I am from NE States...we are already dealing with a huge problem of illegal Bangladeshi migrants which itself is creating a danger of the demographic balance and besides that Assam Accord is yet to be implemented and we can not manage to let our scarce resources to be wasted on the Rohingyas
Yes they should never be allowed...they ll ruin NE beauty... Also how these bangladeshi are able to cross the border...and why dnt u complain about them to police or gov of border control...
NE situation are also suffering from Bangladeshi migrants Nd they are belongs to hindu and Muslim... So solution is Yea tho unlogoko civilization ka training dedo Yea bagaow.. Nd all the time hamare police alerts rehe.. Or sota se sota crime Na ho un areas pe
56 मुस्लिम कंट्रीज है जो रोहिंग्या को शरण दे सकती है यह रोहिंग्या आईएसआई के साथ मिले हुए हैं और आने वाले समय में भारत की सिक्योरिटी के लिए बहुत बड़ी समस्या बन सकते हैं
Sir I am a soldier and according to me rohingya should not be sheltered in India due to security reason, population, employment..... In future the action 'to shelter ; may be headache for our nation.
@@shakilanowersamrat the main problem is your religion against non-Muslims whom you call kaafirs...Jaha bhi kaafir dikhe katal kr do unko...jannat milegi
बांग्लादेश मुस्लिम देश होने के बाद भी रोहिंग्या के लिए कोई नरम रुख नही अपना रहा और 57 मुस्लिम देश है जिसमे सऊदी अरब, ईरान, तुर्की,कतर, uae जैसे बहुत ही आर्थिक रूप से मजबूत देश हैं जिनको अपना घर खोल देना चाहिए रोहिंग्या के लिए
abhi yadav ji,Indian r facing hundreds problems like unemployment, population ecution,etc...therefore no space in India.ndd vhy muslim countries helping them.vhn rohingye r violent nature d called terrorist... Myanmar.. bjp ll permit,due to cunning of intl funds..
@@HSIslamicStory to bhai pakistan eh ko kiu nahi leta , ase to indian muslim ka marisia banke ghumta rehta hai ?? Abi myanman se leke rakta kiu nahi ..
@@HSIslamicStory Haan to terrorist ho hi tum log😜😂🤣isme kahne wali koi baat nai h france m maar diya na apna terrorist waala slogan lagake 1 teacher ko Ola hu uber hahaha Buddham sharnam Gachaami Hum buddhisto se panga b mat lena
Sir my point is India already having large polpulation and facing so many problems internally then if such peoples came illegally in india then it was also threatens india security.
Nothing gonna work if u completely follow only kind of thoughts... Humanity is good until it will not going to harm oneself.. You already have a good example of bangal... Its already burning due to same kind of problems. So it's good approach by government i appreciate it
It is not a matter of any religion. In India Every 6 person lives here but we have only 2.4% land. We are already facing some trouble in population and job related. And also one concern is related to security. And the Indian people will not become a minority group.We always support refugees. India will find solution for their concerns.
I'm not against rohingyas but i will not support the idea of giving them shelters keeping POPULATION EXPLOSIONS, EMPLOYMENTS, and MILITANCY (could arise) in mind
india has done a lot for refugees in past but today situation is different we are facing population blast so can't handle 40,000 rohingyas who are so naive that they can be used against us by anti-national elements.... we should be helping then by asking Myanmar to give the a small state to live in peace instead of spoiling our own country's peace and worsen situation.
Why UN is pressurising india for giving shelter to rohingyas, instead of it UN should talk to maynmar for taking back rohingyas... India already facing various internal problems and by giving shelter to rohingyas we will invite one more problem. And this can be a majore security, economical and political threat to india. Or agar hum aise hi refugees ko shelter dete rhe to ek din indians ko kisi or desh se shelter mangna pad jayega.. SO SAY NO TO ROHINGYAS
रोहिंग्या मुसलमानों को बांग्लादेश में शरण लेनी चाहिये क्योंकि बांग्लादेश में सुन्नी समुदाय के साथ वे आराम से रह सकते हैं और अपने विचारों ,अधिकारों को अपने मुसलमान भाइयों से मांग सकते हैं
Aditya Verma fully ready bas tu govt se approval dilwa de ,,or ye bat tu cow pr bhi applicable kr yo ki jo log cow ko mata mante hen wo apne ghar pr rkhein
हँसी तो इस बात की आ रही है। इंसानियत की बात आज वो लोग कर रहे है जिनके घर मे बचो के सामने बकरो को हलाल कर दिया जाता है। जिन्हें वो छोटे बच्चे अपने हाथों से खिलाते पिलाते है।
Aditya Verma bhai plants hav also life and according to science they also can feel pain,agr wo bol nhi pate that's not mean ki tu unhe kat kr khaa,,or saans lena bhi band kr de bhai pta nhi kitne germs ki jaan leta hai tu
Aditya Verma dear me bhi apne desh ki security ke sath compromise Karne ko nhi bol rha hu... But as human Ap Jara socho un rohigyaz ki family me chhote chhote bachhe honge, ladkiya ungi ,lady's hongi... ager hum unko waps Myanmar bhej denge to unke sath waha ki Sarkar Aur army Ya dusre galat Niyat rakhe wale log unki majburi ka galat fayda uthayege.
India already has 172 million Muslim overstayers from the Partition of 1947, all the Muslims / Islam were allocated land in east and west Pakistan, all the Muslims / Islam should vacate the Varaha Bhagwan country, toba - toba it is Haram for Muslims what do you think? . All the Muslims should check out their DNA and follow the Ancestors Faith of Humanity, Omnipresent Eternal Faith of Sanatan Dharma, . Rohingiyer, Italian and Muslims should be banned from India. SHIVOHAM. RUDRA SPEAKING.
All the muslim who wanted to leave and live in new Islamic country have already gone..We chose to live in India n we Are peacefully living here. Dont Forget India is neither a islamic country nor a Sanatan Dharam country. Any Attempt made to make turn it into a Hindu counrty will only cause Ditrust n tension among thr people. So I kindly request you to plz take out this anti Islamic prejudice n lets work together to make our country a peaceful n loving country
Ashish Kumar sir mene to rohingya ko rukne ki baat ki hi nhi...m sirf itna batana chahta hu ki Islam k baare m jo bhi preconditioning ki jaati hmari society m wo galat h...muslim can be imperfect but Islam isn't.
Islam ke hisab se ap jise bhagwan mante ho wo uske alawa sab bekar hai... ham hindu log apne alawa sab ke bhagwan ya dharam ka ejjat saman rup se karte hain apke eslam esi tarah ki kayi sari kamiya hain...esiliye ye na kahiye
@@yawarali5327 Indians are Indians then let it be a Hindu or a Muslim. But Rohingyas are Mayanmar Citizens they should be send back to their country. Pehele se hamari population jada hai usme inhe kaha jagah de.
dharamshala me dharamshala hi to kholi thi tibetians k liye nehru ji ne..aaj tk wo yhi hain himachal me..ab in rohingyas ko ni rkhna chahiye..aise hi itni problems hain aur bdhengi..
kumar saket tum sahi keha rahe ho bhai Kashmiri pundit apnehi deshmese Bhagao our ye tararist rohingyas ko apne desh me lao our apnehi desh ke tukde karo jagoo hinduo jago
According to your speech few thousand people migrated and now they are 1 million (population vise). Now what will happen if 1 Lakh people settled in India after 5decades. Again rape to local citizens. Can you give full grantee that this types of incident will not occurred in Future. Every country has a resources for its own citizens not for foreign citizens. There are 56 Muslim countries throughout the globe and some of them are very rich too. They can provide work and shelter to them. They hired peoples from different corners of the world.
Why UN is forcing us....India can take their decision on their own.....I think UN should talk Myanmar and give Rohingya their own state and that state should convert into country so that peace will remain in all over the world.... though Rohingya innocent people are also not guilty that's all because of terrorism in this world
hi soni but thats wrong to give country to Rohingya's cos what will happened if outside people come to your country and then after many years they want their won land cos they were living in your country for many years.
