpop industry all the members are decidedly straight.
Guys please calm down sexualties aren't insults you see them as rude because they are assuming your sexuality it is no brainer to say assuming sexuality is rude after all, it isn't insult or a way to be rude to someone which smarty even thought assuming sexuality is insultive enough to get people saying same shit over your reply you don't even know what they feel about these stuff how less things you know about the person you love so blindly honestly I have never ever sawn anyone get mad by assuming their sexualities not even many primary students act think it that way
No one is saying he's 100% not straight. But people in the comments are saying he's 100% queer when there's so many things that this song could be about.
Seeing some of these comments makes me sad because people think this song is hot just because its Taehyung and in reality, its really sad. Dear Taehyung fans, its fine to think he's attractive because - well, he is - but please recognize when he's sad and don't let his good looks shield everything else. He's more than a hot guy who has a deep, 'hot' voice.
YES i’m so tired of some of these comments sexualizing his voice. Like RM stated that this song is so personal for Tae and we should be respectful instead of treating him as some sexy guy.
Okay to all the people saying this song is not Lgbtq+ can ya'll shut up because this song is a masterpiece that speaks differently with every individual who listens to it. And people saying ''Taehyung is Straight don't assume that he is Gay or bi etc'' aren't you all also assuming his sexuality and what if someone calls him gay?? Ya'll are being triggered as if being called gay is a disrespect. Why can't we all normalize LGBTQ+ like if someone calls me gay or bi I'll just smile and tell them its okay bro maybe I've given off that energy but I'm not gay, there's nothing to be offended of. I'm soo sick of hypocrite people.Ya'll need to grow up. Lets say there are a lot of LGBTQ+ Idols in Kpop suppose its Kim Taehyung for now and he is scared to come out but when he give hints that he is gay or etc people start to justify and defend his actions that he is not part of the LGBTQ+ like being a gay or bi etc is a disgrace.
I agree. we can’t assume their sexuality whether they’re straight or gay. It goes both ways when people determine the group as gay and i believe it’s best not to assume at all.
me: *reading comments about the "are you calling me a sinner" while listening to song* huh, must be in korean. Taehyung: are you calling me a sinner? me: OMG. HE SAYS IT IN. EN. GLIGH.
with this song, kim taehyung became the first and only korean solo singer to have 4 songs with over 100 million streams on spotify. Congratulations taehyung😍🎉
The fact that he managed to put emotion into a song and it just omfg im never gonna stop loving this its like a reminder abt the world . Bts are on a whole nother level The emotions put into a song And yet ppl have the nerve to say Bts dont do good?wha-
Taehyung has said before "The song is about someone being hurt due to my fault, And thus I'm suffering with a feeling of guilt for putting that person in pain like that" Here's a link to that video th-cam.com/video/nG9UUi33g2Q/w-d-xo.html
@@akeylaquinbie7955 Yes… which commonly how many LGBT people feel after coming out, trust me i’m LGBT and have been in that situation and know that exact feeling of hurting someone for my sexuality and feeling guilty for letting them hurt like that
When I first read what the song says I started crying ,because it's really relatable to my real life since my mom suffers schizophrenia and my sister and I have to take care of my little brothers like real moms and we get judged every day of of every mistake we do . I feel you Taehyung♡
as a lesbian army, this song always hits too close to home... not even assuming anything but it's very important for me, i cried several times. when I listen to it, I feel the same feeling I got when I first heard take me to church
As a gay man I totally get it! It perfectly encases the feeling of sinking and the fear that you will dissapoint everyone, you're apologizing to everyone and you feel like you're on borrowed time with the people you love.
@@gray_-_-_gBorrowed time- i literally wrote a whole verse about my love with family being on borrowed time which price I'm paying with myself. It's funny in a sense. You can control for how much time they'll love you, until you come out, it's in your hands when you stop making them love you, but in reality the very reason, your own sexuality is not in your hand. You can't control it. Funny is a messed up twisted sense
Omg i literally just fell off my bed and I just drooled LOL and I was like oh my gosh I am really unstable right now and I share a room with my brother so I fell off my bed and he was looking at me like I was crazy so I went in the bathroom and died and came back to life😂😂😂😂😂😂 I was so unstable at that moment when I heard his voice I was bumping into walls and everything like my soul just left my body 😂😂 but I'm stable now hopefully😂😂😂
lgbtq+ armys: relating to this song and talking about how the lyrics sound like they're coming from someone who was rejected by family after coming out, but not saying they think the song *IS* about that. allies: understanding and saying they see the correlations too. ignorant people: *tAe IsNt gAy sO thE sOnG iS NoT AbOUt gAY stUFf*
@@luna-el9cr you should:) if you want obviously, they usually write about youth, struggles growing up, mental health and they incorporate their own stories to help others :)
When I listen to this song, I don't hear any singing, I just hear screams, crying, wailing and remorse over this stigma. There is only one meaning behind this sad song, and everyone knows it I really hope he finds his happiness in this racist and unforgiving world
@@charlize6994 yeah it is, but apology about what? about something he and his siblings thinks it's STIGMA And we don't use the word STIGMA often or in vain And if you search a little, you will find that there is a certain category of people who are called this word
@@tassekkaoumaima4201 I personally think it's about him as an older brother not being there for his siblings as he left to pursue his dreams, and he is a very family-oriented person, he feels guilty that they have grown to be someone that doesn't know him and can't reach out to him and has failed to protect them by not being there.
@@zunairaimtiaz4783 I just don't see how this can be relating to not being there for his siblings, why would that be a "Stigma" and why would you say "are calling me a sinner?" These are quite harsh words for a boy to have on his conscience, just because he pursued a career as a music artist and he had to commit his whole life to it. Beside he was taking care of his family by earning considering they were poor in the beginning so that was for their own good in some ways. And his siblings still had their parents to care for and support them. I'm sure they were thrilled for their brother's success and I'm sure that Tae was still a loving brother to them as often as he could be. I've never heard of any of the other members expressing guilt for not always being there for their siblings because of having to leave home to become a trainee (apart from Hobi maybe, I think he may have mentioned it at his sister's wedding, but it certainly didn't make him a "sinner").
