Thank you host for your awesome detailed analysis. This is the first time that I listened patiently till the end. You make me understand what went wrong with my favourite contestant's performance, his flaws and strength. Thumbs up! ❤
Thank you for the compliment. It is not up to me to call myself a good singing coach. I tried my best to share my experience and knowledge, my goal of teaching is that one day hopefully none of my students will need to come to me again for lesson. It means that all of my students are able to learn songs on their own worth proper technique and interpretation, and can perform self maintenance on their voice.
It is in my plan to do exactly that. But I will be launching and announcing a very important project in March this year. I will be launching and platform for people who want to learn the art of singing from me. Because I don't live in Hong Kong therefore there's no way for me to provide singing lessons for a lot of the students in Hong Kong. This project enables me to share my knowledge and experience with everyone around the world. Please support and keep an eye out on the announcement.
This was already the best I have heard the lawyer sing. At least he was mostly singing in tune, even on the high notes where is Season 1, he was constantly flat in entering the high notes.
@@waikitjim5668 I don't have to. I can tell from the sound that the support is not there. But singing out of tune is much more low level than singing from the throat. I actually like the lawyer since last year's contest. I think he is a good person and fun guy, but he can do with some singing lessons.
Everything is interconnected. Whether it's out of tune, out of breath, poor sound quality, etc, it all comes back to improper breathing support and management
Breathing is a very common problem among singers, even the so-called professionals. I can see out of this competition, only a handful you can say the breathing technique has a passing grade
@@RogerSingingStudio You can have perfect breathing support and still sing consistently out of tune because you are tone deaf. When the lawyer sang out of tune reaching for a high note last year, he did not have proper support, but the main reason for singing flat was that he did not aim higher than where he thought the note was.
李佳是一個唱歌老師, 所以她懂得遷就她的對手。𣎴似龍明明是副, 但竟變了主場。
劉可與李佳合唱的我是一隻小小鳥很出色！李佳的確是一個很好很稱職的幫唱，她沒有搶去注意力，而是配合著劉，她的襯托讓劉更能突顯倒自己的優點。欣賞劉由開首用較輕力唱，慢慢build up至激昂地唱，直至到首歌最後的爆發並帶來高潮！由於李佳的聲音有足夠力量，這配合倒劉可強而有力的聲線和他於首歌尾斷所造的爆發！
李佳唱得不好，点会教唱歌，所以不公平！
教唱歌就一定唱得😂😂😂😂好嗎?
兩人實力相當自然不會被一方吸引所有注意力，反之若一方強而另一方弱，正如添Sir 講，注意力自然集中在強那方，這個情況在這一集已經很明顯。
支持劉可 佳佳👍👍👍👍👍
偏愛聽古淖文，人靚，聲靚，快歌，慢歌，跳舞都得，連Rap都咁正！全能歌手！努力！加油！😊👍👍💪💪👏👏
古淖文 和 吉吉～好好聽呀！唯一令我在電視旁也動起來！尤其是尾段Rap更正！帶動全埸！應該最小89分！正！努力！加油！😊👍👍👍💪💪💪👏👏👏
Roger老師非常專業，分析得好詳盡，長知識了。
譚輝智從第一次唱‘’心碎了無痕“”我已經鍾意佢，越唱越好，一路殺入14強，冠軍都有可能。
劉可+佳佳老師的表演非常出色，完美演繹到歌中的含意和精髓，好感動！是我心目中的冠軍MVP，支持劉可！加油！
支持劉可是我所愛❤
我都鍾意啟豪同輝智，兩位都唱得好好，好有感情，希望他會取第1名
古淖文真係越唱越好，又多變化，好喜歡有佢嘅舞台🎉🎉🎉真係好正👍👍👍超LIKE
聽佢哋嘅訪問，友共情整首個嘅編曲是吉吉設計，和Rap那段都係吉吉提出嘅想法！👍👍💯💯
好鍾意聽Roger老師嘅分析，獲益良多！🎶👍
古淖文唱得好好聽，自然，另人聽得舒服👍👍👍
李佳一個人將兩位開始走向邊緣的參賽者帶回來更上一層樓；
龍婷一個人帶住兩位參賽者步入危險區。
Good observation
龍婷可能唔識唱和音，所以要陳唱
中2、最喜歡劉可和輝智👏👏👏
我聼完譚輝智尼集都覺得譚輝智好有前途,比我有張學友初出道時有的能力和技巧,唱歌時鬆容不迫,同意Roger 老師所講佢係中2男生技巧最高,甚至論穩定性還比安雅希好,除了老師說他如果情感再投入會更好外,同羅啟豪一樣,佢可能唱節拍強勁點的歌比較弱項!這點可能係佢奪冠的障礙!