India main almost kafi log hai bangladeshi nepali and many other or upper se hamari population bhi kafi hai par resources bhi itne hai nahi tho mera mana hai India ko rohingya ko sarad nahi deni chaiye
Prashant sir you are excellent.And i think no one can take your place..Sir I can't explain in words that how much i love you...i attend your every classes on important issues...and finally i thank you sir🙏🙏🙏
आप हमेशा कहते है की मै सिर्फ कानूनी फैक्ट्स पर स्टडी पर्पज से मुद्दे पर वीडियो बनाता हूं तो फिर यहां पर बुद्ध की बात को सामने रख कर और अपने उल्टे सीधे तर्क देकर अपनी सोच को दूसरों पर क्यों थोपना चाहते हो। और आखिर में ये फैसला सुनाने की कोशिश क्यों कर रहे हो की रोहिंग्या को हमें शरण देनी चाहिए। अपने घर में आग लगा के दूसरों की दीवाली मनवाना कहा की इंसानियत है।
As the prime minister, it is Modi's moral and primary responsibility to ensure the well-being and safety of Indian citizens who have voted him to power. Any other considerations must follow after.
I am not rohingya I am an Indian citizen by birth or by choice also I am support all people who are victims of genocide irrespective of their religion , caste , race ,gender
Muslims ke liye 56 country hai to kya Woh tere baap ki jai.kya aur India be Muslim ke be country hai India is a secular country India ko British se Azad I dilane muslim Ka sabse bada role tha hamare he ulma ne reshmi rumal ki tehreek chaliye the remember it
Right of the soil" commonly referred to as birthright citizenship, is the right of anyone born in the territory of a state to nationality or citizenship. World must fight for right of every child born on soil of any country. Every child must have its citizenship. So each and every Rohingya currently living in Myanmar are born there and world must help them to get their right to live where they are born. To live like refugee is not anyone's fate.We all are children of god living on his land.God give us birth where he want one to live and no one on earth must have right to move.
before seeing this video ..i only say no refugees after seeing i also said no.. yes we are Selfish...but we couldn't sacrifice our lives...for provide refugees.. ajj wo ake rahenge baad mein bolenge ye kisi baap ka hindustan hai hum sab ka khoon mila hua hai.. last agar india mein muslim jyada ho gye aur wo hinduyon ke upar attack karde to app hi bolo ki humara aur kaun si hinduish state hai kya.india ka partition hua religion ke adhhar per per hum hindu rastra hoke bhi muslim reh te hen kyun...Pakistan kyun bana batao...sab ko secularism ka bhoot chada hai..koi apne desh ki Kashmir pandito ko nhi bachapaya aur rohingya ko saran dene chale...future socho bhai apko pata hai muslim secular nhi hote..agar kisi ko kuch bolna hai to bolo... hinduyon ke uper jab Kashmir mein atyachar hua tab kaunsi un thha..khoon khol uthti hai... jago hindu jago...ye desh to hoga per gazwa e hind ke tahad koi hindu nhi hota...
hmm agar mein terrorist hota aur hindu hota tab kasam mera desh ki koi bhi hume accept nhi karta..app ko agar lagta hai ki muslim innocent hote hen then plz go to a muslim country..then you realize what is freedom.what is fear..who are muslim...what they do with hindu..1947 mein Pakistan mein bhi hindu thhe per unko mardiya gya..
vikas kumar agar aap ek aise desh k pradhan mantri hote jaha ki jansankhya dedh arab k kareeb hai,40 per cent SE zyada log garibi rekha k neeche aate hain,har ek acchi position k liye already 2 SE 3 hazaar log compete kar rahe hai,jo desh sabse yuva toh hai par jaha ka yuva berozgaari se joojh raha hai toh kya aap ki bhi yahi soch hoti
"there are number of things to identify bad rohingya rather than said go back" sirji mujjo apka ye video bahut achaa laga bahut kuch sikhane ko milta hain aise quote padh ke thanks my suggestion is that "kuch rasta nikalna chahiye"
भारत क्या कोई धर्मशाला हैं जो जब चाहे यहाँ शरण ले ले,एक तो पहले से ही बांग्लादेशी घुसे हुए हैं और अब ये!इतने मुस्लिम देश हैं वहाँ जाओ!हमारे देश में कोई जगह नहीं हैं।
Why Indian government supports Pakistani Hindus to come in our country and get the citizenship? If India is thinking to give citizenship to a Pakistani (which is a terrorist country according to India) hindu then why not for Myanmar Muslims?🤔🤔
Kyoki pakisatan me forcefully conversion ho raha hai hindus ka. They are not safe there. Maar rahe hai unko roz. Pakistan is Muslim majority country, waha hindus survive nahi kar sakte. Kya tumhe itna b nahi pata?
Musalman to kahi b ja sakta hai. There 51 Muslim countries in the world, which are not secular by constitution. But Hindu kewal india me hi rah sakta hai, not in any muslim countries.
krishan kumar tera india hai jo comment kar raha jata maat bol .rss jesai insanyat dusmaan ko vote dai jo hamaisa jakarnai ki bath karta hai jo india law par nahe chalta apnai banài howai law per chalta hai ya modi ko vote dai jo 2002 ka master mind the ya congress ko dai jo har chej ka daam increse karai jo v bahar country sai india mai mojood hai wo kise dharam sai taluk rak tai hai sab ko india sai bahar nekalo bus tab barma muslim ho ya pakistani Hindus to
R Khan haan nhi deni chahiye bhai. Or india hi kyo? Pakistan bhi nhi de rha shelter. Or hume kisi ko dikhane ki zarurat nhi h ki humara dil kitna bada hai wo india dikha chuka hai. Sala ek to mughal aaye phr yha k logo ko loota maara ,bhuto to convert kiya phr kahne lge ki alg desh de to Wo b chlo de hi diya india or bana pakistan. Ab sala inko jagha do phr job bhi do Last year mai delhi me tha afgani basti h waha ek, meri govt unko free house de rhi hai Or sala mai thode door ghar liya to 12000 rent dena pada. Unke pas job hai ,dukane hai Or mai sala abhi b unemployed. Jitna dil dikhana tha dikha diye Kal ko ye bhi khenge ki alg desh do Jese kasmir k log khte h Ese to tukde ho jayenge india k
similar case is in our state Arunachal pradesh, which is chakmas and hajongs issue. The indigenous people fears the same issue of crisis but what makes difference is the supreme court consent to grant citizenship to chakmas in Arunachal.
vikas kumar 1st- bhai aye kese bol sakte ho ke meine socha nehi? mein khud Ko unke jagah par rakh kar hi mera soch bataya. 2nd- I don't want any BOom blast. 3rd- I don't want to sacrifice any soldiers Life. Bhai ghar Bethe phesla Suna na toh bahatihi easy hai.
Deepak Mohanty - Aaj se 50-100 saal baad mere saath bhavishya men kya hoga, yah sonch kar sambhrant, sampann, bahusankhyak varg visthapit, garib, kamjor, alpsankhyak varg ke vartman ka vinash kar de, jisme bahut sare bachche, budhe aur aurat bhi shamil hai, kya yah uchit hoga ... ? Visthapan kai prakar ka hota hai vikas ke nam par, suraksha ke nam par, dharm ke naam par. Visthapit, garib, kamjor, alpsankhyak chahe ye tabka kisi bhi dharm se sambandhit hon, ye hamesha pratarit tha, hai aur rahega, kyoki sampann varg ke vikas men, unki suraksha men enhe hamesha khatra mana gaya hai.
Kaliprasanna Pattnaik - Aaj se 50-100 saal baad mere saath bhavishya men kya hoga, yah sonch kar sambhrant, sampann, bahusankhyak varg visthapit, garib, kamjor, alpsankhyak varg ke vartman ka vinash kar de, jisme bahut sare bachche, budhe aur aurat bhi shamil hai, kya yah uchit hoga ... ? Visthapan kai prakar ka hota hai vikas ke nam par, suraksha ke nam par, dharm ke naam par. Visthapit, garib, kamjor, alpsankhyak chahe ye tabka kisi bhi dharm se sambandhit hon, ye hamesha pratarit tha, hai aur rahega, kyoki sampann varg ke vikas men, unki suraksha men enhe hamesha khatra mana gaya hai.
I think the UN should talk to the Myanmar govt.to declare a small place for their state ... n all the country should help rohingyas for their development... n so that Rohingyas have their own state ... n Rohingyas can be deport from India n form other countries for their safety .....
very good sir........Myanmar should....give.them separate state......every country should....provide separate state if,they don't want his own minority in his country.
haris siddiqui already India had given two seperate Countries ... and now also ... some people want another seperate STATE !!!! RIDICULOUS .. bas isiliye koi Rohingya ko lena nhi chahta coz after that they will demand for a seperate state. Bhai kuchh daya to Muslim countries ko b dikhane do..
VIKASH kAUSHIK I am not telling non Islam country to donate a separate state... but Myanmar to give a place because Rohingyas were living there for the last 200 years ....