His voice is soo calm,soothing,deep,relaxing.. Idk,why people just concern him with looks he also have good..very good voice and personality... with most handsome face in the universe
![BTS V - 'Intro: Singularity' [Han|Rom|Eng lyrics]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Xn1L9pvk6sE/mqdefault.jpg)
![BTS V - 'Intro: Singularity' [Han|Rom|Eng lyrics]](/img/tr.png)
let’s be real, we never left this era.
Fr we just cant
It just hits different in the feels 😌
@@tyngism it does✨
@@hallohoiahloi9271 so true 💜
Fr ssly I can't move on from this
Taehyung: *Hits high note*
Me: *THAT'S MAH BABY*
me *dies*
MY FUCKIN CINNAMON APPLE
Mai Straka
I choked on my noodles. You have to pay my hospital bills 😂
THATS MAH BOY
LOL ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ😂
V’s voice is very calm and soothing. Maybe if I listen to this everyday I won’t need to eat vegetables anymore.
Odd Eye Girl that took a turn SKSKSKKSKS
Nooooooooo, I love vegetables(tbh more than junk food)😢😢😂😢😢
@@웃옷-x7r its your opinion :3
@Brianna Mccartin ty 🤣😂🤣
@@웃옷-x7r your welcome xd
The high notes in this can not be compared with anyone .. Altough Jimin's highnotes suprises me everytime and jungkook's and jin's voice drives me crazy but V has a baritone and knowing this .. its litterally very hard for someone to sing this high with this kind of deep voice ... Everytime I listen to this I get a feeling of respect for Taehyung
Yaa👍
For a Baritone in KPOP, V has widest vocal range (as per real vocal analysts) of Eb2 ~ D6 (3 octaves, 5 notes and 1 semitone), which means he has potential of hitting high octaves with ease.
jungkooks voice is heaven
@@lll2282 bt unfortunately this isnt jungkook's song..so you better go to his songs & praise him peacefully..
@@lll2282 see this is what I hate the most .. why do you stan only one ? Like yes JK's voice is definitely heaven but this is Stigma and it ain't has a single bit of his voice,right ? He himself won't like it that you are only and only his stan. Like for example: If it's about a sexy brain we should say Namjoon but some of the solo stans would name their bias instead .. woah!!
His voice is so deep in this song! And those high notes gosh his voice is the best.
Your right
His voice is so just so soulful☺️💜
I know right!😁
So is everyones voices! 😀
@@sudhiksha9093 lol nope
Honestly I genuinely believe this song is for his siblings. Hear me out. In this particular album, all of their solos were personal, like really personal. Jungkook talks about his love for his hyungs, jimin talks about his struggle to genuinely smile, jhope talks about his appreciation for his mother, suga talks about his deep love for music, namjoon talks about his inner hatred and jin talks about his struggle with success. All of these are extremely personal.
But its only taehyungs song that we never got the backrgound story of. And i believe its because it is related to his siblings, something that is extremely personal and private. Taehyung, like the majortity of the members, prefers to keep his siblings private to protect their identity. That being said, him refering to "my brother" and "my sister" is no coincidence.
As we all probably know, stigma refers to a mark of disgrace. Taehyung probably sees himself as a 'disgrace' in the eyes of his siblings as he's not able to be their in person and 'protect' them physically like older siblings are expected to. His grandmother passed away this particular year as well, so him not being able to attend the funeral as the oldest son would have been a sign of 'betrayal' in his siblings eyes, even if they understood the reasons why he couldnt be there. Taehyungs 'sin' is that he went to pursue his dream as an artist leaving his family behind. Thats why no matter what he does, he cant 'erase it or hide it.' Taehyung values family. So the wound that this situation has given him only gets 'deeper and deeper.' His 'heart hurts everyday.' Siblings dont care much for money or wealth or success. Theyre proud and theyre happy, but more than that they just want their brother in their life. Deep down the love is there, but the situation makes it very hard for siblings to actually form strong bonds especially if this seperation happnens in their teen years- thats when people change and grow the most. Im not saying that they dont love him, but it would be hard to speak to someone you barely even know anymore or who barely even knows you now (as tae eluded to in his vlive how it’s been a long time since he’s spoken to his siblings).
Anyway, this song really just hits in the feels. I have 4 siblings and my older brother left us to go work when we were younger. Im just speaking on the knowledge that i know how his siblings would feel and that the guilt that taehyung feels is normal. When you miss out in being in your siblings life at an early stage, it would make anyone feel sad especially if that was never what you intended for to happen.
So conclusion? Taehyung is apologising to his siblings in this song and hopes that they will one day forgive him for becoming someone that they have trouble reaching.
I think its a beautifully tragic song and it hits close to my heart.
BTS is always deep with their music.
Also this was just my take on it anyway, what’s yours? Guess we'll never really know unless taehyung tells it to us straight tho
This is so accurate and sad...
He always says how much he loves his family..
I even remember when during a vlive he said that his younger brother don't talk to him that much and he feels really bad about it...
But now i think its all fine..
You can see in his vocation vlog he went out with his bro and spend his holidays with his family instead of going outstations.
:'(
Well said.
@Vanilla Cheesecake I don't think so... I mean, if he were gay, why would he apologize to his siblings about it, and who is he addressing when he said that someone else took the blame for it?? There are a lot of meanings and theories to it that any one of them could be right or wrong.
@Vanilla Cheesecake I can see why though. It's very deep, but something tells me that the meaning of the song might be something else. An example, might just be because he did something very wrong in his past that he deeply regrets.
dude you wrote a whole essay
Even with Jungkook, Jimin, and Jin being able to hit all those high notes, and they really can! No one, and I mean no one in the group has the massive range that V has. Seeing that his natural tone is baritone and he is able to hit that note at the end tells me how big his range is...
Taehyung is such an old soul...and his enduring love for all music makes me admire him more. Seeing how he himself has said that Erik Benet (Halle Berry's ex husband) is one of his favorite singers...more admiration...
