Hey, a Manchester United fan here. I believe that Ruben Amorim could give Manchester United some success but I honestly do think it will take time. One of the first things Ruben Amorim had to do as soon as he joined Manchester United was to figure out who fits his system and who does not, and who he needs to buy and who he needs to keep and sell. I'll be sharing out my suggestions today. So, obviously, it hasn't been the BEST start for Ruben Amorim at Manchester United as the results for the games he has managed ended up like this: - Ipswich Town 1-1 Manchester United - Manchester United 3-2 Bodo Glimt - Manchester United 4-0 Everton - Arsenal 2-0 Manchester United - Manchester United 2-3 Nottingham Forest - Viktoria Plzen 1-2 Manchester United - Manchester City 1-2 Manchester United - Tottenham Hotspur 4-3 Manchester United - Manchester United 0-3 Bournemouth Ruben Amorim has officially managed 9 games for Manchester United so far. 6 games in the Premier League, 2 games in the Europa League and 1 game in the Carabao Cup. Out of those 9 games, Ruben Amorim's Manchester United have won 4, drawn 1 and lost 4. I will be going through every single position in Ruben Amorim's system and decide who he should keep and who he should sell. GOALKEEPERS: There are currently 3 goalkeepers at Manchester United. Their first-choice keeper in Andre Onana, their second-choice keeper in Altay Bayindir and their third-choice keeper in Tom Heaton. I think Andre Onana should be a definite keep as he hasn't been really bad this season and it would be hard just to find another first-choice keeper off the bat. I think Bayindir should be a keep also. I know people consider him as a dodgy goalkeeper, especially in the Carabao Cup quarter-finals against Tottenham Hotspur. However, we need to remember that Altay only plays in less critical fixtures. I believe Tom Heaton should also be a keep as he is a useful homegrown player in the squad. ONANA - keep BAYINDIR - keep HEATON - keep CENTRE-BACKS (for the 3 at the back): Ruben Amorim has 3 centre-backs with 2 wider centre-backs and 1 which is more central. A lot of people criticise this defender but I think Lisandro Martinez should be a keep. In Amorim's system, Lisandro plays as one of the more wider centre-backs who need to be more attacking and ball-playing. We know Lisandro Martinez can be capable of that after seeing his assist to Amad Diallo in the Manchester Derby. Maybe in like a year or 2, Lisandro can be getting demoted to the bench but I don't think he should be a sell. Another defender who plays as a wider centre-back in Amorim's system is Leny Yoro, and I think he should be a keep too. Despite Manchester United currently struggling, Yoro is probably the only defender putting in at least a decent performance. Similarly to Lisandro Martinez, Leny Yoro has to be more attacking and ball-playing. Despite it only being pre-season, we saw Leny Yoro produce a great ball to one of our academy players against Rangers. I personally believe Leny Yoro could be a star under Ruben Amorim. Currently, the more central centre-back in Ruben Amorim's plan has been Matthijs de Ligt. His role is to be more defensive and to prevent attacks from the opposition and also try and drive the team forward. At the start of the season, it has been a rocky start for Matthijs de Ligt but now I can see him starting to improve, especially after Erik ten Hag's exit. I think Matthijs de Ligt should be a keep as well. I also believe that Luke Shaw and Harry Maguire should stay as back-up centre-backs. Unfortunately, I think Victor Lindelof and Jonny Evans should leave the club. I don't believe we need that much squad depth for our centre-backs and for me, Luke Shaw and Harry Maguire are better options than Victor Lindelof and Jonny Evans. However, I do think we should sign a centre-back. This defender has played under Ruben Amorim before, back at Sporting Lisbon, where he was the more central centre-back and was great at stopping attacks - his name is: Ousmane Diomande. I think he could be a great add to Manchester United and that would shift Matthijs de Ligt to a RCB, which I think wouldn't be a problem as he played as a RCB back when he played in Juventus. DE LIGT - keep YORO - keep MARTINEZ - keep SHAW - keep MAGUIRE - keep LINDELOF - sell EVANS - sell WING-BACKS: Before I even get to context, I think I speak on behalf of most Manchester United fans. Diogo Dalot will not thrive if he is continuously going to be used as a LWB. Sure, he can be a future wing-back under Ruben Amorim, but he would have to