Helping others is crucial in the present scenario but the main issue is, to which extent . My personal believe is that, although the issue raises a moral question to the Indians about whether we want to support a community in distress or not. It's scope is much bigger than that , northeastern region is already in turmoil due to the insurgents from myanmar, border disputes with china and nepal, adding a huge sum of muslim foreigners to the equation could worsen the situation even further. First step in my opinion should be to keep this immigration to a minimum by tightening our border security to advance standards. We can't let the INDO-BANGLADESH borders be so porous any further . Many nations have met their downfall because of heavy immigration , the central asia is great example of that . Second step should be identifying all the current Rohingya muslims living in India. Even if we don't kick them out we must keep a track of who they are and what they are doing, this is crucial because if a few members of this community gets influenced by any terrorist organization and do something irrational , we will be compromising the internal security of our nation . It could also lead to a hate wave against that community in India , giving way to a mass hysteria similar to USA and Myanmar in India. We have ethnic muslims living peacefully in our country and we don't want the other communities misdirecting their anger to them which would make them feel alienated in their own country. Third and most important step is to look for places to send these people and getting the global community aware , not involved, but aware of the situation . We also need to help Myanmar realize that their is strength in diversity if utilized properly like we very brilliantly do. Stabilizing the situation with very peacefull and level headed demeanour is crucial here . We can't risk to tense our bonds with myanmar, one of our very crucial allies against china because of this. Only if myanmar is developing can we hope some peace for our north eastern brothers and sisters.
Rohingyas people r suffering with their problems ....We {India} can get it n have sympathy for them....But ,,, प्रकृति में सीमित संसाधन हैं और हमे उनकी कद्र करते हुए उनका समुचित उपयोग करना चाहिए और यह हमारी ही जिम्मेदारी बनती है कज हुम् अपनी आने वाली पीढ़ी के लिए इन संसाधनों को बचा कर रखे । 👍चूंकि रोहिंग्या मुस्लिम्स का रहन सहन, वेशभूषा, बोली, कल्चर इत्यादि म्यांमार की बुद्धिस्ट कम्युनिटी से पूर्णतः अलग है और यही कारण ह की म्यांमार इनको अपना नही रहा है । पर भारत , बांग्लादेश जैसे देश इनके लिए रिफ्यूजी कैम्प्स लगाकर इनकी सहायता करने पर उतारू है,,,, हमे यहाँ पर यह सोचना चाहिए कि आखिर कब तक हम इन शरणार्थियों को अपने देश के संसाधनों (जिन पर हमारे देशवासियो का हक ह) का उपयोग करने देंगे,,,,,यह हमारी आने वाली पीढ़ी के साथ अन्याय होगा क्योंकि रोहिंग्या मुस्लिम्स के हक के संसाधन म्यांमार के रखिन क्षेत्र में ह और उन्हें उनका ही उपयोग करना चाहिए । 👍👌solution-- इस समस्या का एक ही हल ह की भारत , बांग्लादेश और UN व अन्य देशों को आगे आकर इस कम्युनिटी के लोगो के लिए आवाज उठानी चिये और उनका हक उनको दिलाने के लिए उस क्षेत्र (Rakhin) को स्वतंत्र घोषित कर देना चाहिए फिर चाहे इसके लिए म्यांमार में आर्मी ही क्यों न भेजनी पड़े । इसके वाद उस क्षेत्र को कोई भी देश गोद ले सकता है और उसी क्षेत्र में उनका निवास स्थान बनाकर उनका पालन पोषण किया जा सकता ह और यही एकमात्र इसका समाधान है । 💐यही मानवता है,,,,, मानवता वो नही की आप एक इंसान की भूख मिटाने के लिए किसी दूसरे इंसान के हक का छीन लो ।💐💐 Pls....Think on it.... 💐💐Thank u very much sir💐💐
हम क्यों रखें रोहिंग्या आतंकियों को? पाकिस्तान तो बना ही धर्म के आधार पर है वो क्यों नही रख लेती अपने रोहिंग्या को। मैं बौद्ध लोगों को सुक्रिया कहना चाहूंगा, जिन्होंने इन आतंकवादियों के खिलाफ मोर्चा खोला। जय हिंद। #IstandWithMyanmar ✌🚩
We should oppose immigration of rohingiyas muslim 1)as we all know india is vastly populated country so giving refugee to extra 10 million people would be a serious concern for india 2)the first and foremost danger for india would probably be increase in pressure of various resources 3)we have already seen population crisis in North eastern states where numerous bangladeshi during 1971 war moved to assam west bengal and various states which has resulted in illegal use of government resources there population is getting increased exponentially 4)also if they are given refugee there would require lots of funds to build there house there also registrating there name as an indian citizens . 5)one of the most serious issue with giving them help and let them reside here is that they are completely different in every context from us whether it is language , believe , understanding they would completely be a stranger to us. 5)also the states would be under several clash that they make sure they don't allow any stranger to get into there home.(states) 6)india is not a highly prosperous nation to do favour to such a huge population . 7)india should focus in its economic growth and concentrate to its own people . 8)if rohingya gets settled into india than technically they would be a minority (so it's a proven that human feel uncomfortable in living in an area where there population is low and it could be sure that they could raise there population bluntly ) 9)as it is known that they are also in contact with hafeez saeeds organization ....so it would be a grave threat to settle our enemies into our home .. Plz do give feedback so that i can improve my answer writing skills coz this are my fewest answer which I have written in any video/post. Thank you
the least question is how this people managed to enter in india, does previous government allowed them to enter? or current government allowed them? if none of the govt allowed, than does our borders are these much freak that any1 can enter? and really article 14,21 and 51c applicable to non citizen.???
Constitution of India doesn't apply to the noncitizen of India.For reference, you can see the preamble of our Constitution, where it is mentioned:"we the people of India...".Hope this helps.
कौन हैं अशीन विराथु? दस साल पहले मांडले के इस बौद्ध भिक्षु के बारे में बहुत कम लोगों ने सुना था. 1968 में जन्मे अशीन विराथु ने 14 साल की उम्र में स्कूल छोड़ दिया और भिक्षु का जीवन अपना लिया.
Currently, India is not in very good condition in terms of economy as well as employment. Providing shelter to refugees will directly affects the current population of India. One should consider the consequences of allowing refugees as they will exploit our resources and in the near future they may get citizenship due to gain of certain political parties.. not only that, they may also enjoy the reservation system in our government organisations because of minority issues. The other point is that, if there are certain security issues then we cannot allow such Refugees... This situation can be compared to situation in which you saw a bunch of beggars on the road without shelter and they may die because of the Harsh conditions... You allow them to come to your home and you don't know weather this person will steal from your home or Kill somebody from home... You went outside for your daily earning. At that point even a single person can kill your entire family because you have no defence once he entered in your house.. On humanity ground you did the right thing but on the other hand the responsibility of your family is served or not?
Sir acc.to morality we should keep them and India is a country which is known for this but sir whenever we have did earlier these things India's relationship wd the concerned country became worse be it inda-pak indo-china india-Bangladesh India is still lagging behind in all the parameters since independence be it poverty, economic divide, unemployment, terrorism By giving shelter to rohingyas we r making it next to impossible . in 1947 thousands of refugees came to India and now we all know the census India should follow realpolitik being idealistic is unrealistic. be practical not emotional fool . instead India should ask Myanmar govt to give rohingyas their social status.
kanika tripathi question of morality is not the concern. These rohingya were involved in bodhgaya bomb blast. holy place of Buddhism. Now they are facing the music. Apart from this rohingya are illegal militants over here. Doesn't hold proper refuge paper. And our constitution never allow asylum for such militants.. we can't violate our law. If we observe our history then during mourya period foreigner alexander and selucus visited India to rule, then Mughals came with same motto. Followed by britishers..and presently Italian servants .so whenever any foreign s visit India they always try to rule ,why to take chance this time ?
India is very populated country and suffering from unemployment, lack of facilities. Everyday a new Australia is born in India. In this state, India can't give shelter to lakhs of refugees who come to India every year. Also as you said it is a threat to our security.
NO COMPROMISE ON NATIONAL SECURITY....OPP PARTIES WHO ARE SUPPORTING ROHINGYAS AND ALSO JOURNALISTS LIKE RAVISH KUMAR (NDTV) SHOULD ALSO BE DEPORTED ALONG WITH THE ROHINGYAS
Send them back to Bangladesh....cause what I understood is that they have went to Myanmar from Bangladesh...and also donate some money for thier food cloth and basic need...but my nation is much more important then any group of any caste creed religion or whatever among whom one or two can harm my brothers n sister here in India. India can keep the children's Up to 14 years old max.