Tae's voice is so unique, it can get so deep and low but his high notes also sound from another world. His range is truly massive.
@@maiagobbo hear him hit opera with his deep voice YESSS
I'm a girl and my voice only has 2 types
Deeper than kim taehyung thinner than baba nirmal singh khalsa
Or a siren
My voice range is 4 octaves 😉
👍
I agree and this song was so Eric Benet inspired. I love Tae's voice soooo much I can cry!
3:02 DAMN!!! HIS VOCAL RANGE IS SO WIDE!! THE HIGH PITCH THO!! 💯 HE EVEN SANG IT LIVE IN A CONCERT OMG I CANNOT
Nothing infront of justin Bieber's 🙂
@@anantyadav4978 ıts so cringe stop dmmfnfmdöfklfödlflfl
@@anantyadav4978 and did anyone ask if u love Justin then go listen to his music leave here
@@anantyadav4978 yeah nothing infront of other vocalists in bts
@@anantyadav4978 stfu fake srmy
Ever army : crying in the comments
Subtitles: *literally fangirling over the song*
ikr 😂😂
I LITTERLY THOUGHT IT WAS ONLY MY SUBTITLES HASKAJFG
ME TOO BYEJEKSJDKALF
Lol ikr
lmaooo
"Are you calling me a sinner"
I threw my phone across the bed lol
Did ur phone break army?
@@CarlaJageryearsago ALMOST LMAO-
@@CarlaJageryearsago Sorry, I don't understand what you mean. What are you telling them against? What's the problem?
@@fataee8646 umm nothing.i just jokingly asked if the army's phone break cus they throw it across the room.there is no problem.
@@CarlaJageryearsago xdd
6 people loved it so much that they turned their phones upside down so they could like it again
Now it’s 42
now it's 43
Introducing the best logic
48 😤
49 :(
This is butter era if you are here you are legend don't forget this is MASTERPIECE
2:42 "are u calling me a sinner"- yes , have u seen singularity ??? Just sayin 👁️👁️
Loll that profile photo😂💜
I've seen singularity I watched a lot of times xDDD
was that part him saying it or RM?
@@alaynarhodes5255 it was Tae bc this is a *solo* by Taehyung so nobody else is in it ;w;
have u read singularity? its lyrics is the best, u should read them
sounds like jesus poured honey right into his vocal chords .... 😩
You don't have to carry the name of God, Not all people have the same religion
@@jyg284sm its not that deep- ur acting like they were full on praying or something and even if they were freedom of religone exists lol
I-
@@jyg284sm 😂😂😂
@@jyg284sm what do you think about God?
Tae: Are you calling me a sinner?
Me: 👁👄👁
V: Are you calling me a sinner?
Me: Am I a true sinner bc I made a deal with the devil that Yoongi's crush "Pillow" will accept him?
😂😂😂
Yes I am sir 😭
Its been 5 yrs. but this is still my fave Tae solo song!!! The fact that he wrote this lyrics and they never disclose the meaning behind this song, keep me up at night sometimes. I know that this could be a song inspired by his storyline in BTS HYYH but it could also be a song with much deeper personal meaning towards Tae. I really love to give him a big warm hug everytime I listen to it. This was such an underrated masterpiece!! 💜
do u have any interpretations of what the lyrics could mean to Tae? I read so many and i'm clueless which makes more sense. Maybe it could be a mix of both..
@@angelawang4660 It has 2 ways of perceiving in my sight, first coming out to his family but not being accepted and only being defined by that to himself or in the eyes of his family. Second, He left to pursue his dream at an early age when his siblings were also young, and now he regrets not being there for them and he and his siblings not growing up to be closer, and him not being able to protect them by being there and he feels like he is a sinner in their eyes. I definitely think it's the second one being the closest because he has always been a family oriented person and he wanted to be there for his siblings.
@@zunairaimtiaz4783 Dude first one is more accountable here. I just don't see how this can be relating to not being there for his siblings, why would that be a "Stigma" and why would you say "are calling me a sinner?" These are quite harsh words for a boy to have on his conscience, just because he pursued a career as a music artist and he had to commit his whole life to it. Beside he was taking care of his family by earning considering they were poor in the beginning so that was for their own good in some ways. And his siblings still had their parents to care for and support them. I'm sure they were thrilled for their brother's success and I'm sure that Tae was still a loving brother to them as often as he could be.
I've never heard of any of the other members expressing guilt for not always being there for their siblings because of having to leave home to become a trainee (apart from Hobi maybe, I think he may have mentioned it at his sister's wedding, but it certainly didn't make him a "sinner").
@@arya.07 Exactly. At first i thought it might be about guilt of being an idol, but in 2015 Tae and his brother were talking a lot and in 2017 Tae said that his brother avoids talking to him so obviously something serious happened between them in 2016 and that’s when this song was written. In this song he said “are you calling me a sinner” to his brother, so it sounds like whatever confession he made (he describes making a confession at the first verse and revealing a secret that is killing him to keep) his brother called him a sinner for that confession. It sounds a lot like an lgbt song. The other members are close with their siblings even with busy schedules so it’s definitely deeper than that with Tae’s case. Also, right after this songs release date is when Tae started wearing a lot of LGBT pride gear which is what a lot of people do after coming out so…. i really don’t know, maybe it is about being lgbt… if it’s about leaving his siblings why cant he just say it ?
Also, Namjoon confirmed that it’s about Tae’s real life and extremely personal so it’s not written for HYYH.
