Tribal People React to The Greatest Speech Ever Made - The Great Dictator
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 4 ก.ย. 2021
- Tribal people reacting to the greatest speech ever made by Charlie Chaplin from the great dictator movie
The purpose of this video is to show the reaction of tribal Pakistani people to
Charlie Chaplin's speech from the great dictator
Our patreon: / trybals
Buy Adnan a coffee: www.buymeacoffee.com/trybalse...
Merch: trybals.myspreadshop.com/
Follow us on:
Facebook: / trybals-105923538317572
Instagram: / trybals_official
Twitter: / trybals1
Please note that this is a reaction video and contains commentary.
For the original video please click here:
• Charlie Chaplin - Fina...
If you are the original copyright owner and would like this video to be taken down please reach out to me at trybalsofficial@gmail.com
All the participants in this video are from Sindh, Pakistan.
Make sure to leave a like and valuable suggestions and please support our channel by hitting that subscribe button. Thanks for watching
www.copyright.gov/fair-use/
Copyright Disclaimer under section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.”
#CharlieChaplin #TheGreatestSpeechEverMade #TheGreatDictator
Sorry I accidentally deleted the part where I shared a quote with Mohammad Riaz Jutt so I am just sharing it here with you too: "Only the dead have seen the end of war"
That is a quote from plato I believe
@@UNION_JACK_THE_RIPPER yes. Here's another one: "If we don't end war, the war will end us" ~ H.G. Wells
@@TRYBALS my father was a soldier when he was younger and he said this too me. "It is easy to call for blood and war before it happens. But at the end no one asks was it worth it."
@@UNION_JACK_THE_RIPPER As a veteran of the war in Afghanistan, we certainly do, and I don't think it was.
The speech in the Great Dictator always puts me to tears
Chaplin had been playing this character of the Little Tramp since the 1910s. He knew that the advent of sound in movies was going to kill the Tramp. He made Modern Times in the sound era, but it was still mostly silent, and the Tramp never spoke. When he made The Great Dictator, he saw the evil in a man who was born just a week apart from himself, who had the same mustache that he'd made a beloved symbol of the Tramp, and he knew that if he was going to 'kill off' the Tramp, by allowing him to speak, by breaking the pantomime that made him the world's very first international movie star, then the Tramp had to 'die' saying something he believed in. In a way, The Great Dictator was a memorial for the Little Tramp, and a funeral notice for Adolf Hitler. This movie, this subject, and this speech were so important to Chaplin, he sacrificed his beloved Little Tramp persona, in order to make it.
Very well said. Thank you for this wonderful perspective.
Well said, thank you my man.
This comment reminded me of a part of a paper I wrote as a student. For what it's worth it sharing it here:
There is only a thin veil between the fictitious world of Tomainia, Osterlich and Bacteria and contemporary reality in The Great Dictator. The story’s satirical nature thus prompts the question: who is performing this oration?
First, there is Chaplin who speaks as an actor-director, making a political film and as such also a political oration. His logical counterpart is the Jewish barber who tries to bring a lost nation back to the right path.
However, is there also a third speaker? Some critics of the speech have claimed that Chaplin / the Jewish barber is out of character (Kamin, 2004, p. 9). One has to admit that the passionate oration does not seem to fit with the calm, reserved, and somewhat clumsy nature of the Jewish barber. Moreover, in the speech he refers to the Gospel According to Luke despite his Jewish background. One could say that there is a third speaker who transcends both Chaplin and the Jewish barber. This third character remains part of the story of The Great Dictator, but again transcends the particularity of the Jewish barber. Like the Tramp, the third speaker represents the universal. It is the reasoned voice of the universal whereas the Tramp was its mute body.
Thank you for teaching me this perspective today, amazing metaphorical beauty in that
"Different Worlds in the Same Room" - that quote literally defines this generation. Very well said.
Words of truth...
They are as if they came from another planet...🤦♂️NEVER heard about Hitler..
YESS, yayy generations UNITE! Black Sabbath: Just do it for the people, we love you! -Ozzy
yep
As a veteran, I always tear up a little listening to this speech. Our service members in America are treated awfully. They are all viewed as a resource towards the greedy ambitions of powerful politicians who will do everything they can to keep their stranglehold on our country. All of the good, thoughtful leaders leave or are forced out of the service while the ones who overwork their subordinates and shift all of the blame down on them whenever anything goes wrong are the ones who get recognized and promoted, reinforcing the idea that the only way to succeed is to use your fellows as tools. This is why it is a horrible cycle that will never be broken. I truly wish for a day when the cooperation and brotherhood the military constantly boasts about are its true values, but I don't think it will ever happen.