be on the right side of the pitch. However, since Noussair Mazraoui is far more consistent and is in better form than Diogo Dalot at the moment, I think Dalot will be the back-up RWB as Mazraoui will be starting over him. With Diogo Dalot being converted to a RWB, the only LWB we now have is Tyrell Malacia, who I believe should be sold as well. He hasn't played professional football for 18 months and his return back at Manchester United hasn't been the best. The first player Ruben Amorim needs to sign is a LWB. There are plenty of options including: Alphonso Davies, Alejandro Grimaldo, Rayan Ait-Nouri and Maximiliano Araujo. However, I only think we need one. Araujo could be a great shout as he played under Amorim back at Sporting. However, I think this LWB needs to be signed at January and Amorim did say that he wasn't going to buy Sporting players in January. There have been rumours that Alphonso Davies could join Manchester United, so I think he will be the man. Besides, he looks like he is going to leave Bayern Munich soon enough anyway. I think Rayan Ait-Nouri could be the perfect back-up for Alphonso Davies as he is a LB that CAN play as a LWB. Also, I don't think Ruben Amorim needs Antony for any longer and I think he needs to be sold. MAZRAOUI - keep DALOT - keep MALACIA - sell ANTONY - sell MIDFIELD: Ruben Amorim has 2 midfielders in his starting 11 who have two slightly different roles. One of them plays more attacking and more like an 8 while the other plays more defensive and more like a 6. The 4 players currently at Manchester United who plays in these roles are: Kobbie Mainoo, Manuel Ugarte, Christian Eriksen and Casemiro. Out of these 4 players, I would like 2 of them to go - Christian Eriksen and Casemiro. I'm sorry, but they do not have the legs to have a future at Manchester United. With them 2 gone, Kobbie Mainoo and Manuel Ugarte are the only midfielders to remain so if we're going to get rid of both Eriksen and Casemiro, we need to sign a back-up or 2. A great shout would be Morten Hjulmand. He is another player who played under Ruben Amorim back at Sporting and can play like a 6 which could be a perfect replacement for Casemiro. The other midfielder I have suggested is a bit more young but could be a back-up still for Manchester United: Ederson. MAINOO - keep UGARTE - keep ERIKSEN - sell CASEMIRO - sell INSIDE FORWARDS/ATTACKING MIDFIELDERS: In Amorim's system, he has 2 inside forwards that play just behind the striker and could even assist them to score. The players who currently play at that position for Ruben Amorim are: Amad Diallo, Bruno Fernandes, Alejandro Garnacho, Marcus Rashford and Mason Mount. I do not see Amad Diallo getting sold as he has arguably been Manchester United's best player this season so far, neither do I see Bruno Fernandes or Alejandro Garnacho getting sold. I think it is already obvious that there is a high chance of Marcus Rashford leaving and if we get the big money for Mason Mount, I don't see why we shouldn't accept it. There are rumours that Ruben Amorim will sign Takefusa Kubo as a replacement for Marcus Rashford and I don't see a problem with that. AMAD - keep FERNANDES - keep GARNACHO - keep RASHFORD - sell MOUNT - 50/50 (if we get the big money for him then accept) STRIKER: Currently, there are 2 strikers at Manchester United - Rasmus Hojlund and Joshua Zirkzee. In Amorim's system, the striker needs to be clinical finisher and need to finish off the chances that they get. Unfortunately, Joshua Zirkzee doesn't have that in him. I believe that Rasmus Hojlund could thrive under Ruben Amorim but sometimes he can become inconsistent. I think we should demote Rasmus Hojlund to a second choice striker and to sell Joshua Zirkzee immediately. Viktor Gyokeres and Victor Osimhen are great shouts for a first-choice striker but since this man has worked under Ruben Amorim back at Sporting. I think Gyokeres would be a more realistic signing. HOJLUND - keep ZIRKZEE - sell NEW A-TEAM GK: Andre Onana RCB: Matthijs de Ligt CB: Ousmane Diomande LCB: Lisandro Martinez RWB: Noussair Mazraoui CM: Kobbie Mainoo CM: Manuel Ugarte LWB: Alphonso Davies CAM: Amad Diallo CAM: Bruno Fernandes ST: Rasmus Hojlund NEW B-TEAM GK: Altay Bayindir RCB: Leny Yoro CB: Harry Maguire LCB: Luke Shaw RWB: Diogo Dalot CM: Morten Hjulmand CM: Ederson LWB: Rayan Ait-Nouri CAM: Alejandro Garnacho CAM: Takefusa Kubo ST: Rasmus Hojlund (I definitely do not expect all of this to happen in January, probably at the end of the 25/26 season. Also please give feedback as it took a long time).