@@มาช่า-ญ9ณ Omg I've been meaning to reply to you for soo long but I wasn't able to for some reasons idk, but thank goodness I finally can. I appreciate your reply a lot, and tysmm for the timeline and facts, cause I didn't know about it. Many people interpret him not talking to his bro with him not being on good terms because of his busy trainee and idol life, but if he was on great terms even after debuting, then suddenly he wasn't and then this song comes out, then the first reason isn't valid at all. And suddenly he's using all the lgbtq terms living in a homophobic country, wearing lgbtq stuff, calling himself sinner and crime and stuff, his bro isn't talking, saying some famous lgbtq lines after coming out (I think Tae once said 'I'm still me' that the main character said in a movie after coming out, but I'm not sure whether Tae or JK said that. I watched that clip long ago and can't find it rn). And yeah you're right, most members, firstly, have good relationships with their siblings, despite some being busier than Tae, and secondly, reveal the meaning of their songs, even if it's very personal and controversial for S. Korea (Suga talked about mental health problems in his song even if it's such huge of a taboo there). Besides, I'm sure Tae, or at least Namjoon knew how this song would be interpreted as, as an lgbtq song, and even tho they support the community, them being associated with lgbtq could ruin their career in S. Korea, considering back then they didn't have a lot of international support, and imo, if this song wasn't about lgbtq, then they would've quickly explain the meaning and clear doubts, but still they didn't and that doesn't make sense if it is about Tae not being there for his bro. But honestly, even tho most chances are that this song is about lgbtq, we can't be 100% sure (tho I am like, 95% sure).
Edit - That was so long but heyy, are you Swiftie?
Taehyung looks like a baby, but his voice can make a baby
I-
@@cyb3r_fa1ry (2)
Can't argue with that
smooth
Ah, now I have had my feelings towards Taehyung intowords lol
Stigma opened up a wound that never healed in me.....
4 years ago a lady names miss Deb, was like a Grama to me, she was so kind and loving.... But she was diagnosed with cancer...she lived past what they said she would.... But one day I was at her house and she always had roses in her yard, I had a funny feeling and collected them because they were so beautiful, that was the last time I ever saw her......my mother told me that she had passed away. I forgot to tell her I loved her that day, I wish I would go back and tell her she meant so much to me.... But this song reminded me of that pain and I cried for the first time in 4 years about it, but afterwards I finally acknowledged what had happened and I could begin to heal.....thank you Kim Taehyung, you helped me heal and to remember to cherish the ones I love...because like those rose petals, everything is temporary.
This is the most beautiful thing I’ve heard today
That was so beautiful to read wow. The last part hit me hard “everything is temporary”
Everything is not temporary.love us always permanent amd it will be forever.
this is so beautiful honestly. im sorry for your loss just know she knows you loved her ♡
Kim Taehyung, ты зачаровал нас утонченными глубинами своего восхитительного голоса. Это по новому индивидуальное и прекрасное видение жизни трепетно и волнительно . 2024
His voice is already so deep and he hits those high notes perfectly
Well i know that you know that i know that we all know that we all TRIED to sing it.
Ofc... i tried.... and every time his voice sounds deep or low i ended up singing it on a high note. But. Then I tried singing it on a normal tone and kinda low (to try to match him) and well i sounded like i have a cold. -___-
I know how you feel bruhh
I actaully did it and was surprised.
@@jeonjungkookismyoppa6107 congrats - v -
Well ify
I did sing it
The one who wrote the captions is a whole damn mood. 😂✨
Agreed😂💀
Yeah it's the marry jin part right?
@@Azura12378 yes 💀🤣
I thought I was only one who noticed this
Ok, I am looking like, am I the only one seeing this. Being loyal to Jin, but I still love you…whaaaaaat. Anyway, they had me going for a min. That was my laugh for the week.
I remember a year ago listening to this trying to learn it by heart in Korean. After listening closely for a month and studying korean pronunciation, I finally learned it. Ha.
lil playful fandom girl SO THERE IS HOPE! I’m trying to learn korean but I can’t even pronounce hello in korean lol 🤦🏻♀️
@SmolParkMochi theres two diffrent meanings to annyeong one is hello and the other is bye
@SmolParkMochi oh okay
@SmolParkMochi :3
Teach me senpai lol
Damn this man can sing lower than my grades and higher than my brother FuQk what can't this man do?!?
#taehyung is perfect !!!!!
there's nothing he can't do
for me its higher than my sister
Not moan so loud?
@@painsuffer4268 What does that mean hyung?
Why is this song so underrated !?!??!
It's not?
@@wkkowrld UM
what, its not??
Its not💀
@@sayari5002 lmao... "Underrated" doesn't only have THAT ONE MEANING
This song is so deeply personal to me, this album came out in one of the darkest times in my life, my entire family was falling apart and I, as the eldest daughter, was sort of forced to hold everything together...
My mother fell into a deep depression where she tried to khs many times in front of me, my brother started hanging with a really rough crowd and began stealing and taking drugs while my father decided he wanted to move on in life without us....
It crushed me, I felt so alone and ashamed that nothing i could do would help us... everyone around me just said to me " be strong for your family" but no one offered any help... they just watched me lose myself from a distance, while we struggled to put food on the table at home. All our family friends turned their backs on us and we became the laughingstock of our church. I was so far away from everyone I cared about; I'd never felt so alone in my life. Every day was a battle to keep my head up and move on with my life but reassembling was proving to be so much harder than people made it out to be.
This song was my cry for help, it spoke to me in ways no other piece of art has. In fact, this entire album encompassed exactly how I felt and how I still feel today while dealing with the after effects of the situation. The wings album is a tragically beautiful masterpiece, everyone can relate with at least one song in the track list, which Is sad but let us all draw together and find comfort in each other. That's why I love BTS so much... Wings opened our eyes to our pain and allowed us to lay all our hurt in front of our eyes, the follow up series Love Yourself reminded us that even though we are hurting and flawed, we still deserve to be loved and cared for ♥️
You're really strong! I'm the eldest daughter too and your story made me tear up. More power and strength to you!💕❤ I hope you're doing well.
I feel you dear. I'm really sorry for all the things you had to go through. I hope you are doing well now. Lots of love to you from a fellow ARMY!💜
I hope you are doing well now!! As an eldest daughter and the current situation that I am in right now, I literally cried while reading your comment. You are right, BTS songs validate our feelings in a way no other artists have done. We are in this together, let's keep fighting!! More love and power to you from a fellow army 💟
Producer: would you want to sing in a high or low voice
Tae: YES!!!!
i remember that stigma lyrics video by you was the first lyrics video that i saw being an army
omg really???
i remember too that every af tae upload at eldest account, i've never forget to comment lol
im an lgbt army and this song really speaks to me.
yeah same
Same...