I hear you, sir.
Let me get this straight. You are a veteran and still haven't come to terms with the fact soldiers exist to do the bidding of politicians?
I can't imagine living life in perpetual denial. Soldiers are gubermental tools employed for the purpose of preserving the status quo or orchestrating it.
@@joweydelanota7421 That's not even close to what I said. I'm not getting into any kind of discussion with you if the first thing you do is try to twist my words into something ridiculous.
@@shrubninja6444 My response is a fair assessment to your comment. The cycle will never end because ppl like you can't accept the thing you are bitching about is a product of your denial.
Think about it: You are a veteran. You already did the bidding.
@@shrubninja6444 Just as a reality check, I agree that wasn’t even close to what you said. And I fully support your prerogative to disengage.
The problem is when you bring introspection and perception and nuanced thinking into these discussions, some people are going to lash out from sheer frustration because they are left so far in the dust.
I love these guys...
They give genuine reactions.
And, they have big hearts.
They're good people.
Facts. Enjoy the genuine reaction and thoughts.
They have such innate wisdom in their observations! I love seeing things I thought I knew about through their eyes and experience. I learn from them!
This performance by Chaplin is a masterpiece, and quite different from his lighthearted comedy that brought fans to the theaters in droves.
I never thought about Charlie Chaplin and Mr. Bean having similar comedic styles, but Muharam is spot on about that. It's their characters' (Mr. Bean and The Little Tramp) childlike innocence that somehow reveals the most ridiculous parts of human nature, but in a way that isn't preachy and overbearing. We can recognise our own foibles in their silliness and laugh at ourselves, seeing that we all make mistakes, but can change if we want to.
@@LazyIRanch
👆😜 That's clever!
You really have a ranch named that?
My ranch is called 'The Saturn Underground' It's only one acre, but I'm raising 100s of pack-rats.
Ya ever try branding a pack-rat with a 20 letter brand?
...they hate me!
@@firstnlastnamethe3rd771 LOL! I really do, it's 20 acres on a mountain, powered by solar/wind and batteries. I have goats, chickens, 3 cats, 2 dogs, and a parrot.
I stole the "Lazy I Ranch" name from an episode of "The Simpson's", when they go to a dude ranch with that name and it's owned by a rich obnoxious Texan. I'm not rich, but I'm obnoxious and a former Texan (but kind of ashamed to admit that lately).
Unfortunately, I know about packrats all too well. I've had several cars destroyed by those damned things. Just had $1400 of repairs done to replace chewed wiring and other parts.
"The Saturn Underground" is a great name!
Have you ever exaggerated the truth even a little bit? If the awnser is yes, then you are a liar and not good. It doesn't mean that you are not loved just not God. In a court of Law we swear to tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth so help us God. We are not a good witness otherwise. Key word is not good. I think once we realize that we are not good we can start the healing process of our planet.
oh man, THANK YOU for not using that corny version of the speech that has the inception soundtrack playing over it!
this performance by chaplin is one of the best examples of what really lies at the heart of every great comedian: a deep sense understanding and empathy for the world around us and the people that inhabit it. i don't think it's any coincidence that comedy routinely produces some of the most insightful commentary on complex and troubling issues in a way that's universally relatable.
Any why comedy 'news' shows tend to end up more legit than 'real' news.
Well said
Gotta say i love that version. But i did listen to it on like my second mdma trip, so its a special connection i have to it
"The duty of comedy is to correct men by amusing them." - Moliere
@@MFZBitch woah that sounds like a wonderful experience, to hear this speech so full of love while loved up haha
Please let Abdul know that listening to him in these videos has helped me to relax when I get out of work. I work for a special charity-run school for children who have experienced trauma and it is very hard work sometimes. But when I get home I love to watch your videos, and especially look forward to Abdul's thoughts. He is so peaceful to watch and it helps keep me going :)
Thank you for your important work! Helping people in need is one of the strongest and most powerful things you can do on earth. You are making a huge difference!
I LOVE this channel!
Other "Try" channels show reactions to food and other trivial matters, while this one really goes deep. The participants really show their own wisdom and humanity in the process.
If this group of people represent Pakistan, I would LOVE to visit there!!!
PLEASE HELP THEM ON PATREON!
Well said.
@@robotempire this and common man show are the best channels
I totally agree with you. ✌️
I think the same.