Mr Prashant, your channel is famous for unbiased videos and information. Please do not try to softly put in biased videos. You haven’t covered in details the organised violence committed by this community. India has suffered massively due to attacks from all sides but still we have a warm heart. Don’t think giving shelter can solve the problem. Ground reality is far difficult to face then to show compassion. Sweden compassion Dikha raha hai aur duniya mein Sabse Tezi se rape crime increase Kahin hua hai toh Sweden mein hua hai. This compassion is good if the other person is also compassionate. There are 57 declared Muslim nations, let them give refuge to Rohingyas. Why every time we suffer in the name of humanity. Let the world also see our sufferings, our pain. Please don’t make biased videos.
I started watching this channel for having the correct information. And not asking for the opinions publically. also not for the UPSC preparation. I think you should not ask for public opinions on SOCIAL MEDIA as these topics are somewhere religiously sensible. Because the point is, Some people's feelings could hurt by someone writing random comments. & these may create unneccessary conflicts towards the other religions or even towards the country. As far as my opinion on the topic, I think there should be a balanced decision taken considering humanity as well as the nation's security. & another point is if in future other countries would start taking out people from there. How much can we absorb?
if govt . will give shelter to them , it would be dangerous for India in coming future . we already have high population , and moreover we learned many lessons from britishers , china , Pakistan etc . Though lessons of budhha teaches us humanity but sometimes we have to think practically not emotionally . Thank you
We shouldn't accept them by comprising our internal security at any cost. On the name of humanity we are risking our citizens' lives, resources and opportunities, we are also human and be rational bcz jab Buddhist, jo ki sab ka bhala chahne walo, ne unhe accept nhi kiya to koi or kaise unhe masoom samjh sakta hai. Ye apne pair pr kulhadi marne jaisa hai.
Not against of rohingyas , In ndia we have so many problems like many states are demanding separated like gorkhaland in West Bengal,kosal in Odisha,bodoland in Assam etc .. instead of giving citizens ship in India let's UN and other countries should discuss to Myanmar..or like Rakhaines can demand other countries..
Don't be emotional US saying right about Syria refugee we also have same think even less powerful than US so if US don't take any risk why should us. We don't have to get emotional and puth our internal security in risk
I am from NE States...we are already dealing with a huge problem of illegal Bangladeshi migrants which itself is creating a danger of the demographic balance and besides that Assam Accord is yet to be implemented and we can not manage to let our scarce resources to be wasted on the Rohingyas
DEBAJEET GOGOI good
Yes they should never be allowed...they ll ruin NE beauty...
Also how these bangladeshi are able to cross the border...and why dnt u complain about them to police or gov of border control...
DEBAJEET GOGOI , u r right. Brother
I agree with you
NE situation are also suffering from Bangladeshi migrants Nd they are belongs to hindu and Muslim... So solution is Yea tho unlogoko civilization ka training dedo Yea bagaow.. Nd all the time hamare police alerts rehe.. Or sota se sota crime Na ho un areas pe
दया उतनी अच्छी है जिससे खुद को हानि न हो ये दया मोत बनकर आएगी मोत ।
Only modi ji can tackle this issue.
56 मुस्लिम कंट्रीज है जो रोहिंग्या को शरण दे सकती है यह रोहिंग्या आईएसआई के साथ मिले हुए हैं और आने वाले समय में भारत की सिक्योरिटी के लिए बहुत बड़ी समस्या बन सकते हैं
It's true.
ये साले आतंकवादी हैं।
@@HSIslamicStory indian muslims are our brothers not rohingyas who are threat to india
@@HSIslamicStory kagaj dhundh le
@@HSIslamicStory jiahdi yo ko 72 hoor ke pass bhej denge
Sir I am a soldier and according to me rohingya should not be sheltered in India due to security reason, population, employment..... In future the action 'to shelter ; may be headache for our nation.
mukesh kumar jai hind sir
Sahi kaha sir aapane or aap bhi kashmir me in aatankvadi musalamano ko goli mar diya kare kuch jihadi log duniya se kam Hoge
@@Trickledown8_ Jai Hind bhai
@@Baycottkattmulle2088
Of course....
Agar sarkar aur kanun hame ijajat de
@@shakilanowersamrat the main problem is your religion against non-Muslims whom you call kaafirs...Jaha bhi kaafir dikhe katal kr do unko...jannat milegi
Humanity is good but Nation is first. So, India should not provide shelter to rohinghya's
😮😮
Including Chakma and Hajong and illegal Bangladeshi
@@Saif-gt9id nobody gives a fuck your humanity
@@Saif-gt9id tuje bhi bgha denge ab packing suru kr de
ROHINGYA MUST GO BACK.
HINDUSTAN KE LIYE SAMSYA HAI.
I Am Also Buddhist ....
But Nation Security First...
Say No To Rohingya
Jai Hind
Nikal lde pehli fursat me nikal
@@karimuddinshaikh9434 likhna Sikh le gavar
They all threat to national security
I agree with you,I am also a Buddhist .
Good reshma.
भाई अगर सभी लोग रोहिंग्या के वापस जाने के हक में हैं तो CAA का समर्थन में सड़कों पर आओ और CAA के विरोधियों कोड धूल चटाने के लिए।
Sahi kaha mene ishke support mein signature camp chala ush par sign kiya
I support NRC
I support CAA OR NRC, I support BJP goverment
Vote for BJP
We should never compromise with security
@@shakilanowersamrat
After partition of India in 1947,
How can you expect symapthy towards your fellow beings
रोहिंग्या को बसाकर नया पाकिस्तान नही बनाना हमे
We can't endanger our people & kids to do so. Moral is a thing but not at stake of terrorism.
बांग्लादेश मुस्लिम देश होने के बाद भी रोहिंग्या के लिए कोई नरम रुख नही अपना रहा और 57 मुस्लिम देश है जिसमे सऊदी अरब, ईरान, तुर्की,कतर, uae जैसे बहुत ही आर्थिक रूप से मजबूत देश हैं जिनको अपना घर खोल देना चाहिए रोहिंग्या के लिए
mai aapki ki bat se shmat hu....
lovelight lko sahi
Humanity is good but our first responsibility to our nation.....i m with my govt ....
Protection of own is not selfish ,its the smartness to be maintained safe and good life.....
No no no....we still facing population issue...
abhi yadav ji,Indian r facing hundreds problems like unemployment, population ecution,etc...therefore no space in India.ndd vhy muslim countries helping them.vhn rohingye r violent nature d called terrorist... Myanmar.. bjp ll permit,due to cunning of intl funds..
Ye log Saran mang rahe hai bad me ulag country mange ge so say no. Or usko vahase raph kiya tha is liye nikala hai
Hmm rape bhi kiya in logo ne ese logo ko nhi gusne dena chiye
Jai Swaminaraya 😁
Rohingya ko kanhi saran nehi dena chahiye, In logon ko Saudi Arab jana chahiye
Great bro
@@HSIslamicStory oi chutia hai kiya be hinduism pura hindustan me hai samjha
@@HSIslamicStory to bhai pakistan eh ko kiu nahi leta , ase to indian muslim ka marisia banke ghumta rehta hai ?? Abi myanman se leke rakta kiu nahi ..
@@HSIslamicStory Ye dekho terrorist aaya
@@HSIslamicStory Haan to terrorist ho hi tum log😜😂🤣isme kahne wali koi baat nai h france m maar diya na apna terrorist waala slogan lagake 1 teacher ko
Ola hu uber hahaha
Buddham sharnam Gachaami
Hum buddhisto se panga b mat lena
Sir my point is
India already having large polpulation and facing so many problems internally then if such peoples came illegally in india then it was also threatens india security.
Nothing gonna work if u completely follow only kind of thoughts... Humanity is good until it will not going to harm oneself.. You already have a good example of bangal... Its already burning due to same kind of problems.
So it's good approach by government i appreciate it
No shelter for rohingya
Pehle SC / ST samaj ko dil me jaghe do .. phir rohingya prem ka sochenge ..!!
Sahi bole
Mon ki baat bata diya bro
St sc ki dsa pakistan me jakar dekh le tab samaj aayega tu kitna surkshit hai
Br ambedkar ke savidhan ke wajah se wo log india me surkshit hai aisi savidhan ki kya jrurt jo videshiyo ko bahr nhi nikal sake bc
Dil me v reservation le lo
It is not a matter of any religion.