回覆
佳佳老師自己又唱得好,有識得就人,真係一位好老師,同佢配搭自然好。
Roger老師，你講得冇錯，譚輝智佢嘅歌唱技巧係無懈可擊，無論係用氣拍子咁甚至乎共鳴恰到好處，我認為佢越唱越好，冇咗怕羞嗰種缺點六強佢一定入，看能否更上一層樓。另外所有評判淨係識得評情演繹等等很少講技巧Roger老師反而你講到好多技巧，這點我認同這種商業同娛樂嘅歌唱比賽，我認為用三個準則去評分才對（悟性、質素，毅力）平均分數才能精準⋯⋯
古淖文進步神速！ 我也 enjoy his voice! His rapping 👍👍
劉可唱得好有感情，好好聽，加油
❤❤❤❤
周吉佩 🍊🍊揀選 古淖文 用心用力協助指導 淖文 合唱
「友共情」一曲，吉吉 是向難度挑戰，這首歌唱法由吉吉 從新編排過，尾部分更加上RAP，創意無限，將「友共情」首歌加上無限色彩，畫面，友情，溫情和故事性，吉吉 幫助到 淳文 脫胎換骨，洗滌評判說
German 的江湖味一掃而空，吉吉大師兄出馬確實非同凡響，兩位是全晚最緊張最期待最出色最吸睛的演出歌手
吉吉 是向難度挑戰，耗時間心力惱力無私的付出，成功幫助淖文，理應嬴得更高分數，超過91分🎉🎉
可可加油❤❤
拍到佳佳老師當然好啦！拍到龍婷就你有你唱，佢有佢唱表現自己，完全沒有心幫助比賽歌手，反令歌手更顯低分
同意
不同意
同意
聽 Roger 老師這個視頻像上堂一樣，因為他不單講解，還會用不同方法，包括播放唱歌片斷，親自示範好和不好的唱法，並因而令人清楚明白如何可以唱得更好，的確是一個懂得教和很有heart的老師
謝謝Roger Sir分享！友共情段rap係吉吉寫同提議既，本來古唔太接受，但喺吉既強烈建議下，古最終接受左，明智決定👍
劉威煌今集表現超好，我覺得佢應該羅M V P，但無論點，佢越唱越好，相信有一次一定羅到mvp，佢係我心目中冠軍,加油你一定得,要相信自己.
喜歡劍文演繹這首歌曲，他外型亦不錯
我覺得他的聲音係男參賽者中最好聽，覺得他會入六強，這幾集評判開始每集給他好評。
老師評論有理有據，難得有示範❤
下集我個人覺得唱得好的有
輝智，焯文，劍文，威煌，牛河
其中輝智最勁👍好值得攞MVP 🎉
認同黃劍文今次唱得好, 令人眼前一亮. 那位嚟幫唱的魏嘉信是"中一幫"實力最弱的一位.