I agree that this channel is special, but why bring the others down? I love Tribal People Try. The participants are lovely and fun, and I’m sure they would also enjoy these same experiences. My only concern with the channel is whether they are being exploited. I see they get a lot of gifts from fans, but I don’t get the sense they are compensated. Hoping I’m wrong.
I also think both channels would benefit from doing a collaboration with one another. Collins are like sharing followers. Both could increase followers, and we could help more people in need. I would love to eventually see whole villages get funding or help in whatever way they need it. We could easily make that happen given the cost disparities.
I believe Charlie Chaplin has read lots of philosophy, because his speech seems to be schooled in that, aside from modern humanist discourse of his time or rather before that period of time (but again right after it). I also notice it in contrast to today, because it's different from how people argue today (with their vagueness, tricks, misdirections, and lack of logic and consistency), although it's very basic and old schooling.
[And while it's "old", it always was sophisticated and progressive in its time, starting thousands of years ago... Of course with refinement over time. But that is the nature of it.]
There's definitely a communist undertone to it ("we should unite" and a few others), but he was a communist sympathiser so it's no wonder. The ideals he's talking about are those we can all agree on, too.
The UNITED states of America: guess I’m communist then.
@@theanonymouscommenter5608 I mean he also says he wants to do away with national barriers (so you're completely beside the point on that one), that the people are the victims of the system, refers to greedy politicians who took the power from the people and treat them like cattle and machines, etc. Listen again and pay attention. As I said, he was a communist sympathiser, which was not rare in Hollywood at the time, and I think you can feel it in this speech.
@@Samhalta He was suspected of being a communist symphatizer, but never actually openly supported them. The only reason that he was suspected of this was because he was rather left-wing, and didn't openly speak out against communism either - in a time when this was almost necessary to not be suspect. Mind you, having left-wing ideas is not at all equal to symphathizing with communism, and Chaplin was a self-professed strong proponent of liberalism.
@Antonio-GransciHe never said that once. Delusional and grasping at straws.
I think this was one of the most important speeches ever spoken. I’m glad you all agree and see the message he was trying to convey. It saddens me that in the 80 years since he did this speech, no one has learned from it... I can only hope we do one day.
P.S. how come Parvati hasn’t been in the last few videos?
We posted about this a few weeks ago and everyone agreed with that post. We recieved many comments that she didn't looked interested in any of the videos lately, I noticed this as well from the beggining but no one was complaining back then. We have decided to give her some break and she will be here soon.
@@TRYBALS As a woman her burdens are different then men. If there is anything as a woman we can do for her we would very much like to do it
Perhaps she could be asked what types of videos she'd like to watch?
@@mikecygk I would suggest something she can easily do at home with her children.
Something fun and educational, she said all she does is stay at home with her kids.
I wouldn't really know though since I have a computer and no kids.
@@TRYBALS I've never once thought she seemed disinterested. I enjoy her reactions and opinions, and I look forward to them when I watch these videos.
One of my favorite speeches ever. It always leaves me emotional 😢.
Same. I’m unusually a very cynical and sarcastic person but this always makes my tear up a little.
@@SethLooks When I get to feeling emotionally jaded, I watch this speech, and it helps me find my empathy again. Sometimes we get wrapped up in our own situations too much, and lose the big picture. I definitely recommend people keep that speech on hand.
I cried watching it
@@heydeanie That means you are a person with compassion, empathy, and morals. I wish those traits were contagious!
The speech takes you by the guts. It's meant to be.
Thank you for using technology to bring us together.
Well said, thank you
People forget that he was an anarchist didn't believe in any government. It was this film and a few other things which lead to him being blacklisted by the US government then had his citizenship revoked. The land of the free but only if you think the right thoughts." REST IN POWER COMRADE CHAPLAIN
I never knew that, I need to read more about him. Any recommendations?
When you are against the very foundation of a country why expect to have citizenship... and a communist? Nice...
@@user-bg6qr9mh3i the whole point of America is too have the freedom to have any opinion you want so the fact that he was stripped of citizenship for no reason other than having a different opinion. Shows the hypocrisy of the so called "land of the free"
@@UNION_JACK_THE_RIPPER you're free to think anything except the downfall of what ensures that freedom , which would be anarchism
Oh sweet, I had no idea. I'm not too surprised considering the content of the monologue. I'll have to read up on mr Chaplin more
"The Parliamentarian's in elections lie......", I screamed "YES BROTHER! SPEAK YOUR TRUTH!" These are very wise men.