"Another disappointing spell for Manchester United. The inconsistency is frustrating, and it feels like the squad lacks the cohesion and intensity needed to compete at the top level. The players need to show more fight, and the management must step up to address the glaring issues. The fans deserve better than this rollercoaster of form."
Old stories. New manager needs new players and he fails to deliver with his new players he is shown the door and a new manager hired and the old story repeats itself. The new manager should use the present players and produce results and we amend the team or buy some few in the transfer window. You can't alter the entire squad once and get all your desired players once.
Hey, a Manchester United fan here. I believe that Ruben Amorim could give Manchester United some success but I honestly do think it will take time. One of the first things Ruben Amorim had to do as soon as he joined Manchester United was to figure out who fits his system and who does not, and who he needs to buy and who he needs to keep and sell. I'll be sharing out my suggestions today. So, obviously, it hasn't been the BEST start for Ruben Amorim at Manchester United as the results for the games he has managed ended up like this:
- Ipswich Town 1-1 Manchester United
- Manchester United 3-2 Bodo Glimt
- Manchester United 4-0 Everton
- Arsenal 2-0 Manchester United
- Manchester United 2-3 Nottingham Forest
- Viktoria Plzen 1-2 Manchester United
- Manchester City 1-2 Manchester United
- Tottenham Hotspur 4-3 Manchester United
- Manchester United 0-3 Bournemouth
Ruben Amorim has officially managed 9 games for Manchester United so far. 6 games in the Premier League, 2 games in the Europa League and 1 game in the Carabao Cup. Out of those 9 games, Ruben Amorim's Manchester United have won 4, drawn 1 and lost 4. I will be going through every single position in Ruben Amorim's system and decide who he should keep and who he should sell.
GOALKEEPERS:
There are currently 3 goalkeepers at Manchester United. Their first-choice keeper in Andre Onana, their second-choice keeper in Altay Bayindir and their third-choice keeper in Tom Heaton. I think Andre Onana should be a definite keep as he hasn't been really bad this season and it would be hard just to find another first-choice keeper off the bat. I think Bayindir should be a keep also. I know people consider him as a dodgy goalkeeper, especially in the Carabao Cup quarter-finals against Tottenham Hotspur. However, we need to remember that Altay only plays in less critical fixtures. I believe Tom Heaton should also be a keep as he is a useful homegrown player in the squad.