FC is the best in pt2 and Ranom is the best male in part 1
支持老師分析,呢集各熱門選手表現真係幾好,李佳又幫到手真係好野,黃劍文有黑馬感覺
譚輝智祖好過安雅希那組，但肥伍給19分安雅希，安唱得不是太好，不及譚，譚那組應最少93分。
支持古淖文及吉吉💯💯💯💯💯💓💓💓💓💓
劉威煌終於俾我睇到佢有返自信！
同意Roger老師講，古淖文每一集都越來越好，每一集都有驚喜，加油！
多謝分析，長見識
支持吓Roger先 🎉
Thank you host for your awesome detailed analysis. This is the first time that I listened patiently till the end. You make me understand what went wrong with my favourite contestant's performance, his flaws and strength. Thumbs up! ❤
Thank you for your support. From now on you should always listen to the very end for every single one of my video. 😂
@@RogerSingingStudio Yes, indeed. 😊
最近真係突然注意到黃劍文，真係好好聽
認同, 最近幾集我開始留意到黃劍文是男子參賽者之中聲音最好聽, 而好彩評判亦開始留意到他, 現在每一集都讚他, 以他的聲音, 才華, 外形和謙虛的態度, 又出過道, 我覺得他就是中二我的吉吉2.0, 希望他之後拿一次MVP, 入六強.
大哥評論得好❤❤
Roger老師，我和家人都覺得劉可唱法好似跟以往不同，一啲都唔自然，冇特色，但反而評判猛讚，莫明(我覺得評判只喜歡大路唱法)。
我覺得劉可唱歌有別於其他參賽者，他唱歌除了有感情更加是係有靈魂。
佢都喺人在江湖, 身不由己啫. 你要玩落佢, 就要跟大隊. 暫時唔好咁多個人主意, 否則評判唔比高分你, 問你死未?
评审们怎样都要牛河回归。😅
我喜歡他以前的唱法，他不愛我和忘記她等等
改變咗反而唔似牛河
因為肥伍不停批評佢 ！逼到佢要改變！
@@irisssschannn7645 迫到佢走。小人当道。人善天不欺。
龍婷同陳燕娜根本不是在同一級別,所以肯定未達到高分成績,睇返龍婷同李佳 羅啟豪 顏志恆......這些同級別的合作就極高水平了。
不關級別事，而各唱法不同，陳燕娜聲線柔和，應拍同類型歌手。而龍婷聲線較響，可拍劉可，顏米羔，古淖文較為恰當！
龍婷幫不到，仲要搶風頭😮同佳佳老師差得遠，永遠支持佳佳❤
不同意
Fc係好勤力自然不做作
又好humble❤❤
好多E神歌，最后2隊全晚唱得最好👍
Roger老師，今次你對古淖文的評價都不錯，但很多時他唱歌時都很緊張，尤其一開始，例如手很震，鏡頭都看到揸咪的手在震，如此不從容，表情又因為緊張的震動而很故意地裝出有感情，所以有時看上去有點造作，好像今次又給心心手，Rap時很情緒高漲，上次同安雅希合作又一樣，行到另一邊無啦啦摺衫袖叫雅希過去，感覺很多肢體動作，你又有何睇法，很想聽聽你分析！
他唱歌的時候緊張是避免不到的. 我覺得他根本是一個緊張大師. 至於他的肢體上的動作, 我同意有時候感覺是比較做多了, 但是我個人的感覺是他這一些動作是反映出來他在舞台的經驗還是不夠. 比如說你看肥媽在台上唱歌的時候, 她也有肢體動作, 但是她的動作令到觀眾覺得她很壓台.
是的，或者就是他很在意除去陣江湖味的手法，他的舞台同比賽經驗那麼豐富，但緊張到震咪就真係唔似佢，看得出他很在意！
你一再強調「今日」90分俾珈偉威煌成team, 「今天等我來」91分係俾FC，和音部份隻字不提，明嘅！一係你唔識聽，一係你極度bias。「今天等我來」呢首歌和音部份先係靈魂！
Great analysis! You must be a good singing coach.
Thank you for the compliment. It is not up to me to call myself a good singing coach. I tried my best to share my experience and knowledge, my goal of teaching is that one day hopefully none of my students will need to come to me again for lesson. It means that all of my students are able to learn songs on their own worth proper technique and interpretation, and can perform self maintenance on their voice.
@@RogerSingingStudio maybe one day you can do some analysis on the current singers … such as Mirrors! 🤭🤭
It is in my plan to do exactly that. But I will be launching and announcing a very important project in March this year. I will be launching and platform for people who want to learn the art of singing from me. Because I don't live in Hong Kong therefore there's no way for me to provide singing lessons for a lot of the students in Hong Kong. This project enables me to share my knowledge and experience with everyone around the world. Please support and keep an eye out on the announcement.