Same
me too🥺
Same...
Some people see this song as just a song. But the meaning behind the song is so so personal and deep that it makes me cry to comprehend it. Taehyung's songs always have these heavy messages that comes straight from his heart. I believe he was having a hard time when writing this song.
Kim Taehyung, ты зачаровал нас утонченными глубинами своего восхитительного голоса. Это по новому индивидуальное и прекрасное видение жизни трепетно и волнительно . Спасибо тебе ТАЛАНТ с большой буквы.2024
Tae:*Sings his solo songs*
Pacific ocean: Am I a joke to you !!
This comment deserves likes.
@@taestytreat2884 yes
*Read More*
@@kath4152 no you didn't fool me with "read more" thing. But yea thanks for agreeing :)
Kathryn Green
U didn’t fool me. My read me is like underlined
THIS SONG DESERVES A FREAKING GRAMMY ISTG
SOMETHING MORE THAN A GRAMMY...
You can really hear his pain and emotion through that high note
Taehyung's voice is so unique in every way, I have never seen or heard anyone else with a voice like his. His voice is usually so beautifully deep that when he did that high note I got genuinely shocked and replayed that moment over and over. The fact that not only him but every single member are so good at controlling their voices according to the song. One second their voices can be all cheerful and the next they can be deep and emotional.
Kim Taehyung, ты зачаровал нас утонченными глубинами своего восхитительного голоса. Это по новому индивидуальное и прекрасное видение жизни трепетно и волнительно . 2024
This need more likes smh...
I just hit 1K!!!!
Ok, I got my new obsession today, aka BTS, and Taehyung's voice struck a cord in me. So soft, so soothing, so deep... I could fall asleep while listening to his voice.
Talvituhkat
That sounded.. *weird*
**I BECAME AN ARMY BECAUSE OF THIS GUY**
AND NOW HE IS MY BIAS AND I LOVE HIM SO MUCH, LAST WEEK I CRIED BECAUSE I KNEW I CANNOT SEE HIM IT'S REALLY SAD BUT I WILL SUPPORT HIM, AT LEAST HE LOVES ME AS A FAN AND I AM SO PROUD THAT HE IS MY BIAS💖
Same here I know it is so silly yet I cry at times realising that I can never meet them. Yet I still hope to meet them cuz no one knows destiny. So don't lose hope.
@@MS-wl5vs preach. This man has helped me so much with his songs, he's my bias. 💜
Oml same here
same, it breaks my heart everyday to think i might never be able to meet him 😭💔
same here yay
Still can’t believe that Taehyung was just 19 yrs old while singing this.. really his voice is like blessing to ears😭💜
I was really upset today..... Because my mom told me that we are being transferred I couldn't believe what she said and left for my school crying my heart out and when I told that to my bestie she also cried very miserably and now after that am just jamming to this song..... I don't know why it gives me a little relief...
I feel so sad for you but trust me it will get better :)
I hope you feel better now.. You must miss your bestie a lot... 😥
Jayanta Patra clout
S solos tae
1.stigma
2.singularity
3.scenery
4. Sweet night
Tae loves 's' words❤😅
Edit: woah 58 likes army borahae on this 1000th day of borahae.
Edit 2: y'all I didn't expect this many likes , thank you. Also , I know there are other solos of tae , I have commented only the titles starting with the letter s. I purple you 💜 hwaiting!🌷
imagine seduction will be the next solo
@@nightshadowfox3167 all Fangirls will be dead after listening to the song 💜😬😅
Unexpectable, my name start with 's'..... Ehehhh just kidding lmao but I feel thrilled and i dunno i dunno i dunno whyyy
My name starts with the letter S and I oop lol
4. Winter Bear 💜😭
i feel like as an lgbt army this song resonates with me and all my lgbt armies. like im not saying he is a part of the community or anything but if you read the lyrics and think about internalised homopobia and growing up in a homophobic country a lot of things make sense. i mean even the title... i'm notforcing a sexuality on him, so don't take it that way, it just really touched me
No don’t apologize. The best art is art that speaks to people in different ways. The best part about music is that it can be there for us in the way we need it most.
@@Vanarana trueeeee
Damn it's so sad that no one bothers or corrects a person if they wrote smth like 'BTS' future wives are so lucky' but you've to put up a whole disclaimer before saying that Taehyung might be gay, just so you don't get attacked, just goes on to show how close minded people can be... I hope these double standards change one day
yall sick
@@lilyoongi146 including u
I came back to this song because I was confused about my feelings. I started to read the comments and a lot of y’all mention that it speaks to y’all as lgbt. and honestly now I see why. I’ve been struggling to know my own sexuality and hearing this again is very relatable now. I feel that if I ever come out to my parents and siblings I will feel rejected, I’ll feel as if I have sinned. ‘Are you calling me a sinner?’ Really hit home. That’s exactly how I feel right now.
Stay strong
I hope you know that you aren’t obligated to come out, and I hope you know that if you want to come out, it’s better to do it when you’re ready. Don’t put so much pressure on yourself to come out or to figure out your sexuality. Take all the time you need in the world to figure it out. It could come to you today, tomorrow or a long time from now, just don’t put so much pressure on yourself and remember that you’re loved. Always. I love you 💜
@@jointhejincult5425 thank you, really. I really needed to hear that... woah omg thank you for your words, I’ll be sure to take my time. I’m glad there’s armys like you :) take care and you are loved too !💜💜
One thing else, if you’re not sure of your family’s reaction to you coming out or if you know it’s going to be negative, I suggest that you come out when you are in a stable place. As in, if they kick you out, you at least have somewhere to go. I know that it’s a very hard thought. But better safe than sorry. I plan to do the same thing. I don’t know what my mom feels about lgbtq. Her reaction to it is pretty…meh. Meh is not enough for me to come out to her. Stay safe :) best of luck to you 💜
@Art with Reet soni it’s LGBTQ+ and it’s an acronym for Lesbian, gay, bisexual, trans and queer.
i personally feel like taehyungs voice and vocal range is very underrated. i mean, yes, recognise him for his low voice but god, his high notes astonish me every single time. and the fact that he can go calm and soothing also is so beautiful 💜
ARE YOU CALLING ME A SINNER- that part got me dying
same 😂
Dude ME TOOOOO
omg I'm literally crying
I'm speechless
Jesus this is so damn deep and meaningful
thank you so much to the songwriter, to the producer, to the lyricist and obviously to our wonderful tae, who gave everything to the feeling of this perfect song .