What about this for a change: You show us (and them) videos from great people from that part of the world? Sometimes I have the feeling that we're a little bit too self centered and the videos are presented as "look all these wonders from the west", as if the west was some kind of magical source of wisdom and wonder, which is not "always" true. So my proposal is, lets have it a little bit going in the opposite direction. I love your channel, so this is not criticism. Let them show some of their wonders to us. If there is something this channel proves is that we are all equal. So, in a way, we are also tribal people. Let them show us! And I give you a title: Tribal people select and share Pakistani wonders with the rest of the world
This is an excellent suggestion. Thank you.
You talking world changing people?? Cuz "The Middle East" has had many of those, but sadly they cant be interviewed or shown videos off.. I Get ur point, but thats just how it is sadly.
@@Theories16 Clearly you don't know of the great individuals and scientists from the Islamic Golden Age. Like the man who developed the scientific method. Or the first attempts at manned flight.
I think you've got the wrong end of the stick... Mauro is saying it would be nice for _us_ to see the things _they_ take for granted, for a change. Their celebrities, cultural rituals, entertainment, food. It makes one feel guilty to parade the things we take for granted in front of people who see them as just short of miraculous. It's just reassurance so they know we're legitimately interested and they're not just our entertainment.
It is up to them to do it for us. If they want to show off, I'd love to see it. These people are perfectly capable of organizing themselves. Let them learn from us and make up their own solutions as well! If you think they can't, you are diminishing them.
Omg, I can't thank you enough for this video. All of these men brought tears to my eyes. I have long been a fan of this speech by Chaplin, but watching the reactions of "tribal people" has warmed my heart. The term "tribal" is usually used to indicate "backwards" thinking. It's an insult to these men. They have shown a greater capacity for human empathy and understanding than most Westerners. I would rather have these "tribal" men running America than any American politician. They actually show compassion for their fellow humans. I love and respect them all.
the context of the word tribe is not so negative in this part of the world
@tusker2418 You have right.I wish you all the best in your Life
I really liked the younger man (didn’t catch his name), when he was talking about all the lessons that all the videos are showing people. And likewise I’ve been enjoying hearing all these perspectives from people on the other side of the world. They are all such kind souls. Please thank them for sharing their thoughts.
Chaplin's voice was first heard in this movie and it wasn't the last time,either.
I was going up the list of videos, but couldn't wait for this. Paolo nutini has a song that uses this speech. I don't know how hard it is to translate a song but it's good. It has a different time though. It's more fight for what you believe in.
Also the man talking about the mosquito reminded me of a 20 year old memory. We were visiting Washington DC. Our driver stopped the van to wait for a butterfly on the windshield. People in the van made fun of him a bit, but I've remembered his carrying demeanor for over 20 years now. People like that man and him in the video make a difference.
Theme not time
I have tons of English songs for them to listen to. Not today's meaningless ones but the ones who have defined history of music. Please let me know how is it possible? I generally pause what they are viewing and translate what it said and they sometimes reflect upon it. I don't think it could be done the same with music
Paolo is today music, but he definitely respects the past. The song is iron sky by the way. I think the best way to do music would be to print out the words so people can read it while hearing it together. Music needs to be listened to and not stopped. That would help with that.
@@grannyshirt yes, or for those who can't read, read the translation to them, and then let them hear the music. Or the other way around, let them hear the music first, and then read the translation. That is how I listen to music in a different language, and it works for me. :)
I am unashamed to say this brought me to tears 😢
Why ashamed? It's true even today. I've been driven to tears a lot in the last 10 months. We have to get out and change things.
❤ much love from Oklahoma ❤
You should be proud that you are compassionate.
I said i am not ashamed.
@@synthWizkid dang... sorry I misread that!
I wonder if they know that their opinions and views are as interesting to us in developed countries as Charlie Chaplin and Bob Ross is.
Wow, I just said the exact same thing to Mohammad Riaz. I told him these videos are here as long as the platform keeps it and think your conversations being heard 100 years from now on.
@@TRYBALS Yes definitely. Recording opinions of all people is needed for history. Especially those who would not otherwise be recorded.
The work you do will likely be used for thousands of years or more. If there were no scribes and keepers of ancient knowledge and civilizations then we would know very little today. And our foundations for civilization would be very different.
@@TRYBALS indeed. I believe their words and perceptions are so important that I have chosen the cast as the focus of a college paper I'm writing on linguistics of anthropology. How the cast thinks and speaks has great value.
This is a very good and interesting point, question, topic. I suppose if one of them reads your comment right now, it might make them feel like they are living in a surreal reality. Indeed.