黄劍文表現最亮眼
其實你知唔知道班評審不停黑化劉可，因為觀眾同佢唔熟，嗰班評審就可以妖言惑眾。如果有智慧去分析，睇過佢接受過傳媒訪問，就知道同班評審講嘅態度，啱啱相反。
認同。劉可聽完肥媽評語，都眼都紅埋。可能受庒，受委屈咁。可能想起朱仔 out 因為佢，班友要跟劇本，制做氣氛。
聴完比賽，再聽老師講評述。得益不少
完全讚成老師對黃劍文的好評，他值得得到MPV！
欲加之罪何患無辭 ，班小圈子评判如生死判官，可以将事實扭成任何结果，像中國好声音的那英，周深都可以淘汰
龍婷第一次副歌係有唱和音，之後重覆既時候就一直唱和音，但係應該係陳燕娜自己選的
Well said.
FC ❤
我試驗過舌頭位置真係好影響好緊雖然我不懂唱歌都能感受到😊
辉智的声线冇得弹🎉
刘可因压力太大令他发挥不完美，真的心疼刘可的
認同，好心痛劉可
劉可加油❤❤💪💪
牛河你得㗎！不要放棄呀！🉑🉑
可能俾d評判之前否定他個人風格的評論影響咗他的信心和開頭的表現，但好彩他之後愈唱愈好，發揮倒自己
我發覺呢個頻道既主持冇乜做功課就評論，古淖文最尾嗰段英文係周吉佩編曲給古唱的，就係因為要突顯古的唱功，又或者主持是不喜歡周吉佩？？
陳燕娜的導師教得欠佳，且整首歌唱得麻麻！如果陳燕娜揾李佳，可能效果不同！因李佳可以遷就他人，是眾人最佳拍檔！
認同老師的說法,這首漫步人生路很平谈。中二生是主角,中一生是襯托才对
@@shanhangfu4243 龍婷不分莊閒，反客為主！
顏 應該揾留可先啱。
點解要同顏比較，依家要睇嘅 係梁， 係要睇梁 嘅表現，唔係睇 同佢一齊唱個個，比賽緊嘅係 梁，唔係同佢一齊唱個個！
不如揾莫華倫黎同佢地唱，睇下夾唔夾到😢😢
建议Roger 老师提醒指点一下刘可就好了，今天他们给刘可唱这首歌的难度实在太多了，刘可的唱功是okay 的，只是前两集他和评判团的答话是有瓜答瓜令评判不满而对刘可的误解……
我是一只小小小烏，呢首歌難度好高的。真係要加難度分。
肥伍根本上是不合格的評判，他不懂講普通話，更不用說他雯不懂批評唱普通話的發音是否正確，那么怎做一個全面性的評判呢！他評分不公，說話克薄。
說對晒，佢只識用手指。
同感，不識合做評判，太不知所謂，說的都是 rubbish
古卓文唱得好好聽可惜有評判暗低古卓文啲分數😤
同意
我也同意
謝謝Roger 老師嘅仔細分析，老師說話非常中肯👍。請問老師一下，我怎樣才能跟老師學習唱歌呢？謝謝🙏🏻
因為我不是住在香港, 所以呢我不能夠跟香港的朋友們上課. 但是有一個好消息, 我在今年三月份的時候會宣佈一個學習唱歌的平台, 那個時候任何人都可以跟我學習唱歌. 請繼續的關注我, 密切留意我的消息.
@@RogerSingingStudio 嘩！😍太好了🙏🏻謝謝！
你一定要繼續的關注我, 這個平台是我2024年的一個重點計畫. 我希望可以幫助更加多想學唱歌的人,
@@RogerSingingStudio 我一定一定一定會繼續關注Roger 老師同參加🎤☺️你嘅教學。你之前每一個短片，我都有睇。我也從當中學習自我檢討，始終有些細節，都好想找機會問老師，指點迷津。🙏🏻🙇🏻♂️
This was already the best I have heard the lawyer sing. At least he was mostly singing in tune, even on the high notes where is Season 1, he was constantly flat in entering the high notes.