In India Every 6 person lives here but we have only 2.4% land. We are already facing some trouble in population and job related. And also one concern is related to security. And the Indian people will not become a minority group.We always support refugees. India will
find solution for their concerns.
Right
I'm not against rohingyas but i will not support the idea of giving them shelters keeping POPULATION EXPLOSIONS, EMPLOYMENTS, and MILITANCY (could arise) in mind
Agree
Luken Rava ...agree with u...
Luken Rava agree
I agree with you..
jennifar sara naxls ne bomb nhi phode ab tak india me...wo bas apni land par kabza kiye hue he
i am waiting for this complete video
grt explanation by awesome teacher
Jai HIND
india has done a lot for refugees in past but today situation is different we are facing population blast so can't handle 40,000 rohingyas who are so naive that they can be used against us by anti-national elements....
we should be helping then by asking Myanmar to give the a small state to live in peace instead of spoiling our own country's peace and worsen situation.
Ask UN bring those refugees to middle east saudi oil rich countries
And Pakistan accomodates 2million + afghan refugees. Still we are asked for more. This is filthy discourse
India is not a dumpyard of refugees
@@mariarehman9911 is liye Pakistan ma itna economic crises hai
Why UN is pressurising india for giving shelter to rohingyas, instead of it UN should talk to maynmar for taking back rohingyas...
India already facing various internal problems and by giving shelter to rohingyas we will invite one more problem.
And this can be a majore security, economical and political threat to india.
Or agar hum aise hi refugees ko shelter dete rhe to ek din indians ko kisi or desh se shelter mangna pad jayega..
SO SAY NO TO ROHINGYAS
रोहिंग्या मुसलमानों को बांग्लादेश में शरण लेनी चाहिये क्योंकि बांग्लादेश में सुन्नी समुदाय के साथ वे आराम से रह सकते हैं और अपने विचारों ,अधिकारों को अपने मुसलमान भाइयों से मांग सकते हैं
bangladesh ne bhi unko shelter dene se mana kaar diya hai..
we can not feed our own population and u want to feed others. if we can't feed our family, will we invite other to feed. think about it...
जो लोग अगर इन दिनों रोहंगिया को इंसानियत के नाम पे शरण देने की बात कर रहे है।उनसे एक बात कहुगा 40 हजार में से एक भी शरणार्थी को अपने घर मे जगह दे।
Aditya Verma fully ready bas tu govt se approval dilwa de ,,or ye bat tu cow pr bhi applicable kr yo ki jo log cow ko mata mante hen wo apne ghar pr rkhein
हँसी तो इस बात की आ रही है। इंसानियत की बात आज वो लोग कर रहे है जिनके घर मे बचो के सामने बकरो को हलाल कर दिया जाता है। जिन्हें वो छोटे बच्चे अपने हाथों से खिलाते पिलाते है।
Aditya Verma bhai plants hav also life and according to science they also can feel pain,agr wo bol nhi pate that's not mean ki tu unhe kat kr khaa,,or saans lena bhi band kr de bhai pta nhi kitne germs ki jaan leta hai tu
ali abassi but 1st in population in the world in few years
Aditya Verma dear me bhi apne desh ki security ke sath compromise Karne ko nhi bol rha hu... But as human Ap Jara socho un rohigyaz ki family me chhote chhote bachhe honge, ladkiya ungi ,lady's hongi... ager hum unko waps Myanmar bhej denge to unke sath waha ki Sarkar Aur army Ya dusre galat Niyat rakhe wale log unki majburi ka galat fayda uthayege.
Thank You StudyIQ for making such informative videos ..I am not UPSC aspirant but I like watching your videos ..Kudos to Study IQ team !
National Security first, that's it.
Prashant sir one of the best teacher . His way of explaining is very captivating
Nation first
Internal security first
Nikalo bhar enko
Jai shree Ram
India already has 172 million Muslim overstayers from the Partition of 1947, all the Muslims / Islam were allocated land in east and west Pakistan, all the Muslims / Islam should vacate the Varaha Bhagwan country, toba - toba it is Haram for Muslims what do you think? . All the Muslims should check out their DNA and follow the Ancestors Faith of Humanity, Omnipresent Eternal Faith of Sanatan Dharma, . Rohingiyer, Italian and Muslims should be banned from India. SHIVOHAM. RUDRA SPEAKING.
All the muslim who wanted to leave and live in new Islamic country have already gone..We chose to live in India n we Are peacefully living here. Dont Forget India is neither a islamic country nor a Sanatan Dharam country. Any Attempt made to make turn it into a Hindu counrty will only cause Ditrust n tension among thr people. So I kindly request you to plz take out this anti Islamic prejudice n lets work together to make our country a peaceful n loving country
Ashish Kumar sir mene to rohingya ko rukne ki baat ki hi nhi...m sirf itna batana chahta hu ki Islam k baare m jo bhi preconditioning ki jaati hmari society m wo galat h...muslim can be imperfect but Islam isn't.
Islam ke hisab se ap jise bhagwan mante ho wo uske alawa sab bekar hai... ham hindu log apne alawa sab ke bhagwan ya dharam ka ejjat saman rup se karte hain apke eslam esi tarah ki kayi sari kamiya hain...esiliye ye na kahiye
@@yawarali5327 Indians are Indians then let it be a Hindu or a Muslim. But Rohingyas are Mayanmar Citizens they should be send back to their country.
Pehele se hamari population jada hai usme inhe kaha jagah de.
Our country already facing population issues. So rohingya's cant be allowed
@@shakilanowersamrat no i dont hate muslims. I am just trying to say that we must have cautious about overpopulation of our country.
NO ROHINGYAS.....😠😠😠🏃🏃🏃✋✋✋
Ye Mera Desh hai....👍👍👍🙏🙏🙏
National security is first then Huminity.
We should pressure world wise to Myammar to recover its rohangiya.
India dharamsala khol rkha h Kya
Sameer trideva 😂😂😂😂 .. Aasharam ki Aashram
Sameer trideva haa(dharmashal) khol to rkha h himachal pradesh m...
saheb sana ... MULLA KI BAT KAR....
dharamshala me dharamshala hi to kholi thi tibetians k liye nehru ji ne..aaj tk wo yhi hain himachal me..ab in rohingyas ko ni rkhna chahiye..aise hi itni problems hain aur bdhengi..
Can you please make a video on migration of Kashmiri Pundits?
kumar saket tum sahi keha rahe ho bhai Kashmiri pundit apnehi deshmese Bhagao our ye tararist rohingyas ko apne desh me lao our apnehi desh ke tukde karo jagoo hinduo jago
According to your speech few thousand people migrated and now they are 1 million (population vise).
Now what will happen if 1 Lakh people settled in India after 5decades.
Again rape to local citizens.
Can you give full grantee that this types of incident will not occurred in Future.
Every country has a resources for its own citizens not for foreign citizens.
There are 56 Muslim countries throughout the globe and some of them are very rich too.
They can provide work and shelter to them.
They hired peoples from different corners of the world.
Say rohingya "NO"
I agree don't send them back in Myanmar but send them back in Bangladesh.
Why UN is forcing us....India can take their decision on their own.....I think UN should talk Myanmar and give Rohingya their own state and that state should convert into country so that peace will remain in all over the world.... though Rohingya innocent people are also not guilty that's all because of terrorism in this world
Tuko jyada inociant lag rahe h tum kar lo shadi sabi musalto se fir apne ghar me rak lana
hi soni but thats wrong to give country to Rohingya's cos what will happened if outside people come to your country and then after many years they want their won land cos they were living in your country for many years.
Garima Soni iytt
Ask UN sent all to Saudi, Iran, Libya , Syria should take them home. Brothers of same religion.
India main almost kafi log hai bangladeshi nepali and many other or upper se hamari population bhi kafi hai par resources bhi itne hai nahi tho mera mana hai India ko rohingya ko sarad nahi deni chaiye
Bangladeshi kya hota hai ??
Poora Bhu-khand Bharat ka hai ..!!
Say No to rohingiya...
Ye Bangladeshi kya hota hai ?? Poora India ka part hai ..!!
Bhai say no kya... 5 saal se to India me hi h ye lok or wo bhi 40,000 se Jada
Prashant sir you are excellent.And i think no one can take your place..Sir I can't explain in words that how much i love you...i attend your every classes on important issues...and finally i thank you sir🙏🙏🙏
Nahi.. inko wapas bhejna jaroori hai.