Me being a new Army makes me wish I was a fan when this came out :(
it’s okay you are just as valuable :)
Sis don't worry honestly I can't relate to what I said be us old army Stan new army and a quick heads up don't fall for everything u see on the internet unless bts makes it clear :)
Same omggg
Don't worry atleast now we are listening it now
Meh you found BTS at the right time hun
Line distribution
---------
Tae: 3.40
Hoseok did some of back vocals too e.e
@@estherv.straus7070 rlly?
@@senoghaw yep, this kinda really HIGH notes are from him too
@@estherv.straus7070 what-
Oh my gosh
@@estherv.straus7070 no . stop, thats a lie of y'all dumb ppl. Repect Tae and give him his credits.
The honesty this song has :(( My inspiration
I was listening to this in class with my headphones on and when tae said “are you calling me a sinner” my friend had shouted yes and I started laughing and told him
Good times
Maddiline Kathryn
Wait a minute. Wait a dam minute 😂
Weren’t you wearing headphones how did he hear that part
Adelyne Jimenez that’s what I’m confused about too🤔
@@adelynejimenez8895 i think they're just stating that they said yes for something different at the exact time like a coincidence they didnt actually hear it
@@adelynejimenez8895 The friend shouted, you can hear people's voices if they're loud enough lol
one thing i love about BTSs songs is that they're open to interpretation, and ur not wrong what ever u relate it to, i relate it to depression and anxiety, however thats mu opinion, everyone has their own opinion and this is what i love abt their songs, they value everyone and are considerate of everyones feelings 🥺🧡
숨겨왔어
I tell you something
그저 묻어두기엔
이젠 버틸 수가 없는 걸
왜 그땐 말 못 했는지
어차피 아파와서
정말 버틸 수가 없을 걸
Now cry
너에게 너무 미안할 뿐야
또 cry 널 지켜주지 못해서
더 깊이 더 깊이 상처만 깊어져
되돌릴 수 없는 깨진 유리 조각 같아
더 깊이 매일이 가슴만 아파져
내 죄를 대신 받던
연약하기만 했던 너
그만 울고 tell me something
용기 없던 내게 말해봐
“그 때 나한테 왜 그랬어?”
“미안”
됐어 내게 무슨 자격 있어
이래보라고 저래보라고
너에게 말하겠어
더 깊이 더 깊이 상처만 깊어져
되돌릴 수 없는 깨진 유리 조각 같아
더 깊이 매일이 가슴만 아파져
내 죄를 대신 받던
연약하기만 했던 너
I’m sorry, I’m sorry
I’m sorry ma brother
숨겨도 감춰도 지워지지 않어
“Are you calling me a sinner?”
무슨 말이 더 있겠어
I’m sorry, I’m sorry
I’m sorry ma sister
숨겨도 감춰도 지워지지 않어
So cry
Please dry my eyes
저 빛이 저 빛이 내 죄를 비춰줘
돌이킬 수 없는 붉은 피가 흘러내려
더 깊이 매일이 죽을 것만 같아
그 벌을 받게 해줘
내 죄를 사해줘
제발
와.... 수고했어요! 손 아플텐데ㅠ
와 수정안하셨네요 대단하십니다
감사합니다!
True army will never forget this masterpiece
And remember Taehyung's inspiration for the song...pain so intense that you start to embrace it, like it.
V's "Stigma" *High* *note* always brings tears in my eyes
GOSH!! Tae ur voice is deeper than the ocean😍😘
wierd tae yesss omg!!! 😭😍💍💍💍💍
Tae-Tae's voice is deeper than the Mariana Trench 💜💜
Yesss😭😍💜✨💞
Pacific Ocean: *...*
**Pacific Ocean has left the chat**
take me to church but make it korean
UNDERRATED COMMENT
Ironic as I was just listening to that song.
this is such an underrated comment omg
this comment should be written down in history books
Yeah.
THIS
IS
A
BEAUTIFUL
MASTERPIECE
A superstar like him doesn't have anyone to dry his eyes... They really mean it when they say it's the loneliest at the top
I've really never felt this way about a song before, it's insane how so many years of pain and fear can be described in a short song like this. This really is how it feels when you feel like a walking, breathing punishment to the ones you love the most, yet the more you try to hide yourself, the deeper the wound gets.
How are you doing rn?
The greatest sin Taehyung has been committing so far is that he keeps slaying his stans with just his mere existence.
Kim Taehyung, ты зачаровал нас утонченными глубинами своего восхитительного голоса. 2024
*"Are you calling me a sinner?"* his voice is so deep it could put me to sleep
Hi, I'm new to TH-cam, step FatmaNur I live in turkey. I share FMV videos. I'm trying to spread happiness with my videos ...... and am trying to entertain as many people as possible ...... ♡
Would you support me if I ask? Check out a channel, don't support me if you don't like it, but if you like it please support me💜💜💜💜💜
The people who disliked the video better be joking. Taehyung must've practiced very hard for that high note
Don't at me
I am new to BTS as my daughter is into them, but I have adopted this boy/ man into my heart🖤 I just want to hug him...
oh my god this song hits home for me.
Apparently in this song Taehyung talks about how he sees himself as a disgrace because when his grandmother passed away and he wasn't able to be at her funeral, so it makes him feel like he betrayed his family. I can relate to this so much because my grandmother passed away but because of covid I didn't get to her as much before she passed. I was so sad and disappointed with myself and I thought it was all my fault. I feel like I betrayed my grandmother because I didn't get to see her. Now she is in heaven and she probably thinks I betrayed her😭😭😭
어떡해ㅠㅠㅠㅠ너무 좋잖아ㅠㅠㅠㅜ감정 딱 잡고 들으면 진짜 눈물 나는 노래ㅠㅜ
Taehyung's voice is doing things to my heart that I can't explain. Sometimes his voice hits freaking low notes that don't even exist, sometimes it's raspy and manly af and then there are times like this.... when he does high notes and it's enough to kill me
Taehyung's voice is really calm, he's my only hope in having a good night's sleep.