When the lawyer breathes, please pay attention to his lifting shoulders.
@@waikitjim5668 I don't have to. I can tell from the sound that the support is not there. But singing out of tune is much more low level than singing from the throat. I actually like the lawyer since last year's contest. I think he is a good person and fun guy, but he can do with some singing lessons.
Everything is interconnected. Whether it's out of tune, out of breath, poor sound quality, etc, it all comes back to improper breathing support and management
Breathing is a very common problem among singers, even the so-called professionals. I can see out of this competition, only a handful you can say the breathing technique has a passing grade
@@RogerSingingStudio You can have perfect breathing support and still sing consistently out of tune because you are tone deaf. When the lawyer sang out of tune reaching for a high note last year, he did not have proper support, but the main reason for singing flat was that he did not aim higher than where he thought the note was.
講嚟都哂氣，啲分數一早內定㗎啦！
真心 以劉可功力 不可能唱得那麼牽強 可能大會要求吧 因為從15強開始 已一直聽到有人說劉可成功回歸
因為評審們只喜歡卡拉OK水準。
壓住左佢嘅特質，沒有了自己😢
支持🍊🍊淖文🧡🧡
Before they performed, the judges already have decided that Leung would be out. So even during the song, they were talking to justify their scores.
龍婷唱得自然冇花巧，陳燕娜唱得拘謹!
Support and like 👍 👍👍💪💪💪🙏🙏🙏
我要更正(周、古配)那段Rap，原先(周)建議加段Rap，但(古)不想....最終還是這個助攻板本！
龍衹適街頭
佢係實力派，用不着搶風頭，隨便唱都己好好
有辱他人。
王玥真係好彩
其實陳燕娜，梁浩賢都唱得好過王玥，但王玥高分過佢哋，梁更要被foul
非常同意
劇本安排，佢同苦盈有金身護體，可能留得長過陳燕娜沈忠賢😢
@@momota987 苦盈同中一賣慘仔可以組情侶檔😁
龍婷，無助工。
陳慧孄亂比分，唱得差比高分，唱得好比低分
陳比安17分
龍婷屢受批評，其实佢配對個兩個都係弱嘅.選歌又係平淡.冇乜編排，龍婷自已唱歌就梗係冇得彈，但佢吾係歌唱老師.其它中一生有幾個都係教唱歌嘅.還有其它原因，所以罪不在佢，吾好成日針對佢
非常認同
講得好啱！👍
對龍婷來說是很難決擇的, 要帶兩個水準最低的, 佢唱得差, 龍只能二選一, 自己都降低水準去配合, 或者用自己能力盡量唱好些, 拉高些分數, 好明顯龍婷選後者而正常只能選後者.
龍婷人品好，點會唔想幫唱？兩個都是阿斗，
扶不上。
龍婷唱得太過大聲啦！所以佢就會好似蓋過晒參賽者既聲音
因為龍婷唱和音唔掂，所以要陳唱和音
應該係
梁浩賢、一早應該走冇
冇優點可言，
好過果兩個女仔先
劉可係刻意將，嗰句唱到好像初出茅廬的小子一樣，唔識演繹唔識唱歌咁，唱出嚟。以劉可歌藝咁了不起，絕對唔會走音😮 Roger老師你未夠經驗，😅
你講到咁我真係無話可說.. 🙄
睇過一段訪問，劉可的耳機出場時有問題只聽到咯咯聲，聴唔到音樂所以影響了個key，後來好快修正咗，所以佢自己都覺得不太滿意的
太大吾中意古，成日面部太多動作😢😢
FC真係唔似素人
唱歌技巧咁好😮
佢是否話無學過唱歌？🤔
@@cyung6028 yes但應該平日自己有唱😂
佢爸爸也是唱歌的,應該有受爸爸影響甚至教過佢唱歌,同埋輝智應該都係有天份嘅。
FC自然,用功