आप हमेशा कहते है की मै सिर्फ कानूनी फैक्ट्स पर स्टडी पर्पज से मुद्दे पर वीडियो बनाता हूं तो फिर यहां पर बुद्ध की बात को सामने रख कर और अपने उल्टे सीधे तर्क देकर अपनी सोच को दूसरों पर क्यों थोपना चाहते हो। और आखिर में ये फैसला सुनाने की कोशिश क्यों कर रहे हो की रोहिंग्या को हमें शरण देनी चाहिए।
अपने घर में आग लगा के दूसरों की दीवाली मनवाना कहा की इंसानियत है।
We should keep in our mind that internal security is the main concern if we neglect it we have to pay heavy price for it. # deport.
Goutam Sahu yes dude u r right
Because world know that india is a
Honest country
It mean not that they gate profit of its ...
So kindly refuge it .
As the prime minister, it is Modi's moral and primary responsibility to ensure the well-being and safety of Indian citizens who have voted him to power. Any other considerations must follow after.
go back rohingya.
Why India is not your dad property
@@irfanshaikh451 tu v rohingya h kya jo inke support me bol rha h hmare Baap ka desh nhi h to kya rohingya ke Baap ka desh h ye
I am not rohingya I am an Indian citizen by birth or by choice also I am support all people who are victims of genocide irrespective of their religion , caste , race ,gender
@@irfanshaikh451 india koi anath ashram nahi he...muslims ke liye 56 countries he kahi bhi chale jaye lekin india me nahi
Muslims ke liye 56 country hai to kya Woh tere baap ki jai.kya aur India be Muslim ke be country hai India is a secular country India ko British se Azad I dilane muslim Ka sabse bada role tha hamare he ulma ne reshmi rumal ki tehreek chaliye the remember it
हमारा देशमे ऐसे बहूत जादा काँचरा हे। दूसरे देशसे भागा हुआ कचरा हमारा मे रखने से आगे आने वाले पिरि के लिए ख़ाराप हंगे।
National security is the most important priority ... nothing else.!!! One can not save itself by being all humanitarian !!
Government को article 370 से भी पहले एक एक rohingya को चुन चुनकर देश से बाहर भेज देना चाहिए l
Right of the soil" commonly referred to as birthright citizenship, is the right of anyone born in the territory of a state to nationality or citizenship.
World must fight for right of every child born on soil of any country. Every child must have its citizenship. So each and every Rohingya currently living in Myanmar are born there and world must help them to get their right to live where they are born. To live like refugee is not anyone's fate.We all are children of god living on his land.God give us birth where he want one to live and no one on earth must have right to move.
Sir, Selfish hona padega kiyonki kisi aur ke liye ham apne logo ko khatre me nahi daal sakte, isse hamari economy, security system sab pe fark padega.
ye pakistani itna musalmano ko support krte n believe in spreading muslim population wo kyu nhi inki help kr rhe?!!
racism is the key problem in our dirty mind........."do what you expect from others"...... promphet mohammad
MONIKA SINGH
haris siddiqui it's not in our mind .
MONIKA SINGH pakistan chutiya hai...Hamara India hi asya desh hai jisko sab bharosha karti hai
Monika sis do u know 2 lac burma refuges are in pakistan karachi and more thn 10 lacs afghanis refuges..what about india?
before seeing this video ..i only say no refugees
after seeing i also said no..
yes we are Selfish...but we couldn't sacrifice our lives...for provide refugees..
ajj wo ake rahenge baad mein bolenge ye kisi baap ka hindustan hai hum sab ka khoon mila hua hai..
last agar india mein muslim jyada ho gye aur wo hinduyon ke upar attack karde to app hi bolo ki humara aur kaun si hinduish state hai kya.india ka partition hua religion ke adhhar per per hum hindu rastra hoke bhi muslim reh te hen kyun...Pakistan kyun bana batao...sab ko secularism ka bhoot chada hai..koi apne desh ki Kashmir pandito ko nhi bachapaya aur rohingya ko saran dene chale...future socho bhai apko pata hai muslim secular nhi hote..agar kisi ko kuch bolna hai to bolo...
hinduyon ke uper jab Kashmir mein atyachar hua tab kaunsi un thha..khoon khol uthti hai...
jago hindu jago...ye desh to hoga per gazwa e hind ke tahad koi hindu nhi hota...
Subhasis Das - Enke jagah yadi koi hindu hota ya hum aur aap hote to kya hamari aur aapki yahi sonch hoti ...
hmm agar mein terrorist hota aur hindu hota tab kasam mera desh ki koi bhi hume accept nhi karta..app ko agar lagta hai ki muslim innocent hote hen then plz go to a muslim country..then you realize what is freedom.what is fear..who are muslim...what they do with hindu..1947 mein Pakistan mein bhi hindu thhe per unko mardiya gya..
sahi kaha ye madarchod mullae bakrichod sirf bachae paida karenge 20 40 bachae bosdike mullae
vikas kumar agar aap ek aise desh k pradhan mantri hote jaha ki jansankhya dedh arab k kareeb hai,40 per cent SE zyada log garibi rekha k neeche aate hain,har ek acchi position k liye already 2 SE 3 hazaar log compete kar rahe hai,jo desh sabse yuva toh hai par jaha ka yuva berozgaari se joojh raha hai toh kya aap ki bhi yahi soch hoti
Subhasis Das
भारत केवल वोट बैन्क का देश है
कठिन कदम उठाना जरूरी है पर
सेक्युलरपती देश को तबाह कररही है
SIR. VERY NICE DETAILS & THINKING ABOUT PEOPLES OF COUNTRIES.
GOD NLESS YOU. THANKS.
"there are number of things to identify bad rohingya rather than said go back" sirji mujjo apka ye video bahut achaa laga bahut kuch sikhane ko milta hain aise quote padh ke
thanks
my suggestion is that "kuch rasta nikalna chahiye"
भारत क्या कोई धर्मशाला हैं जो जब चाहे यहाँ शरण ले ले,एक तो पहले से ही बांग्लादेशी घुसे हुए हैं और अब ये!इतने मुस्लिम देश हैं वहाँ जाओ!हमारे देश में कोई जगह नहीं हैं।
No shelter of illegally rohingya because it will be dangerous for nation security
ABHISHEK RAJPUT
kiran rijiju ne sahi kaha hai.. india ne theka nahi lekha raha hai saari duniya k refugees ka.
Why Indian government supports Pakistani Hindus to come in our country and get the citizenship? If India is thinking to give citizenship to a Pakistani (which is a terrorist country according to India) hindu then why not for Myanmar Muslims?🤔🤔
Kyoki pakisatan me forcefully conversion ho raha hai hindus ka. They are not safe there. Maar rahe hai unko roz. Pakistan is Muslim majority country, waha hindus survive nahi kar sakte. Kya tumhe itna b nahi pata?
Musalman to kahi b ja sakta hai. There 51 Muslim countries in the world, which are not secular by constitution. But Hindu kewal india me hi rah sakta hai, not in any muslim countries.
यही समस्या तो म्यांमार में भी है। वहां मुस्लिम भी सुरक्षित नहीं है। मुझे दोनों मुद्दे एक से लगते हैं, बस अन्तर दोनों मुद्दों में धर्म का है।
dono mudde ek jaise nahi hai dost. myamar k muslim to bangladesh me b rah sakte hai but hindu nahi.
Bilkul bhi nahi Deni chahiye kyouki aaj Sharan kal nagriktaa or parso reservation mang lenge or Congress jaise party vote k liye ye sub karde gi
krishan kumar well said bro... bilkul shi kha h
krishan kumar bjp bhi congress ki tarah he he..bjp=congress+cow,dono chor parties
anil maurya dusre ka dialogue mat chipkaya kar..kuch apna soch liya kar..
krishan kumar tera india hai jo comment kar raha jata maat bol .rss jesai insanyat dusmaan ko vote dai jo hamaisa jakarnai ki bath karta hai jo india law par nahe chalta apnai banài howai law per chalta hai ya modi ko vote dai jo 2002 ka master mind the ya congress ko dai jo har chej ka daam increse karai jo v bahar country sai india mai mojood hai wo kise dharam sai taluk rak tai hai sab ko india sai bahar nekalo bus tab barma muslim ho ya pakistani Hindus to
R Khan haan nhi deni chahiye bhai.