I'm not a fan of bts neither Kpop but damn, this one hits different
Sensual voice, clear and fantastic falsetto, distintive vocale timbre. I love him.
I notice that a lot of ppl in the comments are saying how this speaks to them from the perspective of someone queer, but then them saying that they're not saying they think Taehyung is queer or forcing him to be. But why is thinking he could be queer in someway disrespectful? And why do the people who think he's straight and say so and are not putting the same kind of thing abt how they're not going to force him to be anything and not getting any backlash from it?
It's not a bad thing to be queer, and no one's forcing him to be. This comment section is really something.
great comment. its so rude when people assume that all members are straight. as an lgbt person myself, it was so hard for me when everyone assumed i was straight. i’m not assuming his sexuality but IF he is queer then i hope fans assuming his sexuality doesn’t hurt him.
also, real armys shoudnt get offended over the possibility that he might not be straight. some of these comments are really proving some fans don’t love the members for who they are, they love their own version of the members. i don’t care if the members are straight, bi, gay etc and fans shouldn’t care either, we should just care about their happiness
@@invisiblestring4234 I completely agree with you, I'm closeted myself ( too scared to come out rn) and it's so hard when ppl are constantly assuming this thing about me bc it's considered normal or whatever to be cishet.
There is so much pressure as it to be a certain way, I can't believe the amount of pressure that gets added once someone becomes famous. They're still people and should be aloud to make mistakes, live their truth, and be happy.
I think sometimes people forget that.
I do agree that a lot of comments “defending” this song from having lgbtq+ undertones are lowkey and probably unintentionally homophobic. But the reason people presume any of the members to be straight without much “controversy” behind that assumption is because according to the kpop industry all the members are decidedly straight.
Guys please calm down sexualties aren't insults you see them as rude because they are assuming your sexuality it is no brainer to say assuming sexuality is rude after all, it isn't insult or a way to be rude to someone which smarty even thought assuming sexuality is insultive enough to get people saying same shit over your reply you don't even know what they feel about these stuff how less things you know about the person you love so blindly honestly I have never ever sawn anyone get mad by assuming their sexualities not even many primary students act think it that way
No one is saying he's 100% not straight. But people in the comments are saying he's 100% queer when there's so many things that this song could be about.
HIS HIGH NOTE AT 3:02 IS GENUINELY ONE OF THE BEST THINGS I'VE HEARD FROM THIS MAN UGH
Seeing some of these comments makes me sad because people think this song is hot just because its Taehyung and in reality, its really sad. Dear Taehyung fans, its fine to think he's attractive because - well, he is - but please recognize when he's sad and don't let his good looks shield everything else. He's more than a hot guy who has a deep, 'hot' voice.
Omg very true
YES i’m so tired of some of these comments sexualizing his voice. Like RM stated that this song is so personal for Tae and we should be respectful instead of treating him as some sexy guy.
THIS!!
His voice with this type of music is perfection 💜
those jazzy instrumentals I'm in love this is still my favorite Taehyung's song
I love the subtitles 😭 they’re a whole MOOD
Okay to all the people saying this song is not Lgbtq+ can ya'll shut up because this song is a masterpiece that speaks differently with every individual who listens to it. And people saying ''Taehyung is Straight don't assume that he is Gay or bi etc'' aren't you all also assuming his sexuality and what if someone calls him gay?? Ya'll are being triggered as if being called gay is a disrespect. Why can't we all normalize LGBTQ+ like if someone calls me gay or bi I'll just smile and tell them its okay bro maybe I've given off that energy but I'm not gay, there's nothing to be offended of. I'm soo sick of hypocrite people.Ya'll need to grow up. Lets say there are a lot of LGBTQ+ Idols in Kpop suppose its Kim Taehyung for now and he is scared to come out but when he give hints that he is gay or etc people start to justify and defend his actions that he is not part of the LGBTQ+ like being a gay or bi etc is a disgrace.
I totally approve
Someone finally said it. The same goes with statements like "I'll support them EVEN IF they are gay."
Tx finally someone say rhiss!!☺️🍁🍁
Bruh i love your mindset
I agree. we can’t assume their sexuality whether they’re straight or gay. It goes both ways when people determine the group as gay and i believe it’s best not to assume at all.
me: *reading comments about the "are you calling me a sinner" while listening to song*
huh, must be in korean.
Taehyung: are you calling me a sinner?
me: OMG. HE SAYS IT IN. EN. GLIGH.
with this song, kim taehyung became the first and only korean solo singer to have 4 songs with over 100 million streams on spotify. Congratulations taehyung😍🎉
Simply incredible. TaeTae, V, Taehyung... is a gift
The fact that he managed to put emotion into a song and it just omfg
im never gonna stop loving this its like a reminder abt the world .
Bts are on a whole nother level
The emotions put into a song
And yet ppl have the nerve to say Bts dont do good?wha-
i hope taehyung knows how much he means to lgbt army. this song hits a lot more harder after i came to terms with my sexuality.
It's so good to see everyone really sees this song as taehyung coming out to his parents ❤ there are 99% chances. The pain in his voice says it all
Omg your pfp 😭💜
Taehyung has said before "The song is about someone being hurt due to my fault, And thus I'm suffering with a feeling of guilt for putting that person in pain like that"
Here's a link to that video
th-cam.com/video/nG9UUi33g2Q/w-d-xo.html
@@akeylaquinbie7955 Yes… which commonly how many LGBT people feel after coming out, trust me i’m LGBT and have been in that situation and know that exact feeling of hurting someone for my sexuality and feeling guilty for letting them hurt like that
@@invisiblestring4234 Stop talking nonsense and watch the Short film again. Don't be stupid.