Every time I hear Chaplin's speech, I start to cry. His words are echoing inside of heart, getting in resonance. He is a true legend of peace!
Abdul Aziz Rind saying he had never seen a border without a wall or a fence hit me deeply. As a European, I realized I really take for granted the open borders we have here, being able to visit countries without seeing any walls or guards, only signs telling which country we enter. It's a chance and a blessing. I hope one day it will be the same everywhere. Amazing video, fantastic work as always.
Which country are you from? I asked this question because I want them to see video on those borders
@@TRYBALS I'm from France! It would be super interesting to show them videos about European borders, I agree :D Here's is one about people visiting a place that's situated on a point between Germany, Belgium and the Netherlands (th-cam.com/video/zwZ2IuqDTh8/w-d-xo.html) There are also cities where the border goes through the middle, and you don't even realize you changed countries!
@@OrlindeEarfalas it's really sth we can never imagine being done with our neighbors.
@@TRYBALS Sadly so many people are now trying to close the borders again... It happened with Britain, because exactly like Mukhtiar said politicians promise things and lie, but only think about their own profit. They say people will have more money if the borders are close because their country won't have to share with the rest of Europe. It's so frustrating because this sharing of borders was so hard to establish in the first place! Thanks to it, we haven't had a war in so long!
I am from Germany, many greetings to my neighbour france :) I grown up in a time where everywhere was a border.. My dad fled from the East Germany Regime to west Germany and when we wanted to visit my grandparents we need to fill out so many forms and documents.. The East German Regime gave us an exact route we had to take.. we were not allowed to leave the route. My dad always suspected my uncle to be a stasi member, everytime when he was around my dad shut silent and talked just about non political things.. After the fall of the wall he was able to find out the truth about my uncle.. he was right all the time.. he was a stasi member and every visit in east germany was well documented. it was not just about what my dad & mom talked about, it was about everything.. which food we had, which person we met, where we went and so on.. totally creepy.. I am so glad we dont have boarders anymore in europe.
This is an important channel. It connects us through humanity.
And let that highlight be a reminder that such a possibility exists within and through all of us. There are no borders we define within ourselves that are natural other than safety and danger. Anything else will always come from the questionable "nurture" of the world we are raised in
"God gave us a mind to make our own decisions." Wow. If only so many various religious people felt and acted this way!
This channel shows things that are pertinent to out times and our lives. Their message is universal. I dream of a world without fences and borders. I dream that every person in the world has electricity, affordable food, free healthcare, free education, homes with clean, filtered water running through pipes into every home, I dream that every family will have access to sewers, a shower in every home, and a flushing toilet. I dream that the hating will stop and the wars will stop. I hope that the rich in the world would learn to share with the poor. I dream that people respect others no matter what religion they believe or even those who do not believe in God, but they believe in themselves, they believe in love, and they believe in their fellow man.
You mentioned the rich sharing with the poor and you are absolutely right. I used to be homeless and almost never would a rich person give me anything but a poor person could empathize and give me a dollar or a bit of food. They had very little but they cared.
Very well said Sir 👏
The only way to get free everything is to take it from someone else. This is what Wars are all about.
@@paulvarn4712 That's the way many become rich.
Note that the movie and the speech was made *before* America got involved in World War 2, while Hitler was in power, and the world unaware of the atrocities that were taking place.
Chaplin did say he was in the dark on the extent of Hitler's 'solution'. Pogroms and lynchings, sure, and colonization, the Trans Atlantic slave trade and the US Indian Wars were pretty large scale. But I'm willing to bet no one outside der Fuerer's circle could imagine this moral failing fully industrialized.
One of the best and most powerful speeches ever made in my opinion
What a speech! 👏
Even more, the humble reactions from all. 💕
I thank you for taking the time to introduce Mr. Chaplin to the tribal villagers here. Charlie's speech from The Great Dictator continues to be one of my favorites to this day, and sadly mankind has not learned from his message. I recommend sharing an interview excerpt from Akmed Lorence.
I really love this channel. You guys select really great content for deep discussion and reflection of humanity. I am a big fan of all the wonderful, kind hearted, intelligent people you feature on this channel. And I look forward to every new video. Much love from Farmington, NY, USA. If you take requests, I would love to see their reactions to ecowarriors and enviro-educators such as Jane Goodall or David Attenborough
Thank you Erin for such praise, appreciation, love and support. I would definitely be checking out your recommendation and share those with friends as well. Stay happy, safe and blessed.
You Tribal People are awesome guys. I watched many of your videos already and will watch many more.