Or india hi kyo? Pakistan bhi nhi de rha shelter. Or hume kisi ko dikhane ki zarurat nhi h ki humara dil kitna bada hai wo india dikha chuka hai. Sala ek to mughal aaye phr yha k logo ko loota maara ,bhuto to convert kiya phr kahne lge ki alg desh de to
Wo b chlo de hi diya india or bana pakistan. Ab sala inko jagha do phr job bhi do
Last year mai delhi me tha afgani basti h waha ek, meri govt unko free house de rhi hai
Or sala mai thode door ghar liya to 12000 rent dena pada. Unke pas job hai ,dukane hai
Or mai sala abhi b unemployed.
Jitna dil dikhana tha dikha diye
Kal ko ye bhi khenge ki alg desh do
Jese kasmir k log khte h
Ese to tukde ho jayenge india k
similar case is in our state Arunachal pradesh, which is chakmas and hajongs issue. The indigenous people fears the same issue of crisis but what makes difference is the supreme court consent to grant citizenship to chakmas in Arunachal.
don't use India as a dumping zone
Deepak Mohanty - Enke jagah yadi koi hindu hota ya hum aur aap hote to kya hamari aur aapki yahi sonch hoti ...
vikas kumar 1st- bhai aye kese bol sakte ho ke meine socha nehi? mein khud Ko unke jagah par rakh kar hi mera soch bataya.
2nd- I don't want any BOom blast.
3rd- I don't want to sacrifice any soldiers Life. Bhai ghar Bethe phesla Suna na toh bahatihi easy hai.
Deepak Mohanty - Aaj se 50-100 saal baad mere saath bhavishya men kya hoga, yah sonch kar sambhrant, sampann, bahusankhyak varg visthapit, garib, kamjor, alpsankhyak varg ke vartman ka vinash kar de, jisme bahut sare bachche, budhe aur aurat bhi shamil hai, kya yah uchit hoga ... ?
Visthapan kai prakar ka hota hai vikas ke nam par, suraksha ke nam par, dharm ke naam par.
Visthapit, garib, kamjor, alpsankhyak chahe ye tabka kisi bhi dharm se sambandhit hon, ye hamesha pratarit tha, hai aur rahega, kyoki sampann varg ke vikas men, unki suraksha men enhe hamesha khatra mana gaya hai.
Kaliprasanna Pattnaik - Aaj se 50-100 saal baad mere saath bhavishya men kya hoga, yah sonch kar sambhrant, sampann, bahusankhyak varg visthapit, garib, kamjor, alpsankhyak varg ke vartman ka vinash kar de, jisme bahut sare bachche, budhe aur aurat bhi shamil hai, kya yah uchit hoga ... ?
Visthapan kai prakar ka hota hai vikas ke nam par, suraksha ke nam par, dharm ke naam par.
Visthapit, garib, kamjor, alpsankhyak chahe ye tabka kisi bhi dharm se sambandhit hon, ye hamesha pratarit tha, hai aur rahega, kyoki sampann varg ke vikas men, unki suraksha men enhe hamesha khatra mana gaya hai.
+vikas kumar bhai ha rakhte Hindu reproduction nahin karte sale bache peda karne ki machine h ye
I think the UN should talk to the Myanmar govt.to declare a small place for their state ... n all the country should help rohingyas for their development... n so that Rohingyas have their own state ... n Rohingyas can be deport from India n form other countries for their safety .....
very good sir........Myanmar should....give.them separate state......every country should....provide separate state if,they don't want his own minority in his country.
haris siddiqui already India had given two seperate Countries ...
and now also ... some people want another seperate STATE !!!!
RIDICULOUS ..
bas isiliye koi Rohingya ko lena nhi chahta coz after that they will demand for a seperate state.
Bhai kuchh daya to Muslim countries ko b dikhane do..
VIKASH kAUSHIK I am not telling non Islam country to donate a separate state... but Myanmar to give a place because Rohingyas were living there for the last 200 years ....
pranay ballav very well said...
"Deshhit hi sarvopari hota hai"
Helping others is crucial in the present scenario but the main issue is, to which extent . My personal believe is that, although the issue raises a moral question to the Indians about whether we want to support a community in distress or not. It's scope is much bigger than that , northeastern region is already in turmoil due to the insurgents from myanmar, border disputes with china and nepal, adding a huge sum of muslim foreigners to the equation could worsen the situation even further.
First step in my opinion should be to keep this immigration to a minimum by tightening our border security to advance standards. We can't let the INDO-BANGLADESH borders be so porous any further . Many nations have met their downfall because of heavy immigration , the central asia is great example of that .
Second step should be identifying all the current Rohingya muslims living in India. Even if we don't kick them out we must keep a track of who they are and what they are doing, this is crucial because if a few members of this community gets influenced by any terrorist organization and do something irrational , we will be compromising the internal security of our nation . It could also lead to a hate wave against that community in India , giving way to a mass hysteria similar to USA and Myanmar in India. We have ethnic muslims living peacefully in our country and we don't want the other communities misdirecting their anger to them which would make them feel alienated in their own country.
Third and most important step is to look for places to send these people and getting the global community aware , not involved, but aware of the situation . We also need to help Myanmar realize that their is strength in diversity if utilized properly like we very brilliantly do. Stabilizing the situation with very peacefull and level headed demeanour is crucial here . We can't risk to tense our bonds with myanmar, one of our very crucial allies against china because of this. Only if myanmar is developing can we hope some peace for our north eastern brothers and sisters.
According to the situation, we have to save them first, because humanity can't be ignore.
Rohingyas people r suffering with their problems ....We {India} can get it n have sympathy for them....But ,,,
प्रकृति में सीमित संसाधन हैं और हमे उनकी कद्र करते हुए उनका समुचित उपयोग करना चाहिए और यह हमारी ही जिम्मेदारी बनती है कज हुम् अपनी आने वाली पीढ़ी के लिए इन संसाधनों को बचा कर रखे ।
👍चूंकि रोहिंग्या मुस्लिम्स का रहन सहन, वेशभूषा, बोली, कल्चर इत्यादि म्यांमार की बुद्धिस्ट कम्युनिटी से पूर्णतः अलग है और यही कारण ह की म्यांमार इनको अपना नही रहा है ।
पर भारत , बांग्लादेश जैसे देश इनके लिए रिफ्यूजी कैम्प्स लगाकर इनकी सहायता करने पर उतारू है,,,,
हमे यहाँ पर यह सोचना चाहिए कि आखिर कब तक हम इन शरणार्थियों को अपने देश के संसाधनों (जिन पर हमारे देशवासियो का हक ह) का उपयोग करने देंगे,,,,,यह हमारी आने वाली पीढ़ी के साथ अन्याय होगा
क्योंकि रोहिंग्या मुस्लिम्स के हक के संसाधन म्यांमार के रखिन क्षेत्र में ह और उन्हें उनका ही उपयोग करना चाहिए ।
👍👌solution-- इस समस्या का एक ही हल ह की भारत , बांग्लादेश और UN व अन्य देशों को आगे आकर इस कम्युनिटी के लोगो के लिए आवाज उठानी चिये और उनका हक उनको दिलाने के लिए उस क्षेत्र (Rakhin) को स्वतंत्र घोषित कर देना चाहिए फिर चाहे इसके लिए म्यांमार में आर्मी ही क्यों न भेजनी पड़े ।
इसके वाद उस क्षेत्र को कोई भी देश गोद ले सकता है और उसी क्षेत्र में उनका निवास स्थान बनाकर उनका पालन पोषण किया जा सकता ह
और यही एकमात्र इसका समाधान है ।
💐यही मानवता है,,,,, मानवता वो नही की आप एक इंसान की भूख मिटाने के लिए किसी दूसरे इंसान के हक का छीन लो ।💐💐
Pls....Think on it....
💐💐Thank u very much sir💐💐
हम क्यों रखें रोहिंग्या आतंकियों को?
पाकिस्तान तो बना ही धर्म के आधार पर है वो क्यों नही रख लेती अपने रोहिंग्या को।
मैं बौद्ध लोगों को सुक्रिया कहना चाहूंगा, जिन्होंने इन आतंकवादियों के खिलाफ मोर्चा खोला।
जय हिंद।
#IstandWithMyanmar ✌🚩
Population Explosion is the biggest problem India is facing right now,therefore adding them wud increase the burden
Thanks a lot for explaining the topic so beautifully. This clears my each and every doubt about this issue. Really genius hats off.