@@pennybleta9721 do your research. The song isn't based on storyline, RM said it himself.
who else is still listening to this in 2020 and cant get over those HIGH NOTES!!!!!
When I first read what the song says I started crying ,because it's really relatable to my real life since my mom suffers schizophrenia and my sister and I have to take care of my little brothers like real moms and we get judged every day of of every mistake we do . I feel you Taehyung♡
Kim Taehyung, ты зачаровал нас утонченными глубинами своего восхитительного голоса. 2024
IS HE COMING OUT TO US?! YESSSS IM SO PROUD OF HIM I'M GOING TO CRYYY
SAMEEEE 😭
@@มาช่า-ญ9ณ stop wtf
What the actual fuck is wrong with yall
He's not coming out? It's a song that touches on many internalized issues so you can't exactly say that
Beautiful, sad, honest from the depths of his soul. The unending pain.
as a lesbian army, this song always hits too close to home... not even assuming anything but it's very important for me, i cried several times.
when I listen to it, I feel the same feeling I got when I first heard take me to church
What does that mean
What does that 3
As a gay man I totally get it! It perfectly encases the feeling of sinking and the fear that you will dissapoint everyone, you're apologizing to everyone and you feel like you're on borrowed time with the people you love.
@@gray_-_-_gBorrowed time- i literally wrote a whole verse about my love with family being on borrowed time which price I'm paying with myself. It's funny in a sense. You can control for how much time they'll love you, until you come out, it's in your hands when you stop making them love you, but in reality the very reason, your own sexuality is not in your hand. You can't control it. Funny is a messed up twisted sense
Taehyung is really suitable with these kind of songs. I would literally listen to him all day all night.~ 🥺😍
3:00
Here's the part y'all were lookin' for.
And here: 3:14
Thankss
Omg i literally just fell off my bed and I just drooled LOL and I was like oh my gosh I am really unstable right now and I share a room with my brother so I fell off my bed and he was looking at me like I was crazy so I went in the bathroom and died and came back to life😂😂😂😂😂😂 I was so unstable at that moment when I heard his voice I was bumping into walls and everything like my soul just left my body 😂😂 but I'm stable now hopefully😂😂😂
2:43 how can you forget about this??
@@ASshookysrice omg dude my dirty mind
The captions speak for my soul fr!!!
Kim Taehyung, ты зачаровал нас утонченными глубинами своего восхитительного голоса. 2024
i simp for tae's deep voice, especially "are you calling me a sinner"
BUT THOSE HIGH NOTES THO.
Will never get old, Best taehyung song.
when it's 2020 but you are stil not over this masterpiece
The way Taehyung whispered “Are you calling me a sinner”...
LIKE OF COURSE HOW CAN SOMEONE THIS PERFECT EXIST-
lgbtq+ armys: relating to this song and talking about how the lyrics sound like they're coming from someone who was rejected by family after coming out, but not saying they think the song *IS* about that.
allies: understanding and saying they see the correlations too.
ignorant people: *tAe IsNt gAy sO thE sOnG iS NoT AbOUt gAY stUFf*
@danni _05 No one is saying as a fact, they're saying is their interpretation, why do you bother so much, mmm??
True !! Idk why ppl think them as a gay when they never said it
Underrated comment😞
@@aradhanadubey5679 you're so dense. you missed the entire point of the comment
I just don’t see why people literally want to ignore it so bad, like internalised homophobia much?
never thought a bts song would make my eyes water
Bts songs have a lot of deep lyrics lmao
@@jonghyxn5 yeah but i don’t really listen to them lmfaoo
@@luna-el9cr you should:) if you want obviously, they usually write about youth, struggles growing up, mental health and they incorporate their own stories to help others :)
@@jonghyxn5 i probably will haha i just stan more girl groups than boys so i don’t really pay attention to male groups
@@luna-el9cr ah okay:) I like some girl groups
When I listen to this song, I don't hear any singing, I just hear screams, crying, wailing and remorse over this stigma.
There is only one meaning behind this sad song, and everyone knows it
I really hope he finds his happiness in this racist and unforgiving world
Very true 🌈
It’s okay if you think that but it actually makes sense if the song was an apology to his siblings
@@charlize6994 yeah it is, but apology about what? about something he and his siblings thinks it's STIGMA
And we don't use the word STIGMA often or in vain
And if you search a little, you will find that there is a certain category of people who are called this word
@@tassekkaoumaima4201 I personally think it's about him as an older brother not being there for his siblings as he left to pursue his dreams, and he is a very family-oriented person, he feels guilty that they have grown to be someone that doesn't know him and can't reach out to him and has failed to protect them by not being there.
@@zunairaimtiaz4783 I just don't see how this can be relating to not being there for his siblings, why would that be a "Stigma" and why would you say "are calling me a sinner?" These are quite harsh words for a boy to have on his conscience, just because he pursued a career as a music artist and he had to commit his whole life to it. Beside he was taking care of his family by earning considering they were poor in the beginning so that was for their own good in some ways. And his siblings still had their parents to care for and support them. I'm sure they were thrilled for their brother's success and I'm sure that Tae was still a loving brother to them as often as he could be.
I've never heard of any of the other members expressing guilt for not always being there for their siblings because of having to leave home to become a trainee (apart from Hobi maybe, I think he may have mentioned it at his sister's wedding, but it certainly didn't make him a "sinner").
The depth of your vocals is mind blowing. I can't help, but fall in love with your art.keep up!
💜💜💜💜진짜 뷔만의 음성의 매력이 있음!태형오빠 사랑해요💜💜💜💜
His voice 😭😭😭💜
his voice is like lavander. maybe thats why its hisfavorate scent
His voice is soo calm,soothing,deep,relaxing..
Idk,why people just concern him with looks he also have good..very good voice and personality... with most handsome face in the universe
@@jameelkhan3282 correct
@@jameelkhan3282 i think he an angel in hiding with these features, personality, and voice
Angel until he gets on stage , excuse me being a hard stan 🙃😉
A angel and a demon
Beautiful , the range in his voice is phenomenal.