I love the way how humble you all are and how interested you are exploring the things, that "TRIBALS" gives you to react to.
We are all brothers and sisters, no matter where we were born, life or what language we speak.
Would like to visit your country one day, but this will stay just a wish.
Good luck for the future, stay healthy all and dont forget to bring more of your very nice reaction videos.
Greetings with love from Germany!
Better beer face
I enjoy these videos immensely and I appreciate the way they are so well done. I feel a connection listening to them speak. That being said, I would love to spend a day just listening to Mr. Abdul Aziz Rind talk about his life.
"You'll find them in different worlds despite being in the same room"
Such an accurate description of society today. Until he said this I had forgotten how normal this has become.
Great job, Sir, you are a very wise person and a great humanitarian. Your empathy and devotion to helping and uniting the world never fails to impress. God bless you for all of your hard work 💚
Amazing speech.
Great reaction.
Especially from the older gentleman. He said in a previous video to have experience with firearms as a younger man. Now if that was training or even actual combat, there would have been an enemy, for which he was warned and somewhat brainwashed about (people dont just kill other people, even in war you need training to kill).
Anf for him to react positively to such a peaceful, loving and (lets be honest) socialistic view (or is it humanist?) Is amazing.
Abdul never has participated in any kind of war or tribal conflicts. He knows to operate weapons to defend himself and his family. We sit there, just two of us in that room and I feel very safe. Like I am with my grandpa. He is so kind, wise and loving ❤️
@@TRYBALS That is good to know. No trauma from combat.
I assumed he would be trained by the militairy.
I'm glad those things didnt happen (combat training or actual combat).
Send him (and all of the reactors and crew) my love.
@@CriticalCoen not really, his people know about weapons even when the British ruled. This has passed and still does among generations. You can search their history. Abdul is from the Rind tribe of Balochistan.
@@TRYBALS I just did (briefly) and that is an old tribe. Im impressed.
At least 15th century.
I loved these men's thoughts and reactions to Chaplin's great speech, they were very honest and deep.
I absolutely loved when one of them said "I won't even kill a mosquito from now on, we kill them because we're afraid they might bite but I won't kill it even if it bites".
That's one of the most beautiful things I've ever heard.
Peace everyone.
I love it how all these guys are different. You have the kind father, the cheeky brother, the cool uncle, the cute ladies and the wise old man. They really make the show.
The character giving the speech is the lookalike barber, not Hynkel/Hitler.
Yes, I just thought of sharing this with them because they might confuse Charlie with Hitler in future.
@@TRYBALS by listening to the premise and then watching the video they have the idea that the dictator is having a moment redeeming himself. That's not what happens, regardless of what you think about these men's ability to tell a person from another.
Chaplin was a genius even back then. He knew how dangerous hitler was and he used film to warn others but also to mock hitler and take his power from him. Too bad it was only metaphorical.💔. This time was a warning of something far worse by this monster.
a big milestone for this channel... greetings from Madeira 😃
Thanks! 😃
It'd be interesting to see them react to Sumo wrestling. Most cultures have their own form of wrestling and I feel like Sumo is one of the most bizarre and entertaining for people who doesn't wrestle themselves. Seeing their reaction to and maybe compare it to their own cultural wrestling would be interesting.
That was absolutely beautiful. All of them have such insightful things to say, it's really amazing to hear. Thank you all so much for what you do on this channel, it's really appreciated by us all and I'm excited to continue supporting you!
This was enjoyable on so many levels. And I had never seen ‘Charlie’ in this before so I found this entertaining and educational! Thank you for another great vid!!
This speech is truly epic. Such a contrast to his Little Tramp character.
Especially the earliest versions from the 'teens, which were more random, lowbrow Johnny Knoxville type stuff. But even Johnny had to evolve into a Borat knockoff like BAd Grampa.
I love these videos because everyone featured provide such incredible insight and perspective. We often find ourselves in such a narrow perspective based on our own beliefs, history, and situations that I find your videos not just challenging the participants but your viewers here on TH-cam. Keep up the good work!
Thank you again for another great post. It's the first time I have seen this with Charlie. If only the world listened back then. Loved everyone's reactions. Thanks for all your hard work.Love you all.❤️
This speech is great and gives me goose bumps. He was always political though even in his humor. USA even banned one of his films for its politics. You all should watch one of his silent films. They are short enough for here. 💝💝💝
I just found your channel a few days ago, and I love it! I love seeing the reactions, but also the wisdom you all share. Thank you for bringing joy through your channel. Well wishes to all the Trybals family!