We should oppose immigration of rohingiyas muslim
1)as we all know india is vastly populated country so giving refugee to extra 10 million people would be a serious concern for india
2)the first and foremost danger for india would probably be increase in pressure of various resources
3)we have already seen population crisis in North eastern states where numerous bangladeshi during 1971 war moved to assam west bengal and various states which has resulted in illegal use of government resources there population is getting increased exponentially
4)also if they are given refugee there would require lots of funds to build there house there also registrating there name as an indian citizens .
5)one of the most serious issue with giving them help and let them reside here is that they are completely different in every context from us whether it is language , believe , understanding they would completely be a stranger to us.
5)also the states would be under several clash that they make sure they don't allow any stranger to get into there home.(states)
6)india is not a highly prosperous nation to do favour to such a huge population .
7)india should focus in its economic growth and concentrate to its own people .
8)if rohingya gets settled into india than technically they would be a minority (so it's a proven that human feel uncomfortable in living in an area where there population is low and it could be sure that they could raise there population bluntly )
9)as it is known that they are also in contact with hafeez saeeds organization ....so it would be a grave threat to settle our enemies into our home ..
Plz do give feedback so that i can improve my answer writing skills coz this are my fewest answer which I have written in any video/post.
Thank you
2020 anyone?
बिल्कुल भी नही... उनका जिन्स ही बेकार है.... समझो... ये बेवकूफी होगी
sudeep kumar chouhan ...Sahi bole Bhai
sudeep kumar chouhan bhai hm bhi nhi chahte ki bo india Aaye but kisi zins ko dosh mt do
the least question is how this people managed to enter in india, does previous government allowed them to enter? or current government allowed them? if none of the govt allowed, than does our borders are these much freak that any1 can enter? and really article 14,21 and 51c applicable to non citizen.???
Ripal Patel
Ripal Patel inko congress tmc cpi cpm appeasement ke chalte yanha shelter diya n bangladeshi to lakhon me he yanha .
if.we.not.give.shelter....in.bad.situatin.no.other.country.will.give.us.shelter.....not racism......any.desaster.may.happen.in.any.country......then............?????.....if....we.r.....going....to...behave...like....Myanmar.....we..... shouldn't shelter.them.................Myanmar.illegally...... hailing Muslims....since 2012.
Constitution of India doesn't apply to the noncitizen of India.For reference, you can see the preamble of our Constitution, where it is mentioned:"we the people of India...".Hope this helps.
Humanity is first! Then nation and other things 🏠
Yes humanity is first so they should go to any islamic country
Apney ghar rakh l bhai ...jo galaa kaat r unhy humanity samjhaa l
Anti national
कौन हैं अशीन विराथु?
दस साल पहले मांडले के इस बौद्ध भिक्षु के बारे में बहुत कम लोगों ने सुना था. 1968 में जन्मे अशीन विराथु ने 14 साल की उम्र में स्कूल छोड़ दिया और भिक्षु का जीवन अपना लिया.
Matter of concern for our internal security. And if we allow them it open the door for other Rohingya also
Currently, India is not in very good condition in terms of economy as well as employment. Providing shelter to refugees will directly affects the current population of India. One should consider the consequences of allowing refugees as they will exploit our resources and in the near future they may get citizenship due to gain of certain political parties.. not only that, they may also enjoy the reservation system in our government organisations because of minority issues.
The other point is that, if there are certain security issues then we cannot allow such Refugees... This situation can be compared to situation in which you saw a bunch of beggars on the road without shelter and they may die because of the Harsh conditions... You allow them to come to your home and you don't know weather this person will steal from your home or Kill somebody from home... You went outside for your daily earning. At that point even a single person can kill your entire family because you have no defence once he entered in your house.. On humanity ground you did the right thing but on the other hand the responsibility of your family is served or not?
Sir acc.to morality we should keep them and India is a country which is known for this but sir whenever we have did earlier these things India's relationship wd the concerned country became worse be it
inda-pak
indo-china
india-Bangladesh
India is still lagging behind in all the parameters since independence be it poverty, economic divide, unemployment, terrorism
By giving shelter to rohingyas we r making it next to impossible .
in 1947 thousands of refugees came to India and now we all know the census
India should follow realpolitik being idealistic is unrealistic. be practical not emotional fool . instead India should ask Myanmar govt to give rohingyas their social status.
u r right.
I am agree with you
kanika tripathi
kanika tripathi question of morality is not the concern. These rohingya were involved in bodhgaya bomb blast. holy place of Buddhism. Now they are facing the music.
Apart from this rohingya are illegal militants over here. Doesn't hold proper refuge paper. And our constitution never allow asylum for such militants.. we can't violate our law.
If we observe our history then during mourya period foreigner alexander and selucus visited India to rule, then Mughals came with same motto.
Followed by britishers..and presently Italian servants .so whenever any foreign s visit India they always try to rule ,why to take chance this time ?
National security should be our priority we should take decision under this reference.
India is very populated country and suffering from unemployment, lack of facilities. Everyday a new Australia is born in India. In this state, India can't give shelter to lakhs of refugees who come to India every year. Also as you said it is a threat to our security.
NO COMPROMISE ON NATIONAL SECURITY....OPP PARTIES WHO ARE SUPPORTING ROHINGYAS AND ALSO JOURNALISTS LIKE RAVISH KUMAR (NDTV) SHOULD ALSO BE DEPORTED ALONG WITH THE ROHINGYAS
India wants that to happen. Please do tweet that message to Narendra Modi, Prime Minister of India
Send them back to Bangladesh....cause what I understood is that they have went to Myanmar from Bangladesh...and also donate some money for thier food cloth and basic need...but my nation is much more important then any group of any caste creed religion or whatever among whom one or two can harm my brothers n sister here in India. India can keep the children's Up to 14 years old max.
india ki population already highest ho chuki hai 2016 se ab kya karwana chahte hain
Sir please make a video on the rising fuel prices, how it is priced corresponding to international market
Mr Prashant, your channel is famous for unbiased videos and information. Please do not try to softly put in biased videos. You haven’t covered in details the organised violence committed by this community.
India has suffered massively due to attacks from all sides but still we have a warm heart. Don’t think giving shelter can solve the problem. Ground reality is far difficult to face then to show compassion. Sweden compassion Dikha raha hai aur duniya mein Sabse Tezi se rape crime increase Kahin hua hai toh Sweden mein hua hai.
This compassion is good if the other person is also compassionate.
There are 57 declared Muslim nations, let them give refuge to Rohingyas. Why every time we suffer in the name of humanity. Let the world also see our sufferings, our pain.
Please don’t make biased videos.
Internal security is prioritize first ,first we have to protect our nation , morality comes later.🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
AS A REFUGEE THEY FILE CASE IN THE SUPREME COURT WHAT HAPPENED FURTHER IF THEY LIVED FOR A LONG TIME.
This teaching of Buddha should be taught to the Buddhists of Myanmar.
I started watching this channel for having the correct information. And not asking for the opinions publically. also not for the UPSC preparation.
I think you should not ask for public opinions on SOCIAL MEDIA as these topics are somewhere religiously sensible.
Because the point is,
Some people's feelings could hurt by someone writing random comments. & these may create unneccessary conflicts towards the other religions or even towards the country.
As far as my opinion on the topic,
I think there should be a balanced decision taken considering humanity as well as the nation's security.
& another point is if in future other countries would start taking out people from there. How much can we absorb?
if govt . will give shelter to them , it would be dangerous for India in coming future . we already have high population , and moreover we learned many lessons from britishers , china , Pakistan etc . Though lessons of budhha teaches us humanity but sometimes we have to think practically not emotionally . Thank you
We shouldn't accept them by comprising our internal security at any cost. On the name of humanity we are risking our citizens' lives, resources and opportunities, we are also human and be rational bcz jab Buddhist, jo ki sab ka bhala chahne walo, ne unhe accept nhi kiya to koi or kaise unhe masoom samjh sakta hai. Ye apne pair pr kulhadi marne jaisa hai.
Make a video on delhi sultanate SIR PLZZZ ..
Not against of rohingyas , In ndia we have so many problems like many states are demanding separated like gorkhaland in West Bengal,kosal in Odisha,bodoland in Assam etc .. instead of giving citizens ship in India let's UN and other countries should discuss to Myanmar..or like Rakhaines can demand other countries..
We can accommodate ....even more than they are....we are not UN refugee signatory....but we can protect children it's our responsibility...
U r best..... Plz make video for more internal security issues
Flight mein oxygen ki kami hone per phele khud ka mask lagane ko bolte hein, so internal security is first.
Don't be emotional US saying right about Syria refugee we also have same think even less powerful than US so if US don't take any risk why should us. We don't have to get emotional and puth our internal security in risk