ONANA - keep
BAYINDIR - keep
HEATON - keep
CENTRE-BACKS (for the 3 at the back):
Ruben Amorim has 3 centre-backs with 2 wider centre-backs and 1 which is more central. A lot of people criticise this defender but I think Lisandro Martinez should be a keep. In Amorim's system, Lisandro plays as one of the more wider centre-backs who need to be more attacking and ball-playing. We know Lisandro Martinez can be capable of that after seeing his assist to Amad Diallo in the Manchester Derby. Maybe in like a year or 2, Lisandro can be getting demoted to the bench but I don't think he should be a sell. Another defender who plays as a wider centre-back in Amorim's system is Leny Yoro, and I think he should be a keep too. Despite Manchester United currently struggling, Yoro is probably the only defender putting in at least a decent performance. Similarly to Lisandro Martinez, Leny Yoro has to be more attacking and ball-playing. Despite it only being pre-season, we saw Leny Yoro produce a great ball to one of our academy players against Rangers. I personally believe Leny Yoro could be a star under Ruben Amorim. Currently, the more central centre-back in Ruben Amorim's plan has been Matthijs de Ligt. His role is to be more defensive and to prevent attacks from the opposition and also try and drive the team forward. At the start of the season, it has been a rocky start for Matthijs de Ligt but now I can see him starting to improve, especially after Erik ten Hag's exit. I think Matthijs de Ligt should be a keep as well. I also believe that Luke Shaw and Harry Maguire should stay as back-up centre-backs. Unfortunately, I think Victor Lindelof and Jonny Evans should leave the club. I don't believe we need that much squad depth for our centre-backs and for me, Luke Shaw and Harry Maguire are better options than Victor Lindelof and Jonny Evans. However, I do think we should sign a centre-back. This defender has played under Ruben Amorim before, back at Sporting Lisbon, where he was the more central centre-back and was great at stopping attacks - his name is: Ousmane Diomande. I think he could be a great add to Manchester United and that would shift Matthijs de Ligt to a RCB, which I think wouldn't be a problem as he played as a RCB back when he played in Juventus.
DE LIGT - keep
YORO - keep
MARTINEZ - keep
SHAW - keep
MAGUIRE - keep
LINDELOF - sell
EVANS - sell
WING-BACKS:
Before I even get to context, I think I speak on behalf of most Manchester United fans. Diogo Dalot will not thrive if he is continuously going to be used as a LWB. Sure, he can be a future wing-back under Ruben Amorim, but he would have to be on the right side of the pitch. However, since Noussair Mazraoui is far more consistent and is in better form than Diogo Dalot at the moment, I think Dalot will be the back-up RWB as Mazraoui will be starting over him. With Diogo Dalot being converted to a RWB, the only LWB we now have is Tyrell Malacia, who I believe should be sold as well. He hasn't played professional football for 18 months and his return back at Manchester United hasn't been the best. The first player Ruben Amorim needs to sign is a LWB. There are plenty of options including: Alphonso Davies, Alejandro Grimaldo, Rayan Ait-Nouri and Maximiliano Araujo. However, I only think we need one. Araujo could be a great shout as he played under Amorim back at Sporting. However, I think this LWB needs to be signed at January and Amorim did say that he wasn't going to buy Sporting players in January. There have been rumours that Alphonso Davies could join Manchester United, so I think he will be the man. Besides, he looks like he is going to leave Bayern Munich soon enough anyway. I think Rayan Ait-Nouri could be the perfect back-up for Alphonso Davies as he is a LB that CAN play as a LWB. Also, I don't think Ruben Amorim needs Antony for any longer and I think he needs to be sold.
MAZRAOUI - keep
DALOT - keep
MALACIA - sell
ANTONY - sell
MIDFIELD:
Ruben Amorim has 2 midfielders in his starting 11 who have two slightly different roles. One of them plays more attacking and more like an 8 while the other plays more defensive and more like a 6. The 4 players currently at Manchester United who plays in these roles are: Kobbie Mainoo, Manuel Ugarte, Christian Eriksen and Casemiro. Out of these 4 players, I would like 2 of them to go - Christian Eriksen and Casemiro. I'm sorry, but they do not have the legs to have a future at Manchester United. With them 2 gone, Kobbie Mainoo and Manuel Ugarte are the only midfielders to remain so if we're going to get rid of both Eriksen and Casemiro, we need to sign a back-up or 2. A great shout would be Morten Hjulmand. He is another player who played under Ruben Amorim back at Sporting and can play like a 6 which could be a perfect replacement for Casemiro. The other midfielder I have suggested is a bit more young but could be a back-up still for Manchester United: Ederson.