I just revisited this a few days ago. By far one of the greatest monologues ever.
These guys really take every video and every thing they try on this channel, to heart, they think about it deeply, they consider it's meaning and it's value and take a genuine approach to it and I love that about them. So many people I know, since we live in America, are so consumed with consuming the next video or piece of media, they don't take a moment to slow down and consider it a moment. I think we can learn that from them and I value their input very much.
Kudos to your channel! Love watching and hearing from real people... No scripts, just genuine thoughts.
Such great words from your panel as well as from Charlie.
Aww, I just love me some Muharram and his beautiful smile. 🥰♥️🤗 And thank you, Adnan, for the video. I've never heard this speech before. Now I want to watch it for myself. His words were POWERFUL!!!
I knew I felt a kinship with that man. People should make their own governments. He has the soul of an anarchist. Anger at unjust hierarchies, he sees the world clearly and sees how we could live. Free in brotherhood with our fellow man.
I've only just stumbled across your channel and have the pleasure of already witnessing your guests reactions and words of wisdom to a few music videos. This Charlin Chaplin speech does not get the credit it deserves in western culture. Every sentence hits home the world could be an abundance of humanity an prosperity. This speech from a "movie" was written 80 years ago, representing governments of the 1920's. Yet here we are in 2022, on other sides of the world. And we all agree the same words used way back then, resonate so strongly an relate to us all today. The last video i saw was of "We are the world" which literally brought a smile to my face from your participants reactions. So thank you for that. I'm sad to say its tragic that the same "men who despise us" are the same men in governments all around the world today. sorry for a bit of a ramble, much respect in the great work you are doing. Ruzty from Australia
Watching these videos I have grown to love these people; their goodness is radiant. This helps give me hope for the future of humanity.
I didnt know of this speech. ty so so much
This channel, and these wonderful participants, bring joy, wisdom, and peacefulness to my mind; viewing here is like taking a draught of fresh, cool water on a hot day. Thank you, ALL.
I love hearing everyone’s thoughts on these videos. I would love to sit and have tea with everyone. :-)
This was an incredible idea, that speech never gets old. You have to show them some history videos, they are gonna love them.
Great video and great reactions! Keep up the great work! ❤️
I’m just a guy from America but I really appreciate you all! Have a blessed day!
this inspired me a lot from. the bottom of my heart thank u for the video.
That speech really is meant for everyone and it's wonderful to see that even after translation it is impactful
I am so soothed by their voices..🇨🇦
I discovered Charlie Chaplin about three years ago. I loved his humor. He could make me laugh with no words. Then when he speaks in a film for the first time, they are legendary. I can not stop watching these videos. The men who react are so spiritual, wonderful and wise.
I'm the surviving spouse of a veteran buried in Arlington. He served there in the public affairs office before his death and I had the opportunity to see the tomb guards in action while we were stationed in the DC area. I was touched by the reactions. I wish they had chosen a different video that really highlighted the precision of The Old Guard and how seriously they take their jobs. I appreciate that everyone was shown a background documentary first to put the tomb guard into perspective. I will always remember the man who said that we should we waging war against hunger and social inequality. What honor and morality. Thank you for the compassion you show in all of these videos. They make my world bigger.
Bless all of you. Your content is brilliant and inspiring. All of you are so thoughtful and beautiful. I wish I could know you.
Thank you for the love and care you take in each video
Now, you need to introduce them to Carl Sagans"Pale Blue Dot"
Oh yeah, that'd be a great one for the group. Seconded.
At least the part about 'this is us'.
Truly my favorite speech; the best that I have ever heard. We would all do well by listening closely.
Your videos prove that while we may live in different worlds respectively, there are basic innate human qualities that bond us all together. You are doing Gods work. Bless you all.
I have spent all day watching the videos on this channel, i started out of curiosity.
Is it just my opinion, but this "tribal" people are some of the most SANE Human beings i have ever seen.
Spporry for my bad English, i am from Argentina.
I nearly cry every time I see that speech. The conviction in his words while alsp desperate. A plea to people to end hatred and violence and love one another.
My husband loves theatre and was influenced so much by this speech that he has a painting a friend had made him of chaplin. It sits on our fireplace. Anytime Im thinking of the worlds troubles I look at it and try to keep his words to heart.
Great idea.
This is indeed one of the greatest speeches ever made, and one of my favorite ones at that. So happy to see it here.
I wouldn't be surprised if some of my American peers didn't know who Charlie Chaplin is.
I'd be even less surprised if those same people thought he was actually a certain Austrian Painter.
This is my favorite reaction channel! I always look forward to these videos you put out. I love learning from them as much as they love learning about world culture. You have made a very fascinating channel about human connection! Bravo! ✌️👏👏👏❤️
Thanks for such kind words brother
@@TRYBALS thank you ❤️ i’m a sister though 😂
@@jhoang861 oh, sorry sister 🙏🌷
@@TRYBALS no worries 😉 Keep up the good work ✌️
I want to meet each of these men and hug their necks and share stories with them and learn from them and befriend them. They all have amazing energy and kind hearts. The one with the long white beard has such a grand fatherly vibe to him. I bet we could all learn so much by listening to the stories of these men. Bless them.
Every time I hear that speech, I tear up and get goosebumps. Its so true & so needed especially today. I'm not sure many of our leaders feel the same. I like how one man says he won't kill mosquitoes anymore. I also don't like to kill anything any more. I have my daughter move spiders for me because I'm afraid of them. I'd probably still swat at some bugs but I try.
I have a long time love of old silent films, and there's something interesting in common with these trybals videos. Silent films are silent, so you need to pay close attention to the visuals and the word cards to keep up with what is going on. The same goes for these videos, as I don't speak urdu, I only understand English. So I think I tend to listen and watch more carefully to these videos than most other channels I watch regularly because I have to, to understand what's going on. But it also gives me a deeper appreciation for the experience as a whole. In a way, I think I've gotten to know and understand these people better than almost any other TH-cam channel, because there's no entertainment facade, it's just them explaining their thoughts and feelings and opinions from an authentic place and for that I really appreciate these videos. It makes me have to focus on it without distractions and I more closely listen to what they have to say. I think we could all stand to do that more in this age of noise. 👍
As a young child, I grew up with the same movies that my parents did, in the village hall “sixpenny pictures”. I had never seen TV and didn’t really know what it was, so the “pictures” were a treat on a Saturday morning. I vividly remember the magic of the Charlie Chaplin and the Laurel & Hardy films, which had us kids roaring and amazed - in the mid to late 1960s. I did not remember this speech, being too young to understand it at the time, but that extraordinarily beautiful and sinister dance with the globe in the same film, we perfectly understood without words.
Absolutely beautiful! Chaplin’s speech is so powerful even today. Thank you, thank you for this video. Sending love from the USA!
These people are wonderful.👍🏼 Thank you for showing them to us all. It's a lesson for me as much as it is for them. It's so interesting knowing how other people view the West, and I still cant believe how nice they all are. That in itself is a huge lesson for me.🙏🏼
And so long as men die, liberty will never perish....eta, thanks for sharing. I also had never seen or heard this speech and knew about the same of Charlie Chaplin 💖 keep up the good work
What fascinates me most about this speech is Chaplin didn't like that sound was coming in, as he believed it took more creativity and artistry to portray something without having to explain it. So when it came time for him to do a "talkie", he wanted to use the Tramp character who never spoke to say something meaningful.
I very much enjoyed watching this. I would love to see them react to one of Charlie Chaplin's silent films. They were revolutionary in that he was always making corrupt authority figures the butt of his jokes and those without power were the victors. Without sound, language wasn't a barrier to his comedy.
Bob Ross was my favorites and I still love them but this is now my #1 absolute favorite ♥️ That speech is the great speech of all time and a beautiful message for every man and woman today. Thank you 🙏
Amazing this is one of the first videos where I felt the tribesmen may know who the person was.. and some knew of Charlie Chaplin.. He was a worldwide phenomenon dating back to the silent age of cinema. very cool to see it still translates.
This speech will last & be relevant to men for all time… I saved this speech in my favourites years ago and still go back to watch & listen
This is so deep! I love these people!
The gentleman with white beard has amazing voice. Cuts straight through you.
I would love to see them react to the speeches of Russian Orthodox Priest Alexander Men, he was a truly one of the most loving and wholesome priests in all of Russia and he called out for equality and to love each other rather than hate.
Amazing video 👏👏🥰🙏
God bless to you gentlemen. God bless to us all. And merry Christmas 🎄🎁
Happy holidays!
this video was so good!
Honestly this speech can apply so easily to today here in the US.
Men just like these gave kingly gifts to a homeless couple for their newborn son as they rested in a barn. Indeed, we think too much and feel too little. Kindness is the key. Kindness...and caution. For not all are deserving of mercy and empathy, there is no way to know who is or is not deserving. Be kind, be dignified, but be wary of evil. Compassion, not complacency.
good and honorable people. always a pleasure to hear what they have to say.