MAINOO - keep
UGARTE - keep
ERIKSEN - sell
CASEMIRO - sell
INSIDE FORWARDS/ATTACKING MIDFIELDERS:
In Amorim's system, he has 2 inside forwards that play just behind the striker and could even assist them to score. The players who currently play at that position for Ruben Amorim are: Amad Diallo, Bruno Fernandes, Alejandro Garnacho, Marcus Rashford and Mason Mount. I do not see Amad Diallo getting sold as he has arguably been Manchester United's best player this season so far, neither do I see Bruno Fernandes or Alejandro Garnacho getting sold. I think it is already obvious that there is a high chance of Marcus Rashford leaving and if we get the big money for Mason Mount, I don't see why we shouldn't accept it. There are rumours that Ruben Amorim will sign Takefusa Kubo as a replacement for Marcus Rashford and I don't see a problem with that.
AMAD - keep
FERNANDES - keep
GARNACHO - keep
RASHFORD - sell
MOUNT - 50/50 (if we get the big money for him then accept)
STRIKER:
Currently, there are 2 strikers at Manchester United - Rasmus Hojlund and Joshua Zirkzee. In Amorim's system, the striker needs to be clinical finisher and need to finish off the chances that they get. Unfortunately, Joshua Zirkzee doesn't have that in him. I believe that Rasmus Hojlund could thrive under Ruben Amorim but sometimes he can become inconsistent. I think we should demote Rasmus Hojlund to a second choice striker and to sell Joshua Zirkzee immediately. Viktor Gyokeres and Victor Osimhen are great shouts for a first-choice striker but since this man has worked under Ruben Amorim back at Sporting. I think Gyokeres would be a more realistic signing.
HOJLUND - keep
ZIRKZEE - sell
NEW A-TEAM
GK: Andre Onana
RCB: Matthijs de Ligt
CB: Ousmane Diomande
LCB: Lisandro Martinez
RWB: Noussair Mazraoui
CM: Kobbie Mainoo
CM: Manuel Ugarte
LWB: Alphonso Davies
CAM: Amad Diallo
CAM: Bruno Fernandes
ST: Rasmus Hojlund
NEW B-TEAM
GK: Altay Bayindir
RCB: Leny Yoro
CB: Harry Maguire
LCB: Luke Shaw
RWB: Diogo Dalot
CM: Morten Hjulmand
CM: Ederson
LWB: Rayan Ait-Nouri
CAM: Alejandro Garnacho
CAM: Takefusa Kubo
ST: Rasmus Hojlund
(I definitely do not expect all of this to happen in January, probably at the end of the 25/26 season. Also please give feedback as it took a long time).
@@flash-far-1362 you are too much with this your writings 👍👍
Where's Yoro and we're not getting 10 players in JANUARY? I like your thinking though.
If tha dream comes true,ManU.l will be unsakable by any soccer in Europe.
😮😮😮😮
"Another disappointing spell for Manchester United. The inconsistency is frustrating, and it feels like the squad lacks the cohesion and intensity needed to compete at the top level. The players need to show more fight, and the management must step up to address the glaring issues. The fans deserve better than this rollercoaster of form."
@@GrupManUnited well spoken 👏👍
Onana out
Old stories. New manager needs new players and he fails to deliver with his new players he is shown the door and a new manager hired and the old story repeats itself. The new manager should use the present players and produce results and we amend the team or buy some few in the transfer window. You can't alter the entire squad once and get all your desired players once.
Stupid line up with onana
Calm down brother,he is better than Bayindir
IF RASHFORD ISNOT MAN UTD MANUTD WILLNOT WIN
Is a lie